Hey Reddit - Samsung gave me 24 new SSD drives to play with. Want to see what I did?
Posted Mar 9, 2009, 9:53 AM UTC
Posted Mar 9, 2009, 9:53 AM UTC
This is so geeky, I think it just un-lost my virginity.
So it gave it back? Speak properly!
Nobody thinks you're funny.
What the shit are you talking about? "Un-lose" isn't even a word or a phrase!
That's why it's funny.
What the shit are you talking about? This is the internet, everything's a word and a phrase at the same time!
That commercial was fun!
Oh - they were trying to sell me something? I didn't notice that - I just went straight out and bought all this samsung shit. Damn - have I been conned?
Its okay Adverts help me think and buy stuff. Without them I'm not capable of thought.
because its got electrolytes?
plus its formulated with a correct balance of nice and lovely.
excellent refference
it was a commercial, but the product is so expensive and that kind of performance is so pointless (for most people, MySQL and fileservers might actually like that) that the entertainment factor is probably higher than the 'look at what SSDs can do' factor
I mean, if you need that kind of performance you were probably already looking at SSDs and using it in RAID 0 would probably not be on your list of things you want to do
And I don't see anyone ever actually 'using' 24 SSDs with that motherboard
Still really awesome
Branding. I wish I could be bothered to link to a definition - but I don't want to perpetuate this commercial crap on a site I once loved.
Exactly. Yes, the people who need that kind of performance are already looking at SSDs, but are they looking at Samsung SSDs ??
Well, it's too expensive today. Maybe in a year or two the price (of one drive) will drop to reasonable levels.
Then i'll RAID5 them. Oh yes.
(Fucking commercials, man.)
On the upside, they said that they got no better performance with 24 over 21 of them... so, in theory, with a good controller, RAID 5 should work perfectly fine
Of course you would need the slots on the motherboard to support 2 RAID cards plus enough CPU/memory to actually make that kind of performance worth the time and energy... the SSDs would only be the start of the funds required to actually make 2 GB/sec 'worth it'
To be honest, even 1/2 GB/sec would be a ridiculous upgrade over what i'm using now and that should be completely doable with 5 of these. (I've got a single SATA at 7500 rpm right now. A clever one, but still.)
Wait two years (or X years, however many), buy five of them when they're $100 each, then buy a reasonable RAID controller and go craaaaaaaaaaazy.
that kind of performance is so pointless
You don't have much of an imagination, do you.
I didn't even know I needed that stuff until I saw the ad!
i was expecting to see a video of you putting them all on ebay
I like that.
I was expecting you to put them in domino array.
[deleted]
Wow. So he was just bouncing on a trampoline with ~$25k worth of SDD!?!?
It seemed like a good idea at the time. And I got to buy a trampoline! :D
First comment of the thread that made me laugh aloud. A question though... what exactly is it that you do for samsung to send you 24 drives and jump on trampolines with them?
They make a commercial for them :)
fucks them up the butt with a huge reddit post
How much of what they did in the video depends on it being a raid array and not a single comparatively cheap drive? Would a single solid state drive still give you the incredible load time performance? (Obviously you wouldn't get anything close to the throughput, but I was impressed by the 40 program load.)
uhhh dell has a 256GB samsung for like 250$ upgrade so its not that bad.
Oh that was just super.
Tell me, could you recommend any of Samsung's other products and services?
They make some pretty awesome ships, but that's not important right now.
I bought one of their ships and I always had problems docking it.
You probably need to update the driver.
And they're so non-user friendly, you have to be trained just to use the damn things!
I can't find the add to cart button... o well, they just lost another 2% market share.
I've got an oil platform that's just sitting out in the middle of the ocean not doing too much right now. Wanna swap?
I think cr3 has won the Internet with this entire thread. Over cynical redditors have been trying their damnedest to break his resolve and admit he is a marketing flunkie for Samsung, and instead he has destroyed every attack.
Bravo my British comrade!
You need a thick skin on this internet thing.
Well, he obviously is. But it's an interesting article and I'd be looking at the same article even if it didn't have "I <3 samsung" all over it. So more power to him.
Besides, the best adverts are entertaining enough to watch on their own merit.
Right, because no one can see through this. In a year these drives will be going for a buck and a quarter each, but right now Samsung is selling them for $1,100 a pop. But he's not a marketing guy and this is not a ploy.
Right at the start of the video it says he works for a marketing company and that they are trying to do something exciting for the drives. He did.
He IS a marketing guy, this IS a ploy, and it is an AWESOME ploy.
There's nothing inherently wrong with marketing - stop thinking that it's cool to hate 'the man' just for the sake of it. There is something wrong with certain forms of marketing, to be sure, but this isn't one of those.
Gee, somehow I missed how he "destroyed every attack," in fact, I haven't seen him directly respond to a single one. He might start by answering my question, how much did Samsung pay for this project?
What a great response!
Samsung make Oil Rigs?
wtf! looking at the website looks as though I was playing an RTS. lol
Trampoline with /that/!
[deleted]
Damn Samsung, you scary!
http://www.secc.co.kr/e_secc/products/highrise.html
They also make pretty decent buildings if you are in the market for buildings that are 100 floors or higher
They have awesome phones, tvs, monitors and conventional hard disks(f1 series).
Which Internet PR company did this?
Born in 1989? Wow, I feel under-accomplished now.
Wow, I -really- need to update my portfolio. 2008 was quite a while ago now and I've done loads of shiny things since then. I reckon this campaign will be making an appearance!
I don't know but it was well done. Not too cheesy and didn't try too hard.
Complete awesomeness. But why does YouTube then recommend this video to me next?
Maury: Sex for a CHEESEBURGER! / 16 y/o Stabs People
Both about paying a lot for something you don't need.
YOU TOO!?!?! I had to watch that, and all I could think about was Cartman: Bitch, I'll do what I want. I'll do what I want. What-eva, what-eva, I'll do what I want.
[deleted]
Did you, ah, look at the rest of the build? There were an awful lot of cores.
Why the down vote? He is right.. drives are the bottleneck of most, if not all, systems.
Because he may be right on the most basic level, but it's not the whole story. The drive is only the bottleneck when it comes to seek and transfer time, finding the file. Once you find the file, you still have to do things with it. As eatadonut said, note that he also used two quad core processors, two ATI 4870HD's in crossfire config, and 4 gigs of 800mhz RAM. That is a fast system powering those drives, and you couldn't have done the same thing with a Pentium 4.
Where he's wrong is there's no 'one' bottleneck here. Intel isn't lying when the say the processor is the most key part of the system, it is. And they're not the only ones saying that, ask any computer scientist or engineer. It's silly to propose this is some kind of "Intel conspiracy", it's common fact.
Yes, SSDs speed things up when it comes to finding a file, but for any application where you have to actually process the data, the CPU is always the bottleneck.
File transfer, defrag = good demonstration of a SSD's speed. A HDD is the bottleneck here.
Playing Crysis, decoding/encoding video = bad demonstration of an SSD's speed.
Just gonna say, strictly speaking, you're wrong. Unless your processor has massive L1 or L2 caches, or you are doing computation on small sets of data, memory is the bottle neck. And if you have to do computation on more data than will fit into the page cache, disk is the bottleneck. The processor sits idle for millions upon millions of cycles waiting for even 800mhz RAM to spit out its bits, and trillions of cycles waiting for disk reads. This is why console systems can run the same games as desktop pc's but with seemingly underpowered chips: they have expensive, fast memory.
trillions of cycles spent on disk reads?
1 Trillion cycles at 1 Ghz = 1000 seconds.
You may want to stop by your local Walmart and upgrade to an eMachine.
The CPUs they used (2x QX9775s) have 12MB L2 caches. That is huge.
Also, for the post you replied to, they used 2 HD 4870X2s in Crossfire, not the standard HD 4870.
I was always under the impression that software is designed to work well with the hardware on the market, and that hardware is designed to work well with the software on the market. So why would there be ANY bottleneck? If the CPU in my computer is a bottleneck, why wouldn't the manufacturer have chosen a more expensive CPU and a less expensive HDD or set of memory?
639 comments and you're the only one to mention the page cache. Sad.
You've obviously never met Mr Oracle. I/O is the killer in most large databases.
The drive is only the bottleneck when it comes to seek and transfer time, finding the file.
What do DBs do the most? Find and retrieve files. Of course I/O is the bottleneck in large database systems. When you're talking about personal computers and most servers, however, the CPU is likely the primary bottleneck (assuming sufficient bandwidth).
Write speeds are horrible, no better than a traditional HD or so the Internet says.
Intel isn't lying when the say the processor is the most key part of the system, it is.
How much of a bottleneck the processor is really depends upon the task. Some tasks are very processor intensive and wouldn't benefit much from a SSD RAID like this while others would see clear benefits.
So pretty much exactly what I said in the very next paragraph?
Yes, SSDs speed things up when it comes to finding a file, but for any application where you have to actually process the data, the CPU is always the bottleneck.
File transfer, defrag = good demonstration of a SSD's speed. A HDD is the bottleneck here.
Playing Crysis, decoding/encoding video = bad demonstration of an SSD's speed.
Memory latency is still considered the major bottleneck in computing by professionals. It simply takes too long to go to and from the ram -- think ping time on a much smaller scale. And memory latency, unlike drive access speed, affects nearly every operation you do on your computer. Programmers that know how to work well the cpu cache (thereby reducing memory access) are able to attain dramatically faster code — but the cache is only so big.
Yes. For a long time I've been urging people to get more RAM when their computers seem slow. CPUs have been able to keep up with the demands of Word and Excel for years now. The slowdown is always caused because the system is swapping.
most hardware has greatly increased it's performance over the years. hard drives haven't
[deleted]
[deleted]
Defrag SSD == BAD!!!
How come?
readies geek flame shield
SSD are random access, as is RAM (Random Access Memory). Performance isn't inhibited by it not being in sequential order like HDD.
That still doesn't cover why it's bad, only why it's useless. Presumably the OP thinks it bad because SSDs have limited read/writes. They do, this is true, but even with continuous reading/writing 24/7 modern drives will still last something like 3 years, and with normal usage should crack 20.
Three years is the estimated lifespan with normal use. There's an exact number of reads SSD can do before it starts to malfunction and constant use would reach it very quickly.
A Hard Drive is random access too, tape drives are not.
You're right but I said sequential order, not sequential access. I should have said HDD aren't inhibited by fragmented data.
So I should stop creating a tmpfs, defraging and unmounting then?
Except that on these SSD's, performance actually is inhibited by it not being in sequential order.
2 main points. As ULJared said, it's unnecessary - flash memory has 0 seek time, which is the main delay on physical disks when a file is fragmented (it has to move the read head all over the place, rather than just sit it in one place and read a track, and the time it's moving is time that's wasted for reading data).
The other is that it is potentially harmful to the disk. Flash memory has limited read write cycles, so defragging adds a lot of unnecessary wear.
There still is a seek time, but the seek time is typically less than 1% of that of a HDD and hence the benefits of defragmentation are far greater than they are on an SSD. In theory if you had enough fragments defragging the file system could make a measurable difference, but the degree of fragmentation is so high it would be almost academic.
The bigger concern is that the additional read cycles would cause a lot of unnecessary wear leading to premature failure of the drive.
1
...so, was that Crysis at full resolution?
I'm not a gamer, but isn't that like solving Fermat's Last Theorem?
You're right; this video is obviously fake then. ;)
Nawwe, it still looked about 20 fps. He only had, what, four video cards in there?
[deleted]
But will it run Crysis? oh wait nm
[deleted]
Someone knows how to advertise to reddit! Kudos!
Hope you sell tons.
I want to grill one in butter
I should go out and buy some of those SSD drives with money from an ATM machine.
...I know, I know, I'm sorry.
Try not to forget your PIN number.
I was hoping someone would say that :)
I LOLed out loud at that.
I don't get it...
SSD = Solid State Drives
ATM = Automatic Teller Machine
Does it make sense now? I could just say that it is being redundantly redundant.
edit:I can never make things appear on multiple lines, how the bugger do you do that?
edit2: nevermind, I think i jsut figured it out.
Right I knew the abbreviations immediately, I just didn't find it funny :|
SSD = Solid State Drive
i hope you get an HIV Virus.
/jk
What was the best bit about it - how far did you push it?
Plus any crashes?
We pushed it to the max and then some - and managed to kill a Skulltrail motherboard along with a 1000 watt power supply. After getting a new motherboard, I soldered two 1000 watt power supplies together (well, connected their power_on line and gave them common ground). Cards and drives were powered by one, motherboard and processors by the other.
I measured the total wattage output under load; without drives, it was about 1400W, and with the 24 drives, about 1500W - remarkably efficent devices!
The only problem we faced was the blu-ray drives not playing well with Vista at all in AHCI mode, but that was just a bit of driver hell. The SSDs were rock solid. :D
As for crashes, we had a few while overclocking for the fun of it, but at stock levels everything was stable as a rock. We got the QX9775's to 3.6ghz (*8 cores) happily, but they got a bit... wobbly, any higher. We peaked at 4ghz per core, and then got scared to push it any further because of the price of the chips and the fact we weren't done filming. :D
Did you try other operating systems?
No time to be stuck in any form of driver hell, to be honest with you. I had 24 hours to build it and optimise it. Very tight deadline.
I wanted to test Windows 7 on it to see how it performed in the new Windows Benchmark scores (they go to something like 7.9 rather than 5.9 now), but there was no time. After that, it would have been Ubuntu or similar. Shame :)
[deleted]
I say you did a good job, that computer did the impossible, it ran Crysis.
4*8=32
...suddenly my little 1.83 macbook feels small and insignificant
While it's theoretically 32 GHz, there's still the issue of shared memory and communication time between the cores. You won't actually get 8x the performance of a single 4 GHz core.
But yes, your 1.83 macbook is very small and insignificant :)
nerdy awesomeness
nerd pr0n
I thought there was real pr0n when I saw /TeenGirl during the defrag. Then I saw it said left4dead/scenes/TeenGirl. Plus the real pr0n is in the "BusinessTime" folder.
this is like amateur bdsm porn... for geeks
I'm sitting here drooling "WANT WANT WANT" and wondering how I can get the parts delivered without the wife smelling a rat.
Option a) if you have friends, get them wrapped and say it's a gift
Option b) if you don't have friends, get them wrapped and say it's a gift from yourself to make you feel better for not having friends (better because you get pity sex :)
Reminds me of coming across the term WAF, wife (spouse) acceptance factor, last year. What a great term.
Yeah, that is a great term. I think 24 SSDs and the associated gear to run them is likely to have a vanishingly low WAF.
Tell us a little about yourself (educational things, personal things, a few life stories, etc. etc. =).
I'm mainly curious how you were "chosen" for a marketing task such as this... I would usually assume that a large company would pass over such commercial tasks to big-psychologically-inclined ad-companies that do years of research before rolling out a commercial -- but the Samsung guys just went ahead and gave you 24 new SSD drives just like that?
Good question, should probably post it as a reply to one of his comments, instead of as a top level comment.
That said, I'll take some guesses on it...
It's safe to assume that he, or at least his company, have some credibility (ie: Samsung trusted them at least a little).
The risk to Samsung is relatively low - they didn't 'give' them the drives, they just loaned them for a day. Approx cost of all drives was around $25k (based on other comments here), they're solid state, so they're not likely to die. Even if they managed to kill a couple, the real risk to Samsung is probably around $4k.
Big ad companies can be extremely clever, and very effective, but they aren't geeks. This guy is clearly a geek, and was able to do a presentation that would impress other geeks in a way that a traditional ad company could never pull off (or even think of).
He's real and works for B3ta by the looks of it.
No doubt he's real, and his ad worked. Now I just need to find $25k somewhere (ok, more like $6k, I'd be happy with 1 TB).
duh
The array came to 6TB in size all in all, and was split over 2 RAID arrays and all the onboard motherboard SATA ports. The wiring was an absolute headache. I'll be happy to answer any questions you have about it :)
can I borrow it?
Unfortunately, all the drives are back with Samsung in Korea, as they were engineering samples - which is a bit of a shame really. It's like having a F1 car with no engine. I might put 24 standard drives in RAID just to pretend it's still with me.
A comparison might be interesting ..
Make it so.
yeah, really. I can't help thinking that a good heap of that machine's power came from the cpu/ram.
Given the tested max throughput of the Hitachi 1TB SATAs (http://www.storagereview.com/Testbed4Compare.sr) you should be able to get ~2GBps with 2/3 the drives (16 instead of 24) and near triple the storage space (16TB instead of 6TB). That's just theory, though. It would probably be difficult to get all drives "bursting" at the same time but anyway, with a little work...
Did it ever occure to perform some real tests, say oracle DB, or things like that?
I'm skeptical opening things from the start menu has any real impact. I mean, many of those things could be in the compute/time domain, not the I/O0-wait domain of problems.
Same could be said of crysis.
a better test might have been to use the same controler cards in normal hardware.
well, given that both seek time and throughput are vastly improved over traditional drives, I'd say it's pretty certain that if top says you're spending any time in iowait that SSDs will improve performance for you.
running something like oracle would have punished the ram more than the drives, unless he purposely put the index on disk.
But yes, there wasn't a lot that showed the write throughput in the video. How big was the on-drive cache on each drive? What is the result x 24?
You'll transfer that much "for free", before slowing down.
Given a proper setup, there is no reason a well-tuned ssd couldn't return a fragmented file nearly as fast as one that is all in one piece. (especially a large file)
From now on I can read your comments in your voice!
Hahaha oh noooo! People say my accent is quite strong, but hopefully it's nice/comical. :)
im sure the thing is still mighty fast with the dual quad core CPUs and the dual 4870x2. I'm pretty happy with my Q8200 and my 4830 :) fast enough for me even with my failed overclocking attempts. Wish I could get my hands on a core i7 system though.
I would probably have used i7 if I did it again, but the project started before i7 was properly established (December of last year). Still, dual QX9775 was scary as heck due to the price of those processors - shaky hands...
The dual graphics kicked out more heat than the sun.
24 USB thumbdrives!
Much more affordable, but the wrong interface.
seeing as my dad works for western digital can you please break all those drives asap?
SSD look good but according to all the research and market analysis from WD, harddrives are here to stay for a long time. SSD's might be able to take over the notebook market, but Harddrive technology is very old and well known. They will be able to revamp it to compete with whatever SSD tech comes out for the next 10 years or so very easily.
I don't know why you're getting downmodded. Even the beloved Intel X25-M has its performance issues.
The SSD won't vanquish magnetic/mechanical storage until they get a rewritable medium with unlimited rewrite cycles. And that probably won't be Flash memory.
And just a point of reference here: My Mac Pro with 3x Velociraptors gets 440MB/s throughput. Extrapolate that to 15 Velociraptors, and I've beaten this SSD array performance-wise at a fraction of the cost.
[deleted]
More like a F1 car with no gas tank
FTFY
[deleted]
I've been on reddit for about a year now, and it's really me! I work in IT support for a marketing company, the video speaks the truth. :)
commercial or no, it wouldn't be here if it wasn't freaking amazing
Will it blend?
fork over the 25,000 it costs and you'll find out!
Plus the $400/800 for the freaking Blendtec blender
I swear to god though, I will buy one of those when I get the money and I will make EVERYTHING.
I'd bet it was around $10k, all new.
I was expecting to see a video like that but this was much more impressive.
For some reason I never found this meme funny. Probably because it's just one big advertisement, done cleverly no doubt, but still an advertisement.
OOOHHH GOOD FOR YOU!
--Christian Bale
I don't think you realize the gravity of your achievement. After reading Christian Bale I knew exactly what that comment sounded like and I felt like I was getting shouted at. You have actually shouted at me over the internet. Not just some lame caps, I actually heard shouting.
[deleted]
Yeah, well so is this lame Samsung-sponsored viral video attempt.
Yeah, but I have no idea what it was for, so it wasn't a very good advertisement. I've watched at least 5 of those videos.
They're.. ads for the blenders.
whered you get the balls to play dominoes with 25k worth of hard drives?
I was a little more nervous while trampolining with them, to be honest.
No matter how well I understood that those were solid state drives, I still had a minor heart attack when you started bouncing.
NOOOOOOOOOOO...oh..wait..that's right.
I was only concerned the cables would come loose. It takes a lot of Gs to knock off a surface mount component that weighs a fraction of a gram, though, and that's what you'd have to do to physically damage it.
hhe, that was almost exactly my reaction
I thought you were going to throw them on the floor at that point. I feared for them.
They're solid state (SSD) = no moving parts.
no shit, but i wouldnt play dominoes with anything worth 25k, even if they were rocks
or dominoes.
[deleted]
How fast did windows start?
The Skulltrail motherboard has a notoriously long startup time - about a minute before it'll attempt to boot to any operating system.
Once the motherboard was done initialising, it'd get to a fully usable desktop in about 5 or 6 seconds.
Talking about Windows, had you considered another OS to find out which one was responding the best? Nerdy nerd being nerdy and all that.
As I mentioned down below, I only had 24 hours to get everything working, which would have been tight for optimising Linux properly and getting everything working. I had considered Gentoo or something similar which builds itself perfectly to the hardware, but as I couldn't fully research compatibility assurance, it had to be Windows. Given more time, I would have installed other OS's, just to see if I could inch out any more performance. :)
No no! Showing a fast Windows Vista is much more impressive. With Linux, before you know it, someone runs the same demo in 4k on a 386.
I don't have the motherboard you speak of, but with my ANS-9010B I was getting to a fully-loaded XP desktop in 9 seconds and I would argue that the only limitation was my motherboard. I'm fairly confident with a more modern mb and cpu I could get a boot time of 5 or less seconds as the transfer rate was locked at SATA-II speeds. A SATA-III connection might be able to load in just two seconds.
I bought mine here: (There's cheaper places but mwave was fast and reliable) http://www.mwave.com/mwave/SkuSearch_v2.asp?SCriteria=AA74662
I'm honestly very curious to see this benchmarked, my own testing indicated that it blows even the top rated SSDs out of the water. It was easily double the fastest drive in Sandra, anyway.
Why did you download the george bush speeches?
I needed a lot of files that weren't just entirely 1's or 0's. You know, random garbage.
...
Ones and zeros everywhere! And I think I saw a two...
*facepalm*
I meant contiguous! Honest!
Haha, random garbage. It's funny because it's true. On an unrelated note, I like your hair.
Hahaha - thank you! I have to redye it soon. Just so you know.
Err, why? Unless you do a secure delete (and you didn't say you were doing a secure delete), deleting files takes time based on the number of files, not the size or contents.
It was all a very complex and risky setup for this pun thread.
ba-dump-bump ting
well, i guess i'll upvote you, because you appear to be pandering to every reddit whim. seriously, dont be a syncophant.
really nice video though. we like fun videos with lots of hardware involved
[deleted]
Indeed, where did you get the GWB speeches from?
Commercial sound archive. You can buy packs of things like that quite easily, and as it's all public domain, you only really pay them for their time collating them.
How did you connect the two power supply units together? :O
It's fairly easy!
Locate pin 14 on both (e)ATX bundles, and solder the wire attached to the motherboard with the wire attached to the "slave" power supply. When the motherboard tells the power supply to activate, the signal now goes to both. It's usually green, and is PS_ON (Power Supply On), carrying a tiny current.
I also soldered a few ground wires together to make sure they shared a common ground, as that could have caused some unexpected problems.
You can also buy a cable that does this for you. Looks like an odd 14-pin Y-cable that only has two wires connected to one of the connectors...
Soldering makes me feel geeky and special. It's also a bit more compact; as you can imagine, there wasn't much breathing space for wires, even in a case that large.
is it possible to use such a cable as a poor man's redundant power supply? by connecting two ATX power supplies together with a Y cable, if one powers off or fails, I wonder if the other power supply would be able to maintain a constant supply... I don't know enough about the electronic circuits involved here, but it sounds risky and dangerous.. and I like risky and dangerous, with most things, but not when it comes to my motherboards.. I wonder if someone makes a Y-connector with a protection/failover circuit, to facilitate this connection between two (or more) ATX power supplies. Any info is appreciated.
Good catch on the grounding...
Heh - thanks! Growing up in a family of electrical engineers pays off sometimes.
I would have been afraid that driving 2 outputs would keep it from working. I guess the motherboard supplies at least twice the power necessary to that wire.
It wouldn't make any sense otherwise.
the motherboard doesn't actually supply any power to the power supply. you can turn on a power supply just by shorting the green wire to ground.
Did they pay you to create Viral Marketing? was it a lot?
As the first 5 seconds of the video state, I work as the IT guy for a marketing company who were approached by Samsung. As for budget, I don't know; I'm just the office nerd. I did get a week off my usual tech support to film it, though! Sorry for the boring answer. :)
Kudos for honesty...
and hopefully you get a neat bonus. You reached Nr.1 in Web2.0
sincere Congrats!
Ah, wow. I thought that whole line was just a story to feed us. Good job on doing something more interesting than whatever the marketing types were going to do :)
They sent the drives back, but what did they do with everything else?
It's sitting out the back as an empty shell until I find a better use for such an awesome machine. It's lacking any bootable drives at the moment, of course.
I watched 5 seconds of the video and came here to ask that very question. It's true, it does state up front that it's a marketing company. Hard to believe so many people are into supporting that kind of thing.
Ultimately something cool was done. Who cares who did it or why?
There was nothing fake or manufactured about this, just neat.
You are the dream come true of every Marketer and spammer out there.
I couldn't care less for 6TiB, but awesome soundtrack is awesome.
Dancing to the ska beat
The tune was done by MJ Hibbett who is generally awesome. I found him through some work he did for b3ta, which I help run. :)
and we love you for it.
:)
Ahhh, I knew you were b3tan! I can smell it.
oh yay! that makes the story so much better... MJ Hibbett rocks.
Can I have this skank?
Can I have a job please?
How good is your tea?
Amazing. Trial run?
Speed test! Do you countenance black tea steeped at high altitude? What use is a young pu-erh? Do you make cream of tea after the Sung dynastic tradition? Does pouchong have any place in the modern pantheon of teas?
I was making a joke, but now I want someone to talk to about these things. My life is sad.
Don't squeeze the bag man!
My tea produces multiple orgasms.
I believe it.
mmm, poppies
I must've missed something, because it looked like you moved the DVD rip intra-volume, which isn't that impressive (just repoints the pointer)?
[edit] but everything else was fucking awesome!
I copied it across the two RAID cards. We had two cards very high performance cards in there, but even so, both were maxed out by the drives. I ran out of budget to buy more cards. :(
The copy was from 12 drives to 12 others, if that makes sense. It wasn't moving on the same drive, because as you say, that would have been instant.
That was a copy, not a move!
I was under the impression that Flash ram allowed for super fast reads but that write speeds were worse than traditional HDDs. This video says that write speeds were fast as well. How come?
There are two answers to this, and I'm not sure which is more correct. Choose either.
Any sufficiently advanced technology . . .
If the controller was limiting performance, how much speed would be lost if you took a metric shit-load of HDD's and shoved them in RAID instead?
Considerable. An average laptop HDD (these were laptop-sized SSDs) goes at about 60 MB/s read when I tested mine. 220 MB/s is quite a step up - also seek latency is 0.1ms instead of about 8ms on a HDD.
FTFY
Flash is fine if you're writing nice big sequential streams; they're not so hot when you're doing lots of small writes dotted about the place. The problem is, you can only efficiently set Flash one way; i.e. you can flip one bit from 0 to 1 cheaply, but to flip it back to 0 involves performing an erase operation on not only the bit you want, but also maybe a million others in the same cell. Intel call this "write amplification", because a dinky little 512 byte write can end up erasing and rewriting hundreds of KB.
This is the primary reason everyone loves Intel's new SSD's; they can significantly reduce the effects of write amplification by batching writes together into the same pre-erased cells regardless of the logical layout of the data.
Seeing as how I'm no where near as clever as others out there, I would imagine others have already thought of this idea, but if writing a one takes less time than writing a zero might it be worth while to use an algorithm that encodes zeros AS ones? Obviously, you would still need to write zeros every now and then, but does an algorithm exists that could turn a stream that was 50/50 ones and zeros into one that was, say, 75/25 ones and zeros?
Yes, it would probably take up more space, but the time saving might be worth it.
Umm, no. When writing a file, "writing" zeros and ones takes the same time. (as in, writing a block of data that has 4095 zeros and a single one takes the same time as writing a block with 4095 ones and a single zero) The problem is that once you have written to a location once, you have to erase the entire eraseblock, which is usually 128kB. If you need the space, and no eraseblock is entirely garbage, (so you have not enough free space, some live data on all blocks, and most of a block is old, "expired" data) you have to first garbage-collect the free space by copying all the live stuff from one block then erase it in entirety.
Not really. For a fixed length encoding (N bits raw -> M bits encoded), obviously, you still need to convey the same information. That means there need to be 2^N distinct states among those M bits. And the only way to generate a distinct state is to have some bits different to other bits - we'd still need N bits to be zeroable so all we've done is stick an arbitrary number of 1's in front.
Variable length encoding is even worse - you could for instance encode things using a run of 1's such. eg 00 -> 0, 01 -> 10, 10 -> 110, 11 -> 1110, for a 60% 1, 40% 0 encoding, but look what happens if you try to change a bit. Because the sizes differ, you also have to change every bit afterwards. Even if we ignore that, note that our whole problem is in changing a bit - the chance that we'd have to replace a 0 with a 1 isn't really any different.
There are some circumstances where optimizations could be made, but they'd need to be situations where the pattern of change is known about. For example, Grey codes are a different way of representing numbers which ensure that only one bit needs to be toggled to increment a number. If you had a similar situation on disk (eg. some kind of version counter), you could choose a coding that involved setting bits most of the time, and then occassionally zeroing a lot. eg a 3 bit counter could be implemented as: 000, 001, 011, 111, 100, 101, 010, 110 (bold indicates zeroing bits). This only zeroes bits on incrementing 25% of the time. Without such knowledge as to how the data will change though, this can't be done. In practice, there aren't likely to be situations where this pays off.
Actually, thinking about this a bit more, there may be a way to accomplish something similar, though rather expensively.
You could expand every bit to N bits on the media, with all bits initially 0, except the last one, which should be 0 or 1 depending on the value. When clearing bits, rather than overwriting, the next bit up could be set to indicate flipping the meaning, allowing for up to N switches of state (N-1 if start at 1).
eg. using 4 bits:
Its pretty inefficient, especially since any bit being toggled more than N times in the block requires a rewrite (so writing to the same place lots of times means all that redundancy in the rest of the block is wasted) but should work. When a rewrite is required you could normalise the whole block however.
Or: EasyCo MFT to the rescue! ;)
I just thought about this some more. If write operations are slow because erase operations are expensive, then it's best to avoid write operations altogether. How can that be done? Well, simply include ordinary RAM in your SSD drive, either as a large cache or even match the amount of solid state memory 1:1 with RAM, i.e. one MB RAM for each MB solid state memory. Then you could just include one or several sufficiently large capacitors in the SDD drive package. The result: Most of the time you could work entirely in RAM, but once power is withdrawn because the device is unplugged or the computer is switched off or sent to power saving mode, there would be enough juice left in the capacitor(s) for the SDD drive's on-board logic to detect the blackout and write the RAM contents to the actual solid state memory.
It's the same thing as having a RAM disk on a computer with a UPS and writing the RAM disk contents to a permanent storage medium once power is lost. The only difference is that here the RAM, solid state memory, capacitor and control logic would all be in the SSD drive package, and the user need never know that this is going on behind the scenes.
Come to think of it, I would be surprised if this wasn't currently being done.
Any idea when the G3 drives will actually be available? I've been waiting to purchase one since Samsung had their first press release about it.
Edit: Correction, the G3 drives are SanDisk
Edit2: SanDisk is supposed to release the G3 drives mid-2009
i noticed two zalman 9700's were used for cooling, one would go on the CPU, what was the other used for?
There were two QX9775 processors in it. Eight cores!
Awesome campaign. I'll seriously consider buying one of those when they're available. I genuinely hope you'll get a few of those as a bonus for coming up with the idea.
Is this the first commercial you've ever done?
Yep! I'm not very photogenic, but I can do nerding fairly well.
You've set a standard for nerding that few, if any, could ever live up to. I'm subscribing to your newsletter.
I know this is a catchphrase, but from elsewhere in the thread...
b3ta have a newsletter :)
Don't actually know many nerds, do you?
How much did it all cost?
It was all stock hardware, there's a parts list on the end if you want to calculate it with current prices. According to the microsite, they're still OEM only, so.. dunno. :)
[deleted]
If I wait 10 years will my phone be faster?
Erm, interesting question. I'm going to go with "yes", because 10 years is ages in 'tech time', and it may or may not have anything to do with SSDs.
It may likely deal with them for a short period of time until bandwidth is commonly wide enough with high coverage for ease of remote storage.
I have my doubts unless it is one expensive phone or there is a enormous revolution in storage technology. What value would there be in being able to move GB/sec on a phone?
Just wait.
Was there any mirroring?
No; both were in RAID0.
You said you used 2 cards and all of the motherboard ports. How exactly was the raid setup? Was it software raid and the controllers were just SATA ports on a PCI board?
Check the end of the video for exact details (there's proposed, midway and final configurations). I used 2 PCIe RAID cards, and the throughput test combined both controllers with the onboard ports too. :)
Do you think speed/thouroughput would have been affected if you did RAID1 (3 TB mirrored) or RAID5 (4 groups of 3 drives, 500GB per group- I think)?
Probably, as things like that would change the IOPS which would affect controller performance.
Bleh. Try a database setup at some point. So in your case, pair up drives in mirrors, and then stripe over the whole array.
Then go run some true disk benchmarking applications to figure out the IOPs in random read/write applications. :)
I'd love to do this if I had the chance again. At the moment, these drives are perfect for high-availability/high-speed database usage due to their speed.. and, well, the fact that people with databases that needy probably have enough money to make a decent array. :)
Nice! Some people have all the fun... ;-)
I saw your comments elsewhere about time constraints, but I would LOVE to have seen this rig tested as a ZFS server...
EDIT: Check out this vid
This was probably already asked.
How long did the actual installation of windows take? You must have been limited by your disk drive.
Not too long at all, but as that was limited by the speed of the blu-ray drives, I'd rather not guess how the SSDs influenced that. :)
It was very fast at installing updates, if that helps!
Why in gods name did you run Windows on it?
[deleted]
How much are these drives going to cost?
it would be interesting to see it running on mac os x leopard and get some benchmarks. or a beta of snow leopard.
Can you give a list of the programs you were running? Were you running the entire Adobe suite? I'd like to see it running Reason, Reaktor, and some other huge programs like that. I know it can do it faster than anything I will ever have my hands on, but I would be curious to see just how efficiently it does it. Of course it will just have to be at a later time since you don't have them anymore. :-)
sweet, you edited it ;)
Thank you.
Hahaha.... Yeah, don't know how I made such a novice error. :-)
Check the pan over the menu bar when I loaded everything in the start menu - most are just the apps built in to Vista, but I think a few larger programs are in there too :)
In terms of what we have on the market, I see a 256gb sdd on newegg, its 500.00 and it has 200MB read and 170 write. Is this comparable?
If the one you're referring to is MLC (versus SLC), it'll be the much the same technology. Of course, the controller is important too, but MLC vs. SLC is the main difference in recent SSD tech. :)
You mentioned that you did some tuning - specifically stripe size. How much did those optimizations actually improve throughput?
Not much, most of the tuning was balancing the amount of drives on each controller / on the motherboard etc. Tiny stripe sizes would saturate the IOPS on the controllers, and huge ones would bog it down a bit too, but any in the mid-ranges were perfectly fast.
MLC or SLC?
MLC.
I have to say if those drives were sent to you for promotional purposes then you have done your job very well indeed! You were #1 on my front page, and you've got hundreds of people discussing the technology. Kudos for being good at what you do, brother.
Did you time a standard vista boot?
[deleted]
So, as fun as the video was, there weren't any technical details.
Were you using HW raid? What controller? SW raid? What RAID level? What benchmarks did you use? You said you optimized windows in at least one way. What did you do?
Haha - man, pause the end frames already! I explain all the technical details in there, controllers, RAID levels, benchmarks and everything :D
Windows optimization was mostly installing Vista SP1 as it improves throughput on file transfers.
OMG cr3ative! Nothing special to say apart from I was shocked to see your mug as the number one on reddit. Good work Chico.
Haha, thanks! Where do I know you from, Greengages?
A little podunk forum that houses the refugees of fat-pie. And Arcadian already posted this before I got the chance, can you imagine that?
[deleted]
How long did it take to zero out the drives set up like that?
I'm not sure how long RAID0 usually takes to zero out, but it was always instant. It'd hit "commit" on the RAID setup page and it'd be available in Vista as soon as the Drive Management console woke up.
I would be interested to know if you did any other benchmarking, such as, how fast would it take to render HD quality videos in Adobe Premiere? Did you run PC Mark on it as well?
Actually, do you have a website where you have additional information? This is something I think that can be rather useful in plenty of high-end applications.
We did some Cinebench rendering tests, but as that was almost certainly just related to graphics performance, we omitted it from the video. I'll see if I can find the results; if you're interested, leave a reply to this message so my icon goes red :)
Sure , any additional specs/bench marks would be great. I would be interested also in how fast I can write to it from an external source via Gigabit Ethernet, and 10 Gbps Ethernet as well.
I don't understand anything going in this video, other than it's fast, but you made it way fun!
Which array of RAID was that?
What was the total budget, if you don't mind me asking?
[deleted]
Who are you guys? How'd you get Samsung to send you so many drives?
Samsung paid them to do the thing, obviously.
[deleted]
Fine, ignore the second part of my question - I'm still curious about the first.
I was hoping for the Vista loading time.
Edit: oh thanks.
See below :)
I think you just set a new record for awesomeness!
Do you have an estimate for much a setup like that would cost?
The parts, without SSDs, are... uh, probably around 6 or 7 thousand pounds if you shop around. Or cheaper if you have a lot of time to scout for bargains. As I don't know the market price of the drives themselves, it's hard to predict any further than that - someone lower down in this discussion thinks they saw these drives as a $300 upgrade in a Dell laptop, but I haven't checked that.
[deleted]
The big question that I have is: While you may have had 24SSD drives in the system, (I'm assuming 250GB each?) when will we see 1TB drives? See... I edit high def video...
EDIT: Crap. It's SEAGATE drives that conked out on me, not Samsung.