Finally made contact with my brother. I feel accomplished and stupid at the same time.

A little (OK, really long) back story here: This started a couple years ago when we first got licensed and built ourselves a couple 2m quarter wave ground planes and put them up about 15' with make shift PVC masts. We could receive local repeaters but our goal was to work simplex only and that that set up didn't work. So the 2m radios got shelved and we spent some time studying for license upgrades. About a year later we both had HF radios and I had learned about ground wave propagation. So we set up some 1/4 verticals and again had no luck. So at this point, I'm thinking our only choice is NVIS. We end up making some 27-28' masts and make ham stick dipoles for 40 and 80 meters. Once again we had no luck (although he could barely make out my call one night on 80 meters) . I thought that maybe the hamsticks are too inefficient and my 40 meter antenna is too far off the ground. So I made a wire dipole and hung it under the eve of my house. That didn't help at all. At this point I'm stumped. So my brother said screw it. Let's go back to 2m and we'll see if we can hit the repeater. In all my antenna making I had taken apart the original 2m ground plane I had made so I decided to go ahead and make a yagi this time. This time we could also put the antennas on a much taller mast since we still had the 27' ones we made for the hamsticks. Well as it turns out, that set up is what we needed to make contact, and we didn't even have to use the repeater. Not sure if the taller masts are what helped or if it was my yagi, but either way I really wish I wouldn't have given up on 2m so easily when I started.

Edit: Brother lives about 20 miles away, over relatively flat terrain.

Tl;dr Spent two years making and experimenting with different antennas and bands when I could have probably just put my first antenna up 12' higher to make contact with my brother.

Posted Dec 31, 2018, 11:57 PM UTC · edited

2614
hamsterdave•

For ground wave, stay below 10MHz. 40m will get you a few dozen miles reliably, 80 might get you 100-200 miles, 160 can get you a few hundred. You absolutely need vertical antennas and decent radials, but the antenna itself doesn't have to be massive. That 25' PVC mast with some wire wrapped around it to make it a giant 80m hamstick would do just fine if you're able to lay a couple dozen radials that are 20-30' long. You might also have better luck during the day when skywave is mostly dead, that should cut the noise a bit. I frequently hear my friend about 15 miles north in the early evening during contests on 40 and 80, even over mountainous terrain, as we both run big verticals.

It's much the same for 40/80m NVIS, daytime is the best bet when the critical frequency is high enough. You'll want horizontal antennas that are pretty low. At night you'll shoot right through the ionosphere on 40m and the noise will be awful on 80m even if you manage NVIS propagation.

Don't feel too bad, antennas and propagation are hard topics to really understand, and even if you understand them half the time antennas just do whatever they damn well please anyway. Congrats on the contact though!

14
dan_kb6nuAnn Arbor, MI, USA, kb6nu.com•

Hey, you learned something, and that's part of what ham radio is all about.

10
WizerOne•

A beam can make a HUGE difference on 2 meters! I use the little ELK portable 2m/440 beam, with great results!! ;)

8
DrMcMeow•

the distance and type of terrain / elevation changes would add a lot to this story.

4
TCFlashback65OPAG5RM•

Good idea. I'll add an edit. Thanks!

3
JshWrightKD2CEL•

At 15' you would have been really close to the horizon at 20 miles (rule of thumb for the distance to the horizon in miles is height in feet X 1.5).

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dittybopper_05HFN33eh [Extra]•

Actually, it's 1.4 * square root(distance in feet) = range in miles for radio horizon.

​

So 15 feet would be (whips out slide rule) 1.4 * sqr(15) = 5.4 miles. If you've both got 15' high (at the base) antennas, over flat terrain you can expect about 5.4 + 5.4 = 10.8 miles, not nearly enough.

​

If you're 20 miles apart, you can crank the equation backwards to see how high you need to be. So take the 10 miles, cut it in half to 10, then divide by 1.4 to get 7.1, square it to get 50.4 feet at each end.

​

Of course, as OP found out, using a gain antenna pointed in that direction makes up for lack of height gain. And of course, if you've got even a low hill or some other obstruction between you, the formula won't help. You need software like Radio Mobile instead.

0

What rig and what type of antenna were you using on 2 meters? 20 miles is very doable on flat terrain.

3
TCFlashback65OPAG5RM•

We both have a Yaesu FT2900 and at first we're using homebrew quarter wave ground plane antennas at about 15' off the ground. Then after some experimentation ended up with him having the same antenna at about 28' and me with a homebrew yagi at about 27'.

1
tuoderN1MIS EN60 [G]•

Did you try NVIS in the daytime or night? My understanding is that daytime is what you're looking for.

1
TCFlashback65OPAG5RM•

We tried day and night on both 40 and 80 meters each time.

2
dittybopper_05HFN33eh [Extra]•

Something was wrong, then. You should have been able to make an NVIS connection at least on 80 meters during the day. NVIS is a very forgiving operating method. A few points:

​

  1. The standard advice for NVIS is 40 meters day, 80 meters night. That's wrong right now. It should be 80 meters day, 160 meters night. When the solar cycle picks up, then the 40/80 thing will work. But right now, at the bottom of the worse solar cycle we've ever seen, no.
  2. Hamsticks are atrociously lossy, especially on 80 meters. Remember: Small, Efficient, Wideband. Pick any 2. Hamsticks on 80 meters have efficiencies in the single digits at best. So if you're pumping 100 watts into them, you're getting less than 10 watts actually radiated. Even 40 meters can be dodgy. They're pretty good for 20 meters and up, though. Don't get me wrong, I have 3 for my car, a 40, a 20, and a 15 meter one, but given the choice between a hamstick dipole and a full size wire dipole, I'll take the wire any day of the week.
  3. The standard antenna for NVIS is a half-wave horizontal dipole at a quarter wave high or lower. A quarter wavelength at 40 meters is 33 feet high, so that was fine.
  4. You hung the dipole *UNDER* the eaves of your house? Do you have metal soffits? Or some kind of foil moisture barrier in the insulation in your ceilings/roof? Because that would kill it right there. It's best to get a dipole out in the open somehow.

If I were you, and I wanted to do NVIS HF communications, I would take that 28 foot mast and put the apex of an inverted V doublet made of wire up there. Make the legs either 51 or 44 feet long, and either feed it with coax and a balun at the feed point, or feed it with parallel line. An 88 foot long inverted V up 27 feet, with the ends 7 feet off the ground, only uses about 78 feet of length, and you can even "fold" the antenna to a degree to make it fit into a small lot if necessary.

​

In fact, that *IS* what I do. My main antenna is an NVIS antenna for 40 meters and down: It's a 102' doublet up about 30 feet, though it's a flat-top. My portable antenna is an 88 foot doublet, and I usually put it up as an inverted V with the apex at 25-ish feet (limited by feed line length) and the ends usually end up about 10 to 12 feet off the ground.

​

I also have a copy of an AS-2259/GR antenna that I built. The legs are cut for 40 meters and 60 meters, but of course with a tuner it operates on 80. You can read about it hear:

https://www.reddit.com/r/amateurradio/comments/7emdru/my_as2259gr_antenna_project_so_far/

1
TCFlashback65OPAG5RM•

That makes sense. My guttering is metal and is probably what killed that. To add insult to injury, I live in a suburb with overhead power lines. To be honest, it was kind of a hail Mary effort anyway. I'll have to have a think on how I'd be able to set up a dipole. I have an extreme disadvantage on hf since I live on a small lot and like I said there are a lot of overhead power lines, including mine which runs diagonally across the backyard, plus a tree in the front yard that there seems to be no good way to hang an antenna on without causing major tuning issues.

1
dittybopper_05HFN33eh [Extra]•

That tree is a bonus! Antenna support. The other thing to remember is that you can droop or bend the ends of a dipole down or to the sides to shorten the physical length, as long as you don't fold it back on itself significantly.

Heck, my first antenna was a 40 meter dipole I put up in my parent's attic at the peak. The house wasn't long enough so I ran the end of one leg down the end of the roof inside the attic in one direction, and the opposite leg in the opposite direction. If you've got a wooden frame and roof and something like asphalt shingles, that should work fine for you.

2