Is this normal?

Rant

Hi r/sysadmin,

I'm working as an L1/L2 tech for an MSP. I'm based in France and my company sells, services, and maintains its prorietary software that connects electrnic shelf labels and the corresponding software that pharmacies use to handle their inventory, stock, prices, special offers you name it. To put it simply, back when they created the company pharmaceutical software vendors would design their product so that only their ESL (electronic shelf labels) would work with THEIR software. This is obviously done to prevent that clients will change to another software vendor as it would be way to expensive to repurchase new ESLs that work with a different software.

So the guy that made this company found ways to connect any of those softwares that pharmacies use to any ESL technology used in France. That was his hole in the market. So now this has been going on for 20 years and they have about 3000 clients in mainland France and overseas territories. We are 3 hotline techs and 1 sysadmin / tech leader. 3 techies. For 3000 clients. This company has maybe 40 or 50 employees most of those being sales reps acquiring more clients.

We are currently being completely overloaded with new tickets and we can not treat them faster than they're coming in. This to me isn't surprising when you have 1000 clients per technician but that's where we're at. It happens often that I and other techs have to stay past our worktime to fix and finish tickets and those hours are.. drumroll please... unpaid! Oh and did I mention we get paid 1400€ net per month?

On top of that our supervisor, the sysadmin, works from home permanently. I work in a different region so I'm only connected to my team by teams / phone / email. The main office is near Paris. Our sysadmin is also a complete perfectionist to the point where it slows down our work and results in us overflowing in tickets. His perfectionism is in documentation and diagnostic. Now I understand this is very important but we're a three man team and we need tickets resolved. The founders of the company that work in the same region as me told me that 2 employees have left before I arrived due to them having problems with this sysadmin. He's incredibly competent at his job as a sysadmin but he's got absolutely no pedagogy and has no idea how to talk to people in a normal, friendly way. I'm spending more time replying to his overly long and detailed messages on Teams than I'm actually calling clients and resolving tickets. I've already reported some issues to the 2 founders that work in the same office as me because he was going off on us in the group Team chat kinda saying how we're all idiots and don't know how to do our jobs. I almost replied "pay peanuts, get monkeys" to that convo at that time but luckily, I didn't. Apparently he expects a lot for what we're being offered and he's been told this by his superiors too where they told him something along the lines "you get hotliners, not network engineers, stop expecting them to be IT profesionnals with 10+ years experience."

This is my first professional IT job and I'm super glad they gave me a shot since it gets me experience to put on my CV and gets me a foot in the door for the future but what the fucking hell! Each day I'm dreading more having to deal with him and I'm not the only one. One of the techs used to do infrastructure installations on site and moved over to the hotline because he was done traveling all over the country all the time. He's put himself on wfh despite the company not wanting us to and basically stopped communicating with the team. I spoke to him privately about it when I was in Paris a few weeks back and he says he's also really fed up with our tech lead and the way he treats us / the way his priorities lie. Word around the neighborhood is that they're going to reprimand him and force him back in office since he's not supposed to be wfh permanently at all. The two founders don't even talk to him anymore since they don't want to have to deal with his moods and antics. Apparently back when he joined the company they told him he could become an associate but he'd be required to move to Paris to work from the company's main office but just after agreeing to that he decided to buy the house he was renting at that time and said "oops, guess I'm staying wfh now."

All in all there seems to be this strange infighting between the veterans / founders of this company and I have no fucking clue why we're being caught in the crossfire so to speak.

So the question is; is this normal? Am I just being a sensitive little bitch and taking this too seriously? I really like the work that I'm doing here but the communication part with our supervisor is just bumming me out / killing my motivation. I feel like I need to get out of here before he completely kills my sense of wonder for IT and the motivation to keep learning and discovering.

/rant

Posted May 25, 2022, 10:11 AM UTC

2480
Skinny_deerJr. Sysadmin•

To me it's sound like a toxic work environement you should quit and find something else asap

I did some L1/L2 job also in France for 1 year and half and honestly I didn't enjoy a single minute of it and we were like 100 in the office so I can't even understand how you feel since your team seems way too little for the work ( wish you good luck for that)

The way the sys act is actually what I faced most of the time in France , not exactly in the same case as your but higher up used to be really abusive and lacking empathy .

24
DeathRowLemonOP•

French have a weird IT culture. They seem to not understand that IT jobs always have had a hard time finding employees yet they demand you have formation supérieur / certs and official education while most countries take any motivated and willing to learn person and train them on the job. I’m fixing to find work in my home country where this is the norm. Thanks for your input. I feel like this place is toxic indeed. Everybody on my team is doing unpaid overtime on a near daily basis.

9
Skinny_deerJr. Sysadmin•

Just to clarify the way they require cert and diploma isnt just for IT but every job you candidate for so don't feel treat unfairly on this point at least.

French are way to focus on certif and diplom rather than motivation or other quality which is realy annoying and unfair for some people who couldn't afford study.

which you luck for your next job

9
DeathRowLemonOP•

Or people like me that aren’t French and don’t want to sit in French classroom and learn better in an autodidactic way. Merci à you!

6
Skinny_deerJr. Sysadmin•

Yeah me and my family were born in an other country and also felt that way that why I can clearly feel you on that point.

And for stranger having a job is even more difficult since french have way too much document to fill when you take stranger as employee

4
technobrendo•

Certs and degrees a lot of times are just to get past the HR Firewall

0
fahque•

I’m fixing to find work

It's interesting you used this wording. I thought only southern US folks used "fixing" in that way.

2
DeathRowLemonOP•

I know a lot of accent and language stuff for no good reason 😅

5
MattH665•

Stop doing free overtime. When your shift ends, log out and go home. What they gonna do, fire you and hope the other guys take on your workload too? lol

And yeah that place sounds like a disaster that is just falling apart, look for a new job.

15
DeathRowLemonOP•

Thanks, I am looking. One of my colleagues literally goes home to log back in at his house to finish things up in his free time :S

2
MattH665•

Damn. Maybe try convince them to stop doing that too. From the company's point of view, if work is getting done they're not understaffed. Working like that just encourages them to exploit you.

5
DeathRowLemonOP•

Exactly my thoughts but this guy is being a next level tryhard since he wants to become assistant sysadmin (if that role exists) we call it “adjoint” here. Kinda like second in command. Believe me I tried to make him stop doing that.

3
Keopha•

You should definitely not. You and your colleague shouldn’t have to make up for bad management, it’s not your problem, and if you work overtime you’re not doing yourself a favour since your manager won’t see that you’re not enough. Just work your 7 hour a day or so and that’s it. Leave work at your workplace :)

1
pdp10const char *f= "One of those condescending Unix computer users";•

His perfectionism is in documentation and diagnostic. Now I understand this is very important but we're a three man team and we need tickets resolved.

Bear in mind that shortchanging documentation or skipping over details may give you some breathing room now, but it will come at a substantial cost later. Remember the saying: if you don't have time to do it properly the first time, how will you have the time to do it over again a second or third time?

It sounds like you're severely short headcount and compensation, and stress from that is causing you to be increasingly intolerant of any actions by the sysadmin that you feel slow you down or impede you, whether those may be in the best interests of the organization or not.

I don't see why you should pay attention to any of the other matters except backlog/workload. Even if someone tells you that you can take more shortcuts than the sysadmin allows, the organization will still be understaffed and you'll be making more work for yourself in the long run, so you'd have to leave anyway.

12
DeathRowLemonOP•

I’d understand that in unique or rare cases but most of our tickets it’s the same thing 100000x over. If the ticket is resolved upon the first opening who cares really? The problem was solved and it’s a problem like almost all the others. The only instance where I can find this really useful is when it seems like a run of the mill problem and doesn’t get resolved immediately after the first intervention. That’s what the OG founder said too. Anyway you’re right but since our problems are always near identical it’s not the same / varied as a classic IT support company.

4
pdp10const char *f= "One of those condescending Unix computer users";•

It's not clear what you're talking about here. Are you talking about documentation? Like adding a KB entry for a new problem? You wrote a long rant but only devoted one short sentence to the core problem, as I see it. You're asking if a request is unreasonable, while only obliquely describing the request.

0
DeathRowLemonOP•

Sorry yeah just typing in what was done in the ticket resolution. What he wants is that we fully type out the entire thing time and time again. Even though 90% of the problems we encounter are near identical. Nobody's ever even going to look at that shit just whether this type of problem has occured before for that specific client. What's even the point of entering 30 lines of text for a problem that was solved under 15 min? Convoluted and redundant if you ask me but what do I know? I'm an IT professional fledgeling

3
pdp10const char *f= "One of those condescending Unix computer users";•

What he wants is that we fully type out the entire thing time and time again. Even though 90% of the problems we encounter are near identical.

So: the goal is to collect stats. Most likely in order to prioritize fixes.

TL;DR: there are better ways to structure this data collection for automated tabulation, but overall the requirement is reasonable.


You can suggest a more-structured way to collect data than free-form text, which would make it easier to tabulate. But there's some social risk in that, because if it's much easier to claim that the fix was an old one, than to type out the actual truth, then you're incentivizing people to take a shortcut by lying.

If you're truly handling the same problem over and over, then you can have the resolution already written up in a text file, and paste it in while you're on the phone. Problem solved?

Having the same problems repeatedly is not good, though, unless the customers are paying by the call.

Nobody's ever even going to look at that shit just whether this type of problem has occured before for that specific client.

It's hard to say. Maybe the sysadmin actually looks at most of them. Maybe they only look in specific cases. Maybe they want the data so they can look someday, but they never really check.

3
Individual-Fix3229•

test your theory, don't fill out the resolution on a couple of tickets. If the problems are similar, you should have the resolution ready to paste in

2
VTOLfreak•

Document it anyway. It's your Cover-Your-Ass work history when shit hits the fan and the sysadmin decides to throw you under a bus. One thing I learned from working with bad clients: Write everything down. If it's not on paper, it didn't happen.

1
ZAFJB•

I and other techs have to stay past our worktime to fix and finish tickets and those hours are.. drumroll please... unpaid!

you have a lot of protection under French employment law. Read up, and use it.

10
DeathRowLemonOP•

True, I should. But they’ll just guilt trip cause law is one thing and enforcement another kettle of fish completely.

1
mandrack3•

Then you enforce it by going "I have a life, and can't expect me to do so much, for so little pay". Then let it all fail spectacularly and when confronted... "We are severely understaffed and underpaid. What did you expect, Mr manager, shouldn't you... Manage better?" Are they the type to brag about record profits, too?

8
DeathRowLemonOP•

There has been talk of record profits indeed. The company has consistently been making more money even throughout covid.

4
mandrack3•

Time to send plantation owner & slave related memes to everyone.

5
wmassinghamSysadmin•

I and other techs have to stay past our worktime to fix and finish tickets and those hours are.. drumroll please... unpaid

Holy fuck what? Why are you doing that? I can't believe that that would be legal in France. I'm in the US where labor laws are horrible and it's still supremely illegal here.

In the US, I'd recommend gathering documentation about every hour you've worked unpaid, suggest your coworkers do the same, then go to the labor board to get back pay for those hours. Surely France has something similar.

6
TheFluffyDovah•

With so many tickets how did you find time to write such a long rant on reddit!

Just kidding, sounds like first of all your management need to address the issue of under staffing for the amount of customers you need to support. You have no time to train up and become better at what you do and skill up.

Not sure how long you've been there, but after 2-3 years you have enough experience to move somewhere else, maybe even into junior sysadmin position

5
DeathRowLemonOP•

Lol! I took a break and what better way to do that than to just let it all out?

We are clearly understaffed and they're not finding people to fill the jobs they need filling. What a fucking surprise if all you're offering is 1400/m. I'm actually losing money working here and I'm literally only here for the XP points. I'm actually interviewing soon for another position in my home country (NL). I've been here 6 months now. What also kinda bothers me is that I'm not doing 'real' IT support but I support this ESL technology and a little windows stuff here and there but nothing more complicated than IP addressing problems, drivers and other pretty much surface areas of windows work.

I'm planning on quitting and just dedicate 2 to 3 months max to speedrun studying for CCNA and getting that cert so I can just move the feck on from there. I can also feel that my sysadmin wants to keep me in my low level postition since they just need someone to do it but I'm someone who is constantly looking to learn more and acquire more skills. I'm already teaching myself bash and python in any free time I get (mainly during lunchbreak) cause in the end I want to work with linux only (fuck windows, windows is just for gaming for me haha).

5
TheFluffyDovah•

Don't quit, secure another job, by the sounds of it any internal IT support jobs would be better than what you do now. You will learn a lot on the job, definietely mention your aspirations on interviews. The fact that you want to learn and work with different technologies is a huge plus. We've had many IT guys that only follow internal processes made by other people, don't care or want to explore anything other than what needed for their job specs - this is fine for some, but personally I don't think you can get far in IT working like that. Some solutions require thinking outside the box and these people couldnt hack it.

If you want to work with Linux, get some certifications in that direction, forget CCNA unless you really want to do networking. CompTIA Linux+ is a good start, you could also get CompTIA Network+ for network knowledge, but these should be enough to get linux admin position at some company

3
DeathRowLemonOP•

Thanks I really appreciate it however I don’t agree on your stance on CCNA. It’s a very respected cert and this level of understanding networking is still valuable and will help getting hired. Also, I already have to books. Thanks again for the mint advice!

1
psycho202MSP/VAR Infra Engineer•

Unfortunately, CCNA isn't that respected of a cert anymore these days. Especially in Europe. If you already have a college degree in IT, CCNA will bring you little extra value.

Actual experience is much more valuable, and you have a few years of experience with this MSP.

I'd recommend you to find a bigger MSP in France. Because you're near Paris, I'd say to look into Atos, Inetum (GFI Informatique), and similar companies. These bigger companies usually offer on-the-job training for junior profiles with little experience.

However, 1.4K net is really really low, especially for the larger Paris region. How much is that pre-tax? 1.8K? That's laughably low. Especially with a few years of experience.

I'm in Belgium and our juniors picked straight from the schoolbenches get 2.2K pre-tax plus some extra benefits like a company car, which comes to about 1.8K net. (and we're close to the french border too)

1
pdp10const char *f= "One of those condescending Unix computer users";•

linux only (fuck windows, windows is just for gaming for me haha).

r/Linux_Gaming has 221k subscribers for a reason...

1
DeathRowLemonOP•

Yeah very true except I play a lot of early access stuff which is usually not very compatible until full release and even then..

5
cakeBoss9000•

I stopped reading mid-way. Get your CV, update it and start applying my man. Enjoy the salary bump and the lack of stress later on

5
DeathRowLemonOP•

CV is up to date and I’m spamming them to the void ;). Thanks for the encouragement, pal!

7
ie-sudoroot•

Run away…

4
DeathRowLemonOP•

I'm interviewing for a position elsewhere soon. Fingers crossed right?

4
Hirogen10•

Get out of there this is what I call an institutionalised place they are set in their ways they don't see any need to change they take things for granted, they know they got a hold on the market because of the software they made, they are elitist too the bosses they are rich and dont care just like any company that gets too comfortable, all 3 of you should go on strike or atleast find another job.

3
DeathRowLemonOP•

I’ve hinted a few times at the other two a few times that we ought to at least demand a considerable raise since they couldn’t do anything without us. Sadly, none were willing to go full Spartacus…

1
Le_Vagabondif it has a processor, I can make it do tricks.•

si tu mets ton profil linkedin en recherche d'emploi tu va avoir 300 ESN qui vont te contacter dans la demi-journée.

non, c'est pas normal. sors. de. la.

et en attendant arrêtez de vous faire pigeonner comme des bleus, ils vont faire quoi si toute l'équipe dit "ca suffit" ?

pas d'heure sup non payées, point. en France on a encore des protections suffisantes pour pouvoir le faire, et le marché du travail est super porteur pour nous en ce moment. il doit être heureux votre patron avec des employés pareils :(

2
DeathRowLemonOP•

Carrément, je suis tout à fait d’accord avec toi. Ils peuvent fortement aller se faire enculer. Je cherche déjà ailleurs.

1
Otaehryn•

This is not normal but very common. My first IT job was somewhat similar but now it's much better.

2
DeathRowLemonOP•

Guess it’s true what they say; money rolls uphill, shit rolls downhill.

1
lesusisjordCombat Sysadmin•

First of all, your awareness of what is appropriate/not appropriate in terms of behavior and workload is a huge plus and will help take you far in this career field (and most career fields, actually). So hell yeah to that.

Furthermore, and this is just my personal experience/anecdote, your sysadmin’s attitude is the exact reason I’ve been hired over more technically skilled candidates at many, if not all, of my past places of employment. I know this for a fact because I’ve asked my hiring managers why they chose me over other candidates (I did this after being there for a while - not like the first week or something). And at one job, I was hired for the position that was based in NY, and two weeks later, the slot in Philadelphia opened and the candidate who I was chosen over was selected for that newly opened position. It was obvious that he was more experienced and just knew a lot more about than I did, but it was also obvious that he just didn’t grasp the customer service aspect of the job. It may not have been on purpose, but when you asked him for assistance, you always felt like you were bothering him. It’s not that he was rude per se, but he did not have the type of attitude/personality that made colleagues and customers feel welcomed, if that makes sense‽

My coworkers have also commented on how I’m the most “personable” IT guy they’ve ever worked with. In my opinion, I don’t do anything out of the ordinary. I treat everyone with respect and understand that my role is to facilitate the work done by the users of the systems for which I am responsible. I am WFH mostly these days, but regardless of the work location, when I enter the office/join a call, I name sure to leave any personal problems at the door. If I am angry or upset about something, you wouldn’t know it because I am a professional and don’t allow personal baggage to influence my work.

They want somebody who will treat internal and external customers courteously and professionally and who will represent the company in the best way possible, especially when they work with limited to no direct supervision. Having a basement-dwelling curmudgeon who can’t work with people and acts like certain tasks are beneath them is not a person that anybody wants as part of their team.

With that said, I am not a robot. Just like everyone else, I experience personal problems that may affect my work. If and when that happens, I take PTO and/or talk to my direct supervisor about it l. This way they are simply aware of it on a personal level, and when applicable, know why I may not attend certain calls or may have to push back deadlines for any deliverables that coming up in the near future.

tl;dr your experience isn’t normal, but it is also not uncommon. There are good places to work that value your professionalism and work ethic. I hope you find one soon for your sake!

2
Khulod•

I'm in the Netherlands working for a MSP and have worked in large Enterprises. I can say with confidence your wages are far too low for the work you do. Isn't the minimum wage in France 1500 Euros/mo?

Also, unpaid overtime? Illegal here, and it might be in France as well. At the very least I don't think there's anything stopping you from leaving after your contractual hours are up.

2
DeathRowLemonOP•

Sluit als ‘n bus. Maar het minimumloon in FR is ongeveer 1200 netto. Dus maak er voor t gemak 1500 bruto van. Ik ben aan het solliciteren op een IT positie in Amsta dus wie weet! Ze bieden ook een herlocatie pakket aan.

Wat die overuren betreft en zoals in een andere comment al aangaf; er is een verschil tussen de wet en de handhaving daarvan en werk niet afgemaakt op maandag moet op dinsdag ook gedaan worden.. hoe dan ook. Ik blijf hier niet lang meer hopelijk!

1
Khulod•

Het werk dat niet af is, is het probleem van de werkgever, niet de werknemer. Jij, met je net-niet-minimloon (of onder-minimumloon als je de onbetaalde uren meetelt) bent daar niet verantwoordelijk voor. Je baas kan dat wel zeggen, maar laat je niet gek maken. Vooral niet voor een hongerloon. Je kan voor hetzelfde geld een baan nemen zonder alle stress. Of zoals je hopelijk al doet een partij zoeken die je wel bereid is fatsoenlijk te betalen. Klop vooral aan bij Managed Services Providers en dergelijke, die zoeken vaak skilled helpdesk staf en weten over het algemeen wel wat ze waard zijn.

2
DeathRowLemonOP•

Ja helemaal gelijk. Ik ben al hard op zoek naar iets gezelligs.

1

1400€/month in France and with that kind of workload? WTF!!

Like most have said...start looking for another job. Stop working unpaid overtime, it is their problem you are short staffed.

1
Hirogen10•

Y eah i worked in IT in france for a few weeks and we were on the ground floor we were seen as crap.

1
DeathRowLemonOP•

Fun thing is this company is small and almost strictly It

2
Hirogen10•

see my other comment when you work for a small family of people they love to work people to the ground its the only way they can feel powerful.

0
wezelboy•

Sounds like a classic example of Windows Vertical Market Amateur Hour. Get out fast.

1
DeathRowLemonOP•

The what’s that now?

1

Somebody creates an application for a specific niche. In this case, pharma sales.

The owner gets rich and they pinch pennies on the support for the program.

In this case, throw in a huge sales org and a tiny support staff, and you get this kind of a problem.

Sometimes it can go on for decades. But often at some point it stops working and they start to lose customers and eventually go out of business or it's sold cheap to a larger company.

BASIS: I've worked at a few companies like this in their end stages. No fun at all.

2
DeathRowLemonOP•

Im exactly there; the end stages. The company has been bought out by a bigger fish, basically the pharma monopoly in France,and the OG dev and founder is only really sticking round because the company is his ‘baby’ so to speak. They’re just waiting for their replacements and after that, that’s it. Their out. Millionaires.

2

You should be looking for something better.

I don't know exactly how things work in France, but I'm sure you can find better pay and better work if you look, unless we have some kind of huge worldwide recession.

1
wezelboy•

This is a pretty good description. Another telltale sign- the product is built on .NET

Occasionally they'll use java instead, but running on tomcat on top of windows. Usually these companies try to upsell a "hosted" solution.

2

My experiences were with even older technologies. But essentially the same idea.

A good result when the tech was relatively fresh. No upgrade. Eventually the product is obsolete. No new customers. Lose existing customers one by one.

Possible upgrade impeded by slavish accepting of customer special requests. So key dev spends a month on a $10000 custom feature sale instead of adding $250,000 in value by working on the new version with current tech and current market look and feel.

Eventual extinction or fire sale of intellectual property for the last tiny bit of value and a customer list.

2
BryceKatz•

Is it common? Unfortunately, yes. A lot of small businesses get started by folks with very good ideas and very little concept of what's required to actually run a successful business. You can get away with that for a while - possibly decades - but it doesn't scale. Once the business starts taking off, the lack of business acumen becomes increasingly noticeable AND harmful to the company's overall health & long-term viability.

Is it normal? No. This environment is incredibly toxic. If you can stick it out for a year, do so & then use the experience to get a better job.

1

Here’s a wild idea: convince the two (2) other techies to make demands as a unit, either through a proper worker union or just by staying together.

You can bring the whole company down, without striking a - well - strike. Just agree to not do overtime (paid or nonpaid).

Consider the company’s options: they can fire all three of you, lose all of their experience, have no idea of what the current status is, have a huge pressure to hire new people experienced enough to just gather the breadcrumbs and start the halted process and put the whole company’s reputation at risk. Or they can pay you guys at least 2000€/mo, agree to hire more personnel, and as a bonus avoid the looming catastrophe that will happen despite your teams best, unpaid efforts.

Also your experience inside the company as a merit has to be worth more than your current wage.

Obviously the owners talk though. They use every trick to squeeze value out of you by quilt tripping, screaming, belittling you. They call you incompetent because they have not considered your value, and prefer to see it as low so they can pay you low.

But at the end of the day the less people are in your team the more valuable you are individually. The better negotiation position you are in. You probably can see how valuable one third of all technical customer support is for a tech company. That has a value that can be measured in euros, and it sure as hell is not measured in thousands of euros. And your team should also see how even agreeing to not do overtime is something the company needs to take very, very seriously.

Contact a union organisation, and make sure you don’t break any laws - and also that you can distinguish when the company inevitably tries something unlawful. I’m very confident not doing overtime is legal without any prior notice (unless you have explicitly agreed to show up), and unpaid overtime is outside the law anyway.

I’d say doing nothing, not helping your team members on this issue they no doubt also think, would be being a sensitive pussy. What are you afraid of? The people exploiting you feeling bad? Them trying to intimidate and belittle you? Them threatening to fire you, a thing that would both be illegal and leave the company compromised? Be strong and declare the value of yourself and your co-workers. The management will learn it if you just dare to speak up, and act as a team.

1
BadSausageFactory•

I mean it's not normal but at the same time it's pretty common

1
oliland1•

Viens travailler au Canada! Lâche cette boîte de merde!

0
DeathRowLemonOP•

Faut un visa quand même…

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1