MemoryDealersRoger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com•

This article is incredibly misleading and needs to clarify what "Satoshi's Vision" is. It certainly isn't referring to the full node implementation by Nchain. The main meeting starts today and isn't at the W hotel.

71
DerSchorsch•

Probably a tough thing to say about a tech billionaire, but at least on Twitter Calvin often comes across as a useful idiot with money who regurgitates every single CSW statement by the argument of "Satoshi's vision", in between party pictures and the odd Segwit rant. Does that guy listen to anyone else for advice?

Craig's new tactic seems to be this funky conspiracy where everything that ABC proposes is just to benefit Wormhole, an argument that seems to have found quite a few suckers already.

Personally I'm trying to evaluate Craig's arguments as objectively as possible on an individual basis, but IMHO someone with a seemingly narcissistic and divisive personality should be treated with caution.

Just for the fun of it I was going to compile a list of some of Craig's remarkable claims. Just from the top of my head:

Having written 800+ academic papers, aiming to be in the top 3 of all innovaters in human history..

18
cunicula3•

Not a single one has managed to pass through peer review. The world is full of cranks who make extraordinary claims.

Some of them have been stolen from Chinese researchers, adorned with bullshit conclusions such as "and therefore selfish mining doesn't work."

One of them used a blatantly broken methodology.

He has a long ways to go to become an innovator. Looks like he hasn't gone down that road at all.

16
Zectro•

Thanks for clarifying Roger :)

17
Maesitos•

Wtf is going on with Coingeek?

6
DrBaggypants•

Desperation

10
DerSchorsch•

The article reads as: Before the main meeting they first wanted to win over smaller and on-the-fence sitting miners and then confront the rest, perhaps with the argument of "look, we have the majority already".

5
BitcoinopolyModerator - /R/BTC•

win over smaller and on-the-fence sitting miners and then confront the rest

That was exactly the same method employed by Blockstream when they showed up to Hong Kong with BitFury in tow and used their mining power to intimidate Jihan into signing that horribly dishonest agreement.

3
ratifythisRedditor for less than 60 days•

nChain's SV literally returns as close as possible to Bitcoin 0.1.0, the protocol version Satoshi called "set in stone." Yeah that doesn't mean miners support that particular piece of software, but the fact that Satoshi's vision for the protocol is closest to SV shouldn't be controversial.

Other teams are implicitly saying they know better than Satoshi and DON'T support his "set in stone at 0.1.0" protocol vision, and there is nothing ipso facto wrong with that. They should own up to it, and if they aren't, that itself is a red flag.

4†
CatatonicAdenosineRedditor for less than 6 months•

What the hell are you talking about? Set in stone??? Where did Satoshi say the original protocol should be set in stone? (And don’t go giving me some tweet by Craig.)

8
[deleted]•

Set in stone as in 21M coins, difficulty adjustment every 2016 blocks, UTXO model of transacting etc. Not all the fringe stuff.

6
Benjamin_atom•

Yes.

I'm not oppose to change the original protocol, but if changed, don't fucking call it is Bitcoin.

-5
CatatonicAdenosineRedditor for less than 6 months•

What level of change are we talking here? No optimizations? No bug fixes? Or just no more thinking? Seems a bit ridiculous to me. Bitcoin is a technology, not a religion.

6
Darac_Komarac•

agree ...and religion is the main cause of all suffering on this planet , exactly because of this original thinking that never evolved with society ...written to stone crap .. sorry a bit off topic but makes the point.. protocol must be reviewed and improved constantly...

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
e_pie_eye_plus_oneRedditor for less than 60 days•

I’m assuming satoshi’s vision doesn’t include ‘invite only’, opaque meetings to control the blockchain by a cartel.

0†
E7ernal•

Why don't you clean this place up and get rid of all the liars? Regular users CANNOT compete with botnets and paid troll factories. Reddit is a broken platform - it only works with real moderation. You've been to r/goldandblack. You've seen how our community functions. You know what I say is truth.

0†
PlayerDeus•

I've been banned and unbanned a few times from goldandblack without a given reason as to why, I gave up on it so I don't know if that is changed but that is hardly ideal moderation. At least here they give you reason why a certain action is taken.

1
E7ernal•

Probably a mistake. They do happen. If you're confused about moderator actions feel free to message the mods. Quite frankly I don't know why you'd have been banned - maybe you thought you were because things were caught in filters?

Anyways, don't give up on the community! We work hard to ensure it remains a positive experience posting there.

1
sneakpeekbot•
0
JoshHomeroGarza•

Bcash Bcash Bcash

-1
GrumpyAnarchistOP•

From reading the article, it at least sounds like what they're referring to. Correct me if I'm wrong.

-11
Elidan456•

He just said the meeting as yet to start and you post an article from CoinGeek going full propaganda? Stop posting all your shit comments and wait for actual confirmation from different party.

13
GrumpyAnarchistOP•

awww....poor baby.

-9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ratifythisRedditor for less than 60 days•

It's the Coingeek meeting before the other meeting, at which likely Craig and Calvin - who together do likely represent the majority of all BCH hashpower - attended, so not inaccurate. People just misinterpreted. Two meetings.

-11

Shady as fuck.

9
LovelyDay•

People Coingeek just misinterpreted misrepresented

FTFY

5
JonathanSilverblood •

the don't though, at least not in a grander scale.

currently, they might have hashrate equal to more than half of what is currently mining BCH, but as price goes up their share would end up vanishingly small, and if they fork out the economic incentives would bring other miners in to reach the very same hashrate given the rest of the ecosystem remains fairly stable.

5
newtobch•

It certainly isn't referring to the full node implementation by Nchain

Well...that’s the only implementation that upholds Satoshis vision so technically you could say it is.

-16
DerSchorsch•

Surprise surprise, another pro-nChain new redditor..

12
ratifythisRedditor for less than 60 days•

It's hard to dispute what he is saying, though. SV literally returns as close as possible to Bitcoin 0.1.0, the protocol version Satoshi called "set in stone."

-6

Oooooh you got that talking point memorized well. Keep parroting it.

10
DrBaggypants•

lol. no it doesn't.

5
throwawayo12345•

Interesting... then why did Satoshi continue to develop the code?

3
CraigBCH•

oh no, they didnt call you, roger? :'((((

but.. but.. you are the most important figure in the cryptoworld.. :'((( how is this happened.

There will be another meeting taking place in Bangkok today.

only if you be patient enough to read it all, you would see it in the article, roger.

-17
MemoryDealersRoger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com•

I attended the CoinGeek meeting yesterday, and I’m typing this from the main meeting now.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jonald_fyookball•

Meeting is today and didn't start yet. Not sure who was at the meeting yesterday.

30
--_-_o_-_--•

Thanks for that. Shields up. Your independence and creativity intimidates some.

12
BitcoinopolyModerator - /R/BTC•

Coingeek reported that the meeting funded by Coingeek resulted in the outcome desired by investors of Coingeek.

I couldn't be any less interested in their opinion. Can somebody who is not Calvin Ayre, CSW, Eli Efram, or anybody else waist deep in SV corroborate this "unanimous" consensus? Was the room simply packed with supporters already on that side or did some significant people across the table decide to flip from ABC?

27
cryptorebel•

It seems Jihan is reconsidering:

However, hope isn’t lost as word came to the CoinGeek meeting that Jihan has reconsidered and would in fact support Satoshi Vision and Miners Choice and enable the growth of the world’s one fully functioning digital currency Bitcoin BCH.

There will be another meeting taking place in Bangkok today. Bitcoin.com, nChain, CoinGeek and other miners will work with Bitmain’s Jihan Wu and many other miners to plan how we can all work together to ensure the success of Satoshi Vision, which will ultimately pave the way for Bitcoin to reach its true potential. A meeting of the minds, after all, was the only way to avoid a destructive hash war. Let’s continue to hope business thinking rules the evolution of Bitcoin.

Although I would agree coingeek is probably spinning things a little optimistically. I read it as Jihan is open-minded to supporting SV. Hopefully they can come to some sort of agreement and compromise.

-3†
BitcoinopolyModerator - /R/BTC•

Jihan "would support SV" is a very curious choice of words. It feels like half of the statement was left out on purpose. I'm guessing he will follow SV if and only if the hashrate determines it to be the majority.

18
bcloud71•

coingeek.com/coinge...

Check Jihan's twitter. He said, coingeek is writing fiction instead of news report...

7
Benjamin_atom•

I don't think he want to support SV, he is strongly objecting SV.

Sure, if he doesn't have enough hash power, he may be forced to support sv, or he may fork away like last year.

2†
DrBaggypants•

Never go full CoinGeek.

1
---Ed---•

Dude...

Bitcoin BCH miners in attendance are unanimously supporting Satoshi Vision and Miners’ Choice.

THEY ALL AGREED, so enough of this hijacking talk shit

-14
BitcoinopolyModerator - /R/BTC•

unanimously supporting

Those two words could mean almost anything. To me it reads as if all of the attendees agree that miners should be allowed to choose whichever client to run whether it is ABC or SV.

13
---Ed---•

wow, some of you people see anything you want to see... these two words couldn't be more specific.

It means EVERY MINER AGREED TO SUPPORT the Bitcoin SV client. There are no maybe and ifs and possibilities... its EVERYONE in SUPPORT, that's 100%. Get it?

-9
BitcoinopolyModerator - /R/BTC•

And support necessarily means to run the software before November? Plenty of people in BCH support other coins and clients without ever actually doing anything with them. You also have plenty of developers supporting BCH, like Vitalik, but they will never install the software on their computer, check the code for bugs, or otherwise lift a finger about it. Jihan can support SV and run ABC while Ayre can support ABC and mine with SV.

12
micropresidentBitcoin Cash Developer•

This meeting happened on the 30th (today) and it is 8:23 am. Quick meeting.

14
cunicula3•

Was this a pre-written piece that got leaked on the wrong day, because the idiots at CoinGeek got confused about the time zone difference?

10
ShadowOfHarbringer•

Warning !

u/GrumpyAnarchist is a marked obvious CSW Shill.


Your daily RES tagging info.

9
amorpisseur•

This article is propaganda.

From Jihan Wu:

Coingeek hires fiction writers, but not news reporters.

6
GrumpyAnarchistOP•

he would know

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
excalibur0922Redditor for less than 60 days•

I'm with bitcoin SV as it stands. Sure as hell don't want CTO, pre-consensus, wormhole or DSV.

I just want bigger blocks with UTXO commitment and (later) parallelisation to go along with ASICS for rapid txn verification (to push block sizes into the stratosphere).

Actually I think verification ASICS will come first to help verify large blocks faster on single threaded code... the next hardware arms race frontier and I think bitmain will have a lot of competition from nchain et al in that hardware market.

2
GrumpyAnarchistOP•

we're on the same page. If nchain starts pushing weird changes, I'll turn on them too, though.

1
excalibur0922Redditor for less than 60 days•

Yep!! I also don't support use of patents (the state)... but in a messed up way... I am beginning to question whether it could be for the good to some extent... the irony of the government using its resources to protect an entity that undermines it's own power and has the potential to cut off its own supply lines... that would be beautiful... but really... there are likely to be many future disagreements and if CSW is going to wave patents (state power) around - That's not good. Kinsella (Hoppean ancap - expert on IP) was unable to move him from his Randian position on IP (if you watched that debate)

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mogray5•

Good news if true. A contentious chain split should be avoided if possible.

-3
LovelyDay•

Good news if true.

Unfortunately, it's Coingeek, so the chances are VERY low at this stage.

3
mogray5•

Based on Jihan's tweets you called it. Welp. You can do better Coingeek.

3
knight222•

So miners can get to an agreement when they are actually in charge and not some wannabe devs protected by censorship? Who would have thought??

Bitcoin is actually proving that it works as it should be :)

-5†
--_-_o_-_--•

How do you know the miners in attendance are representative of all of them?

10
knight222•

I don't but we'll definitely see if hashrate will follow.

-3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
newtobch•

True if big.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2†
gizram84•

Oh man, this is going to be so good. I can't wait for the November drama.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-8
cryptorebel•

Sounds pretty encouraging so far. u/tippr gild

-13
Zectro•

So how do you feel having gilded this now that Roger has confirmed this is just propaganda and the meeting hasn't even happened yet?

13
cryptorebel•

Not sure, I said they were probably using optimistic wording. I agree they should have been more clear. Doesn't mean the article is wrong though, but it does seem misleading a little bit. Sounds like there are two meetings, a preliminary one without Jihan, where there may have been over 50% of hash rate present deciding for SV. But perhaps we should wait for further clarification of the story.

-3
Zectro•
6
cryptorebel•

Yeah maybe Jihan didn't like this part:

It’s worth noting that Bitmain had the hash power to stop Blockstream and Bitcoin Core from forking BTC to SegWit. Bitmain’s failure to prevent this fork resulted in billions in lost value and years of retardation to Bitcoin’s development as a currency. Now that Bitcoin is back, in the form of Bitcoin Cash, the same group — but with Bitcoin ABC instead of Core — had wanted to fork again in a non-Bitcoin direction.

But I have to agree, Bitmain failed the community by falling for the segwit2x scam.

-2†
DrBaggypants•

You are pathetic

3
cunicula3•

What's it like tipping the guy in the cubicle next door, you slimy social media manipulator?

7
tippr•

u/GrumpyAnarchist, your post was gilded in exchange for 0.00451135 BCH ($2.50 USD)! Congratulations!


^^How to use ^^| ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? ^^| ^^Who accepts it? ^^| ^^r/tippr
^(Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc)

-3
itsme_q•

This is great news for Bitcoin Cash

-14
--_-_o_-_--•

Further association of Bitcoin Cash with Wright is bad news for both adoption and exchange rates.

13
GrumpyAnarchistOP•

oh, the party hasn't even started yet. ;P

1†