What we do control - a practical example

Stoic Theory/Study

I notice that many people's Stoic practice is based upon a fundamental misunderstanding of what we control. There's a post now entitled "do we control our emotions".

The hard answer is "no". Our emotions are how our beliefs manifest in the conscious mind, so the question is best re-written as "do we control our beliefs". Again, the answer is a hard "no".

To demonstrate this, go outside in the middle of the day. You'll find that the belief "it is day time" (which the Stoics call "an impression") emerges spontaneously. Now try to change that belief to "it is night time" - this means you try to actually believe that it is night time.

You'll find it's impossible - you possess literally no power over your belief that it is day time, because the sun is in the sky and you reason "the sun is in the sky, therefore it is day time".

Here is Epictetus on the same point:

That you assent to that which you feel is true, and cannot be instructed to do otherwise

Discourse 1, 25 "More on the same theme"

So what do you control? You control the faculty which analyses the belief "it is day time". This is the faculty of prohairesis - the faculty of assent or dissent, which can be (imprecisely) called "the faculty of reason".

To prove that you control this faculty, go outside again in the middle of the day. Now, instead of trying to change your belief from "it is day" to "it is night", try to subject the belief "it is day" to rational analysis. You'll quickly find yourself asking things like "at exactly what point does it become night? Is it when the sun dips over the horizon? If so, what happens if I step back from the horizon at the exact moment the sun dips below it, giving me more view over it - have I quickly transitioned from night back into day?".

It's not impossible that you could eventually convince yourself that there truly is no such thing as "day" and "night", and that the belief that there are is a cognitive illusion based on our intuitions about ambient light levels. You could, through this process of reasoning, genuinely stop believing that it was day simply because the sun was in the sky. You might transition to a system that doesn't split the world into "day" or "night" but instead concerns itself with the photonic flux through a given volume around you, and you could genuinely believe that this was a more accurate view of reality than "day or night". This is the power of change this faculty permits.

Now think about a belief that manifests as an emotion more obvious than the ones associated with "it is day" or "it is night". Think about how what you've just learned applies to beliefs like "this person has wronged me", which manifests in the conscious mind as anger, or beliefs like "this person will, they cheat on me with someone else, ruin my life", which manifests in the conscious mind as emotions of jealousy and insecurity.

You do not control these beliefs. You do not control the emotions they manifest as. But you do control the faculty which formed these beliefs, and which can subject those beliefs to further scrutiny. When you are subject to those emotions, if you are trying to "control your anger" or "deal with the cheating" you have no prospect of being well - you are trying to control the element of the problem you do not control. But if you subject the belief "this person has wronged me" or "this person will destroy me if they cheat" to your rational faculty, you are re-assessing these things.

The Stoics say that every re-assessment of an emotion that is leaving you malcontent will reveal error. I cannot convince you of this, I can only tell you that I have now subjected thousands of such beliefs to the rational faculty and found that every single one of them contained the predicted error, and the moment it was exposed the belief that was manifesting as a negative emotion vanished, as surely as a person believing it to be night having their error exposed by the presence of the sun would instantaneously stop feeling as though it was night, assuming they still accepted that day and night existed.

Naturally, Epictetus said it more succinctly than I ever could:

Now, for what purpose did nature arm us with reason? To make the correct use of impressions. And what is reason if not a collection of individual impressions? Hence, it naturally comes to turn its analysis on itself.

Discourse 1, 20 "Concerning Reason and How It Studies Itself"

Posted Jul 20, 2022, 3:02 PM UTC

1734
GD_WoTS•

I think the usage of the English “control” lends to confusion; if “eph’hemin” is translated as control, as it is by George LongWA Oldfather, Elizabeth Carter, and probably others, then we end up with the notion, unwieldy in conventional English, that our passions are indeed in our control.

Also, at least as the Stoics saw it, anger depends not only on the belief of wrong having been done, but also on a belief about delivering punishment to the apparent wrongdoer.

4
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

I'm increasingly coming around to the use of the word "control", because it permits a lot of tests that clear-up what you do and don't control.

If you're angry, and you want to know whether you control your anger, simply choose not to be angry. If you cannot do it, you don't control it.

But if you're angry, and you want to subject the opinion that you should be angry to scrutiny, you can always do it. You might not choose to do it, but that choice is the only thing preventing you taking the action.

I read the George Long translation of the Discourses - I am satisfied that the distinction in that book is as clear as I just made it, and that a word other than "control" wouldn't be so clear.

Take the same example - you can ask "do you control your anger?" and answer it with a simple test "can I always choose to stop being angry". But if we translate eph'hemin to "up to us" and not "control", now you're asking "is my anger up to me?". How does one answer that? I don't think it is more clear - I actually now believe what I did not before, which is that "control" does work.

2
GD_WoTS•

Whoops, I don’t think Long uses the term; mixed him up with Oldfather. I agree that there’s no radical, “flip a switch” control, and that we can’t simply choose not to be angry, or to be jealous, etc.

Something that is eph’hemin is something for which we are the principal cause, bearing primary responsibility for it. If we ask “is our anger eph’hemin?” the answer is yes, anger being a desire, and so an ideal translation, if one exists, will help clarify that. But maybe there isn’t an ideal translation.

1

So what do you control? You control the faculty which analyses the belief...

A resounding yes, if we possess a fully functioning, completely myelinated, undisturbed prefrontal cerebral cortex, which thankfully most of us were born with. Our entire brain is partially in our control until the higher brain can discern that which can be placed fully in our control.

Executive function/cognitive control in humans absolutely gives us all the traits to reason, cooperate and make wise decisions. However, there's typically an interplay between the lower brain functions that takes some practice to recognize and there's the pinch-point that trips most of us up. So, practicing by using our ruling faculty to discern katalepsis from the initial impression from the reflex is such an important part of a Stoic practice. So that's one important part of the equation.

Prefrontal cortex has been implicated in executive functions such as planning, decision making, short term memory, personality expression, moderating social behavior and controlling certain aspects of speech and language. Executive function relates to abilities to differentiate among conflicting thoughts, determine good and bad, better and best, same and different, future consequences of current activities, working toward a defined goal, prediction of outcomes, expectation based on actions, and social "control" (the ability to suppress urges that, if not suppressed, could lead to socially unacceptable outcomes). The frontal cortex supports concrete rule learning. More anterior regions along the rostro-caudal axis of frontal cortex support rule learning at higher levels of abstraction. (From Wiki)

The other important part of the equation is we all can think of about 100 things that can trip us up before we even get out of the gate. Drugs and other substances, malnutrition, dehydration, injury, hormone imbalance, infection, over-active amygdala, poor blood oxygen levels, blood panel values not in normal parameters, and cancer. The list goes on and on towards affecting our ruling faculty. So I encourage us to take care of what the cosmos gave us, to the best of our ability. Our brains are really the entirety of who we are.

2
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

However, there's typically an interplay between the lower brain functions that takes some practice to recognize and there's the pinch-point that trips most of us up.

The theory "everything that goes wrong is a mindless animal instinct that I forgot to arrest" does not correspond to the reality of how the mind works, and it's part of a Freudian "reason versus emotion" false dichotomy.

This bad theory has only one explanation of bad behaviour - "it was my animal instinct taking me over". This is completely false - the actual cause of any behaviour that is maladaptive is "I thought it was in my interest to act that way". There is no maladaptive behaviour that is just "animal instinct", and which is not subject to reason.

If you don't agree, then simply prove your point - describe to me a behaviour which was caused by "animal instinct" and was not subject to reason, meaning that even if you absolutely believed that it would bring no benefit your body would somehow be compelled to do it anyway.

1

It's a pinch-point until the reflex subsides. A person who has turned white as a sheet has to wait momentarily for his senses to normalize.

How would a Stoic prevent the fight/ flight/freeze response? I don't know of any humans except those who have been highly trained operatives to withstand torture. That's not normal species behavior.

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

How would a Stoic prevent the fight/ flight/freeze response?

Describe it. Describe a specific fight/flight response scenario, in which nothing you believed about the situation could change that response, and which you'd be forced to have it no matter what you believed.

If you can do it, and I cannot name anything belief that would prevent that situation unfolding, you've proven your point.

1

Having an orgasm is a reflex. Yes, I can control what behavior comes next, but I am blinded once the reflex starts. Rape victims (male and female) have reported the stimulation of a rape has brought them to orgasm, which is something they couldn't control.

So would you say their prefrontal cortex executive functioning shut down, and if it didn't, then they wanted the orgasm? Can it be both? Neither?

I'm truly just trying to discern where that separation of the brain functioning takes place and how it's biologically possible. I'm not a neurobiologist.

1
NaiveElevator8100•

The torture method of waterboarding, perhaps

1
NaiveElevator8100•

If you see the limits to this and keep it realistic, this is great stuff. (I got a new angle on this:) For instance, you cannot say that you haven't been harmed if a tyrant cuts off your arm, because if you convince yourself of this you're in conflict with nature. The term 'harm' will mean something different than it does for a non-Stoic (even animals), and your body will still signal to your brain that tissue has been damaged (pain). If you then say and convince yourself that you don't value your body, but you do your reasoning and choice and etc, then you're at odds with how your body was designed, which is quite the grandiose and foolish thing to do.

You can go pretty far in changing your beliefs, but they might diverge from reality, and the question is which ones you want to change and why. If you believe that it is night when the sun is out, you've simply swapped some words; if you also want to not have effects that daytime would entain for a human, like being more alert, you're going against nature. You might however succeed in feeling drowsy when the sun is out, because your new belief (an imaginary construct) can become quite powerful. However, your body will still repair DNA damage from the sun and do other things that daytime would entail, like raising awareness; this will still be the case even if your imagination is very powerful.

If someone you are close to dies you will feel sadness to some degree; we're social animals after all. I wonder why we are inclined to call mourning behavior beautiful if an elephant or another animal does it?

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

For instance, you cannot say that you haven't been harmed if a tyrant cuts off your arm, because if you convince yourself of this you're in conflict with nature.

Yes you can, in fact if you place your worth into an arm, then you've misunderstood where worth comes from.

Here is Epictetus:

‘But my leg is crippled.’ Slave, are you going to be at odds with the world because of one lame leg? Shouldn’t you rather make the world a gift of it, and gladly return it to the one who gave it to you originally? Are you going to make Zeus your enemy, and set your face against the Fates, with whom Zeus spun the thread of your destiny at the moment you were born, laying out his plans for you?

Epictetus - Discourse 12 "On Satisfaction"

What use is a person who puts value in his arm. If you do this, all any person who wishes to compel you has to do is threaten to remove your arm. I could make you murder, rape, kill and pillage, and all I need to do is threaten to remove your arm.

And if you say "well, under those circumstances, I'd hope to tell you to take my arm rather than act thus" then you are inconsistent - for you claim that the removal of the arm is an evil and to believe otherwise is unnatural, yet I've easily named a scenario where you'd think exactly the opposite.

So when you say...

If you see the limits to this and keep it realistic, this is great stuff.

Then you've not understood what is being said - there is no "limit" to the usefulness of subjecting your belief to reason. You talk as though it is possible to make yourself believe anything. This is the same mistake - "I control my beliefs".

You don't control your beliefs - you control the faculty of reason by which beliefs are formed.

Is this now clear?

1
NaiveElevator8100•

Of course you can take my arm in certain situations, as I did not put my whole worth into an arm. I am however not very keen on you having to remove my arm, as it will be very painful and my body will be damaged. In nature, what do we call a monkey with only one arm? Dead, of course. Even a monkey knows that the removal of an arm is an evil.
Saying that a removal of your arm is of no worth to you is like the 'this is fine' meme, because you are programmed by nature to value your body and to stay alive and prosper. It took milions of years of evolution for an entity shaped and operating entirely based on nature, down to the way it perceives and values things at a basic level, to conclude that the survival drive is not important, because you control your faculty of reason. Now I'm back at my old arguments, so I won't bother you again haha.

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

Saying that a removal of your arm is of no worth to you is like the 'this is fine' meme, because you are programmed by nature to value your body and to stay alive and prosper.

But you're not - if I said "you need to rape your mother, or I'll take your arm", you wouldn't even be tempted to rape your mother, you'd give me the arm gladly.

Where did this "programming" magically vanish off to? You claimed it was completely involuntary, a "program", something that would happen no matter what you believe, and I am trivially describing scenarios where your "programming" vanishes, which means it's not there at all.

The obvious truth is staring you in the face - your opinion drives your actions, not some "instinct". You only want an arm when you assess it's reasonable to have it, and when you assess it not to be reasonable you will give it up.

This is true of everything you believe. Of course you don't see that - you undermine yourself by saying "I have no control over the impulses I have that harm me". This is the flaw in your life, and the source of your unhappiness, and it's demonstrably in error.

2
NaiveElevator8100•

We're talking past each other it seems, but I also promised to stop my ramblings. Clearly I can't express my opinions very well, as you don't seem to understand my point.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Victorian_Bullfrog•

I quite agree. We, each one of us, are relatively physically delicate, natural scientists who start life with an insatiable curiosity and desire to understand how the world works from the perspective of how we can relate to it. From infancy, we learned to understand and control, and eventually direct that first muscle babble into purposeful reaching out for a toy or spoon. We learned that our smiles are more likely to generate certain behavior, and our cries other certain behaviors. This is all natural and instinctive and takes no conscious effort on our part.

The thing about human brains though, is that there is simply too much information to be figured out in the short time we have before adulthood. Arguably, this explains childhood credulity - the natural inclination for children to trust their caregivers to be telling the truth for beneficial reasons. Eat your vegetables, don't talk to strangers, brush your teeth, Santa is coming. But what about children who grow up in racist families and communities? They learn that part of how the world works includes a differentiation between peoples, a value system of competency and worth based on ethnic features and associations. This applies to familial beliefs about sexual orientation/identity, political leanings, religious beliefs (or lack thereof), etc. It even applies to less grand ideas, like which are the best movies to watch on a Friday night, or whether you routinely eat dinner with bread or rice.

We may not all grow up in racist environments, but we all grow up assuming the world works the way our caregivers taught us. Furthermore, we grow up incorporating our own personal experiences against this backdrop. We learn to look critically at some things our parents and society sanction (which is why the teen years can contain so much conflict), but others we assume are accurate representatives of reality and simply keep them, applying them as valid guides.

Stoicism challenges us to first recognize that our beliefs are assumptions, often learned without effort and trusted, and then look them in the eye and demand they defend themselves with reason. Emotion is not a reliable defense in this context. Emotion validates our beliefs. Emotion is not bad, nor is it useless. It just has no place in this process. It is, like you say, what comes after.

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

Emotion is not a reliable defense in this context. Emotion validates our beliefs. Emotion is not bad, nor is it useless. It just has no place in this process.

There is no "divine" between emotion and reason - your emotions are your reason, they're simply how beliefs (which are things you've reasoned to be true) manifest in the conscious mind.

The quote by Epictetus on impressions is talking about this fact - I remind you of the quote:

To make the correct use of impressions. And what is reason if not a collection of individual impressions?

He's right - the things we reason become impressions, that is a pre-brain statement of "emotions are how things you've reasoned to be true (beliefs) manifest in the conscious mind".

If you hate your boss, it's because you've reasoned that he is not a good person, or treats you unfairly. That hatred is your reasoning process manifesting in the conscious mind. It's not a good or a bad guide, it's simply how the reasonable nature of your mind manifests. When you reason about that opinion, you're acting on another impulse just like hatred, another form of reason manifesting in the conscious mind.

1
Victorian_Bullfrog•

There is no "divine" between emotion and reason - your emotions are your reason, they're simply how beliefs (which are things you've reasoned to be true) manifest in the conscious mind.

Again, I agree. I think people often use emotion asqua evidence when determining if their beliefs are valid. My point was (well, I wanted it to be), this is not helpful.

1
TheophileEscargot•

Excellent explanation! Very useful.

1
Zenographer•

What do you think is the best way to explain or describe the emotional reactions of infants who aren't far enough along cognitively to have beliefs?

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

I believe you've already explained it fine - they're not old enough to have beliefs.

That said, if you need to model yourself as a baby who has not yet become cognizant in order to explain your behaviour, I'd suggest you've found yourself in a strange place.

1
Zenographer•

I meant: how would you explain where the emotions are coming from?

1
BenIsProbablyAngryOP•

Babies are born with a set of reflexes which are slowly replaced with higher thought as their prefrontal cortex develops. Many of these reflexes (including crying, sucking, breath-holding and even the moro reflex) return if a person gets dementia, when the reasoning part of the brain stops serving as the executive part.

1
Zenographer•

So if an infant appears to scream in anger or fear, would you say that's not actually anger or fear?

1