Eldritch Wards Clarification
For the effects of Eldritch Wards (Lich King), it's unclear whether this segment of the Gift
Normal attacks against you that involve bolts of eldritch power or other strictly magical manifestations fizzle uselessly against you if an odd number is rolled on the attack die, even if it would otherwise have hit your Armor Class or have automatically struck you. This defense does not include physical weapon attacks that have been augmented by magic, but it does include wholly emotional or mental normal attacks
would apply against divine Weapon Boosters such as Scythe Hand or Withering Hour. While the initial part of the Gift clearly specifies that it's only talking about low magic and Theurgy, it's less clear as to whether "other strictly magical manifestations" includes divine magic. Has anyone seen Kevin comment on this anywhere?
Posted Oct 14, 2022, 8:26 PM UTC
First no, I haven't talked to Kevin about it. But I have some thoughts that may help.
The sentence you didn't quote has an interesting part: 'used DIRECTLY against you'. That does imply that AoE and indirect magical attacks WOULD work against them! At least other ttrpg (like D&D) divide those types of attacks.
What is a 'normal attack'? I think here is a base attack from a npc or monster statblock meant. If they involve (direct) magic, there is a chance the attack fails (btw: Luck could heavily influence those dice rolls), even if the attack would auto-hit you have to roll a die, something the GM could do behind the screen.
So physical attacks that are augmented by magic are excluded. That includes most armed martial weapons (including magical weapons or artifacts) and even unarmed attacks, and nearly all form of physical projectiles (range weapons).
That part includes a bunch of powers, from divine Gifts to true strifes, and could destroy whole plot-lines, BUT thankfully it is also bound to the odd dice-roll.
Without the roll that Lesser Gift would be to much, however with it a GM can use it in their story... the only one PC that isn't victim of the mind control. On the other hand they can always say the Dice-Roll didn't save them from the attack...!
Thanks for your thoughts! Yeah, the technicalities of this Gift have been a big topic of discussion in my group. We've worked out the low magic/theurgy bit of it, but the "normal attack" bit is a new snag we're puzzling over. I think your logic makes sense, but I'm going to keep trying to track down quotes from Kevin for some more solid confirmation
And since I looked at it for another thread, look at Conflicting Gifts, p. 22, to have a simple rule to use in case you aren't sure about the outcome.