r/guns•
Horger

One of my rounds was a squib load today. Thank you range officer!

So today I was at the range with my buddy, shooting my SA 1911 with some Remington UMC target loads. my friend was halfway through a magazine with it when he fired the weapon and it just fizzled a bit, and failed to move the slide/eject the round. He waited 10 seconds, ejected the shell, and then we looked inside and the bullet was lodged in the barrel.

I got the range officer to come over and he told me what had happened and told me to go to the sales counter and ask them to help me out. I got out there and one of the dudes stripped my pistol, put the barrel in a vice, and pounded the bullet out with a brass punch and a mallet. It was surprising how well lodged it had gotten itself. If either of us had just been oblivious and racked another round and fired it would have probably been a shitty day, but the spectacular failure of the round to do anything was a pretty good clue that something bad had happened.

Also, in the same box of remington cartridges there was a round that was visibly shorter than the rest; I think the bullet was pressed further into the casing than it should have been. I threw it in the misfire box so i wouldn't accidentally load it.

My question to you gunnit, is whether this is a freak occurence, or a somewhat common issue? I am wondering if i should contact Remington and see what they have to say about it. Shit was pretty weak.

Posted Jul 9, 2011, 4:28 AM UTC

2637
Cpl_DreamSmasher•

You should have kept the factory defect and the box it came in, Remington could be very interested if a lot has gone haywire.

15
HorgerOP•

Indeed. Well it is from a case of 500 that I bought so maybe it was all the same lot? hopefully.

3
TwoHands•

from a few anecdotes i've heard.... Rem is beginning to give a lot less of a fuck about quality control, and will only care if a significant number of such squibs are reported.

Hopefully when the OP informs them of his squib round, he will be among enough others to warrant a response.

3
[deleted]•

I've contacted Remington over a (very) bad batch of $10/box 22lr match ammo. A shit was not given. They offered to replace the individual bad rounds if I'd pay shipping to send them back. This was for 5 boxes of very premium match ammo with about a 15% rate of being totally unprimed.

1
Wapiti-eater•

Good call on discarding the shorter round.

That's called "bullet set back". It decreases the volume of the cartridge and can RADICALLY increase chamber pressures, depending on the propellant, volume and other factors.

Though not likely, it's possible, with set back, to have a Ka-Boom and requisite crappy day.

We know you dodged one today. Could be you've actually dodged two. That's a good day.

12
sewiv•

kB! In .45 is not nearly as likely as .40.

.40 hates setback.

2
commandar•

.45 is a relatively low pressure cartridge -- SAAMI spec is 21,000 PSI.

.40 S&W, on the other hand, is already spec'd to 35k PSI, and as little as 1/10" of setback can push those pressures up into the 70-90k PSI range. Boom.

2
sewiv•

I agree completely.

1
Demonspawn•

Because I don't reload (yet)....

Is the reason this is an issue due to the relative quick burning of pistol powders? I would think that above pressure X the bullet would come loose from the casing and start to move, therefore decreasing the pressure. Therefore if a bullet was set too far back into the casing it would just start to move a microsecond earlier.

1
commandar•

It seems that the bullet doesn't move fast enough to mitigate peak pressure. From what I've read, the numbers I mentioned are what Hertinberger in Austria found when they decided to test things. 9mm actually runs at higher pressures than .40 does, but other aspects of the cartridge design apparently make it less prone to setback issues. I'm honestly not smart enough to say exactly why that is, but it seems to play out in practice.

1
daeedorian•

Why thank the range officer? You and your friend are the ones who avoided a shitty situation, and the dude at the counter fixed your gun...

8
HorgerOP•

yeah but the range officer was a pretty friendly/whacky guy so it was an interesting experience talking to him. The dude who fixed it was also really cool and we talked about 1911's for a little while. All in all they were very helpful.

8
daeedorian•

Sounds like a good range. Finding a good range is like finding a good barber...

11
JohnWang•

or a good mechanic

9
Mutki•

Or a wife.

9
sxcamaro•

I have had mixed views on Remington UMC ammo. I had a case crack, 1 FTF, and a a case bend/jam my slide open. (9mm and 40 S&W) Honestly, most of the time I can get the stuff out to the range and have no problem firing 50-100 rounds (but those few problems have always been remembered).

2
HorgerOP•

Yeah maybe it was just a bad day for the robots at the factory :P The stuff that malfunctioned was the newer UMC rounds with nickel plated casings. I went through over 600 rounds with older remington UMC without a single issue. I'll definitely have to be wary when i shoot this stuff from now on.

1
xjeepdotorg•

good thing you weren't doing a tactical trill or in competition, tap rack bang could have seriously ruined your day

2
abbarach•

I was in a squad at a steel challenge match about a month ago where a guy had a squib in an M&P 9. The RSO was VERY on the ball, and let me tell you, when you hear your RSO bellow "STOP!" at the top of his lungs, you freeze, even if you're not at the line.

I talked to him about it afterward- he said in that case he could hear that the round wasn't charged properly, and figured that there was probably an obstruction. They managed to beat it out with a wooden dowel and a large rock, and we went right back to shooting. I didn't notice what ammo the guy was shooting, although I'm pretty sure it was factory.

1
Brotherauron1•

Did they mention what could have caused it? I would be concerned since the gas some how made it past the bullet.. did it mess up your barrel at all? (yes i know lead is a very soft metal so most likely no, but having to whack it out of the barrel may cause issues.)

Edit: also may want to measure the diameter of the barrel to see if it bowed out in any areas due to the pressure unable to escape quickly

2
Raging_cycle_path•

I would be concerned since the gas some how made it past the bullet

I don't reckon this would e the case, more likely not a full load of powder, and the gas would have escaped when the slide went back.

1
Brotherauron1•

he had to manually eject the shell.. so all the gas would have been trapped in the barrel

3
networkguru•

I think it would bleed out around the case

2
Brotherauron1•

which is most likely the case, but i would be concerned about how much pressure was built, as it may deform the barrel

1
Raging_cycle_path•

I'm sorry, I fail at reading the post, you're absolutely right. But I agree with the other reply to you, it probably would have bled past the case, not the bullet. I wonder if it sounded like a hiss of escaping air or anything?

1
Brotherauron1•

which would have been my original concern, it most likely would have bled past, but depending on how much pressure was built, the barrel may deform

1
HorgerOP•

They just said it was no/weak powder charge. I was a bit concerned myself but it seemed like a pretty routine thing to them. I cleaned my barrel afterwards and it didn't look like it was scratched or damaged in any way. I still have the slug from that particular round, it's got rifling marks on it from being stuck and getting knocked out. I was told basically that the bullet had expanded due to the pressure and lodged it in there pretty good.

1
xampl9•

A primer-only round can push the bullet a surprising distance down the barrel -- but not out the muzzle.

OP: Good catch on noticing the squib.

1
nandrizzle•

Shit happens! I would try and call them just to see what they would say.

1
echang86•

Every box of Remington UMC 250 round 9mm I ever purchased has had at least 9 rounds that had the bullets setback. I purchased all these boxes from WalMart. Two other friends had the same problems. The ammo was purchased at different times.

This seems to be a common issue with the bulk packs of Remington UMC ammo. I remember seeing a forum post on it before, someone contacted remington and they sent him a voucher or a check or something...

1
questionablemoose•

I've found several of these short rounds in 9mm UMC and .45 UMC. Remington's QC sucks something awful.

Always check your UMC rounds to make sure they're the same height.

Oh, and one .45 casing had a bite out of the, er, neck. No idea how that would happen in the factory.

1