r/xmen•
Cosmogenus

Chris Claremont revealed something about the Dark Phoenix movie that a lot of X-fans don’t realize but is rather obvious in hindsight

Movie/TV discussion

I’ve seen a lot of people say they rushed to make Jean the Dark Phoenix but after recently rereading Uncanny X-Men #100-138 that isn’t really the case.

I’ll start off by saying that I’m sure most people here know that it was planned as a two-parter. But what a lot of people don’t know is that Chris Claremont told Popcorn Talk back in June the title of the films: Phoenix and Dark Phoenix He says first film was to build up Jean’s character and the second film would show her fall from grace.

I think it’s pretty clear that Fox cancelled the sequel and changed the first film’s title from “Phoenix” to “Dark Phoenix”. Because almost everything in that movie is based on the issues before Jean became the Dark Phoenix. It is also heavily inspired by Jean’s origin story shown in Bizarre Adventure #27 and X-Men Origins: Jean Grey as I talked about in another post.

The movie is structured very similarly to the Black Queen arc. Where after the X-Men seemly die Jean becomes grief-stricken and Hellfire Club take advantage of the situation by filling the emotional void within Jean to make her instinctively trust Mastermind so he could mold her into the Black Queen. Jean’s cosmic power was already making her personality wilder and less under control like when a drug removes your inhibitions. Mastermind made this dark side of Jean’s personality grow and consume her, becoming the Dark Phoenix and flies off into space. The rest is history.

The film also has the cosmic power make Jean’s personality wilder and less under control by unleashing repressed anger from her childhood trauma. The death of a X-Man happens(expect it is for real in this version) and like in the comic Jean becomes a grief-stricken. Then the random alien(who were originally the Hellfire Club as shown by concept art) tries to take advantage of the situation and convinces her to embrace the cosmic power that is bringing out the dark side of her personality. Jean becomes consumes by her Phoenix-self and flies off into space.

Before release Simon Kinberg said that Jessica’s character was based on Mastermind and other characters from the storyline. Based on concept art released back in December its safe to say the other character was Emma Frost. Who was going to play the Mastermind role in the original plan for X-Men: The Last Stand. It’s pretty clear that this was a reworked version of “Phoenix” that replaced the Hellfire Club with those random aliens. I’m sure there would have been a subplot involving them getting revenge on Magneto since Shinboi Shaw was shown in the concept art. I bet it was originally them that the X-Men fought in front of the mansion.

I also noticed that in both the comic and the film Jean gives her manipulators what they want: power. Its too much for them to handle.

So despite what the title and the marketing campaign said Jean wasn’t the Dark Phoenix, nor was she was suppose to be. At least not until the very end of the movie. It just seemed like Fox tried to capitalize off the name of a popular storyline but was too cheap to go all the way through with it.

Posted Feb 2, 2020, 6:21 AM UTC · edited

1611
209forlifeMagik•

Wasn’t this the last film on Their contract with the xmen rights? I agree with your Analysis and breakdown but why would they agree to write out a two film project when they only had rights for one more film? Marvel has been dying to get the xmen rights back in house.

11
Jkthemc•

They had no idea at that point that this was the last movie. Events overtook them.

7
ranjur•

As far as I know, they weren't going to lose the contract for X-Men, but 20th Century Fox got bought by Disney, making it de facto their last X-Men film (though New Mutants was already in the works).

2
CrawdadMcCray•

They had the rights in perpetuity as long as they kept making the films within certain gaps of time, they just happened to get bought out. If Disney didn't buy them Fox would still be making X-Men films.

1
Lord_Paramount•

I think if they introduced the Hellfire Club here for the first time it would have been way better than that horrible First Class appearance.

9
EzriusNightcrawler•

There's plenty about the choices they made with the Hellfire Club that could have been way better.

Was January Jones right for Emma Frost? I'm not sure, instead of recasting, let's kill her off-screen between movies. She's not an important or fan-favorite character anyway.

Let's throw Riptide in there because people may not know who Harry Leland or Donald Pierce are. And everyone is familiar with Riptide (and will be able to tell who it is with no mention of his name or why he's in a purple suit, or... just nevermind).

Azazel seems like a good choice. Everyone loves the Draco. Also, he's vaguely appropriate because of the Hellfire Academy storyline that wasn't half a goof or anything. We can maybe even tease something with sweetheart good-girl "Raven" that we'll never follow up on and kill him between movies, as well. But people may recognize the name and it let's us have Nightcrawler without having Nightcrawler!

Perfect FoX-Men logic!

2
Lord_Paramount•

Yep, and to top it all up, Shaw would make a perfect German Nazi who killed Erik's mother because it's not like there's any comic material on him.

2
CosmogenusOP•

That would have been the perfect role for Mister Sinister.

1
CosmogenusOP•

Was January Jones right for Emma Frost? I'm not sure, instead of recasting, let's kill her off-screen between movies. She's not an important or fan-favorite character anyway.

They didn’t really kill her off. Since she was originally going to be the main villain of the film as shown in the concept art. Apparently January Jones was going to reprise her role.

1
Mizerous•

Kevin Bacon was cool

1
Lord_Paramount•

He happened to play one of my favourite characters and unfortunately I really didn't like that version. But from a neutral perspective he was an interesting villain.

6