r/totalwar•
vanticus

Start Position Prediction Competition

Warhammer III

Hello r/TotalWar! We have now (mostly) come to end of the start position releases and the Immortal Empire map is made clear to us. Along the way, many of you have made your own maps guessing where the various Legendary Lords would begin. I have been recording these guesses and ranking their accuracy as the days went by. Some were more accurate than others- some lords were obvious guesses but some took everyone by surprise. Some people guessed more lords than others, so I graphed everyone’s score in a way that accounts for that.

Methods

Not everyone made their predictions on the same map and not every map was of the same quality. I have counted a guess as ‘correct’ if the Lord ended in the same province as the prediction. A guess counts as a ‘near miss’ if the prediction was in a neighbouring province to the correct province. Some Lords have two start locations (e.g. Eltharion with Yvresse and the Southern Badlands), so both locations count as ‘correct’.

I have included the Vortex, Mortal Empires, and Realms of Chaos Maps as forms of baselines.

Results

Here is a picture of the individual results, ranking from most accurate to least:

https://preview.redd.it/e4j41oom9qb91.png?width=650&format=png&auto=webp&s=25560c8e142afb78e46c90cf4f76be0280e9a569

​

https://preview.redd.it/pd03vfwl9qb91.png?width=788&format=png&auto=webp&s=391cded8401c10474c9dce2379835c4e5490ea5f

100% League

Most entrants to this game made predictions after the first start positions began to be released, so I believe a separate ranking is in order for those who bravely put out an entire map’s worth of predictions without a single confirmed position to guide their decisions.

https://preview.redd.it/hwt3zmmn9qb91.png?width=643&format=png&auto=webp&s=2351687636e6fd521761c1d884dea459bc092d1e

​

Most predictable Lords

Everyone (who did not make a shitpost) guessed the start locations for Karl Franz, Markus Wulfhart, Gor Rok, Tzarina Katerin, Tyrion, Alarielle, Eltharion, Louen Leoncoeur, the Fay Enchantress, Repanse de Lyonesse, Throt the Unclean, Queen Khalida, Orion, the Sisters of Twilight, Drycha, Count Noctilus, Thorgrim Grudgebearer and Malakith (19 total).

Least predictable Lords

No one was able to guess the start locations for Kairos, Skarbrand, Ku’gath, the Daemon Prince, Kroq-Gar, Nakai the Wanderer, Boris Bokha, Teclis, Prince Imrik, Alberic de Bordelaux, Grimgor, Skarsnik, Skrag the Slaughterer, Cylostra Direfin, Lokhir Fellheart, Malus Darkblade, Helman Ghorst, or Archaon the Everchosen (18 total).

Near misses

No one was able to guess the start locations for Nakai the Wanderer, Prince Imrik, Alberic de Bordelaux, Grimgor Ironhide, Skarsnik, Cylostra Direfin, Lokhir Fellheart, Malus Darkblade, and Archaon, but some people made brave suggestions they would move and scored a near miss.

​

https://preview.redd.it/7voo5cjp9qb91.png?width=800&format=png&auto=webp&s=9ae840eb75cd4533bb25bec8047ad07283c68dd8

Sole Successes

Only one person was able to guess the start locations for Volkmar the Grim (Castaing), Oxyotl (SIRUNKLYDUNK), Wulfrik the Wanderer (TotalTotalWar), Queek Headtaker (Castaing), and Mannfred von Carstein (Castaing).

Notable Predictions

Hamoorftw made a clear shitpost, guessing almost everyone would start in LustriaBowl.

SIRUNKLYDUNK has entertained us with his numerous memes about the start positions, but this data suggests that he had to remake at least 40% of his meme stockpile to reflect the true start positions.

CamDMTreehouse’s map did not turn out to be very accurate, but it had some strong near misses.

Finally, Castaing had the highest number of solo guesses, correctly predicting more of the uncertain moves than anyone else.

Overall Conclusions

The average map guessed 53.6% correct, which is 4% lower than the Mortal Empires baseline. The highest % correct maps also guessed far less start positions of the total whole. 19 lords have a highly predictable placement, 18 lords have a completely unpredictable start position. There are still major gaps on the map and several of the prediction maps I analysed also made guesses for Chaos Dwarfs and the approaching Four Champions pack.

The final map was completely unpredicted, and it shows that it is important not to treat things in this game as certainties, as the vast majority of things are liable to changed at any moment. Whether these changes are good or bad remains to be seen, but it is our responsibility as a community to both be receptive to new changes but also firm in our criticism when new changes do not work out in practice.

Disclaimer

I am not a data scientist and this research is purely a result of map-making interest. I hope everyone enjoyed the previous two weeks as much as I did. I make no guarantees that any of this information is 100% correct and its all just a bit of fun. If anyone posted a map but I did not include it, feel free to comment a link below and I will try to include it if I do a round two of this later on.

Here are the links to everyone’s original maps that I based this analysis on:

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vn44ko/guessing_immortal_empire_start_positions/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vnfnrq/immortal_empires_map_speculation_very_quick_and/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/v9x3ql/the_only_starting_position_change_that_i_want/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vhjn25/my_guess_at_ie_starts/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vi31j4/looking_at_habitability_to_guess_where_the_chaos/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vi86t0/gaming_out_new_ie_start_locations_for_wh12_lords/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwarhammer/comments/vcbua1/my_take_on_possible_starting_positions_in/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/v7ph2y/hehe/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vr97q3/after_the_unsurprising_cathay_reveals_heres_my/

Kharnagor’s map may be deleted or I am looking in the wrong place

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vqtjwy/my_attempt_to_predict_the_remaining_start/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vrz0uo/rough_draft_of_new_start_positions/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vuelt5/my_predictions_for_all_factions_starting_position/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vt7p6m/i_got_tired_of_waiting_for_the_start_positions_to/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vret2j/immortal_empires_all_start_positions_concept/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vsio5m/fugly_predictions_including_dlc_chorfs_and_dow/

https://www.reddit.com/r/totalwar/comments/vlmg6r/with_start_locations_coming_up_on_tuesday_i/

Finally, here is the grand picture of my spreadsheet with all the data on it (NSFW)

​

https://preview.redd.it/mwbkeueeaqb91.png?width=1846&format=png&auto=webp&s=d836cefb5086e75c424452aed24b97e0fa782f22

Posted Jul 15, 2022, 12:48 PM UTC

9212
Jejinak•

Oh wow, I didn't realise I had entered a competition. Even though I only made 6 guesses which included a faction called Sylvania and Be'lakor which included the named start settlement. I humbly accept first place.

I am very grateful for all my friends and family who supported throughout my journey. Except you, Ghorst. How did you get so lost on your way Nagashizzar!

More seriously, cool stats. Thank you.

27
SabyZMODieval 2•
21
DragonBallKruber•

The monster math

2
SabyZMODieval 2•
3
Dserved83•

This is awesome! u/Castaing impressed me!

5
glassteelhammer•

So.... statistically speaking, who would win the prize here?

Jejinak is the most accurate with the least (6) guesses.

SIRUNKLYDUNK is the most accurate 100% guesser.

u/vanticus, gimme an answer and perhaps a Lord Pack (WoC) DLC on Steam might go to the winner.

Seems someone should win a prize for all this effort.

5
AverageRainbow•

I mean. A winner could be determined by combining of the two data points (how many factions they guessed and their accuracy). OP could make a follow up post to find the true winner

2
glassteelhammer•

Also could work!

1
vanticusOP•

A prize would be great fun! But you’re right that the “winner” could be taken in various directions. I would like to create some kind of weighting system that reflects both accuracy and number of guesses.

I would also like to take into account the number of near misses, because I think a lot of near misses were “in the right ballpark”, where most of the “wrong” answers were entirely misplaced.

When the 4 Champions get announced, I will probably do a part two. In the meantime, I will trial a couple of ranking systems and try to produce something that is both fair and transparent.

In the meantime, I would nominate that Jejinak, Castaing, and SIRUNKLYDUNK would win the three categories of (1) most accurate, (2) most uniquely accurate, and (3) most accurate whole-map guess.

2
glassteelhammer•

Let me know how the trial runs work out. Happy to sponsor a few DLCs!

Probably gotta clear it with mods, but you could even post it as a formal competition.

Or should we just call it here, and call Jejinak, Castaing, and SIRUNKLYDUNK the winners?

Personally, I'd love some more weighting and to see a best guesser.

1
Jereboy216•

Even though I've only played 1 campaign and know pretty much nothing about Warhammer, i thoroughly enjoyed these last 2 weeks. I am an avid fan of looking at maps and messing with them. So this has been blissful.

Thanks for compiling all this data and presenting it. And for linking all the maps. Many of them I hadn't seen!

3
Castaing•

Wow you put in a ton of work creating this! I loved reading through it.

Looking back over my guesses, my outlook was too conservative and I didn’t think CA would be willing to revisit, e.g. Alberic. Really pleased with how the official map is looking.

2