[Discussion] Silence: Where do we go from here?

Earlier this week, u/thedronk made an excellent post for his card Kil’Sorrow Cultist. It’s a well-designed card in its own right, but it got me thinking about the wider implications of Silence.

Silence is a practical, powerful mechanic, removing all card text from a minion, but it’s probably the Hearthstone mechanic that most challenges Blizzard’s own design philosophy: it’s not very fun.

It could even be argued that Silence is anti-fun. It’s a universal off-switch. And while counterplay is an important component of the game’s strategic potential, card text is what makes the game fun. Without it, Hearthstone is reduced to simply smashing creatures into one another.

Blizzard is well aware of this, of course, and has said previously that they want to be cautious about proliferating Silence. I see two directions for Silence and Silence-like effects:

1) Introduce Silence alternatives. Instead of eliminating all card text, look into cards that interact with keywords (e.g. Battlecry, Deathrattle). These kinds of cards are more difficult to design than straightforward Silences: Their effects are often so mild that they never see play (e.g. Nerub’ar Weblord), or so powerful that they are included in a wide array of decks (e.g. Black Knight). Here are a few attempts to walk this line:
Blood Knight
Fleshbeast (Art by Chris Seaman and property of Blizzard)
Royal Executioner (Art by Slawomir Maniak and property of Blizzard)

2) Explore new vehicles for Silence. Instead of adding more Battlecry-activated Silences, look at alternative Silence plays, or new cards that interact with Silence. Here are a few examples:
Felhunter (Art by John Polidora and Roman Kennedy, and property of Blizzard)
Dispersion (Card by u/Coolboypai)
Quiet Thoughts (Card by u/migster99)

Both of these paths are exciting and should have a place in the game. And be careful of those Battlecry Silences!

Posted Jan 28, 2015, 1:43 PM UTC

74
Loading comments…