There have been a lot of great posts with suggestions for LotV. Here is a collection of the best.
u/psione recently posted about Blizzard’s desire for more than just lists of requested features; they want deeper, more detailed feedback. To meet that desire, I’ve tried to collect some of the best suggestions, analyses, and community projects from the past couple years. This is meant to be an aggregate, not an editorial, so some of the entries may be contradictory; I merely try to give a fair summary of each.
I will say that the general consensus, at least among the Reddit and Team Liquid communities, seems to be that Legacy of the Void needs a thorough gameplay review – something far deeper than the unit additions and alterations seen in Heart of the Swarm – and the addition of features centered around community, esports, and player-created content.
Blizzard has a proven track record of supporting their games long after they’ve been released, but this final expansion offers the best opportunity for attention from former players, new blood, potential sponsors, and the gaming media. Legacy of the Void is Blizzard’s last chance to make a first impression.
LotV needs a community of ‘last chancers,’ dedicated to providing Blizzard with thoughtful, clear feedback, to make the final expansion the best that it can be. The collection below is incomplete, so please let me know what is missing.
edit: formatting
###GAMEPLAY###
Starbow
Kabel and a dedicated group of modders maintain a fan-made expansion to Brood War that integrates the best aspects of both BW and SC2. It features slower economies, lengthier battles, and more positional play.
OneGoal: A Better SC2
ItWhoSpeaks and FoxyMayhem lead a team of fan developers devoted to improving StarCraft 2 with a mod that concentrates on allowing greater expression of player skill and watering down binary mechanics and “coin-flip builds.”
There Be Dragons: Slaying the Deathball
On the Planetary Annihilation boards, ledarsi offers a thorough analysis of the dreaded ‘deathball’ in RTS games.
What Makes for a Good Spectator eSport?
MrInocence leads a discussion on Team Liquid that endeavors to identify exactly what makes for a good esport.
Brood War and StarCraft 2 – Pathing
In this insightful piece, Thieving Magpie explains the function of pathing in SC1 and SC2, and its far-reaching gameplay implications.
Protoss Unit Discussion
u/Antares_ kicks off what turns into one of the lengthiest discussions on this subreddit. Most frustrations with Protoss seem to spring from what some perceive as ‘gimmicky’ mechanics and a ‘deathball’ style of play.
Depth of Micro
u/mLalush offers a detailed critique and examination of the causes behind sluggish and inconsistent unit responses in StarCraft 2.
Why Adjusting Units Will Not Fix Passive Play in StarCraft 2
u/edias00 argues that resource acquisition is the most fundamental aspect of a RTS game, and that changes to worker AI and mining scalability in the transition from SC1 to SC2 had a profound, detrimental effect on gameplay.
A Carrier Love Story
On his blog, u/MiNDGaMeS87 analyzes the beloved Carrier and its current state.
###FEATURES###
Unlock Rewards with Minerals®
u/Gelatinousgelboy shows off a mockup of a currency system, earned in-game through experience, that could be used to buy rewards such as portraits and advisor voices.
Support Mapmakers with Vespene®
u/Gelatinousgelboy proposes a patronage system that would allow players to contribute real money to mapmakers, bolstering the arcade and mapmaking community.
Clanwar Ladder
u/xchamper mocks up a ‘clanwar’ ladder system that would enable fun, robust competition between StarCraft clans.
What a WCS Compendium Might Look Like
Valve offers players a virtual tournament booklet for their premier Dota 2 tournament, the International. Here u/Castaing mocks up an analog for StarCraft 2 and the WCS Global Finals.
Why I Both Love and Hate StarCraft 2
u/hanskempie presents battle.net interface changes that could greatly improve the community experience in SC2, which he sees as a step down from earlier Blizzard titles like Brood War and Warcraft III.
Four Features Legacy of the Void Needs
On Esports Heaven, u/ploguidic3 contends that four features would greatly behoove the coming expansion: local area networking, in-client observing for professional games, cosmetic skins and voice packs, and automated tournaments in the mode of Warcraft III.
[Legacy of the Void Feature Request Survey]
(http://www.reddit.com/r/starcraft/comments/2etny3/over_1500_of_you_participated_in_the_lotv_feature/)
u/MipSuperK releases the results of his community survey, intended to gauge interest in various potential features, such as automated tournaments, a free-to-play ladder, and enhanced social features.
Feature Discussion: Automated In-Game Tournaments
u/TheRageKage12 asks the community exactly what they want to see in an automated tournament system, a feature that has received a lot of attention.
In-Game Tournament Concept
u/revoluti8n conceives of a system that would allow players to create, manage, track, and participate in community tournaments through battle.net.
Posted Sep 4, 2014, 1:33 PM UTC · edited