r/weightroom•
zerojrg

5/3/1 vs 5/3/1 for PL

My question is in regards to pure strength, is 5/3/1 for PL any worse or is it about the same? I have had success so far with the regular 5/3/1 but I am looking to change it up a bit and also have never been a fan of rep ranges above 6. Has anyone tried 531PL after standard 531 and noticed a decline in performance? Anyone other way around? Thanks ahead of time and sorry for any phone errors

TL;DR Is 5/3/1 for PL just as good as standard 531 in regards to just strength gains?

Sorry if this has been asked before, I searched but I'm on my phone and have not had luck.

Posted Aug 27, 2012, 1:41 PM UTC

1716
mrthedonPowerlifting - 1207 @ 204 Raw•

I think it's important to remember that in 5/3/1 for Powerlifting, Wendler recommends the 5/3/1 template for off-season training (i.e. no meet scheduled soon).

He suggests switching to 3/5/1 8 weeks out and when you're within 4 weeks of a meet he goes on to say that "You aren't really going to get too much stronger during this time, but you can become a hell of a lot weaker."

Based on that, I think the aim of the 3/5/1 variation is to preserve existing strength and prepare you to execute specific lift goals in competition, but not necessarily to add a ton to your total. However, I would be VERY surprised if anybody got even remotely weaker following the 3/5/1 template instead of the 5/3/1 template.

I guess I will find out for sure over the next couple of months, as I'm about to switch to 3/5/1 for meet prep myself.

6
[deleted]•

I realized this upon re-reading the book. One of the reasons I decided to switch. It did help me get used to the heavier loads for singles though, so I think it'd be good for meet prep. I recovered from it well too, more so than 5/3/1.

3
koolaidman123•

Many of you out there have a desire to get on the platform and simply want to get stronger. For most, the standard 5/3/1 program will work fine. Simple, slow progress over time is always the answer. But we all have egos and nothing indicates penis size better than displaying maximal strength on barbells. So if you're a dedicated lifter who wants to improve his rep PRs and one rep max strength, here's the simple program to follow: Week 1: 3 sets of 3 reps, work up to a heavy single (no more than 95% of predicted max) Week 2: 3 sets of 5 reps Week 3: 5/3/1, work up to a heavy single (no more than 95% of predicted max) Week 4: Deload

3/5/1 is used to improve 1RM's, not just preserving strength.

1
koolaidman123•

There's no rep ranges above 6 for 5/3/1 pl... It's essentially 5/3/1 with 2 weeks switched around + heavy singles, I don't know how you can get a performance decrease with that.

1
db_ggmm•

I don't see how performance decreases, either, but people will claim it left and right, usually with the suggestion they need to "do x twice a week or it starts to suffer."

2
zerojrgOPso brave•

That's what I assumed but I wanted to hear it from someone who has tried it. I very rarely see people talking about 531PL on here or r/fitness and I want to give it a try myself, just wanted some opinions on it

1
[deleted]•

Preface: I'm a novice, so take this as it is.

I did about 5 cycles of 5/3/1 and after did three cycles of the PL version. Starting today I'm starting Madcow, but anyways; I didn't see any decrease in strength at all, granted I only did three cycles. I did start feeling more comfortable handling bigger weights, which never happened in 5/3/1 really since you never go above 90% in that version.

I did however add a little bit of rep work to the second week, the fives week. Instead of just doing the three sets of five, I went for a rep PR on that last set, which was usually a 10 rep pr or similar. I also picked a lift to max out on in the 5/3/1 week so say if I picked the bench I would do the 5/3/1 sets and then did two or three singles working up to a new 1RM.

Whether this improved or hindered my progress in the long run I couldn't say since I only did three cycles, but at least in the short run it didn't hinder me I think. I say try it out and see what happens. How advanced you are would also be something that will greatly affect this I think. That's what I liked about 5/3/1 though, similar to Westside you can pretty much tailor it to your needs.

-3
t333b•

... but, you do go above 90% in the original 5/3/1, it just doesn't happen until a few weeks cycles in.

3
[deleted]•

You go above 90% of your training max, but if you programmed correctly you probably won't go above 90% of your real max.

At least I know I didn't when I did 5/3/1. I was consistently getting around 6 reps for the 1+ days.

1
t333b•

That's just not true at all. You start with 90% of your 1RM. By increasing weight every cycle, you approach 90% and greater of your actual max, eventually reach it, then reset shortly after when you fail to get the minimum number of reps on the AMAP set.

2
[deleted]•

I did 5/3/1 for 4 or 5 months and my reps never even approached the minimum number. So for me my actual 1RM moved up at the same rate as my training max. So I guess it really depends on your rate of progression.

2
[deleted]•

Several cycles in yes, you'd inevitably reach 90%+, but it'd take quite a few cycles I think; I guess it depends on the person. I know that for me five cycles in I was still getting 5+ reps on my 1+ reps, which isn't quite 90%+ I think. You are correct though, you'd eventually get there.

1
aa93•

Even in 5/3/1 PL you don't go above your training max (90% of 1RM for the first cycle,) even on the singles. Unless you mean going over 90% of training max? The point of the 5/3/1 program is that you don't need to push for a new max week after week to see gains.

1
[deleted]•

True. I should have written it differently. I went past 90% on 3/5/1 because my singles on the '1' week I took up to new 1RMs if I could. I did this because I like going for PRs, I know it may not have been the best idea for the long term though.

I still think though that it'd take a few cycles of 5/3/1 to get to the point where you're handling above 90% poundages. That'd mean not being able to do more than say, 3 reps on the 1+ weeks no?

I am aware I may be way off, thus why I mentioned I'm a novice. But at least for me my 1RM was progressing steadily throughout my 5/3/1 cycles(no singles, still getting 5+ reps on 1+ week), thus I wasn't handling weights that were actually above 90% of my true 1RM.

At least this is my understanding thus far.

1