Curious question about using impact driver to remove drain plugs.

Been working on cars for nearly 16 years now, primarily just my own vehicles out of my garage as a shade tree mechanic and was curious about one thing. Are there any negatives or drawbacks to using an impact driver to remove drain plugs? I've owned a few vehicles that utilized a stubborn hex bit as a drain plug and always felt like I was on the verge of stripping the plug even using a long wrench for leverage. I've always torqued my drain and fill plugs to factory specs but sometimes they're stubborn when it comes time to remove them. My Tacoma has a very shallow rear diff drain plug and unless you're dead center with your socket, you can easily round the edges off. The drain plug for the front diff on my FJ Cruiser is a 10mm hex bolt and that too can be a pain in the ass to remove without feeling as though you're going to strip the bolt. Obviously I know the dangers of tightening drain and fill plugs with an impact driver but wanted to know if there's any risk of damaging them if you're simply just using the impact driver to break them loose. I have a variety of 3/8" and 1/2" Milwaukee cordless impact drivers and simply want to know if it's a bad idea to try and use any of these the next time I do a fluid change for those pesky drain plugs.

Posted Jul 20, 2019, 12:58 PM UTC · edited

210
GuiltyCloud•

Using an impact makes it more likely to round off the plug. Worst case scenario, you should use a breaker bar and a hammer, and get a new plug.

4
derwreckOP•

Gotcha, that's usually been my go-to with pesky diff plugs. I've had to replace the drain plug on my Tacoma's rear diff 3x because of how shallow the bolt is, doesn't leave much "depth" for the socket to fully bite into. When I was adding additional d-rings to my Tacoma's bed bolts, there were two bolts that were completely SEIZED and would not budge even with a foot long breaker bar. The T55 Torx bit actually began to strip the inside of the bolt. I ended up attacking the two bolts with my big ass Milwaukee impact driver and it broke both bolts loose within a second. Made me wonder if I would have achieved the same result when I had trouble breaking loose the 10mm hex bit for the front diff drain plug. Then again, the two bolts had a fair amount of rust that was preventing them from breaking loose, hence the hammer action from the impact driver coming in handy.

1
impiouspunk•

I’ve never had an issue with drain plugs but YMMV. If they are torqued correctly they usually break free fairly easy. I’ve now moved over to Fumoto drain plugs to lessen the burden on removing the drain plug itself. Highly recommend!

1
derwreckOP•

I actually have Fumoto valves on both the FJ and Tacoma, this is mostly in regards to the drain plugs that are on the front and rear diffs of both vehicles. The oil change intervals for both are around the 30k mark so they tend to seize a little more than an engine oil drain plug would.

2
impiouspunk•

Makes sense and a little out of my realm of experience as I daily a Mazda 3.

1
AKADriver•

If anything I don't use power tools on drain plugs because I don't want my impact wrench covered in hot motor oil when the plug spins out.

I've never had one too tight to break free with a 24" breaker bar.

1
alanbryant156•

Using a 6 point socket instead of a 12 point helps reduce rounding the corners of the plug.

1
derwreckOP•

I don't think I own any 12 point sockets in my tool arsenal, everything I have is 6 point but I get what you mean. I learned that lesson the hard way when I first started working on cars and all I had was a cheap toolset from Wal-Mart that had nothing but 12 point sockets and stripped the hell out of my old Ford Ranger's bed bolt.

1
SmoresRoll•

You dont own any 12pt sockets? Head bolts are mostly 12 point sockets.

1
derwreckOP•

Head work is a little out of my league so no need, most in depth thing I've done was swap out a transmission on a buddy's Silverado with both of us tackling the task together.

1