Only a few days left to have your say on a rules update for this sub.

:fuckingkiwi: Meta

If you're like me and never look at the green stickies because you assume they are the same thing all the time you might have missed this.

https://www.reddit.com/r/newzealand/comments/v0fg5x/rnewzealand_subreddit_update_rules_refresh/

I, like some others, only noticed this from a comment in a thread I was reading.

Some people are more likely to notice /new posts so putting this here to gain some attention so more people can put forward their feedback as some of these proposed changes are quite significant.

Posted Jun 3, 2022, 6:54 AM UTC

5552
glittergoblinnz•

How do we get the up and down vote buttons to be little kiwis?

68
libertyh•

Kiwi upvote, possum downvote

41
TransidentalOP•

I tried to think of a better downvote icon, I couldn't.

I thought of some but they'd be offensive to other countries.

13
BackupPersonality2•

Car for upvote, bike for downvote

North Island for upvote, South Island for downvote

So many possibilities

5
TheOldPohutukawaTreeThe Truth Hurts.•

Asking the questions that matter

17
TransidentalOP•

The fact we have proposed rule changes instead of sub mods working on this boggles my mind!

8
turikur•

laser kiwis

4
teelolwsNZ Flag•

UpArdern, DownCollins?

-4
fasttravelsnowCovid19 Vaccinated•

Eyebrows up. Eyebrows down

1
hukehuke•

god these rules are so subjective, im not sure i trust a Doreen type to enforce this

All the comments are objecting

looking forward to them posting about how they took the feedback onboard and they are going ahead with the changes

42
[deleted]•

Ah, the AT method.

13
TransidentalOP•

I wonder if that happens if we, as a majority of our country, have any ability to complain to reddit admins that the moderation team are somehow hijacking our sub.

3
Matt_NZ•

I mean, you can always start a new sub with the rules you want. If people agree then they'll follow.

6
hukehuke•

it's a reddit sub mate.

no one cares

we will just do what we are told as usual

2†
TransidentalOP•

Not so sure, reddit admins have been a LOT more hands on in recent times with this sort of thing. Especially if it were a sub that's supposed to represent an actual country and with how prominent reddit itself has become within social media.

10 years ago meh, who cares - just a large forum. They are much more aware of issues these days.

Imagine if somehow Russian's took over the Ukranian sub ... "oh well, too bad, whatever" yeah right.

1†
bthks•

Yeah, a Reddit admin had to retake the Minnesota state sub recently after the mod who had been in it longest (unclear if he was founder or just an earlier mod, he just had the most seniority so it complicated things) fell into the conspiracy nut job hole during COVID and started shutting down all non-right-wing-nutcase-conspiracy threads and blocking everyone left right and center. It took months and a second state sub being created before it got fixed though.

2
zdepthcharge•

New rules stink of a power grab. This sub will become a ghost town.

20
keera1452•

Yeah they look terrible. It will turn into a desert here if they go ahead

6
TransidentalOP•

Post your thoughts in that thread, it's very important.

3
zdepthcharge•

And how so? I think it would be best to start a new sub and avoid the mods who are attempting the coup.

2
TeHokioiMODKia ora•

We're listening to all of the feedback, none of it is a done deal

1
ends_abruptlFuck Russia•

Rule 10: two redditors go in, one redditor comes out.

18
0oodruidoo0Red Peak•

Rule 34: two redditors go in, three come out

5
TransidentalOP•

Pretty sure the mods putting forward these rules changes want "1 redditor goes in and that's all because everyone else is either banned or can't post within our rules".

3
TreeBearOne•

..blood dome?

2
EBuzz456The Grand Nagus you deserve 🖖🌌•

Listen on! Listen on! This is the truth of it. Arguing leads to shitposting, and shitposting gets to flame-warring, and that was damn near the death of us all.

Now, when men get to arguing, it happens here, and it finishes here in Blunderdome.

1
mattblack77⠀Naturally, I finished my set…•

I think we need one thread a week where we can go nuts with the personal insults. Deep down everyone knows they agree.

13
southstormy•

oh yeah like a PvP thread

2
pictureofacat•

Abuse goes against Reddit's own rules, which every sub must abide by

0
TransidentalOP•

I'd +1 this.

ONLY problem. Some people would report each other to reddit admins themselves and they've been really harsh with bans over this sort of thing in recent times.

Used to be there was free ole reddit, then crazy ole 4chan and absolutely disgusting 8chan.

Now we've lost that free old reddit place.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jdyhrbergKererū•

Can a No Politics flair be added to this sub like r/Australia? Have seen many shit posts or genuine questions turn political and its frustrating.

12
TransidentalOP•

100% agree, suggest it in that thread or even make your own posts so it gets more attention.

They are asking for feedback on their proposed rule changes but I think it should be for open discussion about all rule changes.

3
fade-away-maureen•

Pretty sure we have this already

0
jdyhrbergKererū•

Nope the No-Politics on the AU page means anything political is removed and an automod comment at the top saying any mention will he removed/banned. Theres a politics flair, yes, but the sub desperately needs a no politics flair. I don't need to know how much you hate Labour or Jacinda on a shit post about marmite.

7
fade-away-maureen•

Ok I get what you mean. This sub doesn’t have that but it does have a no politics flair “filter” to filter out posts flaired with “politics”

Seems like a good idea.

2
jdyhrbergKererū•

Yeah I see what your saying now, but I love reading comments (sometimes) a filter sadly won't remove that. Just an idea 👍🏼

2
TransidentalOP•

Update: Good news (depending on your view) everyone!

https://www.reddit.com/r/newzealand/comments/v0fg5x/rnewzealand_subreddit_update_rules_refresh/ib0t41c/

Current rules stay as they are.

I think that's a pretty big win for the community. I think the current rules suit the needs of community really well.
Sure there are part that could use some minor tweaks etc. perhaps but certianly no major overhaul. Especially since it wasn't even 6 motnhs ago or so that we had an update and it seemingly improved the sub for the better I personally thought.

Unless there is something going on we don't know about as to the amount of moderation required by mods right now to keep the sub civil and the way we see it (/u/timmyhate quit for an unknown reason right now - could be blow out and seeing too much hate for all we know).

If there is more going on than what we know or see than I suggest the mods come forward and let us know. You'll get a lot more support if we knew there was some hideous underbelly you protect us from than just not telling us at all.

To the mods:

If you want feedback on a rule refresh etc.
Maybe create an open sticky posts and ask and engage with they community on what changes they want, if any, first and let upvoting and discussion take place from there?

This coming across with rule proposals that you had seemingly come up with yourselves as a vast minority of the sub and were out of touch were the community was just bizarre and very un New Zealand.

My 2 cents anyway.

Go call on putting this refresh on hold though! Kudos for that.

7
TimmyHate(Not a mod)•

Responding solely because you tagged me:

My leaving was not related to any member of the moderation team, nor to the proposed rules.

6
mattblack77⠀Naturally, I finished my set…•

Were you a mod?

1
ring_ring_kachingrang_rang_kachang•

Yes. Was but not anymore.

1
king_john651Tūī•

Honestly I thought that you yourself was a mod until a few weeks ago

1
TransidentalOP•

Lol!

2
SlappySausage001•

More shitposting please

4
torolf_212LASER KIWI•

Shitposts are the lifeblood of this sub. Without them there will only be posts on housing, gangs, nurse/teacher pay, and Jacinda bad (whoever is currently leading national also bad).

Give us memes to break up the same tired issues

6
NewZealandTempTuatara•

I'll post a comment on it citing some of the rules I disagree with in the list. Is there any actual way to get my say in here?

3
TransidentalOP•

Post in the thread listed.

If they ignore the obvious groundswell of opposition well ... deal with that if it happens.

1
NewZealandTempTuatara•

I posted the ones I have a problem with my reasoning, trying to make it clear enough.

I only had a problem with 2 on first read. I left out my grievance with their mentioning of r/circlejerk because that one seemed personal.

I haven't really seen which ones the community has a problem with / you didn't specifically mention any in your thread, I just made sure to have "my" voice heard. Thanks for posting this, I always ignore the stickied threads.

Word for word:


Just two rules I see problem with, I'll quote the specific parts that I have a problem with to make it easier;

3 No low effort self posts
Body must contain ≥150 words (excluding links)
If the OP does not participate in the discussion in the first two hours, the submission will be removed.

These two seem pretty arbitrary. OP shouldn't always have to get involved in the discussion, and 150 words might not be enough to get your point across or explain. Even this comment is longer than that, at 203 words.

5 No sharing of other social media (including blogs)

Not even screenshots of other social media.
Exceptions may only made for breaking news stories from verified accounts of prominent figures & will be removed once an article is available.

I assume this is anti-doxxing. I've reported / messaged the mods about doxxing a few times, especially around the covid breaches when people were ready to ruin lives over covid-rule breaks. This seems like a rule that reaches too far, the definition of social media goes pretty far. Especially blogs. Reposting other social medias is an internet tradition, there should be a more specific rule if this is aimed at anti-doxxing.

2
kiwibearess•

Re your point 1: > means more than not less than so they are requiring a minimum number of words rather than a maximum.

3
NewZealandTempTuatara•

Re your point 1: > means more than not less than so they are requiring a minimum number of words rather than a maximum.

I originally wrote it as that, but then reversed it because the point still stood. (I was confused and should have kept it how it was, my correction may have been wrong)

I won't lie that the greater than and less than symbol has always confused me. I just remember the alligator wants to eat the big number.

2
toroidalvoid•

To me it didn't look like this was a submission or the mods were interested in feedback.

These are the new rules

3
tamakithecunt•

The only rule that counts is the one that states that every post must also include how much Tamaki is a cunty bawbag.

2