What are some interesting linear functions?
My favorite exercise to give to students when I teach linear algebra is to calculate the Jordan canonical form of the differentiation operator on the space of degree (at most) n polynomials, but a few years back some students came to me to ask me to please mix it up a little as the examples involving this operator were a bit complicated for them but the ones that werent about this operator were too easy for them ( I was just doing random matrices that I knew werent too hard, or simple stuff corresponding to transformations in space ).
So, to be precise, my question is about linear transformations between spaces that are interesting, by this I mean Im looking for transformation that show up in nature, that are challenging but one can still do pencil and paper computations on them at the level of your universities' 2nd year linear algebra course ( or 1st or 3rd or whatever ).
Posted Feb 8, 2021, 3:50 PM UTC · edited
Derivative, integral and by extension of the integral, transforms like Fourier, LaPlace.
Between what spaces?
Any reasonable spaces where they're defined.
This is what's wrong with mathematics smh
The answer you seek exists and is reasonably well defined. Goodbye.
Decent answer: consider the span of {e^t, e^(2t)} sitting inside a function space. The derivative function can be represented by multiplying an element of the span by a matrix, which is pretty neat. Can you see what the matrix should be?
(Not giving the matrix partially for the exercise but mostly bc I don't want to type it out on my phone lol)
I feel bad for laughing at this - especially since I have no grasp on this thread lol
Best part is that I won’t be surprised if u/bluesam3’s response is the only “correct” answer - even if it’s incredibly vague
For a specific example: take the linear subspace of C(ℝ) spanned by (x -> cos(ax)) and (x -> sin(ax)) for some (finite, presumably) set of real numbers a.
[deleted]
One example I like for first year linear algebra is to look at differentiation on a small invariant subspace like the span of {e^3t cos(t), e^3t sin(t)}. On that subspace the derivative operator is actually invertible, and you can calculate a non-trivial antiderivative by inverting the matrix.
For differentiation/integration you could do the space of polynomials, but it's perhaps to easy.
Also something like span{ e^t , te^t , t^(2)e^t , ...} possible also mixing in e^at for other a would make sense.
Are the students familiar with Fourier series/transform? If so something like the transformation from span{ cos(t), sin(t), ...} to C^n computing some appropriate number of fourier coefficients would make sense.
I guess it mostly comes down to what sort of transformations your students are used to.
For one example, if I recall correctly the Fourier transform and its inverse exist on L2[0, 1].
They exist on L^(2)(ℝ). But the transform of a function with bounded support never has bounded support itself, so the fourier transform won't restrict to [0,1].
I didn't say the transform or its inverse restrict to that interval.
Similarly, very related to linear differential equations, it's cool to consider how the derivative looks under certain special cases.
For instance, the derivative restricted to [ e^x ] is the identity. The derivative restricted to [sinh,cosh] looks like ((0,1),(1,0)). And then there's cool stuff like the truncated taylor expansion of the exponential gives a companion matrix.