r/ukpolitics•
TLS96

European Elections: Who are you voting for and why?

Posted May 22, 2014, 9:28 AM UTC

7115
Soilbleed•

It borders on Labour and Green for me. Guess I'll spend work time trying to decide.

17
clodiusmetellus•

I was the same and didn't actually make up my mind until I got into the booth.

I chose Green in the end, for the record.

12
salamanderwolf•

greens. As much as people hate them on here for no reason, they still have great policies if your sick of how things are run at the moment.

14

UKIP because I want to increase the leftist butthurt in this country.

7†
[deleted]•

Well aren't you a prat.

13
RightStopThatSilly•

It's not particularly nice, but it is at least the only logically sound reason I have heard thus far for a Ukip vote.

3
[deleted]•

To be honest I think there's a fair chunk of people voting UKIP just for the change. We've all seen the...well...fuckup (to put it bluntly) that the three major parties have made over and over and over again. We may as well let someone else fuck the country up for once :)

It's just a shame we dont have a Vermin Supreme type party, as they'd likely be in with a chance of winning.

1
cbfw86Swinger. -3.88, -3.33.•

petty nationalism is cool ok

-2†
SweatyBadgersElectoral reform now!•

UKIP because I want out of the EU.

6†
TLS96OPLiberal Democrat•

Why?

1†
An_Eloquent_Turtle#savesabir•

Watch any farage speech

2†
cthomp88•

Funny. I come out of watching Nigel Farage speak ever more convinced we have to stay in the EU.

14
An_Eloquent_Turtle#savesabir•

You're a wanker

-8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hungoverseal•

UKIP can't take you out of the E.U fucknuts. Only a conservative vote at the G.E will get you a referendum

-6
cbfw86Swinger. -3.88, -3.33.•

Green EU. Lib Dem Local.

I'm actually quite excited to vote Green. I haven't voted for them yet.

I might give the game away at the polling station and ask the little old ladies if the paper is recycled.

6
SmilePeregrine•

Greens. Posted that to facebook and got

and vote anti-nuclear!

as a reply - a friend coming to my defence summed up why I voted pretty well:

And anti-factory farming! And pro-sustainable fishing! And anti-misuse of antibiotics! And anti-deforestation! And pro-biodiversity! And pro-affordable housing! And pro-NHS and illness prevention! And pro-peace! And pro-quality British-made products (anti-disposable crap)! And pro-workplace democracy! And anti-inequality! Pro-local investment! Pro-local governance and voting reform! Pro-universal human rights! ...

There's so much more to the Green party than anti-nuclear...

And their policies are democratically decided (unlike most other parties) so if you care about all those things (unlike most other parties) but are pro-nuclear, why not join up and have your say?

6
horhito•

Dam it! Had I heard this argument a week ago I might have voted Green.

1
windy906-5.0,-6.3•

Don't, I used to be involved at a local level, some very clever people but most are clueless, childish idiots.

0
SmilePeregrine•

Welcome to all of the world's people. You can't expect the Green's to hoard the tip of the bell curve more than any other party! :)

Out of interest, are you involved in other groups now?

2
windy906-5.0,-6.3•

The problem was it was an inverse bell curve with very few people in the middle. No, not involved any more.

1
Blaster395•

You may as well say the greens are pro-good. Unless you can demonstrate that the greens have policies that will bring about all those things without causing severe damage in other areas, it's meaningless. No party is pro-deforestation and anti-investment in rhetoric.

The policies unique to the greens are few in number, and among those few are anti-nuclear, anti-ITER, anti-GMO and anti-animal drug testing.

Being Anti-GMO will cause more deforestation due to extra cropland required to grow shitty crops. Therefore, the policies are both pro-deforestation and anti-biodiversity in practice.

Being Anti-Animal testing will make it completely impossible for any drug to be developed in the UK, as animal testing needs to be a precursor to testing on humans. Therefore, in practice, they are pro-illness, anti-british made products, and anti-local investment.

Being Anti-nuclear will leave fossil fuels as the only available option to carry the base load of the national grid. It is impossible for solar and wind to ever do such a thing due to variable uncontrollable output. Therefore, the green party in practice is pro-pollution.

Being anti-ITER will slow the development of fusion power. Therefore, they are once again pro-pollution.

1
SoyBeanExplosionPragmatic Libertarian Socialist•

Unless you can demonstrate that the greens have policies that will bring about all those things without causing severe damage in other areas, it's meaningless.

So, there's this thing parties like the Greens have called a 'manifesto', and speaking in broad terms if you read it you might get some kind of idea of the sorts of policies they might implement if they were elected

2
Blaster395•

I have read their manifesto already, it makes a ton of broad claims with no explanation of how they will do it.

0
SmilePeregrine•

You've taken what they are for or against without taking their solutions for it and assumed the worst case - I could do the same with any party policy. e.g., conservatives & free schools, they are against a national curriculum, therefore all schools will teach creationism and jihad. Clearly not.

That the amount of 'unique' policies being few in number is simply false. Within drug use, factory farming & agriculture, planning, workers rights, governance... etc.. Basically they have a well developed, wide ranging, democratically decided manifesto, which you clearly haven't read. If you had you'd know your comment is simply wrong:

anti-gmo: instead of proposing we replace GMOs with 'shitty crops', how about their actual policy of promoting organic and permaculture which is more productive per area (but does require more human input) than traditional crops, and also has carbon, biodiversity, local job benefits. And doesn't require huge investments, monopolies on seeds, consolidation of land, and promotion of inequality.

Anti-animal testing: a) they aren't anti animal testing wholesale, only that which is harmful (so all those in the category of 'mild' would be fine - which is the largest category) so the effect would be limited. b) with better technology we can test on human tissue grown specifically for that purpose, c) they suggest lots of other ways we can research. d) within their animal rights section they also have a ton of policies that other parties don't cover - you've cherry picked the one you think will rile people.

anti-nuclear: again, you've assumed their solution is just jam a few solar panels up. They have a huge focus on energy reduction via insulation, education, more efficient buildings & appliances, etc. They also suggest the use of sustainable biomass, biogas, and CHP fueled by waste. They also acknowledge the need for (much reduced) fossil fuels in the mix such as LPG. They also have support for Europe wide projects that will help balance demand & provide base-load. So again, you've not read the policy & assumed the worst.

ITER: their argument is that in the short to medium term it doesn't look like it'll provide us with the amount of low carbon energy we need. They'd use the money to research other areas. So again, no, they clearly aren't pro-pollution, they would research other, more sure-fire beneficial methods of sorting out the problem.

1
LocutusOfBorgesLiberal Democrat | /r/LibDem•

Lib Dem.

The incumbent at the top of the party list in Yorkshire's outstanding. His being replaced by another kipper mouthbreather frothing at the mouth about PC gone mad would be a tragedy.

5†
nifara•

I've already voted, but it was for Labour on both counts. My local councillor is the incumbent,and excellent, and though I disagree with a small number of major Labour policies in the EU, I disagree with them less than any other party.

5
grogipherBu Chòir!•

I voted SNP. Mostly cause I'm a party member and feel as though they reflect my opinions mostly, but also because the last seat in Scotland, the one that will be vacated by the liberal democrats, is a two horse race between the SNP and UKIP.

4†
AidanSmeaton•

It's actually a four-horse race between SNP, Labour, UKIP and the Greens.

A Green/UKIP vote will be worth 3 times as much as an SNP/Labour vote (assuming they have 2 seats each), so I'll be voting Green instead of SNP.

http://www.betternation.org/2014/05/final-yougov-poll-for-scotland-is-utterly-clear/

5
pennyroyaltee•

Thanks for that, I was unsure whether to use my vote for Greens or SNP. I think that's convinced me that a Green vote would be more effective.

3
grogipherBu Chòir!•

Labour have no chance of getting three seats though?

2
AidanSmeaton•

You're probably right, but some polls have put them ahead of the SNP so I thought I would include them. The Greens definitely have a chance at the sixth seat though.

5
grogipherBu Chòir!•

Aye, I'll concede the Greens are in with a shout of the sixth seat, but if I were putting money on it, I'd put a bet on UKIP or SNP. I've not seen any polls that have put Labour ahead in Scotland?

3
ShetlandJames-1.25, -6.05: Andrew Ryan•

Green (EU), Lib Dem/Green (local 3 member ward, 2+1)

Lifelong Lib Dem. Not voting because I'm disenchanted with the Lib Dems or whatever the media wants to make it out to be. Greens simply better reflect my political make up. I voted Lib Dem at council level because Lib Dems tend to do some of their best work at council level.

3†
grogipherBu Chòir!•

(local 3 member ward, 2+1)

What does that mean, please?

1
ShetlandJames-1.25, -6.05: Andrew Ryan•

3 people elected and I X'd two Lib Dems and 1 Green

1
grogipherBu Chòir!•

What electoral system is that? "/

1
ShetlandJames-1.25, -6.05: Andrew Ryan•

First past the post. You don't rank them, you just X them. Top 3 win.

3
TLS96OPLiberal Democrat•

What do you think is wrong with the lib dems?

-3†
ShetlandJames-1.25, -6.05: Andrew Ryan•

I just feel like the Greens are looking ahead a bit more. They seem to be the party that is more 'up to date' on issues I care about like climate change, voting reform and drug legalisation.

6
AidanSmeaton•

I think that's true - I'm voting Green as well. The funny thing is the Greens had these policies decades ago when people didn't care about these issues. They were simply ahead of the times.

If they can amend their outdated policies on GM foods, nuclear power, and stem cell research, I can forsee them doing very well in the next 10 to 20 years. With proportional voting in Scotland, they could easily outnumber Conservative and Lib Dem MSPs in the 2016 General Election - which would make them the third party behind the SNP and Labour. That would be something.

5
funkytyphoonCommon Weal•

The last poll for Holyrood had the Greens at 8.7% on the regional list vote. That'd give them 10 MSPs, 4 more than the Lib Dems and 4 less than the Tories.

1
CrashingAnalyst•

It feels like they've lost their confidence - they've always done well on a local level at getting local support, and have good ideas when it has come to the big questions of running the country / running Europe - but since the last few years have been disastrous you barely hear anything out of them anymore.

I chucked them my council vote anyway :)

2
Kensingt0n•

I will be voting Lib Dem in the local, they have always done good things in my area and I have very few complaints about them. In the European it will probably be Greens or Lib Dem again.

3
dav3j-1.12, -3.95•

I voted Lib Dem for Europe. I was 50/50 on whether to go for the Greens, as I have to say, a lot of their European Policy is genuinely appealing too. I went for the Lib Dems in the end simply because of greater experience in European government and their spirited defence of EU membership in the face of the obvious fuckwittery surrounding this election.

For the record, I also voted Lib Dem in our local council elections. They've done a great job in the past, and only since the last Council election Labour have had overall control - and what a balls-up of it they've made.

3
nowitasshole•

I've struggled to choose to be honest. I've always voted Lib Dem and on the majority of topics they are my closest match but I don't agree with their strong stance that the UK HAS to be in the EU no matter how bad it gets. I disagree with the Greens when it comes to their benefits free-for-all. I'm probably going to vote for Labour.

2†
TLS96OPLiberal Democrat•

Lib dems stance is if there was a new treaty or major change they would offer a referendum, so they're not saying we "have to stay in"

2†
TravisdkSick of this place? I don't care•

Labor. Nobody else I can mildly tolerate.

2†
Bulldog312Powellite•

*Labour

10
TravisdkSick of this place? I don't care•

What a helpful comment.

-7
Bulldog312Powellite•

It helped you remember the correct spelling I hope.

8
TravisdkSick of this place? I don't care•

Labour is how I spell it usually, which you can see quite obviously by looking through my comment history. However, I'm typing on a device imported from the States, and as such it auto corrects to American spelling. For example:

Labour -> Labor

Colour -> color

Honour -> honor

0
cthomp88•

For me, it's a tactical vote against UKIP coming out on top, which is as good a reason as any.

5
funkytyphoonCommon Weal•

According to your flair, the Greens are the closest party to your ideology. Don't waste your vote on the Red Tories!

2
TravisdkSick of this place? I don't care•

Anti-nuclear and anti-GMO. The Greens are not getting my vote until both policies change.

1
funkytyphoonCommon Weal•

copied from a post I saw here:

And anti-factory farming! And pro-sustainable fishing! And anti-misuse of antibiotics! And anti-deforestation! And pro-biodiversity! And pro-affordable housing! And pro-NHS and illness prevention! And pro-peace! And pro-quality British-made products (anti-disposable crap)! And pro-workplace democracy! And anti-inequality! Pro-local investment! Pro-local governance and voting reform! Pro-universal human rights! And their policies are democratically decided by their members, so can be changed if enough people want to.

Surely you disagree with more New Labour policies than 2?

3
TravisdkSick of this place? I don't care•

There are no huge fundamental issues that I disagree with Labour on.

1
SmilePeregrine•

But how often do you come into contact with the effects of those policies? Nuclear, sure, the energy debate is always interesting, but at least we're having a debate because of them - possibly the carbon reductions outweigh other costs, but you can't pretend the issues of waste, large building & running costs, uranium mining & security aren't there. And GMO - IMO better to have a precautionary principle but each to their own.

http://www.reddit.com/r/ukpolitics/comments/2672tu/european_elections_who_are_you_voting_for_and_why/chod6e9

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2†
iwhz•

The problem is that many people throughout politics and the media will interpret your vote as support for UKIP policies. There will be pressure within the main parties to move their policy positions towards UKIP's to try and win back some of the UKIP voters - we've already seen this pretty clearly, with the rhetoric of all the main parties becoming a little more anti-immigration, for example. I can't imagine how else people voting for UKIP will cause them to "shake up their act".

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Hvny•

If what you're inferring is that UKIP don't support gay marriage, it's factually incorrect. They take a stance that government should have minimal intervention into the course of marriage, even for heterosexual marriage. IMO this is a lot better than what we currently have because it is does not discriminate any course of marriage.

-1
iwhz•

Their leader in Northern Ireland claims that the party continues to strongly oppose gay marriage and that UKIP's deputy leader Paul Nuttall confirmed this in a speech there.

They take a stance that government should have minimal intervention into the course of marriage, even for heterosexual marriage.

I've never heard of them saying this. They certainly played up their opposition to it while the legislation was being debated, to try and draw socially conservative voters from the Tories. Also, they have consistently supported the Tory policy of having some kind of tax break for married couples, which clearly represents an increase in government intervention in marriage. How come UKIP's defenders all seem to have so little understanding of what their party actually stands for?

On LGBT stuff in general, UKIP are consistently very sceptical of things like anti-discrimination laws, and they are happy for Roger Helmer, an overt homophobe, to retain his senior role in the party without even apologising for any of the stuff he has said (for example, that he doesn't see a problem with psychiatrists trying to "cure" gay people and that homophobia is a propaganda device invented by the "militant gay lobbby").

6
DukePPUk•

I'm torn between voting Green or Lib Dem.

I prefer Green policies (on the whole, at the EU level) but based on polling (and a bit of calculating) I think the Greens have a good chance of getting a seat in my region anyway, but it is a close race between the Lib Dems and Conservatives for the last seat. I'd rather the Lib Dems had it than the Tories.

Who says that PR removes tactical voting... it just makes it more interesting.

2
ZoneghostApparently a centrist•

Tory - mostly by virtue of eliminating every other party rather than by positive choice.

Least bad option still sucks though.

1†
jl45•

UKIP, because I want out of the institutionally racist European Union. All nationalities should be treated equal, we shouldn't give preference to Europeans or anyone else based on nationality.

1†
undergrand•

This is a joke. Right? Right?

7†
PeaSouperClassical liberal•

The UK, and every other developed country on earth, applies some discrimination on immigration. That is to say, not everyone can get in to the country to live, work, etc; prospective immigrants have to meet certain criteria.

The status quo in Britain is largely geographic based - if you're from one of the other 27 member countries of the European Union, you're in. If you're not, there are other criteria by which you can enter (I did), but it's very, very difficult, and getting harder all the time (the visa programme through which I got my leave to remain is no longer available).

UKIP are proposing to create a points-based system for immigrants from any country, scrapping the geographic preference. It's still discrimination, of course, but now prospective immigrants will be admitted based on skills, education, and their capacity to enrich Britain rather than the good fortune of having been born in (or had parents or grandparents born in) the right country.

7
undergrand•

Believing that UKIP in power would make immigration easier for anyone is pretty deluded.

1
cbfw86Swinger. -3.88, -3.33.•

I believe being all things to all people is an effective political tactic. It has worked before.

-1
iwhz•

This is like arguing that it's racist to have fewer restrictions on people moving to Edinburgh from Bristol than from Toronto. The way the world works at the moment is that people are arbitrarily split into national groups and treated differently depending on which one they fall into. Arguably, having free movement throughout the EU is a step away from that.

Also, I really, really don't believe that UKIP actually want to treat all nationalities the same for immigration purposes. If they do, then how is it going to work: are they going to start demanding visas from French, Irish, and American tourists, or extend visa-free travel to people from Iran and Somalia?

3†
jl45•

Arguably, having free movement throughout the EU is a step away from that.

It means treating foreigners differently based on where they were born. Pure racism.

-1†
RightStopThatSilly•

But why should we treat British people differently than foreigners? Pure racism?

3
jl45•

nope, british people are already in the country. foreigners are not. There is no need to make a decision about letting British people into the country because they are already here. But if we were for example to take 2 identical people one French and one Brazilian, the French is allowed in, no questions asked under EU rules whilst the Brazilian is not. Total racist bullshit.

1
RightStopThatSilly•

Our immigration officers are "institutionally racist" by design. This fact will not alter if we leave the EU^1 except in the details. Do you want to get rid of them too?

^1 Not that having Ukip members drawing salaries as MEPs will change our membership of the EU.

Edit: formatting

1
jaynemesisPirate/Green - Futurist, Socialist -7.00 -6.21•

Just got back from voting..

EU: Green I'd have voted Pirate Party if they were an option in the S.East, because I disagree with the Greens Nuclear and GMO policies, but that aside they tick all of my boxes.

Local: Lib Dem I'd have considered voting Green but they aren't standing in my area, it's a safe conservative seat anyway so it doesn't really matter, but Lib Dems and Greens are the only ones looking to improve public transport and make the roads safer for cycling too.

1
dominicshaw•

I don't really get the European election system and I have no idea who to vote for. I don't really know what they do over there or how it impacts me. I am a fiscal conservative and a social liberal and have quite liked the current coalition here in the UK. I oppose pretty much everything UKIP stands for.

Who should I vote for and why?

0†
Soilbleed•

Perhaps this test might be able to help http://www.votematch.org.uk/

3
dominicshaw•

Labour or lib dem I guess.. thanks. Who is most likely to win out of those?

1
SoyElPadrino•

Labour is most likely to win out the two (due to UKIP splitting the tory vote). Greens also stand a decent chance at outdoing the Lib Dems.

2
Soilbleed•

The lib dems are going to get hit hard as a lot of their previous voters have jumped ship after the last general election. Labour also have a larger voter base in general. So a labour vote will probably mean more in the grand scheme of things. But I would personally go with whatever party you think best represents you and your beliefs better, regardless of whether they'll do well or not.

1