[Recap] syncretic becoming mod of SRD.
Break out the popcorn!
Last week, syncretic requested to be a mod of SRD.
syncretic had submitted a formal request for moderation, and has also recently been proactive with assisting us current mods in our duties as stated by creepig elsewhere in here.
syncretic stayed proactive and contacted the mods about a possible doxxer in this subreddit. Because of that and probably other actions, creepig modded syncretic.
Here it gets interesting: ssyncretic (not the real syncretic) suggests that syncretic helped with the possible doxxer to improve his chance of getting modded. creepig denies this of course, stating:
Because syncretic had no idea that his actions would lead to getting modded. We don't tell people that they're in the running until their modding is essentially a forgone conclusion. It is not possible for him to have come up with such a dastardly plan to infiltrate our subreddit if he didn't know that he could end up modded for it.
As we know though:
syncretic had submitted a formal request for moderation (http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/w06b0/meta_so_srd_hating_syncretic_is_a_mod_here_now/c598ghy)
You can find the major complaints and more popcorn material in this thread. May the drama flow like the nectar of the gods!
Edit: More nuggets, thanks to CrystallineFrost.
Pastebin is here: http://pastebin.com/tFPYuC5w and there is a longer one too: http://pastebin.com/vWX4vFvM
Accusations that syncretic is associated with MindVirus.
[Jumpoff SRDs](http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/w06b0/meta_so_srd_hating_syncretic_is_a_mod_here_now/c594vda http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/w06b0) being created: r/ThePopcornStand r/SubredditTheatrics/ r/ubredditdrama r/dubredditdrama
Finally, creepig's reasoning for adding syncretic.
Edit 2: syncretic bans a user. Mods just deleted evidence of the ban -see pastebin below.
Just got sent an interesting pastebin: http://pastebin.com/tx5KJYYr
[19:27] @bep creepig
[19:27] @bep syncretic
[19:27] @bep knock that shit off
[19:27] @bep you present a unified front in public
[19:27] @bep or not at all
[19:27] @bep you argue behind the scenes, got it?
[19:27] @creepig syncretic isn't here.
[19:28] @creepig I got it.
[19:39] @agentDRUNK creepig: where did you guys argue publicly?
[19:39] @creepig It's been deleted now.
Edit 3: Thank you everyone for sending me stuff. Just received another pastebin from some IRC chat (why do people prefer pastebin over screen shots?) Pastebin includes syncretic's suggestions for changes to r/subredditdrama.
[21:10] @syncretic I think some sort of "neutrality" rule would be in the same vein as the "don't submit drama you're involved with" rule.
[21:10] == Addyct_ has joined #subredditdrama
[21:10] @syncretic It would prevent people from submitting drama when they have a "horse in the race" so to speak.
[21:11] @ZeroShift Agreed
[21:11] @syncretic If enforced properly it would force SRD to become more of a catalog of drama instead of someone's personal army.
Edit 4: Last paste-bin of the mods' IRC chatroom discussion of tonight. It looks like syncretic is here to stay. http://pastebin.com/zUtmPjhA
Posted Jul 4, 2012, 4:20 PM UTC · edited
Here is my biggest problem with this.
From this thread, it is 100% clear that syncretic hates the idea of any subreddit linking to a theory of reddit thread. In fact, the current policy is that when a ToR thread gets "raided" (which means linked to in a popular subreddit), the entire ToR thread will be deleted, no questions asked.
That's fine. If syncretic wants to have absurd rules in ToR, he can do so. However, the problem becomes if he wants to try and enforce those ToR rules on another subreddit, such as this one. The fact that the "no linking from other subreddits" rule seems specifically directed at SRD just screams massive conflict of interest with syncretic modding here. As a mod, it would be much easier for him to accomplish his goal of preventing any linking of ToR from outside reddits.
I don't like it, and I think he should be removed from the SRD mod list, regardless of how nice he was in tracking down doxxing. Way too much potential for abuse.
EDIT:
To further my point:
"Creating drama" seems to be syncretic speak for "raid" and he has used the phrase before when referring to comments in subreddit drama causing "drama" in ToR... I just don't see how this means anything other than "i'm gonna try and keep subredditdrama out of ToR" and that's just a massive conflict of interest.
Look, if you think SRD needs more mods, that's fine, nobody's disagreeing with that. But to mod someone who shows such a massive non-understanding about SRD, and who has a massive conflict of interest... just bleh.
I 100% believe that is why syncretic wants to be mod. He'll know what posts are in the new queue and have the ability to keep them there until any TOR thread they link to is removed. This will prevent redditbot and archivebot from getting access to incriminating evidence.
This weirdly makes a lot of sense. I just can't fathom how someone can go from "SRD is shit" to "I love SRD and shall mod it with all my love" without an alternative motive here.
agentlame "promised" to explain to me. No response so far.
In private or here? Also, it seems the general policy of all involved has been to stop responding the second their points don't match up any longer. creepig pretty much gave up in the original meta as well when people started pointing out that his arguments didn't make much sense.
In all seriousness, couldn't SRD take action against this though? If syncretic gets out of hand, why not simply start up an SRD thread linked to every single ToR thread in the /new queue. Eventually, he'll have to take more drastic action in one sub or both and then nobody will be able to defend him.
I mean, this is sort of the nuclear option for getting rid of him. But, if he gets out of hand something like this might be what's required to get things back under control.
[deleted]
https://i.minus.com/ibjrejeVseZWbZ.png
Here is more fuel for the fire. By his own admission if the subreddits are entirely mutually exclusive then he, in good conscience, cannot be a moderator of both.
Hypocritical mods with hidden agendas, inconceivable!
[deleted]
The whitewashing rule was discontinued four days ago. Mostly to prevent the heckler's veto.
Boy it sucks that he's the top and only mod here and can enact his will without any other mod being able to say anything about it. Oh wait.
SRD, SRS, WorstOf, etc. SRS in particular has a very storied past with TheoryOfReddit that any intrepid dramanaut could certainly dig up, as removals on ToR are all public, which leads to my last point...
And you don't think that'd get noticed by the other mods really quickly on either side of that? I would be damned shocked if culturalelitist, creepig, or BEP (Wasn't there a shit ton of bitching about him too when he got brought on? Has anything negative come of it?) didn't drop syncretic with the fucking quickness if something like that came up in SRD, and the mods of ToR (Well at least one, yours truly.) certainly wouldn't take it either.
[deleted]
Is this some attempt at getting on the GoT scoreboard? Because your game is shit.
It's an impostor!