Beware IAMA: A bitter, resentful ex-moderator is threatening to spread private information about verified submitters.
This is the link, please check it.
It seems MMM's personal vendetta is involving now not only IAMA's moderators, but also anyone who has submitted a topic.
Bonus: He uses special markup to block his comments from people looking at his profile.
Posted Nov 20, 2009, 7:57 PM UTC
How do you kill that which has no life?
I think this is the end of IAmA as we know it. This place is no longer a safe haven for those who want to share their stories anonymously.
It never was, of course, but now it's become apparent. We have no idea which of these moderators whom we're trusting with sensitive information (and zero accountability) are normal and which are complete psychos. Any of them on that list could be as unbalanced as MMM.
No one with any sense is ever going to trust this "verification system" with their personal information again. Which means we either need to ditch the system (raising the troll threat again) or make these moderators sign legally binding non-disclosure agreements. I don't know if either solution is practical.
I am an IAmA moderator and have shared a lot of personal info with Reddit. I'm facebook friends with a few people on here (and anyone can freely add me, just send me a PM), and multiple redditors have met me in real life, and know where I go to school, where I live, and have all my contact info. People on IAmA can trust us mods because we trust the community.
Stop typing so fast. I can't read your screen very well today because I left my usual telescope at home and have to use these binoculars.
Sent from my Verizon Wireless Blackberry in a tree outside karmanaut's apartment
waives penis at willis77
You're probably the mod I would trust the most, but that still doesn't amount to much. What real world consequences would there be for you if you turned on us? I imagine your contact info would be posted, and you would get harassing phone calls for a few weeks. Maybe word would spill a little bit into your private social circle and you'd lose a couple of friends.
That might be enough of an assurance when the poster is a former Sears employee or a Hollywood actor who doesn't want to be linked to his stories about seeing an actress naked. But it won't cut it when people are posting things that could get them fired from high-paying jobs or expose pasts filled with sexual deviancy/abuse. I would sure be nervous right now if I'd shared something like that with you, however well-known you might be on here.
Well, I don't really do the whole verification thing. If people are entertained by trolls, then so be it. Caveat Legens.
Anyway.
I know there isn't really anything I can say or do more than that to get people to trust me, and that's ok. You don't have to. I was just trying to refute Ciserus's "zero accountability" claim and show that most of us mods are quite sane.
That's ironclad right there!
Could you enlighten us as to the whole situation. Hearsay and rumor is not helping trust in IAmA right now >> In Particular Saydrah's absence about the whole shin dig has been unnerving.
I wish I could enlighten you, but I don't know the whole story myself. I IMed MMM this morning to try and talk about it but he was at work and couldn't talk.
From what I can tell: MMM added PhilxBefore as a mod here. A few weeks later, MMM PMed PhilxBefore and asked to be made a moderator of AskReddit. He was formerly a mod there, and was removed. PhilxBefore told the other AskReddit mods what he had asked. Saydrah, who mods both, told 32bites what happened. Saydrah seems to have been worried that MMM only added PhilxBefore to use that favor to get back into AskReddit.
32bites kicked MMM from the mod list. Marmorek re-added MMM, but both were then removed and marmorek deleted his account. MMM then went to his own subreddit and kicked up a shit storm. He is demanding that the custom styles he added here, like the gold verification star, be removed, and threatened (possibly jokingly) to give out private info from previously verified AMA posts.
Can I have your gpg private key? It'll be cool, I won't do anything with it.
I don't know what that is. I am pretty much computer illiterate. Sorry.
MMM was the same in a lot of ways. Just saying that may not count for much.
Hi karmanaut!
I think the trust issue would be cleared up by a consent form for IAmA providers. It could be just as binding as a EULA...
The biggest problem, and the one which cicerus was pointing out, was that The whole premise was based on "trust me" and in fact certain topics were derailed because the person decided not to trust that mod (I'm thinking of the hollywood director in particular.) At the time, so many were arguing that the mods were trustworthy because the were mods and now we have this breakdown in the system which means that no one can feel comfortable that their promised anonymity is truly anonymous.
But i thought different people have access to your account?
Just because you feel comfortable with all this, doesn't mean your info is safe. Now, i'm not advocating panic or anything, but yeah, just because you're fine, doesn't mean we're fine.
lol, this comment is precious.
I wish I could feel that way still, but over the past year I think my participation here has dropped off tremendously simply because I think the community has gotten bigger and bigger, to the point where I don't know who all is out there any more, and I don't think it feels like a community as much as it once did.
Did you like my status update today? Came up with that little jingle all by myself :)
(Okay, maybe I had a little help from Sublime)
I did. How is little P-Dub these days?
I'm not sure why people are downvoting you. I myself am a big fan of individuals with entertaining status updates!
I think you're a pessimist.
Well, it might not pan out that way in the real world. People might not stop trusting the system, but they honestly should. Given what we've seen here, you would be insane to trust these moderators with any sort of remotely damaging or embarrassing information. They have nothing to keep them honest besides their own sense of honor and their desire to maintain their flimsy online identities.
If someone has everything to lose by posting an IamA, then you're right. But I don't think that characterizes all or even most IamAs.
I remember having conversations with MMM when he first got here a year ago, and thinking he was a troll originally. I was completely confused by how popular he seemed to get so quickly, and then I saw him as a mod, and I kinda lost faith in the mod system, even more so when he wasn't kicked out the first time he was the center of controversy for erasing comments he didn't like from his subreddits.
What made you think he's a troll? I friended him about 6 months ago, and haven't seen anything trollish or anything like today. Maybe he deletes a lot of comment and he seems to have a talent for gaming reddit, so I don't know. But a couple instances where he was trollish/ anything bad would be appreciated.
I wish I could search through my past posts, since it was months ago. I've actually specifically avoided him since because of it, but I had some strange interactions with him when he first joined.
Or just get moderators that are accountable.
I don't lie, which makes me accountable simply because of my personal choice to be honest, but if that were to change, Reddit wouldn't be aware of it. I've PMed moderators of r/IAmA asking to be a mod once, but nothing came of it.
However, rambling about myself aside, I don't think you're putting enough faith in the mods. I could absolutely trust karmanaut, saydrah, and qgyh2, simply because they are extremely well known Redditors. No offense to the rest of the mods, but I don't know them. I'm also not trusting them out of any sort of logic, only out of the thought that the fact they are so involved in the Reddit community gives them some level of credibility.
I do see your dilemma though, and share it to some degree. I don't think there is any solution except for us to trust the moderators, which I feel is easer to do now that MMM is gone. I really don't want to see r/IAmA go though, I've thoroughly enjoyed reading it daily and have learned many, many things I wouldn't know otherwise.
I'm a well-known Redditor, and I wouldn't trust me. I honestly haven't been following IAmA with any kind of frequency, but if anyone told me to "verify" anything about myself that could possibly get me in trouble, I'd tell them to pound sand. This ain't Wikileaks.
Yeah. There is something to be said to leaving it up the users and what they can get out of the thread.
And your opinion is a perfectly valid one. Like I said, my trust in them isn't based on any sort of logic, just my own opinion of them. I can completely understand your position, and assume many people also share it.
kleinbl00 flipped-the-fuck out once a few months ago.
Now he is back and nobody cares about his toy-throwing session. Although I must admit he didn't hold any personal and potentially damaging information.
[deleted]
I guess absolute trust was hyperbole on my part. I apologize. I still continue to have faith in many of the moderators on r/IAmA though.
I'd also agree that it does seem impractical and ridiculously difficult to find a mod that can be held legitimately accountable.
Like I said, my opinion is based on faith. I believe that the majority of mods are trustworthy, at least by my naive standards. I do agree that the ideal situation is one that creates the least need for moderator intervention.
Well, I think we can safely say that the Turing Test is behind us, as we no longer know if other personas on the internet are AIs or not. Neat.
Most of the moderation is already in the hands of redditors as a whole, at least in this subreddit. A lot of people seem to have a pretty inflated idea of what mods actually do- I'd say that at least 95% of what we do involves checking through the spam filter to see if there are posts which should not have been banned, looking at reported links and comments, and trying to keep things even vaguely on topic and interesting. Banning users happens far less frequently than a lot of people seem to think that it does- at this point in IAmA, with almost 35,000 subscribers and a subreddit that has been around for about six months, there are less than 100 users that have been banned. If you look at the traffic stats and see how many people go through here in a day, that's not a very high number. Obviously there are some subreddits (and some moderators) where there are people who abuse the system (r/marijuana seems to be everyone's favourite example), but for the most part, most mods are doing a decent job.
It does seem obvious that some people would like for mods to be more accountable, and I don't think that's unreasonable when people are trusting us with their personal information, especially in cases where that information could have repercussions if it's leaked. I'd like to see some discussion of how this could be implemented to keep things fair for everyone involved.
All of that said, and given that I'm only a mod on 5-6 other subreddits in addition to this one, I don't know very many mods who aren't already taking their responsibilities (especially with people's personal information) very seriously. I mod in a lot of mental health reddits, and we certainly screen and get to know potential mods very well before we ask them to join us, as we are dealing with very sensitive information in many cases. Part of the 'system' in those subreddits also comes down to the fact that mods also feel responsible to the other mods, and there is a lot of discussion about appropriate posts, bans, reports etc. behind the scenes, which is essential in either sensitive or large subreddits.
But in general, redditors do still control most of what happens in a subreddit through the voting process. Right now IAmA seems to be going through a phase where everyone wants to read about mental illness or sex, so that's what's being submitted and voted up. It might not be my personal view of what IAmA could be, but it's what the community apparently wants. I'd personally be happy if I never saw another pun thread either, but I'd be a pretty crappy mod if I just went ahead and banned them on that account.
And again, I'd welcome discussion on how to make mods accountable so that people could feel comfortable submitting personal information to us for verification purposes- although there really are few threads that we ask people to verify, there are some. It's not fair to present yourself as a specific individual if you are not that person (I believe that the question of verification first came up when someone claimed to be a semi-famous British comedian, and the real comedian got upset about it), but generally we don't ask for verification very often.
And as we've seen (not only in this subreddit), a rogue moderator can do a lot of damage to a subreddit if they want to, and anything reasonable that can prevent that would be pretty good in my opinion.
For that matter, every single post we've ever seen on any internet message board could have been made by some really advanced, deceptive [and cool] trolling program that passed the Turing Test. As far as I know, I exist (and I am sure each of you would say the same thing about yourselves), and I have met kn0thing in person at one of the xkcd book signings, and afaik xkcd is used by Randall Munroe, but the rest of you could just be an elaborate Matrix of bots posing as an advanced intellectual online community for my own benefit.
I've always wondered what the hell it is that convinces me that perfect strangers I meet on the internet are not just incredibly advanced AI scripts that have access to BBS accounts, and ICQ/AIM screen names. In a Cartesian/Schroedinger view, you do not really exist except in my mind - ghosts in a machine. It's possible that no actual humans could exist on the other side of any of these accounts, and that you are here for myself, kn0thing, and xkcd.
So then what is it that keeps me coming back to this place? My faith in humanity. The fact that I am willing to trust there are people on the other side of these accounts. That I am willing to put my heart out there and let myself be known to people and risk humiliation at the mere possibility of talking to bots, I don't mind at all. And in my opinion, this is all ontological - are we really here interacting with people, and what if anything does that mean for us? What is being and how does that impact our daily lives.
But hey, I can trust the likes of Saydrah and karmanaut. And I'm sure that you're not an AI script, GOLDMANBOT. GOLDMANBOT doesn't seem like an AI bot to me.
As for MMM, moderators are human, too, and make mistakes. I moderated a heavy forum back in the day, and I made plenty of huge mistakes - many of which probably drove our admin crazy. I'd give him a Red Card and tell him to take some time off to think about his life and how to properly pick up where he left off. If he can do that, then cool. If not, then throw him out.
As for IAMA, I had a good feeling this would happen once the subreddit reached critical mass. It was only a matter of time before trolls infiltrated and started bringing attention to themselves, and they overshadowed all the honest-yet-non-scandalous AMAs which provided a good deal of honest insight and perspective into our world. Everything has a Utopia period, and drowns on afterward with floods of n00bs, trolls, and morons. You cannot stop that from happening. The phenomenon is not new to the internet.
I don't trust saydrah at all. Not even a little bit.
I dunno, I find her judgmental agony aunt routine somewhat tedious, but she hasn't given me a reason not to trust her.
Upvoted for not trusting saydrah.
Cool.
Oh yeah? Well, you're so not invited to my birthday party anymore, pal! And what's more, I'm sending you a homemade look of disapproval for Secret Santa.
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmph.
Yeah, it seems that these 3 in particular have spent a lot of time on their "Reddit persona", and they seem to care about it enough to not jeopardize it.
I agree with you, but technically, the same could have been said about MMM not that long ago.
I think the moral here is a rather old one that we should all know by now: Don't share personal information with people you don't know.
do you think they're saving that up to pass on to their grandchildren? its worth nothing, especially to people risking their jobs and livelihood. look at that kid who got the American Airlines webdev fired. That shit is real. People get fired.
That would be my thought. Certainly if you didn't trust any of the other moderators, you could put a reasonable amount of faith in them to be responsible.
Well maybe you should say hi or something? Maybe ask us out for some coffee? Now you've made me sad.
I really like your answer here. Just thought you should know. That's all :)
I would love to go out for coffee, although I'll have hot chocolate instead because I don't drink coffee. Do you live in Canada and can drive out to a tiny rural town?
Sorry for making you sad D=
On a serious note, you help run an AWESOME subreddit. Thank you so much for all of this.
I LOVE YOU!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Hope that makes you all warm & fuzzy inside. :D
"I don't lie"
I've had a couple psycho ex-girlfriends tell me that before.
I did an AMA about it
I wouldn't call myself psycho, but I can't say for certain, because I'm not certain a psycho would realize if they were. However, I can say for certain I'm nobody's psycho ex-girlfriend, mainly because I lack a vagina.
MMM was that too...
Edit: Also qgyh2? Seriously? What makes you trust him? All he's ever done was post a gazillion posts and submissions. I don't even know if he's human!
What is wrong with getting a firm non-disclosure agreement signed? If moderators have the personal information of users, what is the harm of a standard non-disclosure agreement?
Just a question from a curious kiwi.
I don't think there's any harm to it, but it would be a bit of an undertaking and pretty much unprecedented on reddit. Moderators here have never been much more than a username informally handed a few extra powers.
Someone would have to get the site managers on board, and they would have to hire lawyers, verify the identity of all the mods, and get the contracts out to them. It would take time and money, but in my opinion it's necessary at this point.
Actually, I'm pretty sure they have a lawyer already for contracts, and to create a standard non-disclosure agreement isn't time consuming for a lawyer to draw up. Most companies have them. Especially when their good name is on the line.
I'm just sayin'...
I think this is the end of top-posting as we know it...
tl;dr
You haven't read the whole story, so don't go calling MMM unbalanced. Ask Me Which existed a month before IAmA is now completely moderator free. So go there, the whole verification thing was silly in the first place I think, and I will say I think the stylesheets were getting out of hand.
Salt, you always salt the snail. That is what I learned from Charlie.
There's no joy in salting someone. Everybody loses.
Everyone loses when you use tinypic.
I couldn't even get TinyPic to load, perhaps its something of this nature:
Salt the Snail!
I die a tiny bit every time I see your name.
Obscurity through anonymity.
Interestingly enough, I can still get the animated gif on a hat. Awesome.
Oh please, I'm just linking it as I found it...imgur doesn't even support animated gifs bigger than 2 megs (not that I blame them).
You don't want to salt the snail, but she give you no choice.
There's not enough salt in the world.
Send it to Reddit.
Soulja Boy Sucks