r/EDH•
Isawa_Chuckles

The 105 Deck Challenge

So, who's going to be first the madman/madwoman to construct a deck for all of the possible Partner Combinations?

Will probably get a bit samey half-way through, but it could also be a really interesting exercise in seeing how different synergies meld.

The "Partner" choice seems like a brilliant way to counter the "everyone's playing Meren for a year" thing that the Commander Product tends to produce, as it's way less likely you'll see two of the same Partner Pair at a table, by dint of sheer # of combinations.

I'm half tempted to just start doing two of them a week until Commander 2017.

Posted Oct 25, 2016, 4:33 PM UTC · edited

3524
Kaysol•

The real play is to make 15 49 card decks. One for each partner. Then just mash them together as necessary.

57
ZxasdtheBear•

Thats my plan, im calling it an "EDH cube"

13
CigeHorde of Notions•

You could probably make a 7-10 card base of mana rocks that swaps between decks as well.

9
Kaysol•

Yeah I would have to select a number of dual lands for each deck so there aren't any doubles, but it would work out.

2
EspummaSek'Kuar, Deathkeeper •

I'm not sure such a scheme exists. You also can't account for the color you aren't playing, so you have to adjust anyway.

2
TheDoctorLivesBaevictus / Anafenza / Sidisi, BT•

....Just only include duels strictly in the colors of a single commander. Itd work perfectly, though you mana base may be a lot of tapped lands.

3
Gluttony4•

That sounds insane.

...I love it!

3
TheMegaZordSigarda, Host of Herons•

That sounds like a great god damn multiplayer event. Everyone gets two random partners.

3
LyreBirb•

Draft them.

2
mcoleya•

Yea this is the better play in my opinion. I'm already planning this.

1
another-reddit-guy•

You could make a new format, where you play 2 50-card commander decks mashed together and allow up to 2 copies of a given card in the 98. Like Double Tiny Leaders, but good.

1
squabzillaThe Elves of Freyalise•

Keep in mind, although there's 105 combination, only a fraction of those will actually be semi-viable.

12
EchoSi3rratappedout.net/users/EchoSi3rra/•

and a lot of them will overlap in strategy/card choice significantly

8
LyreBirb•

Yeah we already said only a few would be viable.

-3
El_Panda_RojoAurelia, Holder of Swords•

This seems completely insane.

I'm only building one partner deck, which will be added to the roster of the 13 decks I already have built. One new one is more than enough.

That said... I'm sure someone out there is rich/brave/foolish/crazy enough to do it.

8
YoshiCline22/27 - likes elves a little too much•

I mean, I'm buying all 5 anyways because I've already got 30ish decks, and I'm a college student. It's not about the money, it's about the insanity.

In fact, hey, u/smileylich, you wanna do it?

4
smileylich•

Someone called for me? :) Eh, it's 105 decks, yeah, but only 15 unique generals amongst them, so I predict it may get stale. I like the fifteen 49 card decks that you mash together though. :)

2
YoshiCline22/27 - likes elves a little too much•

I look forward to seeing what you come up with.

1
maskofdamask•

Wait... 15 generals have partner?

2
Isawa_ChucklesOP•

Yep, 1 for each Allied Color Pair, 2 for each Enemy Color Pair.

1
Isawa_ChucklesOP•

All 15 Partners are spoiled, it is time for the Great Work to Begin.

1