DuckedUpOnQuack•

I'd say shit went downhill fast after one of the mods called a questioning user a "debbie downer" for not being okay with what happened.

44
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

more like debbie downvote

16
mach-2ARISE CHIKUN!!•

debeatdownvote.

6
[deleted]•

I called u/flyinggogoplata a debbie downer because he pops up in lots of threads that the mods make an makes snide comments.

If he had stated a case against what had been done, other than just saying "what a joke", then he would've been met with respect and discourse.

Debbie downvote is right though. Fortunately that sort of thing only matters to those who occupy their time watching internet drama unfold.

-66
Jrex13cloud butt butt cloud cloud butt•

Well it's easy to feel above the drama when you get to do all the cool stuff because you're a mod :P

25
[deleted]•

Right? I just wish I actually got some of that cool stuff though haha.

-46
[deleted]•

[deleted]

46
mattyisphttyLet's take this full circle...jerk•

Those who occupy their time watching internet drama unfold

Doesn't take long to watch internet drama and it comes in pretty much infinite quantities. Coming over here and trying to get any form of sympathy is like going to an ice cream shop and protesting because your lactose-intolerant.

Next time you do a contest try this, take anyone who could have influenced in ANY way the contest, and make sure they do not enter. Any large scale contest is run this exact same way. A contest for concert tickets? No one who works in the office is allowed to enter, no one who works for the company at all is allowed to enter, and usually no one in the parent company (most radio stations are owned by a parent) are allowed to enter. That is how you make things truly transparent.

If you think the mods deserved an entry for their hard work, please remember you signed up for the volunteer position. Your hard work has perks over the other members of the community already.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

38
redpingShortus Eucalyptus•

does Cupcake really have control over who wins reddit raffles etc?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

29
redpingShortus Eucalyptus•

Maybe Camozzi is in on it! We don't know how deep the rabbit hole goes, and he's coming off some losses iirc

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
JogindahThe spiffiest of ties•

poutinethrowaway you are the gravy on my fries and the cheese curds in my whey

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Silent_Hastati•

So if r/MMA posts this thread to their subreddit like they did they first one, and we post about THAT thread, and so on and so forth, will it ever end?

Congratulations r/SubredditDrama, we did it. We finally invented the Perpetual Popcorn Machine. Round of applause everyone.

36
Not_A_Doctor__•

It seems more like announcing a controlled detonation. Sometimes you just know the drama is gonna happen.

8
Jrex13cloud butt butt cloud cloud butt•

I guess I shouldn't be surprised that people who don't understand conflict of interest wouldn't understand that defending their shady choice just makes them look even shadier.

This is glorious.

19
wwyzzerdd•

This is pretty much how an SRD contest would turn out.

12
june_oyster•

And for the grand prize - 25 tickets to the u/David-me dunk tank - the winnah is...

13
seedypeteis a golem made of popcorn and SRS•

.../u/david-me? God damn it, how is that going to work? I suppose we shouldn't have put the dunkee's name in there.

10
wwyzzerdd•

I bet he could manage to dunk himself.

6
Erra0Here's the thing...•

And he'd be the first to post about the ensuing drama.

9
mattyisphttyLet's take this full circle...jerk•

I'd rather see a contest to see who gets to throw the ball at the dunk tank. Everyones invited, except mods, however strangely enough u/david-me has the ability to put his own name into the running... Hrm

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
VodkaBarfAbout ethics in binge drinking•

I'll throw in a bucket of my specialty as well!

3
jfa1985who?•

I see this drama continuing to grow.

11
wwyzzerdd•

I see this drama continuing to grow going the distance.

I see this drama continuing to grow round 2.

10
mattyisphttyLet's take this full circle...jerk•

I believe the judges scored the last round

8.5 Mods

9.1 Users

Lets see if the mods can start making a comeback in round 2

4
Erra0Here's the thing...•

We're gonna need a recap in a day or two, I'll wager.

8
Jrex13cloud butt butt cloud cloud butt•

can you imagine if the drama gets so big that EA decides they don't want part of that community at their shindig anymore?

It would be a dramapocalypse!

7
mattyisphttyLet's take this full circle...jerk•

Oh they certainly see the drama, and will either

A) Never host a contest with them again

B) Run the contest under very strict rules and not allow the mods to deviate in any way.

2
redpingShortus Eucalyptus•

It seems like a decent prospect at the moment but I don't see it breaking the top ten

1
AltonBrownsBallsPopcorn is definitely...•

Even the impression of a conflict of interest can damage the company subreddit.

Sorry, just had to re-up my ethics training.

11
mabelleamie•

he's a mod

on the internet

on a content aggregating website

he does it for free MMA tickets

he takes his "job" very seriously

8
skeenerbug•

The head mod of r/mma, u/random_sTp posted in this thread but got buried with downvotes:

I am the head mod over at r/MMA[1] and will happily answer any questions users have, all I ask is you go and read the original thread before judging based on this thread or any comments... www.reddit.com/r/MMA/comments/25f3qv/official_ea_sports_ufc_ticket_giveaway/[2] Also bear in mind that the user that created this thread has been banned multiple times from r/MMA[3] for doxxing users and mods, sending abusive threats and emailing people's mothers and being abusive.

5
FlyingGogoplata•

Quick recap:

New 'Official' thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/MMA/comments/25pbmb/official_ea_drama/

u/J-Hall resigned as mod (after users repeatedly ask him to) and u/random_stp continues to defend him and their choices, says he 'assumes' it's too late to reset the EA prize and do it again.

Meanwhile, the mod winner, u/ialsolovebees posts thread about where to get the best food in vegas while his own subreddit burns: http://www.reddit.com/r/vegas/comments/25ip21/best_vegas_only_food_on_a_budget/

4
ialsolovebees•

I actually posted that well before this shit storm started, but who's counting facts at this point any more?

Also, I'd like to point out that the person who posted the 2 most recent r/mma SRD stories is in fact the same man who threatens r/mma users on a regular basis, and he has since been banned by the admins.

EDIT: Also, literally nothing I could have said would have made this any better, as this mob had already decided that we somehow rigged the contest or were paid off. I honestly find it funny how few complaints and many positive ones there were before u/gato22 (aka u/Speakercity, aka u/Speakercity310, aka u/twooneandlewis, aka u/SparkyMcLongie, aka u/handyfrank, etc) decided to "whistleblow" the whole situation.

-2†
FlyingGogoplata•

All I know is if this happened to me I'd recuse myself. It's the right thing to do.

Literally hundreds of users have voiced their concern. Stop blaming this on one person.

1
larsonol•

A link to r/mma that links to r/subredditdrama that links to r/mma

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
FuturePigeon#AdnanIsGuilty•

Drama centipede!

4
ttumblrbots•

SnapShots: 1, 2, 3 ^[?]

^^Anyone ^^know ^^an ^^alternative ^^to ^^Readability? ^^Send ^^me ^^a ^^PM!

2
Vakieh•

Sooo..... if I comment in the SRD thread reached from an SRD thread via an MMA thread, am I popcorn pissing?

Perhaps I am instead pissing in the corn fields the popcorn comes from.

Quick SRDD make a thread about this, I want the meta so deep you could make a huge vagina joke about it.

1
mattyisphttyLet's take this full circle...jerk•

Been there, done that. Not too long ago with had some u/david-me drama that was absolutely glorious with the whole batch of meta subs getting involved and crosslinking to one another. At a certain point its kind of like pissing into the wind, you know eventually it will land on some popcorn, but it just feels so darn good.

1
random_sTp•

I am the head mod over at r/MMA and will happily answer any questions users have, all I ask is you go and read the original thread before judging based on this thread or any comments...

www.reddit.com/r/MMA/comments/25f3qv/official_ea_sports_ufc_ticket_giveaway/

Also bear in mind that the user that created this thread has been banned multiple times from r/MMA for doxxing users and mods, sending abusive threats and emailing people's mothers and being abusive.

-35
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

The fairest route we could come up with was to pick a group of people who consistently contribute to the community, and that we thought would be good representatives for r/MMA[1] . We started with a list of 12 names, and ended up with only 6 who were eligible to go.

  • You only picked 12 people from your subreddit. Do you only have 12 decent contributors?

  • Including a mod in this raffle is, like people in that thread said, like letting a lottery employee win the lottery. Very suspect. Also kind of stupid-here, let's give back to the community by sending one of the mods on this awesome trip.

  • Did none of you seriously see questions about this in the future? Or did you just decide you didn't care.

edit:

  • Why did you conduct this poll in secrecy, instead of openly asking people to submit names of quality contributors?

  • Chris Camozzi's video picking the winner was posted May 12. You said in your post announcing the mod as the winner that "This came in less than a week ago". I'll go ahead and assume you meant 3-4 days, or half a week. You had from around May 10th, which is a full two weeks before the event, and you didn't have time to pick more than 12 (11 non-mod) names for the contest?

  • Why not have the community vote on who got to go?

  • u/IkeepsItReal has 6 comments in r/MMA in the last 6 months. Why was a user who averages one comment per month considered enough of a quality contributor to be entered? What defines a quality contributor? You said you chose users who "consistently contribute to the community". Is one comment a month considered consistent contribution? Does one comment a month make a user one of the sub's best 12 contributors? If I comment three whole times a month will you make me head mod?

53
GussyH•

It's also important to note that only six users were entered into the raffle, including the one mod.

It'd be great if reddit had a system to decide who was a frequent contributor, instead of mods subjectively choosing based how they feel about users emotionally (and their mod status.) Something like a point-based karma system that's determined by how much the community appreciates their contributions.

21
Jrex13cloud butt butt cloud cloud butt•

Even if they had such a crazy system there would have to be some way of telling how much karma came from the different subs.

We would never be able to figure that out.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
geoffrey_fitz•

You can do this with a pretty straightforward python script and reddit's python module praw.

You can get karma for each user in a single sub and total it or divide by the number of posts to get average karma for example. No mod access required.

1
devperez•

They already show us this information. If you look on your user page, it lists your karma per sub.

0
[deleted]•

Yeah, with so many subscribers, you'd think they would let everyone who wanted enter or at least come up with a contest. Just choosing twelve people seems kind of shitty

9
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

In case you missed my edit, one of the users who was chosen but couldn't make it has made 6 comments on that sub in the last 6 months.

So in other words, when the r/mma mods think "ok, who are our top 12 contributors?" they jump to the guy who schedules his posts by the full moon.

21
Jrex13cloud butt butt cloud cloud butt•

That last bullet.

Half of the users they chose were ineligible, it might not be completely crazy to guess that they would choose inactive users hoping they wouldn't be interested in going to this thing.

9
typesoshee•

Chris Camozzi's video picking the winner was posted May 12. You said in your post announcing the mod as the winner that "This came in less than a week ago". I'll go ahead and assume you meant 3-4 days, or half a week. You had from around May 10th, which is a full two weeks before the event, and you didn't have time to pick more than 12 (11 non-mod) names for the contest?

IMO, 24 hours is enough for a popular post (not even a mod-authored sticky post) to be decently developed on the frontpage of a subreddit. In the post, say everything you need to say, like "36 hours after this post is posted, we will begin PMing the 1st place finisher whether he can e-mail us certain evidence needed to see if he can attend this event (whatever was needed, idk). If we do not receive a response from him with X minutes, we will begin PMing the next place finisher" or whatever you want to figure out. As long as you have a system and you mention your procedure along with the post, people will have enough time to figure it out. Honestly, 48 hours is all you need to do this and decide on a proper "winner" (as long as enough mods are free to be responsible for it during that time).

3
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

They had a week, if you believe that EA set a deadline on choosing the winner, which is way more than enough time.

0
random_sTp•

Please go and read the original thread, we got an email a week before the close date, we only had limited time and didn't want to lose the prize by being unorganised.

If you speak to the members at r/MMA our policy is normally to get user input on all decisions, we have a filter system on r/MMA go over there and filter by [Official] and you will see us asking the community for input and votes for pretty much every major decision.

We had very limited time so we choose the most efficient method.

Edit to answer edit - EA gave us a timeline to get a winner IIRC it was the 15th. IKeepsITReal designed our original logo for our charity Tshirt and subreddit and has helped with other designs.

-26
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

we got an email a week before the close date

The close date? What date was that? You said you got the email half a week before your "winner" thread-does this mean you chose the usermod in half the time you were limited to?

Can you answer any of my other questions?

We had very limited time so we choose the most efficient method.

It would have been more efficient to just announce that one of the mods was going to vegas.

22
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

EA gave us a timeline to get a winner IIRC it was the 15th.

So again, you had the winner picked out 3 days before your deadline.

Remind me again how you didn't have time to conduct this more openly?

IKeepsITReal designed our original logo for our charity Tshirt and subreddit and has helped with other designs.

So the guy who does your CSS and designed a t-shirt is one of your top 12 contributors? More important to the community than 76, 362 other users who subscribe there?

15
random_sTp•

I'm not going to argue the individual merits of the people we selected but that users is a really good guy and helped us out in the past and recently, none of our regular users had an issue with our selections and were very supportive.

The winner was picked on the 14th a day before the deadline.

-26
redpingShortus Eucalyptus•

the fact that you can't answer all of his questions is pretty telling man, glad I don't post on r/mma anymore

6
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

Will you be coming back to answer the rest of my questions?

5
kikuchiyoali•

Are you going to reply to all of u/waazd's questions?

2
Erra0Here's the thing...•

How could you not see this coming? I get that you wanted to reward contributors but even assuming that everything went down exactly as you said it did, allowing a mod to be eligible is just plain stupid. I'd be mad as hell if I was an r/MMA user. Hell, a better way would've been to let the community vote, once for themselves and once for someone else and don't count votes unless they do vote for someone else. Could've been done with a single thread and if it happened to be a mod that was picked by the community, then that's that. Otherwise it goes to the person the community feels is most deserving.

If I were you and I wanted to keep any credibility for myself and my sub, I would do a redraw using the above rules.

15
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

Mods should be ineligible for anything like this, in any decent-run sub. For example, I'm pretty sure the r/hiphopheads mods aren't allowed to win those giveaways they do.

17
Erra0Here's the thing...•

Absolutely. Like I said, the only exception would be if the community wanted a mod to go or felt like a mod was the most deserving.

inb4 r/MMARebooted

7
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

Lol, the community's feelings on who was most deserving don't matter. To quote u/random_sTp:

They asked for someone to represent our community, IMO one of the mods is the best representative.

8
waazdIt's a popcorn MELT, not a grilled cheese with popcorn.•

Also

inb4 r/MMARebooted

Socrates got KO'd for this shit.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Cuddle_ApocalypseTinker, Tailor, Soldier, Shill•

Oh man, I love when mods caught up in some blatantly obvious mod abuse come here to defend themselves.

http://i.imgur.com/GkmRr.gif

14
ky1e•

I don't see how it wouldn't be obvious that having a mod win some secret backdoor poll would lead to an angry community.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
ky1e•

The course of reasoning they took is just silly.

Oh, you want to give these awesome trips away to our community?

But we don't have much time...

Let's just arbitrarily pick 12 submitters, one of them a mod,

then ask if they can actually go,

and then announce this awesome thing to the community

after we've already picked the winners.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
gato22OP•

Happy Cakeday :)

9
Erra0Here's the thing...•

I love everything about this. Tastiest popcorn in awhile. Thanks OP.

10
random_sTp•

Thanks :)

-8
seedypeteis a golem made of popcorn and SRS•

Honestly I think just choosing which users (and such a small number of them) to put in the hat was a bigger mistake than letting a mod compete. Obviously they were both mistakes, but the first one actually made the second more of an issue than it probably would have been. Generally speaking lottery employees don't get to play the lottery with good reason but I doubt the users would have cared much if every subscriber had a chance and a mod was somewhere in the pile with them.

But man, mods selecting the list of who gets to compete and picking a very small number and putting one of their own names in there AND doing the actual drawing to choose the winner is such a perfect recipe for an angry mob I'm kind of amazed that you guys were caught off guard by the reaction.

Mr. Burns just won the free car and heeeeere come the pretzels!

6
kikuchiyoali•

Are you going to respond to u/waazd's reply? You came back to SRD, the least you could do is answer his very valid points.

3
random_sTp•

I'm trying to do this via my phone while working, what points were they?

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1