A Memory Called Empire thoughts
I finished this a couple days ago and enjoyed it for the most part, but was not really blown away. I suppose I had my expectations high since it won a Hugo and saw credible reviewers call it genre-redefining, a masterpiece, mind-blowing, etc etc. but it didn't really live up to any of that for me.
I liked the main cast well enough, but the plot didn't really have me gripped. The stakes felt weak because I don't really know anything about Lsel or it's people, and I didn't feel much tension for Mahit since she walked away from every life threatening situation (multiple targeted assassination attempts) with no more than a bruise.
The political aspects are really were this book fell apart for me. I was sold on a complex look into imperialism and it's effects on a non-citizen who fell in love with it's culture but has a diplomatic duty to protect her home. This did not come across strongly to me. It's hard to explain without just summarizing the plot, but none of the political points hit since I don't know Lsel, I don't know the emperor, I don't the succession candidates very well, and I wasn't given much example of the Teixcalaanli empire being particularly terrible. The city AI has some algorithmic issue? the cops are emotionless, and the citizens think outsiders are "barbarians" (being called this is basically the extent of the oppression Mahit experiences as a Stationer). There's obviously class disparity in Teixcalaan (poor folks and insurectionists live in the projects), but the times when Mahit mentioned where she lived, it sounded even worse (small living quarters, not great food, most entertainment imported from teixcalaan, also it's a space station so there's no nature at all)
Anyway, all of that kind of made the annexation threat feel weak as the reader (especially because all the characters seem to love the emperor). To the ambassadors though, it was clearly very important, to the point where the previous ambassador offered the emperor actual immortality in exchange for leaving Lsel alone. Which, btw, requires super secret and sacred Lsel state technology and living hosts to implant memories into in order to steal their consciousness. WHAT?
Anyway, I'm trying not to ramble [failed] because I have a lot to say, but I wanted to get other people's opinions since this book is very well regarded. What were you all's thoughts? Am I missing something?
Posted Aug 10, 2022, 8:58 PM UTC