r/lgbt•
shapterjm

LGBT Redditors, I need your help with a family issue

I normally like to think I have all these kinds of things pretty well figured out. I have a very supportive family, they have all been there for me ever since I came out to each one. I've never heard a negative word from ANYONE within my family, not even the small children (for whom, growing up, "gay" meant stupid to them and their friends) for which I am extremely grateful.

Here's my situation: I have a fairly large extended family and most of my aunts and uncles have children, around the ages 12-15. I've been completely out to my family now for about 6 years, so most of those kids were quite small at the time, and I didn't feel it was my place to tell them directly. Instead, I spoke to each of my aunts (my mother's sisters, whom I'm closest with) separately and 1) asked whether their kids knew and 2) opened myself up to questions, should their kids prefer to ask me anything directly.

There was only one of my aunts whose children I wasn't sure about, so the other day I sent her a quick note and mentioned the above two things. As expected, she responded warmly, affirming that my orientation doesn't change anything, and family is family, and telling me that her two kids did, in fact, know about my orientation, and that she would direct them to me if they had any questions she couldn't answer.

Here's the dilemma: Throughout her reply, she didn't refer to my orientation, but instead to my "choice." My family aren't the most open-minded people, I'll admit, and I'm willing to look past a lot of things because I know that they mean well and they're not bad people. But is this something I should be upset about? I've never considered my sexual orientation to be a choice and I've always tried to make it clear to anyone who asks that, in my mind, it /isn't/ a choice, it's just how I am. So to hear one of my family members refer to my orientation as a choice is more disturbing to me than I thought it might be. I'm not sure how to proceed. Do I let it go and just be satisfied that I have a more accepting family than a lot of people do, or do I try to reach out and explain why using the word "choice" is a bit hurtful?

Posted Jan 9, 2012, 7:07 PM UTC

1260
moonflower•

It sounds like this is no big deal to your family, and yet you still don't really feel accepted, so you are trying to make a big deal out of it ... do you think this might be because you don't fully accept your self?

74
shapterjmOPThe Pocket Gay!•

This is not the case at all, and I resent the implication. No, it's not a big deal to my family, but the use of the word "choice" makes me question that a bit. I have no doubt that my family will always be there for me, but I've always thought that they weren't just tolerant, but accepting.

And to make it perfectly clear, I have been fully accepting of myself and my sexuality since the day I came out--that's why I did it. I am in no way "trying to make a big deal" out of anything, which is why I didn't jump right into telling her "It's not a choice!"

8
moonflower•

If you were fully accepting of yourself, you wouldn't even have sent her the note

-9
shapterjmOPThe Pocket Gay!•

I don't think you understand the purpose of the note. It was out of respect for her, not doubt of myself. My sexuality is not something I feel the need to broadcast, but I also don't restrain myself in any way around anyone (with the possible exception of work, because I live in the South and I like my face in its current arrangement). It was a simple question of whether her kids knew, because I don't see it as my place to come out and tell them. Human sexuality is something that parents deserve the opportunity to teach their own children about, in their own way.

It sounds to me like you're just trying to stir something up. Let me state again: I am completely, 100% accepting of my own sexuality. I am a fully-out gay man and proud to be so. In no way should any of my comments be taken to indicate that I feel otherwise.

7
moonflower•

what were you hoping the kids would ask you?

-1
SilentAgonyLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Please refrain from harassing people here. Calling homosexuality a choice is homophobia. LGBT 101. Learn a thing before you start spewing bullshit all over my sub.

-172
moonflower•

Did you add that red tag to my name because you misunderstood my post? I thought the mods of this subreddit were above such childish behaviour

128
SilentAgonyLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

I misunderstood nothing. You harassed a user. We've had a number of complaints about you. Now they'll see you coming.

-219
moonflower•

I'm disappointed in your reaction, I thought the mods of this subreddit liked to think of themselves as people who could discuss problems in a mature manner and seek to resolve misunderstandings, instead of instantly resorting to childish name calling and abuse of mod privileges

I guess you can judge it to be ''harrassment'' that I said something which he didn't like to address, but I wasn't condoning her saying that homosexuality is a choice, you have misunderstood

And you have also misunderstood the meaning of 'Concern Troll' ... when you call people names, it says nothing about them, it only says something about you

136
kodemage•

Where did he say homosexuality is a choice?

5
SilentAgonyLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Moonflower insisted that the aunt in question, who had called homosexuality a choice, was not being homophobic. That was just this time. If that had been the only thing, it would have been ignored, but then she went into the girl scouts thread and started lecturing trans people for not heeding the concerns of parents who don't want their daughters around trans girls and has a several months long history of harassing trans people, suggesting they stay away from women, insisting there might just be "something else wrong with them" etc. That's insidious harassment, which is why she got the concern troll tag.

0
SgtPsycho•

In truthiness, that is not what Moonflower said

It sounds like this is no big deal to your family, and yet you still don't really feel accepted, so you are trying to make a big deal out of it ... do you think this might be because you don't fully accept your self?

The words 'aunt', 'choice' and 'homophobic' are literally not there in moonflower's response to shapterjm's post. There is no edit tag on the post either.

I accept that the response was poorly worded , and moonflower then went on to rudely question shapterjm's validity and self-image. While this is very unempathic and probably unhelpful to someone who has chosen to bare their private details in a public forum, I do not feel that moonflower should be lambasted and pursued on this issue.

I have read through your other concerns as listed here and understand that what you're seeing is a historical pattern of disruptive behaviour.

4
kodemage•

Your comment further up this thread is out of place then? It does seem like you're referring to the post to which you responded and not some other post.

1
IkLms•

You are a fucking moron.

4
conan93•

I wouldn't say calling homosexuality a choice is homophobia if it was just a simple misunderstanding from someone who didn't know much about it.

2
[deleted]•

Wow, what a stupid and fucked up reaction to this answer.

2
FrogsOblivious•

It seems like every time this comes up on reddit, it turns out that the user of the word simply didn't realize he/she was using the wrong word. It may be the way they were used to talking about homosexuality growing up, or something.

This could be the case here. I'd say just write her back, thanking her for her support. You can just include a little something to remind her that it's never a choice, while acknowledging that it may have been a simple mistake.

Then we'll see how she responds.

20
[deleted]•

I don't think it's really a very big deal. If she were saying that she doesn't support you because she thinks you "chose" to be gay, that's one thing. But she is supportive, so it sounds like it's just an issue of her not knowing the correct words to use. That's pretty common for people who don't have a lot of experience with the community. I wouldn't necessarily even send her a note back, unless she's far away and you don't see or speak to her very often. Next time you see or speak to her, just let her know that the word "choice" isn't a good word to use when referring to orientation. You don't even need to tell her that it upset you if you don't want to. Let her know in the context of "just so you know, some gay people get offended if you refer to orientation as a choice, and I'd hate for someone who doesn't know you to think you're homophobic just because of that one word."

8
lilgoat•

I've dealt with the same problem with people using the word choice and it's typically just because they don't realize that it is hurtful. If they do believe it's a choice then you could go about explaining that it's not a choice. For me I've found that the best way to go about it is whenever you talk about it in person or in a message, be sure to choose your wording in such a way that allows you to make it obvious that its not a choice. You don't have to go on a crusade to make your entire family know the terminology to use. But just let it come up in conversation that you feel that the word choice is somewhat offensive. Don't try to chastise them for using it, I'd try to make it an informative sentence or discussion that leads to your feelings of the word, "choice".

6
ReyTheRed•

If she warmly and acceptingly referred to it as a choice, then I think you should warmly and acceptingly let her know that it isn't a choice.

I'm not saying it will necessarily work out perfectly, but I think it is the best response. Ignorant people should be enlightened, especially if they are good accepting people who just don't know better. And I don't think escalating the situation would be a good thing, it would just increase the potential for hurt feelings.

3
UrbanOneNYC•

I think many people are ignorant about some things. Who hasn't been lambasted for making a mistake about some social issue out of ignorance, not out of hate?

If your aunt had been less than supportive, you might want to get a little in her face, but since you've been well-received (which may also go to who you are as a person - it sounds like you're a good guy) then I do think it's just ignorance.

Feel free to find the right way, time, and place to bring it up gently. I think you'll both feel good afterwards.

It may be hard, but you'll be doing both of you a favor.

Congrats on the pretty awesome response from your family. It gives me hope for our future!

2
flechesbleues•

If she's supportive and you have an otherwise good relationship, it might be just that she doesn't know any different and hasn't given the issue much thought. Where does your mother fall on the issue? Maybe either you or her could approach your aunt to discuss it, or, if you think a discussion might be too confrontational, buy her a book or something that would lay out answers to all the "basic" questions and send it to her with your next letter (or send her a link to a useful website in an email, if you're communicating that way).

You know the family circumstances, history and relationships though, so you'll have to judge how best to approach it.

1
shapterjmOPThe Pocket Gay!•

I don't know how I missed the sh*tstorm that exploded in this thread when I looked away, but to be perfectly honest, I'm disappointed with everyone involved. I posted this here in a sincere effort to work through something that was bothering me and instead my post became the battleground for the current issues of r/lgbt. I don't appreciate it, regardless of the side I may or may not take on my issue. I recognize the need for an LGBT subreddit and I have not entirely given up on this one, but the posts that went back and forth in this thread aren't encouraging.

1
SgtPsycho•

Sorry. If it helps, I had been here for some years and never seen anything like this.

I hope that it smooths over soon and you feel like contributing again, you will be welcome.

1