A response to shibblenutters' charges of "racism" by me, a left-wing psychology student

Stats & Facts

As you all are probably aware, the idea that discrimination against shibbles is akin to racism is a favorite go-to for their nutty owners and advocates. Like all of their empty talking points, however, this ludicrous, fauxgressive (pseudoleftist) claim is untenable. As a genuine left-winger who also studies psychology, given that this claim is raised by shibblenutters to appeal to the public's moral sense vis-à-vis equality and that it makes an assumption about the relationship between human and animal behavior (namely, that between human races and dog breeds), I feel that I'm particularly suited to addressing it and that ya'll might appreciate my contributions.

Below is a discussion I had about a half-month ago with a shibblenutter in this sub who initially claimed that shibbles "had roles as companions for working class in early America." Here's my response and our semi-lengthy exchange:

...and in contemporary America, their role has been to intimidate, assault, and murder members of the working class, particularly the most vulnerable among them (e.g., infants, young children, the elderly).

As a left-winger, I recognize this dog breed as an oppressive menace against workers. It must be eliminated.


I found not much that linked pit bulls to oppressing the working class

You didn't check out the links in the sidebar, did you?


I actually found more links talking about the connections between race and the breed. I found this great article talking about it! Here is my favorite quote from it. It’s definitely worth the read “As White politicians were trying to galvanize votes under “tough-on-crime” banter by calling poor Black men “thugs,” “gangsters,” and “superpredators” in the 1980s and 1990s, the public at large began to perceive pit bulls as the right-hand man to the Black criminal’s illegal activities.”

Psychology major here. These sorts of comparisons between human and animal behavior are bad analogies, which is a logical fallacy. Whereas the former derives its specific features from particular sociocultural and political-economic (environmental) factors, the latter is biologically determined. Here, I elaborate on the scientific untenability of such comparisons:

we cannot make any reasonable conclusions about human behavior based on animal studies. This is precisely what stimulated the humanistic movement within the field, which took issue with behaviorists' reliance on animal studies. As humanistic psychologists note, behaviorists downplayed, ignored, or even outright denied unique aspects of human behavior, such as our free will and desire/capacity for personal growth. Humans are the only species capable of abstract and symbolic cognition, as well as the only one able to organize complex societies. Unlike in other animals, specific human behaviors generally have sociocultural rather than biological origins. Aside from things like the diving and suckling reflexes, humans do not have "instincts," so to draw conclusions about human behavior based on studies of species that are largely instinctual would be what's called overextrapolation.

Not only are these comparisons wholly unscientific, but they simultaneously amount to dehumanization (in that you are reducing humans to mere animals) and anthropomorphization (via attributing human characteristics to animals).

Stop likening human races to dog breeds. This just makes you seem really ignorant and jerky.


If you could just post the links in a response that would be helpful!

If you're on a computer, the links are listed on the right side of this page. They demonstrate this dog breed to be, by far, the most deadly and menacing. If you're on mobile, go to the subreddit homepage, then tap the "About" section; the links will be listed there.


When you mentioned the analogy, where you talking about the connection between race and breeds?

That's what I said, isn't it?


Or the murders comparison?

What murders comparison?


children are much more likely to be killed by a human than a pit bull

And this is due to particular sociocultural and political-economic factors that generate conflict in our society. It's not inherent to our species, unlike pit bulls' biologically determined aggression.

We can change society to reduce the future incidence of violence. By contrast, we cannot somehow genetically "reverse-engineer" aggression out of individual pit bulls. Instead, we must 1) prohibit their further breeding, and 2) either corral them in locations safely away from human populations until they naturally die off and become extinct, or else actively extinguish the breed via a mass euthanasia program.

Being the bleeding heart that I am, I actually prefer the former option of just letting them die off, safely away from society in humane facilities. However, many posters here aren't so forgiving of these beasts.


As for the connection between race and breed, I see what you are saying. A dog doesn’t understand racism or the economy.

It's not about comprehension. In fact, most people are unaware of the macrosystemic origins of their own psychology. The fact of the matter is that, rather than being biologically determined, specific psychobehavioral outcomes in humans are generated by such macrosystemic factors.


I wanted to provide some links that I think are very good at explaining why biology isn’t the only factor.

Please quote the relevant sections of your sources you feel support your claim.

It's not my job to sift through your sources to find support for your position. This is very clearly your job.

After this comment, as is par for the course when ignorant fanatics face challenges to their views that they are not prepared for, this person copped out and failed to at least give me the courtesy to explain why he so abruptly fled from the discussion.

Hopefully, the points I raised provide useful ammo for when y'all encounter another nutter in the wild calling you a racist for hating shibbles. As I demonstrated above, this idea is complete pitbullshit and deserves to be thoroughly debunked whenever it is uttered.

Posted Dec 22, 2020, 6:43 AM UTC

7640
[deleted]•

[deleted]

35
[deleted]•

[removed]

31
[deleted]•

It truly makes me feel at ease that any race can be a dog lover/pit nutter.

They're all commonly narcissists. The human disease.

18
NewHiggins2Shelter Worker•

I believe the pit lobby's goal is to make everyone into a narcissist by encouraging them not to care for people, and obsess over pits instead.

5
[deleted]•

Makes total sense.

Evidence: 1800's existentialism paved the way for the rampantly intoxicating individualism, which was worsened after ww2 from the boom of War time capitalism trying to keep up after the war...

And then targetted adds and consumer plastic culture. And dogs.

5
NewHiggins2Shelter Worker•

Yeah I don't think the pit lobby is doing this alone, I think they're one of many groups working to make a totally misanthropic, self-centered society without any sense of community.

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

0†
GachiHypersinChat•

I’ve seen about an even split in pit ownership between political factions. The pit I’ve been chased by more than any other in my neighborhood is owned by an older republican dude.

10
TheSunsetSeekerEscaped a Close Call•

Same. They also tend to have them for wildly different reasons.

Right wing people tend to be attracted to the idea of owning a deadly weapon that you can feed.

Left wing people seem to buy them with the idea that they can love away the murderous tendencies genetically bred into these beasts.

Both come to own them by being overcome by their need to control something. The right side wanting to exert dominance over a known vicious animal and the left side giving into a savior complex. It's incredibly interesting to psychoanalyze these types of people, but it's nothing less than willful ignorance to suggest that only one side of the political spectrum is responsible for pitbulls being a danger to society.

16
GachiHypersinChat•

Both sides are also reluctant to ban things for various reasons.

The right, being generally against banning things like firearms, sees banning Pitbulls as an infringement on property rights.

The left sees it as a racist dog whistle.

Either way, it’s fucked.

11
Chezmoi3•

Same experience here. Pitnuttery seems to be bipartisan.

3
Snowontherange•

I hate when they compare a breed of dog to human beings. You can't send a dog to therapist to work out it's anger issues. Dogs don't think at that level. They have animal instincts because they're animals and follow them accordingly. I especially hate when they use the comparison to black Americans and crime statistics. It's low-key racist of them to make that analogy considering the complex history of black Americans and suggesting that racism towards blacks is the same as dislike of a breed of dog. The history of pit bulls is pretty straight forward. They were bred to be a fighting dog. Then people decided they wanted to keep them as vicious guard dogs. Then people decided they wanted to keep them as cuddly pets. Never mind decades of breeding instincts. Just ignore all that because people want a pet.

11
SEND_NUKES_PLZ•

Nice, upvoted

8
AssaultRiflePuppy•

cant call facts racist. if pitbulls kill more then pitbulls kill more its simple. its called instinct and we are taught to notice patterns in order to survive and its been like that since the BC era of humanity.

​

thats why when we see tigers or loins or great white sharks we stay away it aint racist to say all great white sharks will kill you because we all know they will if you swim up to them like i said its instinct to notice those patterns and is part of survival which alot of pitnutters lack because they drown their brain in emotion and pro pit propaganda.

8
gdhvdry•

It's nuts to me, the Africans (Nigerian, Gambian) I know do not treat dogs as some kind of equal or would let them near their babies.

Someone somewhere said that singling out pits from other dogs was like racism and the pitters ran with it.

7
Snowontherange•

It's also a generational and class issue. My rural grandparents don't see the point in pets. To them, animals should be useful as what they were bred to be. My rural turned suburban parents didn't really want any dogs or cats because they are too much work and "dirty". I love pets, but they are still animals to me. I don't get the idea of thinking they are equal to people or overlooking their animal instincts.

5
timascus•

Why does it matter if you’re left wing?

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
WorldControllerOP•

As I stated in the OP, shibblenutters' belief that discrimination against shibbles is akin to racism is fauxgressive (pseudoleftist) claptrap; moreover, again, the claim is raised by shibblenutters to appeal to the public's moral sense regarding equality. It stands to reason that someone who is an actual leftist is qualified to correct these fake "leftists'" misconceptions, similarly to how real scientists sometimes debunk the rantings and ravings of pseudoscientific crackpots.

If you're unsure about what left-wing politics entails, refer to my other comment here where I elaborate on this point.

0†
Living-DebateEscaped a Close Call•

Good thank you. On the same issue someone said people just use pit bulls for fighting because theyre "good at it." I said um no theyre good at fighting because they were created and bred specifically for tenacity aggression and pain insensitivity.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
TheSunsetSeekerEscaped a Close Call•

I'm sure we all appreciate whenever someone shows support against pitbulls, but this post comes off as (forgive me for being blunt) narcissistic, demeaning, and ridiculously verbose.

If you're interested, here's a post that more thoroughly debunks every major pit argument, using links to verifiable statistics and documented history, as opposed to definitions for words you're using.

Remember, not every pitbull owner is insane. Some just believed the propaganda and lies they were told by friends and family. We're trying to persuade them to open up to the idea that they've been lied to. You'll never accomplish that, if you talk down to the opposition like you're doing here.

5
WorldControllerOP•

this post comes off as (forgive me for being blunt) narcissistic, demeaning, and ridiculously verbose.

The term "verbose" refers to writing "containing more words than necessary." Just because an explication is lengthy does not mean it is unnecessarily wordy; indeed, such explications may instead be concise, which is actually antonymous with "verbose."

Virtually every word I included was necessary to establish my position. As far as I can tell, my writing is pretty concise. Since you believe otherwise, please point out any words you see whose omission would improve readability while not changing the essential content of my points.

Forgive me also for being blunt, but I suspect you're just being intellectually lazy.


If you're interested, here's a post that more thoroughly debunks every major pit argument

I'm already familiar with this post. Keep in mind that my intention here was not to debunk every major shibble argument, but rather specifically the claim that discrimination against these beasts is akin to racism. So, I'm unsure why you're linking this to me.


as opposed to definitions for words you're using

Hmm? Which definitions are you referring to? Are you suggesting that my entire position is reducible to the mere listing of definitions, à la arguing semantics?


Remember, not every pitbull owner is insane.

Don't fret. I don't behave demeaningly toward all shibble owners, only their nutter advocates.


We're trying to persuade them to open up to the idea that they've been lied to. You'll never accomplish that, if you talk down to the opposition like you're doing here.

With all due respect, this is a naive tactic, not to mention a simplistic assessment of the situation. As someone who has been debating fanatics of all stripes for well over a decade, it has been my experience that these people all but invariably refuse to discuss in good faith. As I report here in response to such a fanatic:

FYI, in my experience of debating this issue to death over the past year with fauxgressive adherents of popular transgender ideology like yourself, you people all but invariably either resort to petty personal attacks, offer a slew of fallacious arguments, or else simply cop out; not once have any of you successfully defended your views. Evidently, this is because the ideology is indefensible. It is not possible to successfully defend these ideas, hence why all you people ever do is lash out or give up.

Indeed, the same pattern applies to all fanatics. Trying to debate these people respectfully, particularly when they refuse to reciprocate, is therefore a futile endeavor. The purpose of debating them is not to persuade them, but 1) to discourage them away from these ideas as much as possible, and 2) to demonstrate to any readers, including the non-fanatical shibble owners you refer to, just how untenable the ideas actually are and how ridiculously stupid and crazy are its adherents.

I suggest you jettison your naive idealism here in favor of heeding Shakespeare's advice: “pause not, for the present time's so sick; be fire with fire, threaten the threatener, and outface the brow of bragging horror.”

0
wikipedia_text_bot•

[Semantic dispute](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semantic dispute)

For semantic arguments in linguistics, see verb argument. A semantic dispute is a disagreement that arises if the parties involved disagree about the definition of a word or phrase, not because they disagree on material facts, but rather because they disagree on the definitions of a word (or several words) essential to formulating the claim at issue. It is sometimes held that semantic disputes are not genuine disputes at all, but very often they are regarded as perfectly genuine, e.g., in philosophy. It is also sometimes held that when a semantic dispute arises, the focus of the debate should switch from the original thesis to the meaning of the terms of which there are different definitions (understandings, concepts, etc.).

About Me - Opt out - OP can reply !delete to delete - Article of the day

This bot will soon be transitioning to an opt-in system. Click here to learn more and opt in.

1
[deleted]•

No offense, I don’t find this a particularly persuasive argument (it’s kind of BS).

Pit bulls are not meant to “oppress the working class.” They are meant to rip each other’s guts out in dog fights. That’s what they were bred for. Lower class seem to find them appealing.

The suggestion that breed specific laws is “racist” is moronic and racist in of itself because it puts people (minorities) on the same level as animals. We, as humans, can determine what animals are appropriate to have in society and which are not. We don’t have tigers as pets in society. That’s not “species-ist”. That’s because they will rip your face off. Same with shit bulls.

4
[deleted]•

the only way for them to win an argument is to repeat illogical analogies they heard someone else say

3
Akredditman•

Ay he made it, nice

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
WorldControllerOP•

You lost me at pits being oppressive against workers/the working class. In contemporary America, pit ownership isn’t relegated to the working class. Millionaires, celebrities, and well-off households are joining the ranks of pit owners.

You are indeed lost. As I told the last person here who made this same strawman (almost verbatim), likewise erroneously conflating the working class with the poor:

It's not only poor people that own pitbulls. Many famous actors and athletes own pitbulls. This is not a class-based issue

This is a strawman, which is a logical fallacy. I did not state or suggest that only poor people own shibbles. First, not all workers are poor. Second, just because shibbles oppress poor people does not mean they exclusively target them.

Another erroneous conflation you're making is that between shibble ownership and shibble attacks. To be sure, while there is considerable overlap here, not everyone who falls victim to a shibble actually owns one. As an ostensible "Victim Sympathizer," you should know better.


Also, why do you feel particularly qualified to speak on this issue? Because you’re a leftist?

Refer to my comment here where I elaborated to the last person who asked this:

As I stated in the OP, shibblenutters' belief that discrimination against shibbles is akin to racism is fauxgressive (pseudoleftist) claptrap; moreover, again, the claim is raised by shibblenutters to appeal to the public's moral sense regarding equality. It stands to reason that someone who is an actual leftist is qualified to correct these fake "leftists'" misconceptions, similarly to how real scientists sometimes debunk the rantings and ravings of pseudoscientific crackpots.

If you're unsure about what left-wing politics entails, refer to my other comment here where I elaborate on this point.

 


I graduated college with a psychology BA (also competed my honors thesis on animalistic dehumanization). I don’t reference my psychology BA because there’s no merit in it

If your story about your educational background is true, then I seriously doubt that you genuinely believe there's no merit in noting your credentials in relevant discussions. Clearly, someone who has spent countless hours studying a topic formally (and presumably on their free time, as well) knows more about it than the typical layperson, particularly if they've completed honors credits, which require additional coursework.

In any case, you're lying, either about your background or your silly "merit" remark. Actually, I think you're just humblebragging in an ironic attempt to humble me.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
WorldControllerOP•

I never made such a claim that working class were the same as the poor.

Are you sure? Besides the demographics you listed (millionaires, celebrities, the well-off), what else is left besides the poor? It really seemed like you were implying that, since workers are not members of these relatively rich groups, this means they are poor.

Anyway, keep in mind that workers are not mutually exclusive with celebrities and the well-off; plenty of people from these latter groups work for a living.


Of course there’s merit in noting credentials, but being a student isn’t a credential.

What a narrow-minded, myopic, ignorant claim. In actuality, the term "credential" is variously defined as "a qualification, achievement, personal quality, or aspect of a person's background, typically when used to indicate that they are suitable for something," "[t]hat which entitles one to confidence," "something that gives . . . confidence," etc. Like virtually all terms, this one has a variety of distinct (albeit similar) definitions. Not all credentials exist in the form of "a piece of any document that details a qualification, competence, or authority issued to an individual by a third party with a relevant or de facto authority or assumed competence to do so," as you evidently mistakenly believe.

Again, people who've spent numerous hours studying a field both formally and informally are more informed about it than the average person; this is self-evident. As such, they are qualified (perhaps unofficially) to educate laypeople to the extent of their knowledge and, of course, warranted in their confidence to do so. Your claim that being a student isn't a credential is clearly false.


In the field I currently work, it’s actually considered a breach of ethics to refer to a credential that you don’t have (even if you’re currently working toward said credential).

Again, there is a distinction between credentials in the broader sense of the term, and those relating to officialdom specifically. Just because falsely claiming official credentials in a formal institution is considered unethical does not mean that truthfully claiming informal credentials is likewise inappropriate.


I’m not humble-bragging. I’m cautioning you not to present yourself as a qualified individual on a topic (which is what I feel you have done).

First, "humblebragging" is a closed compound word; a hyphen is unnecessary.

Second, it seems like you think that I've stated or suggested that I'm an authority in the field. If so this would be another strawman. Anyway, since you feel I'm so "unqualified" to speak on these matters, please point out any false statements I made. Otherwise, rescind your silly claim.


I don’t care enough about this argument or your opinions about me to prove I obtained my BA or that I competed a thesis

I wasn't requesting proof. What matters is that, again, you are a liar either way.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Bravo! I just want to ad, dogs are technically semi sentient domesticated aminals. Not fully sentient.

-6
Rumored17MODFinal Boss/Moderator :redditgold:•

This isn't r/dogfree. Rule 10.

2
[deleted]•

Edited for the peoples.

-4
Rumored17Final Boss/Moderator :redditgold:•

I mean your comment is still bullshit and misinformation but doesn't technically break any rules so fine I guess. I don't think you know what "sentient" means though.

3
[deleted]•

If you looked it Up, you would know what I mean is true, from a certain point of view.

Ei: domestication makes animals dumber. Semi sentience is a thing seen in domesticated animals.

-3