Heherehman

Almost finished with Groundwork of the Metaphysics Of Morals and had some questions.

1. Why does Kant associate Reason with “Law-Giving” authority? Is there any argument in the book that I might’ve missed? Or is this presupposed the same as Freedom. And even so if u try to justify Reason, Wouldn’t it be through physical phenomena? Through inclinations of why reason justifiably has this authority ?

2. Secondly, Even if granted that Reason has this capacity of “Law-Giving” authority, and lets says I exercise my duty perfectly and perform an action “X” that aligns perfectly with Kantian deontology, Why is it that Kant insists that no principle may be derived through this maxim? If I

1. Almost finished with Groundwork of the Metaphysics Of Morals and had some questions.

Why does Kant associate Reason with “Law-Giving” authority? Is there any argument in the book that I might’ve missed? Or is this presupposed the same as Freedom. And even so if u try to justify Reason, Wouldn’t it be through physical phenomena? Through inclinations of why reason justifiably has this authority ?

2. Secondly, Even if granted that Reason has this capacity of “Law-Giving” authority, and lets says I exercise my duty perfectly and perform an action “X” that aligns perfectly with Kantian deontology, Why is that Kant insists that no principle may be derived through this maxim? If I will for my

Is it just me or has meaningful discussion online become increasingly rare? Most spaces seem polarized or superficial.

I’m experimenting with creating a small discussion group focused on thoughtful exchange across topics like philosophy, society, tech, and religion.

Curious if others would find value in something like this.

Amidst ongoing crises all over the world and the potentiality of a WW3 to be actualised , does everybody think we should just sit and wait or do we have some sort of obligation to act upon something, might that be motivated by religious reasons or ethical obligations? I also feel like We should create a platform, whereupon we can actively discuss topics like these and everybody should be allowed to give an opinion such as in a discussion congregation.What do u think?

We plan to create a platform aimed towards mutual productive discussions on various topics might they be on-going social issues, geo-political issues, technological advancements and religious dogma. The platform will be moderat

Please excuse my lack of clarity and structure since I have no formal background. I’ll define true knowledge as “absolute truth”. If a person has such knowledge of any subject and not just of moral predicates, does it necessarily imply some sort of ethical obligation? Even if it does imply how or why one ought to do X , does it also necessarily imply preaching of X to other people? or are they not mutually exclusive to one another? Also in the case of prophetic preaching (just an example), theres a sort of divine responsibility upon prophets to preach and this assumes omni-benevolence of the God to begin with but what if theres no omni-benevolence or ultimate goodness to begin with? What if

Im not sure if this is the right place to ask this question but is there sufficient evidence in Quran as a primary source to conclude Allah as an All-loving being? The closest to that seems to me Al-Wadud (The Most-Loving) and I think I don’t have to elaborate on the difference between “Most” and “All”. It’s not a problem of semantics rather a complete difference in category. Although in christian theology God is represented as an All-loving being. And so, this makes me think that the problem of hell as a concept and problem of evil (especially problem of hell) isn’t really as big of a problem for Islamic theology as much as it is for christian theology. (I could elaborate on why that migh

The theme of the entire argument is centralised around the following question

Can morality retain its weight or significance under conditions of metaphysical certainty and divine favoritism? And so Can someone who is divinely guided assured of salvation and certain of infinite reward and punishment be meaningfully called morally heroic in enduring worldly suffering?

If someone: • Has absolute certainty in God’s existence, • Knows they are divinely favored and guided, • Has guaranteed salvation and the promise of eternal bliss in Paradise, • And fully understands that rejecting God leads to eternal Hell,

Then,it follows that any amount of suffering in this life becomes objectively

1. If someone: • Has absolute certainty in God’s existence, • Knows they are divinely favored and guided, • Has guaranteed salvation and the promise of eternal bliss in Paradise • And fully understands that rejecting God leads to eternal Hell

Then,it follows that any amount of suffering in this life becomes objectively trivial in comparison. Even the worst worldly pain,torture,exile,loss would be negligible if you are certain its followed by eternal pleasure and protection from eternal punishment. And So, Can a person in that position truly be considered “morally heroic” in enduring worldly suffering?

If they already know the outcome is infinite bliss and they know it with divine cert

I am looking for a bookstore/any source or pdfs etc where major philosophical books are present in urdu language.

I am looking for a bookstore/any source or pdfs etc where major philosophical books are present in urdu language.

So basically I have two accounts that use the same gmail or phone number. And as far as I know,If somebody chooses to block me on one account the other will Be automatically blocked as well. But Somebody has blocked me on one of my accounts but shows up on the other and when i share their profile to the other account it says “post unavailable,cannot find user” So like can they actually choose to just block one account? Also,Theres one other account of mine which has a separate email and number but somehow it has been blocked as well???? (The other person doesn’t know this account even exists) So could there possibly be something that I might not know of?

Age : 16 Gender : Male No past experiences of any issues with my hearing or ear whatsoever.

I had been experiencing weird shut downs of my right ear. Its like whenever I lay on my right ear,It would get blocked for a few seconds then make a popping sound and get back to work again. However after last night,The same thing happened but the ear isn’t popping now. You can barely hear from the right ear and it feels as if its been clogged or smth. It’s not painful but really uncomfortable.