[META] An update on post spamming.

I really like to see a lot of new posts. It's good to see that our community has that much activity. But recently there's been an uptick in karma farmers, people who post over half a dozen questions in a short amount of time in order to get high numbers for whatever reason. That needs to stop, but people banned for it have just been making new accounts to get around it.

So, to combat this, we're taking two measures. The first measure is going to be to adjust the automoderator bot to disallow posts from anyone with an account less than 2 weeks old (Up for negotiation, see this post if you have feelings on the minimum age requirements.) The second measure will be getting a bot to limit all users to only three posts a day. That's posts, not comments.

These changes will be rolled out over this weekend and there may be some hiccups. If you're inconvenienced by this, please bear with it, the kinks should be worked out before the weekend is up.

Posted Sep 14, 2019, 2:26 PM UTC · edited

11434
Winged_Gunsknecht•

Thank you for this change. Not too often it happens, but it annoys me greatly when it does. 3 posts on the rapid are when i get annoyed, but it seems like a good limit anyway.

Those who spampost seem to mostly post short, easily answerable questions who doesn't cause any interesting answers or discussion anyway, so good riddance.

34
garbagephoenixOPMOD•

I was mentioning in another recent post that people tended to get more karma for interesting questions anyway. Provide good content, get good results. Provide empty content, get empty results.

11
trai_dep•

Honestly, three posts a day seems high. I'd rather have people put the extra work into posting one quality post a day, including well-written and thought-provoking body text, for three days. Fewer one-line introductions – if they're asking us to put in mental energy to comment for them, then they need to step up and do the work of creating an interesting and specific scenario.

Plus, if their second or third "amazing" idea that they want to post on a Monday is that awesome, then they'll remember it Tuesday or Wednesday.

Finally, it might make them think, "Has anyone asked this before?" and use the search function. If I see another post wondering if Thanos would be more or less powerful if he possessed the One Ring from LOTR, I'm going to go on a rampage and extinguish half the life in the whole universe.

Bonus Pro-Tip For The Newbies: after my first week here, I had the bright idea to search on the keywords. ("Duh!", I'm sure half of you are saying. ;)) But I found really great conversations for slightly more obscure fantasy, like The Endless, American Gods and other Gaiman goodness. Give it a try!)

18
Nihilikara•

I often forget to flare my posts, so when they inevitably get removed, I need to be able to try again that day.

8
icecoldtoaster•

I personally like seeing a lot of posts. If someone watches something new, say The Boys which is fairly topical, i dont mind at if they post 3 separate questions about said content. Thats fun for me. Just my two cents

7
Winged_Gunsknecht•

But why make it seperate posts, instead of a single one containing several questions? I'd rather have a bunch of different topics, than a lot of posts about the same.

4
justsomeguy_youknowTotal ☠☠☠☠•

I would too but sometimes you think of a question later, or sometimes discussion about one question brings up another question which may warrant its own post because it's not really related to the original question and/or it takes focus away from the original question. Or maybe some other reason.

I don't think a three post limit will change much. I browse by new and it's been my experience that for the most part it's rare to see the same user start more than a thread or two a day. Then again I'm not here every day so it's possible that the mods are on top of it and are getting to it before I see it, so I could be entirely wrong.

2
DukeboxHiro•

Agreed.

2
CoolandAverageGuy•

thinks of the best post ever and waits until Tuesday to post it

gets hit by a truck and dies on Monday night

1
katsumii•

I think the Three Posts A Day rule is the only rule needed, but personally I don't have to worry about either one.

I do think it's an interesting sub, and any curious newbies who find this sub might be turned off if they can't post their question.

But. Can you at least set a friendly message when blocking the newbs from posting? Something that maybe apologizes the inconvenience and maybe also offers browsing the sub until their account is 2 weeks old?

Like, “Hey, it looks like you're new here. We require accounts to be at least 2 weeks old before posting, but we'd love it if you hold on to your question, and browse around or use the search bar until then! ” idk?

3
garbagephoenixOPMOD•

The message was in the cards already, don't worry.

3
ProfessorUberRepublic Loyalist•

Those both sound reasonable measures.

3
JollyRabbit•

I'm going to weigh in as a regular contributor. While I'm generally concerned with any new rules would stifle creativity, this seems fine to me, though as some others have said I would suggest one week instead of two.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Windigo654•

I'm sick of the bots and being hit by them it's constant i can't get a perfectly reasonable suggestion or opinion out without being attacked by them... SORT IT REDDIT! i'm having to block one after the other and it's any wonder other sites don't have a Down Vote button when they Down Vote your Comments for no damn reason and only encourage discourse, and because they Down Vote all Comments they hit it never gets seen by others, i didn't do or say nothing wrong and BOOM hit by them out of nowhere as soon as they see more activity from me.

-1
garbagephoenixOP•

But what are your thoughts on yaoi?

3
Qetuowryipzcbmxvn•

Two weeks seems excessive. If this were a community focused on a specific subject/media then that would make a bit more sense, but we've got more in common with r/Showerthoughts where we'll have people that have a non-essential but compelling question come to mind and might look for places to get answers. Personally I'd go for a day, but a week would definitely have the same effect and be much more accessible.

-2†
garbagephoenixOPMOD•

I felt like two weeks was a nice number, considering that I didn't think many people would make an account just to post here.

Does anyone else have a thought on this? I'm open to adjustments, though I probably wouldn't go down for younger than a week.

13
Qetuowryipzcbmxvn•

It's been a couple months since I made a new account, but r/AskScienceFiction was one of the recommended subs based on other subs I chose to subscribe to. If Reddit still uses that feature, then new users may want to participate and contribute on finding a sub that satisfies their interest. A week is usually enough deterrent for most trolls (because if they can wait a week then they can wait two) without being too big a deterrent for potential contributors.

4
LibraryLassWearing the mommy pants•

I think a week would be sufficient to weed out most of the spambots. Maybe less, even.

3
ZacPensol•

I'm generally against age banning because there are circumstances where an account may be new for legitimate reasons - maybe the person has been a lurker, maybe they want to create an alt account to ask an embarrassing question they don't want associated with their main? I don't think those reasons should make someone unwelcome.

However, I would consider reducing the allowed posts-per-day to just one. Perhaps I'm not seeing why it would be reasonable for a person to post more than one new post a day, but to me even 3 seems excessive. If the post-per-day allowance were set to one, then people who want to repeat would have to go through a lot of trouble just to keep creating new accounts/logging in to alts, and it would spread out their karma if that's what they're wanting, and I think that would dissuade them from posting too much.

3
Winged_Gunsknecht•

I agree with making it shorter, he makes a good argument.

making it a week sounds better. Can always adjust it up if it doesn't have the effect you hope for, instead of having it uneccessarily high and leaving it so, potentially hurting the influx of new contributors.

2
DannyTheBrick•

For what it's worth, I may have created an account just to post here.

I think the restrictions are sensible, but I also think they run counter to my initial experience with the sub. For me, on first discovering the sub, it felt like an opportunity to unload all of those questions I've had--which can easily lead to what seems like karma farming. That said, I was pretty shy (and actually still tend to be), so focus mostly on responding (and looking for people who asked similar questions) rather than posting--but I can understand the urge to just go for it and ask everything.

That said, by in large I support the restrictions, but would advocate for a shorter time as well. I'm willing (although, this of course depends on the mods overall) to endure a few karma farmers if that allows some genuinely curious people in; and I think the 3-post limit actually reduces some of the major downsides of those karma farmers.

2
Sarlax•

I think two weeks make sense. This sub is best when posters grok the sub. I assume posts from new users are more likely to skirt the edges of the rules or break them. I like the idea of users having a getting-to-know-us period.

1
Windigo654•

I feel like the only thing it will do s slow them down... it won't stop them... they'll just wait out the 2 weeks then start Spamming again, we've seen from Twitter and Facebook what happens and Facebook locks your new account for up to 5 days to Authenticate it using a photo you've uploaded to your account but there's still crazy accounts that Spam and bots that Troll everybody especially on YouTube. I dunno what else you could do though because if you block using IP Address people take advantage of that too and just start reporting people for no reason.

-1
ShittyRedditMods•

Hi, got 1 hypothesis and one question here

1: Maybe people posting a lot of posts in one sitting are doing so because they think of questions while they are at school or at work and then when they get online they just ask them all. Maybe it's not all to karma farm or spam.

2: I got a few days old account because I my old one risked getting doxed so I deleted it, however I posted questions here that got a lot of points and I like posting here a lot. If people with new account, real legit new accounts, try to ask a question will they be allowed to message the mods for approval or will you block ALL posts from accounts that are not 2 weeks or older.

Thanks

-3
garbagephoenixOPMOD•
  1. In that instance, we'd much rather people consolidate their questions. If you've got five burning questions about Batman, one about Star Wars, and one about Star Trek, you can include all of the Batman questions in the text portion of the post and then ask your other two topics freely. Or you can include all of them into one post and tag each canon in the title, but I understand why people wouldn't want to do that.

  2. I feel like, with your hypothetical real, legit new account has an honest question, then yes. They could message the mods for approval and we'd allow it. This is purely to discourage the "[The Dark Knight] How did Harvey Dent die?"-tier farmers who aren't likely to take that extra step.

9
LibraryLassMODWearing the mommy pants•

Let's make sure we have part 2 there clearly indicated somewhere so newbies will know they can come to us.

3
garbagephoenixOPMOD•

When we're doing up the automod thing we can add that into the post body.

3
trai_dep•

Another point worth noting is that if there are fewer active posts by a contributor, they'll be more likely to be engaged with their posts. I've seen some mediocre questions turn into decent conversations once the OP comments more about what they meant.

Plus, their being engaged in their active question is a good analog for whether they're karma-farming, or if they're genuinely interested in their query.

3
ShittyRedditMods•

1: Yeah if you look up my post history (you don't HAVE to lol) you'll notice I already do that and it seems to work fine as people can answer one or all parts of the question. Good Idea.

2: Yeah I see some of these "spam" posts sometimes, I guess it's mostly new subscribers getting used to the environment. I personally don't mind them as we can all just scroll past but I guess it makes it a bit harder and time consuming to have to go through them all while moderating.

1
Winged_Gunsknecht•

for 1, i don't really see how that makes it any less spam. posting tons of short questions is spam, regardless of the intent.
It is just lazy to post whatever comes to their mind. they could instead write down the questions elsewhere, filter out the stuff they can just google, and post the actually interesting questions.

2
DannyTheBrick•

filter out the stuff they can just google

I was always curious about the mods perspective on this. One the one hand, some questions are easily answerable by Google and seem to just clutter the board. On the other, many of the easily searchable answers are very explicitly under the remit of this sub and it seems like a reasonable place to find them. In many cases some questions that appear 'easy' to answer end up being more nuanced than perhaps one might get from a Google search.

2
Winged_Gunsknecht•

Yeah, what questions are suited for the sub got no clear answer. Well, might not be a clear answer, but IMO one thing is sure: The shotgun approach to posting is not is :P

1