r/atheism mod is deleting comments and banning people because they criticized her modding. Looks like we have another Karmanaut!
reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/vsp1x/ratheism_...Posted Jul 2, 2012, 8:59 PM UTC
Posted Jul 2, 2012, 8:59 PM UTC
So the OP is involved in the story as one of the people who got banned, breaking a clear rule. Not only is he involved, he's creepily collecting personal information about her. In case the OP deletes those things, screenshot with data removed.
Calling her "another Karmanaut" is hyperbolic when all she did is delete off-topic posts, and the people who like r/atheism don't appear to be bothered by her actions.
A user further down in this post reveals that several people were putting copypasta all over the place, and that's what she was mostly deleting, and that she even unbanned him when he apologized.
The OP appears to be the childish one in this story, not the moderator. "Let's derail a serious thread with copypasta mocking atheists and the moderator, have those comments removed, and then run to subredditdrama to complain about how oppressive the moderator is.
[deleted]
Nope. Every single thing I quoted and linked to was posted in this very thread. The only person's history I looked at was the guy that asked us to do so in order to confirm his story.
I'm not sure if you were just being stupid, or think we are, but it was impossible to miss what you were up to.
[deleted]
I'm amazed at r/atheism. The OP says he's matching the donations of atheists to fight cancer? How is that any different from somebody matching the donations of Christians? If you want to fight cancer, fucking donate, no strings attached.
It's different because everything has to be Us vs Them to r/atheism.
We didn't criticize her. We were circlejerking with copypasta.
Don't believe me? Look at mine and u/ParakeetNipple's comment history for deleted comments in that thread.
I even got banned, and I apologized for the copypasta (even though I had to reply to "You're doing God's work," that's too funny) and the ban was lifted.
I don't like making false witch hunts :/
Reading those comments, especially this one, it looks like your bans were well deserved. Just because a sub is loosely moderated doesn't mean they're unable to deal with intentional trolling. The fact that you apologized and they unbanned you, shows that everyone was being pretty rational.
Not much to see here, I guess.
It was copypasta in a copypasta thread, dude. I wasn't harassing anyone or trolling. It's probably annoying for a mod to delete that junk, deserving of a warning. Heck, I never even replied to her post like others were.
I said "everyone" was being rational, which includes you. You were just having some fun. She wasn't wrong for banning everyone that was participating in that stunt. You made a good decision to simply ask to be unbanned, and she made a good decision in agreeing. You weren't being malicious, but at the time it was happening she couldn't be expected to know that.
Fair enough.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Judging by the comment chain, that seems more like she deleted some r/circlejerk uuh... circlejerking?
What's the difference between that and everyday r/atheism nonsense?
as a proud r/atheism circlejerker, what the fuck? r/atheism's moderation policy has always basically been to do jack shit. I'd argue that it's caused a severe deficit of "good" content, but r/atheism has never attempted to be the best of the best in that sense and I don't think anyone would argue otherwise. This is a stunning reversal. I mad bro.
r/atheism running rampant and turning into a terrible subreddit? Do nothing.
Butthurt about people making fun of you? Ban everyone!
Everybody says there is this CIRCLEJERKING problem in r/atheism. Everybody says this r/atheism CIRCLEJERKING problem will be solved when the admins remove r/atheism and only r/atheism from the default subreddits.
r/gaming and r/science are circlejerks just like r/atheism, but nobody says r/gaming or r/science will solve their CIRCLEJERKING problem by being removed as default subreddits.
Everybody says the solution to this CIRCLEJERKING problem is for r/atheism and ONLY r/atheism to be cast away as a default.
What if I said there was this CIRCLEJERKING problem in r/politics and this CIRCLEJERKING problem in r/politics would be solved only if r/politics were removed as a default subreddit?
How long would it take anyone to realize I'm not talking about a CIRCLEJERKING problem. I am talking about the solution to the LIBERAL problem?
And how long would it take a liberal to notice this and what kind of censorship-loving moron wouldn't object to this?
But if I tell that obvious truth about the ongoing program of persecution against my belief system, religious conservatives and ultra-PC liberals agree that I am a dawkinsworshippingneckbeard.
They say they are anti-r/atheism. What they are is anti-atheist.
Anti-r/atheism is a code for for anti-atheism.
Cripes. We hate r/atheism's circlejerk because they are hateful assholes high on their own sense of superiority who don't even attempt thoughtful content. We hate that we have to join and unsub to avoid it. Imagine if that was r/christianity (which is nowhere near as bad). I bet you guys would have a huge problem if that was the case.
Proud lifelong atheist here, and I happily unsubbed once I made my account. What you're saying OS the functional equivalent of saying hating Israel is antisemitic.
...ugh.
No, we aren't anti-atheism. We're against mindless idiots. Of which there are many in r/atheism. (Note: This does not in any way indicate anything about the average atheist.)
I love the smell of the butthurt godless in the morning. Atheist popcorn-nom nom nom
(for clarity I am sadly affiliated loosely with the views juliebeen espouses but not the full retard version)
Let me guess, is that beanie mod again.
Checks thread
juliebeen
Yuuup.
why is r/atheism still a default sub
I was wondering the same thing. It isn't even in the top 20 anymore.
Its done by activity level, not subscribers. There's a link to view that type of thing, but I don't know where it is.
It's all automated. If you have enough activity to be in the top 20, and you check the box that says's you're okay with being a default sub, you're in.
because it's popular. it had 400k subscribers even before it was defaulted.
deal with it.
[deleted]
You know who isn't popular?
Our Lord and Saviour Ron Paul
Wait, didn't GoT confirm this one?
Yep I thought so too. Some moron is going to claim some extra points over there for getting it featured on SRD.
mods? on MY r/atheism?
How did r/atheism get such terrible mods? They're either not there, think the sub shouldn't be modded at all, or are unstable and juvenile as u/juliebeen appears to be.
I believe the moderation done by the other two can be literally summed up as: nothing. I don't know why they added the new one (I believe it was rather recent, within the last few months). If the policy is to moderate nothing, it doesn't seem as though there's a pressing need for moderators.
u/jij apparently runs r/atheismbot.
TIL they have a 4th mod as of today.
They just got a new one today! u/jij is now a mod.
[deleted]
Did you just fucking dox her? I hope the admins shadowban you. I just sent hueypriest a pm. That shit isn't cool, and I'm pissed.
Edit: I apologize for the name-calling. I wasn't kidding when I said I was pissed.
I thought you hated this subreddit.
No, I hate the neckbeards who use SRD as a launching pad for their hate. I <3 SRD. I hate the cancer.
Nice job. I sent the mods a message asking for this whole thing to be removed since it breaks several rules of the subreddit anyway. OP is trying to create a witchhunt.
Check out who just got added to the mod list.
rubs hands together...
Muahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.
Dude, he it by going through her public post info for five minutes. Not top-secret stuff.
The admins will shadowban you for that. He said how old she was, what she did for a living and where she lived in a witch hunt against her. Some people are fucking crazy. You just don't put all of that information in one place when the pitchforks are out.
Doh, I missed it. Who posted the dox?
u/bigh124
Apparently he's a member of r/GameOfTrolls.
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]