r/linux•
vsTerminus

If you're Canadian, you use Linux and you like multimedia, you're about to become a criminal.

1500 upvotes? What is this I don't even... You guys rock! Thanks to all of you who have stepped up and made your voice heard.

None of the items below will automatically make you a criminal in all situations; It will affect individuals differently depending on their circumstances. The bill is also not centered around Linux, but it has a very strong impact on Linux as we know it.

Yes, there are alternative players for Linux which are properly licensed, but this bill gives copyright holders the ability to define what a 'properly licensed' player is via the terms of their DRM. What happens when they decide that iTunes is the only licensed media player for DVDs and Blu-Ray?


This is a kind of crosspost summary of a new copyright amendment bill that was announced yesterday. Bill C-32 attempts to 'modernize' copyright law in Canada to bring it up to spec with other developed nations (aka to meet US agenda).

The bill would make it illegal to circumvent or break locks of any kind on digital media, even for personal use. This supersedes all other provisions of the bill, which means you may be a criminal if you

  • Own and play region-locked DVDs from other countries
  • Play regular DVDs on Linux
  • Play Blu-Ray Discs on Linux
  • Transfer media to an iPod Touch / iPhone / iPad using Linux
  • Strip DRM from music on Linux in order to listen to it

And anything else that involves restricted content that lacks official Linux support.

Speak up while you can. Find your MP and write them an email telling them why you are opposed to C-32.

We don't want a US style DMCA, please don't let that happen.

Edit: Here is a template based on the email I wrote to my MP. Feel free to use it, modify it, or ignore it. :)

Also: If you are willing, please take the time to handwrite a letter to your MP instead of sending an email. It's guaranteed to make a much much stronger impact and is a lot harder to ignore. However, don't let this discourage you from sending your email instead. Every voice counts!


Dear <Your MP>,

I am writing to you again to express a major point of concern I have found with the newly tabled Bill C-32. While this bill appears to make many positive changes, there is one clause which is particularly troubling.

In Article 41 it becomes clear to me that any media with Digital Rights Management (DRM) protection applied supersedes all other changes introduced by the bill. For example, <Something that affects you personally, such as not being able to legally watch DVDs on Linux>

This bill does not help the consumer, and it does not help the copyright owner either. If it does not help either of these parties, who is benefiting from it?

Bill C-32 has potential, but it needs work.

Thank you for your time,

-<Your Name>

Article 41: http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=4580265&Mode=1&Language=F&File=72#16



Posted Jun 3, 2010, 4:37 PM UTC · edited

1.3K272
codman•

Ive upvoted to spread awareness. I am not Canadian but I am a linux user, and letting this type of shit happen is not an option.

239
roflstomp•

Time to write my MP. The school district I work for (which happens to be in a Conservative MP's riding) is in the process of switching to Ubuntu PXE-boot workstations.

47
vsTerminusOP•

Oh boy. They'd have one hell of a time trying to show copyrighted material for educational purposes. Fair use or not.

If you get a response from your MP don't forget to post it in r/Canada or here too!

47
cscwian•

To quote the bill itself:

"29.4 (1) It is not an infringement of copyright for an educational institution or a person acting under its authority for the purposes of education or training on its premises to reproduce a work, or do any other necessary act, in order to display it."

http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?Language=E&Parl=40&Ses=3&Mode=1&Pub=Bill&Doc=C-32_1&File=51#9

edit: seems like this does not apply if the work is commercially available.

14
vsTerminusOP•

To quote the next part of the bill itself:

"29.4 (3) Except in the case of manual reproduction, the exemption from copyright infringement provided by subsections (1) and (2) does not apply if the work or other subject-matter is commercially available, within the meaning of paragraph (a) of the definition “commercially available” in section 2, in a medium that is appropriate for the purposes referred to in those subsections."

So if you can purchase the works anywhere for any price, section (1) doesn't apply.

18
ghibmmm•

PXE = magic

1
Corey24•

I wrote my MP about this earlier and he gave me some obviously canned response that had little to no bearing on my concerns at all. Wasn't really too surprising.

3
bloodqc•

It's not just with Linux. I think no one would be able to backup their copy-protected DVD.

18
salbris•

Is this true, can someone confirm? I have hundreds of copied DvDs many of which had protection.

8
roflstomp•

Correct - From the current draft revision bill:

41.1 (1) No person shall

(a) circumvent a technological protection measure within the meaning >of paragraph (a) of the definition “technological protection measure” >in section 41;

Section 41A reads as follows:

  1. The following definitions apply in this section and in sections 41.1 to 41.21. “circumvent” « contourner »

“circumvent” means,

(a) in respect of a technological protection measure within the meaning of paragraph (a) of the definition “technological protection measure”, to descramble a scrambled work or decrypt an encrypted work or to otherwise avoid, bypass, remove, deactivate or impair the technological protection measure, unless it is done with the authority of the copyright owner; and

(b) in respect of a technological protection measure within the meaning of paragraph (b) of the definition “technological protection measure”, to avoid, bypass, remove, deactivate or impair the technological protection measure.

9
[deleted]•

I agree, but they will never stop me from using Linux. It works and it's free, and there is no reason that it, or anything related to open source, should be illegal.

8
spellforce44•

GNU/Linux is mostly free. Some audio/video codecs and some hardware drivers, like acceleration support for video cards, are not free.

If you care enough about free(dom) software and unrestricted media, visit fsf.org and defectivebydesign.org to atleast inform yourself.

3
th1rst•

You know damn well he was talking about money, no need to be a smart-ass about something he wasn't even talking about.

8
spellforce44•

I knew he was talking about money, which isn't the real issue. I really don't think I was a smart-ass.

0
[deleted]•

What I'm saying is that I can download a Linux release like Ubuntu without having to pay for it. If I do that with Mac or Microsoft OS's, I'm considered a thief.

4
spellforce44•

You are missing a crucial detail. Free downloading is free like free beer. You can get free drugs if you want, but you will be breaking the law. The same applies when watching mpeg4 movies in your GNU/Linux box. Especially if you leave in Canada and the amendment gets passed.

9
Kinaek•

That may be the case but by purchasing a video card, you are in fact purchasing a license to use their drivers. The same should apply to purchasing a DVD player/writer for your PC. By purchasing the player you should be in fact purchasing a license to use that player to play DVD's on whatever OS you should choose. I dont know if it does apply but I know it does with video cards, it should apply to all hardware.

2
BaDumTISH•

I've always thought that was a douchebag move, charging money for drivers on linux. It's just such a retard thing to do.

-1
Kinaek•

They dont charge money for proprietary drivers on linux. They just might not be available.

1
homergonerson•

I still don't get why people downvote... There is nothing wrong with what you have said, yet still: 23 downvotes.

The OP's self post? 357 downvotes. Why?

2
alantrick•

Why? Because some of us think that his comment adds nothing to the discussion, it's like a 'me too' sort of thing.

5
homergonerson•

Eh, I guess. Don't see how the OP's submission warrants so many downvotes though. I guess we've got to keep the 60-75% approval rate though.

3
AusIV•

I downvoted the self post because it's inaccurate and a tad sensationalist.

First, DVDs can be played legally on Linux, just not with free software. There are commercial, completely legal DVD players on Linux. Canonical sells one in their shop, and Fluendo has one with a better price.

Second, he doesn't support the claim that its illegal to transfer media to an iPod/iPhone/iPad using Linux. From a quick skimming of the law I don't see anything that addresses reverse engineering a device's protocol. There might be an argument that using it to copy music off of a device would be in violation of this law, but I'm not sure that would apply since the technical measure was applied neither by the content owner or distributor.

Next he claims you can't listen to DRM'd music on Linux. Where do you get DRM'd music anymore? Most major music stores have dropped it. Even if you have some DRM'd music you want to play on Linux, how do you do it anyway? I've heard of a couple of DRM breaches that could be used on Linux, but they got patched up pretty quickly. Most of the lasting DRM holes I'm aware of rely on some component of a system that supports the DRM in the first place. While I don't agree with criminalizing DRM circumvention, the OP acts like this is going to be a major inhibitor to Linux user, while I see it as hollow rhetoric.

He goes on to claim that Android is Linux, so this applies to Android users too. You mean I can't play DVDs on my phone? The agony! Seriously though, these limitations restrict free software implementations of DRM schemes. The fact that Android is Linux is completely irrelevant. Plus, if I'm capable of circumventing DRM on media, I'm going to do that on my high powered computer and transfer the plain-text content to my Android device. The only reason I would play DRM'd media on my phone is if the organization in charge of the DRM scheme decided to support Android (which is a remote possibility, completely unrelated to "Android is Linux"). There has been some discussion of Android set top boxes, and I wouldn't be surprised if some of those come with a completely legal and properly licensed DVD and BluRay player application.

The part about Netflix is also a bit misrepresented. Netflix would be happy to support Linux, but they've locked themselves in to Microsoft's DRM scheme, which is beyond their control. If Moonlight ever gets Silverlight's DRM support, Netflix will immediately be able (and willing) to support Linux. This hasn't happened yet, but it isn't completely off the table. Also, Netflix is a subscription based service. If you made a mechanism to circumvent that, you'd be enabling people to keep content that should only be available while they are a subscriber. While it sucks that you can't play Netflix on Linux, again I feel that the OP misrepresented this issue in an attempt to stir up a reaction.

He goes on to encourage people to write their MP's, suggesting that they claim they can't legally play DVDs on Linux if this passes. This would have a slightly different ring to it if it were accurate: If this passes, you'll have to pay for software to play DVDs on Linux legally. An MP is likely to see through the claim that you can't play DVDs on Linux legally and consider the writer of such a letter to simply be a cheapskate.

Now, all of that said: If the OP had made a post stating that Canada was about to get its own version of the DMCA and given an honest analysis of the implications, he would have gotten an upvote from me. But he didn't. His post is full of inaccuracies and rhetoric for the purpose of stirring up a reaction and gaining upvotes. This kind of sensationalism is not good for the community, and will probably do his cause (which I generally agree with) more harm than good.

-1
devgeek0•

First, DVDs can be played legally on Linux, just not with free software.

And it doesn't bother you that you need to purchase proprietary software to watch your DVD? And if you want to watch your DVD any other way, you're a criminal?

1
AusIV•

I didn't say it didn't bother me, I said the OP's claims were incorrect. When you're trying to challenge legislation like this, you're not going to see success by using false arguments. I think mike_sol's comment does a much better job of framing the issues accurately, but still in a manner that will compel a response from redditors, so he got an upvote from me.

1
NinjaTux•

I'm in the same boat. This bill is repulsive and must be stopped. You can't effect progress more than 86ing linux programs and functions.

Is the Canadian government aware that many servers use Linux distributions? Perhaps those companies could pitch a fit.

1
Waterrat•

Nor am I but I'm also upvoteing it for the same reason...I do not want my operating system marginalized.

1
[deleted]•

you're nuts for wasting your time...

-1
[deleted]•

Here's what I sent to my MP, who happens to be James Moore, the guy that's helping push this stuff through:

Hello Mr. Moore,

You might remember me from some prior emails. I'm writing to you today about the new Copyright bill that you seem to be helping champion through Parliament.

I just wonder whether you actually fully understand all of the implications of this bill. Your boss, Mr. Harper, would like to see it pushed through because it placates the Americans, who have much stricter controls over intellectual property than we do at present. This is in part because of massive amounts of lobbying from their flagging record and movie industries.

However, this bill has some real negative effects on Canadians who believe in intellectual freedom.

The biggest threat that I see is that it prevents users of Free and Open Source software from being able to use their computers the way they would like. Things that the new bill would affect include the ability to:

* Own and play region-locked DVDs from other countries
* Play regular DVDs on Linux
* Play Blu-Ray DVDs on Linux
* Transfer media to an iPod Touch / iPhone / iPad using Linux
* Listen to DRM'd music on Linux

Look at that second one. Playing regular DVDs would become illegal. Do you understand why? It's not that complicated, let me explain:

Regular, store-bought DVDs are encrypted with a scheme called "CSS". When you play a DVD, the video is fed through a decryption process that unscrambles it so it can be shown on your screen. This decryption process is owned by the DVD Consortium, an industry group that controls the format. If you want to implement a DVD player, you need to get a license from the in order to get the decryption key to play the video.

With me so far? No playing DVDs without the decryption key. It is a very trivial sort of encryption, that was reverse-engineered almost a decade ago. People that wish to play DVDs using free and open-source software utilize this reverse engineered encryption to play the discs rather than licensing an official codec.

This is presently legal in Canada - as it is reverse engineering, the same process that was used in the 80s by Compaq to create the first PC clone. It is generally recognized as a good thing that it be legal, because it prevents corporations from establishing unfair monopolies - and often helps create large horizontal industries like the PC market. The openness it provides leads to economic strength and superior technology in the end.

However, under the US DMCA, and under C-62, this becomes illegal, because it breaks encryption. Translation: you can have a legally purchased DVD, stick it into your computer running Linux, and have it be illegal to play the content.

Now, going around the problem is easy. It's a trivial law to break, it doesn't take any extra effort.

I don't want to have to break the law to watch something I paid for.

See what I'm getting at? I want to be a law-abiding citizen; but if you're going to make laws that take something perfectly reasonable, like watching a DVD or playing music I bought online, and you make it illegal, you're basically forcing me to choose to be a criminal. That's irrational.

The only people who are in favour of these laws are large industry groups that like them because they afford them more control over their content. In their ideal world, there is no Fair Use, there is no time-shifting (ala using your VCR to record a TV show), there is no format-shifting (like taking music off a CD to put on your iPod), there is no remixing, there is no sampling.

Do we really want to give up some freedoms we have in order to placate America?

I know I'm not going to convince you. You're championing the bill. You won't give up. But, it's worth a try anyway.

I do want you to know that this bill is wrong. You're wrong to support it, and you're giving up our freedoms for a chance to push through some legislature that might make you look good. It's selfish, it's destructive, and it's going to make me campaign against you as best I can when the next election comes along.

Are you really representing your constituents by supporting this? Did you even think to ask us what we think about it?

106
vsTerminusOP•

I can't thank you enough for writing this. It's absolutely stellar and I hope you post the response on reddit, if you get one.

27
[deleted]•

I won't. I've emailed Moore many times about other things (mandatory minimums on cannabis possession, the previous version of this copyright bill, etc) and he doesn't reply.

You know, it would make my day - and drastically improve my respect for the man - if he'd actually try to debate me on the issue; but apparently constituents aren't worth talking to much less trying to convince.

20
vsTerminusOP•

Really solidifies your faith in the people that represent the people, doesn't it?

:(

17
[deleted]•

"Represent" indeed.

1
TurtleStrangulation•

Maybe a written letter would have had a stronger effect, because i bet an asshole like him has to deal with a pretty high amount of angry emails. High enough to only pay attention to those who come from hollywood.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
[deleted]•

Well, yeah... why ignore the people you are working for? Of course he will only read the hollywood emails!

2
binlargin•

Hollywood don't send emails, they send important looking letters on high quality paper because they know that's what works.

2
davin3000•

I would love to get to debate my MP. Not in public, mind you; over a beer or something.

2
jeannaimard•

Won't make a difference. The Canadian Reform Alliance Party government has got it’s marching orders from Hymiewood that all we shall be able to view are what Hymiewood decides we should watch and nothing else.

-6
vsTerminusOP•

Won't stop me from trying.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

Hymiewood

Antisemitism isn't cool.

1
jeannaimard•

Because sucking jewish arse is?

0
[deleted]•

I hope you don't mind my copying this. Please CC the opposition as well to make sure they see that we're opposed to the bill.

Edit: I'm CC'ing CTV and Global as well.

[email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

11
[deleted]•

Absolutely, but if you get people interviewing you, please give me some credit!

12
[deleted]•

If anyone contacts me I'll send them your way! :D

6
[deleted]•

I got a "message received" email from Moore's office: On behalf of the Honourable James Moore, MP for Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam and Minister of Canadian Heritage and Official Languages, I wish to acknowledge your email.

Please be assured that your correspondence will be brought to Minister Moore's attention at the first possible opportunity.

Kind Regards, Office of the Hon. James Moore

1
[deleted]•

Yep, I got one too, I'm sure it's automatic

1
vsTerminusOP•

That's a great idea, I hope to see it on the news. That'd make my day for sure.

6
[deleted]•

to have the general public aware of what this actually means would be great. The news is exactly what we need to do.

3
graycode•

This needs a thousand more upvotes. Brilliantly written.

10
KishCom•

I just wrote my MP -- I wish I had read this one first (so I could steal bits and pieces). Pure awesome, nice job.

6
sudormrf•

Do we really want to give up some freedoms we have in order to placate America?

Upvoted for telling my country to go fuck itself.

6
[deleted]•

I love America, but we don't wanna necessarily have all the same laws, because you people are still trying to get rid of this one and failing.

1
JohnoTheFoolish•

I would like your permission to use parts of this letter in my own correspondence with my member of Parliament.

5
[deleted]•

Granted, just adapt as needed.

2
JohnoTheFoolish•

Thanks, modified and delivered.

1
celesfar•

Upvoting for a good explanation.

3
nolcotin•

I am going to copy past and edit, i.e, plagiarise... this letter to ensure that the letter that reaches my MP is unique and not just form letter.

This is an excellent piece you have written, I only wish I could do the same

3
[deleted]•

Some of us can write; some of us can protest; all of us win.

3
nolcotin•

Uh... I'll practice my penmanship to ensure that these letters count

2
lastchance•

Excellent points in there, I'll be cribbing when I write my own MP. Thanks.

3
twomashi•

This is pretty condescending. I wouldn't like to recieve this.

3
[deleted]•

I didn't like receiving your reply, so, I guess I know how he'll feel.

1
webfiend•

That's a great message and it's obvious you've given a lot of thought to it. Have you sent this or similar messages via snail mail?

The general advice south of the border (US, that is) is to send those messages to our representatives via postal mail. The people giving the advice are under the impression that email can easily be ignored, while the physical presence of a letter or stack of letters is harder to ignore.

I have no citations to say whether this advice is valid. It's just a thought.

2
[deleted]•

Have you sent this or similar messages via snail mail?

No, too lazy. Why the hell should my MP neglect email but read physical mail? If that's the kind of guy he is, he should be living a century ago.

1
webfiend•

Hey, I won't judge. I've never done it either.

1
thelastbaron•

Excellently written, however it won't make any difference unless your MP understands what Linux and FOSS is.

Otherwise, he will be of the belief that Linux itself is the problem, as it allows people to break encryption. You didn't explain the difference between how this works on Linux and how it works with Windows - he will probably be of the mindset "if you have to break encryption to play it on Linux, then you shouldn't use Linux because it is some sort of illegal hacker tool". I don't feel he will understand why you say the ability to reverse engineer is good.

It's like you're saying "it is a good thing that door locks can be picked, because that allows us without any money to break into homes and take what we need".

I reiterate that this isn't my opinion, but it's how I assume he will interpret your points. I agree with what you are saying and I wish you guys the best of luck (I'm American) but I just don't think anybody on the opposing side pushing this through has the knowledge necessary to make the right decisions.

2
[deleted]•

I don't feel he will understand why you say the ability to reverse engineer is good.

I agree. I tried to explain that it is why the PC market exists, but I didn't wanna go full bore into that one.

1
PigeonFriend•

I highly doubt the law would hold you, the consumer, responsible for the fact that the people who created your operating system broke the law. You aren't breaking the law by playing a DVD on linux, the people that create the software by circumventing propriety encryption are.

-4
nolcotin•

READ the (incredibly dense, wordy, and obutse) bill!

6
[deleted]•

If I download DeCSS from a country where it is legal and install and use it, it's me breaking the law. Reasonably Free distributions don't include it.

1
jeannaimard•

Actual text of C-32 which was downvoted (go fucking figure why).

27
vsTerminusOP•

Thanks for linking.

I have it linked in the original post too now.

7
skooma714•

Even playing a legit dvd?

See people, you can't be a law abiding citizen these days. Sure, you don't rape, kill or steal but even the most innocuous stuff is nominally illegal nowadays.

I wonder what the people who think "if it is illegal, then it is immoral" will say now.

25
[deleted]•

I wonder what the people who think "if it is illegal, then it is immoral" will say now.

They will say the usual "If you knew it was illegal, why did you do it? It's your own damn fault.". While, of course, they do other illegal stuff because if they do it, it's not wrong. Once you have wrongly decided that the opinions of others decide what is right and what is wrong, it's really a very short step to "as long as nobody catches me, whatever I do is right".

Edit: the dishonest asshole diminoten throughly edited his side of the conversation that follows, to make it look as if the earlier conversation hadn't taken place. I have quoted portions of his idiocies in select comments.

12
[deleted]•

I have a strong suspicion that what you're doing in your free time is morally and legally wrong. To be explicit, I believe you are murdering children in your free time, and I believe this is wrong.

-10
[deleted]•

Unless you have evidence and a solid argument to prove that whatever I am doing is wrong, then shut up. I mean it. I do not tolerate empty accusations lightly.

7
[deleted]•

I won't go to the authorities until I have such evidence, but I think it wise of you to begin to build your defense. Primarily, I would focus on trying to avoid telling people to shut up. That never works in a courtroom. :(

-10
isionous•

I think someone even came out with a book where he estimated that a typical American on a typical day commits about three felonies.

6
b6666•
2
isionous•

And thanks for giving the title and a link.

1
jamougha•

They probably already think that Linux is a hacker OS and Linux users are deviants.

2
baconated•

That's why I'm mentioning that my business uses it.

I'm also providing an example of how it will be illegal for us to play our internally produced training videos to our new employees.

3
JamesR•

How could it be illegal to play your own videos? You are the copyright holder => you can do what you want, DRM or no. Or is there another clause you're talking about?

1
kumyco•

Street Cred yo!

19
Rookeh•

Street Cred eh!

FTFY

42
Deusdies•

This should be reposted in r/reddit.com to spread awareness.

19
vsTerminusOP•
19
SmartAssX•

:P reddit wont care as much as r/Canada

2
Eggby•

I'm American and I care. Just because I have to live with this shit doesn't mean our brothers and sisters in the north have to!

10
anyletter•

Canadians are American also. You know, that continent that we share.

1
Deusdies•

I'm American and I care

?

-2
vsTerminusOP•

r/Canada is all over this already. I'm part of the discussions there too.

2
jeannaimard•

r/Canada downvoted my link to the actual bill text (go fucking figure why).

1
[deleted]•

Wow, we're getting closer and closer to Right To Read with every one of these copyright acts :/

19
vsTerminusOP•

Holy fuck. Thanks for the link!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
vsTerminusOP•

Appropriate. Thanks :)

7
DwightDL•

Wow, this is stupid. Thankfully I am not Canadian, but I feel for all of my Northern brethren who will be affected by this.

10
ObligatoryResponse•

The country you live in likely already has a law similar to these. Canada is one of the few remaining safe holds.

38
DwightDL•

Well shit. I guess I'm more of a law breaker than I had assumed.

4
go_go_gadget•

Given that you referred to Canadians as "Northern" it's probably fairly safe to assume you're American. To the best of my knowledge, all of this is already the case in the US.

30
vsTerminusOP•

That is correct. Watching a movie on your Linux computer in the United States violates the DMCA. You're already a criminal :(

28
RedSpikeyThing•

Watching a movie on your Linux computer in the United States violates the DMCA.

Pardon my ignorance, but how does that violate the DMCA?

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
vsTerminusOP•

DVDs are encrypted with CSS protection. Linux uses DeCSS to decrypt and play them, circumventing that protection.

My knowledge of the DMCA is quite limited, but I believe that violates it somewhere.

6
patcito•

They're proprietary solutions to watch DVDs legally on linux, you just have to pay for them, just like on Mac or Windows. Not saying I'm ever getting one of these, I don't buy DVDs anyway, but still, it's possible. By the way, most people on windows use DeCSS too (vlc, mplayer etc).

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=NjcyNw

3
vsTerminusOP•

It's true, there are other alternatives, but being locked into those choices defeats the point of Linux.

What happens when the restrictions tighten from 'any compliant software' to 'Windows Media Player and iTunes only'. Sure, a good chunk of the population will remain unaffected, but I bet anyone with half a brain would be pissed off if they were forced to use iTunes or WMP and nothing else.

Edit: What if I want to develop my own media player for educational purposes? That would be illegal unless I paid for a license.

0
Nosferax•

The solution to that is to watch already decrypted DVDs and Blue-Rays, lol.

-1
jdpage•

Indeed -- the DMCA has already done most of this. However, some things could fall under 'fair use' (like DVD ripping), but have not been tried in court yet.

11
eldridgea•

DVD ripping isn't covered if the DVD has DRM (and most do have CSS).

http://www.itproportal.com/portal/news/article/2010/3/5/realnetworks-gives-realdvd-following-lawsuit/

3
justajoe•

AFAIK, the case was settled, so no ruling exists, thus no precedent. The limitations of fair use have yet to be tested in this regard.

5
jeannaimard•

CSS is not DRM, but a market-segmentation device used to enforce an illegal practice.

2
papercrane•

Arguably the ripping a DVD may be allowed. The phrase "technological protection measure" is defined in the bill as:

“technological protection measure” means any effective technology, device or component that, in the ordinary course of its operation

CSS is not an effective technological protection measure as it's known to be broken for some time now. I'm not a lawyer though, so I could be way off.

-1
tacotruck7•

If you are in the US you are already a criminal if you watch a DVD on a Linux box.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ObligatoryResponse•

The country you live in likely already has a law similar to these. Canada is one of the few remaining safeholds.

1
jobeus•

It doesn't even matter if you run linux. If you use VLC or another free software app for playing DVDs, you're circumventing. PowerDVD and the like pay for CSS licenses to play DVDs, and then make you pay for their products. If you're using a free DVD player application in Windows, you'd probably be infringing on the new law.

9
ingolemo•

Should be crossposted to a more widely read subreddit so it can get more exposure. r/politics, perhaps?

7
vsTerminusOP•

I will. Linux users are my people just as much as Canadians are so I figured I'd hit home first.

9
jasonhaley•

post the submission link here so i can upvote it.

8
Eggby•

This reddit is mostly for U.S. politics. You can consider - r/WorldPolitics for non-US political content.

I'd say go ahead and post it there, but it might be the wrong place.

1
ingolemo•

r/reddit.com was probably a better choice anyway.

2
thephotoman•

If you're an American and do these things, you're a criminal. The thing is that I've been anally violating that law on a regular basis since 2004. I'm not about to stop now.

Canuckistanians, join me on the wrong side of the law! We do cocaine!

6
__loridcon•

cocaine you say?

I'm game!

3
papercrane•

There is an interoperability clause, paragraph 41.12 (1), but paragraph 41.12 (2) disallows you from providing software to allow interoperability, so I'm not sure what the point of the interoperability clause is.

5
OceanSpray•

Do you really think they will enforce this?

5
vsTerminusOP•

Think of it like the minor things you can be ticketed for on your car; Tint too dark, bra covers front license plate, stereo is too loud, stuff in the backseat obstructs view, etc.

You may not get pulled over for one of those things on a regular basis, but you can bet that if they catch you speeding they'll kick you while you're down by giving you a ticket for your tint as well.

Similarly, if you get caught pirating, they'll tack on a fine for every DVD you own and might have played on a Linux computer.

11
[deleted]•

I believe a list of that (every DVD you played in your linux box) is locally avaliable under some directory --I forgot (and don't have access to it now) which one.

1
o_creat•

I think you mean ~/.dvdcss it is a cache of cracked keys to avoid recracking each time you watch.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
rogue780•

As a US citizen, I hope very much that Canadians stand up against such an affront to personal freedoms as we in the US have failed to do.

Of course, this may all go away if your PM suspends your parliment again...

5
vsTerminusOP•

One can only hope.

0
[deleted]•

We brits tried to go up against our new and retarded Digital economy act but even after e-mailing my MP's, only the lib dem candidate pretended to take my side. The Labour and Tory dicks just said my opinion was wrong. Oh well... Looks like i'm using TOR from now on.

2
warpstalker•

What, you don't have this yet?

We've had this in Finland since 2006(?).

It's illegal to rip your own DVD's because you're circumventing copy protection (usually). Some guys even turned themselves in after doing that. They didn't have to pay a fine or anything, I think.

4
vsTerminusOP•

Canada has been quite free as far as copyrights go for the last 10 years because every time a bill is introduced the people cry out against it and the bill gets rejected.

The new bill has a few positive points for fair use, but it all disappears as soon as copy protection is in place; Defeats the whole purpose.

11
warpstalker•

That's basically the way of the world, my friend. I bet the US pressures countries into adopting these retarded schemes.

Anyway, I'm sure ACTA will also be coming soon, and it basically doesn't matter what you do about it. Sucks.

8
vsTerminusOP•

Yes, actually. This bill was heavily pressured by the US MPAA. I maintain that just because other countries are doing it doesn't make it a good idea.

11
jasonhaley•

Canada continues to fight the copyright and this is just an on going battle we need to remember to upkeep.

One letter to an MP a year > $50,000 fine for watching Shrek 2 on Ubuntu.

6
tacotruck7•

It is not really the US, but US based (mostly) corporations and their lobbyists.

2
celesfar•

This is a very silly law.

Regardless, I just have to stop here and ask - shouldn't it be totally fine to listen to DRMed music, play blu-rays or whatever as long as you're not actually breaking anything?

If I were a member of parliament, and I knew nothing about this magical compooter thing other than MS word, I'd think "Linux sure looks like it's making a lot of people break digital restrictions on stuff!" and just dispose of it in my "whiners bin" (if I were a politician, I would have one of these labeled "whiners")

So, how do we explain this to said politician?

4
vsTerminusOP•

Certainly, if you're not breaking DRM restrictions then it would be fine to play said content on Linux. However, that is often not the case.

DRM comes in varying levels of restrictiveness. What happens when the next popular music format is restricted to Apple devices only? What happens when it becomes so popular you can't ignore it? That may not happen now, but nothing is stopping it from happening in the future.

You'd be forced to buy an Apple product against your will, or willingly break the law. I don't want to make that choice.

3
psilokan•

Anyone have a well written email to their MP I can "borrow?" I found my MP but I'm at work so I don't have time to write a fancy and well though email about why I oppose it, if someone could provide a template to tweak you'd be making this a lot easier for myself and others :D

3
webhamster•

E-mails will do nothing. They are largely ignored and/or funneled to a lackey who pastes a generic reply based on the subject line without ever reading it.

What gets the attention of eyeballs are paper letters sent via old-person mail because, the theory goes, it's far more likely they are not form e-mails and the person took the time to fold it, put it in an envelope, address it, and walk it out to a mailbox so they must really care about this.

Also, you don't need to pay for a stamp if you are sending a letter to Parliament Hill.

7
vsTerminusOP•

While it's true that a handwritten note will go 20x further than an email, it doesn't mean that you shouldn't try. If a particular MP's office is getting a few dozen, or even a few hundred emails on the same topic, word is going to reach the MP and they'll look into it.

You just need more voices.

6
webhamster•

Of course not, you should always try. I'm just saying that for maximum impact the old-fashioned way gets much more attention.

7
vsTerminusOP•

Absolutely. No argument there. Shame my handwriting is so unreadable.

2
vsTerminusOP•

Here is the letter I wrote to Shelly Glover

It doesn't bring up concerns over Linux (I didn't realize just how much this affects Linux users until after I sent it), but the problem remains the same. Article 41 stating that breaking copyright protection is prohibited regardless of the bill's other provisions.

Edit: Template included in OP.

3
jasonhaley•

Dear Sir/Madam X,

As a citizen living in your riding [and a staff member of (optional name of your organization)], I am writing to you to express my concerns about the inequities of proposed Bill C-32 in Canada. I would like to urge you and your fellow MPs [MPPs] to give serious consideration to the implications of this bill and an analysis on how this will affect the labour force, business sector development, and the livelihood of citizens.

The passing of Bill-C32 will criminalize running copyright digital media on an operating system which is used by citizens, businesses, schools and government institutions: Linux. For example, public libraries which use Linux as an operating system and offer a variety of digital media, including DVDs, to the public, will risk facilitating criminal acts. That's because a citizen who chooses to watch a DVD on a library's Linux computer would be considered illegal, according to Bill-C32. This act would cause the library's service to become redundant, and the same can be said for businesses and other institutions which rely on the Linux OS.

Another example includes all Canadian citizens who purchase cellphones from Rogers, Fido, Bell, or Telus. If the customer chooses one of the several phone models (Samsung, Motorola, LG, HTC..etc.) which carry the Android system then they will risk breaking the law as soon as they choose to listen to music on that phone. Despite the fact that both the phone and the song and/or movie were legally paid for, the act of listening to the song will infringe the copyright, due to Bill C-32.

I hope the provided examples show the complexity of the issue and highlight the problems with Bill C-32. I hope you bring up our concerns at your caucus meetings. I look forward to hearing back from you as to what action plans you have come up with to address Bill-C32 problems in Canada. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

[Your name and signature]

cc A big company

2
psilokan•

Thank you kind sir!

2
radarsat1•

If I download instead of renting a DVD, will I be more or less of a criminal?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
radarsat1•

Hm, I prefer to fix the law, if possible, rather than subvert it...

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
radarsat1•

You may, in general, be right, but so far in this case, there is a history of public outcry actually making a difference.

1
rich97•

There is still one place that is left untouched, if you can get into the IRC scene. Private servers and all that jazz.

0
bluepostit•

Same here :)

1
deadowl•
  • The DVD thing is really annoying. The MPAA should be required to make it easier for people to legally play DVDs on Linux.
  • The reason I don't have any Apple products is because they would make me feel unfree.
  • You can listen to DRM'd music on Linux?
3
vsTerminusOP•

DRM'd music on Linux may be ok so long as you're not violating the terms. However, with iTunes that DRM uses a proprietary AAC decoder I believe and playing that on Linux would be illegal.

So it depends on the restrictions that the DRM places on the media. You may be able to play them legally.

3
YellowOnion•

AAC is not DRM it's the audio codec, it is more likely covered under patent law than copyright law

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

There are licensed and legal players for dvds and most codecs on Linux, If this post were about supporting developers for linux then it would be fine with me, but it's about some sort of bs angle that does not exist.

Netflix is illegal in Canada period. Doesn't matter what os you use there is no studio license for streaming in Canada. Scratch that one, it's done.

Dvd playback can be done as well as most popular formats in Linux legally but you might have to shell out a buck and gasp! support a linux developer.

I'm not keen on itunes/ipod/imac/etc etc but frankly, it's apple is this news to you? Probably not and the same thing applies everywhere, stop supporting a company that is fundamentally opposed to the open source framework.

If you don't want to support oss then push for your peers to use a truly open source media format, plenty out there that sure as hell beat mp3 etc.

In short, this post is just a bunch of hype for some guys agenda and he's trying to take Linux users and people who are generally unfamiliar with the oss model and exploit it.

0