A question about Commanding Right and Forbidding Evil.

A number of times the Quran says to command what is right and forbid what is evil or wrong, But I have a question on what is "evil" in this context. Is the Arabic word used connected to the term haram? If not what type of things need to be forbidden? What is evil in an Islamic context or rather what does the term translated as evil refer to?

Posted Jul 8, 2012, 4:26 PM UTC

115
sunnychilly•

The arabic word "Maaroof" means what is "known" to be right in a given society. For example, a man who divorces his wife is asked to pay some amount to the wife according to the "Maaroof" (like an amount that can be considered reasonable in that society in that time) [2:241].

Opposite of Maaroof is Munkar. For example, giving a person his/her right is "Maaroof"; depriving him/her of it is "Munkar".

This is related to the expectation that a Muslim should always stand for justice no matter what. [5:8]

4
TheOneFreeEngineerOP•

Thank you. that is very helpful

3
sunnychilly•

you are very welcome.

3
shur711•

Anything that displeases Allah. And remember, it doesn't mean that you should go and grab a beer bottle from a drinkers hand and smash it. No. You just tell them its wrong. In the Qur'an it says:

"Then, if they turn away, your duty (O Muhammad SAW) is only to convey (the Message) in a clear way." 16:82

"And obey Allah and obey the messenger and be cautious; but if you turn back, then know that only a clear deliverance of the message is (incumbent) on Our messenger." 5:92

From this it can be seen that it wasn't the Prophets job to force people to do good and stop evil. No, he would just give them a clear message. As long as you tell the person and do your effort, you will have done "forbidding evil".

2
TheOneFreeEngineerOP•

but what is evil? Is it haram things or is there a different implication in the term translated as evil?

1
shur711•

Anything that goes against the teachings of Islam and displeases Allah. Thats just a rough definition I thought up right now. Just don't think into it too much. When the situation arises you will know if its bad or good.

1
TheOneFreeEngineerOP•

Yeah i probably would know if the situation arises but I was more wondering if forbidding evil part obliges me to vote to make something illegal that is haram for muslims but not christians or jews.

1
[deleted]•

Wasn't there a video posted about this 2 days ago?

2
Vogner•

haram gun? that one?

3
[deleted]•

The one with Nouman Ali Khan wherein he mentioned the example of a man doing wudu and you acting holier than thou. Twas' that one I believe.

2
TheOneFreeEngineerOP•

I didn't see that, I'm sorry if there was. This has been rattling around in my head for sometime

1
[deleted]•

It's totally fine. I'm off to do wudhu but I'll see if I can dig it up for you.

1
bloggersvilleusa•

Amr-bil-Maroof

full article at:

http://lasjan.page.tl/Amr_bil_Maroof.htm

excerpt:


At one level it is the responsibility of every member of the society. When we see a wrong we should correct it. A very famous hadith declares it as an issue of faith. "Whoever amongst you sees an evil should change it with his hand. If he is unable to do that then with his tongue. If he is unable to do that, then with his heart, and that is the weakest level of Iman." [Muslim] So if a person does not even feel bad about an evil, he has no faith whatsoever. Similarly we are encouraged to promote good. One hadith promises that a person who persuades another one to do some good deed will get the same reward as the person he persuaded. At this level the responsibility of every member of the society is for his or her own sphere of influence: family, friends, colleagues, neighbors. When taken together these spheres would encompass the entire society.

2
TheOneFreeEngineerOP•

But what is bad? Does that mean haram things? Or is it a seperate class of actions, like oppressing someone or abusing someone? In Islamic terminology what constitutes evil? Is it haram?

1
Drosophilas•

right= good; actions that spread benefit to the individual and the society wrong= evil; the absence of good; actions that harm one's self and the society..

1