Are you a Canadian Linux user? You're about to become a criminal.

None of the items below will automatically make you a criminal in all situations; It will affect individuals differently depending on their circumstances. The bill is also not centered around Linux, but it has a very strong impact on Linux as we know it.

Yes, there are alternative players for Linux which are properly licensed, but this bill gives copyright holders the ability to define what a 'properly licensed' player is via the terms of their DRM. What happens when they decide that iTunes is the only licensed media player for DVDs and Blu-Ray?


I posted this in /r/linux and am spreading it here to raise awareness.

A new copyright amendment bill was announced yesterday in Canada. Bill C-32 attempts to 'modernize' copyright law in Canada to bring it up to spec with other developed nations (aka to meet US agenda).

The bill would make it illegal to circumvent or break locks of any kind on digital media, even for personal use. This supersedes all other provisions of the bill, which means you may be a criminal if you

  • Own and play region-locked DVDs from other countries
  • Play regular DVDs on Linux
  • Play Blu-Ray Discs on Linux
  • Transfer media to an iPod Touch / iPhone / iPad using Linux
  • Strip the DRM from your music (via re-recording or any other method)
  • Listen to music files that have specific DRM restrictions

And anything else that involves protected content that lacks official Linux support.

Speak up while you can. Find your MP and write them an email telling them why you are opposed to C-32.

We don't want a US style DMCA, please don't let that happen.

Edit: Here is a template, based on the email I sent to my own MP that you can use if you like.

Second Edit: If you can spare the time, please consider handwriting a letter and mailing or delivering it in person to your MP. This will have a huge impact compared to an email. However, please don't let that stop you from sending your email, every voice counts!


Dear <Your MP>,

I am writing to you again to express a major point of concern I have found with the newly tabled Bill C-32. While this bill appears to make many positive changes, there is one clause which is particularly troubling.

In Article 41 it becomes clear to me that any media with Digital Rights Management (DRM) protection applied supersedes all other changes introduced by the bill. For example, <Something that affects you personally, such as not being able to legally watch DVDs on Linux>

This bill does not help the consumer, and it does not help the copyright owner either. If it does not help either of these parties, who is benefiting from it?

Bill C-32 has potential, but it needs work.

Thank you for your time,

-<Your Name>

Article 41: http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=4580265&Mode=1&Language=F&File=72#16


Posted Jun 3, 2010, 5:49 PM UTC · edited

764524
HORSEtheGAME•

Does anyone else fear the old politicians that have zero understanding of computers, yet they regulate them?

237
BeJeezus•

They don't understand the energy, insurance or health care businesses either, but this doesn't stop them from taking suitcases full of money from lobbyists and making laws to regulate those in business-favorable ways.

Nothing special about technology.

116

Its worse than you think.

Lobbyist: to Senator (scene, resteraunt):

By the way, since I know you're so busy, I wrote up the bill for you. All you have to do is present it thus saving your time that would have been spent on researching and writing so you can now go to that fundraiser you wanted.

What, Senator? Oh, no, lunch is on me. The restaurant priced it a dollar under what is considered to be a reportable lobbyist gift. Thank god, otherwise I'd have to run up two credit cards on a single lunch.

56
Whanhee•

This is why I'm so opposed to the proposed senate reform into an American style senate.

21
cleverf00•

Perhaps we should write the bills we want to see instead of just protesting against the ones lobbyists present? I don't know the first thing about it though - is it terribly difficult?

Don't get me wrong: this doesn't mean we shouldn't communicate with your representative often. Often they're just listening to whoever's doing the most talking, and that tends not to be the people that elect them (for most issues). Trust me they do indeed care about the personal letters/phonecalls/visits - or at least the new, less secure ones do.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
PaeTar•

check out the pirateparty.ca for more ideas. I'm not a member myself, but I do believe in a lot of things they do.

1
notthemessiah•

Makes campaign finance reform look like the joke that it is. All that current measures at campaign finance reform do is make it harder for anybody to compete with the established politicians, there's a reason why the concept was welcomed with open arms on Capital Hill.

3
Nessie•

[Directed by Oliver Stone]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ChaosMotor•

You see, these old men don't write bills anymore whatsoever. Their friends in the industry write a bill that "regulates" the industry by gifting wonderful things to existing players while establishing regulatory firewalls against any new competitors.

3
[deleted]•

I would have no problem with their laws if they were "business-favorable." If their laws were good for everyone's business, that would be great! Most productive people are involved in a business of some sort, and they would benefit from that.

What you mean is that their laws are favorable to the handful of businesses that bribe them, and horribly anti-business to the many productive people who would love to offer competitive alternatives.

Case in point: the very bill we're discussing right now.

3
BeJeezus•

You are correct, that is exactly what I meant.

1
[deleted]•

but this doesn't stop them from taking suitcases full of money from lobbyists

I do believe that is called bribery.

1
BeJeezus•

Not if it's a "donation to campaign" or some other less-direct vehicle of sleaze.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
dpatrick86•

If you click that link make sure to clear your cookies so this guy doesn't get a dime

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
vsTerminusOP•

It's part of the problem with politics as a whole. It takes many years to get to a position of power (usually). By that time, people tend to be a little out of touch with the world.

Intellectual Property address, for example ><

24
[deleted]•

Why do people always assume that the politicians don't understand the issue? They understand it a lot better than you think. They just don't care about you.

10
[deleted]•

I have a person in my life who is one of them. An elected Politician. They would just assume the Internet not exist, and if they can't have their way they are going to try and shut it down and bottle it up any way they can. And worse, they will succeed because we are a stupid public. If you want to stop this then you need to make some noise. Some more.

8
Zaneris•

Well, at least most of the MP's aren't that old, the bigger problem is them not actually thinking about anything they vote on.

6
timeshifter_•

Fear? Didn't McCain flat-out prove it in 2008? The current generation of politicians is quite detached from the reality of the world. They want things the old way, and they simply don't get that they cannot have it anymore. Technology is constantly changing, and people need to be aware of that. If you're writing legislation on technological matters, you'd damn well better know more about technology than "I use the Google to get to Facebook, then to tweet all my friends!"

6
[deleted]•

Does anyone else fear the old politicians that have zero understanding of computers, yet they regulate them?

-2
timeshifter_•

I fail to see how your emphasis affects what I wrote.

6
[deleted]•

Both comments (yours and the one to which you replied) state that certain old politicians have zero understanding of computers, but it seems your reply was written under the assumption that the "fear" in the original was "I am afraid that they don't understand computers" instead of "I am afraid of them because they don't understand computers."

Your comment seems to imply that you thought it was "I am afraid that they don't understand computers" because of the way you used McCain as an example to say that this was not only possible or likely, but actually a demonstrated fact.

Minor point, really--it doesn't affect the validity of your main idea, with which I agree, in fact.

-1
nullminded•

If it were the "old" way things would be better. What they want is total socialism , and dictatorship. Honestly 95% of politicians are complete and utter criminals. I mean look at everything that's happened. You think the BP oil spill actually means anything to capital hill? Hell no! Why do you think little is being done to punish BP? Because BP makes the government big money. This world is coming to a close soon unless we start making moves. =/

-2
fungah•

How exactly is this bill socialist in any way shape or form? How is it dictatorship? It's heavy handed, and it's favouring big business. Though we're getting fucked, we aren't getting fucked by Stalin's ghost.

3
nullminded•

This bill wasn't really what I was referring to. I guess I was being short sighted. I was talking about the whole picture and the way America is going. Sorry for not being clear on that and just ranting.

1
H-Simpson•

I completely agree, and I'm sure that there are much worse atrocities that happen daily that we as mere "peasants" are allowed to know about.

we need to do something about this bullshit before its too late

1
[deleted]•

oh, you mean like everything else in life ever?

5
apullin•

Advocacy groups pay them to have certain opinions. The advocacy groups exist only to make direct attacks on civilian populations. Downloading & piracy on an industrial scale is clearly detrimental, but aggressively prosecuting private individuals who are just sharing is absolutely not genuinely apply legal protections.

These advocacy groups don't produce anything; they are a cabal in the true sense of the word. The groups gathers enough resources to lobby for laws (DMCA) to make existing behavior on-paper illegal. From there, lawsuits generate revenue.

Remember, they produce nothing: RIAA, MPAA, BluRay Association, etc.

2
ninety6days•

Unlike drugs, broadcasting, shipping, agriculture and pretty much everything apart from a limited knowledge of the law and money? No, this isn't a fear. Fear is usually reserved for something that MIGHt be a problem. This is rage.

1
[deleted]•

Well, if they under zero; they are half way there! They just need to learn about the 1 and they'll know a lot on how computers work!

1
xPaQx•

that's why i'm glad politicians in my country don't even bother about regulating them. Most of them don't even own pc's

1
daysi•

And that the new politicians are without exception servants of the corporations.

1
[deleted]•
1
grandMasterkrust•

Does anyone else fear the old politicians that have zero understanding of anything, yet they regulate everything and fulfil there own agenda's and stuff their pockets with coporate moola?

1
MrHaHaHaaaa•

My dear chap, politicians have no understanding of anything, that is why they are politicians. If politicians had had any talent for anything other than being a politician they would be using it.

1
immrlizard•

Don't feel bad, in the US they don't even bother to read the bills before they vote on them. Thanks to that we have the patriot act.

1
ThisIsRed•

I have said many times that the issues with having such people controlling our laws lies with their inability to rationalize computers and communications systems, so they would rather steamroll over them to err on the side of caution. This deprives responsible users of their rights and defeats the purpose of having a civilized legislation system. It is essentially the same reason we should try to keep religion out of politics. The ignorance of a few should not control the actions of the majority.

0
universl•

Its not just linux, this bill essentially gives the power to the publishers and manufactures to say what you can and can't do with the things that you have already paid money for.

And as a general rule those guys don't want you to have linux running on the the things they produce.

124
Radico87•

Corporations will be the death of modern society.

26
zaza410•

Corporations are currently the death of modern society.

FTFY.

19
Radico87•

Hey, lose that defeatist attitude, we're still not dead yet....

8
SuperSoggyCereal•

When those fucking baby boomers die the world will right itself.

-1
brandoncoal•

Corporations are modern society.

3
manlytears•

Only because they keep telling you they are.

1
Pherecydes•

Corporations are the cancer that is killing modern society.

Is that right?

1
wassailant•

I have this sticking point about the issue of corporations being evil/causing the death of society.

Corporations are not inherently evil - corporations are merely groups of people combining together in the pursuit of a shared goal. The problem lies in the fact that the goal tends to relate to a capitalistic system, ie the pursuit of financial profit.

Practically speaking it results in your statement still being true, but I don't believe it's the fact that corporations exist - rather, the goal that they seek is motivated by capitalism.

1
daysi•

Corporations are inherently amoral. They do whatever is profitable, whatever that may be. If it was profitable to round up poor people and turn them into cat food then you can bet that there would be a corporation doing it.

5
jayathecat•

People say this on reddit but really there is no difference between a modern corporation and a 19th century industrialist. If they were around today, they would be pulling the strings still, and they would pull them in their favour in exactly the way the corporations do.

1
daysi•

But you can kill an industrialist. It's pretty damn hard to kill a corporation.

2
[deleted]•

Corporations are modern society? A man is not an island.

0
n1c0_ds•

Lesson learned: don't pay for it! Whether you pay for it or not, you're screwed if you use it in any normal way.

4
ryuujin•

what section or paragraph do you interpret to mean that, specifically?

1
abw1987•

this bill essentially gives the power to the publishers and manufactures to say what you can and can't do with the things that you have already paid money for

So what?

It's their IP. It's their investment. No one is forcing you to buy it.

-77
WritingImplement•

What about things you purchased prior to this bill under a different set of circumstances?

38
vsTerminusOP•

They fall under the new law just like anything you buy after it.

6
kokey•

Interesting alternative reality where previous contracts could be amended without at least having the option to sue or demand your money back.

1
universl•

I don't think that's true. I suspect it will be illegal for me to rip the dvds I already own, or jailbreak the iphone I bought last year.

0
abw1987•

I concede those should not be included, but the law is the law.

-28
universl•

We aren't arguing if its 'the law' as citizens we have a say in what is and what isn't law, and we arguing that these things should not be criminalized.

16
hukedonfonix•

but the law is the law

... really?

3
YesImSardonic•

The law in the early sixties was that blacks should sit at the back of the goddamned bus and use generally inferior facilities, not to mention be deprived of their votes. That was okay, though, because the law was the law.

1
daysi•

Fuck the law and fuck all you sheep who follow it.

1
[deleted]•

Noone is forcing you to buy it?

Fuck that nonsense. Once I buy something, I expect to fucking OWN it.

An individual license, to do whatever the fuck I want with what I've paid for.

You let these faggots do this, and suddenly, it's "You must pay a subscription for every dvd in your collection."

That's the kind of bullshit you should expect if you let these cock suckers do this.

22
mayonesa•

Once I buy something, I expect to fucking OWN it.

Welcome to the complexities of law.

You own the physical DVD.

You have licensed the information on it.

8
[deleted]•

That's what I mean. I should have the express license to enjoy what I've purchased. If they can't provide their DRM garbage that works for common usage, they should be taken to court.

Only faggots would say Linux isn't in common use. Ubuntu has exploded in home desktop and netbook use.

3
[deleted]•

These proposed laws over fair-use are beyond stupid. Basic copyright laws and the notion of fair-use, however, is not. Society needs rules, not everyone shares the same moral compass.

2
abw1987•

Entitled much?

-9
universl•

How is it entitlement to ask to be legally allowed to modify a product that I paid money for. Don't I own it? What if it was illegal to make a modification to your car? You wouldn't have a problem with that?

9
[deleted]•

I bet you're down with "Software patents".

6
mindbleach•

Absolutely. I am entitled to do as I please with property I own so long as it harms no third party. That's basically the definition of property. If it's not mine to use, abuse, repurpose, alter, misinterpret, and dispose of, it's not mine.

1
fishy007•

The point isn't about putting things up for sale. The point is regarding what you can and can't do once you've purchased an item. If you owned a Honda and Honda suddenly decided that you couldn't listen to the radio in your car anymore, would you be OK with that?

7
IOIOOIIOIO•

Oh, you mean like the trial XM subscription?

1
fishy007•

I don't know what you mean. I've never had satellite radio.

2
[deleted]•

How about the emergency service buttons or factory warrantees? How about your driver's license and license plates? Driving is a privilege, not a right. And if your car no longer meets safety requirements? No longer allowed to DRIVE the car, sorry.

It's similar to a DVD, you purchase the right to view the DVD in privacy, not the IP contained therein. Yes, you should be able to rip it to your drive, but these people don't understand why you'd do that. They probably only barely know how to operate a DVD player.

These laws need adjustments by people who understand digital goods, but preventing you from redistributing the product through law is an understandable goal.

-1
chuzuki•

And if your car no longer meets safety requirements? No longer allowed to DRIVE the car, sorry.

Not entirely true. For example, if your car was built before seat belts were required and was not shipped from the factory with them, you are not required to install any and can still legally drive the car. Same for the shoulder strap if your car only has the lap belt. This probably doesn't apply in all states/countries, IANAL.

Also, driving on public roads is not a right, but I can do whatever the fuck I want in whatever vehicle I can legally obtain on my own property, or on private roads as long as I abide by their rules. Don't even need a driver's license.

1
abw1987•

Yes, if that was part of the terms of purchase, or if that was the law. I mean, it would suck, but I would abide by it.

-5
fishy007•

Well it's neither. Honda has decided that the car you purchased 3 years ago shall no longer have a radio. They have decreed that you cannot turn on the radio.

A law that was passed last month gives Honda the right to do anything they want with your car.

So the law doesn't say that you can't listen to the radio, but Honda says you can't. The law just says that you can't disobey Honda. The radio still works and you can flip it on....but you'd be breaking the law because you disobeyed Honda.

Cool?

7
mindbleach•

Quit breathing my air, serf.

2
kokey•

Yeah sorry being rational here doesn't float very far. People have some kind of entitlement thing even if entertainment media is offered to them on unreasonable terms. I simply won't bother with entertainment media I can't buy on reasonable terms, there's more than enough I can get on reasonable terms. I think this was quite clear when a lot of people didn't buy anything from iTunes, including myself, because of inferior quality and DRM. Once they changed that, I've become a regular iTunes customer.

0
abw1987•

The voice of reason!

-1

Do not send an email or fill out some online form. That is taking the easy way out. We all need to take the time to hand write a letter and drop it in the mail.

39
vsTerminusOP•

Not everyone has the time, or cares enough to give the time. Also, most of us have terrible handwriting.

While a handwritten letter is probably the equivalent of 20 emails, that doesn't mean we shouldn't send those too. Every voice counts.

(But yes, if you can handwrite a letter, please do so!)

5
pokita•

That is such a ridiculous excuse. Print it out and mail it in if you're so worried about illegible handwriting. A physical copy is much harder for politicians to ignore.

33
B_is_for_Buddha•

"Delete"

vs.

"Crumple...crumple...toss"

The man is right.

15
ebbomega•

In every instance that someone I know has handwritten a letter to a Canadian politician they had gotten an actual response, and not just a form letter.

5
jeff303•

For the truly lazy

There are many such services.

1
gjs278•

I care but not that much!

-1
PShap•

I'm an intern in a senators office in the US. Trust me, writing a letter carries much more weight. Calling also works.

12
MercurialMadnessMan•

writing a letter carries much more weight

hehe. Two-fold truth! Trufold!

2
mylescloutier•

FIND THE DAMN TIME.

This is our fucking country at stack for fucks sake. FUCK

Sorry I don't usually react that loudly...

1
ChaosMotor•

Seeing as how email is accepted as legitimate discourse in all other realms of interaction, maybe we should elect representatives who engage in the modern life of the public?

5

One thing at a time my friend.

1
i95SUX•

That would involve thinking for yourself and stepping outside the 2-party system, which is generally called "throwing away your vote". And as long as we continue to think like that, it is. Maybe by using free time and starting local, change can be effected, but that would possibly involve missing some of those engaging reality TV shows, or playing less WoW or something.

1
ChaosMotor•

The only time you throw away your vote is when you vote for someone who doesn't have your own interests in mind, that is to say, when you vote WITHIN the two-party system.

1
TheRiverStyx•

I pointed this out in another thread. They responded to my signature on an e-petition by sending a form email stating that the bill would promote advancement and a bunch of crap I'd expect a politician to say. I replied, which I'm sure will be ignored, by stating that they have been lied to by corporations and people who p2p are the biggest paying supporters of the media as well. Not only that, but I made it clear that it will be complete crap to make someone pay money for media that they can't use on advanced technology to watch it the way they want.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-7
Fenryx•

Herpderp, if I make a comment deriding Israel, I get upvotes, right? Right? Right?!

...someone please love me.

-6
mayonesa•

Check comment history and then think on it.

1
Fenryx•

You have so much comment history, and I have so little caring/effort. If it was sarcasm, then sorry.

I just get annoyed by how reddit likes to bandwagon on causes and get outraged at everything Israel does.

2
jotaroh•

so how does this affect bit torrent downloads?

31
vsTerminusOP•

In a big way. Copyright holders will be able to accuse the uploader of copyright violation, and said uploader's ISP would be forced to inform the person that he/she has broken the law, and then the ISP has to turn over the uploader's personal information to the copyright holder.

Does that sound like something you want in law?

40
cabbit•

Actually the 'Notice and Notice' system being added doesn't involve turning over any personal information.

Here's how Notice & Notice works:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notice_and_notice

26
vsTerminusOP•

Thanks for the link. Either way it's not a system I want in place. And I'm sure ISPs don't want to monitor every single customer either.

22
TheRiverStyx•

I worked for an ISP. Trust me when I say this: this will cost ISPs tens of thousands or millions (depending on the size) if they do or don't implement monitoring.

14
fetchit•

They are doing this in New Zealand soon, the ISPs complained because a lot of them were using dynamic IPs and so they need to make a lot of changes to be able to match people via IP.

Not to mention if you can't download torrents anymore, would you need such a big data cap. I guess people would drop it back a bit and leave ISPs out of pocket.

It's a bit silly to complain about preventing illegal torrents though, I know its illegal and they should be able to try and stop me. But stopping you use the stuff that you brought with your own money is horrible.

2
MemeGoneWild•

Ok, HOW THE FUCK DO WE FIGHT THIS! Writing our MP's is not a big enough step, I mean full on protests, let's march on Parliament!

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
meddlepal•

So really, the message to be taken from this is that you shouldn't be pirating stuff to begin with?

2
Veggie•

Shit. So I shouldn't have started like 30 TV show downloads this morning before work, not even knowing anything about this bill until I heard about it on the radio?

1
[deleted]•

Not a law yet... you're fine.. for now.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SuperSoggyCereal•

Why not just use a private tracker?

1
[deleted]•

What section in the bill does it state this. I'm writing a letter to my MP and I thought it would be helpful to drectly reference parts I'm in disagreement with

1
faircopyright•

Egad! But I'd like to be able to steal things without fear of penalty! This is outrageous...

-1
i95SUX•

Copyright infrigment is very different from theft. If i steal your apple, you cannot eat it. If i copy your music, their is a possibility you have lost a sale, yet you still have your music.

1
ribosometronome•

If you're going to download something, consider using usenet instead. Often times, it's faster. You can connect via SSL and download with relative privacy (your ISP won't know what you're downloading). You don't have the same risk of being caught as you're not uploading to the service.

The only downside is that it's not free. Astraweb is one of the cheapest and is ~15 a month for unlimited downloads or you can purchase 25 or 180 gigabytes of downloads at a time.

2
[deleted]•

I sent an email to Mackay, it's probably pointless, but I have to try something.

14
[deleted]•

Not probably pointless, definitely pointless, because MP's don't care much about stuff from the internet. Send him a hand-written letter by mail. They do care about those.

19
[deleted]•

Now that is a good idea. I'm going to try this too.

5
xtirpation•

Actually, about a year ago, Ontario was trying to pass a bunch of laws that basically targeted and discriminated against young drivers. I sent an email and actually got a real response (or at least so I think, they were able to quote parts of what I wrote)

Hand-written letters definitely have a bigger impact though

3
vsTerminusOP•

It's never pointless. The more people sending letters, the more pressure we put on the MPs to not simply archive the letter and move on.

4
ZebZ•

One sent email represents about 10 voters. One mailed form letter represents about 100 voters. One mailed handwritten letter or one phone call represents about 1000 voters.

8
vsTerminusOP•

I'd better get to work improving my handwriting.

8
KnightKrawler•

Start with your A's. Then move onto E's. Once you can get to where you can go both of those fluidly, move onto the other vowels.

Only work on one letter at a time and within less then a year I guarantee you'll love your new handwriting. Also, SLOW THE FUCK DOWN when writing.

1
mylescloutier•

You can print you know...like with your hand, or did you mean that and not cursive...

1
nerox3•

one copy paste of a form letter to e-mail represents 1 vote

1
YHZ•

You live in Central Nova too?

2
VisualBasicGUI•

From the Trews reference of the name, I'm guessing somewhere towards Antigonish. I used to live in Central Nova as well.

2
[deleted]•

Wow, I never expected anyone to get that reference! Nova Scotia is a great place.

2
TheseIronBones•

This is Canada, its probably going to get derailed by an issue that has nothing to do with it, like a prorogation or a non confidence vote.

Just like the previous 3 bills

13
Fenryx•

Woo non-functional federal system.

9
TheseIronBones•

Its saving my ass

11
mylescloutier•

And of course, since a coalition was talked about in the media recently Harper is in full propaganda mode. "Losers don't get to form coalitions." is his latest line.

SHUT THE HELL UP PARTIES WITHOUT A MAJORITY DON'T GET TO RUN OUR COUNTRY Your job is to work with the other parties and CANADIANS to form our laws, not US and international Corporations.

1
dsmyte•

This annoys me to no end.

Outlawing the breaking of DRM is the same as outlawing a tool. Tools should never be outlawed, actions should be.

I figure if they want to make it illegal to break digital locks, why not make it illegal to break ALL locks. Locked yourself out of your car? Fuck you, go buy a new car. How about you house? Well fuck you too, tear that fucker down.

Fuck US lobbyists and their scum backers.

(Sorry for all the profanity, but after writing my MP last night and being exceptionally polite, I needed to get it off my chest!)

13
vsTerminusOP•

I had a good laugh at this, thanks :)

4
nas•

Tools should never be outlawed, actions should be.

I was going to write almost the same thing. The lock is a pretty good analogy.

If people are writing letters, I think it would be a good idea to try to explain in simple terms why the DRM section is a bad idea. Best is probably personal stories of how it would affect you.

For example, a few years ago I purchased some audio books from Audible. As you might know, their audio files are DRM protected. Fast forward a few years and my new audio player can no longer play the files. Since I believe it was within my rights, I used a procedure involving Goldwave to remove the DRM.

Now, taking the DRM-free files and distributing them would infringe on the original creator's copyrights. However, that's already illegal, even without this new bill.

Microsoft's audio DRM debacle is also a nice example. Imagine if either through malice or incompetence the organization controlling the DRM for a bunch of media you purchased suddenly locks you out. It's not just a crazy theory, it has happened and will surely happen in the future. What would the DRM supporters say, "sorry, pay for that media again"?

2
[deleted]•

Tools should never be outlawed, actions should be.

So I take it you're against gun control?

2
dsmyte•

Well, considering I'm an avid hunter, yes, I am against gun control.

And for the record, I'm somewhat indifferent to the idea of registering my guns, it's the current boondoggle scheme that I'm opposed to (and you should be too considering the massive amount of money they wasted).

2
[deleted]•

I don't care about Canuck money. :D

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dsmyte•

Ha, of course not, and feel free to help refine them to make the more legible - it's all about sharing how to verbalize our stand against this bill and then getting it into the hands of all MPs.

1
cliv•

Don't the interoperability exclusions in Article 41.12 make this argument null and void?

41.12 (1) Paragraph 41.1(1)(a) does not apply to a person who owns a computer program or a copy of one, or has a licence to use the program or copy, and who circumvents a technological protection measure that protects that program or copy for the sole purpose of obtaining information that would allow the person to make the program and any other computer program interoperable.

13
TiDaN•

This is a good point, I'm interested to know the answer to your question as well.

Upvote this man!

2
[deleted]•

In theory, but the media companies will just sue anyone and make them prove, at great cost, that their behavior fits the exclusion. It's happened more than once with the DMCA.

0
cliv•

Not that I doubt you, but do you have any examples of this happening?

Wouldn't defending this be as easy as "Here's DRMed thing, it now works with software B, case closed"?

1
[deleted]•

There was a professor of comp sci, I think, here in the states who did work that involved decrypting some kind of copyright protection measure - maybe CSS - and his university was more or less pressured to have him not present his research because of it's legally dubious nature.

Wouldn't defending this be as easy as "Here's DRMed thing, it now works with software B, case closed"?

Maybe. I'm not a lawyer. But maybe not. The major problem with the whole scheme is that it requires licensing. If you haven't been licensed (paid money to the industry trade group), you're basically the enemy. You have to remember, these guys are thugs, what they want is to completely control the hardware involved in delivering the movie/cd/whathaveyyou to you, so that they can charge you every time. That's just how they think. In the US, you can simply expect to be sued even if your actions abide by the letter of the law. They don't care about being good citizens. So you might have a successful defense but it will cost you a lot of money to use it.

edit: you might find more info about who has run afoul of the DMCA if you search on Slashdot. They've covered the DMCA from the beginning.

1
cliv•

For the Comp. Sci professor's case - There's a provision specifically for that as well. 41.13 (1) Paragraph 41.1(1)(a) does not apply to a person who, for the purposes of encryption research, circumvents a technological protection measure by means of decryption if (a) it would not be practical to carry out the research without circumventing the techno- logical protection measure;

2
NaturesRevenge•

Just FMI, how does copyright law in America work for me, I use Ubuntu for almost everything except PhotoShop and MS specific apps.

10
vsTerminusOP•

The US has the DMCA, which already affects you in most of the ways I brought up here. Watching a DVD on Ubuntu in the states is currently illegal, it's just not something you hear about in court.

25
NaturesRevenge•

Urge to kill..... rising.

34
Lord_Illidan•

Killing is definitely illegal though.

26
fungosaurus•

Urge to storm down the sidewalk with a frown on my face...... rising.

25
NaturesRevenge•

Yeah, but does it violate copyright law?

6
Nathan2508•

I've heard about this in court a few times.

4
trek42•

What if you challenge them to a duel?

2
muahdib•

It is only illegal to kill other human beings, but not monsters.

1
mylescloutier•

It's always the good people who get assassinated...John Lennon, Martin Luther King Jr, etc. And Bush gets a SHOE thrown?

No wonder they do what they like, they aren't scared of us. Instead it's the opposite, like a vicious dictatorship.

0
NaturesRevenge•

Down vote for the fact that I hate the Beetles music, yeah i know, I'm a bad person.

0
diafygi•

That's not true. Section 1201 of the DMCA specifically outlaws the distribution of circumvention tools.

No person shall manufacture, import, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof, that is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title

-DMCA 1201(a)(2)

It does not outlaw the use of those tools. Fair use of circumvention tools is legal according to the DMCA.

Nothing in this section shall affect rights, remedies, limitations, or defenses to copyright infringement, including fair use, under this title

-DMCA 1201(c)(1)

So, is is legal for Ubuntu to distribute libdvdcss2 in the US? No. Is it legal to watch DVDs on Ubuntu using libdvdcss2 in the US? Yes. No one inside the us can distribute that program to you, however, so you have to find it outside of the US. This is why the medibuntu repositories are hosted in a country that still allows circumvention program distrobution.

This was backed up by the recent RealNetworks v. DVD-CCA decision that said:

while it may well be fair use for an individual consumer to store a backup copy of a personally owned DVD on that individual's computer, a federal law has nonetheless made it illegal to manufacture or traffic in a device or tool that permits a consumer to make such copies.

Final Injunction [PDF]

7
muahdib•

Watching a DVD on Ubuntu in the states is currently illegal

I don't like harming other living creatures in any way, but anyone that has proposed something like that need to DIE. If I had such a beast in front of me, despite the peace loving non violent person I am, I would kill, in pure self defence of the humanity.

Someone that can, in full seriousity, propose that kind of laws is not a human being.

3
Markuss69•

That is absolutely ridiculous. What is the logic behind this?

Edit: nvm I read on...

2
vsTerminusOP•

Money-grabbing corporations want to money-grab?

Also a bit of a control thing. Apparently how we use our media is up for debate too...

7
zero_armada•

...This is news to me. I've never heard of such a thing before.

1
vsTerminusOP•

This is the third or fourth attempt in the last 10 years. Each time parliament is dissolved or something else happens to shut it down before it can be voted into law.

3
crazy88s•

Well, if you use a DVD player that has been created with knowledge gained from reverse engineering, then it is against DMCA.

1
happinesslost•

It's not really the player, it's the decryption engine, libdvdcss, that poses a legal issue.

2
interfect•

No, watching a DVD using an open-source player is illegal, because there are no licensed open-source players. Properly licensed, closed-source players have been created for Linux, they are just hard to find. Nobody really wants them because the unlicensed players are freely available.

1
kefs•

Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck Fuck!

9
[deleted]•

Not sure why this post is so Linux centric. Your bill is about regions on dvd's not on what os you play it on. Linux has plenty of media apps that are licensed to play different codecs etc. Netflix on linux in canada is no more breaking terms than netflix on windows.

In short, you make it sound as if Canada AND the US are targeting linux in dmca and it's just not correct.

8
dragonvpm•

The reason that Linux pops out as having a particular problem is because it often isn't supported and anti-circumvention provisions often mean that the reverse engineering needed to make something work with Linux might be illegal under the new laws.

Open source tends to scare those with a strongly vested interest in trying to control what you do with your hardware (see Sony removing it as a boot option on PS3s).

14
[deleted]•

It'd be a different story if they made a fucking player for Linux, but they're too fucking wrapped up in their own lame ass windows centric DRM bullshit it's not going to happen.

2
[deleted]•

I use lame too.

7
gimpbully•

"they" do, fluendo and powerdvd have been mentioned many times. They are legally licensed players available for linux.

1
[deleted]•

Yes, but are they available for the BSDs?

1
vsTerminusOP•

It affects all Canadians, but Linux users moreso. I am a Linux user and it will affect me personally.

Regions on DVDs applies to everyone, but it will soon be illegal to watch any DVD on linux, as that would require decoding it, opening the potential to pirate it. Same applies to blu-ray.

Netflix is refusing to support Linux officially; To make it work we'll be breaking their terms to use an unsupported OS to view copyrighted material. Instant crime.

It is very similar to the US DMCA, but that doesn't make it right.

13
porksmash•

When you say Netflix is refusing to support Linux, I assume you mean their instant streaming feature. I'm just curious.. how do you currently use Linux to view instant streams?

4
vsTerminusOP•

What I saw about Netflix I read on the Ubuntu forums, here.

I'm not a Netflix user personally, but I know plenty of people who love the service.

5
sotek2345•

I will have to check that out - I have had absolutely no luck getting it to work

6
[deleted]•

Too bad your facts are off, it has nothing to do with linux. Netflix is not offered to Canada..period. The studios did not license it and if you use netflix in Canada it's illegal no matter what OS.

You are flat out wrong on dvd playback, there are licensed pieces of software that are developed by linux publishers but you might GASP have to pay for it, and do something that supports open source development.

4
meatsocket•

It won't be illegal to watch any DVD on linux- you can buy licensed codecs from Fluendo and PowerDVD (via Canonical or your OEM).

2
vsTerminusOP•

What happens when they decide that just any old CSS license will do? What happens when you're locked into iTunes and Windows Media Player and everything else is considered a crime?

Maybe you'll be ok with it. But I know a lot of people who won't be, and saying "tough luck, get over it" doesn't cut it.

2
backelie•

What if the world isn't a slippery slope and arguments can be judged on their own merit today?

3
gimpbully•

so you just don't want to pay for a licensed player?

2
mayonesa•

it will soon be illegal to watch any DVD on linux, as that would require decoding it, opening the potential to pirate it

So the real problem is a lack of DRM-compliant apps on Linux.

-2
vsTerminusOP•

Do you see that going away any time soon? New technologies will arise and some of them will choose to not support Linux, and we will be at the hands of the law if we attempt to change that, even for private, personal use.

Especially for something as mainstream as a DVD, it has a huge impact.

2
mayonesa•

Do you see that going away any time soon?

Yes, as Linux and its components get more competent for desktop use, which is really only a last 2-3 years event. Once we get a real substitute for Microsoft Office, not the odious Open Office, there's a chance of many people switching over.

In the meantime, nothing is stopping you or me from starting a company that sells compliant Linux players for $5.

2
eviljames•

Uhh, I would like to lend you a loonie so you can buy a clue. The passing of this bill will, indeed, instantly criminalize many, many Linux users in Canada. Myself included.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
thebigslide•

They will have to be very careful about what packages are installed.

12
vsTerminusOP•

And what media they stream.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

First I was not rude in my post so I'm glad you can let your inner six year old show in your response.

Second, fact is this will also criminalize many many Windows users. The OP is hyping some sort of Linux angle here that does not exist. The same thing can be said for any OS in Canada. It doesn't matter what OS you use to break terms it's illegal. So if there is some good reason to pinpoint Linux in this list of vague violations then by all means good sir enlighten me.

6
slammaster•

I think the point is that you don't have to break terms on Windows, where you do on Linux. Reverse engineering drivers, trying to manage iPods, playing DVDS are all things which NECESSARILY require breaking DRMs on linux, while on Windows you don't have to (though most people still do).

12
interfect•

Is the code on iPods that makes it hard to use them without iTunes really DRM? What content is it protecting?

1
[deleted]•

Even if that is his point he is wrong. There are licensed and legal players for dvds and most codecs on Linux, If this post were about supporting developers for linux then it would be fine with me, but it's about some sort of bs angle that does not exist.

Netflix is illegal in Canada period. Doesn't matter what os you use there is no studio license for streaming in Canada. Scratch that one, it's done.

Dvd playback can be done as well as most popular formats in Linux legally but you might have to shell out a buck and gasp! support a linux developer.

I'm not keen on itunes/ipod/imac/etc etc but frankly, it's apple is this news to you? Probably not and the same thing applies everywhere, stop supporting a company that is fundamentally opposed to the open source framework.

If you don't want to support oss then push for your peers to use a truly open source media format, plenty out there that sure as hell beat mp3 etc.

In short, this post is just a bunch of hype for some guys agenda and he's trying to take Linux users and people who are generally unfamiliar with the oss model and exploit it.

1
ratbear•

Thats not true...there are proprietary media players available for Linux that don't use clandestine measures to break the copy protection.

-1
mayonesa•

The OP is hyping some sort of Linux angle here that does not exist.

Agreed. The law is about circumventing DRM, not using an operating system that doesn't have DRM built in. It's the act of ripping the media that is illegal.

6
[deleted]•

see my response here

1
vsTerminusOP•

Windows tends to be officially supported by large corporations. Linux, not so much. Instead we resort to having to break copyright protection methods in order to simply view the content we have already paid for.

So yes, it may apply to all OSs, it's more likely to apply to Linux users.

5
asdfg2435•

we resort to having to break copyright protection methods

If you stop doing that and continue using Linux, will you run afoul of the law?

Your headline is similar to someone saying, "Bricks are illegal because smashing windows (pardon the pun) is a crime."

8
gimpbully•

by the exact same measure, why shouldn't the people that paid developers to make css be allowed to charge? You seem to accept that the movie studio is performing a legitimate transaction with you (ie: you haven't stolen the movie) but reject the content protection company's transaction right to charge for their product.

1
ratbear•

Then use a supported platform...why is that such a difficult concept to understand?

-10
eviljames•

First I was not rude in my post so I'm glad you can let your inner six year old show in your response.

Wow, you're going to have to become a lot less sensitive if you plan on using the internet for any extended period of time. I can offer some helpful supplies - I keep a box of tissues near the computer, but they aren't usually used for tears.

It doesn't matter what OS you use to break terms it's illegal

So you are fully of the mind that if I purchase a DVD - which (in theory) is a license to watch and re-watch a copy of the movie/tv show/donkeyporn - I should only be able to do it on the devices certain companies approve of. I am not allowed to have the freedom to use this disc, and/or this content in the way I see fit? We will assume for this discussion that "the way I see fit" does not include making 1,000 counterfeit copies and selling them at half the price or any other obvious copyright infringement, I'm talking about using it in the way it was intended for personal reasons. The loonie offer is still on the table.

-2
[deleted]•

you offered me a loonie so I could buy a clue. That's not only rude, but childish.

Don't flatter yourself on my sensitive nature being shook up, you aren't that clever.

Now when you are ready to to learn something. Allow someone who has actively developed software in the spirit of oss for years to explain some things to you.

On this post / A. Netflix = Illegal to use in Canada period. The studio licenses do not exist, this has nothing to do with linux. HYPE

/ B. Legal and licensed means to view DVD formats as well as any popular proprietary media format out there are available. If this post were truly here to educate Linux users in Canada and elsewhere, then the OP could have endorsed the support of Linux developers.

/C. there are so many formats out there that are absolutely better than the mainstream in every way that are completely open source. Endorse these methods and as a bonus, your songs sound better than some mp3 format.

/D. The fundamentally lost idea to most new Linux users is that the community was never about free as in beer only. The community absolutely encourages the support of developers who have created legitimate software for Linux.

You took my words well out of context as you were obviously thinking of some witty comment to further illustrate your lack of understanding on the issue. But to reiterate from your "clever rebuttal" When I stated that it does not matter what OS you use to break terms, I was referring solely to the Netflix service. And it stands, Netflix = not available legally in Canada.

You took that comment and turned it into a DVD/DRM related comment. I think I've covered that above in Section B. Have a good day "sir"

3
asdfg2435•

You do not have the right to play a DVD in your toaster. That DVD was not designed to be played in a toaster.

You do not have the right to play a DVD on your Linux desktop. That DVD was not designed to be played on a Linux desktop.

Both toasters and Linux desktops will continue to be 100% legal.

EDIT: To clarify: Yes, media companies' iron-fisted lock on their "intellectual property" (which they virtually steal from the artists who actually make that property) sucks. I agree. But that does not mean Linux is illegal.

1
ClashTheBunny•

But you're already breaking the license. Why is it a big deal that it's wrong in another way now? Don't use content unless you are given permission to use content. Go find better content producers who don't mind you viewing their work.

EDIT: What's the deal with the down votes? You agree to a license when you watch a DVD. You should know your rights, but you should also not exaggerate your rights.

-1
Rhomboid•

Don't use content unless you are given permission to use content.

So, you are actually suggesting with a straight face that because nobody has produced a licensed DVD or BluRay player that linux users everywhere should just sigh and resign themselves to never watching a single DVD or BluRay, ever, even if they bought them at full retail price?

Go find better content producers who don't mind you viewing their work.

Please name any non-art-school movie on DVD that doesn't use CSS. It's not even optional on BluRay.

6
ClashTheBunny•

Why not buy a legal DVD decoder for Linux then: PowerDVD Linux

2
[deleted]•

Already did this. This morning.

8
vsTerminusOP•

Thank you :)

Post the reply in r/Canada when you get it.

8
[deleted]•
1
gf3•

Also emailing!

2
dsmyte•

Me too, one to my Liberal MP, one to Harper.

2
torchlit_Thompson•

As a young American, I view the 1st Amendment to the Bill of Rights as the Freedom to Disseminate Data, as in the act of speaking. It's not the governments job to assist corporations in circumventing this freedom to streamline their business models. If I want to post encryption keys on my FB status update, or a link to a bit torrent file, I'm well within my rights to spread whatever information I choose. Eventually, they will push too many of us too far, and we'll push back with a class action, citing 1st Amendment, Equal Protection, and anti-Trust violations that not even Scalia will be able to legally cartwheel around. Hopefully.

8
gimpbully•

You might want to research the supreme court's stance on the first amendment. Like it or not, the government drawn up by the constitution was designed to rule on these matters. Their rulings directly dispute your perception that the first amendment provides you the right to distribute whatever you damn well please.

And really? They're going to push you too far? Because you feel you should be able to post other people's creations to your heart's content? Find a better cause.

2
torchlit_Thompson•

Then we change the rulebook, easy peasy. It's called an amendment, and I believe that it has been done before. If someone, or a group of someones, like a corporation, want to use money and influence to profit from exclusive access to information, fuck them. Data knows no boundaries, except the one's that are self-imposed.

1
gimpbully•

we should amend the constitution so you can post other people's content to bittorrent or simply choose to not pay for technology companies have spent money on creating?

1
UnboughtStuffedDogs•

The DMCA is only a decade old, and its big malignant sibling ACTA is going to make things even more interesting (restrictive) sooner or later, when is this hard wind a-gonna blow? Can it be soon?

1
AmateurGod•

As a big linux fan, I disagree fundamentally with the copyright law. However, you shouldn't be shocked to be considered a criminal for breaking it, especially when there are alternatives to the unlicensed software, such as fluendo: http://www.fluendo.com/shop/product/fluendo-dvd-player/

So you were inaccurate to say that using DVDs on linux makes you a criminal. What you should have said was using DVDs on linux via unlicensed software makes you a criminal.

8
[deleted]•

If you haven't caught on, the whole angle he has here is to make it seem as if this is a linux centric issue when it is not. Netflix for example is not legal to use in canada no matter what os you use.

Instead of pushing for people to use open media formats, or to purchase licensed software from linux devs, he's using this for some agenda that is bs.

5
Infectaphibian•

Yep, nice piece of anti-Linux propaganda from the fine folks that brought you this legislation.

1
jsantos17•

Last time I checked the GPL is still a license. Or maybe you mean it's illegal for me to play if I haven't paid them again for a playback license?

2
free_world•

So you want me to install propriety licensing software on my FOSS Linux installation? I think not. This would be enough for me to consider leaving Canada (seriously) and I'm not a criminal.

1
gimpbully•

so consider this honestly, why are the creators of the CSS algorithm not entitled to make money off the technology?

1
free_world•

So, let me get this straight. If I purchase a movie and watch it on my Linux computer as opposed to a player with a special codec, both of which have the same effect (me viewing my personal property) that makes me a criminal? This is dangerous territory.

0
gimpbully•

why are the creators of the CSS algorithm not entitled to make money off the technology?

1
danweber•

Where do people who are sick of Canada move to? The North Pole?

0
durple•

Came here to say basically this. Although I would focus more on the unencumbered media formats as an alternative rather than licensed codecs/software for encumbered formats. Not that I am anything close to a purist myself when it comes to this sort of stuff.

1
Asparagon•

I think what the OP meant that Linux within it's self is unlicensed software. Thus using DVDs on Linux is illegal.

0
[deleted]•

that would be incorrect even if it were what he was trying to convey.

3
free_world•

Right. If you own the damn movie, you own the damn movie. Frankly, all this shit makes me not even want to buy another movie unless it has completely no copyright.

1
gimpbully•

You've (probably) never really bought a movie. Movies cost thousands to millions of dollars. You've bought media and a license.

0
Asparagon•

Well then I apologize for I was mistaken, was simply trying to convey the OP's message.

1
universal_apologist•

out of curiosity is fluendo free software? If not, that might make it unusable to many linux users.

-1
interfect•

No. Even if it were, CSS licensing terms would not be compatible with any open-source license, so you'd need to license all the DVD stuff yourself if you wanted to run or release your own build.

1
[deleted]•

No, that would make it unusable for linux users who are unwilling to support linux developers by purchasing a licensed piece of software. Linux is not about being free as in beer but as in choice, this author and many newer linux users have missed this fundamental piece of the community by a long shot.

1
gimpbully•

i don't think you understand the definition of 'unusable'

1
[deleted]•

to meet US agenda

Why would Canada need to meet US agenda? Do they receive aid from the United States? What happens if they don't follow US agenda?

5
wtfisthat•

They bomb Toronto.

8
vsTerminusOP•

Pressure from the US does more than most people realize. We have trade agreements with the US and we depend on them to buy our stuff instead of buying from China or elsewhere first.

They pressure us, we refuse, they stop buying Canadian exports, we suffer.

4
Hav0kc•

Actually it's not the US agenda but 2 1996 WIPO treaties. The DMCA bring US copyright law in line with the WIPO treaties. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act It's only a matter of time until Canadian Law catches up, hopefully though we can do so in a much more fair fashion that does not punish the consumer

1
ratbear•

He's talking about meeting the agenda of the big U.S. media companies, since Canada is a bit player when it comes to popular culture in North America.

1
mysticalfruit•

This is a bill written by multinational corporations for their benefit. In a nutshell, they've gazed out upon this "internet" thing and they don't like what they see. It's way too open for their liking. They're still stuck in the TV age and don't know how to adapt to the pervasive digital age.

It doesn't matter what OS, device you use... it's all about control. If they don't explicitly allow it, it's against the law.

They've got the laws, but we've got the numbers...

5
vsTerminusOP•

If they don't explicitly allow it, it's against the law.

That's the argument I want to get across here. People have been countering with "Well there are DRM complient alternatives to use", but that doesn't solve the problem you just pointed out.

Thank you

3
wtfisthat•

I wrote my MP. I explained to him how digital locks/encryption that is legally protects is not protected from criminals, especially in other countries. I told him that locks gets stronger when scrutiny is allowed, such as with AES2 etc. I told him that closed, legally protected systems will probably end up protecting sensitive information somewhere, potentially making it even more vulnerable to said criminals. I hope he is smart enough to understand, but that may be hoping for too much.

5
vsTerminusOP•

Well at least you tried. And thank you for doing so.

Even if your MP doesn't understand, he may do some research if he genuinely cares.

1
easlern•

Shitty hyperbole. You know, it is possible to own a Linux machine and never do any of those things.

OMG HEY GUYS LINUX ARE ILLEGAL NOW

3
vsTerminusOP•

Most of the Linux users I know watch movies. Some linux users have MythTV boxes setup and do nothing but.

Just because you're on one end of the spectrum doesn't mean the rest of it should be ignored.

-2
easlern•

So what you're saying is that because you use specific software affected by this legislation, everyone using Linux becomes "a criminal."

Look, I don't give a rat's ass about the moral debate here. I'm just pointing out that you chose a shitty title because the law you're talking about will not affect every Linux user.

8
vsTerminusOP•

You're right, of course. I should have picked my wording better.

2
matchpoint•

Contacted my member of parliament, told him how I feel. Feels good man.

3
vsTerminusOP•

Thank you! If you get a response, post it in r/Canada :)

1
twizzle12•

Will yours listen? I keep getting shitty canned responses. Thank you for your input bla bla bla this is for your own good etc.

0
Confucius_says•

I don't get why this affects linux users only, wouldnt it be illegal to do these things on windows or mac as well?

3
[deleted]•

It doesn't, this whole thread is bs hype. You can't use netflix in canada legally period. No matter the os.

2
vsTerminusOP•

It's illegal on mac as well, except that Apple is moving towards a very locked down, walled-garden type environment. Soon Apple users won't be able to make the choice to use software like VLC at all; Whatever Steve Jobs puts on their plate is what's for dinner.

1