EasytypeDo not ask for source as refusal often offends•

Can't help thinking it would have been better to just tell us everything in the first statement rather than the drip feed of information.

First they say it's a private matter.

Then they say they don't benefit.

Then they say they won't benefit in the future.

Now finally they admit to having invested in it in the past.

Did they think the papers would give up after any of the first 3 statements?

Anyway this has really fucked things up, they can't ever again even mention tax avoidance without this being brought up for political capital.

162

I think just dragging it out long enough to get separate articles from Iceland's PM is enough.

If the headline is "Iceland and Britain's PMs implicated in offshore tax avoidance scandal", then when Iceland's PM quits (which is inevitable) the two will be too inextricably tied in people's minds for Cameron to dodge calls for resignation himself.

Gotta get that distance between stories, even if it's just a day or two, just so that the news article pronouncing judgement on the Iceland PM isn't the same one judging the British PM. Instead the news story will be all about why Cameron's situation is different from Iceland's, rather than why they're the same.

38
cherry_ghost•

No chance. In the British press (where it matters), he would be on the front page with an article to himself. Iceland PM is a seperate story.

They've made a huge mistake in comms and dragged out a story for 3/4 days while making Cameron look even dodgier and evasive.

It was never going to end well, but Labour are currently out in force saying he's been misleading the public since the panama papers broke. That's on top of some questionable tax dealings.

27

Yeah but this is a seriously inopportune moment for him to resign, in the run up to the referendum. Labour has been surprisingly mute about him resigning so far. They're happy to criticise, to make political capital from it, but even Labour doesn't want him resigning just now.

And I suspect the media, for the most part, is prepared to play along with the "honest intentions" narrative. That maybe he needs to pay back any of his father's ill gotten gains, but that David himself did nothing wrong. And part of that is differentiating himself from what Iceland's PM did.

5
Rhymes-like-dimes69•

Cameron obviously has done something wrong.

5
p7rLabour🌹•

No, I think in most voters' minds this will make him look worse than if he had just been up front about it.

May elections will be interesting, never mind the referendum!

4
HalkRadical Centre 4.8,-5.1 •

I wonder if he'd be better now to go on the attack and sue someone prominent who accuses him of something dodgy.

It looks as if in spirit or in fact he's not done anything wrong. His father has minimised tax liability but that's not what the whole Panama thing is about, the Panama thing is about sanctions evasion and concealing ownership.

It's Cameron's bad handling of this that's cost him. It makes me wonder if he's actually handled it well because the press will think this is the final revelation. Could he have something genuinely corrupt in the background? Is that why he held on to announcing this for so long?

29
EtchyTWA•

The charge was never illegality, it was hypocrisy and unfairness.

Cameron just admitted he's a hypocrite and benefited from unfairness.

I also wonder what else is going on, because this looks like classic PR tactics, stall, stall, and then when things hit fever pitch, announce something tiny to hide a larger error.

38
vzzzbux•

They've announced a u-turn on the plans to let the private sector decide animal welfare guidelines, I guess that's relatively small but positive news

10
Asiriya•

Seriously, who the fuck voted for these cunts.

3
NosferatiiDistributivist syndicalist ⧨•

That would have been a huge mistake, glad they've done yet another U-turn here, although it's telling that they proposed something this awful in the first place.

2
jdwalker•

the bastards

1
gadget_uk•

They'll be re-running Camerons trite speech about Jimmy Carr being immoral. On a loop.

4
gildredge•

What unfairness? Is there some provision in tax law that says only certain sorts of people are allowed to use it?

1
EtchyTWA•

Nothing in law. Just inherently you need a certain amount of money to make it worthwhile.

This is why your local burger flipper isn't paying zero UK income tax by being paid via the cayman islands. ;p

1
2times21•

I wonder if the timing of the sale is of significance. To my suspicious mind, the timing seems to coincidental with him becoming PM.

18
RegulatedNeoliberals stole my pocket money•

He admits he sold it when he became Prime Minister to rid himself of biases or vested interests.

28
2times21•

Or he could have done it because if it ever came out it would look bad.

17
trakam•

Corruption rarely stems from serving your own interests but rather the interests of those close to you.

2†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AnyalesWe've got fantastically corrupt leaders here•

Could he have something genuinely corrupt in the background? Is that why he held on to announcing this for so long?

I don't think it's anything corrupt but again he is being specific in his explanation, it is interesting that he only goes as far as saying he held shares. It makes me wonder if there is something questionable about how he gained the shares, did he buy the shares or was he given the shares?

Honest questions for anyone who knows, do you have to declare an interest when you buy shares in your parents company in a different country? Alternatively if you receive a gift of shares in an offshore company should his father have paid CGT on it?

2
Towns99•

Saying he "held" shares is the usual terminology and I think it's implied that they were bought through usual means, maybe you're right that there's something dodgy but it seems a bit far-fetched to me.

As an individual you do not have to declare an interest on assets of this size until you hit a tax point, so when he paid income tax on the dividends he received he will have declared that he had a beneficial interest to HMRC, however you don't declare the size of the asset when you pay income tax. Only when he sold the asset will it have been declared to HMRC on his self assessment tax return for capital gains purposes, unless it was eligible for EIS in which case he would have probably declared the asset when he bought it.

1
AnyalesWe've got fantastically corrupt leaders here•

Sorry I quite clearly said anyone who knows what they are talking about not "i reckon", my only query is that the rules might be different because it's overseas.

0
zakakaka•

He can go on the attack by:

  • banning firms headquartered in tax havens from doing business or owning assets in Britain

  • ending non-dom status entirely

  • making the real estate market in the UK entirely transparent from start to finish, including ownership and transactions

Let him redeem himself that way.

1
Fiishbait•

He did not sue when it was mentioned that he stuck his privates in a severed Pigs head, doing so for this would seem weird.

0†
EasytypeDo not ask for source as refusal often offends•

He chose the "I'm not dignifying it" line. I can't say I blame him for that. Suing would mean he'd have to stand in court and specifically deny it while a fleet of witnesses are called to argue that he actually did.

It'd put it back in the news for a good month while the case dragged on.

5
Fiishbait•

Vaguely recall he also said "I am too busy to..."

That did not help his case either.

2
BeardedViolence•

I find it very hard to believe this is the last step of the tale either.

Next week it'll be 'Yes my parrot does own £15mil in shares in my dads tax dodge, but thats an entirely private matter' walks away from camera

3
Slanderous•

He's probably just praying for the doctor's strike to start and take the heat off him.

2
sh00tah•

His biggest mistake was the stupidity of trying to make paying tax a moral thing. Tax avoidance is perfectly legal and always has been. The only way to avoid tax is to know the rules better than the government, something that gets progressively easier the more pages they add to the tax code. Due to continued government incompetence, and also due to EU incompetence while we're at it, its ridiculously easy to avoid tax. What they should be doing is making the tax system simpler so that there are less loopholes instead they try to moralise to bully people into feeling guilty while most of them dont have two morals to rub together.

1
NosferatiiDistributivist syndicalist ⧨•

Yeah, it's almost like they've got something to be ashamed of...

0
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

I'm a Tory voter, but I don't believe anyone intelligent enough to turn on their computer is genuinely surprised at the fuss because 'it's perfectly legal'.

It's the perception that a small elite with close ties to, or actually in Government implement laws with loopholes explicitly so that they and people like them can continue to build their wealth and 'power'. The fact that it's technically legal is exactly the point - most people feel like it shouldn't be but despite there being widespread agreement that this sort of tax arrangement isn't 'fair', this sort of 'planning' remains possible. It seems to be one aspect where the vast majority have absolutely no power over a small minority.

Basically this sort of tax arrangement isn't available to 'normal' people. I'd be amazed if anyone here pretending to scratch their head at the 'fuss' could organise their taxes in a similar way because they don't, nor will they ever have enough money to access this world.

This perfectly illustrates how Cameron (and by extension the other senior Tories who were his personal friends before) are not like 'normal people'.

120
TVPaulD•

This is a really eloquent explanation of the point at the heart of all this. Very well put.

31
convertedtoradians•

Very well put.

The argument just below the surface is that real people, the hard-working people of Britain that one hears about all the time, don't have large offshore funds for any reason whether because it's a sensible investment or to avoid tax. It's just not a part of their life.

Good, honest British folk never invest in anything more than house and that only over the course of a lifetime. At worst, they might put their money in a savings and investment account at some bank or other.

All this coming up with clever arrangements and offshore banking just seems like they're thinking about the money too much and clearly therefore have too much of it. It'd be better from Dave's position if Cameron's dad just dumped it all in a bog-standard ISA at Lloyds and missed out on even a few tens of thousands of pounds. At least that's a thing everyone gets.

Honestly, I don't care that much. It hasn't changed my perception of Cameron's background, it was mostly his father's doing anyway and I'd rather judge the man on his government's policies than on some new fact which just makes more explicit the fact that his family is richer than I will ever be.

I don't even want him to be like "a normal person" necessarily. I don't think that's a required part of the job.

It just leaves a bad taste, that's all.

22
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

You're right, it's about him, and many politicians and other wealthy, influential people being dishonest. If they believe they should only pay a tenth of the normal tax rate, then just come out and say it. Lobby for that, if you get it everyone would know where they are. Being told 'You must pay 40% income tax or you will go to prison' (unless you know someone who can get you into this complex offshore web) is irritating enough. When someone actually gets caught out you at least hope they'd show some contrition about the bracketed bit, not square up to the public and try and claim you don't understand the fuss because 'it's all legal' because you didn't make it illegal.

This sort of thing is beyond your middle class contractor who avoids income tax by paying themselves in dividends and making sure Granny has given away all of her money and house before she has to risk care home bills.

It really is about numbers. You're never going to have a tax system which everyone agrees 100% on. The best you can do is form a general consensus on what is fair. No one really believes that even the people taking advantage of these tax havens believe it's 'fair', anyone being honest will admit they are doing it because they can.

12
convertedtoradians•

To be honest, I think with a lot of people, it's not even about the possibility of tax avoidance. You could demonstrate on paper that David Cameron and his family were worse off for having used this scheme and it wouldn't matter.

That's because I think what we're seeing is an expression of the British irritation at people setting themselves up as different or special without a good reason. The standard savings account at Lloyds is good enough for the rest of us, but oh no, the Camerons have to put their money in bloody Panama. He can't just pop down Nationwide and open up an ISA; he has to have some scheme sufficiently exotic that noone ever heard of it until it made the news.

Edited to add: Which explains the dishonesty. If Cameron had mentioned the fact he had invested his money like this during an election campaign, say, he knows it would have confused everyone and caused all kinds of problems in a way that "I have my money in an ISA at Natwest" wouldn't have.

6
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

You might be right that it's a contributing factor. I think it's more because it's difficult to believe that Cameron (or anyone structuring their tax in this way), really see any measurable difference in their quality of life having done so.

In isolation I have no problem with someone generating as much income as they can. Obviously taxation takes a utilitarian approach and there it's impossible to ignore the human aspect - on paper taking 50% of a £100,000 income is just as bad (or worse) than taking half of £20,000. Yet faced with that single choice it's easy, pretty instinctive to protect someone from being poorer rather than allow someone to become richer. (On the assumption you have to implement some sort of income tax, before any GCSE Capitalism Studies student copies and pastes some website.)

It feels like 'these people' avoid tax simply because they can, which would be anti-social even if you weren't the brain behind the big society.

6
thetobester•

To be honest, I think with a lot of people, it's not even about the possibility of tax avoidance

I think a lot of people saw David Cameron have a crack at Jimmy Carr - that doesn't look too good in light of him benefitting from the same practices that he was moralising to be "wrong". This kind of thing is disappointing because it erodes the credibility of Tory voters, erodes the credibility of the establishment and puts a peg in the ground that says "we're all morally wrong but will get on our hypocritical high-horse from time to time to reap some perverted goodwill".

0†
hotcosby101pagan•

Very well put, glad to see someone on either side with such an objective and level headed analysis of the situation

19
KarmaUK•

It's the tired old Tory MP thinking that rich people are only encouraged by handing them more money, while the poor can only be encouraged by taking it away. I wonder what the mid point is, where they can only be encouraged by doing nothing.

9
CFC509Liberal Conservative; Heart says Leave, Head says Remain•

I'm a Tory but I'm also very much aware of how elite Cameron and Osborne are. I vote for them in spite of that, TBH anyone who votes Tory on the basis that Cameron and Co are normal people is a bit stupid.

7
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

Like you say, I had to accept Cameron and Osborne if I wanted the Tories in power. I think he's been a huge disappointment, not in the same way Gordon Brown was but he's just....below average. It's very frustrating having to defend Conservative principles when people can point to Cameron as a rebuttal because generally they're right.

People like him and Osborne don't belong in politics, they should stick to banking and finance, out of the public eye. I don't think all politicians should be shop stewards beforehand, but it's difficult to think of someone less qualified to make decisions that will impact the lives of 65 million people than a career politician from an 'off-shore tax structures family'.

5
BeardedViolence•

Pretending to scratch their heads

Perfectly sums up that particular group.

3
Kar_AthriLeninist ☭•

Literally the only way we could stop practices like these is through violent revolution.

2
Mr_Again•

nor will they ever have enough money

As I can tell, what DC did wrong was invest in his dad's dodgy fund. Anyone could do that with a few hundred pounds.

0
errantgamer•

Aaaaaaaand there it is.

Just a bit cynical to sell up shortly before you win the election, don't you think?

60
ZebraSharkPragmatic liberal•

I imagine because it would look worse for a sitting prime minister to be currently profiting from a trust fund than having done so in the past.

27
DeedTheInky•

Or maybe he just moved it somewhere else that we just haven't found out about yet.

5
jac77794•

He won't need the money he will get a PM salary for the rest of his life.

2
chrisjd•

Most of the people stashing their money in tax havens don't need the money, most are billionaires who could easily afford to pay their taxes, it seems the more people have the more they want.

9
_Born_To_Be_Mild_•

You have to ask yourself why.

-1†
LolworthDon't be digusting to each other.•

Ironically because he maybe thought people might make it something it's not

15
_Born_To_Be_Mild_•

Have nothing to do with it then if it's a lose lose situation.

1†
Juiz12•

I imagine if he could go back in time he would. Unfortunately if he already owned them due to his father then the only two courses of action are keep them or sell them.

Edit: He perhaps should have sold them sooner than literally right before the general election though...

5
fireball_73•

How can Cameron be a credible PM if he is implicated in tax avoidance?

40
Quagers•

He isn't implicated in tax avoidance yet.

34
RhaegarionLabour Member | Open Labour•

Avoidance yes, evasion no.

8†
Quagers•

Not even avoidance at this stage.

32
RhaegarionLabour Member | Open Labour•

No other reason to be involved in anything in Panama.

-9†
Osgood_Schlatter•

No - he hasn't avoided tax, the company he owned shares in did.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
fireball_73•

Well didn't he just admit that he benefited from tax avoidance.

3†
Quagers•

No, he admitted he benefited from a company based on Panama, that is not the same thing. Although given the way this has been reported I'm not surprised people are confused.

9
KarmaUK•

He's been implicated in being a twat for decades and that didn't stop anything.

2†
chrisawhitmoreThat which we are, we are.•

Shit, I have an ISA. Guess I'm never gonna be a credible pm

2
letmepostjune22Labour: I prefer their earlier work•

Definitely the same thing

1
gildredge•

Its different how? Its a financial product that exists entirely for the point of tax avoidance.

2
Patch86UK/r/LabourUK•

One was set up intentionally by the tax authorities with a high profile government-sponsored "use these" publicity campaign, and the other is (allegedly) using loopholes and technicalities which HMRC are powerless to close to avoid paying taxes which would otherwise be due.

Surely you can see the difference?

1
letmepostjune22Labour: I prefer their earlier work•

You really don't see the difference between a Gov. endorsed product and a service of funnelling money through foreign shell companies!?

1
chrisawhitmoreThat which we are, we are.•

It's tax avoidance.

1
Austere_FostereFriedmanite•

So the big scandal is that he bought shares in a foreign company, sold them again and paid UK tax on the dividends, but the company itself isn't based in the UK and so doesn't pay any corporation tax here. It doesn't seem that different to owning shares in any foreign company. If the scandal is supposed to be that the company operates partially in the UK but doesn't pay its fair share of tax here, then it doesn't seem that different to owning shares in Google or Starbucks or any other company that legitimately minimises its tax burden.

24
Typefaec•

I'd be very surprised if people wouldn't be angry at the idea of the PM investing in companies like Google and Starbucks, so that's not really a fair point. It's not appropriate for the PM to own shares of a company that minimises its tax payouts, legally or illegally. This is a person who decides these laws, and having that kind of stake is inappropriate.

16
Juiz12•

Which is why he sold them presumably. I imagine if he could go back to 1997 he wouldn't have bought the shares. Perhaps he should have sold them sooner than right before the general election though.

13
Typefaec•

But then you have to question whether he would've otherwise held onto those shares. And while he may not have held the shares as PM, he certainly did as a politician.

2
Juiz12•

Yes it seems more than likely he would have held onto them if he wasn't planning to become PM.

3
mucgoo•

Almost anyone in some kind of pension scheme will have (indirect) investments in those companies.

8
Typefaec•

That's very different and you know it is.

3†
mucgoo•

By that I mean the "foreign company" he is being criticised for is an investment trust. Oversea's incorporated investment trust are standard investment instruments for everyday peoples savings.

5
Craggy_Island•

I work in tax (admittedly, not corporate tax so I don't know all the ins and outs) but I'm also slightly struggling to see what the huge scandal is in relation to Cameron.

As I understand it, companies are required to pay UK corporation tax if they're a) incorporated in the UK, b) centrally managed or controlled here, or c) have a permanent establishment here. Do we know anything about any UK operations of Big Daddy C's company?

I'm not quite sure of how it works if they've been investing in UK resident companies. Presumably those companies just pay corporation tax here as normal.

16
LolworthDon't be digusting to each other.•

I work in tax (admittedly, not corporate tax so I don't know all the ins and outs) but I'm also slightly struggling to see what the huge scandal is in relation to Cameron.

That's alright, most of us who understand tax aren't seeing it either.

6†
AnyalesWe've got fantastically corrupt leaders here•

What he has declared is pretty innocuous but it begs the question why did it take so long to admit it. He has a team of people deciding his response so he must have discussed with people that he was going to try hide it so the question is why.

3
wherearemyfeet•

He has a team of people deciding his response so he must have discussed with people that he was going to try hide it so the question is why.

Just have a quick look at the headlines. You and I know full well the papers wouldn't go "Oh, actually that looks pretty reasonable to me. Let's ignore this and not totally blow it out of proportion with cherry-picked quotes in order to sell papers and rile up our main demographic".

That's what the media does, and they do it because the public totally buy into it. This whole thread is full of people saying "it's not the legality, it's the morality without being able to explain why it's morally a problem".

Media relations is a basic part of politics, and it's a basic part of politics because people unquestionably buy into bluster and nonsense printed by the papers all the time.

1
EtchyTWA•

Cos it isn't the tax, its the tax avoidance + saying tax avoidance is immoral.

That and the ending pay outs for people in wheelchairs "because we have no money left" etc

2†
wherearemyfeet•

Cos it isn't the tax, its the tax avoidance + saying tax avoidance is immoral.

Despite the lack of any effective tax avoidance....

1
Mr-OldFart•

Good job he's not had anything to do with it for over half a decade then isn't it?

That and the ending pay outs for people in wheelchairs "because we have no money left" etc

What a surprise, our resident scrounger trots out that old shite. It isn't even correct. Go get a fucking job, you're perfectly capable of working.

-5†
HarryBlessKnappRight-Wing Liberal•

The only issue for me is it makes it harder for him to take a firm stance on tax loopholes etc. I'm really not seeing the huge scandal though.

2
alittleeconMMT•

Why was he acting so shady about this? Sounds like his made about 8% per year on his small investment, then paid tax on it. On day 1 he could have just said he got out of it in 2010 and since then had done x, y and z to reduce the amount of tax avoidance. He looks guilty as hell now, which if this it it, he isn't really.

16
ex-turpi-causaResident neoliberal shill; highly skilled in sophistry, AMA•

Probably hoping it would blow over. Anything to do with Panama has been mega-negativity hyped so jumping in right at the start probably wouldn't've helped. Better to release piecemeal but neutral-ish statements in that climate, rather than risk saying something that will be spun quite hard.

6
HedgehogkillaFully Cucked SJW | Remain •

Doesn't matter if cameron has done anything wrong or not, all that matters is what the public think he's done.

You'd the tories here would understand this since spreading bullshit and fear is their party's whole thing.

16
jmabbzslightly Labour•

Looks like it's not really that bad but will play very badly in the newspapers. It puts him in a difficult spot in the fight against tax avoidance though.

14
DemonEggyDirty foreigner, here to subvert your democracy•

It puts him in a difficult spot in the fight against tax avoidance though.

It means he can never talk about it again without people calling him a hypocrite.

Kinda like he can never talk about how bad it is to fuck dead animals.

9
Heknarf•

Seems counter productive to encourage the PM not to talk or tackle tax avoidance.

But maybe that's just me..

6
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

No one is encouraging, just stating a fact. I'm a Conservative voter, but this will weaken the Conservatives when it comes to any sort of tax reform so long as he is leader. It's just a fact - no point pretending otherwise then acting shocked when the opposition brings it up.

4
Heknarf•

Yeah, I'm just saying it's silly.

It's true, but it's silly.

5
DemonEggyDirty foreigner, here to subvert your democracy•

I agree. But he'll still be labeled a hypocrite for doing so.

1
Juiz12•

You realise the pig fucking thing was more than likely a piece of slander put into Michael Ashcroft's book because he was pissed off at being snubbed a good cabinet position despite donating so much money and helping the election campaign? There is no evidence for it other than his own word that there is apparently a photo. After Cameron denied him a ministerial role he spent as much time as possible trying to undermine the Coalition government and tell everyone how bad it was, the man seems entirely untrustworthy and a complete asshole.

Even if it was true I don't really see what the problem is. But constantly bringing it up just lowers the tone in general, people gets the politicians they deserve in the end when this generates more interest and discussion among the general public than actual issues. If this is appropriate political news to report on then I guess the Telegraph and Mail's stories about the finer details of Corbyn and Abbot's sex life are fine as well.

Edit: spelling

6
DemonEggyDirty foreigner, here to subvert your democracy•

Oh sure, it may well not be true. But it's fun to believe it is.

2
RichDaviCCHQ SHILL•

Not sure what the problem here is. Cameron bought shares, sold them and paid tax on the profits. Is that really a story?

13
chrisjd•

He profited from an investment company, set up by his dad, in a tax haven, with the aim of avoiding tax, that's the story.

16
Neverfloppy•

Where did you get the idea that it's been set up in Panama for Tax avoidance reasons? (I've no dog in the game just curious) I read there are many reasons to incorporate offshore not all related to tax

12
Heknarf•

I read there are many reasons to incorporate offshore not all related to tax

Cameron said in his interview that it wasn't for tax reasons, and was to take advantage of exchange controls being lifted.

Timeline kind of works. They were lifted in 1979 and his dad started the fund a few years later.

7
awdeam•

From the fund's prospectus:

"The Directors intend that the affairs on the Fund should be managed and conducted so that it does not become resident in the United Kingdom for UK taxation purposes. Accordingly ... the Fund will not be subject to United Kingdom corporation tax or income tax on its profits,"

1
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

But, but TECHNICALLY!!!!

6
Capsulets•

It was an investment fund, which means that all of the money that goes through the fund ends up back in the accounts of UK residents, who pay tax on it. Probably at a higher rate than current cooperation tax due to their incomes.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
chrisjd•

If the fund was incorporated in the UK, they would have had to pay corporation tax and tax and tax on dividends though, it's not either or.

1
Heknarf•

Or they could have invested in a NYC based fund, got less money back due to some of it going to the American tax man, and then paid less tax in the UK because they made less profit.

Tax in a globalized world is a strange thing.

3
gildredge•

Complete crap, setting up a foreign fund that invests in foreign companies isn't tax avoidance. That's like saying getting a job in another country is tax avoidance.

2
EtchyTWA•

...then said doing stuff like that is evil.

yes, its a story.

1†
NosferatiiDistributivist syndicalist ⧨•

Wasn't so hard to admit now, was it Dave.

10
OneOfTheBastardos•

The self righteous mood, doused in hypocrisy and envy, doesn't half make one fearful of the Internet mob.

10
QuaverRest•

Yep. This whole thing seems very reasonable if everything Cameron stated here is true. In plain light of day, not as interesting a story as I'd hoped!

1†
OneOfTheBastardos•

I have no idea. I'm just not going to judge without evidence. Love him to resign but that's not the point.

3
[deleted]•

If it is so reasonable why didn't he admit to it straight up?

3
QuaverRest•

I'd be astounded if his lawyers didn't immediately take charge of the whole situation, and would have told him not to say anything that could be inaccurate (as the public would accuse him of lying) until they had all the facts. So he said what he knew to be true as the media was demanding a statement. That was all done in, what, 4 days? Pretty quick response to a serious allegation. If he's lying, of course, he's fucked.

1
[deleted]•

He'd have all the facts from the start.

2
bennzo1238•

Did anyone really think his dad went to all the effort to avoid tax for his family not to benefit?!

8
NotABoxSocialPlease provide sources for your common knowledge•

Woah, woah, woah. I think you meant to ask if anyone thought his Dad 'minimised his tax liability in a way which is inaccessible to the vast majority of the population; and is widely regarded as wrong but is inexplicably still technically legal' for his family not to benefit.

People like David Cameron have all sat down and decided that people like David Cameron's Dad should not have to pay tax if they can afford to get involved in offshoring. David Cameron has decided the thing his Dad did to make a load of money is perfectly legal, there is no issue here.

8
fireball_73•

Maybe he spent it all on cocaine and hookers?

3
OptioMkIXI <3 Carlswaen•

You're getting confused with Osborne.

3
KarmaUK•

Next we'll find out Osborne's dad was involved in dodgy tax dealings in order to pay for his son's coke and hookers habit.

2
bigdickliam•

is he going to resign?

6†
OneOfTheBastardos•

Why would he?

25
workingcockerneeds must•

exactly. he could shit on the cenotaph and labour still wouldn't be able to affect him.

8
Kesuke•

Doesn't appear so in the slightest.

17
PsychoChomp•

I don't think this is a resigning issue at the moment. If all the news stories revolve around his Jimmy Carr speeches and go through literally everything that's happened in UK or EU to do with taxes since he was elected the drip feeding could force him out.

14
interiorlittleveniceStaunch Conservative, Pro-EU•

I think resignation is unlikely because he's already said he's not standing in 2020, which calms the tory establishment as he wont be defending this in public in four years' time.

Secondly, resigning now puts the party in a horrible position with the referendum. They can send Osborne out to die, although realistically it's quite possible he'll accept just to have a year as PM. A full leadership election would be a disaster now, and most of them probably have Cameron esque baggage.

11
PsychoChomp•

Tactically it would be a very bad thing for the Tory party, but there's blood in the water and I'm sure there's reporters trying to find anything that looks bad on the entire front benches financial history. He hasn't even apologised, (even if you think he didn't do anything wrong being defiant about your rich family isn't a vote winner)

3
LolworthDon't be digusting to each other.•

No need.

7
AlbrechtVonRoonReactionary•

He has already said he won't stand for election in 2020, I don't see why he would resign now. He might as well just hang on until he steps down more naturally.

4
arselona•

Can anybody point out where my info is incorrect. I can't help feel the real story in the Panama Leaks is being completely missed. Maybe even the case is that the establishment is using Cameron as a distraction.

It feels like a strawman, while genuine crooks and a morally repugnant system stays out the limelight.

  1. Cameron's dad, a prominent stockbroker, manages an offshore fund with £20-35m AUM (depending on source), that is fully legal according to the letter of the law, and openly markets itself to the public.

The fund is described as such by tax experts.

“Blairmore Holdings was a perfectly legitimate offshore investment fund. It’s underlying investments were very largely if not exclusively non UK. The fund was registered with the UK revenue as a ‘distributer fund’ which meant that it had to pay out to investors at least 85% of its income each year. The investors would be liable to UK income tax on those payments if UK resident. Equally, if they sold their investment they would be liable to capital gains tax”

  1. Cameron and his wife had a joint £30k investment in the fund, dating back to 1998.

  2. In 2010 upon becoming PM, Cameron and his wife sold all their investments, including his £30k holding in Blairmore (an ironic name in a way) Holdings.

  3. After 12 years of investment, Cameron and his wife record a £13k profit on said investment.

  4. All tax is paid properly and correctly on the funds being redeemed from the fund.

  5. In 2012, the Guardian wrote an expose on the Fund.

  6. In 2012, Cameron attacks Jimmy Carr for using an aggressive tax avoidance scheme that enabled Carr to deposit £3.3m in an offshore fund, which then returns the £3.3m to Carr as a tax free loan, in which Carr pays agreed coupons, but the underlying debt is eventually written off at the end of the loan period.

  7. In 2016, Panama Leaks information covered in points 1) & 6).

  8. After blustering around and drawing attention to himself, Cameron admits points 2), 3), 4) 5). He also admits that of his £300k inheritance, he couldn't be sure whether any portion of it had been originally obtained using legal offshore vehicles.

  9. Hashtags circulate suggesting that Cameron should resign.

  10. Nobody is focusing on the real crimes that have been hidden by compromised due diligence processes in offshore locations.

5
Jim_Nash•

Not sure of your point. Are you saying Cameron is being used as a "fall guy"? That looks a bit conspiratorial.

I think the main point is that Dave paid no tax on the profits of 19K (you say 13?). He paid income tax only on the dividends, which would be chump-change. At the same time, he's preaching the evils of tax avoidance. That is at best very hypocritical.

-1
arselona•

I read £13k originally but searching I see £19k now... The difference is largely immaterial as his profit sits under the joint capital gains threshold.

He paid income tax on the dividend which as you say is chump change. He paid no capital gains tax because the joint threshold stood at £20k when he sold.

Important to note that he sold his investments ahead of becoming Prime Minister, implying that he was complying with the tax rules implemented by the outgoing Labour Government who had previously been in power for over a decade.

He followed the law and paid the correct tax upon repatriating his funds.

I'm sorry but it's not even remotely close to what Jimmy Carr was up to with his £3.3m deal that scrapped the barrel in terms of both morality and legality.

I don't think there is a conspiracy per se, but the focus Cameron is attracting is borderline retarded, and when intelligent people seemingly deliberately miss the point, it makes you wonder.

The Panama Leaks are extremely explosive, and are centred around the British maintained network of dodgy offshore centres involving organised crime, terrorism et al, which is going ignored. THAT is the story.

1
sirjimmyjazzNow I am become Murdoch, the Smearer of All•

Are we just ignoring the Peston article from earlier about this then? Or should I return my pitchfork?

4†
TheLemonTree•

Pretty much seems to be everyone is ignoring it. Pitchforks are more fun I suppose?

7
sirjimmyjazzNow I am become Murdoch, the Smearer of All•

Well thank god for that, we should never let facts get in the way of a good witch hunt

7
ex-turpi-causaResident neoliberal shill; highly skilled in sophistry, AMA•

Facts and thinking just aren't as exilarating as being part of the pitchfork mob :)

0†
RagingBeryllium•

It's always worth keeping at least one pitchfork around.

3
whencanistopHMRC investigated my tax bill•

The Peston article that said a company he owned shares in was based in Panama solely so that it could reduce its tax liabilities?

3
sirjimmyjazzNow I am become Murdoch, the Smearer of All•

That was in there but you seem to have missed the overarching point of the article for some reason?

Because if that's all you took from it you must have been confused as to why people might accuse him of whitewashing...

7
whencanistopHMRC investigated my tax bill•

It was nonsense. His claim that Cameron (snr) paid more income tax than he would have done if it had been based in the UK ignores the fact that the extra income tax is less than the corporation tax the company would have paid if they were based in the UK.

"Hey guys, Cameron paid £10 in tax, instead of £9, isn't that great? Oh of course, the company should have paid £2 in tax, but didn't, but who cares because I've got a narrative that makes Cameron look good."

1†
sirjimmyjazzNow I am become Murdoch, the Smearer of All•

I'm sorry mate but when it comes to trusting Robert Peston over some dude on Reddit I've got to hedge my bets with Pesto. Unless you're implying that he's suddenly showing a pro Cameron bias that has been nowhere to be found in his career so far?

Hell, hardly anyone is reporting on this story without some kind of axe to grind - I'm just happy someone cut past the hurd-dur Cameron's a crook bollocks the Graun have been peddling whilst frothing at the mouth.

7
Taure•

What do you mean, the company should have paid £2 in tax? Does the UK have some moral right that entitles it to tax every company in the world, no matter where it's based?

2
chrisjd•

Coincidentally it was Robert Peston that Cameron gave his exclusive interview to admitting that he had had shares in Blairmore. Of course it's impossible that Peston could have agreed to soften the ground for Cameron in return for the exclusive.

3
sirjimmyjazzNow I am become Murdoch, the Smearer of All•

If he were some 2 bit journo then maybe, but Robert Peston is a vet. Maybe it's more likely he agreed to give the exclusive to someone he knew wouldn't just whip it up into the most sensationalist headline they could think of?

7
cherry_ghost•

Correct. You don't give exclusives to hostile journalists. The Guardian, for example, never gets Tory exclusives ahead of budgets, announcements, new policies etc. It's the Tele, FT and Times mainly, who are far less critical of the Government.

2
Jimmyjamjames-2.75,-2.51 Dan Jarvis for Labour leader•

Which version would you like:

Traditional ---E Left Handed 3--- Fancy ---{ Or you could choose the special Brexit debate forks ---€ or ---£

0†
popcornelephant•

I am hugely left leaning when it comes to politics and it's fair to say that i'm not a fan of many policies that this government make. I also respect that Cameron is a very good politician: he speaks very well and manages to speak in a way that twists things either positively or negatively, however he wishes.

But worst case scenario, he has to resign: who takes over? I can't see anyone who has the same qualities as Cameron. Osborne is embarrassingly weak after the recent budget shambles, I don't think Theresa May is at all respected by the population, and Boris just seems like the strange man that humbles and bumbles at the moment. (It seems like he would try to convince everyone he is more capable of leadership in the next few years, but this has come too soon for him).

Or is this just going to blow over and we'll forget about it in a week?

3
StormyBA•

Grove

1
throwaway_6787•

This isn't news.

2†
Alejandro_Alexandre•

This is the Tories continuing to do what they do best "gaming". To them, everything is a gamble, and for the most part it has paid off. But they are beginning to lose. Osborne has been beaten back on welfare reforms and tax credits. Cameron thought he could simply shrug this off, maybe chuck out a dead cat about anti-semitism in the Labour party or something, but underestimated the anger of the public. Now he looks far worse than if he had simply admitted this in the first place.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1