Explain to me the difference in bitcoin and litecoin.
They seem the same to me other then litecons transfer in 2.5 minutes which is friendlier to business and litecoin has 80 million total units.
I see the 2.5 minute transfer beneficial. Why does bitcoin take longer? Does it make it more secure or is it for better bandwidth reason.
Posted Apr 15, 2013, 10:31 PM UTC
Advantages? None. It's a shitty coat-tail chasing alt chain for butthurt GPU miners and people hoping to be an early adopter since they "missed the train" on bitcoin. The reasons:
1: Active development: Bitcoin has a full time paid developer and dozens of contributors. Litecoin has one part time developer.
2: Worse double spend protection. Yes you read that right. Protection from a double spend is a function of the hash power of the network. These are expressed in blocks, but blocks are only a unit of accounting and the actual security comes from the speed of the network. It takes 4 litecoin blocks to be as secure as one bitcoin block, IF AND ONLY IF the networks have the same hashing power. Since scrypt is intentionally designed to be hard to use on anything but a cpu (and then we cludged it into GPUs anyway) it intentionally limits the hash power of the litecoin network, lowering security. "faster confirmations" is pure placebo. If you're dealing with small amounts or dealing with someone in person, accepting a zero confirmation transaction is secure enough in both coins.
3: Fees. Litecoin has a very dumb fee structure of .1ltc per some amount of kbytes. At this point in time, some litecoin transfers are already prohibitively expensive. It is not "silver to gold" because it shares the exact same characteristics, except being worse at some.
This isn't true at all.
The number of hashes per second is quite irrelevant, as is whether the hash is computable on GPUs or just CPUs, what matters is the total amount of CPU/hardware time going into securing the network as that's what determines how much a 51% attack would cost to perform.
If there was a cryptoalgorithm that took an entire second to generate a single hash on a modern day processor for which GPUs/ASICs are completely unsuitable it would still make a perfectly suitable hash algorithm to run a *coin off.
EDIT: Except I suppose that requiring specialist hardware (ASICS) makes the network more secure against attacks by hired botnets/general purpose supercomputers, although it does not help against an adversary willing to buy hardware.
You are correct. My point is entirely about your "except" bit.
Once the network is filled out with miners running specialist hardware, it should require the attacker it throw huge amounts of money into hardware to fuel their attacks. With any transfer of large enough size special precautions can be taken against double spending.
I respectively disagree with some of your reasoning of point 2. As far as I can tell, there is no reason that Bitcoin decided on an average of 10 mins / block. Perhaps this is just a factor in the blocks * time * size = blockchain expansion rate and that Satoshi arrived at 10 due to this seeming to be a reasonable time that statistically means at higher difficulties then a block will turn up sooner or later and at lower difficulties they won't be churned out too much - but this may be too long for some merchants in the cryptocoin space to wait.
I would propose that although 4 litecoin blocks are equivalent to 1 bitcoin block ( if the machines hashing on each network were to remain invariant until the end of time) but 1-3 litecoin block(s) are better than 0 bitcoin blocks, as the network can then focus on building upon that confirmation.
Now points 1 and 3 are definitely true. I can't figure out that whole fee thing that's for sure.
There is one definite advantage in having ltc and btc around and that's arbitrage. I can imagine when mtgox open up to ltc there will be an arms race in getting the fastest exchange connections. Arbitrage is not necessarily a bad thing - it helps provide liquidity to the not-so-big exchanges and as I'm sure we all agree - that is a good thing in view of recent "magic" issues.
Reasoning behind 10 minutes: Yes, it's a happy medium. There is only a tiny overhead per block, so that isn't the main reason. The main reason is that when mining, you must work from the current valid block in order to produce a valid block yourself. Decreasing the time between blocks means that there is an increase of invalid blocks, and an overall increase in wasted miner time.
1-3 confirmation security: The network security is better off with a slower confirmation time as per above. For merchants accepting *coin, I must explain a bit more about bitcoin. Bitcoin nodes (not miners) only retransmit valid transactions according to their own rules. This means that a 0 confirmation payment, but one that has been relayed to you, means that it has passed basic sanity checking by the network. (that it's a valid private key, that it does access that much btc, etc) The reason behind waiting for multiple confirmations is the race attack, which is exceedingly difficult to pull off and completely not worth it if you are handling small amounts of money or you are physically present at say a restaurant.
Therefore, in situations where you accept less than 6/24 confirmations, you are just about as well off accepting 0 confirmations, as long as you don't connect directly to the potentially hostile user.
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Double-spending
Arbitrage is a great thing, and is needed for the one price rule to happen. I don't really see how litecoin factors into it though.
This is not true at all. 3 litecoin block confirmations is MUCH more solid than an unconfirmed bitcoin transaction, since you need very significant hashing power to redo 3 litecoin blocks while you can potentially double spend an unconfirmed bitcoin transaction with some luck and no hashing power.
0-2.5 minutes: equal security.
2.5-10 minutes: Slightly higher litecoin security
10 minutes+: Higher bitcoin security.
All situations where you accept 10 minutes of mining time: Low risk transactions.
Don't forget botnets. ASIC will make bitcoin secure from botnets trying to take control of the network or mining large sums, litecoin however seems to be designed so that botnets can take control of the network.
No, model you're using is too simplistic.