Response to the Open Letter

Topps text

Hey SWCT fans,

I wanted to take this time on Triple Force Friday to reach out to you all (I know I've missed it by a few hours, but we do what we can) and address a few of the concerns that have been voiced as of late.

This post is in response to the open letter posted by u/Lefeyette and some of the concerns expressed in ensuing comments. Please see the original posts here: [An Open Letter to u/Topps_Admin](https://www.reddit.com/r/starwarstrader/comments/d5gpvm/an_open_letter_to_utopps_admin/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x)

A follow-up to the open letter - ideas...

Thank you to u/Lefeyette, u/Limi-Mercer, u/mzrebekah, u/ribors, u/mdjacobus, u/acthedestroyer, u/tedsallis, u/matty1138, u/piggle213, u/tangentJB, and everyone else that has taken the time to provide us feedback in one form or another.

First, before we dive into addressing the concerns mentioned, I would like to apologize for the delayed response. The amount of feedback provided in the above posts and in other forums has been extensive. In order to speak honestly and openly about the concerns listed below, several discussions had to be had before I formulated the below reply. Thank you for your patience and understanding.

Concerns:

  • Set Accessibility: Being able to access Sets and/or variants that hold trade value is extremely important. This allows new and existing users to not only take part in the pack purchasing experience but also to take part in trades. Returning a few daily chase sets will give users a chance to chase different types of content and allow different types of users to collect them.
    • This is a major concern for us as we want to meaningfully engage our entire userbase with our releases. We know that this means that users that do not pay for currency need access to more exclusive and limited content, in order to have a healthier community balance. A benchmark we want to aim for is being able to chase a full set with a week's worth of Credits. We are also looking into bringing back a few Daily Chases, which give Credit users a more sustainable and attainable collection opportunity.
    • The current state of affairs places large expectations on the team and as we work toward the future of SWCT we have to keep in mind that more premium content is inevitably going to be a required part of that puzzle. But, user access and engagement are extremely important and we are cognizant of the balance we have to strike between monetization and accessibility.
    • This balance is not as easy as the flip of a switch, but we will continue to work toward this balance and opening up releases to a wider variety of users. With that said, we look forward to working together and continuing to have an open dialogue about our content, releases, and the future of SWCT, so please don't hesitate to continue sharing your thoughts!
  • Premium Set Length and Consistency: It's hard to know exactly what you're getting into when you decide to chase some of the longer more involved premium sets, and trying to collect these types of releases consistently can be grueling.
    • This is a consistent concern and one that users have mentioned on several occasions. We want to work toward a better-defined Set and Wave structure which we hope will allow you to collect with confidence. With this in mind, we will be looking to switch up longer-term collection sets with different content and new sets which will allow us to release a wider variety of collectibles. This will also allow us to have a defined Set and Wave length for each iteration.
  • Meditation Chamber Resurrection: This legendary card has been left out of packs for too long and is an example of a fun and engaging collectible which will allow every pack open to having a long shot at a supremely rare collectible.
    • The team loves this type of collectible and we will be adding it back to most packs in the store. Please stay tuned for additional announcements.
  • Box Drops & Larger Releases: The constant grind of long term sets can be exhausting, it would be great if we could break things up and get larger drops of collectibles here and there.
    • We have started moving this direction as we know the constant demands of daily/longterm premium drops can have large downsides. We know this is not something that we want to over-do, but it is a good mechanism for getting larger user engagement rates and one we need to leverage more effectively.
  • "First to Collect" Awards: It seems like the "First to Collect" (24/48/72 hour) Awards are having a negative effect on Set completion rates. Some Sets may benefit from a more streamlined Set Award structure as well.
    • We will look into this, however, we do like to recognize users that take it upon themselves to complete collections quickly, and this is currently our best tool to do so. With that said, we understand that this sometimes overcomplicates things and can lead to a lowered value of the general Awards which can drive down engagement once the "early bird" award has gone out. We'll continue to evaluate this piece of sets and make adjustments as needed.
  • Image Selection: We have noticed a fair amount of image repetition which is concerning and something we hope can be avoided.
    • Image selection and uniformity can be a difficult beast to handle especially considering the sheer amount of content that has been released in the past, as well as the amount of content, that will be released in the future. With that said we will be making changes to the internal process so we can limit duplication of images.
  • Release Complexity: Releases are often intricate and have several moving pieces that can be confusing for users.
    • We agree there are some releases that are more complex than others, but with that said we have taken steps to improve the communication around these releases to help with cognition and approachability. We have started splitting the technical moving pieces of complex/involved releases into one article, with a more streamlined release announcement article in another. We have taken a look at our Award structures for these sets and have streamlined them a bit, which we hope will help to simplify these releases. We will have additional tools to become available in the coming months, which will help with this effort.
  • Combo Packs: Repackaging of previously released, but unsold out content can lead to some buyer's remorse for users that invested early, not to mention making these collectibles available again changes their previous card count value.
    • While we know that this can be disappointing to see, these collectibles are an important part of our offering to users that may have missed these collectibles during initial release. With that said, we are looking to make distinctions on specific sets in the future which will indicate whether a set will be made available at a later date (if it does not sell out) or if the set will never become available again (example: x card count OR 48 hours) which we hope will help to provide additional security to certain collectibles.
  • Pack Odds: High odds can feel punishing especially when the content is limited or only available for a certain amount of time.
    • We are working to ensure that collectibles are not out of reach for users, with that said some releases will have harder odds than others as this is an important feature of the business, but we will work to improve the value provided to users even if they don't acquire the collectible they are looking for. We will continue to tune how we set odds and make sure that we the needs of users with other interests so that the best experience can be had by all.
  • IAP Bundle Exchange Rates: It seems like the Crystal bundle exchange rates could use some tuning, with higher price points providing a more clear benefit compared with other lower-tier bundles.
    • We have been aware of this and this is a change we want to make to bring us more in-line with industry-standard pricing and improved exchange rates.
  • Functionality Issues: There are several long-standing issues, bugs, and stability concerns that we have. When can we expect a fix for these?
    • As we've announced in-app, there are major improvements being worked on as we speak. With that said there have been a fair amount of voices stating their trepidation with these changes, mainly the look and feel of the Marvel Collect! experience is a sticking point. With that in mind, we have taken great care to craft an experience worthy of you our dedicated Star Wars collectors. The new app will be an homage to this fandom and will contain several improvements to functionality (snappier loading times, fewer bugs, progress tracking, etc.) and enhanced features (Fusion, revamped trading, new Awards system, Set tracking, and more).
    • We understand user reticence with this change, however, it is a change that has to be made for the following reasons:
  1. Updated Technology: The tech and underlying structure behind the current SWCT are based on a much older version of our system, and with that comes major restrictions and roadblocks to making improvements. This is why when we have done updates in the past, more issues have popped up after fixing the initially reported problem. The new app technology allows us to hunt down issues and correct them without breaking other pieces of the app. We know some users may encounter bugs, but the beauty of this system means we will be able to more effectively address them.
  2. Increased Flexibility: With new tech and new supporting infrastructure, we can move from fixing bugs and chasing down phantom problems to building toward the future. New features that help users keep track of their collection, show off their collection, strike up trades and deals, compete with other users and more are all possible with this new system.
  3. Improved Scalability: As we improve the app and as Star Wars enters a new era as a franchise, we will be looking to increase the number of users in the app and encourage new users to join our collecting community. Improvements to UI/UX and new user onboarding has helped us attract and keep new users in for longer. This will help us take Star Wars Card Trader into the future and help this community thrive.

With that said I would like to introduce the Product Manager on SWCT, u/Topps_Grandmoff who is working diligently with our developers to give you the best new Star Wars experience possible.

He will be interacting with you guys and posting updates on the app's progress as well as sharing information about the new app's systems. Please help me in giving him a warm subreddit welcome!

We hope you can see our dedication and time we want to invest in new and interesting content as can be seen in the recent "Build a Card" release. We look forward to your feedback and to building a better, brighter future for SWCT with your help.

I'm sure I've missed something and there is always more to be discussed, so please feel free to share your thoughts below and as always MTFBWY.

- Chuck (Topps_Admin)

Posted Oct 5, 2019, 8:57 AM UTC

3628
Loading comments…