Why is the Independence such a worthless CV?

Question

Seriously.. it's garbage, EVERYTHING deletes your planes.. fighters.. worthless.. fucking spotting planes can out RNG them.. Bombers and torp planes.. everything but DD's basically deletes them and you're you're lucky if by the time you drop anything you have more then 2 planes left. It's seriously fucking worthless.

Really looking forward to grinding out 70k exp 300 at a time in this POS.

Posted Feb 22, 2018, 8:16 AM UTC

050
Scurry5See the torp. Feel the torp. Be the torp.•

I would suggest grinding through in PvE operations. Better XP and less likely to get farmed by better CV opponents.

9
Vectoranalysis•

But of what use is it to grind through a ship without good opponents? That does only mean that the progress of learning how to play against competent enemy CVs is postponed to a higher tier where it's even more punishing.

8
Scurry5See the torp. Feel the torp. Be the torp.•

By better CV opponents, I should have said the Ryuujou. In my personal opinion, the Indy feels like the nadir of USN CVs even considering Ranger facing Saipan. Indy's matchup is plain terrible, especially considering the prevalence of AS Ryuujou on Asia where I play. The horrific plane capacity combined with facing T8s makes things even worse, and leads to almost no benefit learning to play using it. In short, I'd say that T6 feels more punishing to learn at than T7.

Furthermore, getting used to manual drops is something that has to be practised somewhere, and I would rather they do it where a mess-up is less critical.

4
Vectoranalysis•

Hmmmm is that the SEA Server that strikes again? Because on EU I felt the skilled Ryujo players were the ones with 1/2/2. The AS players lumped up their squads and left clicked only. Ohhh they joy when mowing threw them with 7 USN fighters :D

Sure basic manual drops should be practised in CoOp or Operations, but against 'real' opponents? Difficult. They behave so much more different than bots.

On the other hand: I had a DD once chase me in the ranger, just went in a straight line so my single squad had it easy to drop him. Bots would've done better I assume.

2
TGangstiHSF Graf Spee•

playing on EU 3/4 ryujos i run into use 3-1-1, 2 of them tend to just group up all their fighters.

and then there is this 1 guy that has his 3 fighters gang up on a clevelands floatplane....

2
RSTL82•

I have been chased by DD’s in my ranger also, what’s even better is that I leave my fighters up so I can spot torps and then dodge them while the secondaries and my dive bombers get them 😂

1
ApkohaOP•

Yeah, I'll have to do that I guess.. seriously the most frustrating 4 games in a row of my life that made me salty af and hate this CV.

1
Thegoodthebadandamanopening supercontainers blueballs more than getting cockblocked•

Tried doing that in Raptor Rescue. Didn't end well.

Did you know that AI Aobas can delete aircraft like a Cleveland? ^^^^/s

edit: now that I think of it, I might have been trying to take the TBs too close to the ships to exploit manual drops. It was ages ago, so I can't remember.

1
Tonaris•

All AI ships in operations have a AA build, since people complained that CVs were to strong. WG did WG things and now CVs aren't really viable in Ops.

3
Vectoranalysis•

such a worthless CV?

Is it though?

6
ApkohaOP•

well seeing as I can't get planes in range to drop anything short of against DDs because they just get shredded.. and even DD's shred the shit out of them.. I'd say yeah, it is.

-4
Vectoranalysis•

Then you must have a different Independence than me, because ... I can drop targets.

Sure you need to play cautiously when facing T8s and not blindly rush in for damage, but ... overall: She's in an ok spot.

Not OP, but certainly not UP either.

6
JGStonedRaiderAll aboard HMS Toxicity•

Patience is the key, especially in uptiers. Initially focus on spotting / air control while the fleets get into position.

For your first strikes, it's more important to choose targets of opportunity and make sure your planes aren't melted as you have so few backups. Once the game has progressed and ships have spread out is your time to shine.

Tip for USN CVs in general is lead with HE bombs to set fires / remove AA and then follow with torps for perma flooding.

However, there will be some games such as uptier / 2 CV games or where an enemy team clumps together to form an insane AA bubble. This happens at all tiers even 10.

2
ApkohaOP•

Thank you for the tips, I'll def give it a try.. you nailed it with the Patience.. I'm use to being more aggressive and it's clearly biting me in the ass.

1
molochzAn tSeirbhís Chabhlaigh•

What are your captain skills?

1
ApkohaOP•

I'll have to go back to check.. I think it's only currently only a 6 or 7 point cpt and off the top of my head I think it's

  • Aircraft Servicing Expert
  • Dogfighting Expert
  • Torpedo Acceleration
  • Emergency Takeoff

but I think i'm gonna respec from what i've been reading and watching into

  • Aircraft Servicing Expert
  • Dogfighting Expert
  • Adrenaline Rush
  • Torpedo Armament Expertise

and then once I get him up to 11 take Air Supremacy

2
FumiKanePersonally I prefer the air•

Take dogfighting expert after AS, you wont really need it until the Ranger.

6
jonasnee"unicum" is not an insult•

emergency take off was a mistake.

4
mrmariokartguybuff me pls•

Stop sending your planes into heavy AA. Learn which ships have good AA and which don't, and for those that don't strike them when they are relatively isolated.

3
ApkohaOP•

that's the issue, after the 4 games I played in a row that all played out the same and brought upon this sodium rant.. I feelt like everything but the odd DD had heavy AA... and I don't know if it was because I was stuck playing late at night on NA and only have 2K+ people on getting matched with a bunch of tier 7 and possibly 8 that are going to have stronger AA.

but yeah.. i'm learning which ships to avoid and have gotten a lot of good tips from this thread.. so onward I suppose.

1
jonasnee"unicum" is not an insult•

the independence was 1 of my favorite grinds, i ended it with 72% winrate.

i think this is a L2P problem if i am totally honest.

3
ApkohaOP•

i'm at a 60% wr.. it's still a garbage ship.. especially when you constantly get matched with majority of Tier 7 and 8 ships .. Not going to "l2p" you're way out of ships that are higher and built to deal with CVs of their tiers. .. well I mean.. i'm sure you're a MLG pro and would have no problem using the Langley against tier 10.. but the rest of us mortals might find it a tad difficult especially stuck with a sub 11+ point captain.

-1
LineCutter•
2
Vectoranalysis•

With out clicking the link: Fara's guide?

1
LineCutter•

Farra's guide episode on playing CV as bottom tier - which is where Independence gets hosed against T8 AA (as does Ryujo to be fair)

1
ApkohaOP•

I will.. thank you.

1
hansjcScharnhorst best bote•

Independence seemed fine to me, only thing that should give you trouble is AS Ryujo, which in my experience, wasn't that common.

good luck at Tier 7 though, Ranger against Saipan is a turkey shoot.

2
Kin-LuuFly, my pretties!•

IMHO the matchup against Kaga is even worse.

1
Lord-PrometheusKronshtadt•

Kaga has tier 6 planes, though. Saipan has tanky tier 9 planes that don’t die unless you get a real lucky strafe.

2
Kin-LuuFly, my pretties!•

But Ranger can at least try to outdamage Saipan. With a maximum of six torpedoes in the water, Saipans damage potential is quite limited. A Ranger needs to pull of one or two good strikes and it will have done almost as much as Saipan has during the whole game.

Kaga outdamages Ranger without breaking a sweat. It also has better fighters and much, much larger reserves.

If you compare the stats of the T7 CVs, Kaga easily pulls ahead of all others, including Saipan.

1
Peo01•

It also has better fighters

Ranger can front strafe Hiryu fighters and take out more than half of the planes, more if the Hiryu player for some reason didn't pick the plane health increasing modules/skills.

Kaga's fighters don't even get that treatment, a single strafe blows them out of the skies, thus giving Ranger's fighters a lot of staying power.

The rest is just about spotting Kaga's TBs and depending on enemy AA in that area either just blocking them or flying straight into the fray... it's not like Kaga's fighters can dare to oppose her.

Of course a capable Kaga player usually brings an AA cruiser with him to mitigate this but he's still at a major disadvantage when it comes to actually engaging over neutral or less saturated air space, hence limiting his options greatly.

Nevermind that most of Kaga's damage potential comes from the vast majority of players still just hard turn into a single direction when the planes are only about half a kilometer out, making it easy for any CV to murder them...

2
Lord-PrometheusKronshtadt•

I thought we were strictly talking about fighter power though.

1
DarzokClosed Beta Player•

I disagree you can fight off a Kaga hard but can be done Saipan will go that is cute and walk all over you.

2
ApkohaOP•

don't make me sad :(

1
DarzokClosed Beta Player•

Its not a great CV but its not worthless but the lack of planes and the fact you end up fighting T7-8 ships can make it highly annoying to play.

2
ApkohaOP•

I think that is what my issue was tonight and what got me so salty.. I don't know what it was but just 4 games in a row my planes were instantly getting shredded if I tried to approach anything but a DD and got me salty AF.

1
DarzokClosed Beta Player•

It will not get better with the Ranger planes last longer and you have a few more but you fight Saipans.

1
misc1444•

I thought the Ryujo vs Indy matchup was relatively balanced. In any case, it's nowhere near as bad as Shokaku vs Lexington (or Saipan/Enterprise vs silver CV).

2
FumiKanePersonally I prefer the air•

Indy is barely ok, she could use some hangar buffs because you can make mistakes in Ryujou and still be able to fight back but making a mistake in the Independence means you will be at a BIG disadvantage for the whole game, specially regarding fighters because you can literally fully enjoy AS (skill) for one full sortie, if you get whiped out you wont have another 7 plane squad.

With the increase on AA, the presence of 311 Ryujou and the fact many players are still learning manual drops at this tier should make the ship more forgiving to play, give her a capacity of 45-46, should be enough to give 2 full replendishes and 3 extra planes per squad, much more forgiving.

2
kebobs22o7•

Indy requires you to be careful where you fly your planes due to low hangar but at t6 its not about the cv, but who is playing it when it comes to strength. Both indep and Ryujo are extremely strong in good hands.

2
ApkohaOP•

Yeah, that is what I'm learning. My initially saltiness was .. well Salty because I had gotten out of my 4th game in a row deletion that I wanted to vent... but I've gotten a lot of good tips and insight on how to play it and the upper tiers a bit better.

2
Auzor•

Indie could definitely use a hangar upgrade.

1
Der-Kleine(IGN: DerKleine [OM]) - Ask me anything about Defensive Fire•

Sounds like a player issue to me (these are solo stats)

0
ApkohaOP•

well seeing as I'm sitting at a 60% WR with it.. I say NAH.. and i'm sure if I was using a better captain i'd probably have closer to yours.. it's still a fucking garbage CV with garbage planes.

-1
StringfelowHawke•

CV mechanics have demolished the quality and enjoyment of play for this entire game. Do yourself and this community a favor and depart from CV’s altogether.

-2
ExCaedibusCarrier•

They haven’t „demolished“ anything that was not „demolished“ before, they were in the game since the beginning, so probably longer than you. If anything, their „demolishing“ has been reduced since then. Please stop spreading prepubescent fatalism to those who want to address their issue constructively.

2
StringfelowHawke•

Yeah sure. “Constructively.” You mean like fixing CV mechanics and game play...by hosing the UI even further then releasing 3 broken premium CV’s? One of which was so broken they had to retract it?

0
ExCaedibusCarrier•

No, please read again. „Constructively“ like being a player who wants to make the best out of the situation instead of whining and ruining other‘s motivation.

1