[-Basics of Mindfulness-]

[removed]

Posted Feb 17, 2020, 1:59 PM UTC · edited

0161
ewk•

RottenCynicist is a ranting religious troll, but he is allergic to simple questions: https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/eik8aa/not_buddhism_not_meditation_or_not_zen/fd08kq3/ He "promised" three Huangbo quotes on sitting meditation, a catechism for "Buddhism", and a list from the BoS Hongzhi poems which are about silent illumination. Here is him failing to keep his word: https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/eik8aa/not_buddhism_not_meditation_or_not_zen/fdc64xr/

People should be aware that Foyan talks about the pitfalls of mindfulness and other kinds of meditation, something the OP is not honest enough to do.

I'll go ahead and report this for the content brigading that it is though... r/meditation clearly doesn't want the OP either... likely because he lies about mindfulness as well.

People who are interested in Zen should study Zen teachings, not some religion brought to the West by these guys: r/zen/wiki/sexpredators .

Study Zen:

https://www.reddit.com/r/zensangha/wiki/ewk/4pillarszen

https://www.reddit.com/r/zensangha/wiki/getstarted

2
RottenCynicistOP•

Who's Foyan? I'd be interested in reading that.

Also, modern science has proven mindfulness is extremely effective.

I'm actually writing you a reply full of empirical data as we speak.

Here's a teaser:

The Effects of Mindfulness Meditation: A Meta-Analysis

Included are 39 studies that fulfilled our six selection criteria: (1) a mindfulness meditation treatment, (2) the existence of an inactive control group, (3) a population of nonclinical adults, (4) the investigation of psychological measures that were (5) assessed at temporal distance from a meditation session, and (6) the availability of sufficient data to calculate effect sizes. The dependent variables examined included, among others, attention, intelligence, self-attributed mindfulness, positive and negative emotions, emotion regulation, personality traits, self-concept, self-realization, stress, and well-being. We found an effect size of r¯¯=0.27 averaged across all studies and dependent variables.

1
ewk•

Here are some examples of studies that examine how dangerous and potentially harmful meditation can be:

1
RottenCynicistOP•

Most of those aren't clinical studies. They also discuss mindfulness in a religious context, as in, it's effects on the ego. I wasn't presenting it for such purposes.

The most potentially damning of those studies relies on subjective moral presumptions that I don't share.

Compare the effects listed in the studies I linked:

The dependent variables examined included, among others, attention, intelligence, self-attributed mindfulness, positive and negative emotions, emotion regulation, personality traits, self-concept, self-realization, stress, and well-being. We found an effect size of r¯¯=0.27 averaged across all studies and dependent variables.

*With the results of studies linked by the blog posts you linked:

For interventions with high number of papers, we performed subgroup analysis and found that cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness-based interventions were effective for both depression and generalized anxiety disorder (GAD),

Our findings suggest that the MSS course maintains wellbeing and engenders resilience to accumulation of stress during the academic year, notably during the summer examination period—our primary outcome. Although the average baseline CORE–OM score of all participants was slightly higher than reported student norms (0·76 score points),

scores for MSS participants at the time of maximum stress (examinations) had fallen towards those norms, whereas scores in the support as usual group indicated increasing distress. The primary outcome results were maintained across intention-to-treat and per-protocol analyses, implying effectiveness, even with only 59% of participants attending at least half the sessions. The moderate effect size translated into about five of 30 students in each group being prevented from indicating distress scores during the examination period at a clinically significant level (a number needed to treat of six). This finding suggests that mindfulness is more effective than other preventive interventions.

Support for meditation is found across academic communities and popular culture. Although the application of meditative practices has yielded positive treatment outcomes, larger purposes of the practice are perhaps lost in the empirically driven West, thus driving a risk of appropriation. In response, the authors outline 4 implications for best practice for counselors who aspire to engage in the culturally responsible use of meditative practices.

I wanna point out that, so far, all the studies linked by the blogs you've linked me actually support mindfulness practice

Self-enhancement was higher in the yoga (Experiment 1) and meditation (Experiment 2) conditions, and those effects were mediated by greater self-centrality. Additionally, greater self-enhancement mediated mind-body practices’ well-being benefits. Evidently, neither yoga nor meditation quiet the ego; instead, they boost self-enhancement.

This is only a negative result if you operate with the presumption that reduction of ego should be the goal, again, I do not operate with that presumption

Researchers also evaluated participants’ well-being using two measures, the satisfaction with life scale and the eudemonic well-being measure, which evaluates satisfaction with autonomy, environmental mastery, personal growth, positive relations with others, purpose in life, and self-acceptance. They found that well-being increased along with self-enhancement, suggesting that self-enhancement is linked with the increased sense of well-being that many get from meditation.  

Oh no! They felt better about themselves and it increased their emotional wellbeing!!! AN OUTRAGE!!!!12

The practice of cultivating present moment awareness, as much of the research on MBSR suggests, has demonstrated therapeutic value for reducing stress and a variety of other symptoms fueled by excessive rumination. Quieting the mind and dispassionately observing the flow of experience is conducive to the deautomization of habitual reactions

Most of your evidence works against your argument, and the way you always manage to do that is incredibly amusing.

As hypothesized, participants in the mindfulness (vs. control) exercise condition showed (i) attenuated repair intentions after having read a scenario in which participants caused harm to a friend (Study 3) and (ii) attenuated intentions to change harm‐causing eating habits (Study 4). Results of Studies 1, 2 and 5 did not provide evidence for our hypothesis. A following meta‐analysis across all five studies yielded an overall significant effect of mindfulness in the harm‐condition, providing preliminary evidence for a potential downside to mindfulness.

Morality is subjective, so this study can't be empirical

1
ewk•

We are seeing the benefits of "mindfulness practice".

If anybody wants to engage this troll directly, that's fine... anybody who says "morality is subjective" is obviously a liar, so I'll pass.

1
RottenCynicistOP•

Great job, you dusterhuffing dipshit! You've once again failed to read your own evidence, and provided me with a mountain of links that disprove your argument rather than supporting it!!! You really gotta learn how to read, buddy.

1
[deleted]•

**STAY IN THE PRESENT MOMENT**

1
ewk•

^> ^Great ^job, ^you ^dusterhuffing ^dipshit! ^You've ^once ^again ^failed ^to ^read ^your ^own ^evidence, ^and ^provided ^me ^with ^a ^mountain ^of ^links ^that ^disprove ^your ^argument ^rather ^than ^supporting ^it!!! ^You ^really ^gotta ^learn ^how ^to ^read, ^buddy.

As I said, this guy has issues.

1
[deleted]•

Looks like you might need to meditate more

1
Aranmil•

So much words for nothing.

1
RottenCynicistOP•

Also, calling a small amount of text like this "So much words" doesn't make you seem all that bright.

1
[deleted]•

Be easy homies.

Be easy homies.

1
RottenCynicistOP•

You're cute babes, but I'm taken. Sorry sugartits.

1
RottenCynicistOP•

Sorry you feel that way chief. Most people I've shown it to thanked me for it, and it was requested by a large number of my followers, so I suspect you're probably just a negativistic prick who shits on things over the internet because you're unhappy with your life.

Good luck, tiger!

0
paynehouseThe ZenMcMuffin •

Fucking hilarious

2
Aranmil•

Well, thank you for nothing.

1
RottenCynicistOP•

Np buddy.

Good luck with that whole "disappointed by life" thing you got goin' on. I suggest starting a mindfulness practice. When it comes to resolving that sorta issue, science has proven mindfulness is a lot more effective than being a shitty person on the internet.

1
hashiusclayis without difficulty•

You seem very content.

1
apollotigerwolf•

do you really feel this much is needed to understand mindfulness?

1
RottenCynicistOP•

People have written manuals on mindfulness that are hundreds of pages long, so yes, I think a page and half is reasonable.

Thanks for asking!

1
apollotigerwolf•

justifying your behavior based on what other people do. who is pulling the strings?

1
RottenCynicistOP•

That makes absolutely no sense partner. Thanks for reminding me why I don't come around this toxic shithole though!

1
RottenCynicistOP•

If masters of numerous traditions are writing hundreds of pages on the subject of mindfulness, that shows this is actually extremely bare-bones in comparison.

I also coulda pointed out that anyone who thinks this is a particularly large amount of text has very weak literacy skills. I was being nice though.

Trust and believe when I say you don't wanna go down this road with me friendo.

1
apollotigerwolf•

if your peace of mind does not stand up to two simple questions what business do you have sharing it with others?

1
ThatKir•

Not relevant to the subreddit; posted by a user with a history of utilizing the mentally handicapped and mentally ill as slurs, making up Chinese history/language, and other assorted lying.

Try r/Meditation

1