Redditor posts a pic of a bird on her chest. Redditors discover that she has also posted in r/gonewild. Witch hunt ensues and she is accused of being fat and an attention whore. She deletes her account. WTF, reddit?
[removed]
Posted May 17, 2010, 12:21 PM UTC · edited
WTF. A woman is willing to post naked pictures of herself AND cute animal pictures and you do this? What the hell is wrong with you? The people who did this will either be virgins for the rest of their lives, or their current significant other will continue to be ugly, fat and unwilling to give them oral sex. You are horrible people.
This is why we can't have nice things.
This isn't true. The reason she ran away is obviously because she had blurred her face out in her GW pics but used the same account (or at least was recognizable enough - I don't know which) for the bird posting. Redditors linked the two together publicly. Anyone who recognized her could thus click through and find her naked pictures (which she clearly liked but didn't want to have associated with her public persona, obviously). Deleting her account makes it that much less likely that people can trace her and link the two.
There was no witch hunt. There are a handful of idiot posts, suitably buried, the same as there are in every reddit thread.
Although I agree with the sentiment behind this post, it's sensationalized and doesn't address the rationality of the situation.
</soapbox>OMG, you mean my kneejerk, righteous indignation at a perceived injustice which was in fact a situation totally caused by the victim's own oversight isn't justified...again?
Are you an Attorney or something close?
Becoming a daily occurrence here on reddit lately.
The comments most definitely weren't buried when I arrived. All the hurtful comments were near the top and any remarks about the picture being cute were near the bottom.
She definitely didn't intend to post it to the same account as her GoneWild pictures. I thought it was a bit insensitive to point this out publicly instead of warning her in a private message. It's easy to do this kind of thing by accident.
Do you sort by newest or best?
And as for using the same account for GW vs Bird picture... I will go ahead and believe that you know she didn't mean to, and it's too bad a white night didn't come to her rescue, but that's hardly the same level as what you are talking about in the title to this thread.
...
O'Rly?
I don't wanna sound like an insensitive douche, but this is almost entirely her fault. By what I've read it seems she didn't want to be recognized for her GW pics, I get it was a mistake, but some other redditor doesn't need to take precautions for someone else. If she didn't want to be recognized for her GW pics, she should have been more careful, or not posted them at all, not saying i wouldn't have enjoyed 'em cause she looks very cute.
Oh no, some people said some horrible stuff. Why can't everyone be nice and flowers.
Exactly. There's one negative comment in that thread that isn't completely buried (because it happened to be a reply to a more popular comment) and it's sitting at -56; -57 since I found it.
Indeed. The comments were what you'd expect from a pic of a tiny bird sitting on your boobs while doing the "I'm too sexy to smile with both sides of my mouth look" in the same account as your hobby porn posts.
The most inciteful comment was from a guy who has -903 comment karma and an award for it. Clearly, he hasn't been anywhere near the top at any point and isn't representative for any of this.
What is the problem with posting nude pics and then later a clothed pic in a different subreddit? I'm not getting the argument.
insightful
*spelling hint rather than analysis
This! If I were you, I'd repost this as a standalone comment, so it can be the first thing people see (at least if they have comments sorted that way). The attempt at white-knightdom is... commendable, but misplaced.
Why is it men pretend to like naked pictures, buy magazines with pictures of naked women in them, but on the internet (and probably RL) have nothing but contempt for any woman who poses nude.
Ya'll are such hypocrites.
allie, that is a hurtful generalization. And unless you stop your bullying, all those men are going to delete their accounts and run away from reddit... for about a week or two.
You understood this situation and presented a clear explanation. Have an upvote!
So this post is embarrassing her further by drawing attention to the fact that we can see naked pictures of her. Way to go blackwolf72, you internet white knight you.
Touché
link to pics?
The problem is that there are creepers who go looking through someone's history when they find out they are a girl.
On the off chance that girl has posted naked pictures of herself on reddit? Looks like their approach is working pretty well.
Honestly, though, we can. I don't know when all the inappropriate comments were downvoted, but they were, a lot. As a group, it appears redditors were in favor of whatshername and against the obvious trolls that called her fat. The problem is that, though reddit gives the silent majority a voice through voting, people don't listen to the voting. People listen to whoever speaks up. What we need to do, as a community, is do what we've been doing. We just need to upvote good content and downvote bad content. What individual posters need to do is remember to take every comment with a grain of salt and realize the top voted comments are the ones people generally agree with.
Wow, okay, I didn't expect my little comment to make it to the Reddit front page. I still maintain what I said. I clicked the article expecting positive comments and was shocked to discover that people were putting this woman down. Thus my fit of justified rage.
Heaven forbid people don't agree with you! Wait, am I offending you now? I'm awfully sorry! Please don't get upset!
Yea, you're cool in my book.
OMG! People were saying negative things? On the internet?!
Why is your rage "justified"?
What's wrong with calling this woman fat or even ugly? You can try and argue against her obesity with BMI, but beauty is definitely in the eye of the beholder.
Seriously, since when are women somehow immune from some cold and hard realities? Her boyfriend sure as hell doesn't seem to care about her health or well-being.
Top voted comments like meme and sex jokes?
This. 1000x this. To be honest I thought she was pretty cute, but yeah, bad form reddit on the "outing" where you made her feel uncomfortable. If she blurred her face out on GW it was because she didnt want it associated with her naked pics... so pointing it out and associating it for her was reaaaaaaaaaal smooth guys.
Unfortunately, the people who commented on the previous post aren't likely to click on this one.
What? But reddit is full of nice guys who would never treat a girl wrong! Lewl.
Well, everybody knows that the bird is the word.
You are doing it wrong. I got plenty of nice things.
Plus she dug me. I could tell by the way she phrased her posts. I was that close...
[deleted]
http://shitmykidsruined.com/
Gross.
I just don't understand how these things work.
I was gonna say that too! so I second yours
How idiot boys treat ladies on the Internet.
You guys know that ladies are pretty rad, right?
No reddit only knows ladies are evil stereotypes that only fall for alpha-males and assholes. We ladies are ALL the same. Damn us.
Tits or GTFO.
Now I'm a feminist for upvoting. >.< Dammit! I'll never learn...
To be fair though the only women I seem to be able to attract are all the same. That is to say every single girl I've been with has cheated on me and then lied when I found out.
..then you're looking in the wrong places.
I can only talk for myself and not for others. But i never cheated.
I know there are a lot of evil girls out there. Same goes for boys. Afterall they are both human.
However, don't prejustice.
Simple answer: cheat on her first.
move to colombia
Fcuking attention whore...
/sarcasm
Well, you do fall for alpha-males and assholes. You're chix, after all. But don't get too twisted up about it; dudes fall for vapidity and crinkled noses.
The real problem here is one of lack of sex. I've found that almost without exception, the only people who are truly interested in ruining anything at all concerning (or having to do with) the sexuality of another person is doing so because they're not fucking anyone.
It's too bad the bird-chick went down because a bunch of sexless shitbags decided to take their lack of promiscuity out on her, by implying promiscuity. Apes, that's what they are.
Hey, I'll have you know that some of us sexless shitbags don't try to ruin other people's fun!
Implying promiscuity? She was fat and definitely not getting laid. Fat pics aren't porn, they're banned material in my neck of the woods.
Oh, god damn it. You just co-opted a stereotype yourself. Don't auto-fail when trying to act indignant.
Why the fuck are you on the internet and not in a kitchen?
Hello father.
Hello mother.
You are, though.
Thought i was on 4chan for a minute there.
You might as well be. Reddit is 4chan with (laughable) pretensions to intellectualism. In fact, few internet communities are as closed-minded and anti-intellectual as this sewer of totalitarian thought. You people, redditors, are not as far removed as you’d like to imagine from the mouthbreathers you despise—and I think you dimly realize this, given your loud obsession with distinguishing yourselves from Sarah Palin and her ilk. This is called the “narcissism of small differences.”
You sound like a fair and unbiased reviewer, reddit_sux :)
and then they go to r/relationshipadvice and ask why girls don't like them
Alternatively:
(fuck off, I'm not showing you my tits)
WHY ARE ALL WOMEN SUCH BITCHES?!
Yeah, of course. Thanks, I forgot that side of it too.
Lose-lose.
Well, you go to a bar trying to trick a lady into sleeping with you. Even though you want her to doesn't mean you will respect her for it.
I do?
I've never "tricked" a lady into sleeping with me. Depending on the situation, that's either douchey or rape. What the hell? Does anyone have healthy boundaries and expectations here?
I'm sure you were 100% honest with alll of them.
I'm afraid you're not living up to your name. We are disappoint.
trying to trick a lady into sleeping with you
You're doing it wrong.
Good going, boys, you let slip one of the good ones. But on the other side of things...
Girls, if you post revealing or suggestive pictures of yourself, you are intentionally objectifying your image to gain approval. You shouldn't be surprised when a bunch of anonymous pigs don't treat you like a person. It amazes me how many girls still don't realize that.
That doesn't excuse said pigs.
No, but it's like being a black man knowingly walking into a KKK Convention, you would be more than a little naive to think nothing would happen.
So, reddit is like a KKK convention? Really, shouldn't we hold ourselves to just a tad higher standards?
[deleted]
No, not at all. Unless advertising, media, music, movies, video game characters, all encouraged black men going to Klan rallies in the way they create norms around female sexuality.
what if he's walking in there with a blowtorch?
Not in any way does it excuse them. All I'm saying is that a female posting nude pictures to an internet community comprised primarily of 16-25 year old males should expect a wealth of varied responses. It's not anyone's fault so much as it is just a sad state of affairs. This, to me, is the same as drunk college boys groping cocktail waitresses at a bar.
STEP 1: POST TITS ON INTERWEBNETS.
STEP 2: GET UPSET WHEN NOT RECEIVED AS INITIALLY INTENDED.
STEP 3: ???
STEP 4: PROFIT.
Too bad for you white knights who've never seen a pussy in real life, the difference is we aren't going to up and leave because we got all butthurt over some limpdicks calling us "pigs" or "assholes."
[deleted]
You don't need to leave. Hopefully, you'll just have your comments downvoted when you're acting like a pig or an asshole. :) It's cool. Eventually you'll turn 14 and be a big boy.
Right. And it's that girl's fault for getting raped because her clothes were too tight.
I think we've heard that argument before.
Exactly.
I called them pigs. They are pigs. You get dirty if you play with pigs.
What? So if you're a girl you can't be nude in a photo without being a whore? I can appreciate the human body without objectifying it, it's your fault if you can't. And yes, I realize that most men can't, that doesn't make it right or fair.
These things are usually defined by what most people think. It isn't like a math equation with a right and wrong answer. It's subjective.
I don't think so. You can argue, philosophically, that the governing body sets the laws, but that doesn't have anything over natural law. You're born naked and there's nothing you or any governing body can do to prevent that. The Earth wasn't flat simply because people believed it and perceived it to be so, it was still round.
As for whether it's appropriate or not to be nude, that's a whole other argument; one that sadly, here in America at least, the nudists would lose.
And as for whether or not it's right or wrong to objectify women, that's not what I'm arguing, only that it's more pathetic than it is not pathetic, and it's certainly unfair and oppressive to us all to condemn our natural states, regardless of how many goatses or "fat rolls" are factored in. You can argue otherwise, but until someone births a fully-clothed child with high cheek bones and a slender figure, I won't be giving any credence to the idea that we're justified, as men, to objectify women and hold them to a particular standard as long as everyone else is doing it.
So you're saying you have the ability to know a person based on their nude photos? If I show you 50 nude photos of a woman would you know what food she likes? How about how she likes to dress? Does she have a college degree?
And how are 50 clothed photos going to tell me what food someone likes or whether they hold a college degree? I don't understand how this means nude photos of a woman are inherently immoral and objectifying.
Say what? Who said that?
If that object in the nude photo later suggests that it likes pickles on its grilled cheese sandwiches you shouldn't get surprised, nor should you tell it that it's wrong.. You'd pictured it eating strawberries with whipped cream (while feeding them to you) only.
We won't know unless we try!
No, you are posting your image for some reason. You are neither "objectifying your image" (?) by posting it nor do you know if it was done for approval.
Really?
[deleted]
By simply posting you have, by your own definition, shown you are a whore for attention.
[deleted]
This is a bullshit argument. This is equivalent of the "she was asking to get raped -- her clothes were too tight" kind of argument.
You can't blame the behavior of reddit assholes on the person who posted the nudie pics. That is entirely unfair. Reddit is all too good at witch hunts. They have proven this again and again.
[deleted]
What has the first part of that sentence to do with the second part? How does "putting yourself on display" imply that you will not be treated as a human?
How did the Disney Channel come into this? O and by the way, they're setting really good examples so far: Brittany Spears (no examples needed for her), Lindsay Lohan (again), and Miley Cyrus (the 16-year-old who was dancing on a pole in booty shorts at a very big awards ceremony). Ok yeah, they sure are warning girls pretty well and especially by example.....
WTF? Why, every time someone is made out to be a douchebag, are they referred to as ugly and/or fat? There is no correlation between being ugly/fat and being a douchebag. You are horrible people.
Yeah, most people here are simply hiding behind a veil of pseudo-intellectualism that they feel was bestowed upon them after they got beat-up for being a nerd in the 6th grade. Oh shit there I go stereotyping...
even more so considering so many of us have faced social ostracization in the past.
Although this is a new account, I've been at reddit since near the beginning (back when paul graham dominated 8 of the top 10 posts of the day). The type of people who post here has changed a lot. The crowd has gotten younger, more aggressive, and generally more annoying. There is also a 4chan element at this place that has done nothing but drag down post and comment quality.
This explains the viciousness that permeates this place now. It's almost more trouble than it's worth to be a contributor here.
Upvoted, seems like 4chan culture is overflowing onto reddit.
4chan culture is fine as long as it stays on 4chan. I do not want to see Reddit, Fark, etc, degenerate into calling women cumdumpsters and everyone posting their possibly-underage girlfriends naked.
This is exactly what I thought when I read the OP.
Cool, let's call their significant others ugly and fat because we don't like that they called this girl ugly and fat! Rock on!
Or they will continue to objectify woman and have an ample supply of woman who do not know they can do better due to a corrupt upbringing teaching them to follow what they are told by men...
Just my two cents, I've seen it enough times sadly. People will do anything to not be alone ;(
My boyfriend always jokes "treat a girl like dirt and she'll stick to you like mud." Too bad this isn't a joke for most people.
Edit: spelling. I really should only type comments on my computer and not on my iPhone.
Maybe, but she's gone now, so it didn't work with her.
There are three types of guys in the world, and two of those are generally on Reddit.
The guy who has plenty of confidence and gets girls he wants with ease, doesn't spend time on Reddit. (There's a very small percent of Redditors who are this way of course).
The nice guys who spent most of their RL time being the friend to an unappreciative girl who used them for emotional support but never gave anything back.
The guy who is convinced that guy #1 gets the guys by being a dick to everyone, and thus they need to 'out-dick' him in order to be competitive with him.
EDIT: It seems like certain people who don't like this post are going through and downvoting other comments of mine, and posters who have come out and admitted their own experiences. Please be mature and keep the reddiquette in mind, thank you.
.4. Guys who have merely adequate amounts of confidence, yet still have sex with women.
.5. Guys who just want to read the paper and could give a fuck.
.6. Gay guys.
.7. Guys who don't have it all figured out, yet are okay with that.
.8. 350 other types of individuals that don't quite fit any attempts at categorization.
I'm ALL about #5 over here. #7 too.
Obviously infinite categorization defeats the prediction benefits of modelling, and that's all this is, a MODEL. You're right, everything is different, but the whole point of identifying categorize and patterns is so that you can define a set of rules which may model consequence to some degree. These categories don't work 100%, and I never advertised them as doing so, but alas it doesn't matter; these models will help some people and others will simply ignore them, but I hardly believe aspiring to confidence will harm anyone.
Wait, you put periods before the numbers?
you mean girls?
Damn, I knew I would mess something up.
I've been guy #2 for a while, at least the last few relationships, but I'm working toward becoming guy #1, if only to find that one special lady.
That was a good summary, btw.
Upvoted for being generalizing and reductive but actually kind of true. These aren't the ONLY kinds of guys in the world (I used to be #2 but I don't fall into any of these categories now), but they ARE three distinct male roles that guys often play.
Hope Reddit sucks it up and acknowledges this by NOT downvoting it.
Haha I guess it is a bit short sighted; would you mind explaining your category?
Right, cause being fat = ugly, ugly = bad, and being unwilling to perform oral sex makes a woman valueless. You too are a horrible person and your prejudices are as bad as theirs.
Being fat and ugly is bad. Are we now being SO incredibly PC that we have to pretend that there's nothing wrong with it?
Being fat is unfortunate because it's unhealthy but since it's not something people choose it's not "bad". Lots of smart, nice people are fat. Being ugly is also unchosen and some very nice people are ugly. Both are superficial categories that only show your own mindless prejudices.
Being fat is not something that people choose? I'm no scientist, but I've heard that some nutritionists have this theory that there is a correlation between being overweight, and eating too much food, and undertaking taking too little physical activity.
Also: its quite obvious socially that being fat and ugly is much worse than being slim and attractive, its a bad thing to be. Social factors count alllie, all the time, not just when its convenient for you.
http://captionsearch.com/pix/vaib62pyrx.jpg pic related
So true!
If you read this, CurveGirl, please don't be offended or hurt by the things some "people" have said. There are some real pieces of shit out there, unfortunately. Please don't leave Reddit forever because this really is a great website most of the time! For all the asshole, piece of shit, no life trolls on Reddit, there are thousands of good and nice Redditors. :) Hope you read this! xo
WHITE KNIGHT!!!!!
Who are you looking at? Not me. Not 1000s of other redditors either.
To clear a couple of things up:
YOU are what's wrong with the internet. "A woman is willing to post naked pictures of herself hooray". What the hell is wrong with you?
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
You're sort of wrong, girls tend to gravitate towards abuse. That said, not all girls, clearly. And reddit has been abusive for some time now. Legitimate comments get buried, sometimes the posters get burned because the group-think is rampant here, just like anywhere else.
The reddit community likes to think they're not evolved apes, that they have extra chromosomes that make them reasonable, enlightened atheistic scientists, but the reality is that they're just dumb apes. Me, you, and everyone else. Reddiquette is a lie.
One of the primary reasons I love the Reddit community is because it's one of the few remaining sites on the internet where you can post without the risk of being flamed for your opinion or being driven off the site. I even said to a friend earlier: "...it's like someone took the entire internet community and ran it through a strainer to sort out the idiots and flaming". I am disappoint.
At the end of the day nobody gives a shit.
This just in: Reddit is a site accessible world-wide, where there are many people with many different points of view.
Which is dumber.... a handful of people with badly thought out points of view, or tarring the entire website's contributors with the same brush?
I can't really say more than this. She looks like a nice girl too. Reddit, I'm disappointed. :(
Soon the only women left on the Internet will be men.
Can't we do a witch hunt on the people who did the witch hunt and drive them out as well?
The hunters have become the hunted.
This couldn't possibly back fire.
shes not hot stop being a white knight
You do realize that you're falling to the level of the people you're insulting right? Anyone who posts a picture of themselves on a site where users can remain completely anonymous is in for a well-needed reality check.
i bet they got here from digg
edit: and 4chan
WHO THE FUCK CARES THAT 1 PERSON GOT SCARED OFF. IF THIS WAS A MAN WHO RECEIVED THE SAME ATTENTION NO ONE WOULD GIVE A SHIT SO WE SHOULDN'T FUCKING GIVE A SHIT NOW.
Let's all show human CONCERN for REVERAND MOON's legal difficulties!!
Are you that starved to see naked woman that your gonna sympathasize with some fat loser. If your ugly I don't want to see naked pictures of you. Your calling everyone else virgins when to me its obvious that your a virgin. Stop making this into a tragedy she was fat, she was ugly, your a fag
Whatever, the stupid whore posted nude pictures of herself online, that's insanely dumb and the bitch got what she deserved.
You say that as if it were a threat as opposed to a given.
Should have stayed in the kitchen.
I can find naked girls anytime I want on the internet. Girl was an attention whore, end of story.
Ugly and fat, kind of like the girl referred to in the original post?
Considering she's at least confident enough to post her pics openly, I find her beautiful...confidence is beauty, belittling someone via the internet is ugly.
More like your mom, asshole