"Even before I became a feminist in 1967, I had already learned that the (imperfect) West is still a far better place for a woman to live than is the most hospitable, beautiful, wealth-encrusted Muslim country"
pajamasmedia.com/phyllischesler/2009/10/27/a-...Posted Oct 28, 2009, 1:17 PM UTC
Having talked to a rather "liberal" muslim(he drinks) who told me to my face straight up, "There are no gay muslims." And just like in the article I saw some things that clearly suggest differently to anyone that hasn't stuck their head in the sand. I lived in Qatar for 17 months. I talked to a lot of people. They all seem to think we in the west are crazy to allow our women to roam free. It bothered me to see one man walking around with four women dressed in burqas trailing behind him.
Muslims in the Muslim world have zero respect for people outside their culture. They love our resources, our money, and our technical abilities. Beyond that they do not care one wit about anyone that isn't one of them, and they don't even care about many of their own(see: Muslims in India, Indonesia, or pick your southeast Asian country).
I heard a radio broadcast about how "Europe would have been better off if the Muslims had conquered it fully," whereas the "cowardly caliph" who called back the two daring, amazing generals was spoken of with disdain. Qatar is not Saudi, the people there are supposed to be "moderate" muslims. If that's moderate, I'm worried.
I have known some very kind and generous Moslems but I have to say that my overall net experience has been that I and others have been treated by them with utter contempt (and that's here in the West). For example, when I graded papers in college (1970s and 1980s) the most rampant cheating was among the Moslem students and when they were caught they were completely without shame. Instead, they attempted to turn the tables and would accuse the grader of tampering with their work to make them look bad.
Once I studied Islam as part of my Philosophy major, I realized that lying to me was as of as little consequence to them as my lying to my dog to get it to go into the backyard before I leave the house.
Its not entirely related to Muslims though, the rampant cheating seems to be extremely common in several "eastern" cultures.
Some of the most interesting articles was about that. I read was a translation of an interview with an imam who ran a religious school in Syria. The imam was complaining that as part of the final exam this year the imam left the students entirely alone so that they may demonstrate Islamic morals too by not cheating. He had set up a hidden camera to watch them and nearly all of them started cheating immediately after he left. The imam was ranting that university students in the west with no "morals" cheated less than his students and was really angry over it.
A second incident I know about was a massive cheating scandal in the equivalent of the BAR exam in India in 2004. The Indian equivalent of the BAR hired a foreigner as procter and during the exam the procter ended up throwing out nearly have the applicants for cheating. In response, a large number of law school students rioted. Their spokespeople were I kid you not, claiming that because the cheating had been going for years that the current group shouldn't be barred from practicing law because the current class had been cheating extensively.
I am from India and I believe you.
However, this one example alone is not sufficient to prove anything. I was born and brought up in India and wrote several exams there. In response to your one anecdote, I can provide hundreds where cheating didn't take place.
You're welcome to draw conclusions from one anecdote.
Holy shit, the only Indian dude in the world named Scott. Do you work for Dell because they get all the guys with American names, are you all from the same town or something?
Cheating is rampant in certain "Western" cultures too. e.g. http://knowledge.wpcarey.asu.edu/article.cfm?articleid=1590 http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=4362510&page=1
The easy generalizations in this thread are somewhat worrying.
Exactly, Florida State, Florida State, Florida State... Wooo!
Three words for you: Southern Methodist University
Suggesting he doesn't understand internal versus external moral foci.
Your grammar gave me a headache.
English people should learn to speak English in a way you can understand more easily?
I think you're a degenerate, clueless bigot.
I love you too! :-)
[deleted]
Actually, as a philosophy major, I've read the Koran and many of the Hadith. I understand exactly why Moslems behave the way they do, regardless of their citizenship. Thanks for playing though, better luck next time!
[deleted]
The same could be said for followers of the bible and torah, could it not?
Please explain what exactly makes all muslims around the world behave the way you think. You could give us some insight.
And did you ever stop to think that Muslims might be the problem?
I mean, if you want a fair discourse, you need to do it. It's undeniable that the Eastern and Western worlds (or cultures) do not think the same, so why act all offended when someone say that an Easterner in the Western world might not automatically act like a Westerner?
[deleted]
I wouldn't be talking about morons if I was you.
Of course they didn't stop to think.
I'd say you're badly informed if you think Qatar or any of the gulf states are moderate. Try going to Turkey, women got full political equality in 1930, they're accepting of other cultures, and if you think they deny that homosexuality exists, just Google "Turkish baths"
Being forced to deal with other cultures by virtue of location is probably the best way to force Muslim societies to loosen up. Just 100 years ago the fastest way to get around the Arabian peninsula was by camel, they didn't get out much.
Anyone out on the peninsula tends to be a bit xenophobic, but many Muslim cultures with a more cosmopolitan history aren't as backwards as you think. Check out the Muslim areas of Russia or India for example.
A wonderful, very Western and open Saudi-Egyptian girl from my business school class, who is (finally) being allowed to marry her European boyfriend, kept insisting to me that her family doing things like confiscating her passport when she went home, or keeping her cooped up in their compounds, and Saudi Mutaween arresting people who weren't behaving "properly", were perfectly all right and should be tolerated.
Sigh.
Right, because the perfect way to demonstrate how free and open-minded you are is to refuse to accept alternative ways of life. Go for it, white men, keep on liberating those poor and downtrodden, even when it's against their will. See: Afghanistan, Iraq, Somalia, Vietnam, Cuba...
Isn't that what religious police and her parents were doing? Not accepting alternative ways of life of Saudis and her daughter, respectively?
Uh, didn't she say that she thought it was alright and should be tolerated? Again with the weird phenomenon of white men needing to save colored women, despite their own protests. I'm going to introduce you to a new word: subaltern. It will be very helpful in case you ever decide to study this matter seriously.
"No need to hear your voice when I can talk about you better than you can speak about yourself. No need to hear your voice. Only tell me about your pain. I want to know your story. And then I will tell it back to you in a new way. Tell it back to you in such a way that it has become mine, my own. Re-writing you I write myself anew. I am still author, authority. I am still colonizer the speaking subject and you are now at the center of my talk"
Yup, if those "alternative ways of life" take away peoples' rights. Absolutely. We got rid of witch hunting, slavery, state-sponsored mysogyny, heresy trials, and child marriages for exactly that reason. Too bad if that stepped on the toes of somebody's "alternative way of life".
You have to remember that it's difficult to understand a mindset until you acquire it. Then, and only then, will you understand and appreciate it.
Did it ever occur to you that some women actually value and appreciate things like modesty, men-providing society structure, relationships with children for the rest of one's life, strong families, and the other things OVER AND ABOVE things like individual freedom? All these things come with undiluted Muslim culture.
Just because you don't value those things as much as other things doesn't mean you should scorn those who have those values.
Having freedom in no way stops you from being as modest as you want to be or having as strong a family as you want.
But the natural result of such "freedom" IS weak families and immodesty. Look at the stark difference between stable Muslim countries and the West when it comes to things like that. Muslim families (which have not become mixed-up with Western cultures) always tend to have stronger families. They also have MUCH lower rates of serious crime and much less psychopaths and drug addicts. Marriage is a fabric which stabilizes a society - and Islam values that.
Now I admit there is a lot of instability in some Muslim countries right now - but if you study it deeply you find that is a result of Muslims starting to adopt Western values and forget the "true" Muslim values - not vice versa.
There is no excuse for taking away an innocent person's freedom of movement. In no culture. Nor of treating members of gender X differently from gender Y.
Any culture that condones this is inferior to a culture that does not. I will not debate this.
I have no problem with you believing this. But you have to understand that not everyone thinks like you do. Some women do not see it as a "freedom of movement" as you call it, but rather see it as a subjection of women to men's carnal desire (though more subtly). Gender X is DIFFERENT from Gender Y biologically, mentally, and physically. Why is it so preposterous then, that Gender X and Y be treated differently? Note I said differently, NOT unequally.
Besides, it's not a restriction on the "freedom of movement" if the women themselves are happy with such a restriction.
Did it ever occur to you that some women would like to choose?
How can you really "choose"? A person acquires the values of his social circle. And any social circle will look down and pressure those who go outside of the norms of that circle.
There is a massive leap from "I value these things and will lead my life by them" to "I will kill you if you do not do the same."
One is a human right, one is sick and diseased.
I understand what you mean. However, a person inherits his/her values from their social circle. It is impossible or rare for a person to adopt values different from the one he/she grew up in.
Problems start happening when you start mixing two different sets of values together, especially when they are very different from each other.
modesty? I demand richard dawkins, abortions, translucent clothes and thongs for everyone!
By that logic, no one would have the right to condemn or question anything since everything would be relative to culture.
As a half-Saudi/half-American who has lived 14 years in Saudi Arabia and 9 years in the US, I can tell you that there most certainly are Saudis who think way things currently are in the country is fucked up, and that the West has done things right with regards to freedom of religion and equality of the sexes.
Just because you didn't meet (or perhaps just didn't notice) any *actual* liberal muslims in your circle of acquaintances while you were in Qatar doesn't mean they don't exist, and you do them a great disservice by painting everyone with the same brush. The best way for liberal ideas to spread is to encourage dialogue and communication between cultures, and you do a lot to curb that when you claim every muslim is against the West.
Further, most of these repressive Middle Eastern regimes were installed by the West.
Those fucks replying to All_That_Matters don't seem to have any idea of the political situation. They point to Qatar (which is a puppet state to say the least) and Saudi Arabia, who is propped up only by the Americans, and claim that these countries are ruled by Islam. The Saudi Royal family cannot be farther from Islam and closer to the "American" way of life. Those who wish for a better human rights situation in the Middle East better stop with the double-speak. Saudi Arabia sucks when it comes to human rights ? Muslims have been saying this from around the world for AGES. Now if only the so-called "civilized" nations of the West would remove their support for the Royal Family (support that exists only as the result of their greed), and let a true Islamic democracy emerge, then maybe I'll hear those who speak against Islam. Until then, no need to feed their ever expanding ego and their hate for Islam.
Yes, like Iran was a "true islamic democracy" ruled by islam.. until its people actually tried to exercise the basic principle, and the thin veil was lifted to reveal typical islamic brutality..very civilised and "true" that was.
Well said.
"I could never get anyone in the American civil rights, anti-war, feminist, or post-colonialist movements to understand this. They needed to blame the Big Bad West for the world’s problems. They also needed to identify the developing world as intrinsically innocent, pure, victimized."
True 1967, twice as true today - and reddit is a great place to observe the process. Building blows up in Indonesia, a place nowhere near Israel and with zero Jews? Must be a legitimate response to Western oppression of Palestinians. China is full of factory towns that expose millions to environmental pollution? Caused by the West demanding cheap consumables (never mind this same polution was there in 60s and 70s). and so on.
What the fuck are you talking about? Terrorism in that region has nothing to do with Zionism. I know you want to desperately paint all Muslims as anti-Semitic savages (itself an act of gross bigotry) but try to make sense in the future.
Ocin, I know where you're coming from on this debate, but why even bother with someone like anonid?
Their voices are no too different than those of the Nazis in the 30s, who fabricated a hatred for the Jewish people and indoctrinated the German people enough to gain their support for the Holocaust.
Reddit can be fun, but you're playing their game. This post was obviously meant for atheists who felt they needed to spread their garbage outside of the atheism subreddit. But don't fall for it. Let them fool themselves. Let them build their hate.
I know I should just ignore it but this kind of moronic rhetoric irritates me immensely. I guess a part of me feels that such hatred and falsehood shouldn't go unchallenged. But you're right, responding to these asshats certainly detracts from my usually enjoyable experience of Reddit and I should learn to ignore it.
There are people who enjoy buggery, and experience same-sex attraction. But for the most part there is no cultural identity of 'homosexual'--that was an import from the West.
"Just because I like having sex with men doesn't mean I'm gay."
Places like Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan are like prison. Even straight men have sex with men and boys because they can't get to women. No dating, falling in love, getting married. Just getting married to a stranger and no sex before that. Like without love.
Blame the west for supporting and sponsoring the puritanical groups in the region.
[citation needed]
What's normal in western culture isn't normal in Arabic culture and vice versa.
There's a difference between a sexual act and a sexual identity, no?
So you are trying to say that "gays" in the Middle East is just heterosexual people who repeatedly enjoy homosexual acts?
Not recognizing homosexuality isn't the same as not having homosexuals.
Yes. I thought it was a funny quip that got the point across but I'll explain further.
The whole idea that there are no homosexuals in the muslim world is laughable. Sure, there are guys who are attracted to other men, and may or may not be attracted to other women, but they obviously aren't homosexual. To admit to that is to basically kill yourself - because dead is what you'd be if you actually said that.
So, instead of just admitting that homosexuals do exist, they just create a workaround. You can have sex with guys but you just can't be homosexual. Otherwise, we stone you. Oh. Ok. That works.
Homosexuals, when given freedom, stick to the same gender for sexual relations. This is true all over any culture where homosexuality isnt punished. We see this in the states, parts of S. America, Europe, etc.
There is a BIOLOGICAL identity of homosexual which as real as anything. Denying this is homophobia and the product of a backwards overly religious society. Whether or not its a cultural category doesnt matter. There are millions of gay muslims. Dont empower the haters by playing these shit sophomoric games of semantics.
I guess you mean that these Muslims are not gay, but they are on the down-lo
Just think for a second that maybe the way you conceive of sexuality may be different than how another culture does.
You are right about the fact that sexual identities are (to an extent) socially constructed.
But saying "there are no homosexual Muslims" is like saying there are no black Somalians because, before being introduced to European culture, they had no concept of racial identity (as opposed to ethnic identity).
*edit: replied to wrong comment
You mean repress and criminalize it?
Guess I should have failed my multicultural course since I'm so Western-centric and find such behaviors appalling.
I'm re-reading the Anne Rice Vampire Chronicles again and I have to keep reminding myself that it is only my cultural beliefs that make me uncomfortable with the idea of men enjoying sex with other men. The characters don't fit in the category of hetero or homo, they just enjoy sex and appreciate beauty regardless of gender.
Exactly.
I don't think "gay" means what you think it means.
Sounds like they're gay to me. Hell, I'll bet there are even lesbians too!
I can see how there are nearly no muslims who'd self-identify as homosexual, even those that are (only/mostly) attracted to their own gender.
The interesting question (if it is so), is why is this the case. A likely reason would be that self-identifying yourself as homosexual unleashes a great deal of repression and abuse on one's self. And then the next question is : is that really a good thing to have in a society?
That is the case now, largely because Western categories of sexuality have been adopted by Arab socities. But before, when there was no dichotomy of homosexuality/heterosexuality, there was little persectuion of same-sex acts, at least relative to the West.
Sure, there still is little persecution of same-sex acts. We are talking about the homosexual identity, which is something else. I am saying there is no homosexual identity in Muslim communities, not because it is somehow 'foreign/unknown' to them but because the persecution and pressure to not adopt such an identity is enormous.
Muslim communities are not unique. You (someone else) pointed to ancient Greek societies and closer to home the same mechanism plays in male communities with little interaction with females (the army up to a few years ago and stronger still in prison communities). In all those examples you'll see that while same-sex acts happen on a regular basis (maybe even more regular than in open societies), homosexual identification is violently surpressed right up to the point that a casual observer can rightfully claim : it totally does not exist here.
there is no cultural identity because they will fucking kill you for it there, same as in most of Africa.
You wouldn't believe the amount of Muslims who say that there are no gay Muslims, and the amount of non-Muslims who say that you can't be a gay Muslim.
Fuck you all.
Why would any non-Muslim say that?
Reinforce anti-muslim stereotypes.
Those who do believe that the Qu'ran is nothing more than a book telling you that being gay is an abomination and that women should never show their skin.
I think you're slacking in your policing duties, sir.
The word you seek is "number."
Gulf states would hardly be moderate.
If you want to check moderate Muslims, go for Turkey, which is functioning secular democracy. They have their share of problems, but they are pretty moderate.
If you want to see European Muslims ... go to Bosnia. War fucked it up pretty badly, but people there have nothing in common with Arab Muslims (except religion). Before the war it was impossible to tell who was Catholic, Orthodox or Muslim (specially in larger cities). War changed some of this (and influx of refugees from smaller towns / villages into bigger cities).
The problem isn't religion itself (as type of religion, not in general ;) ).
The problem are customs and tradition. The more you move from western world the more fucked up tradition and customs you meet. It's the state of civilization in those parts of the world. No human rights, no freedom of speech and so on ....
Check Africa and witchcraft.
I lived in Saudi Arabia for five years and have visited several other Muslim countries. There are quite a few people in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf who have little curiosity about the outside world. Those are conservative societies. But in the more general case, that has been very far from my experience.
Curiosity, yes... respect, no.
It depends? Respect for who? Western Barbarians? Why should they respect them?
Because you depend on us to buy your products and build the refineries that process them. If we're such barbarians then why do business with us at all?
What a statement to make.
To be fair, it was implied to be an opinion based on his experiences while immersed in that culture. It's not like he was just saying it just based on meeting on or two Muslims. Yeah, it's still anecdotal, but it's a great deal more informed than most Americans making sweeping generalizations about people they know nothing about.
To make generalisations like that, whether opinion or not is simply wrong. The fact is the feelings of the general muslim population is very different from country to country. Take Jordan and compare it to Saudi/Qatar, for example. The feeling towards the west is generally positive in Jordan (save for feelings that came about since the last few US instigated wars and the Blair/Bush legacy).
In my experience, and yes this is a generalisation, the people of the US are at least as blinkered and inward looking as those in Saudi/Qatar.
Also, the west cannot drag these countries into our view of the 21st century. They have to find their own path and they are doing so, albeit slowly. Bear in mind that women in the west were similarly viewed less than a century ago.
When it came to light that the US government was torturing people it was a big deal. Not only were people concerned for the violation of human rights but they were worried about the image of the US internationally. Even if you feel it was justified the concern over international judgment was there.
Saudi Arabia and Qatar don't give a fuck.
And we in the west generally view those historic views as equally barbaric. Is slavery okay too because it was practiced in the past?
I don't remember the 'execute for adultery' part of recent western culture. And no, I don't consider biblical history to be part of western cultural history.
Women were not forced to walk behind men a century ago. Citation needed on that.
Exactly, thank you for this post. Americans are always making sweeping generalisations because they are fat and stupid and know nothing.
*whit
Oh really?
I was pretty sure that Iranians in Iran were out in public mourning the Americans who were killed on September 11.
Iran is very different from the Gulf states.
The author was referring to muslims though not arabs.
The author is an ignorant hateful slop of shit.
Iran's people are much more secular than those of most Muslim countries.
As far as I can tell, when people talk about Muslim culture, they nearly always mean Arab Muslim culture, but they don't say it either because they (incorrectly) equate Muslim with Arab or because they think saying something bad about Arab culture will make them racist.
The "no gay Muslims" thing is probably true from the perspective of a strict Islam viewpoint, just like there are "no gay Christians" from the viewpoint of the fanatical religious right. They're infidels, heathens, heretics, whatever.
There were no gays in my high school graduating class of 1985, either. Funny though, years later there were a few who "turned gay." Maybe changing attitudes have something to do with it?
You should ask your friend what he thinks.
[deleted]
To draw your analogy out and make it applicable, let's say that alien species came down and asked us for help because they didn't have something we did, and still continued to treat us in that manner. Would we then have grounds to expect them to at least treat us as equals?
[deleted]
Where does the line get drawn though? Where does the behaviour make you sit up and say "hey, that's really fucked up?"
I don't think anyone from any culture should get to enslave their spouse so they have their own illiterate, cowering baby factory. That's a human being there and culture can go to hell. Don't even get me started on "honor killings". That's some of the most foul behaviour conceivable and the people who partake in murdering their daughters/sisters/mothers/etc. for the most trivial crap (looking the wrong way at another guy) are animals. I would gladly put a bullet between the eyes of anyone who does this and I would sleep soundly afterwards.
Try going to Lebanon!!
This is true for all cultures which have not been exposed to others which are very different from its own. Its a human trait to be afraid of or look down on someone "different". Take for example, the way the West views Muslim culture. It's no different from the way Muslims living in Muslim countries view Western culture.
Muslim and Western cultures are the anti-thesis of each other - almost exactly opposite when it comes to values. However this does not mean that both cultures cannot live together in harmony. It just requires a little understanding of each other.
And now Muslims are conquering Europe, one immigrant at a time. And he might be right about there being no gay Muslims ... they follow the parts of the bible that state gay men should be executed.
[deleted]
Most Westerners think the same about non-whites.
[citation needed]
Open your eyes and ears and read some history books.
[deleted]
is it just me or does the same mentality apply to the west (namely the US) rather fittingly?
I am a former Muslim atheist, and I have to say, that compared to Europe, USA is extremely welcoming. I did briefly feel uncomfortable with my heritage after 9/11 but not before and not since. There are idiots and xenophobes in USA but usually less than in few European countries that I heard of.
Lies and propaganda. The USkkkA is the worst emipire in the history of man. Americans are all racist right wing xenophobes who sit in front of the tele all day watching NASCAR and discussing how to get the bible in schools across the globe.
Are you from the US? Have you lived anywhere else? As many problems as we have here, the US is still a better place to live than most others.
i was born in japan, and live in canada now, but i have visited many a nation, especially 3rd world nations as i hold an indian passport.
I lived in Japan for a while. It was okay if you were Japanese, but after being thrown out of a couple of onsen, it was less than fun. Plus their criminal system makes ours look like a model of justice and fairness.
Canada is pretty nice though.
The US is a failed shit hole.
[citation needed]
The USA is a 3rd world backward "nation."
Try out calcutta or the middle east for a while and come back and see how it goes.
Get some real perspective and stop believing all the reddit hyperbole.
That's simply false. If you mean that they have zero respect for the west, then you may have a point. The barbaric West doesn't really doesn't deserve much respect. Western civilization is a plague on humanity. I hope you also realise that most Muslims live outside the Middle east. Try to stop with the hasty generalisations.
It would have been. The worst atrocities in human history would have been avoided. Western civilization is inherently inhuman and barbaric (refer to brutal wars, atrocities and genocides committed by Europeans during the last few centuries) . Contrary to popular opinion technology and economic advancement doesn't equal being civilized.