"no information leaves this room": Is Reddit (in danger of) being controlled by an elite few?
A rather interesting post was made on r/SubredditDrama today, a screenshot of a private IRC chat between several Reddit admins and many of Reddit's "popular" users. Apparently, these discussions happen quite often, and the only reason this one got leaked is because it revealed two very popular Reddit posters are actually the same person. Anyway, that's for the popcorn crowd.
But the broader implications concern me. You've got a group of mods who are quite chummy with each other, and also with the people who run the site, who are supposed to be (ideally) impartial. Many of these mods run the top subreddits, and because of Reddit's "mods are gods" system, are able to control the flow of (and type of) content of most of the site. Digg was utterly ruined by, among other things, the power user model, where to get to the top, you had to be well known, or at least "in" with the right people. Say something the ones in charge don't want? Enjoy your trip to obscurity.
Combined with the removal of r/reddit.com (which was arguably the best place to vent and/or point out abuses of power), and recent moves like the one that hides who bans users, the trend in the past year seems to be toward a centralization of power (and we all know power has a rather unfortunate side-effect of corruption, especially on the Net), reduction of mod accountability, and painting any criticism as "rabble rousing" or "witch hunting".
Is Reddit going to become as cronyist as Digg? Does the architecture (infinite subreddit making capability for example) prevent or reduce the possibility? Anything ordinary users can do to prevent this?
By the way, the leaked file (posted on Pastebin) was deleted. It was reuploaded, and that too was deleted. And again. A backup was uploaded to Imgur, and that's mysteriously vanished as well. Even on a (relatively) small subreddit as r/SubredditDrama, someone's watching.
Edit: I was "requested" to remove the link to the IRC chat because it supposedly contains personal information. The link was to the SubredditDrama post about it, not the file itself, but fine.
Edit2: Added link to chat with IP addresses removed.
Edit3: Removed link to chat altogether.
Posted Feb 19, 2012, 5:39 PM UTC · edited
1) There are private subreddits, there are private IRC channels. Many names you know visit them and discuss Reddit in general and moderation in particular.
2) It used to be easier to get an answer out of the admins in these subreddits and IRC channels. If it's any consolation, all Redditors are now being ignored equally.
3) Private ban lists and private blacklists do exist. It should be obvious to the casual observer by now that their continued secrecy is more of a fluke than an eventuality. r/favors was invited to join one; the moderators of r/favors declined. I informed the admins of its existence and heard deafening silence.
4) A small cadre of interconnected "power users" DO moderate ~85% of Reddit. I once cross-referenced the visible names in r/modtalk with the top moderators of the default subreddits and if the "power users" felt like taking Reddit dark, Reddit would go dark.
That said, it should be abundantly clear to the most casual observer that "control" of Reddit is a figment and that "power" users on Reddit get along about as well as "regular" users (IE, not at all). And, while we're at it, can we do a little math?
The top post on r/all right now is "Stay classy, Chris.". Reddit reports to me that it has "26,516 up votes 23,220 down votes." r/modtalk has 388 readers - that's nearly double what it had six months ago. And while I can't provide a decent analysis of early leads, seeding, the first hour, etc. I hope that it's pretty clear that 388 users, no matter how much "power" anyone thinks they have, are going to do much in the way of influencing a post with 50,000 votes under its belt. As moderators, the choice is "leave it alone or take it down." There is no middle ground.
It is my heartfelt opinion that the way Reddit runs is colossally stupid. There's no reason whatsoever why a bare handful of squabbling 20-somethings should have a kill-switch (and nothing else) over the content read by 1.4 million people. I have raised this issue with the admins, in private and in public, over the past three years. They keep doing nothing about it. The choice to hide the hand that holds the banhammer has been on Reddit's "to do" list for 18 months - in other words, moderators started asking for it back when Reddit had about 600,000 users. The Admins, in other words, are woefully, dreadfully behind the curve on everything, regardless of whether or not it's a good idea.
The worst part, however, is that "redditors" have had essentially no say in any of this. As users of this website, you are subject to the whims of those who got there before you. They had the ear of the admins; you never did. In part, this is because the hierarchical system of Reddit is completely broken. In part, it is because any complaints about the system usually start with "burn XXX at the stake" and end with "rabble rabble" without passing through the essential "we demand change for the good of the whole website" phase.
Reddit is stupidly run. It always has been. If you want that to change, put your back into it. This is a website that persuaded Stephen Colbert to hold a rally, who raised thousands upon thousands of dollars for DonorsChoose, and who managed to make large swaths of the Internet dark one day to protect Internet rights. Yet SomethingAwful decides to have a snit and 5 years of libertarian policy were changed in three hours.
You wanna see "power users?" Demand more equality, more accountability and more fairness from the admins or you'll boycott Reddit. See who has the "power" then.
Be the change you want to see in the world, bitchez.
Which are fictional numbers, no?
..."based on a true story" is a more accurate way of putting it, I think. Reddit fuzzes the numbers, but somewhere in there, real numbers exist.
The score is real, but that's all. The more popular/active a post is the less reliable the vote totals are. Also, popular posts tend to have a lot more fuzzed downvotes, but you'll never know the precise ratio.
Total score is also fuzzed, unless you think this site can have an order of magnitude more voters than a year or two ago and still only have 3000 difference between up and down votes (this has been analysed and it is obviously as I state).
The score is also fuzzed, if you refresh the webpage for long-dead threads you'll find that as well as the number of up and down votes changing the score will also move up and down.
We have voting threads every month in r/SF_Book_Club and this effect always causes a problem when the number of votes are close.
I've always wondered why they bother displaying a percentage of who likes a post if it's based on "fuzzed" numbers.
[deleted]
I'll hand it to you... You certainly can talk big and you're persuasive.
However, that doesn't mean what you're saying isn't completely missing the mark.
For starters:
Compared to what, exactly? There is no site remotely like reddit, let alone as big as, to have a meaningful comparison. I mean, you could compare it to google or facebook, but what good will that do you?
Lack of an accurate measuring stick means we have to move onto tangible metrics we can see. Site popularity, growth and hits (and profit, but those are unknown to us). The metrics we can measure show that reddit's growth is exploding. Whatever reddit is doing, is working. There is no sign of a decline in the slightest. Quite the opposite in fact.
You say "reddit is stupidly run", I say its growth and popularity proves you wrong. A poorly ran website doesn't have continued, steady (often explosive) growth for 5 straight years.
Trying to stir shit up, are we? Make people feel scared & get people to not trust the mods? You've been/were a mod for quite a while and know damn well something like that would never happen.
Your entire post is aimed at getting users riled up and is nothing more than a propaganda piece, rather than actual criticism with potential solutions. You say everything is wrong with reddit (providing no proof) nor offer up solutions for the problems you claim exist.
In short, if you think reddit is the worst site in the world, is "stupidly ran" and will die in a few months (like you've been claiming for almost a year now) then why not leave? You got your hubski (which you promote every chance you have, it seems - are you affiliated with it in some way?), why not go there and stay there.
But why would I? Reddit is all user-curated content. So, for that matter, is Wikipedia.
Compared to Wikipedia, Reddit is stupidly run.
We can see pageviews. We could see pageviews for 4chan as well... which at 800 million pageviews a month was driving Chris Poole into the poorhouse.
"Growth" and "popularity" without "impact" are meaningless. Hueypriest has said that one of their primary concerns is time on site; that's not a number that's increasing. Meanwhile, the content served by Reddit is rapidly becoming "that which can be hosted by imgur."
Three words: No Pics Day.
I've written up solutions several times. The admins have seen them. The last time I posted them publicly violentacrez cherry-picked points to make me out to be a nazi. This whole post is about distrust of power-users - my point is that if people want this to change, they have to do something to change it.
Your point seems to be that you don't like me.
This made me laugh more than it should have.
I like your points, and as an "older" redditor in his late thirties, I'm watching the imgurization of reddit and the invasion of the highschoolers warily.
I've actually started going back to Fark more and more for interesting content that's not, you know, a cat picture.
But how do you get interesting content back on the front page if 50% of your users are under 20 and don't want to read?
I'd like to see your data on this.
Not if you want to make money. I feel like reddit stripping, as you put it, the libertarian policy that it held was the smoking gun. Reddit has become corrupted by corporate influence because of its popularity, which, according to alexa, is the 50th most visited website in the USA. It has become a brand, and the operators are going to do whatever it takes to uphold that brand.
Your points are awfully vague, and not very constructive. What specifically are your solutions?
You've seen them. Don't pretend you haven't.
I like you. lol
You mean no site with as good of a comment and submission system as reddit's. There are lots of sites where folks go for debate and socializing.
You left out the rest of my comment.
Thanks for the out of context quote I guess..?
"Compared to what, exactly?" You don't have to compare it to anything to say that it is stupidly run.
You're right, you don't. I could say google is stupidly run, that doesn't mean I'm correct.
If I were to make such a claim, I'd make sure to have as many facts as possible to back up my opinion.
[deleted]
kleinbl00 summarized in two sentences. He's an excellent writer and storyteller, which makes it seem like he's always saying something important and significant. However, it's often incorrect or doesn't actually contain anything of substance. It's unfortunate that so many people don't seem to be able to notice that.
[deleted]
I can't remember where I saw it, but I think that one of the reddit founders said that they used socks when they first started the site to give people the impression there were more users participating.
Every single website does this.
Honestly, I would be surprised if there weren't any people gaming the system. I would be surprised if the admins didn't participate in important discussions on reddit through the use of accounts not flagged as admins. I suppose it's common knowledge that the admins communicate directly with power users. I'm quite confident that at least some power users are group accounts, though I have no direct knowledge of any particular one.
I see two main ways in which reddit is "gamed." The first is people seeking a private advantage by getting paid for using reddit to generate targeted traffic. The other is simply people in positions of "power" playing status games and creating drama. With the latter, there may not be any sinister motives. It's just human nature to compete for karma, attention from admins, coveted moderator slots, or whatever. The second type is unavoidable, and I can only hope that the first is not widespread, but there is so much money at stake that I wonder sometimes.
Do you legitimately think Something Awful has that kind of power over reddit?
It isn't my opinion - the Admins confirmed it last weekend.
SA decided that Reddit should be punished for "hosting child porn" or whatever, and within three hours of launching their campaign,, Reddit experienced a necessary change in policy. Note that being in Anderson Cooper's crosshairs changed nothing - it took a handful of lulzy goons to get the Admins to respond.
Meanwhile, a "moderation log" was requested 15 months ago. We got it two months ago. So. If you're actually trying to help the site, expect to wait a year or more. Attempting to destroy the site? Get your answer before you finish watching The Godfather.
If you hung around reddit as much as I do (and I'm pretty sure you do) you would know that the campaign to shut down certain sub reddits started long before anything was actually done.
It was most definitely not a 3 hour campaign.
We could dicker about timeframe. The point still stands: users who demand something are put on indefinite backburner. Agents provocateur who demand something are given the Domino's Pizza treatment.
The Admins explicitly said that they didn't make the change because of SA. You can interpret it differently, and that interpretation will be an opinion.
And there were definitely weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.
Aren't administration also largely 20-somethings that are running a business, yet have little business sense?
The current ones are, yes. The previous group was older, better educated and more experienced.
And less submissive to external pressure.
[deleted]
I did, but it's buried pretty deep.
[deleted]
Reddit is all talk and no trousers. You buy some pants and do some walking.
You must have a lot of time on your hands.
Then make your own website, where there are no mods?
or start anew elsewhere.
[deleted]
The SA fiasco wasn't about jailbait, it was about how Reddit controls content. The last time Reddit censored anything it was because Sears demanded it. We lost our founders over that and, eventually, our core team. Since then, Reddit has made exactly zero headway towards selective control of content, but SA forced the Admins to change their policy - before, it was "we're not going to dictate content (and pretend it's a free-speech issue, rather than a manpower issue)". Now, it's "we're going to dictate content (despite the fact that there are thirteen of us who now must pass judgement over the submissions of 1.4 million users, lucky us)."
I don't think there's a single person at Reddit who champions child porn for child porn's sake. I think Reddit has had such a laissez-faire relationship with child porn for so long because they had no practical mechanism for dealing with it. That hasn't changed - what changed is Reddit Inc. felt that SA's flexing presented an existential threat so they blinked.
Now it gets interesting.
Are you fucking serious? What about the people trading child porn? Were they only doing that to stick it to the man?
No. 4chan has less practical methods for dealing with it, and that mod team still does what it can to keep it off the site.
4chan is a website with 56 subboards which makes it much simpler to moderate in comparison to reddit as the users of that site can't make their own boards. The reddit adminship have no interest in policing reddit, they could start filtering for specific words or appoint moderators to filter all the subreddits, but that goes against their philosophy of how the site should be run. Don't be confused, reddit is not 4chan or SomethingAwful, sitewide moderation would be difficult to implement and not to mention I doubt they'd even want to implement it.
In addition to all the subreddits that were recently banned, we still have r/pedosexhysteria, r/spreadingtheword, and several others that are full of people championing child porn for child porn's sake.
Really, did you not think for a moment why SA decided to run this campaign against CP on Reddit? It's because Reddit had CP!
Once more, with feeling:
The entire parent comment is about people AT Reddit. Those would be admins.
You're talking about people ON Reddit. Those would be users.
Admins != Users.
I know it undermines your point, and for that I'm sorry, but this is a pretty simple confusion that a modicum of sense would clear up.
[deleted]
You're putting words in my mouth. I'm not saying "child porn is good" I'm saying "child porn wasn't the issue." I said it pretty explicitly, too:
You want to have the argument that "child porn is bad." I'm not going to have that argument - I don't think that a reasonable argument for child porn can be made by any thinking, feeling human being. The argument I'm having is that Reddit didn't have any ability to do anything about it then and they don't have any ability to do anything about it now, but under threat, they pretended they would.
Can you have that argument? Or are you too busy having a different argument?
Go back to /r/conspiracy. None of your claims are backed up with any sort of evidence.
I agree with QnA, stop string the pot with your propaganda.
Every one of my claims is backed up with evidence. Instead of dismissively shouting me down, why don't you ask for specific examples, if what I've provided isn't enough?
Okay.. How about your third point, in particular the last statement.
When someone makes such outlandish claims, the burden of proof lies on them.
A tricky one. The subreddit is supposed to be kept private and screenshots of it are strictly verboten. That said, the proof I can offer you is this. It should be clear that it was posted by me and screencapped by me. I won't reveal who those 33 comments came from; you'll have to trust me that none of them are admins or else I wouldn't have come forward. You'll also have to trust me when I say that r/favors didn't join in, as verifying a negative is nigh onto impossible. You'll also excuse me for not disclosing where the shared ban list came from as I find witch hunts distasteful.