r/SubredditDrama•
[deleted]

[Meta] Seriously, /r/SubredditDrama? Have we become no better than SRS? Are we now just another downvote brigade?

The #1 submission in this subreddit right now (here) is a recent conversation between a SFWPorn mod kjoneslol, and RES creator honestbleeps. The significant thing about this conversation is that is sprung up in a thread that was almost a month old. As far as I know, no one else has linked to this conversation other than r/SubredditDrama.

Last time I checked, we are not a downvote brigade.

Regardless if you agree or disagree with kjoneslol's opinions, it is not acceptable to raid another subreddit and pick sides, downvoting one side of an argument and upvoting another. I've seen this subreddit accused of being a downvote brigade akin to the likes of ShitRedditSays, and I laughed. However, I'm not laughing anymore.

There is no reason this subreddit should be raiding other subreddits and downvoting comments made by users to -25 karma while upvoting the other side to +50 karma. That, my friends, is a downvote brigade. That is unacceptable.

We are better than that.

Posted Feb 6, 2012, 5:35 PM UTC · edited

96146
dialupmoron•

It's funny how naive people can be. Putting the spotlight on anything naturally invites people to upvote/downvote it. This happens in any "highlight" subreddit, even bestof.

There isn't even a need for the subreddit to form concerted upvote/downvote brigades. The very fact that it exists puts a magnifying glass on the comments/dramas in question; and given Redditors' overt inability to control themselves, that magnifying glass might as well be a scope with crosshairs.

Last time I checked, we are not a downvote brigade.

You're checking the wrong things. No matter how much you say this, bringing anything to the fore makes you a brigade (in either direction) whether you like it or not. It's inherent to any subreddit like this, including bestof, SRS, and worstof.

114
BritishHobo•

This, pretty much. It's a subreddit where you're linking to posts to say 'look how ridiculous/unreasonable this guy is being!', what do you expect to happen?

40
Rahms•

I think the key difference is that in this sub, people link to drama, they don't pick a side for you. I see absolutely nothing wrong with people being linked to an argument and picking a side. I don't do it myself, but I don't really care. It's not like this is a subreddit advertised for one specific demographic (as in, one that is always going to form the same opinion and agree with eachother).

Please don't compare us to SRS, where it's "hey look how dumb this guy is, oh and this is how much karma his post has." They are a downvote brigade, that targets people and creates retarded disputes.... whereas this is just a place to see arguments that have already happened began. Big difference. The biggest ones are generally because person A is clearly wrong, but has all the power (mod or whatever)....

edit: well, posts that are posted by someone who was in the drama are pretty biased, but the whole thing about us not being a uniformly-opinionated mob of back-patters still applies.

5
ZeroShiftMODSRD Founder•

At the risk of making it seem like we add a new rules every time something like this come up, this sort of rule was implied but never stated.

We were never meant to be a downvote brigade. Ever.

However, it would be naive of me to think that it'd never turn in to one. With this stated, I could not have said it better myself syncretic.

43
[deleted]MOD•

I personally don't see why everyone takes karma so seriously, however, when a real comment goes below the threshold, then it bothers me because while karma means shit, when someone can't see a valid argument because of a "downvote brigade", then it pisses me off.

57
ShadoWolf•

Karma does have some intrinsic value if you think about it a bit. It like any other status symbol. When a post gains karma its a direct acknowledgement from majority that you message / statement is valid or insightful.

Karma can also be used quick and dirty metric by which to measure a person involvement in Reddit.. and by some small token if he/she if worth listening to.

So ya like any other human social system status symbols can have meaning.. even if the system is kind of flawed

2
happybadger•

I personally don't see why everyone takes karma so seriously,

As you hinted at, karma correlates directly with exposure. If I post a link in one of the big subreddits and it gets to the front page, tens of thousands of people will see it. If I post an idea and it becomes the top comment, hundreds or thousands will see it and tens-of if someone puts it in r/bestof.

When you dowvote something, you're directly censoring that opinion or piece of content by making it appear lower than most people are going to read. You're not removing it, but you're burying it under so many other comments/posts that only those who go down to troll town are going to see it. Do it to a discussion and you're promoting some guy who seems to reinforce his own opinion while talking to a ghost.

As pointwhoring, it's worthless. As a direct parallel to how loud your microphone is, karma is the difference between a crazy person spewing crazytalks on Alternet and the president of the US giving a state of the union address.

-2
therealprotonk•

We were never meant to be a downvote brigade. Ever.

How is that a rule and not just an aspiration? Short of me making a post saying "Oi! Upvote me and my mate and downvote this other bloke" it isn't even remotely enforceable. It's just the statement "we'd sure like not to downvote linked comments".

9
[deleted]•

Thank you. I enjoy this subreddit as kind of a popcorn-inducing laboratory observation. "Hey, look at the silly Internet children taking things way too seriously, ha ha".

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
QdwachMD•

I love apple pie !

-11
[deleted]•

Actually, it doesn't matter if someone links to r/subredditdrama. If someone wants to post that, they are free to do so.

5
QdwachMD•

I see, well if you guys are ok with it that's fair enough.

-2
honestbleepsWhy do I have you tagged as "The RES maker"?•

Oy...

Hi. I've now been the subject (and uh, karma beneficiary?) of two threads about me debating with subreddit moderators.

To be clear: I never asked to have that spotlight put on my threads with them, they just got posted here... and no, they weren't posted here by any sockpuppet(s) of mine, I'll swear to that.

That being said: I don't think I'd call what happened here a "downvote brigade"...

Although it's against reddiquette, people vote things up and down based on agreement/disagreement and unfortunately that just can't be stopped. It's never going to go away.

Ultimately, the more people that read a thread, the more votes (up and/or down) it's going to get... and the votes (for better or for worse) reflect the community's agreement/disagreement with the sentiment.

As I mentioned in the latest thread: I honestly think I could've handled the whole debate better myself, and I probably lost my cool. The exposure from /r/SubredditDrama on that thread did two things to/for me:

  1. Reminded me that I should probably be a bit more careful about my word choice when I'm getting frustrated with someone

  2. Yes, admittedly, the updated vote totals do give me some reassurance that although I may not have handled myself in the best way possible, the "community" seems to agree that control should live in the hands of the browser. This is useful information to see reinforced, actually. All I could do before was extrapolate from a sample size of 1 (me).

I don't think it ruins the downvotee's life... if we don't care about karma (I really don't), why should he care if he lost some points?

It also doesn't make my life any better. I didn't gain the ability to go cash in my comment upvotes at the karma store... so do I really care? Meh.. not so much. It's just meaningless points.

However: the thing I don't approve of is the people who posted a comment on the thread calling the guy an asshole, etc...

Lastly, I would certainly say that if anyone encourages "let's all go vote this up" or "down" - that I'd be against... but by simply exposing a thread and having that exposure result in votes? I don't think that's any sort of concerted effort to down/upvote ... it's just a natural result of more exposure.

41
[deleted]•

[deleted]

40
MuldartheGreat•

I went through this thread and alternated upvotes and downvotes on comments.

I HAVE THROWN YOUR ENTIRE INTERNET POINT SYSTEM INTO CHAOS!

34
[deleted]•

[deleted]

19
Bittervirus•

Unfortunately, the sheer act of linking to a post makes you a de facto downvote brigade, like bestof or worstof or countless others.

No matter how many times you tell people that it's not the point, there are still going to be people who don't "get it" and downvote anyway. Especially as this sub gets larger. Too many people think that comment karma means something, and I don't know of any way to prevent it.

18
NoPickles•

Have we become no better than SRS?

What we aren't anything. This reddit points to drama. If people donvote or upvote it doesn't matter.

Don't come here and bitch because ohh a mod in my community is being downvoted.

13
soupyhands•

Pretty sure kjoneslol doesn't give a fuck about karma, and downvoting him doesn't disprove his argument.

10
CDRnotDVD•

It's the principle of the thing.

3
soupyhands•

the principle of what thing.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
QdwachMD•

We should have a "no touching" rule, like titty bars.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-7
therealprotonk•

Comment karma is serious business.

7
[deleted]•

I guess that answered my question.

Edit: loldownvotes. http://i.imgur.com/zCIOx.gif

-13
therealprotonk•

Eh. Redditors gonna reddit. The function (as distinct from the purpose) of subreddit drama is just like worstof/bestof/whatever. People link to posts or comments. That funnels attention to those posts. The folks who go there are going to upvote/downvote or whatever as they see fit. The more subscribers this subreddit has, the more people see the post.

And for most of us, downvoting is 100% anonymous. I can't make a credible claim to you that I downvoted or upvoted your post. In the absence of even the most minimal means by which to link behavior to accounts it makes no sense to come here and lecture us about redditquete. Anyone who did the downvoting (p.s. I downvoted kjoneslol because he was being a dick, but I can never prove that to you) will just ignore your pleas and anyone who upvoted or didn't vote will get frustrated at the lecture.

18
[deleted]•

Bring only popcorn, take only screenshots. Leave no trace, SubredditDrama Queens!

7
CDRnotDVD•

Another problem with downvoting people that appear on SubredditDrama, is that many people delete their posts if they get too many downvotes. If they do delete their posts, then there is no drama left.

7
Skuld•

Lame ducks. I saw those posts at 1 karma last night.

6
velkyr•

The original hipster

11
Skuld•

I was at the centre of subreddit drama before the birth of r/subredditdrama.

More seriously, I was in syncretic's SFWPorn IRC channel when he found that link, haha.

4
TharSheVotes•

You're just a skull.

0
zanycaswell•

Seriously. If you want to be part of a downvote brigade, go to /r/downvotebrigade.

6
LukeTheAlright•

I'm honestly surprised that this subreddit isn't more active.

1
Sniffles78•

I really feel like when people who are involved in the drama post here, or when people go from subreddit drama to argue or downvote people, that it breaks the fourth wall and ruins the fun.

5
[deleted]•

More views = more up/down votes

/popcorn

2
stopscopiesmedoesn't even go here•

There are also people who come from here and then jump into the discussion. I think that's also not something we should do, especially when you're in a subreddit you never visit

1
dannylandulf•

I think that's also not something we should do, especially when you're in a subreddit you never visit

Agreed. If it's a sub you're already a regular in, though, have at it.

3
madagent•

Copy and paste things you want to discuss. Don't allow linking to the actual comment anymore.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1