This makes a sound in my head and it's freaking me out.

Posted Nov 2, 2011, 4:22 AM UTC

Posted Nov 2, 2011, 4:22 AM UTC
Is this some fringe application of the McGurk Effect?
Listen, Brendan. I've seen some crazy things in my life. Some crazy things, okay. Things that would make you hear things in your head, even. Hallucinations. I remember, I saw these giant pylons- those are giant electrical towers, Brendan. They were moving of their own. accord. Now, the cop that arrested me said I breathed a .3, and they found things that did not belong to me in a nearby ditch that I got pegged for. But they eventually learned how I was telling the truth, because the judge said so, and they named the entire principle of-WHAT THE HELL, DIANE! AREN'T TINY PEOPLE SUPPOSED TO BE AGILE? WHERE'S THE AGILITY? CRAWL UNDER THEN NEXT TIME IF THEY TAKE THE BALL FROM YOU. COME ON, IF I CAN DO IT, YOU CAN.-the principle of hearing strange shit in your head when you see giant pylons moving of their own accord. Go ahead and look it up on the internet. I know this sounds like bullshit, Brendan, but I'm telling the truth. Anyway, my point is, when you're being chased by a cop and you've had a fun night, you throw whatever you can out the damn window. It's not worth it. They can't legally trace that back to you, that could've been there the entire time. You understand?
Fuck yeah home movies.
This was hilarious to read in McGurk's voice in my head.
At first I thought, there's no way I'm reading that whole block of text. Then I realized it was McGurk saying it and I savored every second.
The McGurk McGurk Effect?
[deleted]
His name is Honkey Magoo!
[deleted]
Fucking Jon Benjamin's voice.
YOU CAN FUCK VOICES, TOO?!
If I could fuck any voice, it would have to be H Jon Benjamin's.
You know what's bizarre? I had no idea that text had anything to do with H. Jon Benjamin, yet I still read it in his voice.
I don't... I don't get it.
It's okay, no one said what it was from. It's from the show Home Movies, which was referenced because one of the character's names is "Coach McGuirk".
Oh. I don't really do tv. Thanks for the explanation.
I know we're not supposed to post comments like this, but you fucking win.
Brendon. BRENDON. Life sucks, Brendon. That's your lesson. Go enjoy it.
As a Brendan, I felt slightly threatened reading this. Now I know it's not me, it's some idiot that spells his name wrong. All is well.
During the side by side, all's I wanted was that bitch to shut up.
Completely.
Ba. Ba. Ba.
Ba. Ba. Ba.
Va. Va. Va.
Ba. Ba. Ba.
Those teeth.
You don't even have to be British, apparently. Just appearing on a British show is enough to give you bad teeth.
That is crazy!
If you watch the split screen parts as one picture, it'll sound like the sound is coming from one side or the other depending if you're listening to the baa or the faa.
Actually I heard a baa in one ear and a faa in the other while looking at the middle of the screen, not quite at either mouth. That was WEIRD.
I hear "vaa"
huzzah my linguistics class came into use and knew what you were talking about already
That was really cool, but one of the most obnoxious videos I've ever seen. It was all about this auditory effect, but they didn't give more than about a second and a half to listen to the sound at any one time, without the narrator cutting in.
i just learned so much! that tripped me out.
Hey Brendon...
I think they needed to show the "baa baa" man about 100 more times. That wasn't nearly enough.......
[deleted]
Ahh... what the fuck.
These are completely separate phenomena.
The McGurk Effect is pretty specific, and I don't think these are related. I'd like to say that this is a synesthetic effect, and that seems a bit more accurate (if only because it is less specific), but I don't think that is right either. It's a sound based on the expectation of that sound, your brain filling in the gaps. Honestly, I don't know if there is an exact name for what's happening in this image, but it reminds me a lot of Gestalt effects for the visual system.
Edit: I have to ask, do people actually hear a sound? I "hear" one, but it is in the same way that I "hear" my internal monologue. For me there's no confusion that it was an internally generated sound. Do others actually hear it as they would hear an external stimulus?
For me, it's such a low frequency thud that I can't tell if I hear it or not. It does seem to mess with my ears and actually make them the slightest bit irritated. I think that may just be the disconnect between my brain and ear and its just throwing off my perception even more.
BA BA BA
[deleted]
Upvote because the Professor is from my school!
I watched the vid with absolutely no sound here at work. The guy was saying "Bam" and "Fuck", right?
It was really obvious, the switch from bah to vah.
Sorry if I'm misunderstanding, but the baa faa change is just in your head. The audio never changes, just the video. That's what makes it neat.
Look at his front teeth in making the sounds. Baa isn't made by the front upper teeth depressing the lower lip. The f and v sound of faa or vaa is. It's clear.
No, exactly, but the actual audio track remains the same. Close your eyes and you won't hear it. Shitty music aside, this video is more to the point. When they do the side by side, go back and forth between the two at random intervals. Then rewind, do it again at different intervals. Like 2 times on the left, then once on the right. Next time, start right, alternate each time. The difference in video changes how we perceive the audio, since we know how the mouth is supposed to move to make certain sounds. Also, try with your eyes closed and then picking one to watch the whole time.
If you are with me, let me know and I'll shut the fuck up, and if you're trolling me or don't get it, let me know. I'd be happy to work through this.
Quick, call Walter or Olivia.
I am so surprised I keep finding you, i guess I can thank RES. ANYWAYS, you are still not giving me my god damn sushi I was promised.
We must like the same things. If you are ever in Fort Smith AR, I will buy you sushi.
And then we'll find a Catholic church so we can tell any Father with an M name all about it.
[deleted]
The thumping is real - you're not alone.
So it's like.... a gif with sound?
It's like... a gif that makes your brain fill in the sound. There IS NO SOUND. It's all in your head. ಠ_ಠ
What is this black magic?
GIF magic.
oh reeeally
[deleted]
Whoever created the animation was obviously using brain control.
Try closing your eyes.
The call sound is coming from inside the house your head!
If there is no sound, what fills my brain?
http://i.imgur.com/E09Ud.jpg Now it's a JPG that moves AND fills your brain with sound.
I've never been so scared
It's called a talkie.
Wow thats a great idea, a gif with sound!
[deleted]
MAKE IT STOP, WHY WON'T IT <closes tab> ...Oh thats right.
It will work even if you switch tabs or minimize.
Can all redditors please stop watching the gif. My monitor is shaking.
I just realized the thumping was my heart
Any neurologists/audiologists care to take a stab at why? Pretty sure it has something to do with the frame shaking at the point of impact, but my knowledge in this area is lacking.
It's crazy how the standards have changed since that post. There are so many comments that would be deleted today.
Actually, I was struck by that when I found the page, too. They were pretty strict when I joined askscience, and that was way before that post, so... I guess it's just... fluctuations in policy and moderation?
Its because they are on the front page now and it was getting ridiculous over there.
It's also not exactly a field that many scientists work in...
[deleted]
look up mcgurk effect
Most of what you experience as 'the real world' (sight as well) is filled in by your brain extrapolating from past data with a scant handful of the actual information from your eyes, ears and other senses being the basis for all of it. So, your eyes see the gif (well, bits of the gif) and your brain extrapolates the sound that experience tells you should be there. This sort of 'filling in the gaps' is going on all the time, it's just the gif makes it obvious to your conscious mind for a change.
What it feels like is an anticipatory response in the inner ear - like a contraction.
Isn't that a Cyriak animation?
Yes, it is. [special Internet b3ta handshake]
[flashes his cdc gang sign]
RIS
your all gay
Center for Disease Control? O_o
Crudely-drawn-cock
[deleted]
I'm surprised it doesn't happen more often.
It does. All the time.
Woo and yay.
Don't forget hoopla and panowie.
Ahh, old skool! You're not Spacefish are you?
It was right around this point that b3ta became a huge heap of shit.
So about 2002 or so?
Not Happytoast?
It is indeed a Happytoast post to B3ta some years ago. Easy mistake to make as Cyriak is mental this way, too.
Cyriak's stuff is more out there (seriously, just check his youtube), Happytoast's stuff is very pretty and smooth.
Pretty sure it's from a British sketch show. Don't remember which though, maybe Big Train?
Not sure if actually hearing it on my own, or prompted by title... o.O
classic repost, 944 points, 170 coments. Someones's scripts are working well!
I'm glad it was reposted; it's cool. Who the fuck cares about karma and those who whore it?
The issue isn't really that it's a repost, it's that it had 900+ upvotes before anyone had really commented on it. People are actively developing scripts and such to "control" reddit via account swarms. This is a likely example of that.
No, you just don't know how submission scores work.
That doesn't affect this. I think maybe you don't understand how one could manipulate the structure of reddit.
If you controlled an account swarm, that means that you'd control the ability to cast that many upvotes. If a seemingly genuine post is made with material that hasn't recently been posted, but is known to be well-recieved, you can then use those account to seed a few hundred upvotes, gets peoples attention, at which point the "percolation effect" will take over, and the post will rocket up to 1000+ votes. This way, using a small seed, you can create accounts with many karma points. These accounts can then be sold to PR and advertising firms, who use them to do "genuine participation" advertising. Think about it.
Conspiracy theory. If I was going to try and control reddit I would probably lean towards political material, not a gif that makes sound in my head.
You know it might actually be possible for people to not realize they are reposting. I've never seen this in my life and it seems like a lot of other people haven't seen it either. Sorry the OP has a life outside the computer while you clearly don't.
I'm in a wheelchair and dirt broke, so it's pretty hard to do all the skydiving and wine tasting that you and your beloved OP do.
Sorry to break it to you but my life consists mostly of school and work. And even people in wheelchairs can have hobbies outside of the internet.
[deleted]
You know, synaesthesia is right up there with OCD in 'conditions Redditors think they have'.
And dylsexia too.
[deleted]
Heh, I'm the same except all my other senses make sound too. People often wonder why I can't watch a film when all the leds on the player are flashing.
[deleted]
I'm the same. Car blinkers are the worst.
Oh no... you are right? Ahhh! I've noticed in my head they have different frequency of blinking depending on the car....
Shut Up. Guys, no, car blinkers actually make noises. Don't let RatioRegum fool you. However, car tires, on the other hand.
Hey, I have that too! Sadly, I think it's the least useful type of synesthesia.
Have you done an AMA?
A someone with many different forms of synaesthesia myself, I can say that although considered unusual, it is common enough that an AMA based on that alone doesn't seem appropriate. Unless he has proven to have just about every form of synaesthesia documented there isn't much he can tell you that isn't on Wikipedia and the rest of the internet.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Cool thanks I'll check it out, I had no idea it was that common!
I swear I can hear this one too.
Yay, look what I found! Yay, look what I found! Yay...
BRUMF twaaaaang BRUMF twaaaaang BRUMF twaaaaang
Woah! I feel it in my head!
Yeah that's what I get from it too, more than a sound, it's as though I can actually feel the wump wump wump inside my head.
BAAA BAAA BAAA
FAAA FAAA FAAA
I hear nothing
Same. What the hell? Is there something wrong with us or are we the only sane ones?
Everyone's crazy except for us!
I'm afraid we're normal dude.
You're the show in this circus.
Me neither. We just got trolled hard.
Dubstep
Squint your eyes. The more you do that, the lower the volume of the thumping gets.
ಠoಠ
If you close your eyes, you don't hear it at all.
[deleted]
This has been posted so many times that I heard the sound before I even clicked the link D:
[deleted]
thrump....thrump...thrump...I hear it too...shivers
I can't not hear it. (double negatives are necessary sometimes)
I am an English teacher, and I approve this message.
an English teacher with the name SlutBuster?...Seems legit, carry on.
As long as the sluts aren't students!
[deleted]
The sluts are being busted.
I'm not an English teacher, but I play one on vodka. I approve this message as well.
As long as you don't play a forklift operator or commercial airline pilot.
As another English teacher, I second this message.
As an ordinary person I fourth it.
As a personal who has voicemail I choose to ignore this message.
As an ex maths teacher, I 3.14 this.
As a P.E. teacher I don't understand what is going on.
As an art teacher, I drew the same conclusion.
[deleted]
Why the hell are there so many English teachers around here? CAN I GET A CALCULUS TEACHER?
I am an English student and I disapprove this message.
If you can't tell me who this is, I don't want you teaching my kids.
Questioning my credentials, Dr? That's a bit lowth.
as someone that knows someone that is a english teacher, i approve this message.
As a physical education teacher, I excersize my right to approve this message.
Holy hell, thought I was insane and then came to read these comments. It's nice to at least know I have a community of fellow crazies
Do you know how Hitler survived the war? He went into an insane asylum and switched places with someone who looked like him and thought he was Hitler.
"Double negative, bitches!" http://pages.citebite.com/q1e1e8o7o2knj
Claim middle english, double negatives add emphasis, not NOT operators.
holy shit... what just happened!
Imagine if you could go back in time and tell your great grandparents from the 1940's that you just watched three power cable towers playing jump rope, and they made you hear noises that don't exist.
And you gave just enough fucks to up vote it.
You don't need to go back in time really! I mean it's pretty fucked up RIGHT NOW!
I like to imagine than my ancestors fought and died specifically so I could watch three power cable towers playing jump rope and making me hear noises that don't exist.
i like to imagine that my ancestors died so that the population would be (x2)^2 less and I could survive off the ever depleting resources...
But what would be more amazing - Seeing three power cable towers playing jump rope making you hear imaginary noises or the fact that you just friggin' time traveled and met your great grandparents?
I've met both of my great grandparents. lol
I don't know, seems like a really close call..
My great grandparents were born in the 1800s. So the 1940s seems sort of recent. Heck, interracial marriage laws weren't even official snuffed out until my parents were in high school.
Your brain sees all the visual cues for loud noise, so it fills in the blanks.
[deleted]
This is the sound you're looking for.
Mine is a shorter thud than that one... but damn close.
Mine's a bit shorter too, and more like a 'doof' sound, less crunchiness.
I bet you tell that to all the ladies.
yup, that exactly
http://gifsound.com/?gif=http%3A%2F%2Fi.imgur.com%2FE09Ud.gif&sound=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dx75N52_-HII&start=30
close..
Yeah. Whoop, hop, crunch. That's pretty much what I hear.
... Yes, I heard it just like that. Creepy.
My god this is what I was hearing.
This is EXACTLY what I expect to hear when I see this. Shway Hup! Shway Hup. So glad I'm not on my own
Hello, is this the sound you're looking for?
Like Monuman's, my sound is shorter, but almost dead on for that.
It's a whump...whump...whump for me. That is surreal.
For me too. I think this needs to be studied. I wonder if it is the rapid eye movements as you follow the picture shake that creates a real sound that we are all hearing?
Speak for yourself.
I hear nothing.
Finally a GIF with sound.... wait I just turned off my speakers...what?... I STILL HEAR IT!!!
look up... NOW LOOK AT THE GIF look left... NOW LOOK AT THE GIF look right... NOW LOOK AT THE GIF look down NOW LOOK AT THE GIF °¿°
There's also a slight creaky sound like a swingset each time the rope swings.
And the "whipping" sound of the line tearing through the space around it.
I also hear a "boing" every time it jumps.
I get the thrump but not the boing.
Definitely BOING
I heard a boing the first time or two, then it all stopped.
I hear a boing, and it looks like my entire browser window shakes, too.
sweet jesus.
thanks
Yeah, me too. It took me a sec, but then it started sending a rumbling noise through my brain. Eerie.
thrump....thrump...thrump...
but in the background "Doooiiinnnggg.... Doooiiinng......Doooiiinngg"
(Doing, like BOING! not like the action of doing something)
Like that kind of electric-lasery sound that a metal slinky makes if you hold one end up to your ear and jiggle it.
Are you boo-ing or boo-ing-ing?
I was saying boo-erns.
As an English person I declare it valid
As another English person I second that!
So cool, right! It's so crazy that our minds all hear such a similar sound. For me, it's a little more of a "thwump, thwump, thwump." Just a constant, incessant thumping. Over and over and over again. Like some dingleberry teenager next door is blasting dubstep with the bass turned to max because he has NO common decency or sense of privacy. Like he just wants to tell the world, "HEY! My favorite song would make Beethoven shit is guts out so quickly, it would create a fucking chasm in the space-time continuum and suck the whole FUCKING world into a black hole of nonexistance!" That fucking kid.. I'm going to jam Q-tips so far into that little fuck's ears that he'll never be able to listen to another THWUMP again in his whole GOD DAMN life.
I will always be there. Haunting you. And waiting... Waiting.... Waiting....
I heard the actual sound they make when they are going up, as there is one right next to my house. Am I awkward?
No. But you will be from the radiation
You're only akward for asking. Everything else is okay. Thumbs up.
But now we'll never know if we only hear it because of the title.
twangggg thoofmph
Wtf is going on!
[deleted]
shoomp! ....... shoomp! ....... shoomp! .......
Do you find you are thinking the same thoughts as others? You might be part of a
reddithivemindTHE BEATING OF HIS INFERNAL HEART
I hear more of a VWOMP VWOMP VWOMP
I'm very scared. Is that thing near my house?
I think that the shaking makes the thing
OH NO, It's turning into dubstep!
Why am I the only one not hearing anything :(
Do you hear a "boingoingoingoingoingoingoing" after each one too?
Banana
[deleted]
i can feeeel it ಠ_ಠ
Bump for the correct onomatopoeia.
It seems like something with the moving camera when it hits the grounds...
Yeah I heard it!!!! WTF!!!