I work at gamestop and I got to try out the circle pad pro on my 3DS because I have it preordered anyway. Wish I had gotten to try it out with the Resident Evil Revelations, but I didn't get a chance to.
So overall, I think this thing is pretty awesome. The 3DS slides in to it really nicely, and it adds a good amount of grip to the system for those with larger hands.
Edit: All the buttons are accessible, with the exception of the R button (but the new one feels great.) ZR and ZL feel pretty awesome. The Game Card Slot, SD Card Slot, Wireless Switch, and stylus holder are all inaccessible.
(Thanks to Blackfractals for catching my slip up here.)
Also it comes with a AAA, so you won