[deleted]•

How do you kill that which has no life?

141
Ciserus•

I think this is the end of IAmA as we know it. This place is no longer a safe haven for those who want to share their stories anonymously.

It never was, of course, but now it's become apparent. We have no idea which of these moderators whom we're trusting with sensitive information (and zero accountability) are normal and which are complete psychos. Any of them on that list could be as unbalanced as MMM.

No one with any sense is ever going to trust this "verification system" with their personal information again. Which means we either need to ditch the system (raising the troll threat again) or make these moderators sign legally binding non-disclosure agreements. I don't know if either solution is practical.

73
karmanautMOD•

I am an IAmA moderator and have shared a lot of personal info with Reddit. I'm facebook friends with a few people on here (and anyone can freely add me, just send me a PM), and multiple redditors have met me in real life, and know where I go to school, where I live, and have all my contact info. People on IAmA can trust us mods because we trust the community.

79
willis77•

Stop typing so fast. I can't read your screen very well today because I left my usual telescope at home and have to use these binoculars.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless Blackberry in a tree outside karmanaut's apartment

111
karmanaut•

waives penis at willis77

103
Ciserus•

You're probably the mod I would trust the most, but that still doesn't amount to much. What real world consequences would there be for you if you turned on us? I imagine your contact info would be posted, and you would get harassing phone calls for a few weeks. Maybe word would spill a little bit into your private social circle and you'd lose a couple of friends.

That might be enough of an assurance when the poster is a former Sears employee or a Hollywood actor who doesn't want to be linked to his stories about seeing an actress naked. But it won't cut it when people are posting things that could get them fired from high-paying jobs or expose pasts filled with sexual deviancy/abuse. I would sure be nervous right now if I'd shared something like that with you, however well-known you might be on here.

23
karmanaut•

Well, I don't really do the whole verification thing. If people are entertained by trolls, then so be it. Caveat Legens.

Anyway.

I know there isn't really anything I can say or do more than that to get people to trust me, and that's ok. You don't have to. I was just trying to refute Ciserus's "zero accountability" claim and show that most of us mods are quite sane.

12
jerrygofixit•

People on IAmA can trust us mods because we trust the community.

That's ironclad right there!

12

Could you enlighten us as to the whole situation. Hearsay and rumor is not helping trust in IAmA right now >> In Particular Saydrah's absence about the whole shin dig has been unnerving.

7
karmanaut•

I wish I could enlighten you, but I don't know the whole story myself. I IMed MMM this morning to try and talk about it but he was at work and couldn't talk.

From what I can tell: MMM added PhilxBefore as a mod here. A few weeks later, MMM PMed PhilxBefore and asked to be made a moderator of AskReddit. He was formerly a mod there, and was removed. PhilxBefore told the other AskReddit mods what he had asked. Saydrah, who mods both, told 32bites what happened. Saydrah seems to have been worried that MMM only added PhilxBefore to use that favor to get back into AskReddit.

32bites kicked MMM from the mod list. Marmorek re-added MMM, but both were then removed and marmorek deleted his account. MMM then went to his own subreddit and kicked up a shit storm. He is demanding that the custom styles he added here, like the gold verification star, be removed, and threatened (possibly jokingly) to give out private info from previously verified AMA posts.

24
inmatarian•

Can I have your gpg private key? It'll be cool, I won't do anything with it.

3
karmanaut•

I don't know what that is. I am pretty much computer illiterate. Sorry.

8
optimism•

I'm facebook friends with a few people on here (and anyone can freely add me, just send me a PM), and multiple redditors have met me in real life, and know where I go to school, where I live, and have all my contact info. People on IAmA can trust us mods because we trust the community.

MMM was the same in a lot of ways. Just saying that may not count for much.

3
Bensch•

Hi karmanaut!

I think the trust issue would be cleared up by a consent form for IAmA providers. It could be just as binding as a EULA...

3
Spytap•

The biggest problem, and the one which cicerus was pointing out, was that The whole premise was based on "trust me" and in fact certain topics were derailed because the person decided not to trust that mod (I'm thinking of the hollywood director in particular.) At the time, so many were arguing that the mods were trustworthy because the were mods and now we have this breakdown in the system which means that no one can feel comfortable that their promised anonymity is truly anonymous.

2
foolman89•

But i thought different people have access to your account?

1
Quady•

Just because you feel comfortable with all this, doesn't mean your info is safe. Now, i'm not advocating panic or anything, but yeah, just because you're fine, doesn't mean we're fine.

1
mynameisdevin•

lol, this comment is precious.

1
[deleted]•

I wish I could feel that way still, but over the past year I think my participation here has dropped off tremendously simply because I think the community has gotten bigger and bigger, to the point where I don't know who all is out there any more, and I don't think it feels like a community as much as it once did.

0
krispykrackers•

Did you like my status update today? Came up with that little jingle all by myself :)

(Okay, maybe I had a little help from Sublime)

-6
karmanaut•

I did. How is little P-Dub these days?

6
aennil•

I'm not sure why people are downvoting you. I myself am a big fan of individuals with entertaining status updates!

2
SecretSnack•

I think you're a pessimist.

15
Ciserus•

Well, it might not pan out that way in the real world. People might not stop trusting the system, but they honestly should. Given what we've seen here, you would be insane to trust these moderators with any sort of remotely damaging or embarrassing information. They have nothing to keep them honest besides their own sense of honor and their desire to maintain their flimsy online identities.

6
SecretSnack•

If someone has everything to lose by posting an IamA, then you're right. But I don't think that characterizes all or even most IamAs.

5
[deleted]•

I remember having conversations with MMM when he first got here a year ago, and thinking he was a troll originally. I was completely confused by how popular he seemed to get so quickly, and then I saw him as a mod, and I kinda lost faith in the mod system, even more so when he wasn't kicked out the first time he was the center of controversy for erasing comments he didn't like from his subreddits.

14
optimism•

What made you think he's a troll? I friended him about 6 months ago, and haven't seen anything trollish or anything like today. Maybe he deletes a lot of comment and he seems to have a talent for gaming reddit, so I don't know. But a couple instances where he was trollish/ anything bad would be appreciated.

1
[deleted]•

I wish I could search through my past posts, since it was months ago. I've actually specifically avoided him since because of it, but I had some strange interactions with him when he first joined.

4
AbsoluteTruth•

Or just get moderators that are accountable.

I don't lie, which makes me accountable simply because of my personal choice to be honest, but if that were to change, Reddit wouldn't be aware of it. I've PMed moderators of r/IAmA asking to be a mod once, but nothing came of it.

However, rambling about myself aside, I don't think you're putting enough faith in the mods. I could absolutely trust karmanaut, saydrah, and qgyh2, simply because they are extremely well known Redditors. No offense to the rest of the mods, but I don't know them. I'm also not trusting them out of any sort of logic, only out of the thought that the fact they are so involved in the Reddit community gives them some level of credibility.

I do see your dilemma though, and share it to some degree. I don't think there is any solution except for us to trust the moderators, which I feel is easer to do now that MMM is gone. I really don't want to see r/IAmA go though, I've thoroughly enjoyed reading it daily and have learned many, many things I wouldn't know otherwise.

8
kleinbl00•

I'm a well-known Redditor, and I wouldn't trust me. I honestly haven't been following IAmA with any kind of frequency, but if anyone told me to "verify" anything about myself that could possibly get me in trouble, I'd tell them to pound sand. This ain't Wikileaks.

47
S2S2S2S2S2•

Yeah. There is something to be said to leaving it up the users and what they can get out of the thread.

17
AbsoluteTruth•

And your opinion is a perfectly valid one. Like I said, my trust in them isn't based on any sort of logic, just my own opinion of them. I can completely understand your position, and assume many people also share it.

3
woo_hoo•

kleinbl00 flipped-the-fuck out once a few months ago.

Now he is back and nobody cares about his toy-throwing session. Although I must admit he didn't hold any personal and potentially damaging information.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

24
AbsoluteTruth•

I guess absolute trust was hyperbole on my part. I apologize. I still continue to have faith in many of the moderators on r/IAmA though.

I'd also agree that it does seem impractical and ridiculously difficult to find a mod that can be held legitimately accountable.

Like I said, my opinion is based on faith. I believe that the majority of mods are trustworthy, at least by my naive standards. I do agree that the ideal situation is one that creates the least need for moderator intervention.

2
[deleted]•

Well, I think we can safely say that the Turing Test is behind us, as we no longer know if other personas on the internet are AIs or not. Neat.

2
aenea•

keeping most of the moderation in the hands of redditors as a whole

Most of the moderation is already in the hands of redditors as a whole, at least in this subreddit. A lot of people seem to have a pretty inflated idea of what mods actually do- I'd say that at least 95% of what we do involves checking through the spam filter to see if there are posts which should not have been banned, looking at reported links and comments, and trying to keep things even vaguely on topic and interesting. Banning users happens far less frequently than a lot of people seem to think that it does- at this point in IAmA, with almost 35,000 subscribers and a subreddit that has been around for about six months, there are less than 100 users that have been banned. If you look at the traffic stats and see how many people go through here in a day, that's not a very high number. Obviously there are some subreddits (and some moderators) where there are people who abuse the system (r/marijuana seems to be everyone's favourite example), but for the most part, most mods are doing a decent job.

It does seem obvious that some people would like for mods to be more accountable, and I don't think that's unreasonable when people are trusting us with their personal information, especially in cases where that information could have repercussions if it's leaked. I'd like to see some discussion of how this could be implemented to keep things fair for everyone involved.

All of that said, and given that I'm only a mod on 5-6 other subreddits in addition to this one, I don't know very many mods who aren't already taking their responsibilities (especially with people's personal information) very seriously. I mod in a lot of mental health reddits, and we certainly screen and get to know potential mods very well before we ask them to join us, as we are dealing with very sensitive information in many cases. Part of the 'system' in those subreddits also comes down to the fact that mods also feel responsible to the other mods, and there is a lot of discussion about appropriate posts, bans, reports etc. behind the scenes, which is essential in either sensitive or large subreddits.

But in general, redditors do still control most of what happens in a subreddit through the voting process. Right now IAmA seems to be going through a phase where everyone wants to read about mental illness or sex, so that's what's being submitted and voted up. It might not be my personal view of what IAmA could be, but it's what the community apparently wants. I'd personally be happy if I never saw another pun thread either, but I'd be a pretty crappy mod if I just went ahead and banned them on that account.

And again, I'd welcome discussion on how to make mods accountable so that people could feel comfortable submitting personal information to us for verification purposes- although there really are few threads that we ask people to verify, there are some. It's not fair to present yourself as a specific individual if you are not that person (I believe that the question of verification first came up when someone claimed to be a semi-famous British comedian, and the real comedian got upset about it), but generally we don't ask for verification very often.

And as we've seen (not only in this subreddit), a rogue moderator can do a lot of damage to a subreddit if they want to, and anything reasonable that can prevent that would be pretty good in my opinion.

2
ontologicalninja•

I think qgyh2 is great and likeable as redditors go, but for all I could prove, he is a sophisticated AI script which collects information for a botnet.

For that matter, every single post we've ever seen on any internet message board could have been made by some really advanced, deceptive [and cool] trolling program that passed the Turing Test. As far as I know, I exist (and I am sure each of you would say the same thing about yourselves), and I have met kn0thing in person at one of the xkcd book signings, and afaik xkcd is used by Randall Munroe, but the rest of you could just be an elaborate Matrix of bots posing as an advanced intellectual online community for my own benefit.

I've always wondered what the hell it is that convinces me that perfect strangers I meet on the internet are not just incredibly advanced AI scripts that have access to BBS accounts, and ICQ/AIM screen names. In a Cartesian/Schroedinger view, you do not really exist except in my mind - ghosts in a machine. It's possible that no actual humans could exist on the other side of any of these accounts, and that you are here for myself, kn0thing, and xkcd.

So then what is it that keeps me coming back to this place? My faith in humanity. The fact that I am willing to trust there are people on the other side of these accounts. That I am willing to put my heart out there and let myself be known to people and risk humiliation at the mere possibility of talking to bots, I don't mind at all. And in my opinion, this is all ontological - are we really here interacting with people, and what if anything does that mean for us? What is being and how does that impact our daily lives.

But hey, I can trust the likes of Saydrah and karmanaut. And I'm sure that you're not an AI script, GOLDMANBOT. GOLDMANBOT doesn't seem like an AI bot to me.

As for MMM, moderators are human, too, and make mistakes. I moderated a heavy forum back in the day, and I made plenty of huge mistakes - many of which probably drove our admin crazy. I'd give him a Red Card and tell him to take some time off to think about his life and how to properly pick up where he left off. If he can do that, then cool. If not, then throw him out.

As for IAMA, I had a good feeling this would happen once the subreddit reached critical mass. It was only a matter of time before trolls infiltrated and started bringing attention to themselves, and they overshadowed all the honest-yet-non-scandalous AMAs which provided a good deal of honest insight and perspective into our world. Everything has a Utopia period, and drowns on afterward with floods of n00bs, trolls, and morons. You cannot stop that from happening. The phenomenon is not new to the internet.

1
sapphireblue•

I don't trust saydrah at all. Not even a little bit.

20
Seppuki•

I dunno, I find her judgmental agony aunt routine somewhat tedious, but she hasn't given me a reason not to trust her.

3
AmazingMaze•

Upvoted for not trusting saydrah.

2
AbsoluteTruth•

Cool.

0
Saydrah•

Oh yeah? Well, you're so not invited to my birthday party anymore, pal! And what's more, I'm sending you a homemade look of disapproval for Secret Santa.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmph.

0
Seppuki•

I could absolutely trust karmanaut, saydrah, and qgyh2, simply because they are extremely well known Redditors.

Yeah, it seems that these 3 in particular have spent a lot of time on their "Reddit persona", and they seem to care about it enough to not jeopardize it.

9
[deleted]•

..their "Reddit persona", and they seem to care about it enough to not jeopardize it.

I agree with you, but technically, the same could have been said about MMM not that long ago.

I think the moral here is a rather old one that we should all know by now: Don't share personal information with people you don't know.

28
[deleted]•

do you think they're saving that up to pass on to their grandchildren? its worth nothing, especially to people risking their jobs and livelihood. look at that kid who got the American Airlines webdev fired. That shit is real. People get fired.

2
AbsoluteTruth•

That would be my thought. Certainly if you didn't trust any of the other moderators, you could put a reasonable amount of faith in them to be responsible.

1
dearsomething•

No offense to the rest of the mods, but I don't know them.

Well maybe you should say hi or something? Maybe ask us out for some coffee? Now you've made me sad.

8
tootall113•

I really like your answer here. Just thought you should know. That's all :)

1
AbsoluteTruth•

I would love to go out for coffee, although I'll have hot chocolate instead because I don't drink coffee. Do you live in Canada and can drive out to a tiny rural town?

Sorry for making you sad D=

On a serious note, you help run an AWESOME subreddit. Thank you so much for all of this.

0
FillInTheBlank•

I LOVE YOU!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

Hope that makes you all warm & fuzzy inside. :D

-1
[deleted]•

"I don't lie"
I've had a couple psycho ex-girlfriends tell me that before.

5
AbsoluteTruth•

I did an AMA about it

I wouldn't call myself psycho, but I can't say for certain, because I'm not certain a psycho would realize if they were. However, I can say for certain I'm nobody's psycho ex-girlfriend, mainly because I lack a vagina.

7
optimism•

I could absolutely trust karmanaut, saydrah, and qgyh2, simply because they are extremely well known Redditors.

MMM was that too...

Edit: Also qgyh2? Seriously? What makes you trust him? All he's ever done was post a gazillion posts and submissions. I don't even know if he's human!

4
uiuiuiu•

What is wrong with getting a firm non-disclosure agreement signed? If moderators have the personal information of users, what is the harm of a standard non-disclosure agreement?

Just a question from a curious kiwi.

2
Ciserus•

I don't think there's any harm to it, but it would be a bit of an undertaking and pretty much unprecedented on reddit. Moderators here have never been much more than a username informally handed a few extra powers.

Someone would have to get the site managers on board, and they would have to hire lawyers, verify the identity of all the mods, and get the contracts out to them. It would take time and money, but in my opinion it's necessary at this point.

2
uiuiuiu•

Actually, I'm pretty sure they have a lawyer already for contracts, and to create a standard non-disclosure agreement isn't time consuming for a lawyer to draw up. Most companies have them. Especially when their good name is on the line.

I'm just sayin'...

2
[deleted]•

I think this is the end of top-posting as we know it...

1
lulz•
1
inserthandle•

You haven't read the whole story, so don't go calling MMM unbalanced. Ask Me Which existed a month before IAmA is now completely moderator free. So go there, the whole verification thing was silly in the first place I think, and I will say I think the stylesheets were getting out of hand.

1
HaroldPlease•

Salt, you always salt the snail. That is what I learned from Charlie.

45
moriya•
12
[deleted]•

Everyone loses when you use tinypic.

58
[deleted]•

I couldn't even get TinyPic to load, perhaps its something of this nature:

Salt the Snail!

8
[deleted]•

I die a tiny bit every time I see your name.

Obscurity through anonymity.

2
Toma-•

Interestingly enough, I can still get the animated gif on a hat. Awesome.

2
moriya•

Oh please, I'm just linking it as I found it...imgur doesn't even support animated gifs bigger than 2 megs (not that I blame them).

1
[deleted]•

You don't want to salt the snail, but she give you no choice.

8
Holzmann•

There's not enough salt in the world.

6
[deleted]•

Send it to Reddit.

3
throway•

Soulja Boy Sucks

-7
SaydrahMOD•

Please do not panic.

The remaining moderators are aware of MMM's threats and are doing all that we can in order to ensure that nobody's privacy is compromised. If MMM has your personal information and its release could endanger you in any way (including embarrassment) feel free to PM me and I will take specific additional measures to protect you to the best of my ability.

As for those who sent personal information to moderators other than MMM, he doesn't have access to that, nor will he. We don't keep any type of group database of verification information. The mod you sent it to is the only one who has it.

In response to the people who will probably show up and say "why don't you just give him what he wants?" He would still have all the information he has now if his demands were met. Nothing would stop him from releasing private information anyway. The last thing we want is to provide an incentive for MMM to make further threats toward our users.

133
[deleted]•

Much more than this, I'm interested in hear your response to why you personally went after him, and got 32bites to remove some of the IAmA moderator staff (that readded MMM) in a war directly against MMM. I'm particularly curious about:

Saydrah's main justification was that she was experienced with mental patients, my behavior was very similar, and that everything would be sooooo much easier for her if I just admitted it.

Did you use your clout as a poweruser to have multiple moderators removed at your whim based on your suspicion that MMM is "mentally unstable".

I've known MMM for the entire time I've been here, much better than I've known you, and this sudden shift against him is really particularly strange, and he would never do anything to compromise the personal data of verified users, (as he's said over and over and over again...)

Seriously, why did you go on a warpath against him?

It's scary to know that you, a singular user, have such power over subreddits and the moderators, that you can use your 'ties' to get your personal will done regardless of why or what effect it will have on a community here.

189
optimism•

Found out that the newest AskReddit mod was a guy I broke some bones for earlier. Asked him if he would add me there without asking the others, because I did the same for him in IAmA 20+ days prior because he was a trusted friend. There were three scenarios: (a) he wouldn't, (b) they'd kick me off, or (c) I'd kick myself off before the others noticed. He consulted the other mods, as a new mod should, and they said NO, because they had a prior beef with me from months earlier. Saydrah overreacted without talking to me, and went to the IAmA creator 32bites directly (instead of consulting our moderating peers) to tell himn how horrible of a person I am. Before telling the other mods, and before contacting me, 32bites trusted her opinion and deleted me from the mod list. I didn't know anything that happened after I asked 'the new guy'.

After a period of time that I'm unaware of, a user contacted me privately, saying that he had been following me to get the Rogert Eberts IAmA that I still had not posted. The user was baffled that I wasn't on the moderator list anymore. Obviously, I was even more baffled when he told me. I didn't believe him one bit. So many things had happened sing I asked 'the new guy', that I had no idea who in their right mind would kick me off the list after everything I've done for that subreddit.

So I go to contact four mods. The top two, then noticed the guy I trained wasn't active anymore, then contacted a mod I was friendly with. That guy responded after a while with "[I don't know anything about it. Sorry bud. Contact the top guy.]". The other two never contacted me back about it. Never responded at all.

16 hours passed, and I notice that the top guy has a comment or two in my waiting time. What an assbag. Clearly I'm not getting an answer out of any of these people privately, and I noticed I was kicked from the mod subreddit which is controlled by the top guy... so I knew for a fact that the top guy--32bites--was responsible for banning me, and I knew I had the support of a whole lot of users for my contributions, and I knew I couldn't do it privately, so I made the issue public.

Of course, Saydrah assumed I was a cheeky little devil with the worst intentions in mind, so tried shooting me down saying that I knew all along why I was kicked. (I figured it had nothing to do with IAmA... why would it affect me here? Plus, I'd forgotten about it entirely). Then went on to argue how I should have discussed it privately, and other crap that I had already tried.

After a while, one of the other top mods, mamorek, found my post, knew my removal must have been a mistake somehwere, and added me back to the mod list. The second mod (the other mod who still hadn't contacted me) kicked me off the list again and said I needed to contact 32bites (GAH! fuck you! I did!). Later, mamorek messaged me and said "[I'm really sorry about all this. I just added you back.]". Great guy. Clearly, not all the mods supported 32bites' decision. A whole lot of other users supported me in that thread as well. After a while, I was notified that mamorek had been removed from the moderator list as well, without being notified, and he soon deleted his account. Believe me when I say he was a great mod. His account will be missed.

One of the mods anonymously sent me a screenshot from the private mod subreddit, shwoing the discussion between the moderators. Saydrah's main justification was that she was experienced with mental patients, my behavior was very similar, and that everything would be sooooo much easier for her if I just admitted it. Of course I never got to respond to this, because it was private and I had no access. I'll respond to it now: "Fucking rude! I was a great IAmA mod, and I'm here as a reddit mod to help people. You're here doing a terrible job. Hold on to fallacies too long and they'll bite you in the ass!"

How that whole thread ended, and still continues, is me 1) waiting for 32bites' message that Saydrah still seems to assume me will pop into my inbox some day, and 2) waiting for the moderators to remove all the cool stuff I've added to this subreddit, since they think my contributions aren't enough to even talk to me about. Both of these pending issues are adressed in Saydrah's lazy response here.

Kicking me off the list for such an innocent thing (I wanted to know how good I was friends with 'the new guy') was bad. Not communicating to me at all about it was worse. Calling me psycho in private was even worse. Knowing that said "psycho" was in the possession of dozens and dozens of innocent individuals' private information (Incriminating photographs, birth certificates, college and high school diplomas, invoices, names, email accounts, etc.), and not responding at all to requests of simply erasing the stylsheet that I made? Now that's psychotic. Above all, what I discovered with the current IAmA mods was that their inability to communicate has jeopardized the privacy of dozens upon dozens of individuals, and they don't seem to give a damn. Not a damn. THAT is why I want the stylesheet erased, and THAT is why I hope people stop submitting to IAmA. The mods are juggling around your delicate identities and they don't give a fuck if a handful of handfuls slip through the cracks and potentially ruin people's lives. THAT is why I have begun to promote r/AskMe.

I actually created r/AskMe a month before 32bites made IAmA. Back then I didn't know 32bites would powertrip so hard, and jeopardize so many user's private information. I don't expect people to unsubscribe from IAmA, because undoubtedly there are going to be some interesting posts there still, but I would never recommend anyone to submit there, because if they're ever demanded verification, they have to give it to a corrupt group of people who are willing to have your private info put into the public sphere, and also can't seem to communicate between themselves, let alone their users. They lie, cheat and steal... and they used me to gain traffic until they were a default reddit, then kicked me off like I was a piece of gum stuck to their desk.

This is what MMM wrote on r/askme.

He does seem childish after repeatedly writing he'd release information, so trusting him is probably out of the question at this point, but Saydrah and 32bites are at fault as well.

Edit: Nope. MMM is being really shady with the CSS hacks. I don't trust him anymore.

17
metamorphosis•

Knowing that said "psycho" was in the possession of dozens and dozens of innocent individuals' private information (Incriminating photographs, birth certificates, college and high school diplomas, invoices, names, email accounts, etc.), and not responding at all to requests of simply erasing the stylsheet that I made? Now that's psychotic. Above all, what I discovered with the current IAmA mods was that their inability to communicate has jeopardized the privacy of dozens upon dozens of individuals, and they don't seem to give a damn. Not a damn.

I am bellow than average redditor...and I don't know who is who (apart from few 'power users') ...but in all honesty I don't see anything threatening here, or that he explicitly said that he will release information. What the guy is saying here is that - ...if he is what the mods are accusing of what he is or thinking he is (a 'psycho') ...why then they don't communicate better with such person..since person with such attributes [that they are accusing him of] has personal info of IAmAs submitters. Ignoring that (or him) and acting in which the mods are acting towrads such person can "jeopardize privacy of individuals"

In other words he is simply saying "if you think I am psycho, well why are you then behaving in such manner when I have lots of personal information about users" implying that the mods are not caring about Iama users, and they should communicate better. Simply as that.

Not a singe threat here, but simply (imho) showing that mods should act more maturely when dealing with other mods who have such information.

True that this is not really a mature approach, and it can scare the shit out of people...but also I think guys is trying to make a point here to the mods that they are not acting for the better of community and or privacy of the individuals when dealing with such issues as "kicking out a 'psycho' moderator" Not that he is, but pointing out to the mods "what if I am?"

EDIT: and whoever created this submission and showing to us [somewhat regular readers] all the dirty laundry it's making the things worser fro IAma subreddit and community in general. I wouldn't have know about this crap if this was not submitted. Not that i care as much.

33
selectrix•

Did he write about releasing information somewhere else? Because I'm very inclined to agree with metamorphosis here if not.

6
Altoid_Addict•

He did. But I don't think I have the whole story anyway.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

42
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

That's crazy talk. There are not such things as powerusers on Reddit. There are people who make lots of submissions and make lots of comments. They get lots of Karma and are, in general, well known by the Reddit community.

Really? So 32bites is not a poweruser? He doesn't have absolute control over over one of the most popular subreddits?

I'm sorry but that's pretty much the definition of a poweruser.

You should really re-read what he is saying, via his user page. He has made numerous threats to share all the data users shared with him if we don't "delete his CSS". Which, to be quite honest, was not entirely his. Other users had their hands in it. Furthermore, it's the property of Reddit once it gets here.

I did read it. I see about five "I would never, ever" post comments, and not a single "I would absolutely do it if they don't meet my demands", and I went back a few pages.

What seems most likely is that he was playing chicken, and goading the mods into replying to him. Wrong? Yes. Evidence that he would? Doubtful.

13
1338h4x•

And at the same time he's astonished that his threat wasn't taken seriously. Seems a tad contradictory.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
optimism•

He's using CSS hacks in r/AskMe to "hide" things he's really saying - that's wildly manipulative.

Please explain.

2
dearsomething•

Look here first.

You can see he says "I have nothing but respect for the IAmA mods...", and then follows up in a response to his with "Did you see the CSS hack I did on that?"

And if you look at his user profile, scroll down about half way:

MercurialMadnessMan [S] -1 points0 points1 point 22 hours ago[-]

I have no respect for the IAmA mods. Namely, 32bites and Saydrah

He goes on to explain his CSS hack in r/AskMe. He's using it so you can't click on his comments within r/AskMe (to prevent copying and pasting), and so that the front he puts on in r/AskMe is a facade - he's still being a dick, but covering it up.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
matt45•

Wait. What?

There is a private subreddit where we discuss things.

We? Who the fuck is "we"?

0
dearsomething•

The moderators of this subreddit.

There are a lot of private subreddits. Mods use them to exchange information and let each other know which accounts are basically just spamming.

5
[deleted]•

Thats it exactly you nailed it! , Its white night syndrome with saydrah leading the pitchfork mob. She has a large following , I guess it causes lonely redditors to not be able to think for themselves.

"Saydrah's main justification was that she was experienced with mental patients"

Mental Patients??? haha!! Google her userid and then talk about mental patients... Anyone signed up to that many social networking sites might have some personal issues themselves

Go down this list and look at all the sites she is apart of, and then lets talk about mental problems

She either has mental issues, or befriends online communities for her own benefit, or work. As she did with the IaMa post she boosted to the top about some film, basically she social engineered reddit into being a walking billboard for some movie.......

-8
rmuser•

Since when does "number of social networks joined" correlate to "personal issues"?

1
[deleted]•

compulsive behavior or, she is trying to work her way into lots of online communities so she can further any agenda she sees fit. I am thinking this might be what she does for work.

But its really social engineering

-1
Saydrah•

Saydrah's main justification was that she was experienced with mental patients, my behavior was very similar, and that everything would be sooooo much easier for her if I just admitted it.

That's false. I'm not experienced with mental patients. I've worked, as a coworker in an equal setting, with people who have neurological differences that cause them to behave in unusual ways. I wonder if MMM might have a similar difference. I said I'd have an easier time understanding him if I knew if anything like that was present.

Seriously, why did you go on a warpath against him?

I didn't. Something happened which 32 as the subreddit creator had a right to know. I notified him. I've always said that I don't dislike MMM, he just confuses me a lot. I don't understand him. At this point I do dislike him because of the way he's handled this, but at the time everything happened, I argued for him to be retained as a moderator but 32 made a different decision and I agreed to abide by it.

-17
[deleted]•

Interesting. Well, then, I still must put fault solely at 32's feet for this debacle. MMM is a good guy, isn't releasing information, and has done an astronomical amount of good for IAmA, and other subreddits.

To drop him, and sympathizers, without warning, without response and refusing to talk about it is terrible.

And because IAmA is ultimately in the hands of someone willing to do that, to just start sacking people without asking questions, I have to support MMM in r/AskMe.

Let me say this just once:

##IAmA IS NOT 32's SUBREDDIT##

It's all of ours. It's OUR place, not his.

It's scary as shit to realize that what makes Reddit great, IAmA, AskReddit, etc, are all at the whim of people who quite frankly, don't appear to be qualified to run them well.

I mean, seriously, objectively -- how is 32 doing anything but abusing his power to the detriment of the IAmA community?

52
AbsoluteTruth•

... That's quite a lot of spew there. He already admitted in a post that he threatened to release private information, and that is absolutely good enough for me to say fuck that guy. The fact that you're implying MMM is more capable of running r/IAmA after that is ridiculous.

13
KeyboardHero•

IAmA IS NOT 32's SUBREDDIT

I'm going to have to disagree with you there. He created it, therefore it is his.

Don't get me wrong, I see your point. But there's a big distinction between a subreddit run by redditors and a subreddit created for redditors. The former places power in the hands of the community, the latter in the hands of the mods.

This isn't a matter of being power hungry, it's just the nature of creating subreddits.

-1
purplerain•

MercurialMadnessMan is not a "good guy", he's a giant douchebag. Just ask the guys in r/atheism why he was kicked out.

-1
Saydrah•

He felt that the problem I notified him of showed that MMM couldn't be trusted with the unique responsibilities of an IAmA mod, including responsible stewardship of personal information. That conclusion seems to be correct now, though I disagreed at the time.

I'm all for r/AskMe. The more subreddits the better. r/AskUsers was Karmanaut's AskReddit alternative and even though Karma and I both still love AskReddit I enjoyed AskUsers until it became pretty much inactive.

-2
Seppuki•

Why did you guyz remove marmorek?

7
Saydrah•

He kept re-adding MMM at a particularly volatile moment when MMM was busily posting drunken (by his own admission) diatribes against me, 32 and r/Iama. I'm not sure where things stand with Marmorek now. I believe he apologized and asked to be re-added, then changed his mind and retracted the request.

ETA: Actually, I now see Marmorek has deleted his account.

4
MercurialMadnessMan•

That guy put in a lot of effort. They didn't even talk to him first. He deleted his account.

You'll be missed, marmorek,

3
raptosaurus•

Something happened which 32 as the subreddit creator had a right to know

And that would be...?

4
Saydrah•

Some drama in AskReddit that involved r/Iama. MMM said, a long time after the fact, that it was an "innocent test of friendship" though I'm not sure what exactly is innocent about asking someone to do something sleazy to prove they're your friend. In any case, what it appeared to be was MMM using his position in IAmA as a bargaining chip to get favors in other subreddits.

8
roger_•

Did MMM get de-modded from IAMA because of the McDonalds thing?

16
shadowsurge•

What was the "McDonalds thing"? I guess I missed something.

26
[deleted]•

An executive at McD's made an AmA and MMM told him to prove it to get verification and the executive didn't want to so he stopped the AmA.

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/9z2ux/i_am_a_mcdonalds_key_executive_ama/

22
smpx•

MMM stopped the AmA? I didn't know mods had the capacity to do that.

9
[deleted]•

A (person who claims to be an) executive at McD's

fixed

3
tjragon•

Regardless of MMM actions, that guy was clearly a troll.

1
[deleted]•

I thought that was why we had moderators in the first place.

1
MercurialMadnessMan•

I was getting "troll" complaints for that guy left and right. Admittedly, I should have asked the crowd if they wanted him to give verification. Regardless, the way he pulled out of the thread was excatly what some people said they expected a troll to do, so who knows

-3
happybadger•

An ex-executive from McDonalds posted. MMM flipped dick because he wouldn't offer proof of his identity, which in retrospect is a good choice because MMM is a terrorist mastermind. McDonald's guy told IamA to fuck off and left.

If this subreddit was World War 2, that would be the battle of Iwo Jima on the scale of serious business events.

21
waxpoet•

hyperbole much?

7
urish•
0
Saydrah•

No. It was a different issue. The McDonalds thing I believe was an innocent mistake on MMM's part. It led to some discussion among the mods and agreement that we'd approach things a little differently in similar situations in the future, so while it's really a shame that an interesting AMA got killed, the mistake led to positive changes in IAmA overall.

19
[deleted]•

can you explain to a confused onlooker why you decided to say he was a psycho? I don't agree/disagree, I just want to know why.

13
krappy•

Have you read this?

8
ikean•

I've just been reading over some of his stuff myself, and I'm definitely starting to believe he has some sort of abnormality. He swings all too easily from these bizarre tangents to acting polite and innocent, batting his emoticon eye lashes.

1
Saydrah•

He's misrepresenting a statement that I made. Because of some unusual ways that he communicates, I've wondered for a long time if MMM has a neurological difference that makes him seem a little "off" to neurotypical people. I said privately that I wished MMM would tell us if that were the case so we could understand him better. I guess someone sent him that comment and interpreted it as me thinking he's a "psycho." That's really the opposite of what I said; I was trying to put the kindest possible interpretation on his behavior by saying that perhaps I simply don't understand something about him.

-6
[deleted]•

No. It was a different issue.

So why was he de-modded? No opinion on whether it was a good move, but I have not seen any explanation of why.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
Saydrah•

Thanks for understanding.

4
James_Johnson•

I will take specific additional measures to protect you to the best of my ability.

What "additional measures" do you have at your disposal?

11
Saydrah•

I don't want to make too many public statements about that, but I can assure you that he will gain no traction with any use of Reddit to distribute private information on IamA posters.

1
James_Johnson•

I'm still not satisfied with this answer. If he has the information in his inbox he can communicate it to whomever he wants using whatever non-reddit channels he feels like.

Seriously, apart from slapping him with a gag order somehow I don't see how there's very much you can do.

19
Saydrah•

There's not a lot we can do about things outside Reddit, though we do have some strategies in place if something does happen; but I think the only way he'd get any traction or viewership for a release like that would be to use Reddit. Not many people outside our community care who's behind IAmA posts.

-6
[deleted]•

Nothing, she's just trying to appear cooler/nicer than she actually is able to be. Standard-issue Saydrah.

1
uriel•

The remaining moderators are aware of MMM's threats and are doing all that we can in order to ensure that nobody's privacy is compromised. If MMM has your personal information and its release could endanger you in any way (including embarrassment) feel free to PM me and I will take specific additional measures to protect you to the best of my ability.

What kind of reassurance is this? Are you a politician? "Trust me, I will take care of everything, there is nothing to worry about as long as I'm in charge!" Oh dear...

Ah, this whole thing reminds me so much of irc channel politics! So much fuss over so little...

11
llamaspit•

Agreed. What reddit needs is eggdrop.

3
exoendo•

I don't like how MMM reacted, and I don't like how you and the others mods reacted. You all come off as dickish to me

11
MockDeath•

This is rather sad that this situation came to be. I guess it shows it was a good thing he lost his moderation privileges if such threats have been issued. Though on a down side it will now ruin a lot of trust people may have with the mods of the AMA subreddit. Personally if I was in your guys shoes I would try to come up with a way to make people feel safer when doing a confirmed identity AMA post..

10
SaydrahMOD•

I'm giving that a lot of thought. I can't think of any way to prove to submitters that their information has been completely deleted after receipt. I did just go back through my own stuff and make sure I've deleted all the personal information I had on people--I have a very strong, near photographic visual memory for names and numbers, so I remember a lot of it, but I'm not retaining it in any written form.

We're definitely open to ideas about securing the verification process.

0
raptosaurus•

Here's a thought, for every piece of personal info you receive, send some back! That way you'll have a disincentive to not spread it around.

I'm only half-kidding. The only one of you mods I would trust with my personal info is Karmanaut, no offense, because he's already posted so much of his own info here.

5
Saydrah•

That's actually not a bad idea, but I might alter it to say that the mods must have access to each other's private information and any mod who leaks a user's information will have theirs released.

3
ShawnGupta•

There's the m4m on CL for that.

1
MockDeath•

Sadly there is no way to ensure the data doesn't stick around some where. That and it would be an impossible task. About the best I can think of is if there was a legal contract that would allow repercussions over leaked information, and that is not a good answer either for a few reasons.. It may just need time for this whole argument to pass from peoples minds.

I am not sure what all goes on when you guys confirm an identity, can a submitter pick what mod they work through? Some people have more trust for a name they know and talk with.

1
Saydrah•

Yes, submitters are free to pick the mod of their choice. That will not ever change.

2
raptosaurus•

MercurialMadnessMan

And you say you had no idea he was a psycho? I joke, I joke.

Also, what's a stylesheet?

9
Saydrah•

It's a bit of code that can be altered to do cool stuff like the strikethrough for non-self posts and the gold stars for verified posts.

4
raptosaurus•

That's it? Seriously? He threatened to cause a huge privacy breach and singlehandedly ruin IAMA(IAMAgate O_o) over formatting? What is he, a Karl Rove incarnate?

18
Saydrah•

He threatened to cause a huge privacy breach and singlehandedly ruin IAMA(IAMAgate O_o) over formatting?

Yep.

9
[deleted]•

No. He started making threats after he was kicked off as a moderator from IAMA. Saydrah is wrong.

3
strolls•

It seems like he wants to take away IAMA's ability to verify - or to clearly indicate that posts have been verified. It's kinda about more than mere formatting.

3
skooma714•

Madness?

0
[deleted]•

The remaining moderators are aware of MMM's threats and are doing all that we can in order to ensure that nobody's privacy is compromised.

In response to the people who will probably show up and say "why don't you just give him what he wants?" He would still have all the information he has now if his demands were met. Nothing would stop him from releasing private information anyway. The last thing we want is to provide an incentive for MMM to make further threats toward our users.

These two statements do not fit together, unless you have a strong suspicion that removing the content in question would INCREASE the likelihood of him releasing the personal information. That seems incredibly unlikely and I'd like to hear why you think that if it is the case.

No, removing the content does not preclude MMM releasing the private information, but you'd be hard pressed to argue that it will have no effect.

If it is not the case (I don't think a logical person can come to any other conclusion), then you're not doing everything you can to protect the identities of IAmA posters, and you shouldn't claim that you are.

5
Saydrah•

That seems incredibly unlikely and I'd like to hear why you think that if it is the case.

He'd still have all the private information. If he would release it to get a few lines of CSS deleted, then what's stopping him from making his next demand, "All right, now make me a mod again and remove everyone else, giving me sole control of the subreddit?"

We may decide to change the CSS to have the same features without using his code, but we're not going to send a message that we'll give him whatever he wants for making threats.

0
[deleted]•

He'd still have all the private information. If he would release it to get a few lines of CSS deleted, then what's stopping him from making his next demand, "All right, now make me a mod again and remove everyone else, giving me sole control of the subreddit?"

Then you respond by saying "I met your demands already" and you ignore it. The slippery slope argument makes no sense if you can just ignore the next request, no matter how small. Make that a stipulation for you deleting the style sheet information.

We may decide to change the CSS to have the same features without using his code, but we're not going to send a message that we'll give him whatever he wants for making threats.

Nobody, not me, not even MMM, is suggesting that. Either get written confirmation from him that he will make no further requests and then delete the code, or delete the code and tell him that you will fulfull no further requests. But don't tell people you're doing everything you can if you're not. We're not stupid, don't talk to us like we are.

6
Saydrah•

get written confirmation from him that he will make no further requests

I don't trust his word, in writing or otherwise. If I did, I wouldn't be worried at all, since after this started blowing up he promised in writing that no matter what he wouldn't release personal information, claiming that he never actually meant his original threat.

0
lastres0rt•

It's very akin to how you should treat a stalker.

Giving in to a stalker's demands on any level "encourages" them to keep up their behavior. The only response you should give a stalker is in the form of legal action.

So... yeah, meeting his demands == giving in == giving MMM carte blanche to do it again / collect more sensitive info, since he knows the mods will just cave in again for him next time.

0
Senator_Roberts•

I think this whole thing is ridiculous and petty. ESPECIALLY on reddit, leadership squabbles like this should be handled out in the open. For as long as I've been a member reddit has prided itself on being just a little more adult than other sites (occasional 4chan memes aside). I agree with the other users that this kerfuffle could, potentially, damage significantly the reddit experience and reddit's opinion of itself.

Couldn't problems like this by resolved by members of a subreddit voting on their moderators? That way the creator of a subreddit doesn't necessarily hold any more power over it than anyone else--and doesn't necessarily become an insta-mod. In theory, it would also allow the reddit community to decide how it's governed and by whom, and to reward certain leadership styles over others.

4
Seppuki•

WE DON'T BOW TO THREATS!!!!!

3
abends•

BOWGATE

4
itjitj•

And my AXEGATE

8
frozenfire•

I guffaw'd.

0
smpx•

One thing I'm still confused by-- MMM says that he designed or coded or invented some of the stuff that AMA uses, and that he'd like for you to take it down.

What's this all about, and are you looking to take it down?

2
Saydrah•

He coded some of the special features. Others he's claiming rights to because he requested someone else make the code and they did, then he put it into the stylesheet.

We're looking into replacing it with alternate code that would do the same thing and cause no major disruption for viewers, but no decision has been made and I'm a big fail at CSS so it's really not my decision to make. However, some of the features MMM claims are his property were my ideas that he took and paired with code somebody else made.

5
fishbert•

whether it's his property or not, it falls under the "Use Of Material Supplied By You" section of the reddit user agreement:

Except as expressly provided otherwise in the Privacy Policy, you agree that by posting messages, uploading files, inputting data, or engaging in any other form of communication with or through the Website, you grant us a royalty-free, perpetual, non-exclusive, unrestricted, worldwide license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, translate, enhance, transmit, distribute, publicly perform, display, or sublicense any such communication in any medium (now in existence or hereinafter developed) and for any purpose, including commercial purposes, and to authorize others to do so.

In short, MMM already told reddit it can do whatever it likes with the stylesheet. No backsies!

8
krispykrackers•

Exactly. Conde Naste owns that shiz, not MMM or me, or you, or Bigfoot.

7
krispykrackers•

Copypasta it to his inbox. Problem solved.

It's text on a screen for fuck's sake. It doesn't belong to anyone.

6
Saydrah•

Upvoted for making me laugh for the first time all thread. That's great.

3
zem•

Copypasta it to his inbox. Problem solved.

i like you (:

1
Xiol•

What we need is an [A] with database access.

MMM can't keep his inbox against the powers of a DBA.

1
[deleted]•

Yes he can, it's called copy and paste.

17
Xiol•

UpvoteThis is clearly supporting terrorism by giving them ideas.

10
Saydrah•

You're right about that. MMM's email inbox is a concern, though. I don't know if anyone has sent him verification information outside of Reddit.

3
happybadger•

What's to say he doesn't have a .RTF with the information stowed away on his computer?

4
Xiol•

.RTF?

2001 called, they said they want their file format back.

/s

14
LookMumATroll•

Have you got in touch with him yet? Because if not then everything said in that post is useless and this could have been solved before it blew up.

1
NadsatBrat•

There are three relevant questions haven't been asked in this gigantic thread. Care to answer them?

  • Why do you still have the info from the CoS architect guy?

  • Do you work for Associated Content?

  • As a corollary to that, are you paid to submit content from them or affiliated sites?

1
Saydrah•
  • I don't have access to it anymore aside from one way to contact him anonymously (to see if he's still safe), but I'm not confident that it's gone enough that I couldn't be targeted by them. I don't want to give details on why I feel that way (who knows when a CoS lawyer is reading this?) but it's based on a conversation with a Redditor who has a great deal of experience in a relevant field.
  • I'm not going to give details on my employment. If you have a problem with that, I invite you to come live with me and be my personal security guard. It's not hard to track me down online, but I'd like you to please keep it private if you decide to do so, because I have received some really ugly threats from Redditors. I don't typically take that stuff seriously but there's no reason to make it easy for someone with a grudge to take things from Reddit into the real world.
  • I am not paid to submit content from any site. I'm paid to be a "social media expert" although I hate being called an expert or guru or any BS like that. I do shit like giving power point presentations about branding and identity in online media. I get to Reddit at work because "being aware of social media trends" is part of my job.
4
rospaya•

As a corollary to that, are you paid to submit content from them or affiliated sites?

I don't see the relevance in that. Reddit is a social site which means that popular support is crucial for getting on the first page. If it is interesting or in any other way relevant to our fellow redditors, it will get upvoted. Someones motive for posting doesn't matter.

0
NadsatBrat•

It's relevant because it's an accusation leveled several times in the main thread that MMM submitted and (afaik) she hadn't answered it yet.

Do you really think motive doesn't matter at all? Curious, do you think a spammer for one domain, who never/rarely comments, gets high submission karma, and is promoting an agenda (instead of a service or product) is a positive contributor to reddit? Saydrah isn't one of those of course but I come across several each day when I look for material for /reportthespammers. I'm just saying it's not hard to identify the fact that motive is a problem sometimes. And I admit I don't like it when the admins admit to not minding people game reddit unless they attract tons of attention (e.g. Brent Csutoras, etc).

2
rospaya•

Well, if people upvote the link it's not spam anymore, if it's real people, not bots.

1
Verroq•

Nothing would stop him from releasing private information anyway. The last thing we want is to provide an incentive for MMM to make further threats toward our users.

That's the most retarded thing I've ever heard. What does he want anyway?

0
Saydrah•

He wants the CSS deleted, the stars, request color change thingy, strikethrough for non self posts, that bit. As someone else pointed out, he has no right to any of it:

Except as expressly provided otherwise in the Privacy Policy, you agree that by posting messages, uploading files, inputting data, or engaging in any other form of communication with or through the Website, you grant us a royalty-free, perpetual, non-exclusive, unrestricted, worldwide license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, translate, enhance, transmit, distribute, publicly perform, display, or sublicense any such communication in any medium (now in existence or hereinafter developed) and for any purpose, including commercial purposes, and to authorize others to do so.

It's property of Reddit.

That said we may end up modifying the CSS to eliminate his code without making any changes that affect user experience. We're still discussing it.

5
[deleted]•

Why not just track his IP, lawyer up and remind him that he's committing blackmail which is likely illegal where he lives.

6
Verroq•

Why does he want the css deleted?

3
sodypop•

I've been on vacation and have been fortunate to have missed this whole ordeal.

I'm sure you already realize this, but anyone is free to use the CSS tweaks as far as I'm concerned. I made the CSS for the strikethrough and sent it to MMM and some other mods in a PM. For the most part I just used a trick from jamt9000, who also wrote the CSS for the spoiler text and several other tricks as well.

If each subreddit's CSS was supposed to be proprietary, it wouldn't be publicly available.

I wouldn't bother rewriting any of that CSS. Almost all of it was adopted from other subreddits or from r/redditax in the first place.

2
Saydrah•

Thanks, Sody. We had remembered that you made a lot of the Iama CSS hacks, but MMM seems to have gone back and edited posts to take out credit given to you :(

2
pbhj•

Releasing personal private information without permission can be a criminal offence - whoever runs this show should be seeking a court injunction against this person.

-1
[deleted]•

You could try not ganging up on him and treating him like shit possibly, that might help?

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
creon•

What do you have against this person anyways??? If I understand correctly he called someone an asshole for posting a dog abuse video

-12
Saydrah•

I don't know anything about that situation, nor does it have anything to do with anything in r/Iama.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-15
[deleted]•

Fuck, I'm sick of shit like this every time a woman speaks. Just keep it in your pants.

17
[deleted]•

If what MMM actually said is legit, then you might want to reconsider your <3

5
[deleted]•

jesus christ. this kind of drama makes me embarrassed to be a redditor.

129
[deleted]•

[deleted]

48
Saydrah•

Allegedly, Ebert's answers will be in r/AskMe, MMM's new version of IAmA.

2
optimism•

Isn't Ebert a redditor? What must he be thinking at this point...

7
Saydrah•

This comment does not go well with your username.

-7
auriem•

Unfortunately, no one will see them then.

5
inserthandle•

New? He created it a month before IAmA...

5
chameche•

Plus this makes IAmA look horrible. If potential IAmA-ers find out that a bunch of fuck heads have the ability to release their personal information on a whim guess what there might be a lot less of in the future: verified posts. Especially by the people we most want to hear from.

19
[deleted]•

I don't understand why people would send their sensitive information to anonymous Internet-users anyway. I mean, Jesus.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
mercerist•

why don't we require the moderators who receive this sensitive information to make themselves known too, publicly. This way, they won't consider releasing personal information too easily, as they could be hunted down and killed or whatnot by those hurt by it...

1
r00kie•

welcome to high school two.

8
Timid_Pimp•

Junior College?

1
r00kie•

roughly, It's just the fucking internet, people.

1
[deleted]•

I'm glad I'm not alone in this sentiment. I came to reddit because it was a good compendium of links and quality discussion sans the drama. This kind of crap is a huge turn off for a subreddit I held in high regards.

2
zem•

the internet is a potent drama-intensifier. no reason reddit would be an exception to that.

1
baconn•

I can honestly say that I've never seen an online community that hasn't had drama, including Buddhist forums which should be the last group of people on Earth to squabble.

0
[deleted]•

Good fucking god...reddit has turned into middle school.

And I'm still a dork.

83
[deleted]•

[deleted]

14
jaxspider•

Nah, reddit is awesome... this sub reddit on the other hand... :/

You know what they say about too many chefs in a kitchen.

6
embretr•

reddit is awesome(ish) as always. The problem is with the staffing. As always; Good Help Is Hard to Find.

1
shengdan•

Too many dicks on the dance floor.

1
zem•

just drop off iama

1
loulan•

Seriously... We don't even know both sides of the argument, someone takes one thing one of the parties said out of context, posts it here so that he gets support from the community, and redditors fall for it.

This is so fucking retarded.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

82
mrsir•

I do believe that was MMM.

54
[deleted]•

Link?

23
muldoon_vs_raptor•
58
Ciserus•

EDIT: MercurialMadnessMan requires verification of all IAmA's now. He is a stranger to me and I would rather just never log back into this account than risk my career. I had a lot more stuff to answer, but IAmA turned out to be not so anonymous so I can't continue. Bye all.

Holy crap, did that guy ever make the right call.

162
ruinmaker•

As far as I can tell, MMM asked for ID and the Mcdexec refused then bailed. Am I missing something? Also (side comment), "Mcdexec" doesn't sound sound like a very genuine poster in that thread.

8
mrsir•

At work being forced to use IE which goes to shit when trying to expand large comment fields. I will look for it when I get home on my Chrome.

6
[deleted]•

Isn't this also the guy who deleted/banned people for criticising him?

28
Erudecorp•

Yes, his mod status should be removed for all subs.

16
Dax420•

You're thinking of the mod of r/marijuana B34nz

11
[deleted]•

Nah, that was the guy who deleted/banned people for criticising him for being racist.

Ah, found a .gif of the issue I meant. Doesn't tell the whole story but it's the best I could do.

5
feelbetternow•

The irony of starting a "mass exodus" from r/atheism makes me giggle like a tiny elf.

7
SecretSnack•

He is a tool, but why are you giving the "McDonald's key exec" the benefit of the doubt? It's 1000 times more likely it was some unemployed dude in a stained wifebeater.

17
krappy•

IAmA posters are not required to verify unless they are a celebrity. Why would he trust a random person on the web with verifiable information?

27
[deleted]•

So you mean I can do an AmA about me being an exec from company x and answer questions about how we still use slavery to make our products and we dump all of our toxic waste into the oceans? Because we certainly don't need to verify me, since I'm not posing as a celebrity.

4
krappy•

Yes - That is the way IAmA must work or there will be no content worth viewing. The quality posts come with a risk of trolling. Require verification and nobody who truly wishes to remain anonymous will post.

3
SecretSnack•

Not sure how that's relevant. Until there's a trustworthy confidential way to verify AMAs, it's naive to assume any unverified internet bigwig is what he says he is.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

2
raptosaurus•

We're not, at least I'm not. I don't know about you, but I don't exactly trust everything I read on the Internet. I think Reddit is a little smarter than that. Just read it with a grain of salt. Like you do for every other non sourced thing out there(most of the Internet)

5
SecretSnack•

Everything here comes with salt...

IamA = McDonald's?!!!

I do see your point though. I tend to assume massive upvotes equal a vote of confidence from reddit, but I suppose it's not that simple.

3
Anti-Dentite•

Exactly. Even if a post is starred it doesn't mean the topic creator won't spew out bullshit.

If you think a post is fake and read a decent amount of responses then just downvote.

1
inserthandle•

Yes, But in /r/askme there will be no moderating.

1
drowsap•

I have no idea what the fuck is going on...cliff notes anyone?

80
[deleted]•

Backing away slowly would probably be best. But short version, MMM was demodded on AskReddit long ago. He got a new mod (PhilxBefore) into IAmA (and no one disputes that Philx is a good mod) and asked to be remodded in AskReddit. He says as a joke, others interpret it as an attack.

Everyone goes ahead and panics the fuck out, since any mod can demod all others, OMG MMM is trying to take over teh internets. So, he gets redemodded in AskReddit and newly demodded in IAmA. He gets pissed over losing IAmA over what he considered a joke in AskReddit, arguing that subreddits should be viewed distinctly.

Recently, he made statements which implied or, perhaps, explicitly threatened that unless his contributions (in this case, the stylesheet) to IAmA were removed, he would release personal information he gained in IAmA through the verification process. He quickly backed off from that, but not before a few hundred karma went down the drain.

So...basically MMM went from being perhaps treated unfairly to now rapidly appearing to go into crazy town.

tl;dr: MMM has flipped the fuck out.

149

All parties involved in this are being childish. Other Mods, for freaking out unnecessarily, and MMM for acting like a hysterical soon-to-be ex.

IMO, the best solution for now is for IAMA "hosts" (especially the pedophile ones) to delete any info that might endanger them.

47
[deleted]•

especially the pedophile ones

You've got to be fucking kidding me. There were pedophile AMAs that got the fucking gold star?

17
Saydrah•

None to my knowledge.

11

I haven't been coming to IAMA since the gold stars, so probably not. I definitely know that one of the stripper threads had a gold star.

This appears to be a subset of some of the gold starred IAMAs. Some people might lose their jobs because of this silly drama.

3
strolls•

IMO, the best solution for now is for IAMA "hosts" (especially the pedophile ones) to delete any info that might endanger them.

The thing is that they CAN'T. This is information they've sent directly to MMM in order to verify themselves for the IAMA process. They may have told him "google this phrase and you'll see it links to my real personality" or "give me your email address and I'll send you a photo".

There are surely people who could easily lose their jobs - no, their careers - if MMM were to carry through his threat.

6
hiffy•

All parties involved in this are being childish.

The way they set up this subreddit (gold stars for verification, what?) was ripe for power tripping.

3
kleinbl00•

It should be pointed out that his first name is, in fact, "Mercurial."

His middle name is "Madness."

This issue is not unlike giving a guy named "StabbyMcStabStab" a pair of pointy scissors and then wondering why your back is bleeding.

27
optimism•

Did you really need to define madness? Also it's a username. Two of the best users in reddit was named CuntsmellersINC and Necrophilliac.

13
kleinbl00•

I don't think I really needed to define "mercurial." I figured I would take some of the sting out of a word fewer people knew by including a link to a word everybody knew.

It's also a joke. Which, I hope, the "stabbyMcStabStab" reference cleared up.

13
Saydrah•

Well, we don't know those usernames aren't equally descriptive. Necrophiliac did mysteriously disappear. Perhaps he's in jail for defacing graves.

0
[deleted]•

Touch...fuck, my carefully memorized alt-key codes don't work in linux. How do I type e accent ague(sp?)?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
BoonTobias•

I think you've just summoned cuntymccuntington

1
deusnefum•

I don't want to lose karma over this as it seems everyone is against MMM, but I think a more appropriate tl;dr is "MMM was backed into a corner."

I was all enraged at first too but I've been reading MMM's comments and realized while he may have made a few mistakes he does make some very valid points about the other mods. I think I also have an idea what it's like to be in his shoes. Except in my case I left a backdoor on the system and went in and deleted my contributions myself.

I'm sorry it went down like this, MMM.

26
[deleted]•

I totally think this is the sort of thing that it's fine to lose karma over. And I have to say, I was initially strongly on his side.

But I think that he made a very stupid and costly mistake to make an implied threat that he would release private information. Yes, I understand wanting to take your toys with you when you're kicked out of the garden but sometimes people screw you over and there's not much you can do about it.

Personally, I think the thing that bothers me the most is that I have seen no public comment from 32bites about the situation. It seems like MMM was really hung out to dry and treated badly in this process and if that was not the case, then I think there should have been and still should be an official public account of exactly what went down and responses to MMM's criticisms (like not being directly contacted and 32bites not responding to MMM's message after MMM was demodded).

14
_oogle•

Yes, I understand wanting to take your toys with you when you're kicked out of the garden but sometimes people screw you over and there's not much you can do about it.

No. Don't live your life like a bitch. That's not to say MMM isn't a total loser for what he did, but one should strike back with intelligence, as opposed to with nerd-rage threats or not at all.

2
RowingBear•

Until MMM tried to extort the IAmA moderators with the threat of releasing personal information, I may have agreed with you. However his attempts were so egregious that he lost all moral standing, period. He crossed a line which cannot be uncrossed and went from a Redditor I rather liked to a person I despise.

8
RoboBama•

In the hood its called "snitching" and people get shot in their fucking face for it.

But he didn't release the info. But threatening is bad enough.

"If niggaz think ya snitchin they aint tryna listen. They be sittin in ya kitchen, waitin to start hittin"- Biggie

1
Suppafly•

MMM has been in crazy town for a long time. He messes up every sub he gets mod powers in, but somehow people keep adding him.

13
Mitsuho•

Hey, he's ACTIVE.

1
m1ss1ontomars2k4•

If you ask me, his request to be a mod of AskReddit was neither a joke nor an attack. I also find it ridiculous that this would result in his being demodded from IAmA.

7
1338h4x•

What got him demodded on AskReddit that would cause the mods there to flip out at the prospect of remodding him?

3
[deleted]•

I'm not really clear on what originally went down in AskReddit. But my impression was that MMM wasn't willing to go through their process and discuss whatever their reasons were for the demodding, so they considered it over. So when he was suddenly remodded without explanation, they were freaked out.

3
BoonTobias•

Good news everyone, we've managed to fuck this place up within 20 days of the creators' departure

3
[deleted]•

...isn't 32bites the creator? And im has definitely not departed.

3
BoonTobias•

my bad, i meant reddit creators

3
piratebroadcast•

I have been keeping up with this for a while now, and you just explained it perfectly, my man. Oujheush speaks the truth.

2
[deleted]•

Thanks. I think this is my highest scoring comment ever. Fun fact: I was actually not going to respond to drowsap because I didn't want to misrepresent any of the sides involved and since I obviously don't have full knowledge of what happened. But, I figured since no one else had responded I might as well give it a shot. Glad I did. :)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Yea cliff notes please.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
jaxspider•

And not enough about reddit. :(

1
Ciserus•

Saydrah has already voiced the opinion that I'm mentally unsound [...] which makes it really curious why she/they would jeapordize subscribers' privacy after concluding this themselves. Regardless, the mods are risking things that they should not be risking, and I am concerned for the subscribers ...

What in the jogging Christ? Is his argument that they are jeopardizing users' privacy by not taking into account the fact that he's a loony who will breach that privacy if they piss him off?

I have no idea what the real background is to him being kicked off the mod list, but at this point it won't take much to convince me of the "mentally unsound" thing.

76
grandmoffcory•

That's the exact form of justification a crazy person uses.
Hell, that's the kind of justification Twoface used in the [fairly] recent Batman R.I.P. storyline.
He [Twoface] gets pissed at Nightwing for not saving a girl from being killed by himself [Twoface.]

18
Ciserus•

I'd call it terrorist logic, but in a way it's even crazier (the rationalization part, not the killing people part). He's not just trying to transfer some of the blame for his actions onto his opponents... he's trying to do that and then actually claims he has moral superiority for it.

It would be like if during the election campaign Obama had threatened to blow up the city of Phoenix if McCain didn't pull out of the race. Then when he didn't, Obama goes, "See? McCain doesn't care about Phoenix! But me, Phoenix is my top priority!"

18
[deleted]•

I'm pretty sure in the meat of his post he was saying that they're being careless with the verification information since he was removed as a mod. I honestly didn't read the quoted text at the top of this thread as a veiled threat in context. I'm not sure what he means specifically though.

7
Ciserus•

I wasn't sure about it at first either, but in his other posts it becomes clear that that's exactly what he means.

I told Saydrah that I'd spread private info if the stylesheet wasn't erased. [...] They're risking a leak of private information through their inability to do something simple.

_

Not communicating with me was their worst decision, considering my inbox is a goldmine of users' personal information. They clearly don't respect people's privacy one bit. A mod delete-bomb is the least of their worries. It's like frisking a criminal for a knife when they have a gun pointed at you.

I don't want to go digging for any more because the douche is keeping us from copy-pasting his posts and I've got to retype them all.

13
formode•

Drag Select from the "permalinkparentreportreply" line up to his username. Works fine.

2
cantCme•

I don't quite understand this, he is talking about a css stylesheet here that he created and he wants them to stop using? And the risk they are taking is him threatening to spread the personal info, or is he talking about some stylesheet that contains personal info, which he is against using because it is risky. My gut tells me it is the first.

2
Dax420•

The former. He is threatening to release private info if they don't stop using his stylesheet. The reason being that he started his own subreddit and he wants to use that stylesheet exclusively on his subreddit.

Dick move.

5
ThrustVectoring•

I'm not sure what he means specifically though.

he means 'stop ignoring me, I am important'

2
[deleted]•

He has said over and over that he has no information to leak, and that if he did, he wouldn't.

You should be much more worried about 32bites who adds and removes multiple mods at Saydrah's whim. A little power drunk there, I'd be worried about what he knows way more than MMM.

Just saying.

3
ProximaC•

He's also stated he would "spread private info" and that his inbox "is a goldmine of users personal information".

Just saying.

9
32bites•

You should be much more worried about 32bites who adds and removes multiple mods at Saydrah's whim. A little power drunk there, I'd be worried about what he knows way more than MMM.

No, it was not Saydrah's decision for MMM to be removed, he was leveraging favours to be added back as a moderator of AskReddit without anyone being told.

I decided that I did not want moderators who try sneaking around doing morally questionable things.

As for the other moderator who was removed (I can not recall his name at the moment) kept adding MMM back as a moderator after he was explicitly told not to do so. After being removed as a moderator he deleted his account on reddit.

3
[deleted]•

So, moderators got mad that he got invited back to AskReddit by a mod without the general consensus of the mods, so you removed him without the general consensus of the mods? Just up and did it?

Just curious how things went down.

3
32bites•

This comment is a rather good overview of what happened, If you would like some more detail please PM me.

2
tjragon•

but at the time everything happened, I argued for him to be retained as a moderator but 32 made a different decision and I agreed to abide by it.

Saydrah said it was your decision to remove MMM. Or am I confused?

-2
m1ss1ontomars2k4•

No, he's saying that his threat was fake, but had it been real those anonymous AMAs would not be so anonymous anymore, because no one responded to him in the way he requested.

The other IAmA mods not doing anything is like the TSA doing nothing when someone screams "I HAVE A BOMB", when in reality they don't. What if that person really had a bomb and used it to blow up a plane?

3
Karthan•

MMM is pointing out hypocrisy, I think, to subvert their argument.

1
rvf•

That's some circuitous logic you have there.

11
Karthan•

Mleh. I try.

4
cyberandroid•

circuitous logic

circular logic

-3
rvf•

circular logic

Erm, no.

6
agentravyn•

Permalink

He's gone as far as to make it difficult to copy and paste his text, but here it is in case he deletes it:

Not communicating with me was their worst decision, considering that my inbox is a goldmine of users' personal information. They clearly don't respect people's privacy one bit. A mod delete-bomb is the least of their worries. It's like frisking a criminal for a knife when they have a loaded gun pointed at you.

65
[deleted]•

For the sake of transparency and fairness, we should also post his other comments. We are not Fox News, we do not selectively quote:

I promise that I'm not going to leak private info. I don't even have any. But the mods not responding to me was a terrifying privacy concern.

I'm not going to leak private info. That's a promise. I'm just saying they shouldn't treat someone like shit, like they did with me.

I've never leaked private info and I don't plan to, ever. My point is they should really treat people with respect and decency when they have so much info leverage.

I'm not gong to leak private info. Trust me.

75
AbsoluteTruth•

This was AFTER this shit started to blow up, as far as I am aware (I may be wrong, I didn't look at the timestamps). Regardless, he threatened it in the first place before making these comments, which is unaccpetable. He can fuck himself.

38
[deleted]•

I think the threat was absolutely inappropriate. He was being immature and trying to goad a response from people who were ignoring him. That's just silly - no doubt.

But we have to acknowledge that he's an incredibly valuable redditor, incredibly, and has written the majority of all the hacks and css that define this and other subreddits. He was also treated, in my opinion, unfairly.

-Shrug- Internet drama I suppose. Both sides are at fault in my book.

37
S2S2S2S2S2•

has written the majority of all the hacks and css that define this and other subreddits

No, no. By his own admission, he did not. I don't know the extent of his capabilities, but he gathered them. He did not write them himself. This is not to cut him down, just to set it straight. :)

21
AbsoluteTruth•

After the threat he made that would have affected many innocent people who absolutely do not deserve to have their security compromised in such a manner, I don't believe he should be a moderator of ANY subreddit, regardless of what he's contributed. It's completely irresponsible, and had he done it, he could have ruined the lives of many people. There's no forgiving that.

1
shakbhaji•

He was also treated, in my opinion, unfairly.

Exactly. If the other mods had at least responded to him, and let him know why they booted him, this drama may have been avoided altogether. There wasn't even good reason to remove him as a mod in the first place. The guy got a little overzealous with the McDonald's guy post, BFD. He made a mistake. But he's also obviously made a lot of positive contributions to this subreddit.

That's not to say he's blameless for what happened afterwards, but IMO this started with the other mods, and accordingly get a majority of the blame.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
ikean•

My take is you're either the type of person that does something like he did here, or you're not. It's pure hypocrisy that he's trying to call out anyone else on bad behavior. He's the little kid stomping his foot in the ground because things didn't go as he wanted. And if he stuck to that, fine... but once getting put in his place for revealing true colors he litters threads with politeness and smiley faces in some pandering attempt to return to good standing. This is the internet, you don't get to stomp your foot at it and make demands. I have no previous bias, but from what I've seen he isn't a capable moderator and deserves nothing in his defense for his emotionally bizarre character.

0
ThrustVectoring•

I don't read his statement as a threat, he was definitely trying to get across a different point - that it is gross negligence to not communicate with a person in a trusted position such as MMM's.

Remember, that not communicating is in fact communication - namely, that the person you aren't communicating with isn't important. Telling someone that they aren't important when they are is asking for drama and issues.

5
AbsoluteTruth•

There was a post where he specifically said he threatened to Saydrah to release personal information, as far as I remember.

3
raptosaurus•

my inbox is a goldmine of users' personal information.

I promise that I'm not going to leak private info. I don't even have any.

I'm getting mixed signals here

22
formode•

You're not the only one.

9
inserthandle•

It's this thing called bluffing.

1
pavs•

I'm not gong to leak private info. Trust me.

And... you trust him because he said so?

6
[deleted]•

Interesting.

If you don't believe him, if he's untrustworthy, why do you trust that he actually would in the first place?

Isn't it much more likely that he was claiming to do it in order to goad a response from mods who were ignoring him, but never actually would?

And yes, I trust MMM, I've known him on reddit for quite some time.

10
kittish•

I commend your effort to defend MMM and put up with people playing devil's advocate here but I am going to add once more to this;

If you don't believe him, if he's untrustworthy, why do you trust that he actually would in the first place?

Isn't it much more likely that he was claiming to do it in order to goad a response from mods who were ignoring him, but never actually would?

You have admitted that he had a burst of immaturity but this is the essential problem. What if he felt especially pissy, for whatever reasons in the context of his life, and decided to really screw someone over because he always sort of had a thorn in his side? If he had their information, it takes one bad idea to really upset the person on the other end. Just one. Even if he wants to take it back later, it's been done.

This is the problem--just making such a painfully immature decision discredits his entire character in this sphere because he was playing with fire and he knew it. Maybe he isn't a jerk IRL or for the duration of his stay on Reddit, but he has lost his footing and it's essentially over for him to regain his character here.

You can't get away with advocating blackmail, let alone threatening it for dramatic emphasis, when you have such important information to people in your hands.

1
ThrustVectoring•

I trust him because this was never about private info, it was about MMM being ignored as unimportant when he clearly was, due to the fact that people trusted him with information.

5
agentravyn•

These were posted only after I confronted him about it. And I don't trust him at all, especially with the CSS shit he's pulling to hide his comments from his user page.

6
krappy•

It makes me shudder to think about this individuals ego.

22
greyjay•

From this end, it sounds like the whole group of mods in question have ego issues unfortunately. I guess this is what can happen when reddit becomes someone's life. An interesting result in a fascinating social experiment.

13
kittish•

Also when it just gets entirely blown out of proportion and ends up on the front page of Reddit.

We all love gossip when it's not about us.

1
lulz•

Thanks for articulating my unease at this thread.

1
[deleted]•

What a crybaby, I knew I was right. If he does this he'll have crybaby etched into his forehead forever.

-1
agentravyn•

Do keep in mind that he is over in his subreddit, fapping furiously to all this attention.

54
flaminglips•

Has this been verified?

48
guyincorporated•

This post made my night. Thank you.

2
zem•

would that this were the top-rated comment :) well, i did my little bit towards it.

1
Bauer22•

OMG THIS IS A FUCKING TROLL POST! DELETE THIS MODS!

-4
[deleted]•

Can I get a "Holy fuck, who gives a shit" high five?

43
Detry•
_o/*\o_
18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
frozenfire•

I vaguely recall MMM being involved in some attempt to cause a great deal of grief for the atheism subreddit. I'll have to find a link about this, because he was also removed from r/atheism's mod list for some childish shit like this.

39
[deleted]•
34
frozenfire•

Indeed it is. Thank you.

10
Chetyre•

Wow, really? At first I was rather indifferent to all the drama, but with how he's acting now I think the mods made the right decision. Keep it up guys and gals.

27
tizz66•

This is why 13 year olds shouldn't be allowed on the internet.

27
mrmojorisingi•

If I recall correctly MMM is a university student in Calgary.

10
Hipgnosis•

he makes us albertans cry in shame. at least there's BioWare for all of you gamers!

2
Palpz•

Ugh. Fucker's ruining the reputation of my Alma Mata!

2
[deleted]•

You beat him to the punch: Alma Mater.

3
Palpz•

Ahhhh, very well then, carry on.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mrmojorisingi•

That's some Kurt Greenbaum shit right there, sir.

2
tizz66•

You wouldn't have guessed.

1
Notmyrealname•

If you can't trust random people on the Internet, who can you trust?

26
byrdgang•

This is turning the world upside down! Oh, the humanity. Will it please stop?

2
blocparty•

Is this not the same arsehat who somehow became a moderator of r/atheism; then only used his powers to fuck with the subreddit?

25
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jlv•

You should really have done better to be more precise in your title. Though this is pretty uncool, it seems more like a bluff to get the mods to remove the work that he's done here as a penalty for the way he got kicked out. No doubt that MMM shouldn't be leveraging that information, but you should really explain the situation better.

21
krappy•

Unfortunately for him his contributions now belong to the community - he can't just take them back.

2
FillInTheBlank•

Public domain FTW!

0
[deleted]•

He isn't leveraging the info. He keeps saying "I would NEVER release information! I don't have any!"

-6
daybreaker•

I told Saydrah that I'd spread private info if the stylesheet wasn't erased

Really?

14
[deleted]•

He was bullshitting to attempt to elicit a response from people who were refusing to respond to him. If you've read both sides of this, that much is plainly obvious.

-2
bapppppppppp•

drama, on my reddit?

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

Now this would be a crappy movie plot: "Professional blackmailer creates a discussion board where people willingly give him their sensitive information so he can destroy their lives with impunity."

Almost writes itself :)

19
Shawn1141•

Exactly, I'm not trying to be an ass, but if you gave personal info to a complete stranger so you could have a gold star next to your post did you really think it would be safe. Just cause these people were deemed worthy to have mod status by other people you don't know doesn't mean they are more trustworthy than anyone else.

3
rboymtj•

Redditor for 1 hour.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dearsomething•

Thanks for catching this. I'd like to point out that I saw your comment, but sort of thought nothing of it in the midst of the drama.

I went back to this submission and the clicked the submitters name. It was created for this thread, and has since been inactive.

It's a bit shady.

1