Finally made contact with my brother. I feel accomplished and stupid at the same time.
A little (OK, really long) back story here: This started a couple years ago when we first got licensed and built ourselves a couple 2m quarter wave ground planes and put them up about 15' with make shift PVC masts. We could receive local repeaters but our goal was to work simplex only and that that set up didn't work. So the 2m radios got shelved and we spent some time studying for license upgrades. About a year later we both had HF radios and I had learned about ground wave propagation. So we set up some 1/4 verticals and again had no luck. So at this point, I'm thinking our only choice is NVIS. We end up making some 27-28' masts and make ham stick dipoles for 40 and 80 meters. Once again we had no luck (although he could barely make out my call one night on 80 meters) . I thought that maybe the hamsticks are too inefficient and my 40 meter antenna is too far off the ground. So I made a wire dipole and hung it under the eve of my house. That didn't help at all. At this point I'm stumped. So my brother said screw it. Let's go back to 2m and we'll see if we can hit the repeater. In all my antenna making I had taken apart the original 2m ground plane I had made so I decided to go ahead and make a yagi this time. This time we could also put the antennas on a much taller mast since we still had the 27' ones we made for the hamsticks. Well as it turns out, that set up is what we needed to make contact, and we didn't even have to use the repeater. Not sure if the taller masts are what helped or if it was my yagi, but either way I really wish I wouldn't have given up on 2m so easily when I started.
Edit: Brother lives about 20 miles away, over relatively flat terrain.
Tl;dr Spent two years making and experimenting with different antennas and bands when I could have probably just put my first antenna up 12' higher to make contact with my brother.
Posted Dec 31, 2018, 11:57 PM UTC · edited
For ground wave, stay below 10MHz. 40m will get you a few dozen miles reliably, 80 might get you 100-200 miles, 160 can get you a few hundred. You absolutely need vertical antennas and decent radials, but the antenna itself doesn't have to be massive. That 25' PVC mast with some wire wrapped around it to make it a giant 80m hamstick would do just fine if you're able to lay a couple dozen radials that are 20-30' long. You might also have better luck during the day when skywave is mostly dead, that should cut the noise a bit. I frequently hear my friend about 15 miles north in the early evening during contests on 40 and 80, even over mountainous terrain, as we both run big verticals.
It's much the same for 40/80m NVIS, daytime is the best bet when the critical frequency is high enough. You'll want horizontal antennas that are pretty low. At night you'll shoot right through the ionosphere on 40m and the noise will be awful on 80m even if you manage NVIS propagation.
Don't feel too bad, antennas and propagation are hard topics to really understand, and even if you understand them half the time antennas just do whatever they damn well please anyway. Congrats on the contact though!