Student-led group sells NFTs of Trump tweets for charity
thehill.com/policy/technology/551003-student-...Posted Apr 29, 2021, 8:41 PM UTC
Posted Apr 29, 2021, 8:41 PM UTC
Since they didn’t make the tweets, how can they legally do this? They don’t own the platform and they don’t own any of the copyrights. I would expect a lawsuit in their futures. Or at least a strongly-worded cease and desist.
Frank Fingerman
NFTs are not a transfer of copyright necessarily. But I don't see worth in that NFT. It is kinda like painting your own mona lisa, it will never be worth as much as the original
[deleted]
At some point, in some courtroom somewhere, a precedent will be made to establish a tie between copyright/trademark/ownership and the source content in an NFT.
I dont know what it will look like. But there is just too much at money flying around for traditional systems like copyright, to not exert some influence on this stuff.
[deleted]
At best it is a "replica". The only way I could see the value of such a NFT jumping is if at some point the original author decides to delete their stuff from Twitter or make it private.
Well I value the Mona Lisa at $0.
[deleted]
copyright alliance dot org says tweets can be protected by copyright if certain criteria are satisfied.
Must be original to the author
Must be more than a single word or short phrase
Twitter's TOS says you retain rights to your content but also give them the right to publish, and others to do the same. Which seems to mean others can retweet your tweet.
I am a certified internet lawyer.
I think they're assuming you aren't tweeting via the POTUS account in that article.
That would make sense, as POTUS is a public figure. Thanks for pointing that out.
> All other tweets are selling for .0232 Ethereum, or about $63.28. Each NFT of the tweets also contains corresponding graphic art.
That's what they're selling. It's a .png of the tweet. And idiots are buying and making sure these kids have college money. Win-win I guess?
There have already been lawsuits in the past regarding stuff like this. I expect one for this case
Someone made bank on that covfefe tweet
I want it now take my $$$
Charity reinvests the money on Dogecoin
This is the way.
Bro I just sold your reddit comment as an NFT and made 18000 sats on it!
Nice! 50/50?
Next up, Elon tweets. I'd love to get my hands on doge shillpost #435.
Wonder how much for the “Cofefe” one
I don’t see why you would buy this when trump may sell his own tweets in the future...
So they don't own it but they want to profit off it? Sounds like they need to get jobs in the government!
I don't get NFT's at all. Is it like creating trading cards which can be exchanged on the blockchain?
Sort of! The most simple yet accurate way I’ve found to understand it is that an NFT is a receipt stored on a specific blockchain.
The receipt doesn’t actually give you ownership over the subject, it just verifies that the receipt itself is legit. So the legitimacy of an NFT comes from the issuing authority. NBA trading card NFT’s issued by the NBA would (presumably) be more valuable than an NBA trading card NFT issued by me. Both are using the same underlying technology though.
Wait. So does that mean someone can take any google image they want and sell an NFT of it? So I can go on google right now and just take a handful of the most beautiful landscape images, make an NFT, and then list it on Opensea?
yes, you can sell whatever you want to anybody on opensea, free of any consequences. Just got to pay those opensea listing costs.
And bullshit your way in to people buying other people your shizzle that you just ripped off.
But you can always use CZ his server, usually that's cheaper then opensea.
You can even create it on bcash for like 1/20th of cent although that community does not usually fall for a bunch of bullshit.
Have fun fucking over those greedy tards that buy your NFT's, they deserve it!
PS: Might want to deactivate your conscience first.
You can but you're liable to be sued.
I followed an NFT collection based on illegal graffiti. 3d modelled animated trading card type things, was dope, basically trading cards of writers in the illegal graffiti world, for those actually in the subculture. Most people never heard of these guys, we're talking ADEK, KUMA, OKER etc Straight up illegal taggers and bombers.
So as a part of the NFT animation, photos of the illegal graffiti was used. The photos were taken either by the NFT creator or if not, by random people on Flickr, licensed full on there for commercial use and attributed. All good right?
Believe it or not , one of the graffiti writers called ICHABOD contacted the creator of the collection and sent threatening messages talking about getting his lawyer involved lmfao
His illegal graffiti, photos of it by someone else, that photo licensed for commercial use - doesn't matter. Copyright law states that the creator of the work holds copyright. So whoever created that illegal graffiti is the holder of copyright, and would win in court if it was used for anything.
It's nuts.
Also lame as fuck. Imagine being a well known illegal graffiti writer and threatening to send lawyers because someone used a photo of your illegal graff in an NFT. 😄
They've raised $6k so far. Bids start at about $60 while some of the tweets have starting bids at $12k!
Better scoop up some deals then.
Wholesome students!
How is this shit relevant to this board?
Can someone please explain how this works? I thought NFTs were the original creation so how are these people selling NFTs of tweets they didn’t create or publish? Isn’t that just selling a screenshot which isn’t an NFT?
The whole NFT for Tweets saga makes no sense, they are just fishing for suckers
Be hilarious if it went to environment groups. Eth NFTs are literally more toxic than trump twats
I got 1eth on the Covfefe tweet..
I’m pretty sure you need the tweet author’s approval before you can mint their tweet as an NFT
What I want to know is: what platform are these guys using? Because selling tweet NFTs actually requires that you gain the tweet author’s permission but they definitely didn’t gain any permission here so I have some Googling to do
Wholesome.
[deleted]
They don’t own the copyright. It’s either owned by Trump or Twitter. Will they sue? Probably bad PR, but may open IP doors they don’t want opened, if they don’t.
NFTs have no relevance to copyright law as it is currently written. No one owns anything as an NFT except the proof that the NFT was made and belongs in their wallet. It is no more proof of ownership than posting “first” in a YouTube comment is.
So where does their value come from?
Greed
What's the point of buying it if you don't own it? Like NBA topshop, you technically "own" whatever electronic card/play you buy. But for that it seems like the only "ownership" is the value of the NFT (if you were to sell it eventually). I still don't get what drives it though.
You just have to think of NFT collectibles like physical collectibles. Anyone can make any thing collectible, think of vending machine collectibles. Anyone could probably make a claw game with Trump tweets as the prize. you can put anything in there and they’re easier to get, so they’re not exactly the most coveted collectibles. On the other hand you have baseball cards, which is what NBA is trying to do with top shots. A physical baseball card is only valuable because it was licensed by the MLB and made by topps. Top shots are valuable because they’re created on public blockchain and licensed by the NBA. Saying NFTs are a bubble is like saying card stock is in a bubble when someone pays $100,000 for a baseball card.
Greed combined with ignorance.
+Fool with money
“Greed is good”…I’m selling that quote now for $50k
There is no value in any of this.
NFTs are just an elaborate scheme to separate idiots from their money.
That's why I took out a second mortgage and bought myself some dogecoin at 25 cents and XRP at 1 dollar.
I will not go down in history as an idiot! I will never touch this NFT stuff which is clearly being abused to bamboozle me. But they won't get me. I am to smart. I even know how to master the mempool but Bitcoin is a bit expensive right now so I am buying more doge and xrp! Might even pick up some safemoon, it's really cheap and the other day I saw Bitcoin go up 1 dollar in a second, so the same could happen with safemoon. Perhaps I could sell my daughters doll house, she is thinking about becoming a boy anyways.
Money laundering.
It’s like a baseball card. Anyone can make them, but the value is in it being rare and collectible. They have no intrinsic value (a baseball card is less than a penny of cardboard and an NFT is some blockchain code).
[removed]
Artificial demand
Same place as baseball cards, value is in the eye of the beholder.
for real? i don’t fact check reddit comments but that is makes NFTs more stupid if this real
depends on the NFT really, if made by the original creator of an art then they have the grounds to be valuable. some can be used in games
the term NFT by itself just refers to a unique token and that concept can be used for a loooot of different things
[deleted]
Aren't firsts a time honored tradition? It's the modern version of the ancient "dibs."
I wish we can sell "first" in YouTube comment.
Wait. So does that mean someone can take any google image they want and sell an NFT of it? So I can go on google right now and just take a handful of the most beautiful landscape images, make an NFT, and then list it on Opensea?
Yes. Tip me if you make a million dollars.
LOLOL thanks I will. I had an idea that I thought was actually really smart, but I didn't know if it was legal since I wouldn't actually be the owner of the images. This is fantastic news lmao!!!
[removed]
[removed]
That’s not quite accurate. If you package something up as an NFT, and that something is say a Disney princess cartoon, and sell it for profit, you definitely are liable for copyright infringement. Copyright and ownership always comes back to money. If someone wants to make an Elsa doll, no ones going to jail. But if someone made 50 and tries to open an Etsy store to sell, then they are liable for damages and can be sued.
So yes, there is relevance. Selling an NFT is selling something. If you package up a link to a tweet, now that’s pretty gray. But there’s definitely a potential damage claim. There just isn’t any case law yet to use as an example yet.
Not true. Read their terms of service.
This is just plain wrong. You automatically own the copyrights to works that you create. That intellectual property belongs to the creator, and if you try and sell it, you're going to get sued.
I’m not wrong at all; NFTs do not have anything to do with copyright as it stands.
NFTs are very much covered under the current wording of copyright law. Hey, if you're not breaking the law, why don't you sell some Disney characters as NFTs?
I agree technically but disagree from a value basis. An NFT sold by Trump or Twitter would have more value than one by some random first mover.
I didn’t say anything about value. An NFT is something, it’s just not relevant to copyright.
Not arguing. I agree from a technical standpoint.
One day you will be buying and selling houses with NFTs
Real estate and copyright are different things.
Well it's proof of ownership either way. I don't disagree with what you say, it is accurate of NFTs as of right now, but I think there is a lot of potential in the tech once it has been realised.
Though in terms of copyright, would an NFT not be similar to the old trick of posting lyrics/recordings to yourself - it has a timestamp?
The shitshow should be interesting.
Hopefully it’s more of an “any press is good press” as opposed to the classic FUD we get from the news.
They'll spread FUD if they're looking to buy cheap or applaud it if they want some price pumping.
You're selling a link to an image. There's no IP transaction and the connection to the initial IP is dubious at best. NFTs have potential to be awesome but the current applications we see are a complete joke.
I'm actually really curious about how copyright is handled regarding tweets. In some sense, a tweet is a "publication" that you are authoring and publish on the web. There are some kinds of publications where the author is automatically granted copyright upon completing or publishing the work. But it is possible that terms of service including a clause transferring copyright to Twitter.
[removed]
In their current state, NFTs do not actually legally convey ownership of anything but the contract itself.
Pretty sure they will sue so we atleast will know how to handle it.
I think they could sue and give the compensation money to charity.
most things that are done by politicians are ususally free of copyright because it would enable politicians to silence critics quite easily.
that's why you can also buy tshirts with trump tweets and noone can sue them.
That’s an excellent point. It might depend on what account he was tweeting from.
I don't hink so. He made a public comment as POTUS, doesn't matter what account it came from.
I think Leigh Cuen: art and collectible NFTs, in their current form, are a digital analog of autograph of a person (or entity) who creates an NFT.
We know that autographs of celebrities are valuable, so, by analogy, that makes NFTs valuable.
So it's like getting an autograph on a poster.
Except that if you get an autograph on a poster, at least you get a physical object you own.
Given that NFTs only point to a resource, it is more like getting an autograph on a white card which describes where one might look at the poster (like, in a public library), with no guarantee it will be there.
NFTs have nothing to do with a copyright.
Currently we have low-level protocols which only deal with transfers and have no way to authenticate the creator (i.e. checking who created NFT is done outside of the blockchain protocols, usually on a web site of some sort) and no way to provide unambiguous connection to the content.
So a lot can be improved there. NFTs could come with more explicit IP rights, but that requires new infrastructure and conventions.
Reminds me of this guy selling instagram posts as art.
Dibs on selling Kanye West’s tweets as NFTs
There's only one way to find out, right? When the lawsuits are filed.
It’s a tweet, there is no copyright to be owned.
Wrong. Copyright protection is created for Trump immediately upon creation. The only way he doesn’t have Rutgers is if Twitter’s TOS, claims those rights. In that case Twitter owns the copyright to the tweets.
These folks clearly do not, unless however owns the rights has donated those rights to the group.
That would be highly unusual.
Twitter may or may not be copyrighted