Anti-intellectualism is, to me, one of the most disturbing traits in modern society. I hope I'm not alone.

While this is far from the first time such an occurrence has happened to me, a friend recently started up a bit of a Facebook feud with another person from our hometown over religion. This is one of the kinds of guys who thinks that RFID implants are the "Mark of the Devil" and that things like hip hop and LGBT people are "destroying our society."

Recently, I got involved in the debates on his page, and my friend and I have tried giving honest, non-incendiary responses to the tired, overused arguments, and a number of the evangelist's friends have begun supporting him in his arguments. We've had to deal with claims such as "theories are just ideas created by bored scientists," etc. Yes, I realize that this is, in many ways, a lost cause, but I'm a sucker for a good debate.

Despite all of their absolutely crazy beliefs, though, I wasn't as offended and upset until recently, when they began resorting to anti-intellectualism to try to tear us down. One young woman asked us "Do you have any Grey Poupon?" despite the both of us being fairly casual, laid back types. We're being accused of using "big words" to create arguments that don't mean anything to make them look stupid, yet, looking back on my word choices, I've used nothing at above a 10th grade reading level. "Inherent" and "intellectual" are quite literally as advanced as the vocabulary gets.

Despite how dangerous and negative a force religion can be in the world, I think anti-intellectualism is far worse, as it can be used so surprisingly effectively to undermine people's points, even in the light of calm, rational, well-reasoned arguments.

When I hear people make claims like that, I always think of Idiocracy, where they keep accusing Luke Wilson's character of "talking like a fag."

Posted Mar 28, 2010, 2:01 AM UTC · edited

3.2K2.7K
terafunker•

Intellectualism led to modern society and all things fat, lazy anti-intellectual retards love about it.

You think dipshits got that TV satellite into orbit, designed that fancy cell phone you use to sext your baby-mama, or engineered the engine in the 4x4 you use for muddin'?

721
Fauster•

Palin's base is comprised of anti-intellectuals, I shudder to admit that she is a neo-populist. Populism 'juxtaposes "the people" against "the elites."' Liberals who know history often thinks this means "the poor" against "the wealthy." And wonder why more poor Republicans aren't on their side. Today's populism pits the uneducated against the educated.

Uneducated people still get mad about increased benefits because that lumps them in with other people that they love to feel better than. Also, most of the uneducated in this country don't want handouts, they want to be treated with respect. Uneducated people would like to believe that they're doing the hard and honest work in the country while the educated are swindling it away. The reality is too grim to admit: without government subsidies, the heartland economy would collapse; timber is cheaper if bought from overseas, and it's cheaper to ship logs to an Asian sawmill and ship them back than to process them here; beef from Mexico is cheaper, even if it's the same old cow, and to boot, the uneducated compete for service sector jobs with recent immigrants.

Everything about the Tea Party movement makes sense from the lens of uneducated vs. the educated. And mocking the admittedly stupid arguments of tea partiers only inflames their inferiority complex. Until the Democratic party starts giving tax breaks for those who do good, honest, and American manual labor, the Dems will keep taking punches to the jaw.

617
iamyo•

Inferiority complex. That's exactly what it is. I've been trying to analyze this and I had figured out some of what you say here. But you got the missing piece: If the Tea Party people, many of whom qualify and get government programs, don't lash out in crazy rage at the unimagined hoards taking their tax dollars (which are minuscule, for many of them) then they cannot be superior to 'those people.' And yes, it's about race, to some degree.

But it is clear and has always been clear to me that it's about wounded egos and a sense of inferiority. The rest I could not put together.

Another thing that needs to be said though is that the anti-intellectuals have a set of counter-sources. To them, Glenn Beck IS an intellectual. They have their own 'intellectual' set of information, and beliefs. They have their creation 'science.' It is complicated, arcane and comes in the form of books.

So when someone tells them they don't know anything, they point to their creation science book, or their alternative history book. Every once in a while, these authors have degrees, often from degree mills or not in the field they are writing in. Every once in a while they are renegades with the standard educational background. (E.g., some creation scientists have Ph.Ds in biology.)

So when we say 'anti-intellectual' to me that is the more tragic thing because honestly, I've known people like this. And a lot of them have bookshelves FULL of books. They LOVE to read, some of them. And the books are crazy and full of misinformation. And then it is like they filled their brains up with empty garbage about how the founding fathers were right wing Christians or whatever and there is no space in there for any critical thinking or new information. That's what bums me out. Because they aren't DUMB. They aren't. They are ignorant and misinformed and susceptible to any source of information that's hateful and fits their twisted world view and that's vastly more depressing.

80
[deleted]•

No, that fits perfectly with "anti-intellectual". They just read and read; they don't examine or criticize or challenge; they just accept whatever sounds good to them without thinking about WHY it's good. And if they DO have a reason for having a particular opinion, it's one they found in a book which they read to re-enforce or add to their own beliefs. It's a top-down approach to knowledge rather than bottom up; it's totally backwards and it's the foundation of the religious mindset. To them, education has only ever been about teachers telling you what's true. That's as far as they got in the education system; they don't know what they don't know about what it means to be an intellectual.

367
tarrasque•

Wow. Spot on regarding a huge portion of this world's population. Wow.

46
CannedMango•

they don't know what they don't know about what it means to be an intellectual.

There is actually a research study done on this and it has a very significant real world impact. More importantly than just people being unaware of their ignorance, it's how their ignorance allows them to essentially push their opinions onto people who know more than they do, but are more naturally reluctant since they are more aware of how much they don't know.

13
IgnatiousReilly•

Don’t fool yourself into thinking it is just religious folk and conservatives who do research this way. When it comes to politics, nearly everyone (and possibly everyone) does this to some extent. It’s a big, complex world out there, and we can’t be experts on every aspect of it, but if we’re voters, we’re supposed to be.

The delusion of expertise enjoyed by the average voter might be the biggest problem there is in a Democracy. Anyone have any alternate suggestions for a reliable system of government?

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
naturboy20•

“Do not believe in anything simply because you have heard it. Do not believe in anything simply because it is spoken and rumored by many. Do not believe in anything simply because it is found written in your religious books. Do not believe in anything merely on the authority of your teachers and elders. Do not believe in traditions because they have been handed down for many generations. But after observation and analysis, when you find that anything agrees with reason and is conducive to the good and benefit of one and all, then accept it and live up to it.” Buddha

7
OriginalStomper•

it's the foundation of the religious mindset.

Waaayy too broad to be true. Shame, because it detracts from the valid points.

It is entirely possible, and fairly common, for religious believers to be intellectuals. Unless you are using some hyper-specialized, "no-true-scotsman" definition for intellectual?

4
[deleted]•

This quote comes to mind:

However, for the man who studies to gain insight, books and studies are merely rungs of the ladder on which he climbs to the summit of knowledge. As soon as a rung has raised him up one step, he leaves it behind. On the other hand, the many who study in order to fill their memory do not use the rungs of the ladder for climbing, but take them off and load themselves with them to take away, rejoicing at the increasing weight of the burden. They remain below forever, because they bear what should have bourne them. -Arthur Schopenhauer

4
NCRider•

Are you saying you can't be intellectual and religious?

3
jeannaimard•

they don't know what they don't know about what it means to be an intellectual.

So, for them, being anti-intellectual is the “unknown unknowns”…

2
haiduz•

Same thing with 9/11 nut jorbs. They accept that 9/11 was a conspiracy and just dwelve in on the stupid bullshit that supports the fair tales.

2
kokey•

I'm an autodidact, or you can refer to me as uneducated. I dropped out of high school. I guess you could consider me educated to some degree since I did take maths and some sciences up to high school level. I'm not a native English speaker, and I can say I've learned most of my English from television, reading and the internet.

I do teach myself by being interested in many things, or setting up goals and challenges, and then thinking, reading, researching and working my way there. I know I have an advantage over people who spend much of their life being educated. One thing I observe is that if you study for something, and passed an exam on it, you don't retain nearly as much of the information as having to figure it out by yourself. I prefer trying to figure something out on my own, and then following it up with research, which I find more interesting then since I can appreciate what it took to form this body of knowledge. On the other hand if you haven't been exposed to further education, you have less of an awareness of the spread of knowledge and depth of study already out there. I have this problem, I still discover fields of study that I haven't known about before, but it's quite exciting when I do. Other times I do find myself reinventing the wheel.

I find people who spend much of their time in education, in other words in the bubble of academia where they are surrounded by other academics, to be ignorant in their own way. I guess these are the people you can refer to as intellectuals, and that would make me anti intellectual. Many of these people, to me, appear as if they don't think of 'why' something is the way it is, they just follow whatever the popular thinking is in an environment of people who have never had to take tangible things to fruition and sustain it like much of the rest of the population have experience in doing. These are often people who quite arrogantly believe they know how the world works, and better than others. It's quite telling for me when I see educated people from the US have an opinion over things we have in Europe (where I moved to almost a decade ago) I am generalising, since it depends on the field of study.
For example there appears to be much more feeding back of practical experience into the academic side of engineering and medicine, but other fields aren't as focussed on delivering something tangible so there is a lot of room for intellectualised junk.

I can relate to this feeling of being suspicious of intellectuals. Especially when these people contribute nothing to society other than entertainment, like the arts, and they are only sustained through academia by the taxes other people pay for productive activity, or the money that other people spend on entertainment.

2
kublakhan•

Ironically, what you are describing also describes the vast majority of what goes on on this very website. Just look to the front page to see a massive list of links that pretty much reiterate the same themes you've seen a million times before on this website. Seriously-- take a second to do this (I'll wait) and see how many of the links actually challenge your beliefs. Then see how many of these links are just new forms to old tropes that you've seen a hundred times on Reddit before, and which do nothing more than solidify what you think you already know.

I think the overwhelming majority of the people on this website are highly educated, yet have the exact same approach to reading as the people you are decrying: seeking out sources and subreddits that correspond to their pre-existing views, finding news stories (especially political ones) that reinforce the ideas that they hold near and dear, villifying people and ideas that they perceive as antithetical to their views on the world, etc. How many of you who believe the above comment actually take the time to read the conservative or religious subreddits, or go to other websites that represent these views? How many of you upmod links to sites that you disagree with, or upmod comments that don't align with your views? And maybe more importantly, how is what you do any different from what you perceive these "anti-intellectuals" as doing, and why do you actually think you're different?

tl;dr: what you are describing is not an attribute of the uneducated / religious/conservative/ignorant/etc., but rather a description of people in general -- even the people of Reddit.

2
hastasiempre•

I'm totally with you on this. It's a poignant and precise definition of modern non-critical quasi-scientific acceptance of reality. But it's rather what the western educational system cultivates. It discourages the questioning of the matrix and enforces compliance with rules no matter what. It creates sham variety while in fact that's an easily manipulated uniformity, the ground for fascist ideology.

1
angch•

Not necessary top-down/bottom-up, but close, imho. It's Mappers (see how individual packets of facts connect) vs packers (collect facts, ignore connections between facts). Read the first chapter of The Programmer's Stone.

Mappers experience learning as an internal process in response to external and self-generated stimuli. Packers experience learning as another task to be performed, usually in a classroom, using appropriate equipment

1
brodies•
1
Pontiflakes•

This reminds me of the scene in The Fountainhead where a group of wealthy, influential people have an "intellectual" discussion on a higher-level thinking topic by telling each other what other "intellectuals" have said on the topic. They are so pleased with themselves that they can circulate others' ideas and receive their peers' validation for simple regurgitation. The sad part is that the people they quote have just been doing the same thing; no one innovates, no one creates, it's just a stagnant circle of second-handers.

0
badui•

Sir, I tip my hat to you. You win this thread.

0
itzmattu•

It's funny that you are trying to categorize intelligence and getting bestof'd for closed-mindedness.

You clearly have predetermined notions that if you are smart, you are a democrat/socialist/other "right-side" keyword of the week. You came on here to try and present some half thought of notion to the community, that is already biased anyway, to reaffirm your position.

Sadly, it shows that you yourself are horribly closed-minded and don't even know anything about the terms you use.

Top-down and Bottom-up approaches to education are used all over various fields of education from sciences and engineering to liberal arts and music. Either one is viable and useful for various cases. The key thing is that, independent of where they start, they always cover the whole field. THAT is what matters, and what your post completely skips over.

You balk about the inability of people to critically think, but you seemingly can't even edit your own information. Who are you to speak?

I can't stand this subculture of reddit that comes on here and strong arms a viewpoint that is half-assed and immature. You want to make yourself feel better about your ideas? Good for you. But don't go claiming they are inherently intelligent just because you hang out on reddit.

Pro-tip: Reddit isn't full of geniuses, just preferred by them.

-2
Hungry_Jefferson•

A guy I worked for last year was very smart. He built engines and fixed machines for his landscaping business. He changed my rotors and brake pads. He's a whiz at math. A really, really nice guy. Aways polite and very insightful. I could have long debates with this guy, and he really critically thought everything that went into his mind.

He was also very religious, and a racist. There's some disconnect in his mind, where he can't apply his intellect, his critical thought, to religion and cultural/racial diversity. A "friend" of his had died from alcoholism, he told me. "The kid was into a lot of stuff. Drugs, booze. Just didn't take care of himself. But you know, he probably had some diseases and stuff. He was a fag." Granted, he's an Italian guy and likely had Catholic beliefs instilled in him since he could talk, but at some point in his life, if he was remotely capable of higher thought (which he is) why wouldn't he have questioned his own viewpoints? Tradition and faith are strong devices, but wouldn't curiosity and introspection play a part in ones development eventually? I suppose not. Scary.

8
anthama•

I can clearly remember a point in my life where my own beliefs were against my religion, no matter how I looked at it. I had to decide then to go full blind in terms of religion and ethical beliefs or to give up religion. It might be the case with your friend choosing the other path, he's not going to give up all critical thinking (if he's smart enough, his mind will demand it), but some stuff he'll choose to stay blind to.

2
krunk7•

I truly believe that once you reach a certain base level of intelligence you cease being capable of distinguishing between faith and reason.

See, both faith and reason lead to the same neurological phenomenon: belief.

To everyone beneath this threshold, "scientist" is the same as "priest" or "vicor". To them, the "intellectuals" just go to a different church.

6
clickmagnet•

Upvoted, especially for your last point. Writing off the Teabaggers as merely stupid is not helpful, and often not true. Of course a lot of them are really stupid, and a lot of the ones who could have been smart have caught religion. But there is a third category. Watch again this previously-reddited debate between Alan Grayson and a Teabagger: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhJ7M8o8W-Y (bonus: she's hot).

Teabagger demonstrates a formidable command of detailed and relevant information. The fact that most of it is false doesn't diminish the intellectual ability required to know it. She's not stupid. I'm not intellectual enough to know the word for what she is, maybe one of you stuck-up stickybeaks can help me out. I need a word that means "the ability to retain complex but false data despite evidence to the contrary."

1
WTFppl•

This has nothing to do with the topic really, but is an interesting read none the less!

I queried your statement... Physicalism: a false view of the world

Now I'm going to read this- The Emperor’s New Methods

1
anthama•

A liar? I mean not to be condescending, but I honestly can't tell why some people choose to believe lies rather than the truth. It's the same crap that religious people claim that their absurd beliefs are the most rational way of thinking, they're just lying and we should call them out on it.

1
angryboy•

I like that girl. She makes excellent points and is clearly very intelligent. She argues her case very civilly to boot. Sure she is slightly misinformed but who isn't? Also she is HOT

1
JesterMereel•

Doublethink.

1
[deleted]•

intellectual ability required to know it

What does this mean? How much intelligence does it require to memorize talking points and a bunch of disconnected sound-byte statistics? None. She didn't do her research; she's just parroting something that someone told her was true.

There are two kinds of people who generate this sort of information in the first place: Idiots who strive to think logically and apply their analytical abilities, but fall short because they simply aren't that smart, and then downright evil people who purposefully make use of logical fallacies to further their own agendas.

0
[deleted]•

It goes both ways. That's the problem though, the fact that there are 'sides.' Both groups refuse to see the primary third option: there are no sides.

1
teambob•

This is a really great argument. Another point is that education is often beyond the financial reach of these people. Isn't it human nature to view something you can't have is worthless?

Perhaps if education was universally available the attitudes of the general population would be different.

53
wr3000•

An education is not beyond the reach of anyone. At one time this was true but not today. That's what makes this all so sick. There is no excuse for not being educated in modern society. Between libraries, public television, and the Internet, anyone can become ridiculously educated for free.

104
mattieB•

Education takes time, energy, and direction. You make a good point. These resources are available to anyone but the truth is without prodding or an imminent need for specific knowledge the average citizen wont utilize them. I've always thought of it as a state of inertia. The blue collars out there are quick to say "nah I don't know about that fancy book stuff, but I can tell you about being an American working man." This statement is like an object at rest. Staying at rest seems natural. It's just easier to be a simple man. Without prodding it's just not going to change. Not until that blue collar fella comes into a situation where he/she is faced with personal adversity that requires them to get educated are they going to utilize those tools.

62
ShinyRatFace•

Its true that education itself is pretty easy to come by. I've learned all kinds of cool stuff from the history of the Roman empire, how to read and write Norse runes, to the basics of quantum theory and how to make egg rolls from scratch with nothing more than google and a library card.

The problem that I run into is that many people don't want to respect anything I have to say or any knowledge that I have because I don't have a college degree "proving" that I know anything.

The narrow mindset that college=education really annoys me. It is one way to do it. It is probably the best way if you are looking to learn something to further your career as employers like that little piece or paper as proof that you learned something. If you just want to learn something to sate your curiosity it probably isn't worth spending the money to get a degree in it.

I really like history. I learned a lot reading books from the library and from the internet and I'm happy. My friend that got a degree in history? She's working at a coffee shop for minimum wage and struggling to make student loan payments. We are equally educated, I just have less debt.

28
tso•

educated maybe, but not certified as knowing those things.

thats basically what the lower end of university is, a certificate that you know what you claim to know. And that certificate is more worth then the actual education when it comes to getting ahead. If a company hires you for something, and that something results in a accident, their insurance provider may withhold payouts or drag the company to court unless said certificate say you knew what you where doing and so cant be the source of blame for the events.

and tv, educational? maybe until the 70's but since the 80's its been mostly the mental equivalent of empty calories. And who uses libraries these days for anything but free access to the facebook and lolcats?

bread and circus. Or these days, happy meals and UFC.

10
club_soda•

I think you're missing a bit of circular logic here. The missing factor here is time, which is 'free' in the monetary sense, but certainly not Free in any other sense.

Sure it takes motivation, inspiration and blah, blah blah, but your average uneducated person doesn't have the time to become educated. Free time is the product of educated folks. To become educated, you must have the free time for it, but to have free time, you must be educated.

Let's say someone wanted to construct a 4 year college education on their own, without any resources other than the libraries, television and the internet. How long would that take while they were also busy putting food on the table? How many opportunities would there be to quit?

Don't look down on the poeple that don't accomplish this extraordinary feat, praise the people that were miraculously able to pull it off.

8
kidcorporeal•

That may be true, but it will never make you popular.

5
cyborg_selkie•

You're right, I use free modes of education all the time. However, I also had parents who read to me and who were staunchly pro-intellectual. Would I have had the same zeal for learning if I was born in an anti-intellectual enclave in America? It's certainly possible, but there are more factors in a person becoming educated than availability, as human beings are not purely rational.

5
fuckinhell•

I think you are wrong. I'm not talking about a basic education. I'm talking about a higher education. Being educated at a school like MIT or Harvard, etc was most certianly out of my reach because I am not rich. I suppose it depends though on how you define "education".

3
Flyboy•

The only motivation for people to seek education is economic: "I'll get a degree so I can get a better job." And then consumerist values propagated by the media tell them that the solution can be found in a tidy package, such as those offered by for-profit career schools like Everest. The result is that they are nominally educated in a specific career field and end up deep in debt, which is where they started.

They're not going to the library to better themselves.

3
iamyo•

But they've been taught not to trust any of the standard sources of knowledge. They wouldn't watch public television. They wouldn't read history that doesn't reaffirm their world view. They look to Focus on the Family for information.

1
TheGoodGreat•

In our society, simply being educated is not enough. You can be a rocket scientist but if you go apply for a job at NASA you won't even get an interview without a degree from a university that says as much.

1
[deleted]•

You fail to see the opportunity cost though, if you have to work to make a living then you can't afford to spent that time studying, even if it were free.

1
SomGuy•

An education is not beyond the reach of anyone.

That's not entirely true, even in the USA. Some of the poorest kids in this country are effectively prisoners of school bureaucracies that can't be bothered to actually teach them to read. They get promoted along with their peers, year after year, because being held back a grade is bad for the stats.

1
anthama•

Yes, but a better incentive for education could come through colleges or universities (you can get a better job by the end of it). And that can only be done by young or rich or those who can get enough scholarships.

1
frankichiro•

With access to internet, the only thing a person need in order to become educated is curiosity and the ability to learn how to learn.

Modern man is called "Homo sapiens sapiens", which basically means "human that is aware of that it is aware". This suggests a habit of consciously trying to become progressively more well informed and skilled in many areas of life. For some reason though, your mileage may vary when it comes to this urge, and the interesting question is why?

We all live different lives, with different expectations, ideals and languages imposed on us, that form our habits and thought patterns as we grow up. It is quite easy to spend a whole lifetime living within the frames of a given intellectual environment, and to identify yourself as a human only within the context and extent of that inherited perspective.

If you are never exposed to the great mysteries of the world, the overwhelming sources and edges of life that fucks up your sense of reality and meaning, your urge to figure stuff out and achieve things might never burn as intense for you as it has come to do for others.

We humans invent things to make a lot of things in life simpler and quicker, so that we can free up time and energy to do other things instead. Sometimes that means being able to do more advanced things, and other times it means not needing to do stuff any more. Every time we reach a new level of comfortness, our urge break out of our lifestyle will diminish. We're safe, we settle, we maintain, we depend, we stagnate, we fear change and and transformation, which is life.

What people need in order to become educated, is to be challenged. Free access to data, information and tools definitely helps of course, but if a person have no desire to explore life and the universe in any broader sense, availability won't really matter.

So what can be done? Share your passion for learning with others, and try to inspire them. Keep fighting laziness and restrictive ideals. Dare to question your life. Look outside your daily environment for the things you don't know that you don't know. Teach yourself how to improve your brain. Never take anything for granted. Never be afraid to make mistakes. Stay awake and keep dreaming!

68
dandlion•

Nicely written, but I think you forget one smallish thing in that is also a factor here. People also need to be inspired to seek this path instead of the intellectual laziness we are all reading this to condemn.

While you touch upon my point in your last paragraph, individually, living a life where we are not is by far the best way to set an example, yet, you omit the concept of not alienating those who do not see it so. While you can live your own life better as you have outlined, I suspect that that in itself is not going to be enough to defang the likes of Sarah Palin and company. Besides the steps you have outlined, I feel that it is also necessary to show that living intellectually does not necessarily make you the enemy.

Admittedly, there is nothing tasty about this chore, but by appreciating the humanity of those we are so prone to disdain, we are more likely to derail this attempt at "keep them dumb and angry" than by any other process. Tea-bagger tactics are unfortunately nothing new, quite often "cheap bandwagons" have appeared that mobilize this crowd. Usually such bandwagons have served only to prolong the misery of those that they appeal to, but alienating them further only serves to strengthen their rationalizations.

15
[deleted]•

Modern man is called "Homo sapiens sapiens", which basically means "human that is aware of that it is aware".

No, it doesn't. Taxonomy doesn't work this way. While I don't oppose the sentiment that humans are aware that they are aware, I can't stand this sort of thing, which is blatant rhetorical misinformation. This is intellectual laziness on your part; I don't think you have malicious intent, so it's not dishonest.

Sapiens comes from the latin verb sapere, which means "to taste". Alternative meanings have the same sort of connotations as saying that one has "good taste"; sapere has a more abstract meaning that refers to mental abilities rather than physical ones: to discern; to make good judgements. The metaphor of a keen sense of taste (used to distinguish the quality of foods and detect chemicals) being used to describe the mental ability to discern right from wrong in arbitration, to see the best possible course of actions to achieve a goal, etc, seems natural. To get an adjective out of sapere, we take the root sap and add iens; sapiens is the quality of having the ability to make good decisions and discernments and having problem-solving abilities; of having wisdom as opposed to merely knowledge.

Of course, laypeople often confuse education with intelligence, since you need to be smart to think abstractly and learn the sciences. So sapientia means "proficiency in the sciences". This error is repeated in the natural course of the evolution of languages, and occurs again and again throughout time. Look at modern english: intelligent is often confused with learned. "Look at the elitist in his ivory tower. Think's he's so much better than me just because he's got his book-learning." No. The scientist is better than the teabagger because he has and exercises the ability to think critically.

Anyway, I got on a bit of a tangent there. My point is that "sapiens" does not have much to do with the modern English word "sapience", which means, as I'm sure you know, self-awareness. With "sapientia" being conflated with "knowing a lot about philosophy", it's easy to see why it was chosen as the root of a word meaning to be aware of one's own consciousness.

It is not wrong to say that "sapiens" could be translated as "thinking", but the name homo sapiens sapiens does not mean "man who thinks about thinking". Taxonomic names do not carry a sense of Latin grammar, just meanings. They are just a labeling system of the directed graph of species and subspecies. They often contain references to some quality of the groups they describe, but this is only as a convenience for memorization and often entirely arbitrary.

Homo means human, referring to the genus which includes all the man-type animals. Species within that family are sapiens, but also neanderthalensis and erectus. Neanderthalensis is named after a valley. Now, we can divide further into subspecies, but we tend not to do that anymore with homo sapiens for reasons which will be made obvious:

If you go back a few decades (not really that far at all), homo sapiens sapiens refers exclusively to Caucasians. It's entirely about white supremacy; some other subspecies are homo sapiens afer, homo sapiens americanus, and homo sapiens asiaticus.

The only reason we still use homo sapiens sapiens to refer to modern man (as a whole, which is a new development) is because there is another human subspecies aside from us: homo sapiens idaltu. But they're all dead, so unless you're talking about human evolution, homo sapiens sapiens is redundant and pedantic. It would be as if CNN referred to Obama as "The American President" rather than simply "The President". Granted, there's other presidents, but we only use the adjectives when we're talking about something in the context of multiple presidents.

Anyway, my tl;dr is this: homo sapiens sapiens means, if anything, "the wisest of the thinking men", in direct opposition to "the African thinking men" and "the Asian thinking men". It's a leftover from racist times that no one's bothered to change, although many have tried.

5
benm314•

Their political curiosity tends to be entirely satisfied by Fox News and church. If that's all you know, what more could you ask for? Eternal life, American exceptionalism, and moral superiority. Good luck taking away any of those things. :(

3
judgej2•

With access to internet, the only thing a person need in order to become educated is curiosity and the ability to learn how to learn.

If you take off the "With access to internet" bit, I would agree totally. The Internet is just one tool - one of many. Just like any other tool, you still have to separate what is right, factual, scientific etc. from everything else.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Domakesaythink•

While I agree with you, I think it's false to say that internet is the answer to uneducated pple. If that was the case, then we'd jjust send a bunch of computers with internet in Africa and South America and they would become as educated as the rest of the world...

It's one thing to have access to knowledge and anoher one to have the tools to understand and structure this knowledge so it makes sens to you, from what you already know, etc... That's precisely what school is for, giving you a frame of understanding for this knowledge.

One of my teachers used to say that you could probably find all the information needed on the internet to build a atomic bomb. And if you did, could you really build it?

Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to bash your post and I completely agree with you but still, school has its purpose.

1
jeannaimard•

With access to internet, the only thing a person need in order to become educated is curiosity and the ability to learn how to learn.

Oxdung. Without an official diploma, you might as well be an earthworm.

Modern man is called "Homo sapiens sapiens", which basically means "human that is aware of that it is aware".

Are those tea-partiers aware of their awareness (if they have one)?

1
madfos•

This is what I've always doing, but u see, not everyone see the world in general, most of the population in this world always try to hide in the comfort zone, those who make it big are and were the ones who dare and not shy to change. Almost all of my friends are living in fixed inherited perspective, they cant or not able to or do not want to see things from other perspective as it is a safe bet to go down that path, and i can say this happens to most asians. im asian btw.

1
coconutcream•

You deserve more than 5 upvotes! Great post.

0
MyStady•

Isn't it human nature to view something you can't have is worthless?

I think it's vulpine nature actually.

18
foxyvixen•

Hey! Screw you guys. I didn't want to hang out with you, anyway.

3
MJ13•

Were trying that with healthcare. You saw their reaction to that. It's not just an education issue. It's race and class too. There are plenty of undereducated seniors that voted for Obama, and see this reaction by the right for what it is: you have a group of super educated elites at the top with an agenda, say continued hegemony in the Middle East for the purpose of controlling the oil. Those people sit on the board of directors for an oil company, GM, and a coal company. They hire scientists to produce papers and arguments in favor of continued oil exploration, global warming challenges in terms of human impact, and an idea that there is a mythical creature called "clean coal", whose cousin is clean shit by the way. Next, those powerful men with powerful friends create a television network where they can run television commercials and have "news casters" repeat their scientists claims 24/365. They make sure that their channel scares the living shit out of their target audience by first building a sense that no other channel cares about their uniquely white concerns (like a cult). You throw on a couple of playboy centerfoldish news casters who do report some realnews just to keep up appearences, but you save your crazy shit for a timeslot after your target audience returns from the early bird special at the Golden Corral. Those prime time guys look trustworthy: white, they seem to hate everyone/thing you hate/ they have blackboards, and they scream the rage you are not allowed to since it is no longer PC. So, you now become a ditto head. You'll believe anything they say even on topics you don't really understand.

At the same time the MSM allows this propoganda network to parade as a real news outlet because the guy who owns the station owns every other mews outlet ... in the world. So they let the fake news channel come up with fake terms like "anti-intellectualism", which is Orwellian for "fucking stupidity". Not only do they allow it, they perpetuate it, and write articles about it, and the so called intellectuals fret about it because they don't have the balls, the powerful cabal of rich, board of director sitting friends that own magazines and fake news organizations, to refute the Idiocracy of Sarah (I'll do anything for attention) Palin and her tea bagging (Klansman without robes) moron supporters.

I say all this to let you know that we are not really fighting a group of uneducated people...follow the arguments to their sources, and you will find some of the scariest, ubereducated mofos on the planet. Don't argue against a dumb argument, ask a tea bagger a question about why they believe climate change is not partially affected by people, and they will give you an answer written by an oil or coal company, that they heard on Fox news. Sorry so long....got me fired up

14
[deleted]•

Good comment. There was an article I read recently about the Koch brothers whose father was a co-founder of the John Birch Society, and who currently fund a large number of the right wing propaganda. The link below shows the foundations funded by the Koch family, and you will trace MANY of the sources quoted by Fox and other right wing media right back to that.

This is not a matter of education and intellectualism per se, but the ability of a few very wealthy, very conservative people using their wealth to create a country in their image, through the manipulation of the Broadcast media.

Link to foundations funded by the Koch billionaires: http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Koch_Family_Foundations#Organizations_funded

5
[deleted]•

In Denmark education is free (and open) to everyone. You even get paid to study when you reach eighteen.
Still only around 15% got a higher education (Bachelor, Master or Ph.D). It's not about availability.

9
tso•

payed to study? unless the system is radically different from its neighbours, said payment is hardly enough. Ans the rest will come from a loan that needs to be repayed no matter the outcome of the education process.

1
qwertyslayer•

this comment is worth its HTML-weight in gold

2
[deleted]•

It's funny. Read the old testament and God hates you. A large amount of Jewish people who are slaves rewrite the book(New Testament) glorifying their place at the bottom of the food chain and create a flux after life of more rewards than the rich peeps they serve. Suddenly, those slaves are richer than their masters.

2
tso•

i think you may be getting your time periods mixed.

2
HMG-CoAReductase•

I really, really disagree that a formal education is beyond the financial reach. (To everyone who wants to say you can become educated without college, yeah, you can, but it doesn't help you get a better job, and without people seeing a practical benefit of it, there isn't much motivation to do it.) State schools (some, not all) are often in the range of a couple grand per year. There is plenty of financial aid out there for people. You might not be able to move far enough away from your hometown, you might have to go to a state school that isn't in the top 50 or whatever, but you can go. Maybe they don't see spending $20-30k on school as a good investment, maybe they know a bunch of people who went to college and chose the easiest major so they could party more often and didn't end up with a good job, but everyone can go if they really want to. Even people that fucked up in high school can start at a community college and transfer out.

1
[deleted]•

Actually I would say the bigger impediment is a culture of anti-intellectualism itself; it seems to be a self-propelling machine of destruction. Your point would simply be true for a minority.

First the set of bad situations (increase in real costs and decrease in prices for agricultural goods) leads to economic poverty and the slow institution of agricultural subsidies to maintain job rates. A culture of anti-intellectualism which already existed in a subset of the population, along with a lack of job prospects drive many people to join the said movement. Once this reaches a critical mass, its pure peer pressure that's keeping the average person from considering a masters/phd etc. Especially since the decision to hit college is made by impressionable high-schoolers (more impressionable than say a 30 year old anyways).

1
[deleted]•

Yeah, but then it'd be harder to maintain control of the masses.

-1
ilykdp•

Harder for whom?

0
BrkneS•

Lord knows I hate to do this but

|Isn't it human nature to view something you can't have is worthless?|

AS WORTHLESS, it's AS worthless..... It's either a typo and I apologize about it, or it just drives home your point about the uneducated even more... either way I hate myself for posting this.

Edit: Structure

-6
bscottk•

"The Intellectual Elite."

Listen to Rush Limbaugh or Mark Levin for 15 minutes, and I guarantee that you'll hear this phrase in reference to the media, Obama, liberals, or congress.

I've been listening to Limbaugh (colloquially known as El Rushbo) whenever I have the opportunity just to see what the kooky shithead is up to.

He has definitely been positioning conservatism as the everyman's savior and defense against the liberal intellectual elite's domination and control.

Science is wrong.

Hoard your money.

Self interest = self preservation.

God is the only guiding path.

Fear what you don't know.

Change is bad.

They're all out to get you.

All these messages are, by design, anti-intellectual. Likely because a black guy that uses big words was elected for president and now he's tinkering with "their" system.

17
Digitalabia•

Drill baby drill

1
anthama•

Anti-intellectualism is bad enough, but I have a real problem with self-interest taking top priority at all times, it's the same reason these right wing assholes refuse to give health care coverage for anyone who doesn't already have it. If they have it, and don't have a problem (probably never faced a serious problem and denied coverage), then fuck the rest. It's a disgusting form of ethics that have become way too acceptable for me.

Also, as a side note, you really shouldn't be listening to right wing shit. I bet a good chunk of fox news and right wing talk radio is filled with people who can't stand him and are only looking for a sense of "look at what these idiots will believe", I mean is that really worth supporting these assholes.

1
davin3000•

I'll even try spinning it for you!

You know you're helping build America; when you are helping build America.

15
TheEngine•

How tautological.

Of course, I'm now clearly outside the bounds of Tea Party glossolollia.

1
c0rnd0g•

I keep pressin' this upvote thing but they'll only allow me one gosh darnit!

The Republican party has become the party of outsourced big-business and American-Made is now a joke with them. They can't have it both ways.

15
super_jambo•

Actually looking at the success of their PR - often they can and do.

13
godless_communism•

I think you have to consider the uneducated may be right about the educated swindling their hard-earned money away. Clearly, Wall Street is very happy to keep herding the cattle to the slaughter over and over again. And there are some Democrats (blue dogs especially) who are eager to write away vast amounts of our treasure over to corporations and the wealthy.

I'll have to dig up the article, but recently in the Harvard Business Review there was a criticism of investment banks that chided them for giving up on actually researching how to invest in businesses in a way that fosters growth. Instead, Wall Street has spent much of its time figuring out ways to game the system, or using quants to create hopelessly complex derivatives. So instead of a strong banking system that knows how to grow the economy, we have an industry that's good at creating confusion and ripping people off.

It's difficult for the uneducated to articulate what is really wrong, because well... they're uneducated and don't fully understand the mechanisms of macroeconomics, monetary policy, globalization. All they can understand is that brown people are taking their jerbs. I guess what's really wrong with the system here is that the educated have long used the uneducated as cattle to lead to slaughter in order to become rich.

The "elites", the educated in society have abandoned the notion of creating an economy that lifts all people up. Instead, they've created an economy that's bi-modal (lots of rich, lots of poor and a shrinking middle class) - one that is composed of overlords and the poor bastards who just come with the land & whom are there to be exploited. In other words, the moneyed class is using the educated class to exploit and murder the uneducated.

So, I think in many ways the criticisms (however poorly articulated) of the uneducated against the educated are in spirit - correct. What the educated need to do is to turn against the moneyed and to force a more equitable society, instead of joining forces with them. And for the uneducated, they need to emancipate themselves from ignorance and do the hard work of educating themselves. And it would certainly be great if the educated could help them get proficient without also demanding that they abandon every value they hold dear.

Americans are essentially pragmatist. Show them the way and they will eventually abandon what no longer makes sense. The anti-intellectualism of the religious right is nothing more than a political grab for power by the moneyed interests of our society intent on making cattle out of the uneducated.

In commie-speak the petite bourgeois need to attack the bourgeois to free the proletariat.

7
Digibella•

It is only cheaper to buy foreign because they do not have to comply with the same labor protections, environmental protections and safety protections that we do. This is amazingly short sighted as the environment they pollute so we can "buy cheap goods" is OURS as well and it is being destroyed by this short sighted, money is everything attitude. Not to mention the human rights violations that are perpetrated (and therefore encouraged by current "free" trade policies) in the process in order to "make more money".

4
kikimonster•

Its not because.... labor is cheaper and the money is worth less? If we had all the same protections and laws in the Philipines. Instead of having to pay someone .3 USD an hour, you'd be spending .6 USD an hour. Still a heck of a lot cheaper than someone in the US at minimum wage.

1
UnboughtStuffedDogs•

The term that fits this best, IMHO, is The Global Race to the Bottom.

1
egarland•

I would disagree that this is in any way anti-intellectual. To the right wingers, it's the opposite.

If you listen to right wing talk radio (and TV) you'll hear them explain how their listeners (viewers) are the smartest people in society. Despite all evidence to the contrary, they're the ones who are better informed and that's why they come to different conclusions than their simpleminded opponents. This mentality reinforces right wingers naturally high confirmation bias allowing them to dismiss arguments simply because they're from the uninformed liberals, regardless of how well informed the person is they are arguing with.

When trying to persuade republicans you first have to overcome their feverish case of confirmation bias. Anything that confirms their beliefs is instantly accepted as factual evidence regardless of validity and anything that contradicts their beliefs is instantly rejected as "flawed and incorrect in some way" regardless of their ability to find that flaw. An argument where evidence is discussed only serves to reinforce their beliefs because they rehash all their internally confirming "facts" while continuing to dismiss anything else.

I've completely avoided getting into debates with republicans lately because of this issue. The less they rehash their positions the easier a time they'll have discarding them. Attempting to convince them they're wrong is worse than useless.

Bringing reality into this sort of self-reinforcing mentality is difficult. It insulates itself well, especially from the large sweeping arguments. Most of the right wing agenda right now is based on oversimplification and fear. Unfortunately, I don't have the answer as to how to pull it apart but I'm guessing it will involve exposing the differences between reality and the oversimplified picture they've been fed as well as calming fears. Time will naturally take care of both of those things, so maybe the best thing to do is let them hang themselves with their cooked up hysteria have an agenda ready for when the loonies come down from crazy town and re-enter reality.

4
ljuvlig•

Fauster, thanks for that tweak--I am definitely a liberal who could never understand poor republicans. Now with your reframe I see how the educated/uneducated thing may have more explanatory power than the rich/poor thing. The odd thing of course is rich Republicans probably are educated. Somehow they just hide it with claims of "I drive a truck!"

This suggests, then, that it's more than educated/uneducated, but "part of my culture" versus "not part of my culture," where culture includes education, tastes and preferences, religion, worldview etc. Reminds me of a recent paper in Nature on "cultural cognition," where they did a nifty experiment showing that people were more likely to take on the same views on hypothetical vaccine when the science was delivered by a person culturally like them--either a "hierarchical and individualistic" (republican type) person or a "egalitarian and communitarian" (democrat type). Author argue that "cultural cognition" explains why things like anti-abortion and anti-global warming hang together, even though there is no logical reason for them to. http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v463/n7279/full/463296a.html

2
Fauster•

Cool! Thanks for the link. It reminds me of a study in which a student stooge would cheat on a test. If they were wearing a rival school's shirt, other students would behave ethically, but if the stooge wore the same school's shirt, other students would cheat.

Every culture has unique metrics to gauge social status and leadership... and I wish I could see a way to make them mesh in this country. For Dems to pull off victories in the fall, they would have to screw immigration reform, and run on a hang-the-bankers platform this summer. But the education divide is as deep as it is real. You don't know how much you need education, until you have it.

2
EByrne•

Commenting just so that I can take note of this post and copy/take credit for it later (just joking, but seriously good stuff).

1
randombozo•

Obama gave the middle class big tax breaks and nobody noticed.

1
tso•

timber is cheaper if bought from overseas, and it's cheaper to ship logs to an >Asian sawmill and ship them back than to process them here; beef from >Mexico is cheaper, even if it's the same old cow

i do wonder how much that is an effect of exchange rates and oil prices being based on US dollars.

1
only_human•

Feel free to mock my stupid arguments, although I'd prefer if you would prove them wrong instead.

[...] without government subsidies, the heartland economy would collapse [...]

There is a strong correlation between intelligence and SAT scores.

There is a correlation between SAT scores and income.

The highest paid 20% of income earners carry 70% of the tax burden.

Intellectual [...] 3. possessing or showing intellect or mental capacity, esp. to a high degree

Therefore, we can say that the subsidies for the heartland economy are primarily being paid for by intellectuals.

Palin's base is comprised of anti-intellectuals [...]

Palin's base, as in Republicans? I understand Republicans are all about tax breaks for the wealthy (intellectuals?).

Palin's base, as in tea partiers? I understand that tea partiers are about reduced government and lower taxes all around.

It would seem that if intellectuals are in general higher income-earners, then an effective anti-intellectual strategy would be to increase the tax burden on the wealthy and give that money back to the lower income earners in some way or another. Isn't this the strategy of the Democrats?

1
more_than_human•

What are you arguing? You answered your question.

Isn't this the strategy of the Democrats?

Yes, it is. Tax the obscenely wealthy, not give them tax cuts, like the republicans do time and again.

Palin's base doesn't seem to understand that the the party they are against is the party that is fighting for them.

3
only_human•

Tax the obscenely wealthy [...]

You're somewhat mistaken on this front. 20% of the income earners in the country pay 70% of the tax burden. Taking the median as representative of the low-end of this percentile, we have those who are earning 300k+ in salary. The obscenely wealthy (Bill Gates, Warren Buffet) have most of their net worth in capital assets, rather than salary. So really, tax burden as a % of net worth is highest for the well-off to moderately wealthy income earners.

That being said, I'm a poor college student. I'll be happy if I earn enough money over summer to pay for next year's tuition. I want to graduate, pay off my debt, and start a small business.

If my ambition pays off, I'll be well off or (if I'm lucky) moderately wealthy. Exactly the group that suffers the most from tax increases.

Are the Democrats fighting for me? Short-term, yes. Long-term, no. In essence, the Democrats are robbing from my potential to pay for entitlements I haven't earned.

I appreciate I may be an outlier, but I like to think that there are others who still have the American Dream.

Addendum: nice name, more_human_than_human was my second choice.
2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
heathpitts•

Great explanation!

1
johnlennin•

American manual labor? What makes manual labor American? Why does nationalism have to spring up into this?

1
koske•

Until the Democratic party starts giving tax breaks for those who do good, honest, and American manual labor, the Dems will keep taking punches to the jaw.

the truth is they dems are, and the repubs want more tax cuts for the rich. taxes where cut for 95% of workers last year...the 5% that didn't get cut wasn't at the top

1
adeptly•

Damn good post... only thing I have to offer is this, They get upset about people, technology and society leaving them behind and the "Dey Took Ur Jobs" (to quote south park) mentality.

1
kerabatsos•

Uneducated people still get mad about increased benefits because that lumps them in with other people that they love to feel better than.

Very well said. And I think exceptionally accurate.

1
zenwarrior01•

You started to hit on a very important point: most Americans are strongly against elitism, which typically has intellectuals at the helm. I had just wrote a few days ago how Americans need to respect elitism more, but it's impossible to realize after years of McCarthyism and decades of "Communism vs Democracy". Bottom line, those tea party types equate intellectualism with Socialism... and "Socialism" is still a dirty word in the U.S., so there's little hope of respect anytime soon.

1
jazum•

if you dont have the anti-intellectual base supporting your campaign you dont have the heart and soul of this country, you anti american snoberific nerd

1
PedometerBlues•

tldr; Palin is Pol Pot.

1
haiduz•

This is what I really hate about the republican party:

You cant be the party of American exceptionalism and anti-intellectualism at the same time.

Personally, I subscribe to the idea of American exceptionalism because of our educational institutions and developed business environment allow people with great intellect to develop it and utilize it to its fullest potential.

1
eaturbrainz•

I agree with most of what you've said, but I don't like your contempt for manual labor. So-called "manual labor" is not merely unskilled factory work or fruit-picking (which, themselves, are lines of work that deserve dignity for being hard labor). It includes all the skilled handicrafts as well. A site full of programmers, who are essentially craftsmen in data, should show more respect and understanding to the very real skills and knowledge of manual workers.

Liberalism or leftism that holds manual labor and workers in such contempt is not worth holding to at all, or even worth calling "liberalism".

1
[deleted]•

Today's populism pits the uneducated against the educated.

  • The educated should read A Canticle for Leibowitz, in order to prepare them for what will inevitably come.
  • The uneducated need to read A Canticle for Leibowitz, in order to realize that the educated always end up on top.
1
[deleted]•

This is such a great way of framing what is going on. I think Chomsky said something similar, in that we would be stupid to dismiss their rantings as just "crazy right wing paranoia". These are people with legitimate problems (loss of jobs, loss of income, loss of freedoms) and instead of doing something constructive with it, enterprising politicians like Palin saw a niche that they could exploit by making it "us vs them".

1
idiomorph•

I completely hear what you are saying, and I would just like to add that even though outsourcing is cheaper, it is completely bad for us in the long run as a nation because it is unsustainable. It fuels anti-American sentiment around the world and results in the U.S. being viewed as an evil empire engaging in neo-colonialism. Additionally all of the energy that is spent on transportation costs for goods to be shipped is a huge contributor to emissions that are unhealthy for the planet.

Multi-national corporations who happen to be based in the U.S. but often don't have national loyalty due to their global expansion are given all the same rights as, and usually more privileges than, the average citizen. This results in a vicious cycle where our goods become cheaper and cheaper while we lose more and more jobs. Those jobs are indeed the manual labor positions that created the middle class which made America so prosperous in the first place.

1
alarmarm•

Nothing in this post derives from the Tea Party members being labeled uneducated, except perhaps for the last: "mocking the admittedly stupid arguments of tea partiers only inflames their inferiority complex." This, of course, is a blanket statement. I suspect that this post got the number of upvotes that it did because of the mechanism that freshtimes has discussed: People like to read thoughtful-sounding comments the reinforce their already formed opinions. In this case, it seems we want to believe that all the tea-partiers are stupid so that we can conveniently discount everything they say.

While it may be true that the tea-partiers have an inferiority complex, it is certainly the case that the far left has a superiority complex. What should be done about it, on an individual level?

I'm really impressed by this post. It is quite thoughtful, points out some interesting ideas that demonstrate an honest understanding of some of the issues in play, and yet purposefully introduces some biased spin. What up with that?

1
[deleted]•

As if there are no educated people against the current administration (or hell, even the previous administration) policies with regard to the economy and other domestic policy. You can be smart and educated and still be wrong, which is why taking so much of the economy under the control of any small group, is a very, very bad idea, no matter how warm and fuzzy it may make you feel.

Let me decide how much my time is worth, and you can decide how much you wish to pay me. We'll either bargain, or walk away, but we'll do it of our own volition, and not under the velvet-gloved dictates of someone appointed by someone we may not have even voted for. Let me decide who my doctor is, why I take into my body, and who I share my body with, etc. and you can do the same. Don't tell me that because you are an "intellectual" or a group of "intellectuals" and therefore know what's best for me. Don't ignore what I have to say, and don't shut me up or criminalize my opinions by calling them "hate speech" or code for hate speech. The more avenues of peaceful dissent you close off, e.g., the "Fairness Doctrine", then you make non-peaceful avenues more likely to be used.

Everything about the Tea Party movement make sense from the lens of freedom vs. tyranny. They say that two kinds of people go to Washington: those who want to run the world; and those who want to save the world. And the ones who want to save the world want to save it from the people who want to run the world.

1
BloodsVsCrepes•

Palin's base is comprised of anti-intellectuals

Probably so: angry morons are a proper subset of all anti-intellectuals.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
klyemar•

But your comment is already so factual and accurate, why make it any more so?

-2
railmaniac•

Nobody said Obama's base is filled with intellectuals. Read the sentence again, it says Palin's base is anti-intellectuals. For the Dems, it's not intellectuals v/s anti-intellectuals.

Liberals who know history often thinks this means "the poor" against "the wealthy." And wonder why more poor Republicans aren't on their side.

See?

-2
Delheru•

Extremely good comment.

They want to be proud, and democrats tend to rub their "second tier" status in with the "vote your economic interest - take money from the rich" points. It the points are valid, being kept alive with someone else's money that has to be taken from them by threat of force makes you rather dependent on them. Even if you are dependent on them in any case, the illusion is important.

Independence is important. The problem with handouts is that even though democrats think they bring power to the poor, they actually in many ways do the exact opposite - they end up in a situation where the rich leaving (Ayn Rand style) would completely screw the poor up... because, like I said earlier, they're more or less tenants on the upper classes "farm".

Tax breaks for uneducated American labor are probably the smartest thing democrats could do. Instead of handouts, support small american companies and their less educated labor by minimizing the taxes they pay. This would improve their living conditions without making them feel like dependents.

0
BilS•

Yeah! Good points!

0
fross•

Replying and upping this so I can refer back to it later and re-read it. Great argument.

0
halfthetime•

Gee you don't sound like an elitist. You just make unsubstantiated statements and perpetuate stereotypes. So eveything you say must the truth as known throughout the world. I am so glad I got the privilege of reading your screed. I am now a much wiser and kind human. How can I thank you for your prejudice and bias. You are so much wiser than me. Ask yourself how your screed would read if you substitued an ethnic group for the uneducated.Pretty nice hey.

0
[deleted]•

Sarcasm fail.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
halfthetime•

Is there nothing about which you are ignorant? Perhaps you can repair your car. Not because you spent years learning about such things but because of your innate abilities. Now there is only one way to replace a sparkplug are you suggesting there is only one way to think. I do not agreeing that people should be discriminated againist nor am I agreeing that some people are wrong about everything because of a single issue. The majority of the posts here seem to belittle people not because of what those people think but because of what the posters think.One takes a lot upon himself when one proposes to know what is worth knowing and what is not. Being an elitist is as damaging as any other moral failing.It is the same us against them as is discussed here.

1
nbcaffeine•

What's anti-intellectual about 4x4ing?

38
knightofni451•

There's also nothing inherently anti-intellectual about satellite TV, phones, or driving in mud (although some people might argue that the behaviors tend to coincide). I think he's just trying to point out that fools don't appreciate the "intellectuals" who make their way of life possible, not that any of these things is bad. And even if I'm wrong and he was just being a elitist douchebag, his point is still totally valid.

61
terafunker•

My point was exactly that: fools don't appreciate the "intellectuals" who make their way of life possible.

Sitting on your ass making fun of smarter people wouldn't be possible without the progress we've made collectively thanks, mostly, to the ideas and innovations of those very intelligent and educated people working on behalf of industry and government to make the easily-accessible, cheap, and easy-to-use forms of entertainment, communication, food, and transportation favored by the American anti-intellectual.

32
EweOnBlackLedge•

Your point is basically Atlas Shrugged summed up...minus the anti-government rhetoric

3
surfwax95•

Exactly. I dislike when people think the people behind stereotypical "redneck" motor vehicle sports (NASCAR, 4x4, ATVs, etc) are stupid. I have a few friends that "mud" and could probably tell you more about gear ratios than you'd ever like to know.

37
thomasthomas•

The people behind them? Usually not stupid. The people who watch them? Stupid with a capital DUMB AS FUCK.

125
surfwax95•

I will concede that point.

45
[deleted]•

How you feel about Thai boxing?

3
[deleted]•

Fuck you. Your posting history hardly illustrates the product of a brilliant mind.

Leave NASCAR alone.

-1
[deleted]•

You seem to be implying that NASCAR is not retarded. This requires clarification.

19
surfwax95•

For me, watching NASCAR is pretty retarded. I'm more of a Rally and Autocross man myself…

However, it takes much more engineering prowess than I possess to make a 3,000lb+ machine stay together at 200MPH. Also, V8s revving to 9,000+ RPM are pretty insane.

19
MrDanger•

And in the next breath they'll tell you Obama is a socialist foreigner Muslim who is bent on the destruction of Christian America. I know these guys too.

7
adaminc•

Come muddin' in Canada then!

2
prince314159•

I'll give it that one to you, but in general, people can speak about something without knowing the nitty gritty of it. I can speak to you, for example, about quantum mechanics in very simple terms, yet if you actually work with quantum mechanics, the simple terms won't help you one single bit.

2
terafunker•

I wasn't making light of the activity of muddin', but rather the way some of the good-ole boys I've met that are into said activity sit back and pick on those who prefer higher interests in life... same goes for the NASCAR fan who thinks an F1 or MotoGP fan is an elitest intellectual for wanting to see a vehicle turn both directions in a race, or those who claim country music of heavy metal the peak of civilisation and anything else they don't find some interest in to be intellectual garbage for rich people and fags (their words, not mine).

1
Omnicrola•

God made dirt so dirt don't hurt.

(I love 4x4'ing, btw)

30

I just bought a 1998 Wrangler with a 2" lift kit and 32" mud terrains! I've only been off-roading once before and can't wait to go again. :)

1
[deleted]•
1
[deleted]•

Oh god I just realized I said this when I was stupid.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

It's a stereotype.

2
px403•

I don't think that was the claim. I think the claim was that lazy anti-intellectual retards love 4x4ing.

1
[deleted]•

4x4ing is actually elitist where I come from. Here in Grafton County, "mudding" is the layman's motor sport.

1
skazzaks•

I couldn't agree with this guy more. It is discouraging to follow this thread down and see people who would call themselves the intellectuals of the thread blindly throw out stereotypes and then reassure each other that, yes, those people that do X are the morons.

1
TheKeg•

terafunker mentioned the engine being engineered. 4x4ing was a reference to how some lower class citizens spend their time.

without that engine, how would people 4x4? pedal cars for one wouldn't work to well unless you are Fred Flintstone.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

35
MrDanger•

That's "som-bitch", son.

86
diarrhea_kid•

Sumbitch, yankee.

43
[deleted]•

Summbitch, sir.

11
[deleted]•

He's not your 'sir', ma'am.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mcrbids•

And to be even more fair, while they could "set up" a 4 link suspension, they sure as shit couldn't design the equipment to actually construct the relevant parts! Somebody's got to design the ball and socket joints, and somebody's got to design the machines that manufacture the ball and socket joints! Let us not forget the well-balanced, smooth-running 454 cubic inch V8 engine powering the whole thing?

46
Rentun•

No "Somebody" didn't design all of those things, many people did.

No one person designed any V8 in the world.

5
negro_machine•

Psh, how hard is it to design a V8? Just throw a crap ton of veggies and maybe a banana into a blender and fire it up. BAM, V8 like a muafucka.

6
[deleted]•

And to be even more fair, while they could "set up" a 4 link suspension, they sure as shit couldn't design the equipment to actually construct the relevant parts!

Sorry but this is an assumption.

1
Snoron•

This is an assumption too, for all you know he knows these same guys and the limits of their capabilities.

2
pantzareoff•

uhm. could you?

0
caramine•

That isn't really the issue here, is it?

5
selectrix•

An educated person (and only an educated person) could.

3
iconicimage•

That highlights the difference between intelligence and aptitude.

2
[deleted]•

The thing is, these pig fuckers don't care about what you've done to help them or the technical merit behind anything they use in their daily lives. Technical innovations are owed to them, and its up the geeky scientist faggots to discover and implement them.

16
halfthetime•

With name calling like that you could only be one of THEM.

3
geft•

Without science, we'll still be in the dark ages. Screw those anti-intellectuals.

6
stonegossad•

Funny thing is I know plenty of Religious people who honestly believe that Christianity guided us out of the Dark Ages.

7
slimmaster•

Yeeeeehaaaaw!!!.. I shure love me sum muddin'!

3
TescoPeeledPlums•

One tl;dr that can completely sum up that paragraph is a quote from bill gates: "Be nice to nerds, eventually you will end up working for one."

3
[deleted]•

It would be awesome if engineers all over the world decided to make the interface for all devices and services not be designed for the least common denominator, then you would have to have at least some intelligence to use modern conveniences.

3
terafunker•

Pick up a Japanese cell phone sometime.

1
SmugCheck•

Confirmed.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
accountt1234•

No, that was done by smart people. Well, to be more specific, smart people that made a shitload of money, doing just that.

2
my_life_is_awesome•

Exactly. 'Nuff said.

So... do you have any grey poupon? I'm making a sandwich.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Suppy•

you use for muddin'

I miss having the time to play a good MUD, I wouldn't be able to type so fast without my experiences.

0
crookers•

Sext? Muddin'? Who uses such horrible slang???

-1
j0nny5•

Lol :)

Saying it "led to modern society" is definitely a bit of a jump, though. All of the things you describe were caused far more directly by capitalism and the structure of financial compensation that was in place before any of those things were invented.

Inventors usually don't choose who wants to purchase or use the fruits of their labor, marketers and the market do. If 4x4s were only marketed and sold to farmers and the military, you probably wouldn't see them used for (what some would see as) un-intellectual ends. The fine balance between utter freedom and human advancement.

This is where education is paramount; the theory is that if you are taught critical thinking skills, it will be much more of a stretch that you'll end up in a situation where you're sexting your baby mama and muddin'. Then again, I've done both. Logic fail ;)

-8
enkiam•

You cannot make claims about causality without experiment. It is impossible to randomly assign civilizations to various economic models. Thus, your hypothesis on the motivations behind certain inventions is untestable, and should be regarded as your opinion, not a statement of fact.

5
j0nny5•

I'm sorry, I assume that all I post is regarded as opinion. I think it's fairly obvious that I cannot test intention on the behalf of the inventor of a product, but that isn't even the point I was making. The poster (who, I know, was joking, but he raised an important point IMO) linked the (unintended) use of technology with the existensce of that technology. It's like saying, "look at all these people being stabbed with kitchen knives. You know who invented kitchen knives? Intellectualism!". Sexting and mudding can be assumed to be unintended uses of technology. Obviously, this is my opinion, and it's a bit ridiculous to assume I'd claim to know the inventors of both text-messaging and bias-ply radial tires in order to ask them what their intentions were when inventing these things. I thought the poster was funny, and wasn't attacking him; just the prevailing jump-to-conclusions that people seem to make from existence to intention. Capische?

0
enkiam•

I'm sorry, I assume that all I post is regarded as opinion.

Then you should frame your posts to reflect that, perhaps by prefacing them with "In my opinion..." or "I have no evidence to believe, but I accept on faith that..."

0
Hollic•

Errr.... his point was how the technology to accomplish these feats was come by; intellectuals.

2
j0nny5•

And by that logic you can say that anything was "come by" anything else that happened before it chronologically. To oversimplify, intellectuals invented products. Products were then demographically assigned by another group. They were then marketed. They were then advertised, endorsed and promoted. Then people bought them, and for whatever reason, used them in ways that the "intellectuals" likely didn't anticipate in my opinion. How is this, "sexting was come by intellectuals, because they invented the cellphone." Really?

And yes, I KNOW the poster was making a joke. I'm not attacking them. Sheesh.

0
Hollic•

Sigh... could people without vast understanding of electronics have come up with cell phones and satellites? Unlikely. Are these same people shunned for being "ivy-league white-tower intellectuals" by the same people who utilize that technology? Yes. Is this hypocritical? I guess that's up to you. Sigh.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-16
Hungry_Jefferson•

The Point >>>>>>>>> You

4
flio191•

This is just as much "talking down" as you so propose is ruining the intellectual–anti-intellectual relationship...

4
deadapostle•

I don't think that you really proved your argument very well. Maybe you were opposed to his use of 4X4 as a prop of the anti-intellectual ideology, and perhaps that is classist, but you actually chose to use 'intellectuals like you' as a form of slur.

Not only that, but you ended up basing your opinion of the man (having his head up his ass, having a superiority complex, and even an assumed ignorance of farming equipment) based solely on one of his many examples and ignored his point altogether.

Okay, you were offended by his choice of 4X4. Some people may have been offended by his choice of the phrase 'to sext your baby-mama.' Clearly he could have chosen a less antagonizing means to explain his point, but his point itself is quite valid: that the greatest advancements in technology, which feed the comfort of a very large portion of people who happen to be anti-intellectual, are brought about by the very same intellectual culture they claim to despise.

I should also point out that it is quite probable that a great number of the men and women who have engineered these technologies enjoy their benefit as well.

What is even more important is understanding where anti-intellectuality comes from. In many cases, the very mouthpieces of anti-intellectualism are themselves intellectuals.

David Horowitz - Intellectual anti-intellectualist

William Bennet - Intellectual anti-intellectualist

Pat Buchanan - Intellectual anti-intellectualist

Hell, even Fox 'n' Friends' own Gretchen Carlson is an intellectual anti-intellectualist.

Do you know why?

4
TMI-nternets•

your good friend and millionaire, does he talk shit about people that made him satelite TV?

2
[deleted]•

Calm down brah.

-1
Jruff•

Your shits all retarded

349
Az1521•

And you talk like a fag.

248
karmanaut•

And you quote idiocracy too much.

147
[deleted]•
87
catmoon•

Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn.

40
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

hahahah! I was just watching this tonight!

0
MrFlagg•

but its got what Plancks crave.

8
socratessue•

Ossum.

0
i_am_my_father•

Idiocracy will continue to be quoted because it is a prophecy.

5
ltjboy03•

n u kuote Idiocracy 2 much yo

3
Gluverty•

No fuckin shit, lady, do I sound like I'm ordering a pizza!

1
CrPlunk•

you knew this would have to be said, before you clicked the link.

1
ltjboy03•

n u tak lik a fAg

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

50
Jruff•

I feel bad as well. I downvoted my own comment. I am actually a science teacher and I have 3 rules in my class.

  • Respect yourself and others.
  • Don't do anything to get your self in trouble.
  • Anti-intellectualism will not be tolerated.

I teach my students to always seek evidence and to question the knowledge they take for granted. I'm teaching evolution this week, and I have a mother that has been calling the administration to complain about my teaching. This topic really does break my heart.

103
Detoid•

I really like this list.

No matter how much you try, there is always going to be a parent that has an issues with the way class is being taught. One time after almost every parent and student came up to me to say thanks, ask about future schedules, and shower me with positive feedback (ego was soaring!), a mother started screaming at me! I shut her down, but after she left, yes, I cried. It was so embarrassing. I guess with time teachers become more battle hardened.

27
Recidivist•

But sometimes, when teachers get battle-hardened, they also lose their zest for teaching and start thinking of it as just a job, a career. I hate it when that happens. The only teachers I've ever had respect for are the ones who've been full of enthusiasm for their subjects and encouraged questioning, even if it means that a 14 year old kid (me, then) will argue with them and tell them they're wrong for half an hour because in his arrogance he thinks he knows better. Conversely, those are also the only sort of teachers who used to like having me as a student.

3
[deleted]•

Yes, you are a public figure. You have to have armor.

1
[deleted]•

I like your 3 rules, and since science teachers have it so hard now, thanks for your efforts.

17
[deleted]•

It's interesting to see that this whole anti-evolution thing is mostly an American thing. I think that not many people here in Europe seriously dispute evolution. What do my fellow Europeans think?

2
Fr0C•

When I read the headline, my first thought was that s/he should have written "...in American society."
An anti-intellectual society is not modern.

Btw, I'm visiting my parents these days, and yesterday my dad suggested, once more, that they should go on a vacation in the US. My mom refused, and this anti-evolution crap was her main argument against it.

3
trutommo•

You should instead stealth edit the top comment to something intellectual.

1
Peaker•

You should watch South Park's "Go God Go" episode.

1
TheProphetMuhammad•

"Do you have any Grey Poupon?"

3
missioninfinite•

On reddit the top comment is almost always a joke.

2
voilavoila•

don't feel bad, the poster could just move on from his home town and look to the future.

1
heliotropic•

reddit has intellectual posts?

1
Pufflekun•

i thnk u meen retarted u dum fuk lern 2 spel retart haz too t

17
[deleted]•

I think the people downvoting this are missing your sarcasm.

3
mindbleach•

I think the people downvoting this don't give a fuck how sarcastic it was, they just want to get it off their screens and keep other people from being subjected to it.

8
Pufflekun•

fuk u

i subjected ur mom 2 my dick last nite

0
ychromosome•

You are wrong, sir. He clearly meant retired.

1
Wonka_Vision•

Leaving out the apostrophe was a nice touch!

4
FerociousImbecile•

This thread's gayer than a sack of wet hammers.

1
[deleted]•

Gayer than two guys sitting on a park bench sharing a banana.

4
wanderingjew•

the correct idiom is "a bundle of dildos bound together and used as fuel, a torch, etc"

1
qabsteak•

Fag.

1
monkeyman114•

Faggot. Figures the gay romans came up with it first.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ltjboy03•

ur shitz all retard yo

1
xang•

You mean retired.

1

tl;dr

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
crapcrappingcrap•

Fuck you smartass

-1
[deleted]•

Ctrl F. Upvote.

-3
dajensen•

Oh man I love reddit fuuuuuck

-6
Areonis•

I think some of the anti-intellectual backlash comes directly from religion, where faith is a virtue. Asking questions is actively discouraged and books are banned for being "of the devil." I mean most evangelicals are taught that they will be marginalized by the godless heathens. Their literal view of the Bible obviously doesn't match up with science so they are "forced" to make it so that the intelligentsia are brainwashing everybody.

279
[deleted]•

Religion =/= fundamentalism. The sooner this distinction is made, the better.

163
freehunter•

Religion is still not rational, nor is it intellectual. If you're not allowed to question everything, you're bing irrational and unintellectual.

173
[deleted]•

Totally don't want to start a debate here, but being rational and questioning everything has lead some people to religion. Also, I consider myself religious, but I constantly question the church and the bible. There is no rule that says "if you believe in God you are not allowed to be rational." There is a lot of falsehoods but there are also a lot of truths in religion.

If you want to get a good idea of where my reason for belief comes from read Tolstoy's A Confession, its really philisophically interesting. I don't agree with him completely, but I went through a very similar process as him recently.

edit: wow, I probably should have known I would get so many replies if I mentioned god in r/science. Thanks everyone for your comments and criticisms. Do know that I consider everything that I hear, so your replies are appreciated.

113
zzbzq•

This is true, since questioning everything does not indicate that the questions are receiving correct answers.

80
freehunter•

Well, there's a huge difference between begin "religious" and being "spiritual". Lots of scientists are spiritual, and lots of respected scientists believe in a God. The problem is, by definition, being a Christian means you follow the word of the Bible and take it as truth, and the word of God is not to be questioned.

I'm going to respect your wishes to not start a debate (if you can question the Bible and still believe in your faith, then I'm glad you are happy), it's just of my opinion that God and faith are two separate things, it's possible to believe in God but still question everything from a scientific standpoint, provided you do not have religion behind you telling you that the scientific consensus is wrong because the Bible says so.

13
callum_cglp•

Totally don't want to start a debate here, but being rational and questioning everything has lead some people to religion.

They weren't being rational then.

There is a lot of falsehoods but there are also a lot of truths in religion.

Such as?

Edit: Formatting for clarity.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
Bavaron•

How does rationality lead one to settle on Christianity though of all things? Is there compelling evidence for it? Last I checked, it had absolutely no evidence going for it which puts it in the same league as every other religion. Maybe it's its popularity or maybe all the threats and promises it makes overrode the evidence requirement?

7
logic11•

If you believe in God you are not being rational.

Belief in God is belief without rational evidence. It is your choice to believe in God or not, but to try and claim that it is in any way rational is simply wrong.

3
Teekoo•

I hate church, the sitting, standing and kneeling.. I wish the priest would just pick a position and fuck me!

2
frack0verflow•

There is no rule that says "if you believe in God you are not allowed to be rational."

It's hard to understand your meaning. Many people (myself included) would argue that believing in a god is irrational to begin with.

Are youtrying to say that within an irrational belief system there are contained rational beliefs because if so then the argument is moot.

Sometimes it seems that belivers and non believers have two totall separate dictionaries where certain key words just outright have a different meaning.

2
rchase•

If you could reason with religious people, there wouldn't be any religious people.

edit: I know that's trite, and a quote from a television show. But it's still profoundly true.

1
xcalibre•

you said you don't want to debate but i feel compelled to mention that belief in the unprovable IS irrational by definition.

there are indeed rules dissapproving of questioning... my limited knowledge of the multiply-rewritten egyptian stories is that it is unforgivable to question the existence of god (ie. go to hell do not pass go)

if these stories can be rewritten and reinterpretted willy-nilly, to me, that is a good sign that they are piles of dog excrement that can be ignored. actually, religion shouldn't be ignored, it should be stomped out. It preys on the weak (the young, the terminally ill and elderly) with guilt and false promises

1
naasking•

There is no rule that says "if you believe in God you are not allowed to be rational."

I agree. I think the rule is generally, "if you believe in (most) religions, you are not being rational". The religions consistent with rationality are the ones that do not posit beliefs inconsistent with science. The only "religion" I am aware of is Zen Buddhism, if we use the term "religion" loosely, but I've not studied this in depth so I'd love to hear of any more.

There is a lot of falsehoods but there are also a lot of truths in religion.

There is no shame in reusing good ideas, even if from a unreliable source such as a religion. There is great shame in subscribing wholeheartedly to that source merely because it may have a few good ideas.

1
bebnet•

I just want to point something out in your very reasonable position:

religious =!= christianity/bible-reading/god

I think one of the biggest problems with the subject of religion is that people very rarely are able to prevent themselves from associating ideals from one particular group with the entire subject of religion itself. This generalisation is a curse that afflicts many subjects, not just science, and not just religion, but it is one of the most anti-civilization forces at effect in our modern culture today. Our inability to disassociate generalised ideals from workable knowledge of the details is the problem with religion, and those that espouse a purely scientific method have long recognised this fact and work to resolve it.

1
[deleted]•

"But being rational and questioning everything has lead some people to religion."

I am not so sure about that. Being exposed to it leads people to it, for sure. But I wonder, if religion didn't already exist in the world for you to refer to, would you have been led so readily to it?

0
agnt007•

you can question everything in hinduism

26
[deleted]•

You can question everything in every religion.

31
freehunter•

Hinduism isn't really based on relying on faith, though, and there's no one book telling you exactly how to think and exactly how things were created. Hinduism is rational, for the most part.

5
ribosometronome•

You realize that not every religion is Christianity, right? And that there are some religions where you're encouraged to question the teachings?

26
[deleted]•

Christianity is not anti-intellectual. How many high-quality Jesuit schools still exist which teach reason and rationality just as well as any secular school? There are plenty of Christian groups that are entirely embracing of intellectualism, the problem is that everyone looks at "born again" southern Christians and then paint the entire religion with the same brush. They feel the need to express their ignorance loudly, and drown out all reasonable Christians.

I'm pretty sure that if Thomas Aquinas were alive today he'd take one look at the fundies and say "wow, you guys are dumb."

63
binary•

Reminds me of my stint with the Baha'i faith...

1
freehunter•

It's obvious from the words in my second sentence that I'm talking about religions where things are taken as fact based on faith. Hinduism and other such religions are different, obviously.

0
hardman52•

Religion is still not rational

Not necessarily. If you participate in something that doesn't depend on reason, but it brings you positive benefits, is that irrational?

12
Dulousaci•

Yes.

The benefits themselves are either all in your head (and therefore irrational), such as a positive outlook on life because God is watching out for you, or they are totally unrelated to the specific irrational belief, such as meeting a friend at bible study. You could meet the friend somewhere else; the irrational act of believing the bible as truth had nothing to do with the actual beneficial act of meeting the friend.

4
freehunter•

If it brings you spiritual happiness, that is a good thing, and a rational choice. If you're actively denying scientific fact and basing your world view on faith, this is no longer a good thing, nor is it rational.

1
Virtualmatt•

It's great if you get a positive outlook from it, great, but don't pretend it's rational or logical. There's nothing logical about taking an untestable, unproven story as fact.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
binary•

I think it's worth saying that there are a lot of smart people in the world who believe in some sort of God.

Contrary to what many atheists would have you believe, religion does not equate to being bat-shit crazy or anything of the sort. I agree with the irrational part--faith is irrational--but unintellectual implies some sort of stupidity, which is not inherent with being religious.

10
freehunter•

I've stated in another post in this same topic that many scientists believe in a God, and still more are spiritual. The ideas are not irreconcilable, but the loudest of the religious teachings will not have you think so.

1
Dearon•

Since you seem to have a lot of knowledge about this, what is it exactly that a, say, Christian is not allowed to question?

9
freehunter•

Basically, the Bible is the word of God, and anything the Bible says cannot be questioned. The world is 6,000 years old, dinosaurs never existed (or existed, but were never mentioned and died in the great flood), men used to live to be 900 years old, Jesus healed with the power of magic and walked on water, and there is no such thing as evolution.

Now, not every Christian believe that (which in my opinion makes me question if they really know what being Christian means), but the general rule is, if God said it, it's true (unless he later took it back like the "no eating pigs" thing), and don't question God or Heaven.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SpelingTroll•

If you're not allowed to question everything, you're bing irrational and unintellectual

Straw man here. You're assuming that religion implies not being able to question everything.

Without religion there would't be science. Astronomy and physics, and by extension, math developed in the ancient temples because of intellectual curiosity, the very sentiment you say religious people lack.

1
freehunter•

And what happened to Galileo when he made the discovery that the Earth revolved around the sun?

1
[deleted]•

Religion is still not rational, nor is it intellectual.

It isn't it was meant that way. So stop questioning the religion from the rational/intellectual point of view. That's like trying to assess a poem by using a ruler.

1
pewpewpewz•

Someone got a little touchy

1
freehunter•

I'm not questioning religion from a rational point of view. I think I've made it clear that I am of the opinion that religion is not rational. I'm asking religious folks to analyze their lives and see if their are leading their lives rationally. If that means questioning their religion, then that is a good thing, even if it doesn't lead them from it, they should still know their convictions.

You say religion wasn't meant to be rational, yet religion is influencing our government and science. Should government and science be irrational, as well?

1
Moz•

It doesn't matter what it was intended to be. Religions make specific claims about the world and are therefore subject to scientific inquiry.

1
iquanyin•

in buddhism also, questioning is fine.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
archontruth•

A lot of people have this view, and I feel sad for them. For every Christian you see on Fox News ignoring every part of the Bible except the bits that confirm his prejudices, there are more who have actually read the whole book, think about it quite a bit, and question it a lot.

1
freehunter•

If you're not allowed to question everything, you're being irrational and unintellectual.

That's the difference between my viewpoint and yours, and also where they reconcile.

1
obrysii•

Love is not rational, nor is it intellectual. Are you going to fore-go finding a lover because of that?

1
freehunter•

Love can be rational, and I hope everyone would find a lover who could match them on an intellectual level. Just because the feeling of love might not explainable doesn't mean people don't fall in love for rational reasons, they just don't tend to justify it as such.

0
campingknife•

Upvote for sly reference to Microsoft search engine.

1
freehunter•

Haha, I caught that after someone had quoted it, didn't bother to fix it since about 50 people have quoted it in various attacks on my post.

1
eaturbrainz•

You're still overgeneralizing. There are plenty of religions in which a person is allowed to question everything. A person who actively disagrees with the tenets of the faith will be considered a "bad X" (for religion X) or as an apostate for the exact same reason that a conservative is not considered a liberal, but people are allowed to ask whatever questions they please.

1
freehunter•

I realize that it's a sweeping generalization. Any logical person would infer that I said what I said for the sake of brevity and readability. "Religion is still not rational, nor is it intellectual" is eminently more quotable than "Some world religions such as fundamentalist Christianity and various other (but not all) Abrahamic religions have a tendency (but not a requirement) to be anti-intellectual and irrational in certain cases, as spoken by certain people." That doesn't say anything, and is too hard to read. How do you think I got 200 upvotes?

1
rm999•

Religion is still not rational, nor is it intellectual. If you're not allowed to question everything, you're bing irrational and unintellectual.

I've seen religious people attacked by scientists for questioning evolution; it goes both ways. Does that make science not rational or intellectual?

0
[deleted]•

you haven't seen religious people get attacked by scientists. you most likely saw scientists disagreeing with their ideas. I have seen scientists attacked by religious people for questioning their "faith"

5
mexicodoug•

I've seen religious people attacked by scientists for questioning evolution; it goes both ways.

You're missing something important. Questioning with reason doesn't equal attacking. Scientists are constantly shown incorrect through the scientific method of publishing their theories and testing them rigorously. "Back to the drawing board" is what the scientist lives for and does every day.

It doesn't work the other way. When a religious person is questioned on the basis of his/her beliefs, they don't go back to the drawing board to fix or more fully understand the problem. They go back to dogma.

By the way, scientists constantly question the theory of evolution, and the theory has evolved in highly enlightening ways over the decades. Genetics alone has brought amazing new insights into how evolution works (thus improving the theory of evolution) in the past five years alone.

However, evolution has been observed for as long as people have been recording their observations. The theory of evolution was first coherently explained by Darwin and those capable of reason have been been discussing it ever since. Nobody has disproved the Darwin's theory, but many improvements have been made by skeptics and other researchers since then.

4
freehunter•

Well, the problem with that is, believers in the scientific consensus are generally attacking the religious folk for simply shutting down evolution, not for questioning it. Religious people tend to say things like "the Bible doesn't mention evolution" or "God made everyone perfect" or "the world isn't old enough for evolution". This is a questioning of evolution, but the questions they are proposing are based on faith, not science. Basically, science is not fitting their faith, and they're unhappy with it.

However, I understand your point, there's no law saying idiots can't believe in science as well. This one, though doesn't go in the other direction quite as easily, if you're basing your knowledge on faith, you're likely an idiot to begin with.

2
benm314•

A true scientist would never attack anyone for questioning. Science is based in large part on continuously questioning assumptions.

A true Christian would...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
FerociousImbecile•

Delete this one. To avoid em-bare-ass-ment.

-2
shadow1515Grad Student|Pharmacy •

That's simply not true. Often religion is a system of myths and rituals with no other purpose than to preserve and transmit social mores. No belief required.

0
freehunter•

Those are called "dead religions". Greek mythology is now viewed as a simple way to convey stories and history. Modern religions are viewed by those practicing them as the unquestionable truth.

3
DSchmitt•

This is true, though I disagree with calling it a religion at that point, personally. There are a lot of Jews, for instance, who are atheists, but will still go to temple and take part in rituals and such. It's a cultural thing, not a religious one.

Religion has a rather squishy definition, often times. The one I use, for instance, relies in part upon belief in supernatural elements to explain some events.

1
[deleted]•

Religion is still not rational

That's a very naive opinion. Religion can be very rational, in pragmatic terms e.g.- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Will_to_Believe

nor is it intellectual.

That betray a deep ignorance of millenia of theological scholarship.

If you're not allowed to question everything, you're bing irrational and unintellectual.

Questioning everything leads to solipsism.

0
inwats•

There's at least one religion I can think of that encourages questions and debate, and that's Buddhism. But since the majority of religions don't allow debate, your generalization is pretty accurate.

0
freehunter•

Hinduism as well, though I would hesitate to lump those two in the general category of "religion", I would rather call them "ways of living". They're not founded on faith, but rather a philosophy of questioning, meditation, and learning.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

if it was rational it isn't religion.

2
[deleted]•

Do you really think questioning everything is a fruitful venture?

-5
monopocalypse•

Um, yes? Yeah, yes.

26
[deleted]•

Do you think not being allowed to is more fruitful?

5
freehunter•

Yes, I do. It's impossible to count the number of things that have been discovered just by questioning things that were previously "known facts". For example, the discovery that Earth is round, or that Earth rotates around the sun, or that, unlike it says in Genesis, the stars were not put there just to provide us with directions at night.

3
cerebralscrub44•

how else has progress ever been made?

1
drunkbirth•

Yes. But it is more disturbing to have soemthing be off limits, or immune to questioning. Religion should be held to the same rigors as any other explanation for events, and that includes falsifiability.

1
MrFlagg•

uhhh.

ya i do.

1
sepht•

You should probably ask yourself why you believe certain things, especially if they're big, important, and controversial. To be fair, religion seems to fall in that category.

On the other hand, I think Gogol is right when he says "Let me warn you, if you start chasing after views, you'll be left without bread and without views."

1
pavs•

Religion breeds more fundamentalism. The sooner this distinction is made, the better.

42
[deleted]•

Sure, some religious people are fundamentalist. In America, it might even be the trend. But you cannot give statements like 'Religion breeds more fundamentalism' without giving specific qualifiers; they aren't all the same.

5
pavs•

Give me one example of a terrorist, murderer, who killed specifically for their lack of belief.

I will give you 100s of examples of people who murdered specifically for their religious beliefs.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
citan_uzuki•

I'm not quite sure what you hope to say here. Does that mean that religion should be abolished, in order to prevent fundamentalism? Should we abolish roads, in order to prevent car accidents?

1
pavs•

Acknowlidging religion breeds fundamentalism is a first step to recognizing the aspects of religion that breeds fundamentalism and abolish them.

In an ideal world religion should be abolished, but unfortunately that won't happen anytime soon.

2
Areonis•

Well making faith a virtue is at least anti-rational, and I would argue also anti-intellectual. Critical thinking is a big enemy of religious beliefs.

34
wedgeomatic•

Faith isn't by definition irrational. I'm aware that it is A definition of faith, but it's not the only one and it's not the one used by most religions. Moreover, I don't really think that "faith" as generally understood is something that applies to all religious groups.

EDIT: Seriously, not all religious people are Fideists. If you don't even understand the basic claims of the groups you are criticizing, how do you feel justified in criticizing them? And again, not all religions are Christianity. In fact, most religions aren't Christianity.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

30
Areonis•

Faith = belief without evidence. How is this rational?

14
PD711•

I have never encountered a definition of faith that wasn't irrational.

9
ixid•

Can you give a rational one?

7
[deleted]•

Faith, by definition, is belief in the absence of a reasonable reason to hold that belief. It's the antithesis to reason.

6
benkapa•

I'm a Buddhist. Buddhism is a religion. There's blind faith and there's faith founded upon reason. Buddha asked his disciples to question everything until you reach an airtight conclusion. Then, you can have faith based in that conclusion. I like this method a lot.

Here's a video of debating where you try to kill your opponent's position with logic out of compassion for them rather than egotistical pride.

We use logic to dispel our all too common blind faith, such as believing that our keys are what starts our car. Upon analysis we learn that keys don't start our car because there are many other things necessary to start the car. The other parts of the ignition system, engine, hand turning the key, gas, those that brought the gas to us, etc.

When we start to use logic and deductive reasoning, we start to see how most all of our beliefs are built upon blind faith. Questions are the vitamins of the mind. If we stop asking questions and think we know it all, we lose out on our opportunity to evolve.

0
[deleted]•

You are stereotyping. There are many rational religious people who understand where questions of faith apply and where they don't. You don't have to be a rabid materialist to understand the value of science.

I presume Fox has led you to believe all conservatives are mouth breathing Sarah Palin fans?

-1
ixid•

There are many rational religious people

That's a contradiction in terms. At best they've put up a non-rational mental fence around their religious beliefs even if they apply rationality elsewhere.

9
[deleted]•

Conservatives have led us all to believe they are mouth breathing Sarah Palin fans.

7
[deleted]•

The religionists who vote in this country are the ones who matter to me. And they have real-world effects, like the Prop 8 vote in California and the Orwellian Texas textbook rewriting going on right now.

6
Areonis•

You just stereotyped. I am actually conservative on economic issues, but yes I do have a mostly unfavorable view of the religious right. They actually ARE anti-science though. You don't have to be anti-science if you are religious, but if you are allowed to accept things without evidence, it's hard to argue the case for why you need evidence and this itself is undermining science.

3
khasiv•

It may not be Fox's fault. I was reading through a conservative Facebook group with at least a million members, and was appalled to see that they all were spouting essentially the same anti-intellectual, fear-mongering vitriol.

2
drunkbirth•

The "value of science" isn't in technology, but in new explanations about the world. Something every religion shares are pre-fabricated, evidence-proof explanations that displace any other possibilities. (P.S. it's also full of advice on when it is appropriate to pimp your daughter (Old Testament). It is not a beautiful, sacrosanct part of our culture that enlightened types should politely work around.)

2
[deleted]•

The intersection of religion and reason is the null set.

In every analysis religion requires fundamentalism -- the closing of the mind and the assertion from authority.

All other religions but one's own are incorrect. Religion quickly devolves into a mass of bullshit.

7
cyantist•

Wow, this is not at all the case.

There are many religions that are non-exclusive. There are many people who are a member of a religion for community purposes. There are many in Asia who are members of several religions. There are many who hold beliefs as abstracts that are true and not incompatible with otherwise literally incompatible beliefs. Many Christians believe God is a personal god, and that the church does not hold authority but rather guidance for having a "personal relationship with God" -- no assertion from authority.

I'm afraid I'm going to have to believe you haven't done much analysis.

12
mexicodoug•

There are many politicians who claim to have religion yet upon analysis aren't religious at all and in practice oppose religion. Look up Benito Juarez (Catholic) and Josef Stalin (Russian Orthodox). Benito was on the side of good and Josef was on the side of bad, but they both recognized themselves as religious while doing their best to eradicate religion's power in the government.

Many of us are hoping that the most powerful politician on the planet, Barack Obama, will use his power to help remove the power of religion from governments worldwide even though he is a professed Christian.

2
zzbzq•

"Few." You kept saying "many" by mistake.

1
njharman•

ok, whatever. Areonis's post is about religion and doesn't touch on fundamentalism at all.

3
[deleted]•

The problem is that he is using the word religion where he means Fundamentalism. The two are distinct, and while his point might be true of fundamentalism, it doesn't extend to religion in general.

8
zzbzq•

This is a good point. We need to make a distinction here. Fundamentalism is religion that is actually sticking to the logical conclusions of its assumptions. It is internally consistent, it just contradicts reality. Non-fundamentalist religion contradicts both.

4
[deleted]•

Sure it does. Faith and reason are utterly alien and inhospitable concepts. The instant you have faith, reason is dead to you, because there is a portion of your worldview that canno be questioned or verified, and it will gradually distort everything else to fit.

2
FerociousImbecile•

Fundies are the only true religiots.

The rest all just pay lip service to it.

1
DSchmitt•

Yes, thank you. I would further extend this to say that non-religious fundamentalism is also a problem. Dogmatic belief in Communism and the correctness of Stalin, for instance, or dogmatic belief in the correctness of Mao, to give a couple of non-religious examples, is just as dangerous. It's dogma that's the big problem.

You and I disagree on many points in this thread, but I think we can agree on this one, yes?

1
Gluverty•

Unless that was his/her perspective on religion.

1
Areonis•

I did not use religion where I meant fundamentalism. I was using evangelicals as an extreme example of anti-intellectualism, but there are examples from more mainstream Christian groups like the Catholic church as well as Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism.

0
tsarus•

It seems like you use Haskell.

1
[deleted]•

Yes, but religion is irrational just like theism and any other kind of magical thinking

1
eric22vhs•

The problem is that the line between fundamentalism and religion is extremely fuzzy.

1
BrkneS•

I think it does, but it you can make a rational distinction between religion and fundamentalism here and now, I'll concede your point, otherwise I think you're wrong and full of shit.

1
[deleted]•

Let us begin with definitions. What do you consider to be fundamentalism? I presume we won't be limiting ourselves to Christianity, either.

1
[deleted]•

Religion =/= fundamentalism. The sooner this distinction is made, the better.

A non-sequitur. We're discussing the fact that Religion = ignorance which is leading to anti intellectualism. Your point has no relation here. Both organized religion and fundamental religion and dumbing people down and robing them of their own god given humanity. They only vary by severity.

1
[deleted]•

I don't think you are correct here. Intellectualism isn't limited to science, nor does practicing religion ipso facto make you some sort of obscurantist charlatan. I think you views on religions have sound profound biases, which would do well to be tempered with some research.

1
[deleted]•

I think you views on religions have sound profound biases, which would do well to be tempered with some research.

Since were making baseless assumptions ill give you mine. I think you have a profound bias toward religion being good and if you ever crack the glue on the spine of your history text book from high school, youll read some of the horrible and awful things done in the name of god. I like how religion used to know about astronomy but would keep it "hidden secret knowledge" from the rest of the people so they could predict eclipses and threaten the town with doom if they didnt give up half their crops and their virgin sons/daughters.

You should read some some history on religion, its mostly bad.

1
Railboy•

Many, many religious moderates share these anti-intellectual views. Fundamentalism isn't necessary for anti-intellectualism.

1
[deleted]•

Any religion is bad. Faith is the root of ignorance.

0
[deleted]•

I thought the root of ignorance was usually poverty and poor education, coupled with various social factors.

1
FerociousImbecile•

Dream on, bible-boi.

-1
[deleted]•

I'm not religious.

2
Devilboy666•

Can't have fundies without religion

-1
[deleted]•

The history of thought shows you can have rabid thinkers about almost any topic- religion is hardly unique in this regard.

4
crapcrappingcrap•

Uh, no. Religion is fundamentalism, by definition.

It sounds like you're trying to say that some are more fundamentalist than others. Which is also true.

-7
datn•

No, "A is a subset of B" does not imply "All B is A", especially when A and B are defined on Wikipedia.

Also, Christianity is not all religion.

That said, an argument claiming that the phenomenon of religion and the concept of faith can help an anti-intellectual mindset need not use fundamentalism to make its point.

7
crapcrappingcrap•

The link was so retards like you wouldn't get lost on the way to a starting point for education. Keep your irrelevant logic to yourself. The definition of fundamentalism is "All B is A" and you can use whatever sources you like to learn that.

-3
[deleted]•

If you read the link you posted, you would see fundamentalism has a rather clear history that a pertains to a specific subset of Christianity (let alone all religions).

5
crapcrappingcrap•

If you read beyond the first few paragraphs in the link I posted you would see that fundamentalism has a rather broad definition and pertains to far more than the specific subset of Christianity to which it is most often applied in the United States.

But this is reddit so that's a real big "if".

1
[deleted]•

The anti-intellectualism was and is also a "feature' of the atheist communist societies.

The intellectuals were seen almost as 'traitors' and as belonging to the bourgeoisie and the emphasis was on the workers and peasants. Lenin hated the intellectuals even if he was one of them. Stalin, Mao even more so. Pol Pot outright murdered them en masse. Countless people were murdered for being literate or even for wearing glasses (!).

The workers were hailed, the intellectuals were tolerated at best and had shitty pays in all the former Socialist countries. Back in the days I was a blue-collar worker and I made twice as much as most of the engineers. Joining the party (some privileges), promotions, getting apartments, whatever, were a hard thing for the intellectuals or for those who had 'bad' origins (children of the intellectuals).

70
TooTallForPony•

This point by mosox and the current treatment of intellectuals by the religious Right both relate to the same phenomenon - those in power trying to prevent people with reason from making balanced intellectual arguments against the leaders' decisions. Kill them if you can, suppress them if you must, otherwise disparage them, but don't let them explain to the general public why your plan is stupid.

36
UnboughtStuffedDogs•

Thought is fine, so long as it is thought in support of Power. Thought that is not in support of Power could ferment a counterrevolution, and must be monitored. Ask Orwell, and Coleridge, and all of the James Bond villians who kill their scientists once they finish their superweapon.

1
[deleted]•

I think that's mostly because intellectuals could most easily challenge the government's claim to power. Not because they would question the official atheist stance of the government.

26
[deleted]•

Of course. But the very same people who were in power saw the religion as an even greater danger.

2
fuzzyonion•

because religion = power to the clergy. I agree with butol. I don't think anti-intellectualism is a feature of communist societies. Those leaders killed smart people around them because they were a threat. They promoted education.

7
Sunergy•

It seems natural to me that religion would be a bigger target than intellectuals, if we accept that what the party wants is to limit the ability of the people to revolt. While intellectuals can rally the masses through leadership and campaigns of information, their cries often seem fall upon deaf ears when the workers aren't completely miserable. Intellectuals are also often slow to act, as they are hardly a unified group. Organized religion, on the other hand, often takes the form of a well organized and unified hierarchal system that gains the undivided attention of the people at least once a week and in extreme cases can leverage almost complete devotion. I agree with your initial argument that it's obvious that anti-intellectualism does not always stem from religion, but the point that you seem to be reinforcing is that intellectualism and religion both can influence a populous, and that religion is often perceive the one that has the most influence of the two. I think that this makes the case that if religion was not being actively marginalized it would be in religion's best interest to limit the influence of intellectuals, possibly by spreading a doctrine of anti-intellectualism. So while I agree with your ideas, I think the argument you are trying to make is undermining your position.

0
Poloniculmov•

In my communist country not all intellectuals were bad, just the people that spoke against the system like philosophers and historians. The communist party did their best to build an education system (also doubled as an indoctrination system), to teach everyone to read and write and encouraged young people to get college degree.

3
[deleted]•

They were kept under the thumb. True, the engineers and such were viewed better than the humanist intellectuals, they were "productive". But the emphasis was on the workers/peasants:

http://www.kultura-extra.de/extra/feull/pic/workerandpeasant.jpg

1
[deleted]•

This is true. My great grandfather who fought in the second world war was murdered because he was an intellectual. AFAIK the communist party of Mongolia had him killed because they were suspicious of his intelligence and his great tactical ability. All I heard then was that he was taken to a ditch somewhere and shot.

3
kikimonster•

Oh crap... I forgot to link this to the Khmer Rouge. That's exactly what they did and my cambodian friend's parents are very bitter about that fact. Especially since they were part of the this "intellectual" class.

3
StudiedUnderSinn•

This was imposed by the state -- it was not a set of societal attitudes as we see in English-speaking Western countries today.

2
c0rnd0g•

Ironic isn't it that the people now taking up the flag of anti-intellectualism also proclame themselves to be the "true patriots" in America. They have more in common with the Tyrants and Mullahs than they will ever admit.

2

Massive upvote for this post, and for bringing up Pol Pot.

2
Areonis•

I never made the argument that religion is the only source of anti-intellectualism. There are other sources. Religion just happens to be a major one.

1
[deleted]•

If you wrote that 200+ years ago I would have agreed. Religion is weak, can't even stop the abortions, let alone the education.

1
dstz•

Don't you bring your fancy big words here mister. This is a debate about liberals vs conservatives, atheism vs religion, if you didn't figured that out with that big brain of yours.

Stinky intellectuals.

1
[deleted]•

I'm an intellectual troll.

1
20thMaine•

I want to point out that they were communist-like, but they were mostly dictatorships will little to no semblance of democracy. What do you need to be a democracy? A well educated populace that makes good decisions! What was a tenant of the communist manifesto? Education (i.e. not being brainwashed) for all children.

Being intellectual should be a good thing in a real communistic state.

1
anttirt•

That they were atheist is a red herring. In many senses, the state took the role of the church. It became an absolute authority, an unquestionable source of truth. Intellectuals are natural enemies of any such organisation. It is not the divine part of religion that makes it push anti-intellectualism, but its drive to become and remain, in the hearts of the people, an absolute authority on all things.

1
[deleted]•

My girlfriend studies philosophy and is from a very religious background. When she tells people in her family's social circles what she is studying the response is always some form of a warning that she shouldn't think too hard about certain things lest she drift away from her church. She hates it and it's driving her away from her church. I think, deep down, she likes philosophy better than Jesus, and I think that's awesome.

47
[deleted]•

Well, that's what happened to me. My parents made me go to a small, private religious college in the middle of nowhere.

I majored in theatre. And voice.

You know what I found? I found that some of the best people, the most solid friends, the kindest and most generous people I knew, were those evil homosexuals I'd heard so much tell about. I also found that someone who was actively involved in paganism could be the best girlfriend I ever had (and was so, so, so stupid to throw away--I will die with that regret)--the best friend, the biggest positive influence. I found that music that actually talked directly about the confusions and pain of life was a lot more helpful than music that sounded similar but that went out of its way to twist confusion into certainty.

My parents failed, and I am so glad they did. I was a suicidal Christian. Since I was "born again" as an atheist, I've been stable and happy. I no longer have to wonder why things aren't always the best, despite wishing for them to be, and being a nice guy. Now I can just accept that it's because no one's at the helm, and that being a nice guy is its own reward. I no longer have to reject people based on some arbitrary criteria; I am free to make friends with whomever I like--and despite seeming to be a bit of a curmudgeon--that's most people (even religious people).

So your girlfriend's fears are well-founded. She's realizing that the cage she has been trapped in her whole life is only in her mind, and she can think her way out of it, just as easily as she was thinking herself in.

Freedom is coming into her life.

It may cost her everything, but it will still be worth it.

42
citan_uzuki•

It's funny, because religion itself isn't supposed to be a cage, but it often feels like that to people who are subjected to it without any explanation or choice. Your story is precisely why "typical" Christianity is a terrible, direct failure of itself.

The moment other Christians claim you're "going down the wrong path" or you're "going to hell," they've all failed one of the most important points of Christianity - don't judge, but forgive. Don't deny, but accept. That seems pretty simple to me, but I rarely ever talk to a Christian with those ideals at the forefront of his/her beliefs.

3
UnboughtStuffedDogs•

Cedarville?

1
[deleted]•

religion is not necessarily distinct from philosophy, but of course, that mostly depends on which religion you're talking about.

1
20thMaine•

Jesus did have some good ideas. I'm not advocating worshiping the dude, but you could still admire him for trying to make a difference.

1
[deleted]•

He had some bad ones too. Turn the other cheek... what's that shit about?

1
20thMaine•

Ok, so someone slaps you with the back of their hand on one cheek, right? I think the idea was to turn your cheek, so that if the person is to slap you again with the same hand they have to open-palm-slap you, which is bad/embarrassing to them/less shamful to you somehow.

I'm sure you could throw in something like standing up to their violence with non-violence and stopping the cycle, or being the better person.

Personally? Unless my life is in danger, I'd try to fight back minimally (i.e. get them to stop fighting me).

Edit:Aha!

Wikipedia has a good literal interpretation of turning the other cheek.

The tl;dr is, you don't backhand their other cheek with your left hand because you use that one for 'unclean' things. And an open faced slap/punch would have been a challenge, and say that they are equal to you (backhand is a tool of showing who has authority).

I love it when things like this have actual context.

2
BrickSalad•

Well, it worked for ghandhi.

1
karmanaut•

I disagree. Religion itself has long been an impetus for education. Think about how many schools are run by all different religions. Historically, the only place you could be educated was through a church.

You don't have to study math or science to be an intellectual; there are a lot of religious scholars and they're still learning about something. Furthermore, religious scholarship has a lot of similarities to philosophy, literature, etc.

30
mindbleach•

Historically, the only place you could be educated was through a church because the only jobs that didn't involve intense physical labor were "clergy" and "royalty." Both classes perpetuated the lie that they were as important to the safety, stability, and wellbeing of the populace as the laborers they demanded respect and usually tribute from.

This is if by "historically," you mean "in feudal Europe." China, Rome, Japan, Egypt, and Greece were all big on tutors and small private schools.

14
callum_cglp•

Think about how many schools are run by all different religions.

Why do you think that is? Think about that statement for a minute.

4
karmanaut•

Get out of the atheist bubble for a second. Historically, being in the church has required an education, whereas almost no other fields did. When society consisted of serfs, nobles, and clergy, only one of those required an actual education. Clergy needed to read the bible and other works, whereas lords and vassals learned by doing and watching, and education was seen as a waste of time.

When education expanded, who already knew how to read, and write, and teach? The church. They just expanded their schools. Almost every ancient college was started to train priests; even here in the U.S.

Furthermore, education meshes well with traditional Christian values. It's a common fallacy that the church has held back education throughout history, when really, that's untrue. The only libraries that remained in Europe during the dark ages? In monasteries. The original re-translations of texts that restarted the Renaissance? Done by religious scholars.

As an atheist, I get angry when other atheists make unfounded criticisms of church and religion. There are plenty of things wrong with the system already; don't make up new ones, because you decrease the credibility of valid complaints.

23
callum_cglp•

I made no such statement about the historical value of religion in education - I responded specifically to your present-tense comment about religions running schools.

Having attended a Catholic elementary and high-school, I see no value in attaching a religion to education. In fact, it downright scared the shit out of me at times. Being told that you're going to hell for watching too much TV does not help to create an environment conducive to learning.

7
Schpwuette•

Historically, being in the church has required an education, whereas almost no other fields did.

But they were loathe to let that education leave the church. And while these re-translations may have been done by church scholars (who else?), they were in the minority. The Renaissance had to fight tooth and nail to get past the church. They were against the printing press. They were against the english bible. As a whole, the church was a retardant for popular education. There were people who fought against it, but if the rest of the church didn't exist, the protesters wouldn't have been needed.

Also, when Islam grew strong in the middle east, all intellectualism was immediately crushed.

3
FromTheIvoryTower•

Point of order... who started the dark ages?

The church supports education to an extent, the extent of which is that they can better convince people to obey them. Past that, the point at which people may begin to question, they have attempted to quash. Education doesn't mesh well with 'traditional Christian values' at all. Education leads to reason, reason is the antithesis of faith.

1
antofthesky•

Historically, I agree with you. The church did make substantial contributions to learning. However, at various times in history, it also suppressed various intellectuals who disagreed with its dogma.

Furthermore, today in the US, much of this anti-intellectual mindset does come from politicians and individuals who follow a certain political path which is intertwined with religion. Let's call it the religious right, for lack of a better term. Although I'm perfectly aware that this doesn't represent all religious folks, there is a distinct segment of the population who fuses evangelical religion, with neoconservative politics, with a general opposition to/distrust of science as far as things like evolution and global warming. It's understandable if people see this and associate religion with anti-intellectualism.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
RescuePilot•

Galileo was threatened with excommunication for saying the Earth is not the center of the universe. Religion has long opposed scientific progress. The only support education that indoctrinates others into the approved religious worldview.

2
pearlbones•

they were educating people specifically so that they would be able to serve the church, not to be able to serve themselves.

1
c0rnd0g•

No ... The thinking goes ... I need a certain part of my followers to be worldly and educated enough to run things... I will give them a lot of power and also watch them closely and the moment that they go too far... I will destroy them.

The heritics are tolorated as a smart defence mechanism... just like how Microsoft has a little Apple unit to help them think about how the other side works.

Or look at how successful any totalitarian government works... the elite "thinkers" are given power and wealth and that keeps them from questioning things "too much". They turn a blind eye to just about any amount of general suffering.

Once you get to a certain level... it's so much easier to just toe the line than destroy your life. We are pretty good at not rocking the boat in life. Those that are cast away as trash... if they're not killed outright... people that have gone over the edge? What are they going to do? Start another religion?

1
sn3twork•

Though as soon as you learn something that contradicts your religion and accept it, your religion won't want you.

-2
karmanaut•

That's because today's organized religions are overreaching hierarchies that have to have an opinion of everything's morality in today's society. The church should really be limited to their views on certain moral issues, and stay the hell out of everything else.

1
mindbleach•

s/today's//g;

Organization implies hierarchy. Hierarchy implies authority. Truth is not authoritative - science is practically poison to received truth.

1
Detoid•

My father who is a bad-ass scientist is also a Christian. He never really stops being a scientist, always seeing the world though that lens. Yet, he has no problem also being a Christian. There is only a problem when people think their territory and power is being threatened by science; they enjoy their position far too much.

Also, I think Jews value wisdom very highly, and embrace study and knowledge. Hanging out with some Jewish kids when I was a teen for the first time made me want to be Jewish so badly. They were so interesting and smart....totally different from my peers at school who were stuck in the "Baw haw haw,Im so stupid, its coool" phase.

17
Areonis•

There is a big difference between saying that religious people are anti-intellectual and saying that religion itself is. Most Jews that highly value education are not very religious anymore and choose to define themselves as Jews culturally more than religiously.

1
Detoid•

I cant really respond to what you said about Jews, as I have very little experience with the Jewish community. Seems kinda insulting though. How do you know how religious any person is other than you immediate family...it's hard to see into someones insides.

I don't think that the rift between Christianity and science should be an issue, we both know that it is, a huge one, that seems to come from earthy interests, not from the religion itself, or even a majority of its followers, but rather from its leaders. I can't remember anything in the Bible that says that study and contemplation is a bad thing. I do recall a lot of emphasis on faith, but don't see how that excludes developing the intellect. I could be wrong, I not a christian, and its been a long time since I read a Bible, but at one point I did read the whole thing.

0
NewbieProgrammerMan•

My father who is a bad-ass scientist...

Where can I get a bad-ass science degree and/or job? I really want that on my resume.

1
mOdQuArK•

I have no idea what a bad-ass science degree would involve, but I like to imagine that it has something to do with lots of really big explosions.

1
[deleted]•

Heheh, about half of my close friends are Jewish, and I know exactly what you mean.

1
sheldybear•

Though that connection seems not to be an inherent development of religion. At the beginning of Christianity there was a boom in philosophical discourse, and likewise with science and literacy with the formation of Islam. Adversely, there was a huge amount of anti-intellectualism at my largely secular high school (in Canada), that went far beyond just hatin' on the nerds. I think, and hope, that it must be something deeper than religion that is the driving force at work here.

3
Areonis•

I never said that religion was the only cause of anti-intellectualism. I simply said that some of the anti-intellectualism is caused by religion. How did you come to say that the beginning of Christianity corresponded with a huge amount of philosophical discourse? Much of the Greek and Roman contributions were lost until being "rediscovered" during the Renaissance.

1
sheldybear•

Aquinas and Augustine come immediately to mind when thinking of Christian philosophy, and they were even canonized for their philosophical contributions to the faith.

Though some early Christian schools of thought rejected Greek philosophy outright, it still resulted in an internal dialogue in rethinking topics that had previously been discussed by the ancient Greeks (specifically the role of virtue, the soul, and epistemology, but that's all I can think of right now).

On the other side of things, religions like Hinduism and Buddhism both reject the role of reasoning in the journey to samsara, but neither of them demonize intellectualism at all.

I agree with you %10000 that religion accounts for some anti-intellectualism, but I wanted to reiterate that the sentiment spans far beyond the faithful, perhaps making it a cultural phenomenon?

3
deuteros•

Not sure I agree here. For most of Christian history clergy have usually been the most educated people in society and the church was at the forefront in education.

2
Areonis•

This is coming from the same people who executed scientists for heresy for claiming that the Sun didn't revolve around the Earth and that the world was more than 6,000 years old. They also weren't too keen on the round Earth either.

-2
[deleted]•

The Jesuits were largely responsible for education in France and trained some of the most potent minds of the 18th century- Diderot, Voltaire, etc.

1
Areonis•

I agree that there were religious people who greatly contributed to education, but I would argue that the positive contributions are outweighed by the negatives.

1
deuteros•

This is coming from the same people who executed scientists for heresy for claiming that the Sun didn't revolve around the Earth and that the world was more than 6,000 years old. They also weren't too keen on the round Earth either.

This is just simply wrong.

Nobody was executed for denying geocentricism or believing in an old earth. Most Christians accept the idea of an old earth.

Nobody believed the earth was flat in the Middle Ages. People have known the earth is round since antiquity.

1
Areonis•

I was mistaken as to the people killed for their scientific beliefs and I should not have simply parroted something I had merely heard.

It can be argued that Giordano Bruno was and certainly the church threatened excommunication to members for old Earth and heliocentric views. At that time this was almost as bad as a death sentence.

Most Christians accept the idea of an old earth.

Most Christians now accept the idea of an old Earth. This was certainly not true in the Middle Ages and the early church actively opposed it. 45% of Americans believed that God created humans 10,000 years ago in 2004 so it is certainly still popular.

Again I respectfully apologize for my misrepresentation of the facts.

1
DanRisinger•

I think theres something about eating fruit from the tree of knowledge in the bible...

Though I seem to forget what the ramifications of eating that fruit were.

1
towardsthesun•

Some of the anti intellectualism definitely comes from religion - people think the answers to life are given in the bible (or whatever other manual they base their beliefs on), and therefore curiosity is squashed and scientific and philosophical development is stunted.

I wouldn't say modern society is anti intellectual though, instead merely that "mainstream" society is. Mainstream society is too concerned with how they are perceived by others, so they place their time and efforts in the latest fashions and fads, unaware, uninterested, or ignorant of the "deeper" questions of life. But you can loop this phenomenon into an evolutionary framework - people want to feel accepted, part of the group, as for obvious reasons it increases both survival and reproductive success. Materialism and superficial meaning which pervades our society can all be explained with respect to the movement towards evolutionary success innate within us and all other life forms.

I think our society is defined by the vast knowledge base we all have access to by the click of a mouse, and that this is increasing the knowledge and intellectualism of the common person. It may seem like modern society is anti intellectualism merely because the people who you see on TV and the people who follow it are ones with flash but no substance - superficiality reigns supreme if you give your attention to popular culture.

Dig a little deeper however, and you will find that we as humans are actually a pretty creative and intelligent folk. We are headed in the right direction I think - it just takes the mainstream culture a little longer to catch onto what us intelligent people are concerned with :)

1
Areonis•

We agree. I said some of it comes from religion.

1
towardsthesun•

Touche. But who is "we"?

1
Areonis•

I meant that you and I agree.

1
PWL73316•

What a massive generalization. How anti-intellectual of you.

1
Areonis•

Which generalization? That some of the backlash comes from religion?

2
PWL73316•

Your generalization that religion itself as some kind of cohesive whole is like that. Most branches of all religions teach that it is important to question everything and understand your faith at the deepest level possible.

1
Areonis•

Religion is based on faith or belief without evidence. This is irrational and in my opinion anti-intellectual. This belief without evidence leads directly to fundamentalist branches of religious groups.

Most branches of all religions teach that it is important to question everything and understand your faith at the deepest level possible.

This is patently false. I know very few branches of religions that teach you to question everything. I bet the list of Christian denominations that teach adherents to question the divinity of Jesus along with the divinely-inspired nature of the Bible and the all-loving nature of God could be counted on one hand. Islam is much, much less likely to tolerate any questioning of the actions of Mohammad or the Koran.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
moultano•

I've been exposed a bit to Hinduism recently, and I think this is one of the reasons India will do well. In Hinduism truth is an end in itself. In the major Hindu text, the main character is encouraged by a god to slaughter his family in the pursuit of truth. There's no iconography of knowledge as sinful like the tree of knowledge or tower of babel. It does have its old earth creationists but on the whole I think it's a lot less likely to promote anti-intellectual thought.

1
i_am_my_father•

Some from religion. Some other part of anti-intellectualism comes from describing intellectuals as harmony destroyers. The anti-intellectualism in South Korea is a case of the latter. Being smart --> too much into something (like physics) --> less social, questioning the mob, being an "unbalanced" person, all of which are interpreted as being "not grown up". South Korea is secular in that politicians can't use religion successfully to persuade voters, but not very secular in that there is a God called "we".

1
mcstivi•

Yes -- Knowledge is viewed as a negative pursuit (the apple that adam ate was knowledge!). Enlightenment thinkers actually had to reverse this view, and branded themselves with the phrase "dare to know."

1
jenjen60•

Yeah. Just look at the story of Adam and Eve eating from the tree of knowledge, and the consequences thereof.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
lennort•

Your view of religious people is about as accurate as a fundamentalists view of atheists.

0
Areonis•

How did I mischaracterize religious people? In the first part I criticized religion itself and in the second I criticized evangelicals.

3
lennort•

After re-reading your paragraph, I take it back. I'm not sure what my problem was; I must have been in some weird state of mind.

1
Areonis•

That's fine. I've done that before myself.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
emsenn0•

If you think plumbers farm, you should probably try some of that "intellectual" stuff you were just talking about.

2
Workaphobia•

Bleh, that's far too simplistic, blaming anti-intellectualism on the prevalence of faith in their culture. Yes, faith and learning are fundamentally at odds in an abstract sense, but what's much more pertinent is that they don't identify with any smart people, and view intelligence as an excuse to validate moral positions they disagree with.

-2
naringas•

ignorant people are easier to control

264
ExistentialEnsoOP•

I've actually have often wondered if some of the more clever right-wingers like the fact that most of the country's public schools are substandard for that very reason.

143
karmanaut•

I don't think that's it. Republicans want people educated, but they want them educated the "Right" way. They want to be able to push their own point of view; see the recent Texas Textbook incident for a case study

107
cerebralscrub44•

that's not educated, though. That's being brought up to believe that certain people and ideological movements in history had more or less significance, or relevance, or helped more or fewer people than they actually did. That's brainwashing, not education. It's the same with religion, IMHO - if you're brought up to believe something without being permitted to ever question it, and your mind develops in an environment hostile to questioning it, then it's natural that you must be considered brainwashed - by your parents and church, primarily. Of course there are exceptions to this, as I'm sure many of the replies to the OP will show.

120
benm314•

Yes. More concisely,

indoctrination ≠ education.

61
TooTallForPony•

It's not even deliberate brainwashing. Many people in the U.S. grow up in an environment where 99% of the people they meet are white, blue-collar, Christian, and Republican (and often all go to the same church; I met a friend recently who told me she was a social outcast for years for claiming that God didn't exist - in 2nd grade). When you live in those conditions, it's easy to believe that everyone in the world lives the same way, so it's hard to accept that others might have different beliefs. This is the environment that leads to fundamentalism and terrorism. Contact with people outside your community fixes that, so in its own way, Reddit is saving the world. :)

52
TheColorsDuke•

I could easily play devil's advocate here and say education and brainwashing are the exact same thing. Even raising a child in anyway is "brainwashing." You are taking something like the minds ability to understand (which is infinite) and forcing it to adhere to certain principles.

For example:

That's being brought up to believe that certain people and ideological movements in history had more or less significance, or relevance, or helped more or fewer people than they actually did.

Well, who decides how relevant or how significant an event actually is? Events do not have some kind of intrinsic significance. By assuming that liberals or people who think like you understand the correct amount of significance in a situation, you are doing the exact same thing the right-wingers are doing.

17
j0nny5•

You can't really flavor true critical thinking skills with too much bias. It's pretty hard to tell a child, "Think about what you're going to do. Will it cause you to die? Be injured? Cause another to die or be injured? Less severely, will it cause difficulties in other ways? Consider these things as you make decisions." and have much of spin to it.

The flip side, of course, is, "Think about what you're going to do. Will it make god mad? Cause you to go to hell? Lose your heavenly reward? Consider ONLY these things as you make decisions." That would be, IMO, brainwashing.

8
epicwinguy101•

But how does one decide the actual relevance? If we assign value to something that is nonzero, we have to evaluate that significance in a way that pertains to how you perceive reality, your beliefs. It is impossible to find an absolute relevance to a historic event just as it is impossible to find an absolute velocity of an object. Everything is relative. We are all brainwashed, because the people who wrote history down had a bias, the books have bias, the teachers have bias, parents have bias. We have learned nothing ourselves but brainwashing bias, and everything is a reaction for or against the biases we have seen.

IMHO, nothing has any real value, relevance, or significance. We are a collection of molecules who have developed a limited intelligence in the form of an electrochemical control circuit, who have organized into societies and communities. These societal constructs have collective viewpoints. Outliers to these accepted values, past and present, will be shunned by these communities. But at some point in the future, this species will go extinct. At some later point, as the universe draws to a close, nothing will have mattered at all that you, or I, or any human alive, ever existed. The story has the same ending no matter what.

So knock yourself out, and assign personal value and significance. Because there is no universal metric to assign any worth to an event, object, or characteristic other than the 0 that it will wind up as.

2
jenjen60•

Those kind of ideologies need high levels of brainwashing in order for future generations to embrace them. I was raised in a very rigid apostolic environment, and was sent to Christian schools, and summer camps that were full of chapel and religious classes meant to brainwash me. No fun there. Luckily, I was able to break free from that mindset, but I feel bitter about my upbringing and lack of choices.

2
nordic86•

You do realize Democrats want the exact same thing, right? Its all about control. Democrats are just the other side of the same coin.

0
halfthetime•

Everyone is brainwashed . If you possess an idea that can be contested than you could be considered brainwashed and all ideas can be contested.

0
ParsonsProject93•

I've recently talked to a couple of my friends and I have found out that all of my friends who live in a restricted and censored life have fathers who are immensely republican. It is completely ironic that a republican who hates communism and censorship and loves freedom restricts his own son from the internet in fear that he will learn something he isn't supposed to. I'm not sure what their religious stance is but it is nothing but insanity that republican father treats his son like a dictator treats a citzen.

EDIT: Sorry about the horrible punctuations, I was tired beyond belief last night.

27
pearlbones•

you've recently talked to a couple of your friend's what?

33
j0nny5•

Conservatism is rife with hypocrisy. The structure that creates it has the emotion of fear as its foundation. It is a human construct that was created for a simpler time when knowledge was not a pursuit, but rather a blight on a labor-based population. At that time, few outside the priesthood or noble aristocracy could read, and it was illegal to learn. Imagine you were completely illiterate for a moment. You would be very easy to control and manipulate, because all that would be left would be a play on your emotions and instincts.

10
tdehnel•

Not to derail the conversation, but I'm just going to leave this here.

6
[deleted]•

How old is this friend? Sorry but I am a liberal that is 100% against censorship but I also don't think kids should get free reign on the internet. There is nothing wrong with limiting the amount of time a kid can spend playing video games or browsing the internet, nor is there anything wrong with restricting the kinds of sites a kid can visit.

The is nothing hypocritical about supporting democracy in government but setting up your home as a monarchy. Of course there are limits. You shouldn't try to control your children's lives 24/7 and make them live in a bubble but you also shouldn't just let them run around and do whatever they want with no direction or rules.

It sounds to me like you and your friends are quite young and just hate that parents make rules that you think are unfair.

5
vimfan•

Where do people get this idea that Republicans hate censorship and love freedom? I thought Republicans were generally social conservatives, which would generally be ok with censorship and restrictions on freedom, to preserve their own points of view.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
throwaway4227•

My sister and I lived in a restricted and censored life, and both of my parents are bleeding heart liberals.

1
[deleted]•

anyone in power can benefit from an ignorant population regardless of their agenda.

13
DSchmitt•

My agenda is to increase our understanding of the universe for the benefit of everyone, to have a more just and egalitarian society, and to increase technology until we have defeated aging, can terraform worlds and asteroids, and can spread to the stars. An ignorant population wouldn't benefit me; my agenda kind of requires an extremely educated populace.

I suppose that's one of many reasons I'm not in power. :-p

24
TMI-nternets•

finally, it has come to pass! a karmanaut comment I'm not agreeing with 100%.. I just might need a cigarette, now.

3
thomasthomas•

take texas instruments for example

2
HUGE-FROG•
1
saw2239•

Wouldn't educated in the "right" way mean not so much education as psychological conditioning? The minimizing of racial minorities as well as the enlightenment by the Texas School Board would seem to demonstrate this, at least in my opinion.

1
T0RN8R•

The other half of Republicans don't care about 'other people' getting an education, they worry about conserving every bit of their paycheck as they can, pressuring as little tax money for education as possible. Why?

What's the use in paying a tax on top of your children's 20k (each) tuition to private school? Can they expect any 'personal' gain?

1
c0rnd0g•

It's funny because you just posted something earlier about how religion has historically "educated" people to a higher degree but here people are being educated the "right" way. Why aren't they the exact same thing?

1
OhTheHugeManatee•

Do you think this is a uniquely Republican phenomenon?

Really?

1
Railboy•

That's only half the picture - the other half is, they want people that they don't consider part of their club educated poorly.

1
UnboughtStuffedDogs•

How quickly the line changes from 'we love education' to 'what the hell are you teaching our children?' when new perspectives get introduced.

1
SmurfLovesNuts•

Republicans want facts in the books. A lot of the "evidence" for Evolution has been proven to be false in court, even up to 20+ years ago, and yet this "evidence" is still in the text books. It's infuriating.

0
grumble_au•

Many people want facts on the internet. With people like you posting that is increasingly unlikely.

1
solarshit•

easy competition.

you set up the game and the rules and manipulate everyone else.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
ThrustVectoring•

Even the non substandard schools teach ignorance. Until high school I learned a grand total of fuckall from formalized math instruction, and as little as I could get away with from everything else.

As a 'gifted child', our educational system is obviously not worth putting effort into, since they negatively reinforce initiative with boredom and social humiliation. The good teachers just know enough to leave the bored kids alone as long as they put just enough effort into the make-work to justify keeping them with their slower peers.

2
[deleted]•

Please don't blame teachers. They, of all people, know how bad the system is. Just try sitting down with some for beers. You'll find it's even worse than you thought. The difference is that they are trying to do something about it (but there isn't much they can do).

That being said, yes, some teachers are shit. And that's what you get when you won't pay them anything and won't let them do their jobs and insist on hiring coaches who can also maybe sorta muddle through teaching math or social studies (I'm 35, and there's a math teacher who, if I ever run into again, I'm going to ream--he flushed an entire year of my math education down the toilet).

2
tadfad•

There's a case to be made that the dismantling of public education is part-and-parcel of a wider scheme to reshape the citizenry in line with neo-populist dogma. At least, let's hope it's that and not just the decay of civilization writ large.

1
robotfuel•

I've actually have often wondered if some of the more clever right-wingers like the fact that most of the country's public schools are substandard for that very reason.

Based on this comment I think you would enjoy this text book (literally) of knowledge about our current school system and how it came to be.

1
[deleted]•

Republicans aren’t the only politicians who seek control.

1

"Our schools have been scientifically designed to prevent over-education from happening. The average American should be content with their humble role in life, because they're not tempted to think about any other role."

-- William Torrey Harris, U.S. Commissioner of Education, 1889

1
madelinecn•

Well look at where most of the Republican's constituents live, Alabama, Tennesee, Mississippi etc. These states have some of the poorest ratings for public education.

1
novalidnameremains•

I think you hit the nail on the head right there. In the US, we treat education like a limited resource, like oil or minerals. Good education has become a thing of the privileged as opposed to the immutable wildfire that men of the Enlightenment had envisioned.

1
halfthetime•

That is also what is said about the Dems..

1
zeppelinfromled•

You know that right wingers come up with ways how the left makes people ignorant so that they're easier to control? People aren't as malicious as our cynicism would have us believe.

1
[deleted]•
1
jeannaimard•

I've actually have often wondered if some of the more clever right-wingers like the fact that most of the country's public schools are substandard for that very reason.

Oh, that’s by design.

The right wing has gutted public education to insure that only the rich can properly educate their children, insuring that financial success (being in the upper-class) becomes strictly hereditary.

1
[deleted]•

He quoted Lenin I think, nothing to do with the right-wingers.

0
SmurfLovesNuts•

down voted. I'm a right-winger, and I hate the fact that our schools are such crap. As a nation, we are ignorant, fat, and the worst: lazy. It's shameful.

0
Omnicrola•

It's a Brave New World.

31
hob-goblin•

"I don't understand anything," she said with decision, determined to preserve her incomprehension intact. "Nothing. Least of all," she continued in another tone "why you don't take soma when you have these dreadful ideas of yours. You'd forget all about them. And instead of feeling miserable, you'd be jolly. So jolly,"

32
rawbdor•

“Alpha children wear grey. They work much harder than we do, because they’re so frightfully clever. I’m awfully glad I’m a Beta, because I don’t work so hard. And then we are much better than the Gammas and Deltas. Gammas are stupid. They all wear green, and Delta children wear khaki. Oh no, I don’t want to play with Delta children. And Epsilons are still worse. They’re too stupid to be able to read or write. Besides they wear black, which is such a beastly color …. I’m so glad I’m a Beta“

12
tadfad•

Soma = TV

10
BrkneS•

This smells like Ayn Rand, but I could just be a hypochondriac...

1
brandoncoal•

Funny, it tastes like Huxley.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

You're totally right, and the sad part is that in A Brave New World the people largely controlled themselves.

Willful anti-intellectualism seems, to me at least, a contradiction of terms. To truly be willfully ignorant wouldn't one ultimately have to know what is correct in order to deny it? Instead, anti-intellectualism is fueled by the endless stream of entertainment that is becoming increasingly more accessible. Why bother learning when there is always something "better" on TV?

29
Omnicrola•

Or more to the point, why bother learning when I can look it up via google/wikipedia/imdb/phone app/etc in 10 seconds. There is a large difference between learning and regurgitating, and I fear we are losing the ability to learn. The plethora of information at our fingertips is a powerful tool, but people must first learn how to learn. And then WANT to learn.

9
tepidpond•

There is a large difference between learning and regurgitating

A piece of knowledge which can be retrieved in under 10 seconds is a thing which is not learnt, but memorized. For instance, in 10 seconds I can find a formula for calculating orbital velocity. However, I could not in 10 seconds find and digest enough information to understand how and why that formula works, and what the numbers actually represent.

Google does not hamper learning, Google obviates the need for memorization.

43
[deleted]•

[deleted]

19
tdehnel•

people must first learn how to learn. And then WANT to learn.

I think it's more important that the curiosity is there before all else. That, to me, is the distinguishing characteristic of an intellectual; the realization that the world can be understood and a desire to explain it logically, instead of just accepting things at face value.

A good example is a pot of boiling water. Ask some random high school students to explain what's happening, and you'll generally get 2 answers:

  1. it's boiling because it's hot and that's what happens when you heat water

  2. the water at the bottom of the pot is heated to the point that it turns into vapor which rises to the top...etc etc

The difference is that the second group is actually thinking about what's going on.

7
xandar•

Even assuming that's true, there's not wanting to learn and then there's actively opposing learning/experts. The former is unfortunate, the latter is really damaging our country.

It's the difference between someone saying "I don't really care how evolution works." and "I'm not going to trust those scientists to tell me how the world works!"

I don't see the internet directly producing anti-intellectualism.

3
hob-goblin•

Agreed, but why memorize trivial data that is handy at your fingertips.

I would phrase it as learn how to think and to think critically.

1
Bullyonburnin•

It's sad, but true.

1
devolve•

It's like a form of learned helplessness.

1
mrbubblesort•

Sounds a bit more like Fahrenheit 451 to me.

1
[deleted]•

It's also easier to be ignorant. You get to avoid all those aggravating thinky feelings, like being aware of your own shortcomings, knowing how fragile our existence is, and experiencing tremendous self-doubt. Ignorance is bliss.

In reality, lots of very progressive sciencey people also find ways not to think very deeply about things. It's just less obvious.

11
Bonerlicious•

It's easy to think that everyone is as clever as the average redditor when in reality they're not. In my opinion this has nothing to do with drive, curiosity or standards of education. It's just simple biology. Some people are clever (some mediocre) and others stupid.

Now, of course I know this is impossible to test but if it were at all possible to test the worlds intelligence using some infallible exam whilst keeping all variables (regards life style, education, start in life etc) the same, a majority of the worlds population, I think, would fall into the mediocre/stupid catagory.

Just think how motivated you would be to read a wikki page if you knew your poor memory would retain only 5% of what you read. You just wouldn't bother and not only that you'd despise and put down people that can remember 80% as some kind of pyscological defence to your incompetencies.

So this majority are not willfully ignorant it's just an unfortunate fact of life that most people have bad brains.

1
[deleted]•

There are a couple problems with that theory, most prominent that failing to understand isn't generally the source of these problems.

What I mean is this: The problem isn't that someone would read about a difficult concept and say, "I don't understand that." It's not a problem when someone says, "I don't fully understand that, so I'm not sure whether I believe it." The problem comes when someone says, "That doesn't make sense to me, so it must be meaningless bull-crap."

There's a big difference there, and it's not just ignorance. All three of those quotes express complete ignorance, but only the third includes a willful refusal by the speaker to admit to limitation. It's really more about the ego and the attitude that one would prefer to remain ignorant rather than admit to being ignorant.

Fundamentally, it's not about understanding or belief, it's about attitude. These are all part of the same attitude:

  • I don't understand it, so it must be wrong.
  • I don't do things that way, so it must be the wrong way to do things.
  • I don't like it, so it must be bad.
  • He disagrees with me so he must have evil intentions.
1
sloppythirds•

ignorant people are easier to control

hence, the millions of Obama fanatics

4
[deleted]•

Strauss ftw.

3
Seekin•

And it takes far less effort to remain ignorant than it takes to educate yourself. This is the reason that ignorance is enticing to a large number of people and why anti-intellectualism is so prevalent. Yet another reason that a good educational system is so desirable that we must continue to fight for it whenever possible.

2
i_am_my_father•

I tried to control ignorant people by saying things like "Conservative politicians talk like fag!" or "Bush hates our freedom!".

Didn't work.

2
ourturbolazers•

too true

1
splynncryth•

I'm not sure that is all there is to it thought the phrase "fat, dumb, and happy' may apply to your line of thought.

This is just my own musing, but in looking at what intelligence has allowed us to do to the environment and our own population, I wonder if anti-intellectualism isn't some artifact of natural selection. If the population is less intelligent, it cannot react as quickly to things like new diseases. The reduced population puts a reduces strain of the environment as a whole. This is a really cut down version if my musings though.

So it is now a race, can intellect solve our problems before all the intellectuals succumb to an anti-intellectual society?

1
ChrisAndersen•

That might actually be a good response when the topic turns this way.

It probably still won't work with the chronically ignorant, but it may make just one or two in the audience think twice.

1
SmurfLovesNuts•

too true.

1
son-of-chadwardenn•

I'm tired of this "ignorance is a conspiracy" bullshit. People are ignorant because they don't like learning. The news sucks because it's profit oriented and the crap they make is profitable. Teachers have quite a bit of freedom in creating lesson plans so I'd like to know how evil congressmen and CEOs are poising the school system.

1
[deleted]•

Wake up, Sheeple!

1
dunmalg•

Anti-intellectualism is, to me, one of the most disturbing traits in modern society.

Substitute "humanity" for "modern society". The vast average majority has always disliked intellectuals. The only difference is now you're exposed to them all over the internet, when before they were largely confined to backwater bars, Fraternal Order of the (Whatever) meeting halls, and pro football tailgate parties. Go back 200 years and it was the same.

261
tootie•

I would go so far as to say that anti-intellectualism is probably near all-time lows.when was the last witch burning or monkey trial?

65
prozacprinsez•

Texas school book debate They took out theories of Thomas Jefferon because he is too liberal

38
kekspernikai•

How dare he separate Church and State! Imagine how much better Amurrica would be we combined them into "Sturch" and let God make our decisions.

7
rottenborough•

By God you mean Sarah Palin?

0
[deleted]•

I think we are simply more aware of the rest of the world. All-time low? Nah, not by a long shot.

Also, the monkey trials were actually quite an intellectual exercise. But this 'us vs. them' attitude fueled the fundamentalist movement that was, at the time, very small.

9
rollem•

The Dover Delaware case was a monkey trial. Fortunately, the judge was not anti-intellectual. There are still witch burnings in modern, but developing societies all over the world. It's disgusting.

I'd say a lot of the conservative base is anti-intellectual, though mostly non-radicalized. 50 years ago, a lot of those people were in the democratic base, but Reagan and the values voters mostly changed that.

7
touchguitar•

Are you referring to the evolution vs creationism trials in Dover, Pennsylvania?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Kierkegaard•

Don't you mean Kitzmiller v. Dover in Dover, Pennsylvania? Judge Jones's opinion is a fantastic read.

1
dVnt•

That was Dover, PA; not Dover, DE.

That decision was something to be proud of and it restored my confidence in our justice system a bit. I didn't think it was going to turn out like but John E. Jones III gave the ID movement a reaming in his final decision:

ID's backers have sought to avoid the scientific scrutiny which we have now determined that it cannot withstand by advocating that the controversy, but not ID itself, should be taught in science class. This tactic is at best disingenuous, and at worst a canard. The goal of the IDM is not to encourage critical thought, but to foment a revolution which would supplant evolutionary theory with ID.

Right on the fucking money. He's a conservative republican judge too, appointed by G.W. Bush of all people.

1
Bhima•

There are hundreds of low profile cases ongoing all over the US at any given time. The last high profile trials surrounding creationism were during the Bush presidency... which was not all that long ago.

1
Dustmuffins•

Hardly a witch burning...

3
SquareWheel•

when was the last witch burning

Communism in the United States.

1
nonsensepoem•

when was the last witch burning or monkey trial?

The last monkey trial was 2005, but I'm sure another will occur in Texas within the next year or two.

1
[deleted]•

Indeed. Not too long ago anti-intellectualism was a part of the establishment. Just see how difficult it was for the people of the enlightenment to get their ideas through.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
trivial•

I just watched a video about Liberia where there was a leader named General Butt Naked, who coincidentally fought completely naked for the belief that bullets would not harm him if he were unclothed perhaps having some ancient warrior protection. His army was named the Tupac army, which were mainly comprised of younger boys. After fighting they would often rip out and eat an uncooked heart of an enemy so as to capture their vitality and power. Sometimes before battle they would drain and drink the blood of an innocent child for added magical protection.

General Butt Naked has since converted and is now trying his best to heal the wounded soul of Liberia (so it seems).

Just sayin.....

1
niobevulpes•

Said the king to the pastor: "I'll keep em poor if you keep em stupid".

58
junkit33•

Yeah, I'm starting to realize that the response to just about any complaint on Reddit is "nothing has has changed - you just see it more because of the Internet".

If anything this is one of the most intellectually accepting times in world history. Hell - until the Internet revolution of the 90's you were pretty much a guaranteed outcast to society if you were any kind of a geek/programmer/engineer. Now it's downright trendy to be a geek.

18
[deleted]•

No, it's trendy to look and act like a geek. You still have to like to get drunk and be able to make lots of friends. If you actually ARE a geek, you're no better off than you were before.

12
musitard•

Why can't a geek like to get drunk and make lots of friends?

1
[deleted]•

Not that they can't, but it's not the stereotype that hipsters are trying to emulate.

2
helmMSc|Quantum Optics•

Smelling bad, staying unkempt and having no friends will never ever be popular.

2
tso•

a geek is a nerd with social skills (and maybe above avarage credit rating)

1
saulhoward•

Substitute "humanity" for "modern society"

I don't think this is true. I think the specific brand of anti-intellectualism that is being talked about here is a uniquely American phenomenon.

The sheer cultural dominance of the anti-intellectual way of thinking that is being described here is alien to me as a European, and I don't see it in the Asian cultures I've been exposed to, either.

Although of course anti-intellectual ideas do surface here occasionally, there is no way you could describe them as the "vast average majority".

11
[deleted]•

I am forced to disagree with this, given my first-hand experiences with people from all over the world. I've listened to the most amazing anti-intellectual nonsense spouted from the mouths of people from Europe, Asia and South America. This is clearly not a uniquely American phenomenon.

42
GodBlesstheUSA•

Anti-intellectualism is fairly common. If you think it doesn't happen in Europe then you really haven't read your history. I'm English and I see it all over the place in England.

In some ways I think it is a good thing. While it galls me personally, it seems to get the below-average people through their day. They can bitch about scientists and say things to discourage their kids from going into certain stores like "You don't want to go in there, them are just books" and then go to bed at night and get up and do their dreadful, boring job in the morning.

17
jagin2000•

I see this in England too. I think it's because many people in western society have decided that they are the most important person on the planet. So if someone is better at something (e.g. smarter), then they must devalue it at any cost, to keep their concept of being no. 1 in their minds.

12
thebassethound•

The problem with even viewing it as a good thing, such as in the scenario you described, is that it will be passed on to the next generation. In a society in which even the working classes can get a good education, go to university and do great things, such anti-intellectual values only serve to perpetuate class divides.

1
Phild3v1ll3•

I disagree, I'm about to start my Masters in computational neuroscience and you can imagine how hard it is to explain this to people. While I will often encounter some wise guy comments, the vast majority of people will ask interestedly what it entails and when they still don't understand they may follow up it up with "that's way above my head, you must be so smart". I've never once encountered anyone who would use my education against me and shun or insult because of it. Not until I began having arguments online did I ever encounter anti-intellectualism and whenever I did it was from an American. Asians most certainly have a different attitude and value intellectuality or at least a good education way beyond any other culture. There may also be some anti-intellectual elements in European culture but it's never the open hatred, which Americans routinely display. So while you may be right that anti-intellectualism is not an exclusively American phenomenon, it is most certainly more widespread and far more mean-spirited over there. In my opinion this is mainly due to the religious right, who are not merely anti-intellectual but in all seriousness associate facts and science with the devil and regard them as an affront to god. It's a sad state of affairs indeed.

9
liquidhot•

So, do you visit non-english websites when you meet these Americans? If not, I would think that you chances of encountering someone anti-intellectual would be much smaller than if you did visit said websites. Also, your sample size is probably much too small to have any indication in either direction.

11
Tekmo•

You're just experiencing sampling bias. The people who are most likely to expand their horizons to interact with those outside of their culture tend to be pro-intellectual. The same goes for immigrants.

7
doctor_alligator•

Not until I began having arguments online did I ever encounter anti-intellectualism and whenever I did it was from an American.

This is not a fair example. The vast majority of the English speaking end of the internet is American. You're just exposed to them more than others.

3
[deleted]•

online

That's the problem right there.

3
2curious•

Anti-intellectualism is not uniquely American, neither in its frequency nor its character. Thugs and criminals who are able to exploit times of crisis to rise to power target the intellectual class (not exclusively mind you, but early on in their machinations, often first). Think Chavez, Pinochet, Kim Il Sung, Pol Pot, Mao, Hitler, Stalin, Robespierre, Cromwell -- keep going back and you'll find more (Pope to Galileo: "Nobody likes a smart ass"). It's endemic to the human condition because intellectual ability will vary widely from individual to individual; it represents a fundamental and perpertual inequality that divides people and it is not one that is easy to redress. Generally, humans (and apes) respond rationally to the presence of inequality: they may find it repugnant, attempt to redress it, or exploit it to their own advantage. It is the soil of envy. What thugs always realize, whether consciously or not (because they are never entirely dim, just average), is that inherent (and cultivated) intellectual ability is a critical advantage. It's a game changer. And it is one not easily controlled. You can't predict with any certainty who, where and when someone is going to come along and upend the natural order of things. So you (the thug) are continually on the alert for something funny. In your world, where Guns, Numbers, and Money -- some combination thereof -- are the units in the arithemetic of power, people who come along with algebra and calculus are a threat. Because they are. When it comes down to it, smart people (individually and as a 'class') are dangerous. Intelligence and it's products (knowledge, wisdom, insight, etc.) can diminish the efficacy of guns, numbers and money in the hands of an opponent, either making them less relevant or by augmenting the potency of guns, numbers and money in the hands of the intellectual.

2
cyks•

I disagree, I'm about to start my Masters in computational neuroscience and you can imagine how hard it is to explain this to people.

Really wasn't that hard to understand. You would be surprised how many other comments here blame the religious-right.

1
SomGuy•

Masters in computational neuroscience

That sounds cool. Are you pre-med, or going into bioengineering?

1
SomGuy•

I grew up mostly outside the USA. (My father was diplomat, and I was born in Malaysia, and also lived in Singapore, Indonesia, and Germany.) I remember rather vehement racism from some of our neighbors in Singapore, which was anti-Japanese. This included beliefs which were patently ridiculous from a scientific standpoint (e.g. Japanese people were descended from immigrants to the islands who had mated with the local monkeys. Yes, they claimed this literally.)

At the same time, I did see a fair bit of reverence for scholarship, particularly among the Chinese in those countries. There was some anti-intellectualism from the Malays and Indonesians, but it tended to be aimed at Chinese intellectuals in particular; academics from their own ethnic groups were put on pedestals.

1
jeannaimard•

Some years ago, a friend of mine was offered to go to college by his extended family, as they found it awful that he would not have a college degree.

Trouble was that the programme he chose was given in a backwater university where he would have to stay at an uncle’s whose wife did not value education.

For her, once you were past the age of compulsory school, you had to get a job.

The uncle is a mechanic, and his two sons wanted to become engineers. Of course, that already did not sit well with the wife.

But when that guy in his early 30’s showed-up to stay at their place to precisely go to university, all hell broke loose.

My friend was practically kicked-out of his uncle’s place for having such a detrimental influence on his cousins!

He was lucky to be able to go through one session by staying at first with some friends he made in University, then by making arrangements with the University to show up for 2-3 days every other week, but in the end, he was not able to complete his degree thanks to the bitchy aunt.

But 15 years later, the two boys managed to get their engineering degrees anyway by going to the big city and staying with their cousin…

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
saulhoward•

You are correct, I didn't mean that anti-intellectual ideas only come from America, just that anti-intellectualism isn't mainstream in other countries I'm familiar with.

To clarify - I don't suggest that anti-intellectualism is mainstream in America, either. I don't know enough about the culture. I am often surprised by some of the things Americans say on the topic though, I had to Google "Grey Poupon" and am still confused as to how owning a certain brand of mustard qualifies as a accusation of intellectualism.

Thinking about it, I don't think I can think of equivalent political movements in other countries that champion their disregard for intellectualism. It's like saying "Join our movement, none of us are clever! We put no thought into this!" This wouldn't go down well in the cultures I am familiar with.

-2
[deleted]•

The Grey Poupon thing comes from an old television commercial. Here is the original commercial. There were many comedic spinoff ads, and many spoofs done of this particular commercial.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
grandpa•

Go back 2000 years and it was the same.

FTFY. Plato's Republic has whole sections with worked examples of how to deal with anti-intellectuals.

1
TheColorsDuke•

You are pretty right-on with your post. However, "pro football tailgate parties" just makes you sound ignorant (oh, irony). I love football and that has no relevance, in any way, to my intellect.

1
my_life_is_awesome•

It's the internets. And who invented those nets?! Damn.

1
Arkanin•

The problem isn't that people dislike intellectuals because they are more educated than they are. Intellectuals are only scorned when they threaten the beliefs of the masses. The reaction of the masses react to those particular groups of intellectuals is to attack them and tear them down.

In fact, the masses want intellectuals who support their beliefs, and those intellectuals are used as a valuable tool in the crusade of anti-intellectualism.

Example time. Tell me if this sounds plausible.

Let's take a hypothetical individual, Jimbo. Jimbo's a b'liever, his respected intellectual is Dr. Ron, Ph. D. in Civil Engineering and is one of his church elders.

Scientist A: "I have discovered a self-replicating protobiont that is considerably smaller (in units of RNA) than other protobionts. This has important implications for abiogenesis and I intend to publish a paper shortly.

Jimbo: "What's a protobiont, can I attach that to my lawnmower?"

Dr. Ron: "That scientist is saying life was created without God! He's wrong because of this flawed argument I'm going to give you. It supports your beliefs!"

Jimbo: "What??? Good thing you proved him wrong with your argument Dr. Ron. I'll go write your argument down so I can forward it to all my liberal relatives. That guy's a faggy deluded liberal intellectual!!"

Scientist B: "I have discovered a photoluminescent chemical that is promising as a non-linear refractive index. Here is my paper.

Science Journalist publishes article: SUPERGENIUS PROVES MOLECULAR OPTICAL COMPUTING FINALLY HERE!!!1

Dr. Ron: "Hey Jimbo, check this out! Someday our computers are gonna use LIGHT instead of electronics and they'll be super fast! And this amazing guy did it!"

Jimbo: "Wow what a great scientist! He spent a lot of time in front of a computer and it shows but he's gonna be the next benjamin franklin or something!"

1
[deleted]•

Some people don't know. Some people don't want to know.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
fujbuj•

Regardless, as you said, the reach of anti-intellectualism far surpasses any period in history. Fact is, information spreads quicker and further, and in turn there's obviously more of it (not to mention the dumb folk can rally together in bigger groups now). I would say it's a very dangerous time, especially considering technology will only progress.

1
[deleted]•

Woah, woah there, buddy! You had me until pro football tailgate parties. Tailgating is a LOT of fun, regardless of the number of brain cells you're using.

1
[deleted]•

The Internet has also broken down the primacy of the City in terms of policing the discourse. Newspapers have always had a "liberal bias" to the extent that living in a city and being exposed to different people and different ideas is "liberal." That's due simply to the fact that the economics of publishing and distributing a newspaper only hold up with a certain population density.

The Internet, on the other hand, lets people in Fuckwit, Texas and Susterfucker Kansas compete against thought leaders in New York and San Francisco. In the past, nobody would give two shits about people in those areas, but now they carry equal weight.

1
rob_jeebs•

It really doesn't matter if it's at an all time low or high, what matters is that it is more dangerous now than ever before in human history (with the exception of the previous 65 years) because we live in an age where it is possible to destroy the world with the push of a button.

Anti-intellectualism in 17th century Salem meant some witch burning, anti-intellectualism in the 21st century United States could conceivably lead to to serious decisions, even nuclear ones, being made without intelligent input.

1
MJ13•

I'm going on the record as saying equating the American Republican party with modern society is a mistake. Outside of the US, people are not vehemently against intelligence. Even the Catholic Church supports the idea of climate change.

0
hugolp•

People dislike reality and being told what it is real. In reality intelectuals and other types of charlantans are usually very welcome.

Intelectuals are not more intelligent than anyone else, they are just peole that can repeat theory and dont care about reality.

I am an engineer, so I am not dumb, and being called an intellectual is one of the worse insults I can recieve.

-10
Gyarados•
5
hugolp•

Thats no the popular meaning of "intellectual". When some one calls you an "intellectual", he is telling you that you are so lost in your theories and in your references to famous people that you are loosing sight of reality.

-9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Itisme129•

That's not at all what it means... It's really not that hard to look it up in a dictionary.

An intellectual is a person who uses intelligence (thought and reason) and analytical thinking, either in a professional or a personal capacity.

All it means is somebody who is able to think about the reality of the world using their brain instead of jumping to whatever conclusion suits them best. It has very little to do with how many theories you can spout off.

2
EweOnBlackLedge•

I don't know where you live but where I live, that is utterly untrue. Please don't assert things that are only true in a minority of cases as if they were generally true.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

That's ̶n̶̶o the popular meaning of "intellectual**."** When someone calls you an "intellectual**,"** he is telling you that you are so lost in your theories and in your references to famous people that you are losing sight of reality.

There, now that that's taken care of, we can actually have a conversation.

How do you feel about someone who is considered to be "smart?" How about "scientific?" Are "scientific" people wrapped up in the blah blah that you are rambling on about?

I find that the people who claim there is something wrong with being an intellectual are the kinds of people who wish they weren't so stupid.

1
thatpaulbloke•

Okay then, I promise not to call you an intellectual. You donkey raping shit eater.

4
hugolp•

See, this is the type of people that claim to be intellectuals, when they are just "educated" fan-boys.

-2
[deleted]•

Intelectuals? What?

1
[deleted]•

You're one dumb engineer.

1
[deleted]•

People doesn't see the correlation between science and our living standards. They don't realize that the car, warm house, our compter, the food, medicine and even democracy and freedom all are thanks to science.

112
[deleted]•

They doesn't? Am that an problem?

131
OmnomoBoreos•

Me am fail engish? That unpossible!

Thanks for the heads up GetsElectic!

38
GetsEclectic•

That**'s** unpossible.

42
OmnomoBoreos•

Thanks! I'll fix it right away!

16
[deleted]•

He actually just trolled the shit out of you. Lurk moar.

1
wtf___over•

Funny too. I was going to go all ballistic and defend him, but then I saw your reply and broke into a chuckle.

2
TimmyMojo•

I remember reading an argument between a religious person and a rational person where the religious person said something along the lines of "stop confusing technology and science; they are two different things!" in response to a comment like yours here. I tried to find the source, but alas.

-_-

26
[deleted]•

We all know technology is magic, not science.

11
SarahC•

I've had discussions with this kind of idiocy...

At the point at which it happens, I just lose the will to talk with them. I've been floored out of shock, after looking at them for a second for any sign of sarcasm, and not seeing it.

I struggle trying to think through their thoughts to even come up with a meaningful response!

7
fingerrockets•

whenever I deal with or hear about people like this I always think of "The Dragon In My Garage" by Carl Sagon

2
multirachael•

Well, they may have somewhat of a point, although I'm sure they don't understand why. I tend to think of "science" as the process of observation, experimentation, fact-checking, peer-review, etc. that leads to the developments in technology (as well as knowledge). A computer chip or an MRI machine or an electron telescope is a piece of technology, all were developed by a process of science, and can aid in furthering science. They do go hand-in-hand; but I'm not quite sure they are the same thing.

5
[deleted]•

Science provides the basis for technology to exist and expand.

Expanding technology in return allows more science to be done.

1
multirachael•

'Tis a glorious cycle.

2
eaturbrainz•

I remember reading an argument between a religious person and a rational person

That's a false dichotomy, or at best a tautology.

0
pingish•

How is democracy caused by science?

6
[deleted]•

It's complicated.

6
haakon•

You need to way instain the Professor.

1
devinrf•

Carl Sagan collaborator/PBS documentarian/Pulitzer Prize-nominated science writer Timothy Ferris just released a book last month on that very subject: "The Science of Liberty: Democracy, Reason, and the Laws of Nature" Thesis:

"[T]he democratic revolution was sparked - caused is perhaps not too strong a word - by the scientific revolution, and science continues to empower political freedom today."

Both are rooted in Enlightment ideals, anti-dogmatic, anti-authoritarian, self-correcting. America itself, for example, is frequently referred to as the great "experiment in democracy," or the "laboratory of democracy." Historically, they both evolved together, and they no doubt contributed and buttressed one another along the way, I imagine.

1
MacEnvy•

Democracy is an invention like any other. It didn't exist until someone thought about it, refined the idea, and tested it (the Athenians I suppose).

There's a reason it's called "political science". (Though there are people here who will dispute that, disregard them. They are physicists.)

-3
MacEnvy•

Four downvotes, but no rebuttals? I'd like to hear what people thought was incorrect about my comment.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TheDoomp•

I think people absolutely realize that things like the computer come from science. What I don't think people realize is that the majority of the compassion, laws, and scientific contributions we see in this world come from religious origins.

The Catholic Church has made several contributions that people neglect to realize as well.

1
eaturbrainz•

Democracy and freedom don't come from science.

1
TheChanger•

A quote I love, from Iain Banks' The Bridge:

*If I had my way I wouldn't let anyone who believed in star signs or the Bible or faith healing or anything like that use electric power, or ride in cars and trains and buses and aircrafts, or use anything made of plastic. They want to believe the universe works to their crazy little rules? OK, let them live that way, but why should they be allowed to use the fruits of sheer fucking human genius and hard work. *

1
whatthehelp•

SCIENCE!!!

-1
kleinbl00•

Sheep and Wolves: A Short Essay

Something almost everyone misses in Idiocracy is that it has a fundamentally elitist message: "Humanity is so doomed that even the most underachieving underachiever our generation can muster up will be a brilliant savior compared to the dregs of civilization that shall follow."

The writers knew it, too: they bury this message by making you sit through a powerpoint of just how many kids Cletus McSlackjaw has in the amount of time it takes you, noble and witty viewer, just to get your intellectual member up. In doing so, they obscure the true message:

it only takes one.

The movie stands as a microcosm for governance. Convince the proles that what you do is boring, effete, unmanly and probably sacrilegious so that they don't pay close attention to you while you go about your boring, effete and unmanly process of ruling their lives. Occasionally, a few of them will pop their heads up and notice that they're being herded by wolves; best bet is to either promote or destroy... and continue the business of tearing throats.

The intellectually incurious cling to an afterlife because no matter how insignificant their contribution to the world around them, they will be validated. The ruling class, on the other hand, is often made up of individuals unsure of the very existence of such an afterlife so they must make their mark on the world around them. It is said that there are no statues to polite men and that nice girls never make history. It is also said that uneasy rests the hands of power. Is it really so much better, then, to know than it is to be utterly without wonder?

And so, anti-intellectualism has existed and been encouraged since the invention of fire... and it shall be just as irrelevant until the end of time. Those who actually control things care not a whit what the idiots think of them; should the idiots actually organize enough to rise up and steal power it only indicates that you let them get too smart. Those who actually want to control things, for that matter, learn early on that it's far more efficient to convince one or two wolves to go your way than one or two hundred sheep.

Humans are social creatures. YOU are a social creature. The real question is this:

Are you a herd animal...

...or are you a pack animal?

If the former, enjoy the grass. Enjoy the sky. When death comes, it shall be quick and painless. If the latter, reconcile yourself to being always hungry, always suspicious and always alert...

...but know that at the very least that your teeth are sharp.

101
DrMungkee•

This is an extreme lacking in shades of gray. As humans, we are nothing but shades of gray ever changing as the winds of the ocean.

Our minds are swayed by utter banalities, platitudes and irrelevancies. The end result is utterly unpredictable. As hard as a society may fight intellect, one can offer a cure out of benevolence and change everything... for a period of time. Think polio.

I have faith in humanity. Decades ago we put men ON THE FUCKING MOON. Today we can't seem to fight economical downfalls without throwing massive percentages of a powerful country's worth at the wealthiest on the behalf of the middle class.

All it takes to change history is allot of money or allot of votes. I bet you Google could A) put forth enough capital to change things or B) influence enough people to change things. They started out with a few people in a garage and a good idea.

There's an immeasurable amount of good ideas left to be discovered.

Quit your bitching and change things if you don't like the way they're going.

20
butteryhotcopporn•

Decades ago we put men ON THE FUCKING MOON. Today we can't seem to fight economical downfalls without throwing massive percentages of a powerful country's worth at the wealthiest on the behalf of the middle class.

Putting a man on the moon is not comparable to correctly manipulating the aggregate of economic choices man makes.

4
Roxinos•

As humans, we are nothing but shades of gray ever changing as the winds of the ocean.

And yet, like the winds of the ocean, there are large trends and a certain predictability to the whole system.

2
Rentun•

Okay, you're going to have to stop this winds of the ocean simile. It's the corniest thing I've read in a while and I can't stop snickering to myself.

3
[deleted]•

This is an extreme lacking in shades of gray. As humans, we are nothing but shades of gray ever changing as the winds of the ocean. Our minds are swayed by utter banalities, platitudes and irrelevancies.

You imply platitudes are a bad thing right after you used a platitude

2
kleinbl00•

Dichotomies are never revealed through shades of gray. Nor are explanations tendered through calls to action.

Your point has nothing to do with my point, although I do think it's pretty funny that you anoint Google as your personal savior while accusing me of "bitching" about the status quo and further demanding that I change things in my garage.

It's "a lot," by the way.

1
stcredzero•

Quit your bitching and change things if you don't like the way they're going.

I would put it this way: words can be good, but actions can be even better.

0
IrishWilly•

summary: Wake up Sheeple!

19
jb1974•

...non-sheep might read "The Sheep Look Up" by Jon Brunner. Though it's from 1972 it's surprisingly relevant. Some of the "fiction" (scientific extrapolation) he wrote about then is just happening now.

2
ovinophile•

Aw hell. Just gimme the grass and the sky then. All this talk of running around looking for your next power grab while constantly watching your back sounds so tiresome.

6
Astyanax•

Those who actually control things care not a whit what the idiots think of them; should the idiots actually organize enough to rise up and steal power it only indicates that you let them get too smart.

Well said.

2
DrMungkee•

Mao

0
TwoPointCorrelation•

It is said that there are no statues to polite men and that nice girls never make history.

You should read Crime and Punishment by Dostoevsky, if you havent yet. The protagonist essentially thinks the same and kills a pawnbroker and her sister, trying to demonstrate his potential for greatness.

2
gabe2011•

Wow! I <3 u. That was a great essay. And despite the fact it confirms my ideas of elites, intellectuals, and sheep, I would still this idea fascinating regardless. Who wrote by the way?

1
kleinbl00•
3
andrew1193•

An "intellectual" who wanted to see large numbers of people murdered, and relished the terrifying, absolute power that Stalin had over the lives of everyone in the Soviet Union.

1
gandalfblue•

Did you write that?

1
c0rnd0g•

The film was a single minded joke (a funny one) that pointed out the fact that in modern life (in the western world) has become so easy that, were you inclined to, you could rather stupidly pop out as many kids as you wanted to with very little consequence and then raise them to be as stupid as you are.

As hilarious as it is...the film doesn't address two points...

A. Your kids rarely turn out like you want them as much as you may try to shape them.

B. Some mysterious bunch of "intellectuals" were making their world run in the background... even with the degridation that they portrayed. This is, for me, the point that kinda kills the whole joke for me... cause they enjoy little things like electricity and subway systems.

It's a funny and scary parable... but we are not sheep or wolves or even sheeple... we are hairless monkeys with all the social mechanisms. Some people fear change... some people are exited about using the "stick" to get the termites out of thier hole... the "stick" people will always win in the end... it's just a question of how many millenium will we have to go through to prove this.

1
[deleted]•

Um, I'm a university prof, and what I do is boring, effete, unmanly, and probably sacreligious, but I most certainly don't rule anything. Would that I did... There would be throat-tearing aplenty.

But I'm too effete and unmanly to do it. And I'd probably go to jail and get butt-raped.

1
[deleted]•

I dunno... you could probably apply it somehow. If it's quantitative, you could make a shitload of money consulting and then starting some movement. If it's qualitative, you could probably start your own religion/rewrite culture in your area.

1
mjk1093•

Very good, I think you channeled a little bit of Nietzsche from the afterlife there. On the other hand, I always wondered (reading Nietzsche) if the true Ubermench wouldn't be someone who would go against this natural order of things and create a new one. I guess this is where the Left-Nietzcheans get their start.

1
Digibella•

I am neither a pack animal nor a herd animal, I am a human being. I own pack animals (dogs) and work with herd animals (horses) and understand both of their natures, but my nature is not the same as either of theirs : )

1
[deleted]•

If the latter, reconcile yourself to being always hungry, always suspicious and always alert...

Why should you be hungry? Aren't wolves supposed to eat them in this metaphor?

1
hubub•

I AM A SALAMANDER!

0
iamtotalcrap•

weee, a Marxist false dichotomy. I'm a platypus you insensitive clod! I got poison n shit!

0
BlowjobMillionaire•

You talk like a fag.

-3
ProbablyNotToday•

You're just an elitist socialist faggot.

92
[deleted]•

Maybe tomorrow.

1
khasiv•

I'm only up-voting this because I think you're being ironic.

0
theAtomicFireball•

I'm only downvoting you because I think you're stating the obvious.

46
khasiv•

It is not obvious why anyone up-votes something.

6
Confusedmonkey•

You will never know why I upvoted it, only that I upvoted it... or did I...

12
hencethesuspense•

I think you mean sarcastic.

1
brandoncoal•

Sarcasm is a type of irony.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TescoPeeledPlums•

OMG STFU NAZI COMMUNIST GO DIE IN A HOLE PAKI

0
karmanaut•

I think one problem is that it is an elite club. Not anyone can be "an intellectual". It takes work ethic, intelligence, and education (which costs years and money). That's where the "white tower elitist" attitude comes from.

However, I do think that part of the problem is the isolating effect that it has. Even as children, some of us were probably "bookworms" who didn't socialize as well as everyone else. It's harder to relate to people who are very smart and educated on certain topics. It's not their fault, it's just how the brain works. However, it tends to come off as smug and condescending. It's similar to a social circle but based on intelligence and education instead of wealth/status.

90
neutronfish•

However, it tends to come off as smug and condescending.

I don't know what's more smug and condescending. Pointing out something based on a body of scientific evidence with the use of a few relevant terms, or saying that you know better because you're a "real person instead of an Ivory Tower know-it-all?" Creationists who start their arguments with "let me school you on something here..." tend to seem far more condescending to me than a biologist.

71
karmanaut•

Ignorant people who think they're smart are much more obnoxious than a smart person who thinks they're smart.

That doesn't change the fact that both can come off as condescending and smug, to different audiences.

65
Pander•

As a smart person who thinks they're smart (I know, everyone on the internets is a genius), I come off as smug and condescending to everyone.

And you know what? I'm comfortable with that. If fitting in means I have to deal with the rabble, I'll be elitist.

16
Slayback•

Here's a tip for - take it or leave it.

Being a smart person that doesn't come off as smug and condescending, but is still recognized as smart, gets you much farther in life. Also, sometimes not letting on what you know can give you a great advantage.

29
karmanaut•

It happens to me all the time. I am in a good law school, and some of my friends from high school never even went to college. I don't really have much to talk about with them when I go home, and I always think about how having been educated has set me apart.

9
muhnooer•

YOu should really try acting dumb, but using your smarts to influence the people that actually are dumb. Reserve your elitism for the internet... trust me its pretty awesome. Nothing is more fun than influencing all of your friends to do the shit you want by playing them off their own inability to think.

2
Seekin•

Then intellectuals are perceived as compounding this isolation by placing such emphasis on peer reviewed journals that, of necessity, use jargon (short-hand language which assumes a huge background of relatively esoteric information) which makes it impossible for non-experts in critical fields to understand. While all of this is quite necessary and beneficial to the scientific endeavor, it gives the impression that educated people want to isolate themselves from the rest of the population.

This is why we so respect and appreciate people who can communicate subtle scientific points in a way that anyone who cares to can understand (Sagan, Gould etc.)

20
karmanaut•

Then intellectuals are perceived as compounding this isolation by placing such emphasis on peer reviewed journals that, of necessity, use jargon (short-hand language which assumes a huge background of relatively esoteric information) which makes it impossible for non-experts in critical fields to understand. While all of this is quite necessary and beneficial to the scientific endeavor, it gives the impression that educated people want to isolate themselves from the rest of the population.

It's the same with the law and "Legalese". There are a lot of barriers to entry in all expert fields, and that just plain pisses people off.

21
Kicken•

There are a lot of barriers to entry in all expert fields, and that just plain pisses people off.

Does it ever! It makes em' just want to go home, have a beer, watch their Nascar, and rant about you on facebook. :P

6
karmanaut•

Then I shall sue them for libel.

8
jb1974•

When I was just out of high school I worked at a hospital for a while. I read a lot of science fiction and general science books, and thought of myself as "well read" in technology (well, I was 17, after all). I heard a doctor record a description of the surgery he had just done, and I caught about every third word. More specialized language than I knew existed at that time.

Several years later I heard a plumber call in to describe the situation and order parts. In this case I also understood about every third word.

I doubt the plumber could read an article in JAMA and understand all of the implications of it (neither could I). I also doubt the doctor could read the manual and install a whole house reverse osmosis water filtration system

Which one of these I consider "more important" to society depends on whether I have a blocked colon or a blocked drain (as it were).

1
[deleted]•

Many different professions have their own lexicon that's esoteric for everyone else. Think about auto-mechanics. I have a very basic knowledge cars, and there are parts to my vehicle that I wouldn't be able to identify at all, even if you told me what they were called. I admire mechanics for knowing more than I do about cars... that's how it's supposed to be. Intellectuals are supposed to be more well-versed in intellectual topics than the general public.

Knowledge is power, and people are threatened by power. They either respect it, or they lash out against it; a few try to obtain it.

10
[deleted]•

"Prejudices come from the bottom up" --one of my old educators.

1
i_am_my_father•

What's really funny about journals is that you can use phrases like e.g. or i.e. and yet you are not allowed to use isn't, don't, haven't.

1
ThrustVectoring•

I do think that part of the problem is the isolating effect that it has.

The isolating effect isn't from intellectualism, its from anti-intellectualism. Intellectualism is, at the root, the ability and desire to seek intellectual challenge and stimulation, and the best source of intellectual challenge is to intelligently talk and debate with other people. This is an inclusive gesture that accepts anyone willing to rise to the occasion.

Intellectuals were not always such a small minority group. About a quarter of Americans bought influential and thought provoking books in the early 19th century. Now the percentage of Americans who can read and comprehend a simplified description of how courts and lawyers choose jurors is at about 4%.

As far as being a "bookworm", well, I'll take communing with the ideas and thought processes of past great authors over that of the average person from my generation. Honestly. They wet their panties over Twilight, gush over the latest athletic accomplishments of pampered superstars, listen to generic corporate music that glorifies a vapid consumer culture, and generally show a lack of regard for anything that remotely passes for critical thinking. They are just so banal and vapid, is it really any wonder that I'd rather delve into the thoughts and minds of Heinlein, Churchill, Asimov, Orwell, Huxley, or any other luminaries of the past three thousand years.

tl;dr books are interesting and help you learn interesting things to talk about, and if you don't value that you can be a vapid fuckwit where I don't have to deal with you.

15
mrkurtz•

Intellectuals were not always such a small minority group. About a quarter of Americans bought influential and thought provoking books in the early 19th century. Now the percentage of Americans who can read and comprehend a simplified description of how courts and lawyers choose jurors is at about 4%.

citation needed (requested)

5
[deleted]•

Another request for the cite on that reading comprehension study.

3
my_life_is_awesome•

I like you. This post just got my panties wet.

1
ThrustVectoring•

wow, thanks.

2
angryboy•

If you're hot I will fuck you without a condom and jizz on your tits.

1
stcredzero•

Intellectuals were not always such a small minority group. About a quarter of Americans bought influential and thought provoking books in the early 19th century. Now the percentage of Americans who can read and comprehend a simplified description of how courts and lawyers choose jurors is at about 4%.

[citation needed]

I want the citation, not because I'm giving you a hard time. I am genuinely alarmed!

1
ThrustVectoring•

I read it from Gatto and iirc he didn't cite it either.

http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/underground/toc1.htm

1
ware_am_i•

Though I agree that "intellectualism" is largely correlated with classical education and money, I believe the mindset is independent of those things. It's just too keep your head in the sand, surround yourself with like-minded thinkers, and spout off the party line. It doesn't require a degree or a fortune to have a well thought out opinion and the ability/desire to defend it.

5
[deleted]•

It's just too keep your head in the sand, surround yourself with like-minded thinkers, and spout off the party line.

...Um, we're on Reddit.

3
[deleted]•

Being an intellectual requires intelligence? Whodathunkit? And an education does not require money. Knowledge is everywhere waiting to be learned.

3
Workaphobia•

I define Elitism as the arrogant position that those who are most qualified for a job should be the ones to do it. If that's condescending because it's not all-inclusive, that's unfortunate, because I'm not in a position to compromise the integrity of the definition.

Therefore, any persuasive argument, bargain, or dictate that compels ignorant people to defer to the judgment of others, would help to resolve this matter. I don't care if we educate them or get them to accept that they don't know what they're talking about, but this mob rule, this Vonnegut horror slide show, has got to end.

1
PWL73316•

"Bookworm" intellectuals are not the "intellectuals" you talk about about - people with no social skills who cannot get their messages across have very little effect on society.

1
dstz•

Even as children, some of us were probably "bookworms" who didn't socialize as well as everyone else.

You're mistaking geek for intellectual. It's not difficult at all to think of many very prominent intellectuals who are/were famous, down to Earth and likable people.

Well except in this kind of circlejerk thread were geeks mistake themselves for ostracized intellectuals, and turn this debate into conservative vs liberal, religious vs atheist. This is not a very intellectual thing to do.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Doomdoomkittydoom•

If so, the only thing that differentiates it from other people is that it is elite with regard to intelligence. It's no more, and sometimes quite less, a "club" than the innumerable groupings people naturally make for themselves.

The populace is quite enamored with the likes of the various elite athlete clubs, who represent an actual club, are far more isolated and socially sequestered than your average intellectual.

So the question, I think, still stands, why is intellectualism vilified?

1
Browzer•

**"Do you have any Grey Poupon?" **

This actually really pisses me off. I'm sick of conservatives criticizing people because they don't eat the same boring food as middle America. I drink soy milk instead of regular milk. No doubt this make me some elite evil commie in the minds of many conservatives. And yeah, I like sushi, Indian, Thai, and other foreign food. So what?

68
[deleted]•

Not being fat makes you gay.

99
[deleted]•

Unless you're small-statured and have a slightly-higher-than-normal voice. Then you're a woman. Beard and all.

The moment I step off a plane to the US, my penis apparently falls off, because for the entire stay, I will be referred to as "ma'am." Beard. And. All.

It has never happened in another country.

9
[deleted]•

And now for the amazing drumroll Kylearm - the bearded woman!

2
tarpsocks•

What part of the US were you in? That seems really bizarre to me (I live in chicago).

1
srmatto•

What's adorable about the Grey Poupon thing is the brand is owned by Kraft Foods.

53
eaturbrainz•

Oh, it's a mustard? I'd always wondered what Grey Poupon is.

1
[deleted]•

--Yes, and Kraft is a German company. You know, Germany? As in, Nazis? National Socialism??? And what color were the Nazis' uniforms? Gray. And what country did the Nazis take over? That's right, France. Where dijon mustard comes from. And what are the French? COMMUNISTS!

Well, I'm not going to sit idly by while you ivory tower surrender monkeys celebrate your Nazi commie socialized death factories with your fancy-ass mustard. You're gonna eat American mustard from now on! You know, the stuff in the yellow squirt bottle? The bright yellow mustard? The color that God intended?

You people make me sick.

0
mjk1093•

--Yes, and Kraft is a German company.

Unless Northfield, Illinois has been annexed by Germany, no, it's not. I think you're confusing Kraft with Kraftwerk.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PersonX2•

France is a democracy, even more so than the U.S. The U.S. modeled their government largely on France's democracy.

1
Lukkas•

I wasn't even aware Grey Poupon was pompous! In fact, up until fairly recently, I didn't know what Grey Poupon was. I just knew I liked "spicy mustard."

I guess I've been a closet elitist all along!

19
mybrandnewaccount•

TIL Grey Poupon and spicy mustard are the same thing.

11
[deleted]•

Not quite so. There's a bit of an extra zing in that Poupon the Grey compared to some other spicy mustards.

Edit: I will go and find out more detail later :D

4
androo87•
3
Slubberdegullion•

I think it's dill.

1
[deleted]•

except I eat spicy mustard all the time that isn't grey poupon

1
WrongAssumption•

It's a reference to an old ad campaign that advocated being snobbish. The quality of the product is not relevant really.

11
PDB•

It became "pompous" because of a TV Ad. Up until then, it was just "spicy mustard".

2
mcgroo•

Here's the ad that made mustard "elitist".

So fine it's even made with white wine!

2
throwaway5002•

Grey Poupompous.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hencethesuspense•

no, you've been a closet idiot.

-2
icantthinkofit•

Soy juice. There is no soy tit.

14
bluetshirt•

Of course, since coconuts have breasts, this whole issue is perfectly resolved, and you're not just being a pedantic ass - you're actually contributing to the discussion.

And i'm not just being a sarcastic dick.

26
grgcnnr•

milk: Defined first as a liquid issuing from a mammary gland and second as any liquid that resembles the milk of a cow.

12
chronographer•

Doesn't milky mean "milk like". Maybe we should rename it "soy milky"?!

2
[deleted]•

Milk of magnesia is harvested from the Venus de Milo.

6
trutommo•

Thank you Lewis Black

3
markshepard•

Soy is the anti-milk. It gives you tits, where none should be.

-1
pickledpepper•

If this were true, why don't we hear about gynecomastia being highly endemic in eastern Asia where they consume lots of soy products like tofu?

6
[deleted]•

Disproved years ago. Stop being so anti-intellectual with your dairy lobbyist funded pseudoscience.

4
markshepard•

BUT JEREMY PIVEN SAYS ITS TRUE, SO IT MUST BE TRUE

2
cursoryusername•

Soy, or should I say rice "milk" tastes terrible...

But yeah, I see your point on the whole "this person is not like you, so they must not be a real person" thing

1
Browzer•

I don't drink soy milk plain. I use it in my coffee. Also, they have soy creamers which taste better. I got used to it. Milk just wasn't having a good effect on me.

1
sirnoobius•

only fags eat lettuce.

1
TheWholeThing•

I'm with you on everything except soy milk, just like the real shit better.

But damn I do love sushi, Indian, and Thai food.

1
HawkUK•

Whatever it is...it sounds pretty nasty...

1
bw1870•

Holy crap! I like sushi and Thai , and have almond milk in the fridge. Does this mean I'm a liberal? I knew hanging out on reddit would rub off.

1
silentshout•

Yep. When they say that to me, I say yes. I much prefer dijon mustard to that yellow-food-colored crap they call "mustard." Then again, I have a French husband so most of these people hate me by default :)

1
my_life_is_awesome•

Pardon me, sir, do you drink your soy lattes at Starbucks perchance?

1
Birdrun•

Australian here. What is this Grey Poupon anyway? What's the significance of it? I've heard that line before, on the Simpsons, I think, but I've never heard of the stuff.

0
Poloniculmov•

It's Dijon mustard. The commercial had on guy in a limo ask another in a limo: "Pardon me, would you have any Grey Poupon?" Also Poupon sounds like something a fag might say.

2
Birdrun•

I see. Thankyou kindly.

1
dougbdl•

Remember Obama getting called an elitist because he requested Grey Poupon on his hamburger? This really is unbelievable...watch the video...

http://gawker.com/5244126/obama-orders-burger-with-elitist-european-condiment

0
thephotoman•

To be fair, RFID implants may be the mark of the devil--just not in the sense that this poor soul thinks. There are serious problems with the technology, and its rapid uptake does not make me comfortable.

This is a kind of person you have to find in meatspace and take out for a weekend on a regular basis. You've got to show him the world, as he may never have seen it.

67
DanRisinger•

RFID implants scare the shit out of me.

If the patriot act continues to slowly gain new means for abusing power, a police state will have no trouble falling into place.

42
px403•

If you are scared of anything for more than 30 seconds, you are probably being manipulated. Do some research into the technology, it can never be used by a "police state". RFID chips can easily be cloned and disabled by anyone. If some politician tries to make a power grab using some fancy new technology, the power goes to us, the people. We understand the technology better than they do, and that has always been the case.

Take a look back at when you became afraid of the technology and try to understand who it was that influenced you to feel that way, and what they had to gain from doing it.

38
DanRisinger•

I'm not afraid of RFIDs themselves, I'm afraid of a state where I feel like a beepers going to go off every time I have to cross through some checkpoint.

There's a bunch of potentially useful things with RFIDs, it would be great to have medical information brought up quickly without having to rifle through papers or type something into a computer, but the idea that this chip under my skin is projecting my identity and potentially my where abouts is a little unnerving.

11
Rentun•

Did I miss something?

When mandatory chip implantation become a thing?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
px403•

Sounds like you are being drawn into the cult of Munroe. Seek help.

I also disagree with the second part of your comment. You can think a change is going to suck, but fear will cause you to act irrationally when you should be evaluating the situation and preparing for it. That's just my philosophy though, and I have heard many valid arguments against it.

3
stcredzero•

If some politician tries to make a power grab using some fancy new technology, the power goes to us, the people. We understand the technology better than they do, and that has always been the case.

A small minority of us truly understand it at all. Take voting machines. A small minority of us are programmers who could write even a defective program using encryption. A minority of those programmers would understand well enough to really get it right. For an entire embedded system, it's even worse.

4
px403•

We don't all need to understand it. Only a few people need to understand it at that level, and then publish the results. At any given moment there are at least 10s of thousands of really sharp researchers looking for something that hasn't been broken publicly yet so they can be first to publish.

1
[deleted]•

I get so sick of people who immediately point to 1984 whenever new technology arises. The funniest is when the person is also someone who says things like all information should be freely available.

2
[deleted]•

People do that to keep it from happening.

1
Zalani•

agreed. they handed them out at my school thinly disguised as a way to scan in a meal in the cafeteria instead of swiping our id's. I refuse to put mine on my phone like they suggest. it's taped to the wall of my dorm room like it has been since they gave it to me...thinking about it, why haven't i destroyed it yet?

13
px403•

Do you know what goes a LOT farther than an RFID signal? Visible light. Did you know that if your school wanted, they could also set up video cameras to track you?

To track you around campus via RFID, they would need to set up listening posts every 10 feet or so. The tracking hardware is what you should get mad at if it ever comes into existence, not the chip.

All this fear over RFID is annoying, it's just a chunk of metal that beeps out a number when it passes through an induction field. It does make it significantly easier to skim credit cards, but it's not like it was ever that hard to skim a magnetic strip, and visa has a tendency to trample on anyone that makes an attempt at cc fraud, because you are not liable for the fraudulent transaction, visa is.

17
Zalani•

i didn't know this. i feel as though it is significantly easier to fool video cameras, and i didn't know that RFID chips were that ineffective. I was under the impression that they were sometimes used in cell phones and the like as means of tracking. I probably should JFGI before i freak out. sorry :P

8
redwall_hp•

Do you know what goes a LOT farther than an RFID signal? Visible light. Did you know that if your school wanted, they could also set up video cameras to track you?

It's much easier to be able to call up a database entry that shows a listing of places and times where the RFID checked-in than to scan through various security cameras. Facial recognition software just isn't that good.

1
ThrustVectoring•

My former university put them in student ID cards, but IIRC they are just passive units and their scan range was pretty horrible.

4
MiasmaticMachine•

They're almost certainly passive. The active ones cost significantly more and are still pretty sizable.

5
tso•

depends on the antenna at the other end mostly.

1
DanRisinger•

Thats actually very scary that the schools are distributing them, they're working their way into society a lot faster than I thought.

1
Zalani•

they didn't say "oh these are RFID chips"...but what else could they be? My friends think i'm insane. I know the probably aren't tracking us with them, it's not like i'm doing anything even slightly illegal, it's just the idea that they could track me with the proper motivation that freaks me out.

3
marikas•

Too late, the devil has got to you. You're fook'd!

1
agoodleach•

I believe you are referring to a suppository.

1
DanRisinger•

They're putting RFIDs up peoples poopers now?!

1
Suppy•

What exactly is a RFID chip?

1
DanRisinger•

It's a small magnetic chip which works a lot like a bar code.

If you've seen someone open a door by moving a card past a scanner, you've seen one in action.

2
Suppy•

Ah, those. Got it. Thanks.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

56
[deleted]•

Why is it scary?

you say here that anti-intellectulism is scary because intellectuals might be shot? are there not wider implications?

The United States is now an empire

China and India have barely even started their stories - do you honestly believe the government feels the USA has such an unassailable lead that they don't need anymore intellectuals?

The Myths of Intellect

hard work is a major component, but there is also such thing as innate ability.

If so, you should know that these words are hate speech!

you seem to be attempting to label something you don't like as hate speech - being smug, condescending or pretentious are all legitimately seen as negative traits.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
Bananageddon•

The Insecurity of the Lazy

Do you use any of the following words in a derisive manner?

  • elitist * condescending * smug * pretentious * smart-ass

If so, you should know that these words are hate speech! You are using them to direct hatred against a class of people whom you perceive as being different from yourself. And yet, this same class of people is trying so desperately to help you, to show you that you can pull yourself up just like they did and enjoy the same advantages. These words are used as a defense mechanism, to cover for one's own insecurity.

That was where you lost me. If someone is being smug, it's probably not because of what they're saying, but how they're saying it. Smugness also has little to do with intellectualism either, for instance I think most people would consider Glenn Beck to be extremely smug, and he's one of the most anti-intellectual types out there.

If you are being called smug or pretentious, don't automatically assume that it's because you're clever and they're stupid. It might be because you're smug and pretentious.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-7
Bananageddon•

Ok, you seem to have entirely missed my point, I guess I didn't explain myself very well.

Smugness has nothing to do with knowledge. It has nothing to do with how much you know, how much of an expert you are on any given topic, or what those topics might be. Smugness is about how and why you impart that knowledge to others. If you're sharing this knowledge because you want to pass it on to others, simply because it's good to know about stuff, then you're not being smug. If you're doing it because you want other people to be in awe of how much stuff you know, then you're being smug.

Also, if you're passing this knowledge on in a way that makes the reciever of said knowledge feel like a dumbass for not having already known it, rather than feeling good about the fact that they now know more stuff, then you're being smug.

Here's an example; imagine that instead of titling his latest book "The Greatest Show on Earth", Richard Dawkins had chosen to title it "Evolution is real and anyone who disagrees is a fucking moron". Do you see how the first title isn't smug but the second one is?

Smugness is using the fact that you know more about something than someone else to make them feel shit about it. It's unkind, unhelpful, unnecessary and it should be called out whenever someone does it.

8
[deleted]•

An argument could be made that in a society supposedly drenched in anti-intellectual sentiment the criterion for determining smugness is simpler and more inclusive. I think the idea is that we could get to a point that merely a reasoned disagreement could be considered smug.

Frankly, I think this whole thread is nonsense. America needs to invest more in sciences, very true. But there seems to be an common idea in many comments that there's some vast conspiracy to enslave and endumb intellectuals to encourage them to buy more television products and kill people across the ocean.

0
Phallus•

There ARE people who will preach the knowledge they have in a condescending and smug manner, at request or not so that they'll feel superior. They aren't trying to impart knowledge, assist, or share; they're being pretentious.

There are also people, such as myself, who genuinely attempt to impart knowledge when it's perceived to be desired and are met with your mentioned hostility and "hate speech." Which it pretty much is in this context, but that doesn't change that they're genuine negative traits that are presented fairly often.

6
GoofyBoy•

Psychologists call what you're doing "projection" - you justify your fears by making up a story that casts the other person as a villain in your personal morality play.

....

Here's what's really going on if someone calls you smug and pretentious: You are doing nothing, they are suffering from intellectual intimidation. And it is an illusion, a hallucination on their part. I'm not kidding when I call this line of thinking poison. It teaches you to hate people who learn. What could lead a society to downfall faster than to hate learning?

The irony is sooooo delicious on a Sunday morning. (I'm sorry, am I being smug and pretentious for pointing this out?)

4
throwaway5002•

I'm sorry, but the first few sentences before you continued on your ramble were hilarious.

...and then the ramble was made more hilarious by how hard you missed his point at the beginning.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
zaphodi•

US occupies over 50% of the habitable land mass

heh. its more like 6.5% actually, according to cia factbook.

9
haakon•

I don't think he meant "occupies" as in how much space the collection of states called USA takes up, but rather "occupies" as in military occupation. I'm not sure it's as high as 50% even then, but the US does still have post-WW2 bases in Japan, Germany and lots of other countries.

1
[deleted]•

Let me get this straight: pretentious, condescending, smug people are trying desperately to help me?

Go fuck yourself dude. Seriously. I don't care what your intentions are, treating others like your inferiors will never get you anywhere in this country.

I'm happy that you celebrate hard work. That's what's really dying in this country. You should have read a little more history with that library card: a lot of your self-anointed intellectual peers were busy apologizing for Stalin while he was murdering the twenty million. They also try to shift blame what Pol Pot did on the USA, because he was executing textbook communism. Straight out of Marx.

You can't throw a stone around reddit and miss an avid Marxist who thinks he's an intellectual. That's what anti-intellectuals hate.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
narcotron•

Everything you see today, I owe to a public library card.

Beautiful. I'm always surprised at how few people go to the public library and use it. If you live in a big city, chances are, you've got an amazing public library right at your fingertips. People say they don't have the time or resources or whatever to learn, but gee, they can get a FREE library card and have access to more knowledge than they know what to do with. I'm glad someone has fully taken advantage of it. Cheers to you, good sir!

2
nokes•

To be fair, Bill Gate's is an extremely brilliant and hard working man. Sure rich parents helped, but during the early days of Microsoft he consistently put in 14+ hour days. Not to mention how much programing he and Paul Allen did just by themselves.

Edit: deleted factually incorrect last sentence.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
nokes•

ok, I'm an apple user anyways.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
nick8325•

He's saying the revolution wasn't anti-intellectual. Instead, the defeated Pakistani government sabotaged the new Bangladeshi government by murdering the country's intellectuals.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
eaturbrainz•

The United States is now an empire. It spans the globe, the US occupies over 50% of the habitable land mass, it spends more on defense than the rest of the world combined - we're all familiar with the arguments. Well, you don't need much education to patrol a street and shoot an AK-47. What you do need is a society and economy that tends to drive as many young people into military service as possible.

This is conspiracy theory.

Our most hailed scientists, Einstein and Feynmann, had some role in the formation of atomic weapons.

Einstein developed his theories without atomic weapons in mind at all.

For another example, uneducated people are easier to scare. Scared people go to war to defend their freedom and pay more tithes to defend their immortal soul. Educated people ask "Why should I bomb this brown person?" and "Where is this invisible sky person?"

Please do not conflate American "manifest destiny" civic religion with religion in general.

This is the part that's most controversial on Reddit, because the twenties-to-thirties range is the biggest demographic here. Well, I have talked with Generation X, and I have talked with Millennials, and both of them fit like bookends of progressivism around Generation Y, which is basically sounding like Archie Bunker.

Millenial is another term for Generation Y.

Guess how they chose to rebel?

Not very good reasoning. Statistics have shown that Generation Y, aka the Millenials, are one of the most progressive, best-educated generations in well... generations.

If so, you should know that these words are hate speech! You are using them to direct hatred against a class of people whom you perceive as being different from yourself. And yet, this same class of people is trying so desperately to help you, to show you that you can pull yourself up just like they did and enjoy the same advantages. These words are used as a defense mechanism, to cover for one's own insecurity.

Not always. Those words can be used against the kind of pseudo-intellectualism that pervades places like Reddit, attempting to use a veneer of intellect to justify propositions that have no basis in actual fact, are not internally coherent, or whose axiomatic justifications are fundamentally objectionable.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BaronVonFastrand•

A Permanent Distaste you say. Of anyone Over Thirty. I'm Boned.

2
Digibella•

I am one of the baby boomers who raised the current generation and I think this generation is AWESOME! They have just helped elect a president who in ONE YEAR has (In the interest of space-http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_Barack_Obama%27s_accomplishments_as_president). They have been taught NOT to hate others because of their differences, but to celebrate and learn from those differences. They are our hope and our future and I think they are doing great.

1
[deleted]•

Keep popping the happy pills and never call me in the morning.

2
[deleted]•

If this comment wasn't spot on - it would've been top.

Unfortunately you're right.

1
my_life_is_awesome•

Upboat for user name.

0
[deleted]•

"Most people would rather die than think; in fact, they do so" Bertrand Russell.

39
rtb•

Not sure how modern it is; Hofstadter wrote Anti-Intellectualism In American Life 46 years ago.

37
[deleted]•

Also, that work chronicles anti-intellectualism from the Early Republic to McCarthyism. So it's easy to say that anti-intellectualism is American as Apple Pie. Also, The Paranoid Style in American Politics is a good, quick read.

16
mjb987•

Certainly a interesting book, and it doubles as a good (albeit highly focused and specific) history book as well.

3
hxcloud99•

Leonard Hofstadter? And I thought he was just acting.

1
nokes•

I think the first big anti-intellectual movement is the second great awakening. It was at this point in American history where Christianity was spread in mass by a few people with very little education. Which wished to instill a purer form of christianity, outside of the educated clergy. They also where excited by the new political democracy they where in and viewed their revival and rejection of the European Christianity as part of this. Many of these groups went to the southern united states to form churches. Which is where you get the bible belt (a once Anglican region that somehow replaced Anglicanism around the time of the 2nd great awakening with something less british... baptist). In short a bunch of anti-intellectual's who despised Europe, who wanted to get the fundamentals of christianity and rejected all that fancy talk of educated clergy.

These are distinct from the New England churches. Which by some strange of mixture deism and calvinism became far more unitarian. Then you have the contrasts with Christian churches in Europe, which tend to be far more likely to believe things like evolution and global warming, and are more tolerant to people's sexuality.

Edit: However on the bright side, 2nd great awakening was abolitionist, and pro women's rights, and sought social justice, something that has diminished in the modern evangelical movement.

1
outsdanding•

replied so I can find this

0
hillgiant•

You're not alone, but unfortunately, you are outnumbered.

35
[deleted]•

I go to a dogshit university in a dogshit state (Kentucky), and I'm pretty sure that I spend 99% of my time being insulted by lazy, mouth-breathing, science-fearing asshole Republicans. I'm seriously losing my ability to give a shit, and my grades are taking a rather sharp turn downwards because of it. I have never been called so many hurtful names by so many jealous morons in such a short amount of time. Hell, the first day in one of my science classes, the teacher felt the need to announce that she was a faith-holding Christian (as opposed to a non-faith-holding Christian?) In other words, if you don't like this bullshit, DO NOT COME TO KENTUCKY. There's nothing to do here anyway, and anyone who has "Kentucky pride" has their head planted firmly in their ass.

ANYWAY

Here's the scary thing: stupid people don't just call you an "elitist faggot" and move on. No no, they call you a "dumbass" or a "fuckwit" because they think they're smarter than you. What I'm getting at is that several people in this thread see this anti-intellectualism as a mass decision by people to be stupid. But really, it's mostly a mass decision by dumb people to talk very loudly about things they don't understand. To actually think, to actually learn and to actually take time to shut the fuck up and listen to someone speak are signs of weakness and stupidity. If I spend more than a hour reading a book, I can guarantee you that someone will ask me why I'm "still" reading that book. After all, they could look at all the words and figure out what they mean quickly, why can't you? In case it's not clear: none of these people pull any meaning out of words in books. They gloss over them, remember vaguely what they (the words in the books) mean and put the book down. It took me a while to figure it out, but I eventually realized with horror that 90% of the people in my classes and do exactly this.

I know its cliche, but I seriously think we should find some reliable metric for gauging a person's stupidity and kill them if they fall below a certain score.

</rant>

tl;dr - I live around a lot of stupider-than-normal people. We should kill them.

34
[deleted]•

Why don't you transfer? It sounds like that place is making you crazy.

23
[deleted]•

Meh, be careful with that attitude. I know how it feels, but a few years on, you're going to look back and wonder why you thought you were so superior.

Let me help:

You're an undergrad. You might be the smartest kid in the class, but that very likely still means you know fuck-all about anything. If the people around you are idiots, you need to either transfer or nut up and get what you can out of the classes. If you want to be surrounded by smarter people, you'll need to go to grad school, which is quite a bit more interesting/challenging. If you don't want to go that route, shut up and just get your paper. If you're getting bad grades, you're getting bad grades. Smart, well-adjusted people don't get bad grades. They have a lot of other problems in life too. Fix it.

(Posted by a university prof with the best of intentions.)

11
isaacnewton2010•

What if you really are the stupider-than-normal person who thinks that their smarter than others?

It has always been kind of a fear of mine or maybe I guess just a thought that I like to entertain myself with, I mean my school, or my town my state or my country could really be a section of the world were are the retards are placed. Maybe the world doesn't exist and it is just some stupid thing made up to manipulate this little retard. And really I might be so stupid that I can't comprehend anything outside of my box and will never know outside of it, probably because i'm too stupid or something, kind of like a truman show for retards. I mean seriously all of the people I've come in contact could also be in this retard system where the retards go... maybe I have some stupid grandiose?? illusion. i don't really think this but sometihng like it could be possible I guess. whatever, it is fun to think about.

It maybe a bit similar to this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evil_daemon

3
[deleted]•

What if you really are the stupider-than-normal person who thinks that their smarter than others?

Maybe I am. See also. I'll resist making a joke about "they're" vs "their", since I'm not a Grammar Nazi. (:

3
kiwican•

Yes, yes we should.

How about "death panels" but for the stupid, instead of the terminally ill?

2
[deleted]•

I normally consider myself a pretty mild-mannered person, but for some reason the thought of the hordes of fatass, welfare-using redneck motherfuckers in line at Wal-Mart burning in a furnace, along with their ugly fuck-up children, greatly pleases me.

2
pantzareoff•

The scum is a collection of wash-off from the more cared for. Only there is no drain. When the powerful, well-off, active-minded, etc, lose touch with the not-so-powerful, well-off, active-minded, society decays. Those "fatass, welfar-using redneck motherfuckers" serve as a looking glass to clarity when you look at society at an aggregate level. They are just as valuable as you, motherfucker, don't forget it. There are shitloads of people in the world. Not everybody is going to have life pan out well. It's just noooot possible.

2
[deleted]•

Wow.

The scum is a collection of wash-off from the more cared for.

I know this is a thread dealing with intellectual debate, so don't take this the wrong way when I say this, but please shut the fuck up.

lose touch with the not-so-powerful, well-off, active-minded, society decays.

Except, I was talking this entire time about people who aren't active minded at all. They're lazy, ignorant and refuse to change. You're describing people who actually try and fail (who I feel sorry for), as opposed to the dumbasses who skirt by (which, as it just so happens, is the entire topic of discussion for this thread).

Those "fatass, welfar-using redneck motherfuckers" serve as a looking glass to clarity when you look at society at an aggregate level. They are just as valuable as you, motherfucker, don't forget it.

I have no idea what you're blabbering about, nor do I care. You didn't even bother to look at the context of the thread you're attacking me in, and you ended up looking like a huge dumbass because of it. Great job.

Not everybody is going to have life pan out well.

Yes, but doing absolutely jack shit with your life isn't even attempting anything, is it?

You're a fucking idiot. For the record, anything else you respond with is going to be downvoted and unaddressed.

-3
mistyriver•

What do you think about Berea?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

I know very little about it, and I don't go there.

Why?

1
mistyriver•

Seems like it might have its good points. Plus, it's free.

2
angryboy•

Upmodded for dipshiticidal fantasies.

2
[deleted]•

Good metric for being a brain-dead, pig-fucking, degenerate is watching Fox news for other reasons than the lulz. If you watch that retardation and think, "Wow, this is so true; and it reinforces my christian values" you are fair game for the great cretin hunt. We can call it Action T5 ;)

BTW, Kentucky is a very well-known breeding ground for vicious degenerates ;)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_S._Thompson

0
SomGuy•

Anti-intellectualism is a big problem, but there's a bigger problem of pseudo-intellectualism. There are far too many frauds in academia, lending a pretense of scientific validation to policies that have been proven to fail no matter how many times they get a fresh coat of paint and are re-sold to the public.

Paul Krugman is typical of the problem I describe.

29
ExistentialEnsoOP•

One phenomenon where I think this is especially clear is the Antivaxxer movement and many related "alternative" approaches to medical thought. Many of the people who seem to succumb to such things seem perfectly sane, educated people, yet they readily buy into ideas that are patently bullshit, because they're too lazy to fact check, and some guy with a PhD told them it was true.

32
Workaphobia•

because they're too lazy to fact check, and some guy with a PhD told them it was true.

Indeed. I personally fact check every claim that is ever made to me, explicitly or implicitly. I don't trust PhDs, so I reproduce all experimental conditions on my own, relying on my own tedious confirmations of well-established principles dating back to Gallileo. It does take quite some time to re-certify the safety of all my medications, inspect all my food sources, and personally examine the technical details of my medical records, but it's quite worth it to not have to go by the word of one of those unreliable PhDs.

16

Indeed, one's own investigations reveal the singular benefits provided by artificial stimulants, contrary you will find to the putative report of these so-called experts and their narrow concerns for somatic vitality. It is seldom otherwise that one can source the adequate exertion of the mind sufficient to unchock the cogwheels of thought and spare one the most terrible mental fatigue and vexation; a natural remedy to be found only amongst the most abstruse cryptogram, or the most intricate analysis of the criminal mind.

2
Workaphobia•

I find it ironic (more accurately: neatly coincidental) that you 1-up'd me while I was wearing my 1-up shirt.

2
stcredzero•

Free market alternative: become a member at a site like this:

http://www.consumerlab.com/

2
Ziggy55•

How often do you come across information that contradicts what the PhDs told you?

1
throwaway5002•

You had me going for a couple sentences there - kudos.

1
SomGuy•

Well, there have always been quacks, and quacks have always pretended to have some scientific basis for the hogwash they're selling. I'm rather shocked that the national health service in the UK actually pisses tax money away on homeopathy and chiropractic.

12
OzJuggler•

And then the government sit idly by while Simon Singh takes a fall in the courts for stating the objective fact of homeopathy being fraud.

1
SomGuy•

I have to wonder what's gone awry with the libel laws in the UK. In the common-law tradition, truth is a complete defense. When did the parliament alter that?

2
cursoryusername•

True, but with a significant percentage of doctors not doing things in the interest of the patient, and only in the interest of dogma and profit, it's very easy to see why there is a backlash on many fronts...

By both intellectual and non-intellectual segments of the population.

Fact check milk thistle and get back to me. And that's just one example.

1
rawrimayeti•

How is Krugman a fraud?

22
SomGuy•

He's a political operative masquerading as an economist, just like Keynes was.

An economist is someone who studies why people make the choices that they do, such as what kind of work they do, whether to save or spend their earnings, or what kinds of goods and services they consume. Krugman is in the business of inventing rationalizations for power-grabbing.

-11
rawrimayeti•

An economist need not divorce his understanding of the field from his social values. Just because Krugman is honest about his politics does not mean he is a bad economist.

23
[deleted]•

yur politics is showing

12
[deleted]•

As an econ major you are totally wrong. That is just one aspect of economics called consumer theory... Economics is simply a set of tools used to examine many different structures. There is also a large field of political economics - of which Krugman is actively involved. I find it somewhat ironic that in your frustration with pseudo-intellectualism you are simply dismissing an extremely intelligent methodological economist because you disagree with him. My econ proff and one of my best friend's strongly disagree with Krugman - but they still respect him as an extremely intelligent man. I personally like him - and while I disagree with many of the aspects of economists like Hayek I still have the utmost respect for their amazing intellect.

You will find in economics many of the disagreements are nominal and based on the valuation of such qualitative ideas such as "freedom." My financial econ proff this past quarter just got his PhD at MIT and is an extreme economic conservative/libertarian. When I asked him what he thought of Keynes he said that while he thinks our current stimulus is a phenomenal waste of tax payer money and he vehemently disagrees with it - it would be foolhardy to disregard his genius and revolutionary ideas in the field of macroeconomics.

I frequently see non-economists such as yourself with these insane ideas and resentment of economists you disagree with. Which is sad. Because in the field itself despite on going disagreements there is always a respectful presence.

10
PDB•

"Because in the field itself despite on going disagreements there is always a respectful presence." Could that be because it's all about theories?

1
SomGuy•

you are simply dismissing an extremely intelligent methodological economist

He was nothing of the kind. A methodical economist would re-visit his conclusions when faced with data that didn't agree with his prejudices.

I frequently see non-economists such as yourself

Let me tell you something about economists, sparky: I've worked on the front lines of the financial industry, with quants who were directing billions of dollars daily, setting investment policy for UBS/Warburg. What I learned from that direct observation, is that their academic credentials were worth precisely squat when it came to giving the bank useful advice.

When I was there, the bank was losing a couple billion a quarter on positions that they'd taken a year earlier and couldn't hedge out of. They'd taken those positions because their economists' models told them that they should.

Now, speaking of Krugman in particular, that asshole advocated a real estate bubble as a matter of policy, as a remedy for the NASDAQ bubble. Maybe he seems like a genius to you, but I judge intellect by how well someone's positions square with reality.

0
androuglas•

He did win the Nobel prize in economics, you know. It's a bit hard for me to see how he is masquerading.

9
ChaiOnLife•

Henry Killinger(nee Kissinger) also won the Nobel prize for Peace, after he firebombed Cambodia.

9
SomGuy•

There is no Nobel prize in economics. There's a swedish banker's prize that they pretend is a Nobel prize.

3
OzJuggler•

Further to ChaiOnLife's comment...
The leader of the terrorist / freedom fighter organisation the PLO was also awarded the Nobel Peace prize. AND they awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to Obama before he'd actually done anything yet.

Receiving the Peace prize means nothing, and it's not clear if there ever was a time that it did.

1
callum_cglp•

He's a political operative masquerading as an economist, just like Keynes was.

Come on.

8
SomGuy•

Keynes made a living offering a patina of academic prestige to Britain's government expansionism.

-4
drunkbirth•

I'm a layperson, but hasn't Keynes been proven right? The evidence looks strong that if we hadn't had a stimulus bill, we would have had a depression.

4
dbag127•

It's impossible to "prove" economics because we can't go back in time and NOT have a stimulus bill and see what the results are. And there are plenty of people who don't agree with keynes, even though it's all that's taught these days.

7
SomGuy•

I'm a layperson, but hasn't Keynes been proven right?

Keynes has been proven wrong continuously, ever since the Hoover/Roosevelt disaster.

-5
sjstuckey•

Please share a picture of your Nobel prize.

1
Arguron•

Allow me to introduce you to Friedrich von Hayek and Milton Friedman, the 1974 and 1976 recipients of the Nobel Memorial prize in Economics, respectively. You might call them Krugman's intellectual polar opposites, and they won the prize before it had become completely corrupted by political influence.

7
SomGuy•

That's a very weak rejoinder. Better luck next time.

1
thephotoman•

You were doing well until that last sentence. Specifically, it should not have been your last. You need to explain it better.

11
Morans•

The most sophistical thing a person can do is to dismiss arguments as fraud without doing the work of demonstrating it. You're argument probably relies on the lazy "self-evident" question begging.

6
SomGuy•

You're argument probably

Want to try putting words in my mouth? Have at it. This could be fun.

-2
Morans•

It another comment, you said this:

Keynes has been proven wrong continuously, ever since the Hoover/Roosevelt disaster.

This obviously omits any explanation about how "the Hoover/Roosevelt disaster" proves Keynes wrong, it appeals to history as proof. Still, considering that you've made no effort to demonstrate the truth of your accusation, I can speculate about it all I want. Attacking my speculation won't justify your argument, as much as you might like it to.

2
SomGuy•

Ok, I'll spoon-feed it to you: despite Hoover's profligate spending, followed by Roosevelt stealing the people's gold, spending more money and taking on more debt than anyone had thought possible, destroying food to drive the prices up, paying people to waste their time on unneeded "make work" projects, and even imprisoning people for disobeying his unconstitutional orders, the depression continued until after Roosevelt's death.

What brought us out of the depression was the release of around a million men from military service, reduction of government spending by 2/3, and repeal of a large portion of Roosevelt's insane wage and price control policies.

Clear enough?

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
SomGuy•

I beg to differ. There was a great tradition of intellectual economists before Marx, and it continued despite hostility from the mainstream of academia.

0
Seekin•

Unfortunately, enough money can tempt people of any profession away from ethical practice. Do you suspect that many of the marketing "shills" you describe are actually unaware of the harm of their practices? I Think it's possible. There are none so blind as those whose wallets are in their way.

Also, it always fascinates me that those who make a living by invoking the placebo effect and convincing people to pay them for it ("energy healers", "acupuncturists, homeopathy peddlers and the like) adopt much of the jingo of science, albeit almost always inappropriately. It seems telling that they wrap themselves with a vernier of scientific credibility while simultaneously claiming that western medicine is so incompetent or harmful.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

It is funny how people project their own flaws on their personal boogeymen.

1
SomGuy•

I've never pretended to have a scientific basis for telling other people what to do, sunshine.

-2
[deleted]•

Add Ancel Keys to that list. He has nearly singlehandedly created and perpetuated the dietary fat and cholesterol myth that has turned us into a bunch of fatties. Loser.

1
SomGuy•

Not familiar with Ancel Keys, probably because I've never needed to diet. I eat whatever I want, and I've never been overweight.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SomGuy•

Friedman and Kristoff certainly fit. As for Krugman, he's been a pro-inflation cheerleader for as long as I've been aware of his work.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NitsujTPU•

It's kind of funny how the top-modded posts in science are all self-congratulatory, like this one, and have nothing to do with critical thought.

27
my_life_is_awesome•

Stop being so critical :)

8
citan_uzuki•

Actually, that's sort of funny because it's going against the point that was trying to be made in the first place.

1
NitsujTPU•

Huh?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
eric22vhs•

Most of the people we consider anti-intellectual aren't knowingly anti-intellectual.

Even the tea-partiers. They may be disgusting religious bigots, but really they're people who know things are going wrong in society, but don't really understand why. Fox news, and leading neoconservatives take advantage of this and market their political agendas towards them, telling them there're all these smart rich people in the North East who hold them down and take advantage of them.

Now let's face it, we all make fun of these people, call them ignorant hicks, and etcetera. This doesn't help. In their eyes, this just backs up the rubbish they hear on Fox News that these liberal elites are taking advantage of them.

They cling to things like religion because to them, it's a set of easy to understand ethics, or as they refer to them, morals. They're not choosing to be ignorant and destroy hopes for future civilization. When they choose to go out hunting instead of staying inside and reading a book, it's the same thought process going through their head as when a redditor decides to look at funny pictures on the internet instead of doing their research paper.

The difference is, they're brought up in areas without much academic reinforcement, often still using dial-up internet, where a lot of liberal "do-gooders" early on in life decide to never step foot, while their parents explain to them that if they venture into a major city, they'll find everyone is rude and thinks they're smarter and more privileged than they are.

It's the people who aren't stupid, but take advantage of cultural ignorance for the sake of their own agenda that we should be disturbed by.

24
archontruth•

The Tea Partiers are really the truest outgrowth of the culture of the Bush administration. They're mad as hell, and they have a legitimate grievance, but they've decided to attack the wrong target and help the people they should be blaming, all because they didn't bother doing any research before going on the warpath.

5
[deleted]•

If by "outgrowth of the culture of the Bush administration" you mean "angry that the people they elected to keep the government small made it bigger" then you would be accurate.

1
Rentun•

Wait, there AREN'T smart rich people in the northeast taking advantage of us?

2
[deleted]•

That's probably what an anti-intellectual would get out of his comment

1
Rentun•

Quit talking like a fag.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

23
[deleted]•

Thank. You.

and the fact that your comment only has 7 points after being up for 11 hours is making your case.

1