Hello friends! For whatever reason, be it eye shape (hooded) and/or eyelid skin (oily I GUESS???) no eye makeup has ever stayed on my lids except when it has been done professionally for weddings, and not even "still perfect", just still on and looks good.
I have tried: Urban Decay, Milani, NYX (the ones in the pots). I have applied and then waited at least a full minute and yet at the end of the day (or even only 6 hours later), my eye makeup has completely melted away or has smudged into a mess on my lids. Even liquid or felt tip marker style eyeliner doesn't last on my primed lids, and I've tried putting a nude shadow down after priming.
I use a mix of makeup, from Urban Decay, NYX, Cia