r/baseball•
lemcoe9

r/baseball Players of the Week - Week 6: Angels' Reid Detmers throws a CGSO in a brilliant start against the Rays, Phillies' Bryce Harper wins unanimously after putting up a smooth 1.904 OPS and 14 hits, and Yankees' superstar Giancarlo Stanton cranks four homers, driving in 12 RBI!

Feature

Welcome to r/baseball's Players of the Week feature! We have one Voter from each team, and we vote each week on the best hitting and pitching performances in both the American League and the National League. This week (May 9th through May 15th), we had 25 Votes.

Our Voters are charged with a simple question: Which MLB players had the best week?

All stats are from Baseball-Reference.com's excellent Daily Game Log Finder tool.

Mobile-Friendly Week 6 Results

National League Pitcher of the Week: Jose Quintana

NameTeamVotesIPHERBBSOHRERABFWHIPBAbipSO9SO/W
Jose Quintana PIT913.05051000.00490.769.1526.92.00
Kyle Hendricks CHC614.1813900.63540.767.2005.73.00
Hunter Greene CIN412.24391512.13511.026.11510.71.67
Pablo Lopez MIA37.03101111.29250.429.15414.1∞
Carlos Rodon SF29.2161031519.31441.966.60014.05.00
Ranger Suarez PHI113.09331312.08520.923.2359.04.33

Baseball Reference Stats - FanGraphs Stats

From The Voters: Rodon having 15 strikeouts over 9 IP and still getting blown up is impressive. - u/mingram

From The Voters: No Rbi's given up in 13 innings is pretty good. Shout out the Hunter Greene though throwing 7 no-hit innings and getting saddled with a loss, if he didn't have the two BB that caused the loss he'd of gotten the vote. - u/ZaneKitsune

From The Voters: I really, truly, strongly considered voting for Albert Pujols here. - u/kuhanluke

American League Pitcher of the Week: Reid Detmers

NameTeamVotesIPHERBBSOHRERABFWHIPBAbipSO9SO/W
Reid Detmers LAA129.0001200.00280.111.0002.02.00
Tarik Skubal DET613.06051600.00480.846.22211.13.20
Nestor Cortes NYY615.14141810.59540.522.09710.64.50
Martin Perez TEX112.110221301.46500.973.2869.56.50

Baseball Reference Stats - FanGraphs Stats

From The Voters: Some really great weeks made this one hard to choose - u/value_here

From The Voters: walks up to podium ...... adjusts microphone ... clears throat ... “Nestor Cortes Jr.” ... walks off stage to a thunderous applause - u/aweinschenker

From The Voters: Cautiously optimistic on all the Angels rookie and farm pitching. I'm still waiting for my dick punch. - u/naaahhman

From The Voters: Hats off to the kid. - u/HmathForDayz

National League Hitter of the Week: Bryce Harper

NameTeamVotesABRH2B3BHRRBIBBSBBAOBPSLGOPS
Bryce Harper PHI2523814603843.609.6431.2611.904

Baseball Reference Stats - FanGraphs Stats

From The Voters: Holy shit - u/mingram

From The Voters: Bryce Harper tore his UCL, and then had one of the best weeks of his career. What a G. - u/kuhanluke

American League Hitter of the Week: Giancarlo Stanton

NameTeamVotesABRH2B3BHRRBIBBSBBAOBPSLGOPS
Giancarlo Stanton NYY18246101041220.417.462.9581.420
Shohei Ohtani LAA4296102041021.345.387.8281.215
Kyle Tucker HOU11746301273.353.542.7061.248
Gavin Sheets CHW11335103720.385.4671.1541.621
Yuli Gurriel HOU121510202401.476.522.8571.379

Baseball Reference Stats - FanGraphs Stats

From The Voters: Ey go Yankees baybee it’s the Yanks - u/SteepDowngrade

From The Voters: Toss up between him and Stanton, felt like they had similar weeks, but I think Ohtani's performance mattered more to his team. . - u/ZaneKitsune

Mobile-Friendly Week 6 Results

Posted May 17, 2022, 12:31 PM UTC

16524
No32Cleveland Guardians :cle1:•

Reid Detmers throws a CGSO

…really underselling it lmao

134
lemcoe9OPAtlanta Braves :atl1:•

I was trying to being a little sarcastic by teasing it.

34
cardith_lordaMinnesota Twins•

I agree with u/mingram - Harper went OFF this week. 9 of his 14 hits were for extra bases and he still went out an stole 3 bases on top of it, lol.

60
mingramBaltimore Orioles :bal3:•

Absolutely insane week.

18
RandomHighGuyMontreal Expos :was4:•

Rodon getting 2 votes despite putting a 9.31 ERA makes no sense.

45
value_hereCincinnati Reds :cin1:•

Chicks dig the long ball strikeouts, I guess?

23
hnevels13St. Louis Cardinals :stl1:•

I thought my eyes were broken, I coulda swore we just lit the man up….

8
gatemansgcPhiladelphia Phillies :phi1:•

i'm happy to see ranger got a vote!

1
bilweavSan Francisco Giants :sfg2:•

Bryce Harper is rated.

23
AlkynesofchemistryPhiladelphia Phillies :phi2:•

He is truly one of the most rated players in history.

15
neighbs•

Stanton is hot, let's go Yankees!

Yankees in 5 you heard it here first.

20
LebigmaccaLos Angeles Dodgers :lad1:•

RemindME! 6 Months

4
RemindMeBot•

I will be messaging you in 6 months on 2022-11-17 12:54:05 UTC to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

^(Parent commenter can ) ^(delete this message to hide from others.)


^(Info)^(Custom)^(Your Reminders)^(Feedback)
4
value_hereCincinnati Reds :cin1:•

Reds voter here, I will be taking no questions at this time

17
B0rf_Minnesota Twins :min1:•

Understandable have a nice day

6
DocphilsmanPhiladelphia Phillies :phi1:•

Harper's slugging was higher than ohtani's ops for the week. I feel like that's all you can really say, he was absolutely on fire

6
gamedemon24New York Yankees :nyy1:•

Curious if any voters would weigh in: if Reid had given up like, 3 hits would you have gone Nestor? Can't argue with Reid as-is though

3
mingramBaltimore Orioles :bal3:•

I went Nestor as is. No-nos aren't that rare anymore and he objectively had the better week. But people like what they like.

3†
thesuperiorvegetableCalifornia Angels :laa3:•

If Reid gives up one hit, Nestor get it. Dominant performance and not too many hard hit balls but 15 innings pitched with 18ks and a .5 whip is ridiculous. Nestor has an unreal week. The guy is really taking steps to be a top tier starter if he already isn't one. He really looks unhittable right now and if I had a vote he's the Cy Young.

But c'mon. No-no's are so special. 317 all time. Out of roughly 24300 games in the last ten years, there were 43 no hitters, or 0.18% of all games played. Baseball is quirky, I say celebrate when cool things happen!

4
mingramBaltimore Orioles :bal3:•

Yeah, I don't fault anyone going for Detmers. But I dig me some strikeouts.

2
value_hereCincinnati Reds :cin1:•

I went Nestor as-is. I usually favor two start pitchers over one start pitchers anyways, and recently I have been shown some evidence that no hitters aren't even a guarantee of a win!

3
Misty7297Tampa Bay Devil Rays :tbr3:•

No Pujols votes for pitcher of the week?

2
etched_chaos•

And MLB The Show still gave Bryce a ratings drop.

2
jtrom93New York Yankees :nyy1:•

As someone who always held Stanton as one of my favorite players... I still get little butterflies reading the words "Yankees superstar Giancarlo Stanton".

1