[deleted]•

FTA

The top 50 of the 147 superconnected companies

  1. Barclays plc
  2. Capital Group Companies Inc
  3. FMR Corporation
  4. AXA
  5. State Street Corporation
  6. JP Morgan Chase & Co
  7. Legal & General Group plc
  8. Vanguard Group Inc
  9. UBS AG
  10. Merrill Lynch & Co Inc
  11. Wellington Management Co LLP
  12. Deutsche Bank AG
  13. Franklin Resources Inc
  14. Credit Suisse Group
  15. Walton Enterprises LLC
  16. Bank of New York Mellon Corp
  17. Natixis
  18. Goldman Sachs Group Inc
  19. T Rowe Price Group Inc
  20. Legg Mason Inc
  21. Morgan Stanley
  22. Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group Inc
  23. Northern Trust Corporation
  24. Société Générale
  25. Bank of America Corporation
  26. Lloyds TSB Group plc
  27. Invesco plc
  28. Allianz SE 29. TIAA
  29. Old Mutual Public Limited Company
  30. Aviva plc
  31. Schroders plc
  32. Dodge & Cox
  33. Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc*
  34. Sun Life Financial Inc
  35. Standard Life plc
  36. CNCE
  37. Nomura Holdings Inc
  38. The Depository Trust Company
  39. Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance
  40. ING Groep NV
  41. Brandes Investment Partners LP
  42. Unicredito Italiano SPA
  43. Deposit Insurance Corporation of Japan
  44. Vereniging Aegon
  45. BNP Paribas
  46. Affiliated Managers Group Inc
  47. Resona Holdings Inc
  48. Capital Group International Inc
  49. China Petrochemical Group Company

Lehman still existed in the 2007 dataset used

209
robertcrowther•

Interesting that most of these are banks, the path to riches is not to do something valuable but to finance someone else doing something valuable.

215
fx2600•

Isn't financing said people valuble to society? Without financing it would be much more difficult to start up or expand a business.

98
squidbootsPhD|Plant Pathology|Plant Breeding|Mycology|Epidemiology•

Yes, it's valuable. But in an almost oversimplified way, it could be said that almost anyone can dole out money and collect dividends and interest, but it takes more skill to, as robertcrowther says, "do something valuable."

A bit disheartening that the system is set up to reward the resource holders and not the innovators.

164
SideburnsOfDoom•

A bit disheartening that the system is set up to reward the resource holders and not the innovators.

And Karl Marx is glad that you finally get his point.

268
tso•

hell, there days you can even hand out money you do not have.

17
fx2600•

If an engineer at IBM does something innovative it is still the corporate share holders that will see most of the profit. The investors there who profit aren't doing anything more skilled than the investors in a bank.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
[deleted]•

Yeah, but innovation is often impossible without resources, and when you put your resources at risk to support something innovative, it's reasonable to earn a return on the risk you've incurred. For every early investor who made money off Facebook or Google, there are thousands who sunk cash into similar startups that failed. Without the hope of eventually profiting from new investments, people would be even more inclined to hoard their resources and less inclined to stake them on new ventures. Innovation would lessen.

The current system isn't perfect, but it does reward those who allocate resources towards the most successful/promising innovative efforts, and allocating resources towards the most successful/promising innovative efforts is a pretty important thing for an economy to do.

12
Filmore•

The simple question is: What is the best way to distribute a limited set of resources?

To address this issue, our entire economic system is set up to reward those who move the most resources in the shortest amount of time. Money is the most liquid resource simply by its nature.

It therefore stands to reason that those who would be rewarded the most in our current economic structure are those who can quickly, and with great volume, move the most liquid resource (money).

If there were a resource as ubiquitous as money that was more liquid, then people who dealt with THAT resource would hold the top spot.

10
darkslide3000•

It's only "valuable" in the perverted and unequable system that is capitalism. If the means of production were distributed and controlled by something more fair and reasonable than private owners, it would not be such a huge effort (and would not require so many fat bankers feeding off it) to get the investments to where they are most valuable for everyone.

4
utexaspunk•

You've got to have a lot of money to participate in finance, but you can't make money at it without applying a shitload of smarts on research and due diligence, which is why the people who are good at it make lots of money^* with it. They provide a valuable service because those other companies that you say "do something valuable" can't grow without capital, but you've got companies that really don't do anything valuable clamoring for capital as well. The finance companies (at least in theory, when functioning and behaving properly) are the invisible hand in action.

* This should not be interpreted as suggesting that some in finance (despite the undeniable utility of what they do and the skills they demonstrate) might not be compensated in a manner which is wildly disproportionate to the compensation others receive for performing other functions of comparable or greater skill and utility.

2
mp2146•

Given how many enterprises fail, I doubt that's the case. It takes skill on its own to recognize a good idea and give it the investment it needs.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DoctorDeath•

It takes money to make money.

1
lolmonger•

Yes, it's valuable. But in an almost oversimplified way, it could be said that almost anyone can dole out money and collect dividends and interest

You may as well criticize the government for building roads with tax revenues.

1
5jsm5•

That's not almost oversimplified, it's grossly oversimplified. Anybody can dole out money and collect dividends and interest but that doesn't mean they can do it well.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

43
[deleted]•

Also, the financiers interest is in making money. This has nothing to do with the success or failure of good ideas or good enterprises. Money can be made betting against success, as well, as has been evident in the enormous profiteering from the global recession.

11
iamalwayshere•

Agreed. The oil does not replace the engine. And that's what the system is attempting to do. More "oil" for the already "oil" rich (pun intended) and less for the innovator engines. squidboots puts it best:"the system is set up to reward the resource holders and not the innovators." Money is not an economy.

8
anarkyinducer•

Yes, financing in the way you're thinking of it is a rudamentary service that's a mix of cash flow and risk analysis.

What ends up happening though is that financiers will seek out investments that maximize short term dollar returns, not value or stability of any venture in the long run. This isn't news. What's new are the synthetic derivatives that banks have started issuing in lieu of actual ventures. These are sucker traps designed to transfer real wealth from individuals to the issuers of such 'assets'.

The process goes something like this:

  • [1] pick a real asset - say tech companies, or real estate, or college education, or even right to pollute.

  • [2] make artificially cheap credit available for people to buy this asset by either directly issuing credit or better yet having government do it through political wrangling.

  • [3] create derivatives around these assets and create derivatives around the derivatives which make money when the original asset tanks in value.

  • [4] sit back and watch people dump ever increasing amounts of money into the now overvalued asset.

  • [5] sell the first derivatives -> profit!

  • [6] sit back and watch people default on the ridiculous amount of debt they racked up thinking the underlying asset would magically increase in value in perpetuity.

  • [7] cash in the second derivative after the market tanks -> profit again!

  • [8] pick a different asset...

28
[deleted]•

"The people look like ants from up here!"

4
atari_eric•

Wow, that clarifies a lot of things for me - I didn't know you could short-sell an entire industry...

2
tonio4321•

Can you please go though the steps with a concrete example? I'm not a financial person but I'd be interested in it.

1
[deleted]•

No. Financing itself is not enough. Because finance is intangible. It takes the creation of tangible items to make the financing valuable. Finance does not buy anything it convinces people with means to do things with what they have.

Ie. You pay someone to come to the job site to build you a house. But it is not the money that builds the house, but the guys building it. So in a round about way it is valuable, but in a direct sense money has ZERO value.

Beyond that, financing is actually an encumberance. Because you can essentially buy more than can be supplied. Ie. Intangibles for tangibles. In other words, you could theoretically own the entire world and everything in it, on paper, but in reality using the world and its things is another thing all together. What I mean by this is that if people who are in finance (banks) sit on the money then it does not fuel any development or progress. It can become a hinderance. It's like fuel for an engine. If you let it sit, it goes bad. But in an engine it is doing work.

8
UnDire•

Te problem is when the chairman of the bank is also a member of the board on corporations that benefit from the banks finances, and the chairmen of those companies that get the financing are members of the banks board.

6
aleczapka•

Add goverment to this and we have full picture...

3
MxM111•

It is not the question if they are valuable. The question is if they are more valuable than anyone else, including producers or actual goods.

3
kneb•

Do companies like this finance start ups?

2
grnhgh•

Yes. It is. But don't look at it so simply. Don't stop there.

Keep going, and start by imaging extremes:

All financing: no work would get done, because everyone was a bank.

No financing: little work would get done, because few people could trust each other and there would be little cash floating around.

Obviously, the optimal situation is somewhere between the two extremes.

What's happening right now is that we've drifted away from optimal, toward one extreme. What's happening is that there is too much tilt toward banks and financing, and it is detracting from the original intent: to produce efficient and numerous economic output.

Banks and financiers are not EVIL-OMG, but the current system is not optimal, and it's has been becoming less optimal.

2
dick_long_wigwam•

Finance is a lubricant currently being used as fuel. Nominally, it helps people with promising ideas get those ideas in practice.

2
jambonilton•

Yes, but when you make money by having money, inequality tends to increase indefinitely.

2
stalk_of_fennel•

sure is valuable. would be even more keen is if that money they're sitting atop of was more evenly spread out and people might not need financing.

1
TinfoilFury•

Technically speaking, financing is (sort of), but banking is not. Letting this sort of thing be run for profit is disastrous, as we have seen.

"Cleaners 'worth more to society' than bankers - study" http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8410489.stm

1
[deleted]•

I would be careful with this assumption. This study covered "super-connected" corporations. If you think about it logically, banks that finance companies involved in myriad different industries should be the most connected.

For example, one would not expect General Motors, which largely exists in one or two industries, to be as financially connected as an investment bank whose entire business model is based upon buying equity in other companies.

tl;dr - That banks are the most interconnected in a system where shares of corporate ownership are investments seems inevitable.

84
pestdantic•

That's a weird example to use. I hear GM makes more money as a bank than as a car company.

22
[deleted]•

This was true for a period. However, having more than one line of business (ie. "one or two industries") does not make a company interconnected in the same way as a business model predicated on investing in corporate equity.

17
davidstuart•

Keep in mind the difference between a commercial bank activity and an investment bank activity. If I loan you money to start a business or buy a car, that is a commercial bank activity. If I operate a mutual fund on behalf of millions of investors, that is investment banking. The connectedness undoubtedly comes from investment banking activities.

The fact is that most fund managers do NOT manage the companies they invest in. In fact, they are sometimes criticized for "renting" stock instead of buying stock. They buy into a given stock, get out quickly and buy somewhere else as relative prices change, since the fund managers are under great pressure to beat the stock indexes each quarter. Not the kind of activity that foster a controlling mentality.

8
LostAbbott•

The only make loans to their customers in the form of auto leases and loans. And yes of course that makes a lot of money. They do not however make home loans or anything of the sort. Meaning that they are not super connected.

6
evildemonic•

"GM makes more money as a bank than as a car company"

And that kind of proves the point...

5
[deleted]•

I think it was called Allied Financial, it was huge until everyone started defaulting on their car loans. believe it is now in government conservator-ship aka nationalized.

2
presidentender•

I imagine that financing automobiles would take care of that even without other banking activities.

1
lotu•

A couple of years ago a lemonade stand would make more money then GM as a car company. So I don't know if GM is a good example.

1
noddyxoi•

To finance someone else doing something valuable with other peoples money. FTFY.

53
Ddraig•

Risk free and Insured by taxpayer funds.

48
[deleted]•

Speaking of which, why do Fannie/Freddie seem to be getting a pass? They were insuring 50 percent of all home loans before the housing market crash and their total liability to the taxpayers is like $3 trillion, which is way more than TARP cost. Their head lobbyist for years who was responsible for all the favorable treatment they got is named Tom Donillon, and is now actually Obama's National Security Adviser. How's that for cronyism? They also have/had operations in every single Congressional district in the country, and were ubiquitous for doing things like putting every DC law firm on retainer to prevent lawsuits, and putting critics on "research contracts" to keep them quiet.

3
TheBlackVoltronLion•

And I'll form the head!

0
BHSPitMonkey•

Or imaginary money.

6
[deleted]•

All money is imaginary.

12
[deleted]•

A ton of businesses rely on short-term financing from banks to do things like make payroll and run day-to-day operations. This was the reason for the bailout. If banks stopped lending then companies across the country wouldn't be able to pay their employees. Letting the banks fail for their reckless actions is what should happen in a market economy, but they had to pass a bailout or it would have led to a global depression, the last of which allowed for the rise of fascism in Western Europe and Communism in Russia...you can see where this is going. There's actually a great Frontline documentary that tells how Bernanke got all of the central bankers and foreign leaders together and said something along the lines of "if we don't act today, there will be no tomorrow."

1
noddyxoi•

The problem is that the middlemen(banks) consume all the money with their schemes. "Hey look the stock markets are in bull mode" ... They make lots of cash with other peoples money. Nothing goes to the people. Then they give themselvs huge paychecks. Then a market crash comes. Taxpayer that got nothing with the bull market pays the bill. Repeat until infinity or there is no money left else in the hand of the bankers.

1
loupgarou21•

Talking with people that tend to be involved in a lot of startups I am somewhat disheartened by the prevailing concept that the inventor is less valuable to a startup than the person handing the business side.

It seems that there is a disturbing idea floating around the startup community that anyone can come up with an invention and implement it properly, but it takes a special kind of person to run a business.

3
superfine_eligibles•

Not sure why that is disturbing or dismissed as an "idea floating around". It's pretty obviously true. If I had to assign weights I would put them at 1% invention, 19% implementation and 80% running the business.

2
[deleted]•

Agreed. I'm more concerned with loupgarou21'a apparent belief that anyone can run a business than the opposite.

0
SpinningHead•

This is why Jefferson hated "stock-jobbers" and speculators. They have no loyalties to the nation, they produce nothing, and profit more from speculating on the productivity of others than the producers do themselves.

3
SirElkarOwhey•

The closer you are to the money, the more you get paid. And nobody's closer to the money than a bank.

3
Skyrmir•

The banks are where the money trail ends. There's a lot more wealth out there, only so much of it gets reported. I know personally of a company with ~3 times the holdings of Goldman Sachs, almost as old of a company, and they're not on the list.

Some big companies aren't on that list because they're not one of the 'interconnected' ones. Others aren't listed because the information isn't available to outsiders.

2
jagacontest•

I know personally of a company with ~3 times the holdings of Goldman Sachs, almost as old of a company, and they're not on the list.

Who are they and did they meet the criteria for the list?

2
Skyrmir•

I'm not sure if they meet the criteria, however the other big money groups they have ties to aren't listed. So my guess is that they don't tie into this set of 147 companies, even though they're controlling a bit short of a trillion in assets.

Sorry I can't name them, personal ties make it a bad idea.

3
manixrock•

If you take fractional lending into consideration you realize that they get rich by causing inflation. They lend out 10x the amount of money they have, this leads to increased profits for them and increased market prices for everyone. Tell me how this is moral.

2
[deleted]•

The path to riches is to loan governments money. Commerical banks at the highest levels of the Federal Reserve system create money out of nothing in order to buy US Treasury bonds, and then collect the interest on the bonds, as well as on loans they are able to make from having an increase in 'deposits' credited to the US Government's accounts.

Bankers have no allegiances other than to profit, and have historically been glad to finance both parties in a war, from Rothschild to the Bush family financing Hitler.

2
dick_long_wigwam•

the path to riches is not to do something valuable but to finance someone else doing something valuable.

Replace "finance" with "facilitate", and I think you've got yourself a wise business truth right there. If you like bikes, don't try to manufacture bike parts--open a bike store. If you like antiques, don't sell them online--open eBay. You get a lot more exposure to the things you love, and all you need to focus on is a storefront.

1
[deleted]•

Especially when they can arbitrarily create the money out of nothing.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
cynoclast•

No. The path to riches is usury.

Banks get back about $1.20 on the dollar for every dollar they loan.

All money is created through indebtedness to them. Thus the economy literally cannot grow without the banks coming out ahead of everyone else due to usury. If you thought the bailout was privatizing gains and socializing losses, you should try the fed.

In such a system it is inevitable that they end up owning everything.

Ending this this should be the focus of OWS. In the long run no other change will have any effect of changing the status quo.

1
trevormsutherland•

I think that this is very interesting work. The trouble is that even though corporations may be persons under law they can not make even a single decision for themselves. People do! So I think that some work should be done to see who the major shareholders are across these networks and then we will know who the individuals are that have the most influence on a global scale.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
twoodfin•

Vanguard Group Inc

Bwahahaha. My 401(k) rules the world!

Seriously, guys, is it shocking that big banks and large capital funds are the predominant sources of lending for big companies? Apparently in r/science it is.

20
ITSigno•

predominant sources of lending for big companies

While also true, this isn't about lending per se, but rather ownership. The banks have controlling interest in numerous TNCs.

11
twoodfin•

The banks have controlling interest in numerous TNCs.

I don't think that's true. I certainly believe that Vanguard, for example, owns (through its fund-holders) big chunks of IBM and Microsoft. But that's because they run some of the biggest index funds. I'd be surprised if they have a "controlling interest" (defined as holding 50%+1 of the voting shares) in any of the S&P 500. If you combine the holdings of all of the biggest banks and funds, sure, that will get you to 50%+1 for many large companies, but I'm not sure what that's supposed to prove.

2
ITSigno•

I avoided getting into specifics in my reply above, but I'll get into it a bit more here.

If you buy a share in a company through your bank, the share is still yours.

If you invest in a mutual fund and the fund invests in a company, the fund owns the stock, not you.

Now, take Goldman Sachs, if you took all of their investments in, say, DuPont, and put them together (across all funds and or direct bank holdings) and you got 50% +1, then they would have controlling interest. (Not meant to be a factual example)

If you took JP Morgan's holdings and added them to Goldman Sachs to get the 50% + 1, then neither company has a controlling interest and to say they do would be dishonest.

If, on the other hand, you said that ownership of tens of thousands of TNCs was largely split amongst 140 companies then we are closer to what the article said. The article also points out that they take into account direct and indirect ownership, and so would be including ownership through assets spread across multiple funds/holdings.

I'm not sure what that's supposed to prove.

This study seems more focused on data collection and network analysis than it does about proving a point. This isn't r/politics. It would be interesting to see more of the data and their methodology. What is their definition of indirect ownership, for example.

8
[deleted]•

is it shocking that big banks and large capital funds are the predominant sources of lending for big companies?

Actually, yes, it is extremely shocking.

Money and power should rest in the hands of the innovators and manufacturers and not in the hand of the investors.

9
strum•

Seriously, guys, is it shocking that big banks and large capital funds are the predominant sources of lending for big companies?

Read the article. These connections aren't about loans - they're about ownership.

7
wiltedbouquet•

I was so disappoint. I thought Vanguard was cool, man. Now I have to move my money again.

1
[deleted]•

banks man. banks.

0
ima_coder•

I don't see Reddit in this list; it's where I get my marching orders!

edit: I fixed the capitalized letter after the semicolon; I do want to sleep at night.

16
c0bra51•

You don't capitalize after a semicolon by the way.

/ocd

10
[deleted]•

You don't capitalize after a semicolon, by the way.

FTFY, I think. Is that a hard rule or just a style thing?

5
Mourningblade•

Style. Modern style is to eliminate commas that don't change the meaning of the sentence. Of course, modern style also drops the Oxford comma. Bastards.

12
MxM111•

You don't capitalize after a semicolon by the way.

If you have enough investments, you can capitalize at any time.

2
antonbe•

When I went to business school in NYC a few years back, I had a lot of friends and acquaintances (probably 15+, just in my school, more in other schools) working for a company called AXA that I've never freaking heard of. It's really shocking to know just how god damn big that company is.

12
[deleted]•

The US insurance market works very differently to the rest of the world. In Europe and Canada they are free to use their AXA corporate entity to do business while in the US the primary regulator of insurance organizations are the states themselves. While companies can obtain licenses for multiple states the regulations are often contradictory to the point where certain mandated parts of polices in one state are outright illegal in another.

What they end up doing is buying local insurers in the difficult states and insuring via them. This is even the case with well known US insurers, if you have an auto policy with State Farm it will actually be with an organization based in your state with ties to state farm not to the US wide organization state farm.

This is why companies like AXA are virtually unheard of in the states, they tend to be reinsurers, own other brands or be secondary insurers.

22
antonbe•

Thank you for explaining this!

1
nstlgc•

They're quite well-known over here in Europe. They're a bank like we have so many others.

10
CarolusMagnus•

They're not a bank, they are an insurance company and fund manager.

1
nstlgc•
1
PatLemay•

Well known insurance company in Canada

6
creepingdeathv2•

lol ... AXA is a huge huge company! you should read forbes fortune more.

-1
reflibman•

I think that Vanguard Group at #8 is interesting, as this organization helps INVESTORS control money without a lot of fat cat, Banksters types - at least as far as I know.

Edit: Yes, I'm a client, but no other affiliation!

11
theotherwarreng•

This was posted in r/economics a while back, and the general consensus was that was the point.

Vanguard lets you buy index funds, and, in doing so, itself buys stock in these big companies. While you own the index fund, they "own" the stock, so it's completely unsurprising to see them on this list.

9
killerstorm•

Pretty much all companies on this list just hold assets for their clients through ownership of asset management companies, funds etc.

So it's not exactly newsworthy. Large asset management companies hold shitloads of assets. So what?

You can learn this information from wikipedia. E.g. Morgan Stanley Smith Barney manages $1.7 trillion in client assets. That's how Morgan Stanley got on this list.

But, of course, "super-entity" sounds much more sinister than "list of large asset management companies".

3
wiltedbouquet•

I'm a client, too. Now I'm not so sure. Maybe they have REALLY good PR?

2
geekology•

Do you honestly think that is their only model for making money?

1
xtracto•

I remember some years ago there was a webpage (with Flash IIRC) circulating which contained a neat app showing a network of a lot of companies and their chairs and board members.

You could actually see that the same 100 persons (at most) were behind the majority of the companies.

Karma points to the one who can find that page :P

9
justmytype•

I believe this is what you are referring to. Enjoy ;)

9
xtracto•

Yes indeed! This is exactly what I was thinking about.

THanks a lot!

2
pestdantic•

Someone find this man his webpage!!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
UnDire•

When I learned of this network studying Sociology, back in the early 2000's I was stunned and surprised that few people were aware of how this worked. It was one of the major turning points in my personal ideology.

7
iar•

I don't understand the surprise or significance of this study. They set out to find companies that "control" the world economy through "ownership". They found a bunch of companies who pool other people's money and invest it. How is this a surprise? Yes that is a function of the financial system - pool individual's money and invest it into promising enterprises. I guess its a novel application of complex systems analysis but the result is nothing surprising.

7
[deleted]•

It is surprising because most people believe that there is no centralized control. This study provides that there is some sort of centralized control or effort by a few to control everything.

3
iar•

No it doesn't. It just shows a money trail. Just because some huge fund is invested in a company really doesn't mean they are leveraging the sort of direct control you are implying.

1
[deleted]•

It's fundamental monopolization. Which is the goal of all big companies. Corner the market on something and keep doing that until you control everything.

2
soonsighter•

As far as I know, the Depositary Trust Company is simply one of the world's largest securities depositories, it holds in excess of US$10 trillion worth of securities in custody. The DTC acts like a clearinghouse to settle trades in corporate and municipal securities.

They are pretty much a middle man between counter parties for trades. How are they a "super connected" company exactly? I don't think they are doing anything malicious here.

4
[deleted]•

It's funny that people are evaluating the moral aspect of being superconnected. The point of the article isn't whether there is anything malicious in the network, but that if something goes wrong with one of the nodes in the network (e.g., rogue trader loses 50 billion dollars) it causes a ripple effect through the entire network.

This is not in society's interest. This is why banks are considered too big to fail. Ultimately, society bears the costs to maintain this supernetwork which is basically assumption of risk in the event of a system wide failure.

Since a dense system effectively reallocates risk to society (i.e., taxpayers) with the ostensible benefit of efficiency or scale, one has to wonder if there are any society wide benefits from having these superdense networks.

Hence, there it may be more beneficial to society if the network is more distributed even if less efficient or loses the benefits of scaling.

10
[deleted]•

Let me give you a hint. Any company that personally controlls 10 trillion dollars worth of anything has the ability to control the world. That is, when you consider what sort of power that company would have.

Morality and intent have zero to do with the equasion.

1
soonsighter•

It has in custody $10 trillion worth of securities but it does not own them. They simply vault and keep record of what counter party owns what stock.

2
[deleted]•

Well, I work for ING (#40) and our servers and network suck goat balls. I've never worked on such a piss poor network before.

4
BKMD44•

That's how they stay rich! Upgrades, HAH, for what? 10 base t is plenty fast, we just upgraded from token ring.

3
[deleted]•

Don't worry, all the money that was supposed to improve that network probably went into the CEOs pocket.

3
wiltedbouquet•

Not that kind of network, silly!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gameshot911•

Since many of these companies are publicly traded, I'd like to see a graph of the top shareholders of those 47 companies. This will give us a better idea of the real powerholders.

3
wd0511•

My heart jumped when I saw no 4 on the list because I misread it as AXE.

1
megablast•

retarded and proud, nice one.

2
wd0511•

Needless to say, I've read FAR too many of those books for my own good :/

2
emptymatrix•

Now, go for their board of directors...

1
karlhungis•

Hooray, my company isn't listed!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1

I bank with Barclays. Erm... not entirely sure how I should feel about them.

1
hotsizzlepancakes•

I don't see Cisco on that list and Cisco Connects them all!! amiright?

1
[deleted]•

Yes and no.

1
[deleted]•

And behind the scenes sits Beelzebub, lord of the flies.

1
paulmclaughlin•

So, pension funds own lots of shares of many companies. What a surprise.

1
NonHomogenized•

The top 1% of American households owned, as of 2007, 43% of all financial wealth in the US. The next 4% owned another 29%. The bottom 80% owned just 7%. Pension funds aren't where the ownership lies.

1
sonicmerlin•

Where's Apple?

1
[deleted]•

So what exactly is the problem with this?

1
fiercelyfriendly•

The evil oil companies are keeping a low profile..

0
eoin2000•

They're probably owned by the above.

12
I_CATS•

I was surprised how many of those were actually European, and the reasons why Euro taxpayers should save the lenders of Greece and Southern Europe (which most likely are these companies) becomes much clearer: it is a bailout for their piece of shit loan investments.

-1
Bipolarruledout•

Nice. So in reality it's actually smaller now.

-4
TrollingIsaArt•

This study is interesting, and science. The speculative political comments posted here, are not.

There is a class of organizations, who by the nature of their business, help to finance other businesses, and thus have a stake in them. Additionally, these organizations are linked, via being closely related, and via the increased likelihood of interpersonal relationships between the associated people.

132
ninjaofpatience•

The speculative comments in the article didn't help either. Implying the protesters are just crazy conspiracy nuts was uncalled for.

46
johnwalkerjunior•

Yeah, they aren't conspiracists.

Or are they?

22
AanonymousS•

Protester : everything is fucked up

Pssst that's a conspiracy everything is fine .

9
kuahara•

Anyone else look at the thumbnail before clicking and think this was going to be about 147 companies controlling 40% of the universe?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Some of them definitely are, but I agree it wasn't really called for.

8
Brisco_County_III•

The most interesting implication of this for me is the systemic risk of this level of interconnection. It is seriously dangerous to have one of these major controlling entities fail, both because they are so large and because they are so widely tied to other parts of the economy.

Definitely putting the impact of Lehman Brothers, and the concept of "too big to fail", into concrete terms for me.

14
slash196•

The fact that Lehman Brothers was so far up the list casts a lot of light on the turning point that was its collapse. Funnily, the free-market wackos LET it fail, as an "example". This ought to put the lie to the ridiculous idea of an alternative to moral hazard.

2
Pogo4pres•

It would be more accurate to say they were too FEW and too big to fail. It was the monopolization and concentration of these banks and investment institutions that meant 2 or 3 of them represented far too huge a percentage of the obligations in the investment markets. We had something like 3 dozen major commercial banks in the 70s it's now 5 (not including finanical corporations, which are also fairly consoladated), and the remaining medium sized banks and credit unions are simply too small a section of the markets.

2
PaidAdvertiser•

And when they royally screw up their money collecting schemes the governments of the world give them more of everyone elses money.

5
kbntly•

Well the thing is there doesn't have to be some underlying conspiracy. It's simply that they all see the world the same way... that the goal is to make as much money as you can (they say this publicly... i.e. the point of a business is to make money). They see the world as a playing field, and the wealth of the world are the "points" available. So basically, they DO want power, which eventually extends to a global level... there's really no need for some conspiracy or cooperative plan.

"the super-entity is unlikely to be the intentional result of a conspiracy to rule the world. "Such structures are common in nature," says Sugihara."

They act like the massive wealth of these companies happened by accident. Sure their original goal may not have been to "rule the world", but I'm quite sure (they say it constantly in interviews) their goal was to make as much money as possible. When you control the wealth, you have the power too... everyone knows this.

I'm not sure if my statements are clear... but basically: the goal of these companies is to control as much wealth as possible, which is just another way of saying they want to have as much power as possible. No conspiracy necessary... they publicly admit it.

0
EpistaxisOPPhD|Genetics•
115
[deleted]•

The 99% use Vanguard.

Vanguard is the company that holds my mutual funds for my retirement. All they do is buy like the top 100 companies on some stock index. Like the top 100 companies of the SP

Right now, at this very moment, you can buy a piece of Vanguard. You can be the man.

-8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
[deleted]•

Don't take my word for it, look it up. It's a mutual fund company. It's where little people invest their money for retirement.

Vanguard got big cause they didn't charge fees.

3
danweber•

There are fees, but they are very very low.

Also, you can't buy stock in Vanguard. It's owned by its funds. That's pretty populist as far as a financial institution goes.

3
[deleted]•

If all they do is buy the top 100 companies, then why such an expensive management team? Seems bloated to me given your comment.

2
superfine_eligibles•

Dumb comment is dumb.

Vanguard's management fees are razor-thin. That's their entire selling point. You kids are gonna have to grow up and put money into your 401k's soon, you might wanna get off r/politics read up on investing a little bit.

Edit: I apologize for being a complete dick

0
[deleted]•

Way to be a complete dick to a stranger

1
[deleted]•

I'm a 41 year old attorney. Any script kiddy can put together a algorithm that purchases shares in the top 100 based on assets. Yet, they have a management team that must be hugely expensive. Who cares if their fees are 'razor' thin. That just makes me think there are inefficiencies in, gasp, the finance industry.

1
[deleted]•

If you ask me, things are even more decentralized than they used to be in, say, 1910, when seven men representing a quarter of the entire world's wealth met on an island to draft the Federal Reserve Act.

It appears to me that, nowadays, there are a lot of very wealthy, very powerful, and very ambitious individuals who all have different opinions on how the world should be run. If there is some kind of grand conspiracy among these individuals, it is probably very chaotic with very little actual direction. I think that just about the only thing they can all agree on is the expansion of their own profits.

And even if they could somehow direct their efforts to a common cause, I suspect that they'd find it incredibly difficult to actually run the world.

It would be incredibly fascinating to know what sort of discussions go on inside the Bilderberg Group meetings. Someone ought to write a satire or SNL skit with these Bilderberg "big wigs" bickering like a bunch of children on a school yard about how the world should be run.

65
philmoskowitz•

You don't get it. There doesn't need to be conspiracy for there to be unwitting collusion. They all have converging goals so it's only natural that they directly or indirectly work together for their common benefit.

94
[deleted]•

It's exactly like you say it. The idea that there is some kind of conspiratory cabal that works united is so last century. In principle these people don't even have to know each other. When they need to present united front, they work trough various lobbyist organizations and PR firms. These fronts and coalitions are build dynamically over single issues. There is no central planning, just common goals.

In practice these people know each other, so information flows between them very well when there is something they all want.

38
superportal•

When they need to present united front, they work trough various lobbyist organizations and PR firms. These fronts and coalitions are build dynamically over single issues. There is no central planning, just common goals.

... but to paraphrase the authors... Where is the "reality-based" evidence of this?

I could also equally assume the 147 are highly competitive and want to destroy each other. Without evidence or some logic which you have not presented yet (which shows they would only collude), then your conclusion is not substantiated.

4
[deleted]•

I could also equally assume the 147 are highly competitive and want to destroy each other.

But they do. How does that contradict the co-operation? If you want evidence, just look at the money. Who pay for lobbyists. Just look at financial lobby in Washington and Brussels, banks play together for common goals while they compete against each other.

One relevant example: EU is currently raiding banks for evidence of their manipulation of Euribor rates. It was thought that it's impossible to form cartel that includes biggest 44 banks, but this seems to be the case. They are competing all right, but if there is free lunch available that brings bigger profits than beating your opponent, assuming that everybody plays along, it seems that everybody chooses to take that lunch.

2
Pogo4pres•

I don't excpect people to agree with all of Marx's ideas but I'd say he got it pretty on the head in his conception of a "band of hostile brothers". When you talk about concentration of wealth and economic power it is natural when the system is based on competition and expansion (growth), companies compete, some fail, some get bigger, some are victims of boom/bust cycles, more successful ones buy up the smaller ones or the assests of the ones that failed, companies merge to compete with other large corporations, so the whole system whether we see or admit to it is unintentionally designed toward consoladation.

And of course all these companies are at each others throughts, that's what competition is about, they want and need to get into each other's markets and steal them, but they also know what is in all of their best interests, hence the "band of hostile brothers", they know what government policies benefit them, they know when they need to all join lobbying efforts to deregulate or cut programs and ease tax burdens, they know when they have to rely on the government to deal with unions or striking workers (or even massive social unrest) who are beginning to get beyond a companies ability to deal with them, or when foreign politics is hampering the ability of all of them to ply their trade in the economic sphere.

1
Hrodrik•

The only place you see central planning is in those American conservative think tanks, which are pretty much a bunch of pricks with financial interests getting together to shape policy making in their favour. We can thank this asshole for starting the fad.

0
[deleted]•

There is no central planning,

That might or might not be true. It's impossible to say unless you know every conversation these individuals have with one another.

What we do know is that there are quite a few organizations precisely for powerful individuals or corporations to gather and discuss policy: the Bilderberg Group, the Trilateral Commission, and the Council of Foreign Relations, to name a few.

Whether or not this constitutes "central planning" is difficult to say. My own take on it is that each of the players in these groups have their own reason for sitting at the table with the other big wigs. For most of them, it's probably just profit. But you can bet your ass that, among them, there are ambitious individuals who want more power.

0
[deleted]•

This is a good example of accidental collusion.

I believe AT&T had something similar in bidding for telecom concessions in the US, but I cannot find the original article.

3
[deleted]•

You don't get it. There doesn't need to be conspiracy for there to be unwitting collusion. They all have converging goals so it's only natural that they directly or indirectly work together for their common benefit.

Where, exactly, did I say anything contrary to this?

I would say that, if any of them have some ideological goal that goes above and beyond passing or repealing a few regulations--say, a one-world government--they would most certainly need to coordinate their efforts, because let's face it, it's not easy to control 7 billion people.

0
OvidPerl•

It's a given that even if these corporations compete, they don't want to do so at the expense of destroying the ecosystem which allows them to exist. Competing against one another does not preclude mutual cooperation to support their ecosystem as this would be of survival value.

I'm particularly interested in knowing if this phenomenon occurs in nature.

0
h0ncho•

They all have converging goals

No they don't. Look at the current Samsung/Apple feud for example. Samsung tries to block Apple from selling their devices, Apple tries to block Samsung from blocking their devices. These goals ain't even close to be converging. Same with other companies; they compete with each others. Their goals are opposite of each others.

-9
EagleOfMay•

Pointing out spats in the marketplace just misleads from the points of natural collusion.

Both of the companies you use for your example have production facilities in China where environmental laws are lax and bribing local officials relatively easy. Both companies work towards lowering trade barriers so that they can take advantage of cheap production and weak worker protection laws in one nation to export other nations.

3
h0ncho•

Pointing out spats in the marketplace just misleads from the points of natural collusion. Both of the companies you use for your example have production facilities in China where environmental laws are lax and bribing local officials relatively easy

This is not collusion.

Both companies work towards lowering trade barriers so that they can take advantage of cheap production and weak worker protection laws in one nation to export other nations.

There is more than enough companies out there that lobby in favour of stronger trade barriers. Agriculture would be #1 here.

2
[deleted]•

Well, first of all, you're talking about the tech industry. The tech industry is savagely competitive and always will be.

Banks, on the other hand, prefer to form cartels. As a matter of fact, that's essentially what the Federal Reserve is: a banking cartel with the added perk of having government-granted authority over the only legal tender currency. Now, that doesn't mean banks don't compete; they all want to dominate the entire market, but if they're in a market stalemate they will begrudgingly work together, insofar as the law permits it.

1
[deleted]•

"seven men representing a quarter of the entire world's wealth" - Interesting fact. What's the source?

47
Devotia•

It's conspiracy wonk. I lost the actual numbers to a Chrome crash, but basically this, with a dash of Illuminati where third party editors wouldn't edit it out.

Same numbers, same lack of citation. Even counting Rockefeller's worth (and the link to him is shaky, at best) and valuing the rest at Andrew Carnegie's worth (since doing it at Rockefeller's would just be silly) they would have a combined net worth of about 5% of the US economy. So for this math to check out, these guys not only needed to be hiding 6 Carnegie fortunes, but 5% of the US economy in 1910 needed to equal almost half the world's wealth. I guess if you don't count Europe it might be close.

74
the6thReplicant•

So not correct then.

32
[deleted]•

Not necessarily.

The point of secretive behaviour is - you know - making your behaviour stay a secret.

7
[deleted]•

The key word is representing 25% of the world's wealth. No where did I say that they own it.

0
Devotia•

My numbers are what they represented at a vastly inflated number. The richest man in the world (Rockefeller) was accounted for, and even he only holdings equivalent to 1/65th of the US economy. Even if they had a group of 65 (which they didn't), AND they all were on par with Rockefeller (which they weren't), they would only have a combined wealth equal to the GDP of the USA in 1910, which is still under a fifth of the world economy.

If you've got actual numbers with citations that in any way contradict my mental math, I'd be happy to see them. I just can't see any way you can even remotely get these numbers to a quarter of the world's combined wealth.

As to the historical accuracy of The Creature from Jekyll Island, I've not read it, but I have read the text of a speech Griffin gave on it. However, we must remember that both the speech and book were written by a man who claimed to have found the Biblical Ark of Noah, touts amygdalin as a cancer cure and wrote a book on the existence of chemtrails. It's a bit of ad hominem, I'll admit, but when you are an avid proponent of oft-debunked conspiracies in several arenas, I'm less likely to take you as a reliable source of information, especially when that information is so extraordinary and poorly cited (Not talking about you, but about Mr. Griffin.)

5
[deleted]•

I got it from The Creature from Jekyll Island. Certainly not the most objective source. I think "representing" is a key word here though; these seven men represented the financial institutions (i.e. banks) commanding 25% of the world's wealth.

2
vbullinger•

Devotia's not including the richest family in the world: the Rothschilds.

1
didierjar•

The idea that there is a conspiracy in the functioning of the world economy has always been overselling it, usually in an attempt to discourage any honest discussion on what should be plainly obvious. No one needs to meet in a giant boardroom and have maniacal booming comic book-villain-conversations about how best to manipulate the masses.

But that also doesn't mean that it isn't easy to see that their interests converge. As capital accumulation creates large concentrated power it will do what it can to maintain that position and accrue more. All you need to do is realize that and then most of the functioning of any large economic enterprise makes sense (even though once you step outside the abstract world of markets they'd be sociopathic in their conduct). And these entities do share a fair amount of information and tactics and then adopt what works.

Such as the "Mohawk Valley formula" later called "scientific methods of strike-breaking" during and after the Depression. The entire modern PR industry and most corporate run polling agencies serve the essential function (among others) of keeping a finger on the pulse of populations opinions and then, in the words of Edward Bernays, "Manufacturing public opinion in the interests of the privileged." The business community and state have always understood this. And any cursory look at post 19th century history reveals it rather well.

This fundamental opposition between concentrated power of markets and meaningful, democratic, functioning institutions was succinctly summed up by John Dewey: "As long as politics is the shadow cast on society by big business, the attenuation of the shadow will not change the substance."

38
clickity-click•

Very educational post. I typically speed read but I took my time with this one. Thank you for posting.

4
Terr_•

And the influence of money in the political system is, while initially "a way to decide to participate", ultimately antithetical to representative democracy, since an individual who controls more wealth gets more representation.

4
modfatha•

Except Chomsky's a communist or something, so nothing he says can possibly be true, even if there are a dozen sources and footnotes on every page. Besides, capitalist imperialism allows me to enjoy a good 4-5 hours of TV each day in my only free time between work and sleep, why would I want to jeopardize that?

-1
twoodfin•

Except Chomsky's a communist or something, so nothing he says can possibly be true, even if there are a dozen sources and footnotes on every page.

That's a strawman. Those who disagree with Chomsky tend to think he's an intellectually dishonest sophist, not that everything he says is a lie.

6
Bipolarruledout•

So the good news is that they're all driving us over a cliff? Conspiracy is an extremely strong word. The bottom line is that the world was sold this economic failure as a free market utopia.

How many people were on the earth in 1910? Based on this "trend" this 147 is going to shrink rather than expand. Can we end this fantasy that wealth and power does not exert a political influence on governments? Next perhaps someone can figure out how many laws were written and enacted by these entities. Over 40%?

24
Jigsus•

In 1910 there were 1.7 billion on this planet. Now there are 7 billion. So there are 4.11 times more people on this planet. 7 ruling men*4.11= 28

There are considerably more people in charge now.

11
philmoskowitz•

you should be using ppp gpd then to now if you want to make any sense of that rationale.

5
Jigsus•

It doesn't matter the result is very very similar. Whichever way you slice it the power has divided.

4
emsharas•

I'm still amazed by the fact that it took thousands of years to reach 1.7 billion people, and then in 100 years we were able to quadruple that to 7 billion. What the heck?

3
[deleted]•

A huge increase in personal mobility via ship, train and automobile, along with the agricultural science to provide enough food for everyone and the medicine to keep them healthy.

There are a lot of us because in the last 200 years we've tailored the planet to our existence, before that we were merely along for the ride and at the whims of mother nature.

6
Maskirovka•

How is this amazing? Take a math class where you study the exponential function...and then think about agricultural technology and public health factors.

0
mantra•

Even if bigger, it's still a rather small, finite and "doable" number.

2
erikbra81•

who all have different opinions on how the world should be run

That's going a bit too far. Their opinions on how to run world are 1) very well aligned on many important issues, and 2) completely different from what almost any electorate would opine.

These are the world's top elite, from very specific social circles. They don't represent a wide array of values or opinions.

Conspiracy? Who needs it? These guys are like a clockwork whether they coordinate or not.

10
[deleted]•

Their opinions on how to run world are 1) very well aligned on many important issues, and 2) completely different from what almost any electorate would opine.

How do you know? Have you been to the Bilderberg meetings?

0
erikbra81•

It's the same people there that are at Davos and all these gatherings. Their opinions are known.

2
[deleted]•

What are those opinions?

1
Switche•

This wasn't the point of the article at all

John Driffill of the University of London, a macroeconomics expert, says the value of the analysis is not just to see if a small number of people controls the global economy, but rather its insights into economic stability.

and later

Crucially, by identifying the architecture of global economic power, the analysis could help make it more stable. By finding the vulnerable aspects of the system, economists can suggest measures to prevent future collapses spreading through the entire economy.

I'm pretty fiscally conservative, but objectively speaking, this article was quite clear in stressing there are stability concerns raised by this research, not conspiracy, and it's irresponsible to bring up conspiracy after the article was so clear this is a factual research effort into the stability of global economics.

Your points are valid, but they're misplaced as a criticism of this research.

9
[deleted]•

The purpose of my post wasn't to criticize the research but add to the discussion. Admittedly I was rambling a bit because I had a couple of drinks in me when I wrote it.

1
Valendr0s•

Right... even if 7 men did have 25% of the world's wealth, it was just because it was from standard oil and other monopolies.

Then the economy imploded, the distribution of wealth got even worse, and we decided to ensure a company couldn't control too much of a single sector of the economy, made a law against monopolies. Then the distribution of wealth got far more even and we had the 50's and 60's, the middle class Renaissance and great prosperity for the most number of people ever.


Now it's happened again. We need to go back to the tax rates of the 50's and 60's and make another new law, but this time instead of targeting monopolies, it should target corporations that are "too big to fail". No company should be so big that it can cause the American or worldwide economy to fail.

7
[deleted]•

We need to go back to the tax rates of the 50's and 60's and make another new law

http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2007/04/are_the_rich_really_different

I'm not sure they need to be THAT high. They could definitely be higher though.

3
Laatuska•

If there is some kind of grand conspiracy among these individuals, it is probably very chaotic with very little actual direction.

There are issues which are against the interests of all or most of them, like any regulation that threatens economic growth or free movement of capital and investments (access to cheap labor).

Why wouldn't they collaborate in defeating initiatives that hurt them all? We see this sort of cooperation all the time in certain sectors of industry: cartels and price fixing, lobbying and bribing.

6
rubygeek•

They don't need to collaborate. They just need to individually follow their own interests, and whenever their interests align you suddenly have corporations with collective ownership of a large percent of the total wealth of the planet pulling in the same direction.

A lot of people who scream about conspiracy could benefit from reading some Marx. Capitalists by and large aren't evil, nor do they by and large divide the world between them in some dark smoky back room somewhere. Some, sure, but that hardly matters. By and large they don't have to. They are cogs in the machine as well. Just by pursuing their own interests, their actions align and inherently leads to promoting certain policies, namely policies that protect and extend their wealth.

The working class could do good picking up a trick or three: Actually taking actions, including voting, that actually align with their personal interests rather than continuing to effectively act in ways that protect the rich.

(And that's pretty much the executive summary of marxism)

5
[deleted]•

I would say they collaborate on things they agree on, absolutely. But keep in mind that, in the market, a lot of these corporations are competitors with one another.

And even then, to say that they all have the same ideological goals would be very difficult to prove.

1
Laatuska•

And even then, to say that they all have the same ideological goals would be very difficult to prove.

Our system should be built in a way that assumes that they do. Anything else seems wishful thinking to me.

1
robertcrowther•

I think that just about the only thing they can all agree on is the expansion of their own profits.

The problem is their agreement on that one topic is the root cause of most of the issues a group like this could/would cause.

4
jacques_chester•

Do you mean banks do business with lots of companies? And often hold shares on trust for customers?

I'm shocked. Shocked!

23
ShanduCanDo•

This is an outrage. We should pass a law that says banks may only have one customer at a time.

5
jacques_chester•

Occupy Parliament/Congress/The Daily Show!

4
koobaxion•

#occupyeverything

2
throwawaymangler•

I work in telecommunications, and think you guys would be absolutely blown away by how much bandwidth financial companies have available to them. There has been increased focus on lowering latency, even going so far as to fret over nanoseconds, and require the carrier to use equipment that may not provide the best metrics but whose ASICs provide that nanosecond edge.

It's also strange, in some cases, where those 10/40/100gb circuits terminate, and who buys them - at least to me.

Anyway, the problem I have with it, personally, is that I don't see this sort of investment in next-generation equipment and higher bandwidth for the consumer-level backbone. The focus is all on the high-paying financial firms, and fuck the people paying $50/month for a 20mb/s Internet connection. Oversubscribing the living balls out of those connections is no problem, because they'll take it and like it.

1
ima_coder•

Concentration of power is not good or bad in itself, says the Zurich team, but the core's tight interconnections could be.

I'm having trouble reconciling the two parts of this sentence from the article. Aren't concentrations of power actually tight interconnections?

22
Shawn_of_the_Redd•

I would say sort of, but not necessarily. In theory, the US government provides an example of how this might work. It has concentrations of different kinds of power in its Legislative, Executive, and Judicial branches, but they are distinct, separate, and balance each other in meaningful ways (again, in theory).

They remain "connected," and have "concentrations of power," but they don't all see things the same way and may operate on different agendas.

7
SomebodiesSon•

Is it the difference between affect and effect?

A concentration of power means one source can affect all the rest if it wants. Not necessarily good or bad, depending on what the powerful point decides to do.

Tight interconnections means an event in one can effect all the others. So one part going bankrupt causes the others to as well.

3
Maskirovka•

Perhaps it's more clear if you differentiate authority from power? For example, you can imagine a celebrity network on twitter...it might be tightly interconnected and have the power to influence people in small ways, but celebrities have no authority.

I think the team is mincing words. influence != power != authority

2
Game_Ender•

You can have the same guy be an owner of half the worlds companies, and it would result in a concentration of power. Yet if all of his companies were relatively independent it wouldn't be bad from an economic standpoint. If, on the other hand, his companies are tightly interrelated, such that if a few fail the whole group goes down, it would be very bad for the economy.

2
atari_eric•

Power corrupts. Does concentration of power produce concentrated corruption? Absolutely!

1
PaidAdvertiser•

Straws. Grasping. You.

-1
ima_coder•

Class. Sentence structure. Missing you.

1
johnwalkerjunior•

You can concentrate power in Caesar, who redistributes land rights by taking the excess from the upper class, and ensuring that the general population have access to free grain...

Or you can concentrate power in someone like Julian Assange, who will fuck the world dry and not even have the goddamn courtesy to give it a reach around.

-5
superportal•

There are some truths here, but then it's combined with unsubstantiated sensationalism. It's disappointing to see it upvoted with many "rah-rah" non-scientific comments here.

When this study came out a while ago ("Jul 28, 2011") it was vetted on r/economics (I believe it was there) and already determined to have a bunch of methodological flaws/issues. I don't remember everything mentioned off the top of my head but here were some issues:

(1) It's called:The network of global corporate control.

So then, what do they conclude about "global corporate control"?

Not much. This paper makes conclusions about CONNECTIONS, somewhat on ownership (with questions) but not much about actual CONTROL. For example, it doesn't show level/magnitude of outcome control by 147 companies or whether that translates into a uniform planned or unplanned outcome (the authors say it probably doesn't, but no "reality-based" evidence is provided).

"The real question, says the Zurich team, is whether it can exert concerted political power. Driffill feels 147 is too many to sustain collusion." (no "reality-based" evidence is provided for this assertion)

(2) Many of the connections are because these are financial services companies who are holding stock in trust for customers - when you buy stock, depending how it's done (ie mutual fund, index ETF), it may be held in trust in the other financial company's name. Also, there are other levels of stock holdings that gived preferred ownership to some owners (such as insiders) relative others.

"Yaneer Bar-Yam, head of the New England Complex Systems Institute (NECSI), warns that the analysis assumes ownership equates to control, which is not always true. Most company shares are held by fund managers who may or may not control what the companies they part-own actually do."

(3) Just to move forward on #2 - Let's say for example 147 firms owned another firm. So each would own less than 1% - it seems unlikely that 147 firms will agree on how a firm, let alone many firms, should be run.

Nevertheless, I agree that Financial firms do exert a lot of influence in the economy, but that's was well-established before this study by anybody with a modicum of experience in this area.

22
mhermans•

a bunch of methodological flaws/issues

Strangely, you do not mention a serious methodological flaw. You mainly focus on the theoretical discussion on whether and to what degree "control" is really at play here. This is a discussion that has a very long lineage in social theory (cf. an overview on power), and that cannot be answered in a single empirical paper.

Offering that kind of critique and casually dismissing the results as "something everybody already knows" is slightly disingenuous imho. It is not my main research field, but I do have a strong interest in e.g. interlocking directorate studies and I have not seen an analysis with a "sample" this large. And its conclusions go against the grain of nearly every layman's overall conception of how the free market operates.

For instance, this is a graph on interlocking directorates in the BEL20 I presented a while ago for Transparency International Belgium. Even those people, who work full time on issue like collusion, corruption, covert links, etc. were quite surprised at the degree of concentration if you look at (just the formal*) connections between the top Belgian companies, financial institutions, regulatory institutions, media companies, etc.

This kind of "network view" is absolutely not "well-established", and I feel that dismissing it as such is not ideologically neutral.


* If you add informal networks, the picture gets even more interesting. For instance, people familiar with the Belgian "who's who" can discern underlying clusters, based on Flemish and Walloon families.

32
superportal•

methodological flaws/issues

I was referring to the implication that this shows collusion, and the quotes I offered back that up. Where is your evidence to the contrary? There is nothing in the methodology that leads to the conclusion of how these 147 firms influence the rest.

Offering that kind of critique and casually dismissing the results as "something everybody already knows" is slightly disingenuous imho

You can look up the ownership holding of any public company and see that large investment banks, financial services and financial holdings companies own much of the non-insider shares. So it's a not a big a secret. As mentioned, it's often held in trust, through funds, pensions, etc. It's also not a big secret that most loans and financing comes from the same large financial institutions. Anybody who works in the financial industry is aware of this.

And its conclusions go against the grain of nearly every layman's overall conception of how the free market operates.

What free market are you referring to?

[edit]

This kind of "network view" is absolutely not "well-established"

I did NOT say that.

I said: "I agree that Financial firms do exert a lot of influence in the economy, but that's was well-established". It is well-established using other non-network data, theory and experience. I'm not so entranced by this network view because it's superficial, it just shows connections not the degree of control, and it neglects a lot of variables.

dismissing it as such is not ideologically neutral.

??? Where am I not ideologically neutral in my comment? What you "feel" is irrelevant--you are injecting your own biased feelings (perhaps from a view of what you imagine is a "free market" by your mention of it). I have experience in the financial industry and my statements are based on data, analysis and 1st-hand experience.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
adius•

"Not ideologically neutral?" You're arguing with internet forums posters here, not robots programmed for rational political debate

-2
[deleted]•

"r/science"

I think we all expect/want the discourse here to be of a different breed.

4
adius•

Yeah I'm just not sure if reddit is the best location for this kind of thing...

-1
mhermans•

it was vetted on r/economics (I believe it was there)

I located the [only topic in r/economics that discusses this](http://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/jqjzz/study_shows_powerful_corporations_really_do/), and it is complete gibberish. I have a lot of trouble finding a single insightful and to the point comment.

There are possibly three links reporting the same story (1, 2, 3) and none of them led to any "vetting". Which insightful subreddit am I missing?

18
[deleted]•

Yeah, he lost me at "vetted on r/economics". A bunch of redditors with more expertise than actual economists.

5
Bipolarruledout•

That's like asking the GOP to vet climate change statistics. Sure, there's no "proof" of climate change but there's sure a lot of data to support it. The fact of the mater is that we don't have enough data to fully understand these systems and the very act of collecting it would change the dynamic anyway. Would anyone seriously suggest that the data goes further to disprove the implied conclusion than to prove it?

Until we can model complex systems on a sub-atomic level there will always be someone who begs the possible but not very probable.

4
MrMannersOnline•

Sure, there's no "proof" of climate change but there's sure a lot of data to support it.

Drawing an analogy between this paper and climate science is putting a lot of disrespect towards climatologists. The quality of work in climatology is leaps and bounds ahead of this paper (full disclosure: I am a social scientist, but not an economist).

14
Maskirovka•

I am a social scientist, but not an economist

An important distinction that is lost on most people.

1
superportal•

Would anyone seriously suggest that the data goes further to disprove the implied conclusion than to prove it?

On the issue of "control", like collusion, I'd say it's inconclusive based on the data provided in the paper. And the authors pretty much say the same thing.

They mainly suggest it has implications for (1) how this affects volatility to the system as a whole due to possibly reducing risk diversification, and (2) the effect on market competition -- not if there is some "global conspiracy". But no firm conclusions to those questions are offered.

9
erikbra81•

I don't understand why people hear the word "conspiracy" as soon as you want to talk about dominant institutions or uneven distribution of power. Weird, because most of the time the word wasn't even uttered.

7
Maskirovka•

I don't understand why people want to debunk conspiracy theories even when nobody is suggesting there is a conspiracy.

Also, the article mentions conspiracy.

3
PaidAdvertiser•

con·spir·a·cy    [kuhn-spir-uh-see] Show IPA noun, plural -cies. 1. the act of conspiring. 2. an evil, unlawful, treacherous, or surreptitious plan formulated in secret by two or more persons; plot. 3. a combination of persons for a secret, unlawful, or evil purpose: He joined the conspiracy to overthrow the government. 4. Law. an agreement by two or more persons to commit a crime, fraud, or other wrongful act. 5. any concurrence in action; combination in bringing about a given result.

con·spire    [kuhn-spahyuhr] Show IPA verb, -spired, -spir·ing. verb (used without object) 1. to agree together, especially secretly, to do something wrong, evil, or illegal: They conspired to kill the king. 2. to act or work together toward the same result or goal. verb (used with object) 3. to plot (something wrong, evil, or illegal).

2
superportal•

Weird, because most of the time the word wasn't even uttered.

The term "conspiracy" was used in the New Science article, as well as in comments.

1
[deleted]•

Would anyone seriously suggest that the data goes further to disprove the implied conclusion than to prove it?

Thats not the way science works, what you are describing is the precautionary principle or something very similar. Not being able to disprove something is not proof and never will be.

Can you disprove that you want to have sex with poodles? No? Well on the balance of probabilities therefore you do like to have sex with poodles.

This is not science and it isn't logic, its mental aerobatics to attempt to make data match a conclusion not formulate a conclusion from data.

3
[deleted]•

It's disappointing to see it upvoted with many "rah-rah" non-scientific comments here.

What? Unscientific comments on an internet forum? No way!

1
optimister•

There is nothing inherently evil about being big and powerful. As the article points out,

The real question . . . is whether it can exert concerted political power.

14
whatthedude•

In fact, being big means that you are fairly accountable and move slow. Sure, the people at the top make more money. But if you've ever worked within a big organization, it's not that different than the government when it comes to pure bureaucracy.

7
[deleted]•

Corporations have a dictator at the top.

3
whatthedude•

That have to run big decisions past a board...and publicly traded companies all have shareholders that vote...

CEOs are often picked more marketing than anything else. Lloyd Blankfein is smart but isn't the smartest guy at Goldman, but it looks good to have a nice Jewish guy that was raised in the projects make it to the top. He's good at his job but his story is even better.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Bipolarruledout•

Is that still a question or is it simply a delusion that allows people to feel better about the world we live in?

1
ShanduCanDo•

Yes, it's still a question. You might be surprised to learn this, but speculation and hearsay do not actually qualify as scientific evidence.

1
zoograph•

LOL of course it can

1
noddyxoi•

See the Barclays article in wikipedia for example. Or Goldman Sachs. One makes money with weapons trade and laundering. The other makes money investing against their own clients and cooking books of countries. And this is only what is public.

GS is controlled by jews (i'm not racist) they have people in high places all over the globe and their CEO has once said they were "doing god's work". See the past CEO revenue to see the earnings of god.

These are nothing but the invisible armies / mafia of the XXI century.

-1
ShanduCanDo•

i'm not racist

Yes you are. You can't just say "I'm not racist" and have that excuse every racist thing you say.

Calling Jews "they" like they are some massive, single-minded cabal is racist. Assuming that business decisions are made first and foremost based on race is racist.

Anyway, the "God's work" thing was pretty clearly not supposed to be literal. That's the danger of getting all your news from sound bites.

4
noddyxoi•

I admire jews, specially the agricultural efforts in Israel and their schemes to control the economy. About them i just don't like the ortodoxes costumes.

I like blacks, they are the opposite of jews as they are "cool" and relaxed. I just don't like RAP, as it's too much gangster.

I do not like chinese, they frighten me with their foxconn and lack of human dignity.

1
ShanduCanDo•

The fact that you think that all members of the same race uniformly think and behave the same way makes you racist. There's no such thing as "good racism".

1
[deleted]•

The conclusion doesn't really follow from the paper. The paper focuses on ownership, with the angle of showing the inter-connected nature of ownership that could be relevant in case of financial crisis. It doesn't purport to establish that the "super-entity" somehow directs the actions of the other companies.

The list is full of banks, but you'd expect such a list to be full of banks if you're looking at ownership. When you put money in your 401k, where do you think it goes? To some mutual fund manager at a bank who buys equity in some companies. Probably most public companies in the world have shares that are largely held by a collection of mutual funds, pension funds, and other financial vehicles at banks. That doesn't mean that any given bank has control of any given company. And indeed it doesn't even mean that the banks really "own" these companies. Goldman Sachs has $850 billion in assets under management, but $80 billion in equity. Only the latter figure is really its own assets. The former is other peoples' money that it manages on their behalf.

14
dhphg•

this

-2
estacado•

Can somebody just list out the 147 companies.

13
Gareth321•

They only list the top 50 companies for some reason. I checked the paper itself.

18
Kerkko•

Top 50 control-holders on page 33 of the study.

15
ubuwalker31•

Thanks for the direct link to the study.

2
igrokyourmilkshake•

agreed--listing the top 50 is insufficient when the entire premise is that they're an interconnected dependent mass. Identifying 34% of a tumor is almost futile.

2
hotdinerbatman•

politics bleeding over into r/science now? damn.

12
prsnep•

Science is a method, not a subject matter. Science is not mutually exclusive from politics. If a scientific study was done in any field, it is science.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gethereddout•

The final number of folks in control would get even smaller if we had more access...

10
Bipolarruledout•

Considering these are publicly available records this is quite shocking. What about all the shell corporations that can't be readily associated with these?

6
AlekhinesGun•

Actually, it would become even larger, considering that every publicly traded company is owned by thousands of people.

3
[deleted]•

Share-holders have as much say as voters do in their government.

3
gethereddout•

Exactly. The distribution of power is an illusion. Controlling critical nodes of power is all it takes to dominate a network.

4
bitchslap2012•

This is a great article. Finally have a cool study to go along with all the wealth inequality statistics that we wave around at OWS. I am sure that the web of shared interest could be even smaller than the 147 companies if they had access to the private files of these TNC's.

9
[deleted]•

The problem is that many large private firms aren't listed on this. Koch Industries would probably fare pretty well if they were listed.

There should be a global movement to ensure that companies with revenues exceeding $1 billion have to publicize their ownership data regardless of private or public ownership.

Similarly anyone with total yearly income exceeding 100 million USD should reveal their total income and sources of income (it would be a check on personal power on a local/ state level).

8
combustible•

But then you're saying the wealthy aren't guaranteed a right to privacy that less-wealthy people are? Seems a bit unfair...

15
ellipsisoverload•

There's surely a large difference between privately held firms and the people who own them... The people maintain their privacy, the firms do not...

8
combustible•

But the person I was replying to was suggesting that high-earning individuals should not be allowed to keep their earnings private.

7
[deleted]•

the rights to privacy should not trump the security of a clean and fair democracy. In cases where power (money) is concentrated enough and there is no real public knowledge, those with the power can warp government decisions through influence alone.

2
mhermans•

Just make the same rule for everyone then. In Norway for instance all tax returns have been public information since 1863.

4
VannaTLC•

Norway is not a good comparative model to the US..

1
Bipolarruledout•

Not unfair at all. They also a "right" to less money should they choose to exercise it. Tyranny of the majority is a well known side effect of democracy but there's absolutely no precedent against it as any non-protested class will attest to. Only a capitalist would claim that someone making 100 million is being "oppressed" while the homeless person or hungry child is not.

3
Boshaft•

The US Constitution was created specifically to be a precedent against the tyranny of the majority.

1
[deleted]•

hmm somewhat true... in retrospect, I think that the second rule should only apply to people who own shares in or are top management in companies that have government contracts. (multiple edits for clarity. also should note that this sort of limited law will only be effective with clear seperation of corporate money from political campaigns/ ad spending)

I was inspired by the ontario income disclosure form; it reveals the salary of every person making more than 100k with part or whole of their income coming from government sources.

1
mhermans•

Why not make the same rule for everyone? In Norway for instance all tax returns have been public information since 1863.

4
[deleted]•

Most people do not believe that their private income tax information should be available to the public (unless they are paid by the public, of course). This type of invasion of privacy would be a non-starter in North America, don't even bother going down that road....

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
[deleted]•

I'm not even going to touch that last suggestion (not many people are willing to give up their legal privacy), but...

There should be a global movement to ensure that companies with revenues exceeding $1 billion have to publicize their ownership data regardless of private or public ownership.

All that will happen is that private companies will split into smaller private companies the second the hit a billion dollars in revenue. Same ownership, solves nothing.

5
[deleted]•

if you're earning a huge amount of money, shouldn't there be a check against your potential power to warp democracy? Its not like I'm suggesting we track every detail. Just put down the larger details. eg . Mr Lincoln earned $100 million this year in total- including 80 million from capital gains of the defence contractor that he owns.

2
[deleted]•

No. I believe it's totally sufficient to divulge all campaign contributions publicly. What we need to do is make campaign financing and lobbying reform central issues again. I don't give a shit if Sir Joe Blow is worth $100 million if he doesn't enter the political ring. If he gives money to a person running for public office, however, I want to know about it.

1
whatthedude•

Your target of revenues of over $1B seems to come from......?

Seriously, go back to the sand box.

0
Kni7es•

The takeaway message here is that the global economy relies on the health and stability of a very small number of "Keystone" firms. If you're familiar with the ecological concept of Keystone Species, these firms have a huge effect on their 'environment' (markets) relative to their size. The cautionary note here is that if one or more of those businesses got in trouble (no longer solvent), it would be the collapsing pillar upon which untold thousands of other firms stand upon.

Environmental science teaches us that an environment is more stable when there are many species each having limited influence on the others. That way if one species were to fail, their ecological niche would be small enough to be quickly filled by other species.

Likewise, this can be applied to economics. A market is more stable when there are a large number of small firms competing with one another, such that the failure of one does not unduly affect the others. We saw what happened when Keystone Firms failed in the mortgage market in 2008; it sent shockwaves throughout the entire global economy. Economics and Biology both prove that "Too Big to Fail" is fundamentally unsustainable.

8
paiche•

This is a really cool interpretation of ecology/economics. I am familiar with keystone species especially relating to invasive species, but I have not heard about it being applied to economics. Can you suggest any books or articles on this?

2
Kni7es•

As an environmental science student who specializes in policy and economics, you would think I'd have something off the top of my head. Uh... I don't. Sorry. :(

This is one of those concepts my peers and I talk about a lot, so I'm at a loss for identifying the genesis of this concept. It's just something I take for granted. I'm pretty sure you could find something good on Google Scholar or JSTOR (if you have access to it).

If I may add one more thing to the original point it's this: These concepts are nothing new. I often say that all strategy is rooted in nature. Decentralization is a stabilizing factor in not just ecological systems or economic systems, but systems in general. You could apply it to architecture and engineering, for instance (and indeed, the original metaphor for Keystone Species is based around that). For example: If you have a suspension bridge, and you need 100,000kg worth of support, it would be more stable to use one hundred 1,000kg tension cables instead of one big 100,000kg cable. Exact same concept, different type of system.

2
paiche•

Cool thanks for the info. I was thinking there might be more because one important ecology equation is the lotka volterra which relates to competition between species, and I also know that it has its origin in economics, along with several other ecological principles I can't think of at the moment. I do have access to jstor so I will give it a go. Thanks for the thoughtful reply.

1
Aserapha•

If you want a 'fun' cross disciplinary exercise, try describing a finding for one discipline of science like cellular biology in another disciplines terms such as Economics...(although 'Classical' Economics is as much of a science as Anakin Skywalker was a Jedi...)

1
tendimensions•

This isn't necessarily a bad thing. There was a TED talk that covered the brilliant idea that in order to help conservation efforts (use less of the natural resources on the planet) it was much easier to work with the few transnational companies that made up the biggest usage rather than try to change the behavior of billions of individuals. I'd post the talk, but I can't figure out good search terms on the TED site to dig it up right now. The guy giving the talk had already worked successfully with a handful of companies to make huge diffences in how coffee growing used the farmland and he only needed to work with a handful of companies. Who, by the way, are very interested in conserving for perfectly selfish motives.

7
davy_crockett•

That sounds like one benefit of having an economy made up of a few large companies, but it probably doesn't outweigh the cons of such an economy.

3
JimmyRyan•

Yeah, while appreciate seeing some good that comes from it, I still don't plan on putting down my pitchfork.

4
Shawn_of_the_Redd•

That's a fair point, but this is also surely an issue where a whole lot trades on the degree to which things get centralized. It's good to have organizations big enough and powerful enough to be able to be effective, but on the other hand overcentralization seems like it would contribute to groupthink.

That could result in a kind of "built-in short-sightedness" if there is a problem bigger than the handful of organizations are able to tackle. That'd be bad. Global warming would be the example that springs immediately to my mind, but I am sure there are others - things like building momentum for an international effort to ban things like child labor, that kind of thing.

1
Paterack•

Don't blame the banks, blame yourself if you've no job and no money.

Edit: Sigh. I should have put /sarcasm at the end. It's a Herman Cain quote

Edit 2: Really Reddit? Sarcasm, look it up.

6
Dr_Donut•

Nice try illuminati super entity

8
bitchslap2012•

"Yeah bro just go out and find one of those jobs that the banks shipped overseas!" The financial companies that caused the recession are indirectly and in some cases directly responsible for the millions of jobs that have been lost in the US.

6
Afterburned•

Most of the jobs lost in the U.S. are really, really shitty jobs(think stitching stuffed animals). And we have a shortage of workers in much better paying fields.

1
Bandikoto•

And we have a shortage of workers in much better paying fields.

No, we don't.

We have a shortage of indentured servants in those fields, because that's who the corporations actually want to hire.

4
Afterburned•

I wasn't talking about tech. Many tech jobs are absurdly easy to outsource and will be. I'm talking about plumbers, carpenters, electricians and other skilled trades of all varieties. It depends upon where you live, but most of the trades are experiencing job shortages and job growth,

0
PaidAdvertiser•

Maybe some people would rather stitch bears than go to college for four years while taking on loans that won't be paid off in 15 years working in management making a shit salary or wiping peoples asses in a hospital. All the good jobs are taken and they have been taken for years with a hundred people all waiting in line to take those jobs.

Also, what if you were arrested for breaking one of our nations insane drug laws? Might as well wipe your ass with your diploma after that.

3
Afterburned•

There are tons of jobs in the skilled trades open, and over the course of the next 10 - 20 years those jobs are only going to increase as the baby boomers retire or die off.

And what do our drug laws have to do with banks? It's not that difficult to not break them. So while I am all for getting our drug laws changed to something more progressive (mostly, all drugs are legal everywhere.) You can easily avoid the situation you speak of by not doing drugs.

1
Tobar7•

Afterburned: great like allegiance to the fact free cult. You will rise high in the republican party, but, that's not saying much.

0
Afterburned•

Tobar7: Says nothing about anything. You could rise high in any party you wanted to, since that is all politicians can do. And for your information I find both the Republicans and Democrats to worthless shits.

1
Shawoop•

Fuck you.

3
wemptronics•

Quotation marks usually help out in situations such as these.

2
PaidAdvertiser•

So if you are being sarcastic everyone should upvote you for being so damn witty?

1
[deleted]•

It's amazing how few commentors seem to have read the article...

6
railrulez•

But the title tells me all I need to make up my mind!

1
kko_•

study finds that 1% of the reddit community understands the meaning of this and the rest think it has to do with OWS or the illuminati.

5
[deleted]•

Do you understand the meaning of this? Perhaps we can benefit from your analysis if you were so inclined to share it.

6
64-17-5MS|Organic Cehmistry•

[citation needed]

2
kko_•

one person who doesn't get it "is the 99%" therefore only the 1% get it.

-3
64-17-5MS|Organic Cehmistry•

By that you must be one of the 1% (get him guys!!). If higher knowledge about posts in r/science is a requirement for posting comments, why don't the moderators make a rule of it? Edit: This was not a question specifically for you and I don't expect any answers. I just find it tiresome to see all the complains of "non-scientific" comments on r/science.

-1
nstlgc•

Down with the 1%!

-4
unknownpoltroon•

147 companies, how many of those have the same 6-8 people controlling the company? I saw a chart once, they had 8-10 of the biggest companies in the US, and they all had the same people on their board of directors, mostly.

5
vbullinger•

They sit on boards of multiple companies so that they can guide those companies in mutually beneficial directions. And these people meet in bigger groups, behind closed doors, to guide policies for all of their companies so that they benefit eachother at the expense of the rest of the society.

See the Council on Foreign Relations.

1