DOCSIS 3.1 Low Latency
Does comcast use this docsis feature?
https://www.cablelabs.com/technologies/low-latency-docsis
Is there some way I can find out before purchasing a DOCSIS 3.1 modem?
Posted Jan 23, 2020, 5:50 AM UTC
Does comcast use this docsis feature?
https://www.cablelabs.com/technologies/low-latency-docsis
Is there some way I can find out before purchasing a DOCSIS 3.1 modem?
Posted Jan 23, 2020, 5:50 AM UTC
The modem won’t fix ping issues from server to server. It’s what equipment the servers are using as well as the path taken to get there. This Can give you a little better information.
What? I'm trying to reduce my last mile latency. What server to server?
Someone found some information about this. LLD isn't available yet. You can close this post.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Comcast_Xfinity/comments/esovij/docsis_31_low_latency/ffe71zy/
[deleted]
[removed]
Your comment in r/Comcast_Xfinity has been removed. We understand that problems and issues can be frustrating to resolve, but we ask that you refrain from using inappropriate language in our community.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
I doubt it since I'm not sure how much good it would do in most cases. I didn't read all the papers on it there but unless they're applying qos to the routing as well I don't see this as being particularly impactful for any reasonable consumer use. If it's just optimizing latency from the CMTS to house, then you can find out your max possible savings by doing a traceroute to your favorite website, and look for the first IP address that isn't your router, and then ping that and see what the latency is to that IP, for me it's 7ms to whatever comcast router that is. If this tech could reduce that latency to 0 that's all it would save me, 7ms, which isn't going to be reasonably noticeable in anything I do. If you have a bad ping to your gaming service, say 200ms, dropping to 193ms isn't going to make it good, and if it's amazing already, say 40ms, dropping to 33ms, while a large % drop, isn't really substantial in a reasonable range of human reaction time.
Yeah I just don't see a big benefit to this.
Why would a 10 ms latency reduction not be helpful?
It’s negligible
10ms to 1ms is a 10x reduction, and that's not negligible. My next hop latency out of my equipment is 10ms average, my buddy's fiber is below 1ms. When you're dealing with real-time traffic like game streaming, this matters. When you're dealing with TCP handshakes or chatty applications or even DNS lookups, this matters. I would take 100Mb/s 1ms connections vs 500Mb/s 10ms connections any day.
It's literally more than half my latency. I've compared it with 8 vs 18 to 19. It's a very noticeable difference in quality and latency.
It is also about jitter. You will be able to download and upload without causing latency spikes in your games.
The feature is still in the development phase.
They've already published the spec. It says so in the first sentence. It's not still in development.
The vendors have not released it yet - they are working on it. Therefore no operators have deployed it at this time. It will make headlines when Comcast deploys it, so you will not miss it.
Is that a guess or do you have a source?
Do you have a DOCSIS 3.1 modem?
It's over half of my latency. My ping to servers in Dallas are 18-19 ms while the ping from those servers to the hop just before me is 8 ms. I could cut my ping from 18-19 down to 9.
This makes a big difference for cloud gaming. I've compared the difference between Comcast and Att fiber. Fiber gets around 8-9 ms and it's much smoother with fewer drops in video quality.
It really doesn’t that’s a very good ping
What really doesn't? Have you ever used cloud gaming?
It doesn’t sounds like your issue is jitter. That’s still quite low latency
Mine is a D3.1 and I'm connected via the OFDM on the downstream.
I don't think this tech, even if used, would help your use case much as it would be difficult to tell the difference between game and movie streaming (which the article specifically calls our as latency tolerant) and there's no way Comcast would allow customers to flag their own traffic as people would just always flag theirs as most important then high priority becomes the new default.
Fiber transport definitely has some amazing speed benefits over electronic routing but can only go so far and is less resilient to failure.
LLD is designed to be marked by the applications running on the customer's computer. Comcast has no saying in that. They can define custom rules, though, to add support for applications that are not aware of it.
Down the road, when L4S is implemented across the internet, all of your traffic will be LLD.
Oh well then the answer to the question is never. No ISP will let customers mark their own traffic because everybody will mark their own as most important, because why wouldn't you, and the priority thing will be utterly useless.