How important are browns in a composting weed pile?

As spring is ending, I have a near infinite number of weeds on my land. Currently when I'm clearing areas, I just put all the weeds I've pulled into a pile. Freshly pulled weeds count as greens, right?

Thus, my compost piles are very green at the moment.

I'm planning on getting a chipper, at which point I'll be creating a lot of woodchips, but I'd rather use the woodchips for Back to Eden style groundcover.

What am I risking by not intentionally introducing browns into my green weed compost piles? If its slower, I don't really mind, but if the resulting compost is 'worse', maybe I'd want to remedy that.

Posted Jun 23, 2022, 12:27 AM UTC

813
cephalophile32•

Will it decompose? Yes. Will it stink? Yep. If you can, lay out the weeds to dry first. Then they count as browns :)

16
GreyFoxLemonGrass•

Eh, I have piles that are weeds, and they’re too brown to decompose quickly. If your weeds are stalky and mature they may be balanced enough to not be considered “green.” If they’re all nice wet purslane and dandelions then yeah, they’ll probably smell. If that’s the case let them dry out a bit and then pile them up again.

5
BoudiccaGoesWest•

Ok, so this one time when I was living in the city and had a tiny backyard and no browns to work with, I dug a hole and buried a plastic garbage can with holes drilled in the sides for worms, and threw all my household compost in it and nothing else. A year later, the resulting sludge I dug out was some of the vilest textured and smelling substance I’ve ever encountered, but everything I planted over top of it had massive growth spurts the next 3 years.

tl;dr—in my experience, there’s no such thing as too many greens, but you may want a gas mask.

5
Sqwitton•

The trick with this is to cut off the bottom of the can so when it's full you can pull it right up (and cover the contents if desired).

5
lizardsquirt•

Compost can become too high in nitrogen which makes it smellly

4
Mean-Mr-mustarde•

Browns are very important, some say you should have between 4-25x more browns than green.

4
glamourcrow•

If the stems of your weeds are rather hard, it should work. It's usually only a problem when you use grass cuttings that will stick together, preventing air from circulating. As long as the air is able to get in between the layers of green, you are fine. You only get a bad smell if the deeper layers of your heap are deprived of oxygen.

An easy solution is to go to your local recycling centre and get some cardboard, remove anything plastic, and put layers of loosely crunched-up cardboard between layers of green. Add a few twigs for extra airiness.

A more time-consuming method is to turn your heap weekly and mix basic siliceous diabase rock dust into your greens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rock_flour

We have four large compost bins, one for dead leaves in autumn. I use the leaf compost to mix under my greens in summer and we are regularly turning our piles. I use cardboard and rock dust and it works well.

We have only a few hectares of fruit orchards and a large vegetable garden, not a giant farm.

4

Any storm dropped branches or old straw available for carbon layer?

3

Your only issue really is going to be smell. Otherwise the output will be fine.

3
Vrayloki•

You can use torn up cardboard or paper as browns

3
vertterre•

Just lay them where they are, give them a week or two to dry out and the pile won’t smell as much

3
Seelixx•

If you don't have any paper or cardboard throw in some dirt too. I'm pretty new to composting, but had the same issue and it seemed to help break up the greens at least so they didn't clump up and mold.

3
bothydweller72•

I compost a lot of green stuff sometimes, I’ve only had smell problems if I tried to put too many fresh grass clippings in at a time. If you did get a smell problem, turning and spraying with lactobacillus will sort it

2