Are you a Canadian Linux user? You're about to become a criminal.
None of the items below will automatically make you a criminal in all situations; It will affect individuals differently depending on their circumstances. The bill is also not centered around Linux, but it has a very strong impact on Linux as we know it.
Yes, there are alternative players for Linux which are properly licensed, but this bill gives copyright holders the ability to define what a 'properly licensed' player is via the terms of their DRM. What happens when they decide that iTunes is the only licensed media player for DVDs and Blu-Ray?
I posted this in /r/linux and am spreading it here to raise awareness.
A new copyright amendment bill was announced yesterday in Canada. Bill C-32 attempts to 'modernize' copyright law in Canada to bring it up to spec with other developed nations (aka to meet US agenda).
The bill would make it illegal to circumvent or break locks of any kind on digital media, even for personal use. This supersedes all other provisions of the bill, which means you may be a criminal if you
- Own and play region-locked DVDs from other countries
- Play regular DVDs on Linux
- Play Blu-Ray Discs on Linux
- Transfer media to an iPod Touch / iPhone / iPad using Linux
- Strip the DRM from your music (via re-recording or any other method)
- Listen to music files that have specific DRM restrictions
And anything else that involves protected content that lacks official Linux support.
Speak up while you can. Find your MP and write them an email telling them why you are opposed to C-32.
We don't want a US style DMCA, please don't let that happen.
Edit: Here is a template, based on the email I sent to my own MP that you can use if you like.
Second Edit: If you can spare the time, please consider handwriting a letter and mailing or delivering it in person to your MP. This will have a huge impact compared to an email. However, please don't let that stop you from sending your email, every voice counts!
Dear <Your MP>,
I am writing to you again to express a major point of concern I have found with the newly tabled Bill C-32. While this bill appears to make many positive changes, there is one clause which is particularly troubling.
In Article 41 it becomes clear to me that any media with Digital Rights Management (DRM) protection applied supersedes all other changes introduced by the bill. For example, <Something that affects you personally, such as not being able to legally watch DVDs on Linux>
This bill does not help the consumer, and it does not help the copyright owner either. If it does not help either of these parties, who is benefiting from it?
Bill C-32 has potential, but it needs work.
Thank you for your time,
-<Your Name>
Article 41: http://www2.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=4580265&Mode=1&Language=F&File=72#16
Posted Jun 3, 2010, 5:49 PM UTC · edited
Does anyone else fear the old politicians that have zero understanding of computers, yet they regulate them?
They don't understand the energy, insurance or health care businesses either, but this doesn't stop them from taking suitcases full of money from lobbyists and making laws to regulate those in business-favorable ways.
Nothing special about technology.
Its worse than you think.
Lobbyist: to Senator (scene, resteraunt):
By the way, since I know you're so busy, I wrote up the bill for you. All you have to do is present it thus saving your time that would have been spent on researching and writing so you can now go to that fundraiser you wanted.
What, Senator? Oh, no, lunch is on me. The restaurant priced it a dollar under what is considered to be a reportable lobbyist gift. Thank god, otherwise I'd have to run up two credit cards on a single lunch.
This is why I'm so opposed to the proposed senate reform into an American style senate.
Perhaps we should write the bills we want to see instead of just protesting against the ones lobbyists present? I don't know the first thing about it though - is it terribly difficult?
Don't get me wrong: this doesn't mean we shouldn't communicate with your representative often. Often they're just listening to whoever's doing the most talking, and that tends not to be the people that elect them (for most issues). Trust me they do indeed care about the personal letters/phonecalls/visits - or at least the new, less secure ones do.
[deleted]
check out the pirateparty.ca for more ideas. I'm not a member myself, but I do believe in a lot of things they do.
Makes campaign finance reform look like the joke that it is. All that current measures at campaign finance reform do is make it harder for anybody to compete with the established politicians, there's a reason why the concept was welcomed with open arms on Capital Hill.
[Directed by Oliver Stone]
[deleted]
You see, these old men don't write bills anymore whatsoever. Their friends in the industry write a bill that "regulates" the industry by gifting wonderful things to existing players while establishing regulatory firewalls against any new competitors.
I would have no problem with their laws if they were "business-favorable." If their laws were good for everyone's business, that would be great! Most productive people are involved in a business of some sort, and they would benefit from that.
What you mean is that their laws are favorable to the handful of businesses that bribe them, and horribly anti-business to the many productive people who would love to offer competitive alternatives.
Case in point: the very bill we're discussing right now.
You are correct, that is exactly what I meant.
I do believe that is called bribery.
Not if it's a "donation to campaign" or some other less-direct vehicle of sleaze.
[deleted]
If you click that link make sure to clear your cookies so this guy doesn't get a dime
[deleted]
It's part of the problem with politics as a whole. It takes many years to get to a position of power (usually). By that time, people tend to be a little out of touch with the world.
Intellectual Property address, for example ><
Why do people always assume that the politicians don't understand the issue? They understand it a lot better than you think. They just don't care about you.
I have a person in my life who is one of them. An elected Politician. They would just assume the Internet not exist, and if they can't have their way they are going to try and shut it down and bottle it up any way they can. And worse, they will succeed because we are a stupid public. If you want to stop this then you need to make some noise. Some more.
Well, at least most of the MP's aren't that old, the bigger problem is them not actually thinking about anything they vote on.
Fear? Didn't McCain flat-out prove it in 2008? The current generation of politicians is quite detached from the reality of the world. They want things the old way, and they simply don't get that they cannot have it anymore. Technology is constantly changing, and people need to be aware of that. If you're writing legislation on technological matters, you'd damn well better know more about technology than "I use the Google to get to Facebook, then to tweet all my friends!"
I fail to see how your emphasis affects what I wrote.
Both comments (yours and the one to which you replied) state that certain old politicians have zero understanding of computers, but it seems your reply was written under the assumption that the "fear" in the original was "I am afraid that they don't understand computers" instead of "I am afraid of them because they don't understand computers."
Your comment seems to imply that you thought it was "I am afraid that they don't understand computers" because of the way you used McCain as an example to say that this was not only possible or likely, but actually a demonstrated fact.
Minor point, really--it doesn't affect the validity of your main idea, with which I agree, in fact.
If it were the "old" way things would be better. What they want is total socialism , and dictatorship. Honestly 95% of politicians are complete and utter criminals. I mean look at everything that's happened. You think the BP oil spill actually means anything to capital hill? Hell no! Why do you think little is being done to punish BP? Because BP makes the government big money. This world is coming to a close soon unless we start making moves. =/
How exactly is this bill socialist in any way shape or form? How is it dictatorship? It's heavy handed, and it's favouring big business. Though we're getting fucked, we aren't getting fucked by Stalin's ghost.
This bill wasn't really what I was referring to. I guess I was being short sighted. I was talking about the whole picture and the way America is going. Sorry for not being clear on that and just ranting.
I completely agree, and I'm sure that there are much worse atrocities that happen daily that we as mere "peasants" are allowed to know about.
we need to do something about this bullshit before its too late
oh, you mean like everything else in life ever?
Advocacy groups pay them to have certain opinions. The advocacy groups exist only to make direct attacks on civilian populations. Downloading & piracy on an industrial scale is clearly detrimental, but aggressively prosecuting private individuals who are just sharing is absolutely not genuinely apply legal protections.
These advocacy groups don't produce anything; they are a cabal in the true sense of the word. The groups gathers enough resources to lobby for laws (DMCA) to make existing behavior on-paper illegal. From there, lawsuits generate revenue.
Remember, they produce nothing: RIAA, MPAA, BluRay Association, etc.
Unlike drugs, broadcasting, shipping, agriculture and pretty much everything apart from a limited knowledge of the law and money? No, this isn't a fear. Fear is usually reserved for something that MIGHt be a problem. This is rage.
Well, if they under zero; they are half way there! They just need to learn about the 1 and they'll know a lot on how computers work!
that's why i'm glad politicians in my country don't even bother about regulating them. Most of them don't even own pc's
And that the new politicians are without exception servants of the corporations.
Shoulder thing that goes up.
Does anyone else fear the old politicians that have zero understanding of anything, yet they regulate everything and fulfil there own agenda's and stuff their pockets with coporate moola?
My dear chap, politicians have no understanding of anything, that is why they are politicians. If politicians had had any talent for anything other than being a politician they would be using it.
Don't feel bad, in the US they don't even bother to read the bills before they vote on them. Thanks to that we have the patriot act.
I have said many times that the issues with having such people controlling our laws lies with their inability to rationalize computers and communications systems, so they would rather steamroll over them to err on the side of caution. This deprives responsible users of their rights and defeats the purpose of having a civilized legislation system. It is essentially the same reason we should try to keep religion out of politics. The ignorance of a few should not control the actions of the majority.