TheLazyPeon just released a 2020 impressions video for Crowfall, what do you think of Crowfall in 2020?

https://youtu.be/SRyrYBbBjJc

As someone who knows nothing about Crowfall (except that it's another indie kickstarter in perpetual development: PVP flavor), I am torn between two possiblities when I watch this gameplay of Crowfall

  1. It's one of those super complex games with no tutorial that expects you to figure it out or eat, sleep and breathe the wiki/youtube guides (Warframe, Terraria, Minecraft, Ark Survival, Rust, Path of Exile, etc.)

  2. It's a multimillion dollar unreal engine asset flip (launder the kickstarter money via the asset flip and keep the 99% profit margin)

Thoughts on Crowfall? In the wake of the Chronicles of Elyria cancellation I'm currently more inclined to believe possibility #2

Posted Mar 28, 2020, 9:03 PM UTC

069
Pyroxy3•

Is it released? No? Then I don't give a fuck.

84
PierreDelecto_2020•

Ah, finally someone with sane words of wisdom.

17
NetSage•

As a backer I hope it comes around. But honestly it's been so long with pretty shitty builds and plan changes I'm kind of in this boat. Supposedly this last patch was a pretty big one so maybe I'll try and see what their progress is like.

3
LeRoyVoss•

Don't fucking care, gotta stay as far as possible from those kickstarter scams. Thank God never put a dime into those, how many went through with the amazing feature and success they promise?

And can't stand that Peon guy. He sounds like an entitled brat that will never grow up. Nothing professional about him.

20
VodkaBoys•

I think albion was kickstarted and that one worked out really good

1

Adventure Quest 3D was a kickstarted game that launched with most of what it promised.

I do agree this guy is an asshole though.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
BrookCe1•

The guy makes a living doing game reviews on YouTube, you want him to suit up to suffice?

-5
Ekklypz•

The guy could have make a proper living if he didn't shoot himself in the foot ages ago along other shit. Insufferable idiot he is.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
devilkingx2OP•

He probably makes a lot of money, so he is making a proper living.

0
LeRoyVoss•

Doesn’t make him less of an idiot.

3
Gevatter•

AFAIK no, he doesn't. Watch his non-gaming related videos.

1
torsoreaper•

Surprised he hasn't posted a "why I quit crowfall" video yet

16
Miraluna_•

Haha, it sorta was. Then later he can do a "why I returned" video.

15
torsoreaper•

So glad someone got the joke. This guy literally only has 3 types of videos.

9
DingusMcButtFace•

It's a MMO gameplay channel that's based on "First Impressions" type videos... how much variety do you expect that kind of a channel to have?

6
JohnnyBGaming•

I know it can be lame and it drives a lot of people away (myself included) but I can't blame him. He found a formula that works. For the extreme example you have people like the Kardashians. They have even less to offer but people eat that shit up!

3
Barkzie•

Lmao I came here looking for that. He repeats the same cycle over and over.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Razwerd•

He should have waited for the latest update which is something like a "beta" for the game from what I read. It releases on a couple weeks on live server, would be better impressions video.

7
Gevatter•

I don't think he cares enough. Also, those kind of videos get more views.

2
JrawrdEVE•

When a single one of these crowdfunded MMOs release I'll stop believing they're all just a scam.

7
BlaineWriter•

Albion online was kickstart mmo I believe?

14
JrawrdEVE•

Was it? I didn't know.

-4
devilkingx2OP•

Which one do you think is the most likely to actually release currently? I think Ashes is the only one that'll release as a decent game within the next 3 years.

1
PierreDelecto_2020•

3 years if you still remember Ashes exists I feel sorry for you.

2
Trashcan_Paladin•

Star Citizen

-1†
blurrry2Star Citizen•

Star Citizen.

-5
JrawrdEVE•

lol

1
Tyestor2007Scape•

EVE

laugh it up, dead spreadsheet simulator player

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
DingusMcButtFace•

Hindsight is 20/20. If I had the disposable income back when crowdfunded MMOs were gaining a lot of traction, I might have given them some money despite being pretty frugal myself.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
DingusMcButtFace•

I think the point of crowdfunding was so that there would be an informal platform for people to give money to strangers who "pinky promise" to deliver on the content. Honestly I think it was just the media coverage and the fact that they got so much funding for these games that gave them credibility (plus some recognizable names backing these projects).

But yeah I agree, I doubt it was a good idea to give thousands of dollars to a previously unknown company to create something like an MMO, even if they had eventually delivered.

3
AtisNobDebuffer•

I was absolutely shocked at the idea of just give a fancy random blog post money

There were successful KS games, and there were failed non KS games. Ppl pay for things they believe in and publishers kinda lost some trust. Nothing to be shocked about.

1
blurrry2Star Citizen•

pa·tron /ˈpātrən/

  1. a person who gives financial or other support to a person, organization, cause, or activity.
1
VeritasXIV•

I did for SC back in 2012 because I was desperate for a sandbox pvp mmo with real time skill based flying/ dog fighting/ fps combat since the only game that had that, Darkfall online, was shutting down.

If literally NO game company will make the only type of game you enjoy, then and only then do Kickstarter games remotely make sense.

But would I do it again? No because it takes too long if it ever completes at all.

1
devilkingx2OP•

Well I hope you find the space game we're all looking for, Everspace 2 maybe.

1
BluntedJ•

RIP. Wow, I started thinking the game looked playable. Then after that first few seconds....wow. Too bad. Not expecting a hat trick here.

4
Miraluna_•

Current state is #1. Also, video was on build 5.100 from last year not the current build that just patched for testing 2 days ago.

For anyone interested in Crowfall, you can register on the website to be invited to the free beta test phase when it starts later this year. CF recently got another $11.7 million in investor funding, so they don't need the crowdfunding to launch the game.

3†
JohnnyBGaming•

You make no points in regards to the build. He admits it's probably out of date by the time we see it. He admits everything he shows may be irrelevant within a week of him originally recording it.

Personally, I'd avoid crowfall. Lots of bad signs. They were already selling items for well over 1k years ago. They used backer money to hire a videographer duo so they could keep interviewing themselves too.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ClaireHilda•

See what just happened to Chronicles of Elyria

The same thing will happens to Crowfall and Ashe Of Creation ( looking at alpha 1 show, im even more convinced now that it's just a pure scam, even them they didnt look happy with the it during the stream )

2†
devilkingx2OP•

I don't have high hopes for Pantheon rise of the fallen or Camelot Unchained either tbh. We don't need to speak about Star Citizen Shudder

4
miasmawhisper•

So they show off playing their mmorpg live. And youre MORE convinved its a "pure" scam?

Were you dropped on the head at birth?

1
ClaireHilda•

No, im convinced it's a scam because it looks like dogshit from every point, it looks like any other generic MMO that close down within a year

Just watch the stream again and look at their face when they're playing, even themself they looked like they didnt believe in it, specially the marketting girl

0
SammyC25268•

the game does have a few starter zones where you can practice combat against NPCs and gather resources. Player vs. player combat is not allowed in these low level zones that are part of God's Reach. The earth temple has player run and NPC shops that sell equipment. The game does display tips about how to craft how to eat, how to fight and how to gather resources.

edit: you might want to post your question on r/crowfall

2
Gevatter•

Did he played the newest version? The one on the test-servers?

2
devilkingx2OP•

Apparently some new update came out recently after the time he was playing this game so he was playing on the previous version from like 6+ months ago.

Some people say that it's an unfair representation of the game, others would argue that the game is many years into development and shouldn't have been in this state 6 months ago.

2
Gevatter•

Apparently some new update came out recently after the time he was playing this game so he was playing on the previous version from like 6+ months ago.

And the new update is huge. Technical and gameplay wise.

2
potatoparadise•

No, he did not. Lol

1
VNAIL•

Crowfall is an example of a game that lost focus. It's layers upon layers of half-baked features that don't really go together, but were piled on top of each other over the course of development.

What they pitched in kickstarter would have been great, what they have now is a mess.

2
Celfs•

It's just a bad money grab fest in development for over 5 years that isn't going anywhere. Makes fun of the whole point of what a kickstarter should be. Good idea on paper, really bad execution, not worth it at all.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Zippo-Cat•

Crowfall is a good idea, no execution.

1
Drekor•

Alright so first off I think his overall impressions are correct but at the same time he doesn't really give the game a fair shake. There is a lot of stuff that he is missing and trying to go purely solo just makes something that is already bad even worse.

My biggest complaints are that he seems lost on what to do while he clearly stated it was an open world sandbox so he knew what the game was and apparently forgot as soon as he started playing. That's on him.

He still nails things mostly on the head though, the game feels like shit and plays like shit and the world feels dead and for a game that is so reliant on players to feel alive that's a real problem.

1
Gevatter•
  1. CF isn't released yet, it's not even in a late beta phase
  2. LazyPeon haven't played the latest version, but a version that is 6+ months old
1

I don't think you understand what an asset flip is lol

1
devilkingx2OP•

While watching the gameplay I was thinking that it looks like fortnite/dauntless in terms of graphics& artstyle

and by description it sounds like the game Rend

But when watching how the game is presented, the total lack of tutorial or direction, having you just fuck around in a world with nothing to do, it reminded me of watching jim Sterling review asset flips.

1
Al_C92•

I mean if they have at least something to show for it that be a welcome change =/

1
[deleted]•

you know its using the unity engine right? Jtodd and gordon are actual veterans of the industry and wouldnt throw their rep away, plus theyve been actively receiving seed money from investors. Game is legit.

0
devilkingx2OP•

I assumed it was a custom engine but my third guess would've been unity or source. Either way I didn't mean it literally.

I want to say that multiple industry veterans who. are/were famous have actually made kickstarter scams/ripoffs. (The psychonaughts guy, chris roberts of star citizen, the shenmue guy, etc.)

But hey, it's also very likely to be scenario #1 rather than the asset flip money laundering thing.

2
Gevatter•

What about a third option, i.e. that LazyPeon played on an old build? (Maybe even on purpose?)

1
devilkingx2OP•

Definitely not on purpose but it seems to be fact that he did play on an old build.

"The game was a mess 6 months ago AKA several years into development" isn't a good thing no matter how you slice it.

1
-virtualworlds-•

Gordon threw his rep away years ago when he fucked SWG players in the ass with no lube.

1