BanannaBread•

So I can PVR... but once a publisher raises a flag then I've suddenly broken the law and am a criminal.

In order to PVR legally, every citizen would have to have up to the minute knowledge of publishers actions. Not paying attention for 20 minutes could potentially make you a criminal.

This is so beyond stupid that it makes me ashamed to be Canadian.

6
MasterOfBrutality•

Back up a DVD? That's a paddlin'. Use your PVR? That's a paddlin'. Jailbreak your phone? That's a paddlin'.

3
shepppard•

what does "paddlin'" mean?

1
mooglebeanOP•
6
shepppard•

hahaha. that's awesome

2
coldshuts•

I don't think that sending a letter is gonna change anything... Harper needs a real kick in the ass or something.

2
superwinner•

The US is writing our copyright laws, same as they are doing for every other country. Fuck them, seriously.

7
vsTerminus•

I've spoken out about this before here on Reddit. (1 and 2)

I sent a letter to my MP as well way back in May. She responded with a generic letter (The same one MPs around the country were sending out) and have not heard from her since. I assume she's no longer reading my letters at all. Conservatives.... >:(

I filled out the form OP posted and sent off another letter.

I can't wait to see what ridiculous provisions companies start putting on their DRM schemes once the law is backing them =/

"To download this song, please send your first born child via USPS Priority Mail to..."

2
[deleted]•

Although I have issues with how parts of the bill read, notably how it pertains to unlocking, jailbreaking, etc, here is what C-32 will change, and is the overall reason why I am in favour of it:

Canadian photographers are the only visual artists whose copyrights are not automatically protected for all commissioned works and photographic portraits. In Canada, the owner of the copyright to a photographic work is the person who commissions it and not the photographer.

1
BuryMeWithIt•

Everyone, please at least e-mail your MP.

You can find your MP's e-mail here: http://canada.gc.ca/directories-repertoires/direct-eng.html

vsTerminus posted a well written letter below which I'll paste here for ease of use:

Dear Ministers,

I would ask a moment of the Legislative Committee's time to look carefully at Bill C-32, The Copyright Modernization Act. The bill, which appears to be flexible and allows for many new freedoms around copyrighted works. There is, however, one very important flaw that I must bring to your attention, and that is the overly strict anti-circumvention provision. As a Canadian consumer I am concerned that my digital rights will soon be forfeit and I urge this committee to reconsider passing this bill without the necessary amendments.

The anti-circumvention provision included in Bill C-32 does not allow for the circumvention of digital locks under any circumstances. This gives corporate copyright owners and distributors the opportunity to exercise absolute control over the customer's interaction with digital media. There are no restrictions on what digital locks may be used, nor what the conditions of those locks may or may not be. As the saying goes, "Absolute power corrupts absolutely".

Under Bill C-32 educational institutions cannot break a digital lock, even for lawful, educational or research purposes. Consumers are unable to transfer their media to new formats (format shift), or make backup copies to protect their investments. Educational institutions will be unable to use copyrighted works with digital locks for research purposes unless they are expressly allowed within the terms of said digital lock. This is not good for the consumers, nor is is good for educational institutions. Preventing citizens from using their media for lawful purposes does not benefit anyone except the corporations, and I feel that it may threaten my constitutional rights in the future.

A simple example that I can think of, from a consumer stand point, is DVD encryption. Nearly every DVD disc in production today includes a form of encryption and region protection - a digital lock. If I were to travel to France tomorrow and purchase a DVD, it would be region-locked to France. By watching this DVD in Canada I would be violating Bill C-32's anti-circumvention provisions and could be considered a criminal.

One possible solution to this bill is to amend the bill to allow circumvention of digital locks for lawful purposes. While I agree that copyright in Canada is out-dated, we cannot simply throw our rights away. I urge this Committee to either add an infringing purpose requirement to the prohibition of circumvention or add an exception to the legislation to address circumvention for lawful purposes.

In addition to this, I believe it is of the utmost importance that Canadian consumers have access to the necessary tools to facilitate such lawful acts. It is imperative that the ban on the distribution and marketing of devices or tools that can be used to lawfully circumvent be eliminated by removing paragraph 41.1(c) and any associated references to it or any paragraphs in the Bill that would be rendered irrelevant by this change.

Finally, I believe that digital locks placed on copyrighted content by corporations should be regulated by the government. While it is true that content needs to be protected against unlawful uses, we must ensure that these locks are not simply being used to deny consumer rights. Vendor lock-in and other anti-competitive behavior through the use of digital locks must not be sanctioned under law. I hope this committee agrees.

In conclusion, I believe it is in the best interests of Canadian citizens to amend Bill C-32 to allow for digital lock circumvention for lawful purposes, and to remove the ban on tools which can be used for lawful circumvention.

Sincerely,

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
vsTerminus•

Never pass? From the reaction I'm getting from my MP and responses from other MPs posted on Reddit, they're in favor of it and they don't seem to understand that it's going to re-classify half the population as criminals who aren't even aware that they've committed a crime.

What will it change? Probably nothing. Except that whenever someone is taken to court they'll get hit harder and with no possible defence.

6
Nogoodhandle•

I think they understand perfectly well what will happen. Got to have warm bodies for all those new prisons they want to build.
They are doing the same thing for cannabis law (mandatory minimums) as well, if you make everyone a criminal it makes it easier to fill the prisons, especially in an era of falling crime rates.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
vsTerminus•

Have you spoken out about it to your MP yet?

If it does pass it's on your shoulders and people like you who don't voice their opinion until it's too late.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
skootlesOntario•

Do you even know why the others died? It wasn't because of strong opposition, it was because of elections and parliament being desolved. It was killed by default, not with pure intention.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1