r/lgbt•
[deleted]

What did moonflower actually do?

He/She's tagged as a concern troll in /r/lgbt and I can't see why.

More often than not, he/she posts pretty well thought out comments and posts and I don't think it's fair for them to be tagged as a 'concern troll' if they were simply expressing their opinion.

(please don't simply comment TRANSPHOBIC LOL)

edit: and that's three people who commented TRANSPHOBIC LOL. faith in /r/lgbt restored

Posted Jan 15, 2012, 11:21 PM UTC · edited

54196
[deleted]•

I got a troll flair for suggesting that we educate ignorant people instead of acting hostile towards them. It kind of terrifies me that all my comments on the subject got downvoted.

156
[deleted]•

Holy fuck, you're not kidding. Never have I seen such passive aggressive moderation... ever.

91
joeycastilloHealing•

Make your views known to the moderators. This is a very recent trend, like within the last seven days recent. If the community speaks out, I believe it can be reversed before it goes any further.

52
SimonSaysPlay•

umm... It's the moderators who put that flair on t-n-k's profile!

17
[deleted]•

NOPE.AVI

-61
Peritract•

What are you saying "no" to?

  1. The idea that the moderators should be spoken to about the subreddit.

  2. The idea that red flair is recent

  3. The idea that the community's wishes will be considered.

12
martymar18The Mythical Flaming Unicorn•

Silentagony ha been that way since she got called out in Halloween for her tasteless costume.

26
[deleted]•

Wait, what did I miss? Link?

17
martymar18The Mythical Flaming Unicorn•

the picture in question http://imgur.com/LNQmW

the comment backlash http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/lun8n/happy_halloween_rlgbt_d_boo/

the damage control and butt hurt http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/m17d1/my_official_statement_on_the_halloween_costume/

i imagine it is only a matter of time before the angry lesbian overlord passes judgement on me as well and i get the scarlet flair. can we call it that?

33
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
seiyonoryuu•

i'll do the same thing i did to get kicked out of r/pyongyang

piss off ALL THE MODS!

LGBT MODS SUCK! (literally! :D)

there, that ought to do it

6
gay13578•

This is nuts. Then there was this golden comment by one of the mods: http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ofy6e/i_bat_for_both_teams_but_sometimes_homosexuals/c3gyxv6

/r/lgbt is a pretty great board, why does this woman have to begin labeling people as she fits? Let the downvotes work as usual, and stick to being a sentient spam filter: it's not your community. It's ours. Normally people just create split reddits when something like this happens, but for a title so standard as LGBT that's just not a possibility.

23
[deleted]•

why does this woman have to begin labeling people as she fits?

Because shes a mod.

Let the downvotes work as usual, and stick to being a sentient spam filter

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

it's not your community. It's ours

No its ours -_-

-55
gay13578•

Why so rude? I understand where you're coming from as a T, but she's free to be an ass and say (imo) close-minded things about bisexuality? Yet we can't label her? This isn't right, it's mod abuse. It should be an open community - no opinionated power users.

Edit: Okay sure, be mature and just downvote. It's in your interest of revenge specifically so you ignore the interests of others, how nice.

24
AndrensathSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

be a bitch.

Because $deity forbid a woman have a mind of her own, amirite?

-16
SilentAgonyLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

I say controversial things all of the time, which is exactly why I want people in this subreddit to be able to say controversial things without recourse. We're not banning or even red-flairing for controversy, and if you'll browse around the subreddit a bit, you'll see that. We're banning for a slightly extended definition of harassment - to include multiple harmful self-posts (most often erasing trans identities or attempting to label trans people freaks or mentally ill, but including some other things as well) and red flairing for users that continually harass people on the subreddit. Nowhere did we say we'd flair or ban somebody just because they were downvoted a lot or got into an argument with somebody. If you'll look around this discussion, you'll see rmuser has posted several links to comments that, not alone but as a trend, warranted that person's red flair. We're not going to spend all of our time justifying and debating every red flair, but I think if you read through rmuser's posts today, you'll find we've been very even-handed.

-38
joeycastilloHealing•

What's so funny about that articulation of a moderator's role in the community? As recently as two months ago SilentAgony herself articulated her role in the following words:

I am your moderator. I will remove threats and personal information. I will update the logo sometimes for funsies. I am not an LGBT leader nor am I an LGBT spokesperson, unless and until and only in contexts in which you wish me to be. I love this community.

- SilentAgony, 4 Nov 2011

This is a perfect example of a good credo for a moderator — a light touch, enforcing the rules and refusing to let personal beliefs get in the way of the fundamental job of making the place work. Did something change since November? Certainly I don't think the community at large was clamoring for red-flairing.

it's not your community. It's ours

No its ours -_-

What do you mean by that precisely?

19
AndrensathSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

Presumably that as trans* people (y'know, the T in the LGBT) we have just as much right to feel safe in r/lgbt (oh look, there's that letter again)?

-13
[deleted]•

So, I remember when you were getting upset over SilentAgony's Halloween costume calling it 'transphobic' and now you're instinctively agreeing because she's a mod? Hypocrite.

13
SilentAgonyLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Laurelai defended me - not just here but in the trans subreddits where she's a mod.

-14
[deleted]•

You must be thinking of someone else. I stuck up for SilentAgony.

-16
gagaoolala•

Wow, what a bitch

8
[deleted]•

Yes a gender slur will prove you right!

-12
EnterpriseE1701E•

This isn't just confined to flair, the community at large hates to have to justify their actions in a political manner. It is irritating to think that any of us should have to educate the bigoted or ignorant, but we should still probably do it for pragmatic benefit. There are a multiplicity of threads in which I point out that educating the ignorant and pragmatism are better strategies to improve the material condition of queer-folk at large, but they prefer to not engage it, going off on privilege, or whatever seems to dismiss an argument without addressing it.

My condolences-- the anti-political nature of this subreddit plays out on more levels than just one...

11
smischmalshe-wizard•

I think that the issue isn't that people object to the idea of educating the ignorant, but to the idea that we should be expected to educate the ignorant. I personally think it's wonderful when people choose to educate people, and I try to help out with that too, but I totally understand that a lot of other people just want to be left to their own devices and not have to explain themselves to every ignorant, pseudo-bigoted jerk-off that comes along.

Note, I haven't dug through t-n-k's comment history, so I'm not certain which they were advocating, but I don't think that that scarlet flair is really all that bad, it all depends on how people will choose to interpret that you "Would like us to educate them".

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
smischmalshe-wizard•

Of course, and it is certainly an important goal. But even in my own case there have been situations in which I didn't have the time or energy or patience or even, on occasion, the desire to educate people. So, I think that one shouldn't be expected to always be the educator, even if ideally, you should try to be. Being an activist is far from easy after all.

Furthermore (again drawing on my own experience) there are situations in which being the educator could be risky, leading to social reprecusions. In my opinion, it should be left to the individual involved whether they want to take that risk. I believe that this individually evaluated, case-by-case strategy is better than uniformly expecting everyone to do it, regardless of their individual talents, tendencies, or situation.

1
LivipediaSunlight•

Pretty much. I got the same shit about biphobia. There are some wonderful people here, but I'm a little taken aback by the amount of outright immaturity and hostility coming from the mods.

10
DuchessofYanks•

That's really childish and I'm sorry you have to deal with this. I think I'll be leaving this subreddit until the mods can get their act together.

5
option_i•

Ignorance is a two-way street.

-12
rroseselavy42Social Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

what does that even mean?

9
option_i•

.....sigh, nevermind.

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-15
[deleted]•

haha wat

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-12
[deleted]•

Dude seriously wat

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
smischmalshe-wizard•

Looks like someone is trying really hard to get that scarlet flair. Maybe a bit too hard.

1
rmuserLiterally a teddy bear•
-18
[deleted]•

Thank you for proving my point.

21
Lynx7•

Holy fuck you are using this as evidence against him? Really?

10
rmuserLiterally a teddy bear•

Yes.

-11
Mshur•

Evidence of what? That he wants to educate people? Why is that bad???

4
[deleted]•

Somebody came on here complaining that they couldn't tell their young nephews or cousins (something like that) about their sexuality and explain it to them. She said the OP has no reason to be upset (because the OP's aunts and his ENTIRE FAMILY had shown NO signs of homophobic behavior or thoughts) and should just stop trying to tell everyone about it. Silent Agony came by gave her the red tag, and gave moonflower no further explanation via comments on that thread beyond "Don't troll the OP".

/r/lgbt cares nothing for opinions and only is interested in the hivemind.

35
[deleted]•

Ah, thank you. I thought so.

How sad.

19
[deleted]•

I love a good circlejerk as much as the next guy but it does nothing to further our goals if it's just a shouting match, Us vs. them. It needs to stop being seen that way and needs to be thought of as the collective. At the end of the day we shouldn't be fighting for LGBT rights, We should fight for Human Rights.

11
Aspel•

We shouldn't be fighting for LGBT rights, we should be fighting for Human Rights.

I want to make hot sweaty love to you right now.

8
[deleted]•

At the end of the day we shouldn't be fighting for LGBT rights, We should fight for Human Rights.

What a fucking shitposter.

-22
moonflower•

you certainly are

7
moonflower•

Since this is your discussion I would like to correct what he said because you have been misinformed, so here's a link to the post I just made to him

9
moonflower•

That's not what I said at all ... I did not say he had no reason to be upset, and I did not say he should stop trying to tell them about it ... here is a link to the thread in question

You have badly misunderstood my comment, just like many others did ... I said that his family were being accepting of him, and he still did not feel accepted, and I suggested that may be because he did not accept his self

He has every right to be upset, and he has every right to tell anyone about it

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
Inequilibrium•

And even if moonflower was wrong, so fucking what? Is there a rule against being wrong about anything, ever? We may as well cease all in-depth discussions and debates, then.

Also, forgot the upvote/downvote system, we'll let two mods decide what's right and what's wrong.

21
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
Inequilibrium•

moonflower didn't get red flair for saying something bigoted, as far as I can see. Nor did t-n-k - questioning the behaviour of trans members of the community is not transphobic.

13
Aspel•

Maybe you'd like /r/laidbackqueers better :I

10
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•

Hi. I don't really hang out here, I hate this subreddit (and SilentAgony in particular) but I've seen moonflower everywhere. He's probably the best Concern Troll I've ever seen, but after what feels like a year or so of watching him constantly try to subtly derail everything into "trans people are wrong," I can't blame anyone for finally red-tagging that bastard. I don't know anything else about anything.

4
scoooot•

He's probably the best Concern Troll I've ever seen

3/10 at best.

1
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•

His dedication has to bump that up to a 6 or so. Then again, 3/10 is still pretty good relatively.

1
scoooot•

I am nut impressed.

0
[deleted]•

Think a lot of people don't know the point of holding discussions or arguments. If someone says something stupid, discuss why it's stupid. Don't just insult them and ostracize them.

16
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-11
soderkis•

Not that it is a legitimate argument. Discussing a topic might imply that there is some sort of controversy or whatever, but just because I explain to you why an argument does not follow does not mean that the discussion somehow suggests that the argument does follow.

Besides, what is the alternative? We have to come to terms with the fact that we live in a society with some really really stupid people. Are we supposed to spend our lives insulting them and hope that this will improve our situation?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
soderkis•

It makes sense in response to your earlier post. It was a pedantic point to make, so never mind.

I don't know if I should expand too much on my second point. Do you even want to hear it?

2
[deleted]•

But you cannot argue it without acknowledging it. Otherwise, you're a fascist.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

Just like a fascist would say. Continue proving my point, please.

1
rmuserLiterally a teddy bear•
15
Lizbeanism•

Though the comments this user posts are loaded and biased towards a transphobic view they are not overly offensive. This user is merely expressing their opinion in an articulated manner. They may be expressing the wrong opinion and perhaps they are also trying to get a rise out of people, but they aren't what r/lgta should be concerned about because they aren't openly bullying anyone.

Also, attaching the red flair to them has not stopped anyone from replying to what they post and it has not stopped them from posting.

28
smischmalshe-wizard•

Also, attaching the red flair to them has not stopped anyone from replying to what they post and it has not stopped them from posting.

I think that's kind of the point. Discussion is still able to proceed if one wishes it, but it is there as a warning to the rest of us that they may not be worth the effort. I actually really like that, and I think it is a much better course of action than banning or removing comments (as I've seen on some other subreddits before).

1
zoolander951•

I agree with you, but I don't think you can call an opinion "wrong" per say

0
Lizbeanism•

I meant wrong from their perspective.

5
scoooot•

But you can call things which are not a matter of opinion wrong, when they are presented as an opinion.

For example, if I were to say, "It is my opinion that down is up.", I would be "wrong".

0
scoooot•

they are not overly offensive

Irrelevant. He is a concern troll.

Also, attaching the red flair to them has not stopped anyone from replying to what they post and it has not stopped them from posting.

Hopefully, it has raised awareness for what concern trolling is, and how to defend against it IRL as well as here.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
pseudodoxia•

Yeah, I think you went overboard on this one. Scarlet-lettering people qualifies as harassment and bullying.

Maybe you should have just banned him if you were so upset?

9
outsider•

Looks like the same reasons she has been banned elsewhere.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
Aspel•

Nothing I've seen Moonshine post has been terrible. Stupid, maybe, but not terrible. More often than not, I see it as a well intentioned plea from moderation.

8
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•
2
Aspel•

I still don't really get what that means, or know what concern trolling is.

When did he ever say "trans people are wrong"? I thought he was trans. And a she.

2
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•

No, not trans. And not a she either.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Feuilly•

Why is r/lgbt taking moderation tips from a forum based on Something Awful?

5
[deleted]•

I don't understand anything that the moderators of /r/lgbt do.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Feuilly•

How did this reply end up in r/lgbt to a different one of my comments?

Reply in r/Canada and I'll give you an actual response.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
Amain153•

All this rage gives me a sad on the inside. <3

4
Tango_Mike_Foxtrot•

Some people live in a world where they have to constantly protect themselves and be proactive in defense of their own actions so when they come to a safe place ( Here for example ) they don't know how to turn that part of their brain off, and assume people are still attacking their way of life when they very obviously are not.

3
shapterjmThe Pocket Gay!•

At least in my topic, moonflower <i>consistently</i> went out of his/her way to troll me and the other people posting in the topic. It's not just that moonflower made unhelpful or opposing-opinion posts, it's that the posts either blatantly ignored previous information (actively ignored, even) and were disrespectful. There's a difference between dissent and disrespect. I haven't seen a single constructive post from moonflower and I wholeheartedly agree with the "concern troll" tag...though at this point I'd say it's more "confirmed" than "concern."

2
moonflower•

If you want to make italics, you use asterisks, *like this* comes out like this

I don't remember our conversation, but if you are saying I ignored ''information'', could it have been that this ''information'' was really only ''opinion''? Could you show me what ''information'' I ignored?

5
shapterjmThe Pocket Gay!•

You're free to look up the exact posts, they were never removed. Your comments were disturbing and I'd rather not revisit them, as I told you after you made (and continued to make) them. No, the information you ignored was not opinion, you specifically disregarded portions of my posts which rendered your subsequent posts unnecessary.

-3
moonflower•

I wouldn't know where to look, I can't even remember our conversation ... surely you could link to the general discussion without needing to read it again? I could easily find it from there

2
shapterjmThe Pocket Gay!•

As I said before (in the other thread and previously in this one), I want no more part of a discussion with you. You are perfectly free to look up your previous responses by clicking on your username in the upper right-hand corner of the screen, which will quickly lead you to your comments on my thread.

-4
[deleted]•

LGBT is almost as bad as SRS now, god forbid somebody has an opposing opinion.

1†
RobotAnnaVery Cute, Just Like Miku•

you mean as awesome as srs?

i mean it will never be but maybe one day. we can hope.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
[deleted]•

LGBT is almost as bad as SRS now

fuck yeah. the shitposters (I have you tagged as a transphobe, onetimer ;) are realizing this. run, run like the internet cowards you are.

-3
[deleted]•

look at onetimers posting history..an MRA troll.

3
ButterflySammy•

Hey it is nice to see you stopped trolling the other thread to insult someone for being a troll.

1
[deleted]•

onetimer ought to get benned from /r/lgbt ~

-1
[deleted]•

I agree.

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
[deleted]•

I'm gay and have the same right to post here as transsexuals, also if you read my posts you'd see I'm against the 'MRM'.

*BTW, love the tag <3

-6
[deleted]•

OH NO MY INTERNET POINTS

-11
straight_ally•

The condescension is practically visible.

Seriously, let's act like adults here. If you're going to make a point, then make it. Don't act smug and continue to feed the fire by acting like every bit as intolerant of other people's opinions as you perceive them to be of yours.

11
[deleted]•

onetimer is part of the /r/mensrights community, and MRA people have strong ties to white supremacy among many other evils.

-4
straight_ally•

Ok, and if that warrants action, then so be it.

But, (and I'm not talking specifically about you by any means), the mods shouldn't be mocking people for their (non-bigoted, non-demeaning) beliefs.

And of course with that, I'm talking specifically about http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oggdt/from_handsoff_to_active_defense_moderating_an/c3h8nuz

Disagree if you wish. But this ^^^ type of thing shouldn't be happening for people who aren't being homo/transphobic or deliberately trying to insult anybody.

8
anarchotamago•

I think being a men's rights activist is enough of an evil in itself.

-5
[deleted]•

Why dont you try looking through their rather long posting history

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

What exactly is a concern troll?

3
[deleted]•
-10
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•

Sad. This should be the top post. I didn't realize how well know that bastard is outside of Reddit. Still, quite a fuckin' shitstorm you have yourself here, eh?

1
[deleted]•

haters gonna hate

-3
AndrensathSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

TRANSPHOBIC LOL

-22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-23
[deleted]•

TRANSPHOBIC LOL

-28